[PDF Download] Postmodern portfolio theory: navigating abnormal markets and investor behavior 1st ed

Page 1


Postmodern Portfolio Theory:

Navigating Abnormal Markets and Investor Behavior 1st Edition James

(Auth.)

Visit to download the full and correct content document: https://textbookfull.com/product/postmodern-portfolio-theory-navigating-abnormal-mar kets-and-investor-behavior-1st-edition-james-ming-chen-auth/

More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant download maybe you interests ...

Finance and the Behavioral Prospect: Risk, Exuberance, and Abnormal Markets 1st Edition James Ming Chen (Auth.)

https://textbookfull.com/product/finance-and-the-behavioralprospect-risk-exuberance-and-abnormal-markets-1st-edition-jamesming-chen-auth/

Econophysics and Capital Asset Pricing: Splitting the Atom of Systematic Risk 1st Edition James Ming Chen (Auth.)

https://textbookfull.com/product/econophysics-and-capital-assetpricing-splitting-the-atom-of-systematic-risk-1st-edition-jamesming-chen-auth/

Basel Accords Bank Capital and Portfolio Risk Behavior 1st Edition Samina Riaz

https://textbookfull.com/product/basel-accords-bank-capital-andportfolio-risk-behavior-1st-edition-samina-riaz/

Financial behavior : players, services, products, and markets 1st Edition Baker

https://textbookfull.com/product/financial-behavior-playersservices-products-and-markets-1st-edition-baker/

Portfolio management theory and practice Second Edition. Edition Heisler

https://textbookfull.com/product/portfolio-management-theory-andpractice-second-edition-edition-heisler/

Modern Portfolio Theory and Investment Analysis 9th Edition Elton

https://textbookfull.com/product/modern-portfolio-theory-andinvestment-analysis-9th-edition-elton/

Housing Markets and Household Behavior in Japan Miki Seko

https://textbookfull.com/product/housing-markets-and-householdbehavior-in-japan-miki-seko/

Markets in Profile 1st Edition Dalton James F

https://textbookfull.com/product/markets-in-profile-1st-editiondalton-james-f/

Canadian-Daoist Poetics, Ethics, and Aesthetics: An Interdisciplinary and Cross-cultural Study 1st Edition John Z. Ming Chen

https://textbookfull.com/product/canadian-daoist-poetics-ethicsand-aesthetics-an-interdisciplinary-and-cross-cultural-study-1stedition-john-z-ming-chen/

POSTMODERN PORTFOLIO THEORY

Navigating Abnormal Markets and Investor Behavior

JAMES MING CHEN

Quantitative Perspectives on Behavioral Economics and Finance

Series Editor

College of

Michigan State University East Lansing, Michigan, USA

The economic enterprise has firmly established itself as one of evaluating human responses to scarcity not as a rigidly rational game of optimization, but as a holistic behavioral phenomenon. The full spectrum of social sciences that inform economics, ranging from game theory to evolutionary psychology, has revealed the extent to which economic decisions and their consequences hinge on psychological, social, cognitive, and emotional factors beyond the reach of classical and neoclassical approaches to economics. Bounded rational decisions generate prices, returns, and resource allocation decisions that no purely rational approach to optimization would predict, let alone prescribe.

Behavioral considerations hold the key to longstanding problems in economics and finance. Market imperfections such as bubbles and crashes, herd behavior, and the equity premium puzzle represent merely a few of the phenomena whose principal causes arise from the comprehensible mysteries of human perception and behavior. Within the heterodox, broad-ranging fields of behavioral economics, a distinct branch of behavioral finance has arisen.

Finance has established itself as a distinct branch of economics by applying the full arsenal of mathematical learning on questions of risk management. Mathematical finance has become so specialized that its practitioners often divide themselves into distinct subfields. Whereas the P branch of mathematical finance seeks to model the future by managing portfolios through multivariate statistics, the Q world attempts to extrapolate the present and guide risk-neutral management through the use of partial differential equations to compute the proper price of derivatives.

The emerging field of behavioral finance, worthy of designation by the Greek letter psi (ψ), has identified deep psychological limitations on the claims of the more traditional P and Q branches of mathematical finance. From Markowitz’s original exercises in mean-variance optimization to the Black-Scholes pricing model, the foundations of mathematical finance rest on a seductively beautiful Gaussian edifice of symmetrical models and crisp quantitative modeling. When these models fail, the results are often catastrophic.

The ψ branch of behavioral finance, along with other “postmodern” critiques of traditional financial wisdom, can guide theorists and practitioners alike toward a more complete understanding of the behavior of capital markets. It will no longer suffice to extrapolate prices and forecast market trends without validating these techniques according to the full range of economic theories and empirical data. Superior modeling and

data-gathering have made it not only possible, but also imperative to harmonize mathematical finance with other branches of economics. Likewise, if behavioral finance wishes to fulfill its promise of transcending mere critique and providing a more comprehensive account of financial markets, behavioralists must engage the full mathematical apparatus known in all other branches of finance. In a world that simultaneously lauds Eugene Fama’s efficiency hypotheses and heeds Robert Shiller’s warnings against irrational exuberance, progress lies in Lars Peter Hansen’s commitment to quantitative rigor. Theory and empiricism, one and indivisible, now and forever.

More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/14524

Postmodern Portfolio Theory

Navigating Abnormal Markets and Investor Behavior

Michigan State University

East Lansing, Michigan, USA

Quantitative Perspectives on Behavioral Economics and Finance

ISBN 978-1-137-54463-6 ISBN 978-1-137-54464-3 (eBook)

DOI 10.1057/978-1-137-54464-3

Library of Congress Control Number: 2016942679

© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s) 2016

This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed.

The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made.

Cover illustration: © ZUMA Press, Inc. / Alamy Stock Photo

Cover design by Oscar Spigolon

Printed on acid-free paper

This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by Springer Nature

The registered company is Nature America Inc. New York

To Heather Elaine Worland Chen, with all my love

A CKNOWLEDGMENTS

This book incorporates ideas from papers I have presented at the University of Cincinnati, Florida State University, Georgetown University, Michigan State University, the University of Pennsylvania, the University of Virginia, and the Faculty of Economics of the University of Zagreb (Ekonomski Fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu). The International Atlantic Economic Society and the ACRN Oxford Academic Research Network have provided multiple platforms for the work underlying this book. Along the way, I have benefited from scholarly and professional interactions with Anna Agrapetidou, Abdel Razzaq Al Rababa’a, Moisa Altar, Christopher J. Brummer, Irene Maria Buso, Adam Candeub, Seth J. Chandler, Felix B. Chang, Tendai Charasika, César Crousillat, David Dixon, Robert Dubois, John F. Duffy, Daniel A. Farber, Christopher C. French, Santanu K. Ganguli, Tomislav Gelo, Periklis Gogas, Gil Grantmore, Andy Greenberg, Losbichler Heimo, Hemantha Herath, Jesper Lyng Jensen, Jagoda Kaszowska, Daniel Martin Katz, Yuri Katz, Imre Kondor, Carolina Laureti, Cordell Lawrence Jr., Cordell Lawrence Sr., Matthew Lee, Othmar Lehner, Heimo Losbichler, Gerry Mahar, Milivoj Marković, L. Thorne McCarty, Steven C. Michael, Ludmila Mitkova, José María Montero Lorenzo, Kevin Lynch, Laura Muro, Vivian Okere, Merav Ozair, Elizabeth Porter, Mobeen Ur Rehman, Carol Royal, Bob Schmidt, Jeffrey A. Sexton, Galen Sher, Ted Sichelman, Jurica Šimurina, Nika Sokol Šimurina, Robert Sonora, Lisa Grow Sun, Elvira Takli, Peter Urbani, Robert R. M. Verchick, Benjamin Walther, Karen Wendt, Gal Zahavi, and Johanna F. Ziegel. Christian Diego Alcocer Argüello, of Michigan State University’s Department of Economics, provided very capable research

assistance. I am also grateful for contributions by several students at Michigan State’s College of Law: Angela Caulley, Yuan Jiang, Morgan Pitz, Emily Strickler, Paul M. Vogel, and Michael Joseph Yassay. The research services of the Michigan State University Law Library and administrative support by Marie Gordon were indispensable. Special thanks to Heather Elaine Worland Chen.

6.9

6.10

7 Sinking, Fast and Slow: Relative Volatility Versus Correlation Tightening

7.1 The Two Behavioral Faces of Single-Sided Beta

7.2 Parameters Indicating Relative Volatility and  Correlation Tightening

7.3 Relative Volatility and the Beta Quotient

7.4 The Low-Volatility Anomaly and Bowman’s

7.5

7.6

7.7

7.8

7.9

8

9.1

9.4

10.8 Profusion and Confusion Over Measures of  Coskewness and Cokurtosis

10.9

14 Parametric VaR According to Student’s t-Distribution

14.3 Student’s t-Distribution

14.4 The Probability Density and Cumulative Distribution Functions of Student’s t-Distribution

14.5 Adjusting Student’s t-Distribution According to  Observed Levels of Kurtosis

14.6 Performing Parametric VaR Analysis with Student’s t-Distribution

15

L IST OF F IGURES

Fig. 2.1 The security market line 10

Fig. 2.2 The security characteristic line 13

Fig. 2.3 The efficient frontier 16

Fig. 6.1 The Pythagorean relationship between upside and downside semideviation 92

Fig. 6.2 Fitting an ordinary polynomial function to the equation y = x a + b, where the exponent a + b is a noninteger. The coefficients for each term in the polynomial equation are analytically rather than computationally determined 101

Fig. 14.1 A plot of the probability density function for several members of the Student’s t family of distributions 264

Fig. 15.1 The Gaussian and logistic distributions

Fig. 15.2 Logistic (blue), Student’s t (red), and Gaussian (gold) distributions

Fig. 15.3 Logistic (blue), Student’s t (red), and Gaussian (gold) distributions: A deeper look at the left tail

282

285

286

L IST OF T ABLES

Table 6.1 The Treynor, Sharpe, and Sortino ratios

Table 6.2 Comparing the Sharpe ratio with a standard score

Table 6.3 A closer comparison of the Sharpe and Sortino ratios

Table 6.4 Trigonometric measurements of asymmetry in single-sided volatility

Table 6.5 Risk-adjusted measures of financial performance drawn from lower partial moments of the distribution of returns

Table 7.1 Relative volatility and correlation tightening in developed and emerging markets, 1988–2001

Table 10.1 The first four orders of a family of risk measures drawn from statistical cross moments

Table 10.2 The first four orders of a family of single-sided risk measures drawn from statistical cross moments, specified on the downside of mean returns

Table 11.1 Coefficients of determination indicating the statistical power of Fama and French’s three-factor model, CAPM with coskewness, and conventional (single-factor) CAPM

Table 13.1 Gaussian VaR at commonly used intervals

Table 14.1 VaR according to Student’s t-distribution for different numbers of degrees of freedom (ν)

Table 14.2 Kurtosis in returns on 13 noncash asset classes, February 1990 through May 2010

Table 15.1 VaR at γ2 = 1.2 under the logistic distribution and Student’s t-distribution, ν = 9

Table 16.1 VaR and expected shortfall under Student’s t-distribution, ν ∈ {4, 6, 10, 12}

82

82

85

93

98

124

212

213

229

254

271

273

284

301

Table 16.2 VaR and expected shortfall under the logistic distribution

Table 17.1 VaR and expected shortfall under logistic, Student’s t, and Gaussian models at a confidence level of p = 2 –15

303

316

CHAPTER 1

Finance as a Pattern of Timeless Moments

1.1 INTRODUCTION

Quantitative finance traces its roots to modern portfolio theory. Despite the deficiencies of modern portfolio theory, mean-variance optimization nevertheless continues to form the basis for contemporary finance. The term postmodern portfolio theory captures many of the advances in financial learning since the original articulation of modern portfolio theory. A comprehensive approach to financial risk management must address all aspects of portfolio theory, from the beautiful symmetries of modern portfolio theory to the disturbing behavioral insights and the vastly expanded mathematical arsenal of the postmodern critique.

This survey of portfolio theory, from its modern origins through more sophisticated, “postmodern” incarnations, evaluates portfolio risk according to the first four moments of any statistical distribution: mean, variance, skewness, and excess kurtosis. Postmodern Portfolio Theory also evaluates the challenge that prospect theory and behavioral finance pose to portfolio theory and, more broadly, to quantitative finance. The efficient capital markets hypothesis and the conventional two-moment capital asset pricing

T.S. ELIOT, Little Gidding, in FOUR QUARTETS 49–59, 58 (Harcourt, Brace & Co. 1971; 1st ed. 1943) (“for history is a pattern/Of timeless moments”).

© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s) 2016

J.M. Chen, Postmodern Portfolio Theory, DOI 10.1057/978-1-137-54464-3_1

1

model now compete with the postmodern alternative of an expanded four-moment capital asset pricing model and its behavioral extensions. Mastery of postmodern portfolio theory’s quantitative tools and behavioral insights holds the key to the efficient frontier of risk management.

This book proceeds in four parts. Part 1 introduces portfolio theory. Chapter 2 expounds modern portfolio theory as a framework for assessing risk-adjusted financial returns. Conventional mean-variance analysis, the foundation of modern portfolio theory, emphasizes expected return, standard deviation, and beta. These quantitative measures are drawn from the lower moments of statistical distributions.

Chapter 3 outlines new approaches to portfolio theory that account for market abnormalities and investor behavior. The foundational theory of contemporary finance is riddled not only with mistakes in measurement, but also with mistakes in perception. At its most ambitious, the postmodern critique seeks ways to account for the destructive potential of systemic coordination and cascades. At its most modest, postmodern portfolio theory respects fundamental limits on human knowledge.

Parts 2 and 3 pursue the postmodern agenda for risk management by emphasizing asymmetry in finance and the higher statistical moments of financial returns. This book’s approach to postmodern portfolio theory emphasizes single-sided statistical moments, the statistical notions of skewness and kurtosis, and behavioral responses to these decidedly abnormal financial phenomena. Beginning with a bifurcation of beta on either side of mean returns, Part 2 of this book tours financial and behavioral space in search of a mathematically cogent account of risk on either side of mean returns. After a brief exploration of time series models that measure asymmetry in volatility alongside intertemporal changes in volatility, Part 3 specifies a four-moment capital asset pricing model based upon a Taylor series expansion of log returns.

Part 4 devotes additional attention to the problem of fat tails and kurtosis risk in finance. It does so by examining the treatment of value-at-risk and expected shortfall as measures of market risk in the trading book of financial institutions observing the Basel Accords on international banking regulation. Risk management, even when undertaken by some of the world’s largest financial institutions under central bank supervision, cannot fully escape mathematically dictated limitations on economic forecasting.

PART 1

Perpetual Possibility in a World of Speculation: Portfolio Theory in Its Modern and Postmodern Incarnations

See ELIOT, Burnt Norton, in FOUR QUARTETS 13–22, 13 (“What might have been is an abstraction/Remaining perpetual possibility/Only in a world of speculation.”).

Chapter 2

Modern portfolio theory

2.1 Mathe Matically i nfor Med r isk M anageMent

portfolio theory may be the most fecund intellectual export from quantitative finance to other sciences. Social sciences outside the strictly financial domain have applied portfolio theory to subjects as diverse as regional development,1 social psychology,2 and information retrieval.3 proper understanding of portfolio theory and its place in finance and cognate sciences begins with a return to the origins of modern portfolio theory. For “the end of all our exploring/Will be to arrive where we started/and know the place for the first time.”4

Modern portfolio theory offers a mathematically informed approach to financial risk management.5 Modern portfolio theory assumes that investors are rationally risk averse.6 Given two portfolios with the same expected return, investors prefer the less risky one.7 although idiosyncratic risks are hard to identify, let alone manage, diversification reduces the systemic risk that market forces will swamp an entire portfolio of highly correlated assets.8 reward follows risk:9 though a riskier investment is not necessarily more rewarding, modern portfolio theory does predict that an investor will demand a higher expected return in exchange for accepting greater risk.10 a direct, positive relationship between risk and return is canonical to conventional theories of finance.

© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s) 2016

J.M. Chen, Postmodern Portfolio Theory, DOI 10.1057/978-1-137-54464-3_2

5

2.2 M easures of r isk ; the s harpe r atio

Measures of risk abound within modern portfolio theory. harry Markowitz’s original formulation used the volatility of returns, as measured by their standard deviation, as a proxy for risk.11 William Sharpe proposed a measure of “reward to variability” that relied squarely on standard deviation:12

Sharpe ratio =RR f s

where R represents expected return, Rf represents the return from a riskfree baseline such as treasury bonds, and σ represents standard deviation. the Sharpe ratio bears an obvious resemblance to the definition of a standard score in ordinary statistics:13

2.3

B eta

an alternative measure for risk, beta, compares returns on an individual asset or a portfolio of assets with returns realized from a broader benchmark, based on the entirety or at least some significant portion of the financial market.14 the beta of an asset within a portfolio measures the (1) the covariance between the rate of return on the asset and the rate of return on the portfolio as a whole (2) divided by the variance of returns on the portfolio.15 More formally:

Beta may be most intuitively understood by relation to standard statistical measures of correlation. pearson’s r is the standard measure of correlation between two sets of data. When specified for an entire population

rather than a sample, pearson’s correlation coefficient is designated as ρ(x, y): r ss xy

xy , cov, () = ()

By contrast, beta is a measure of covariance. For any two sets of data, represented by independent variable x and dependent variable y, beta for y is the ratio of the covariance between the two data sets to the variance of x:

the mathematical relationship between beta and pearson’s correlation coefficient can be reduced to the verbal description of beta as “correlated relative volatility”:16

Whether designated as correlated relative volatility or (even more colorfully) as financial elasticity, beta reports the sensitivity of an individual asset or an entire asset class to market returns.17 Because beta measures nondiversifiable, systematic risk, it supplies information on volatility and liquidity in the broader marketplace.18 By measuring covariance between a single security and the market as a whole, beta presents the simplest model of market behavior that does not “assum[e] away the existence of interrelationships among securities,” but nevertheless “captures a large part of such interrelationships.”19 In this sense, beta is less comprehensive than standard deviation, which, as used in the Sharpe ratio, captures both systematic risk and the idiosyncratic risk inherent in a single asset.20 this limitation on beta can prove useful in fund management, since a measurement of beta may help separate an active portfolio manager’s skill from her or his willingness to take risk.21

Zero beta indicates a lack of correlation between an asset and its benchmark. negative beta indicates inverse correlation; positive market movement means a loss in value for the asset, and vice versa.22 For certain assets, negative beta may represent successful performance. For instance, over an appropriately limited time frame, an inverse exchangetraded fund (etF) that uses derivatives to profit from a decline in the Standard & poor’s 500 (S&p 500) would report complete success in that endeavor if it is able to report a beta of −1 relative to the S&p 500. By holding that etF, an investor can hedge against a decline in the S&p 500 without carrying the margin account needed to engage in the shortselling of securities.23

t here is a notable exception to this interpretation of zero beta. Under unusual conditions, zero beta may indicate zero correlation with the market despite rampant volatility in the price of an asset. e ven if the underlying asset is quite volatile in absolute terms, a complete lack of correlation with the market yields a beta of zero.24 a purely speculative asset, such as Bitcoin, may exhibit wild swings in price with zero or nearly zero correlation with changes in the price of other tradable assets. e stimates of the absolute value of Bitcoin’s correlation with other assets range from a high of 16–17 % for gold and inflation-linked bonds 25 to a low of practically zero for gold and leading world currencies. 26 In these circumstances, beta would report little or no risk, while standard deviation would report a palpable degree of risk. Formally: β ≈ 0; σ ≫ 0.

to compound the difficulty in interpreting results of this sort, sources point in diametrically opposite directions on the investment potential of Bitcoin. one source, persuaded that Bitcoin’s “high risk is compensated by low correlations with other assets,” recommends “[i]ncluding even a small proportion of Bitcoins in a well diversified portfolio” as a step toward “dramatically improv[ing] risk-return characteristics.”27 another source concludes that Bitcoin behaves more like “a speculative investment than a currency”28 and “is completely ineffective as a tool of risk management.”29 Consistent with the notion of confirmation bias in behavioral economics,30 one’s perspective on Bitcoin may hinge on whether the interpreter is (or at least is predisposed to be) a breathless enthusiast,31 or else dismisses cryptocurrency as a technological fantasy for gamblers, libertarians, polemicists, and criminals.32 although there is no upper or lower bound on the value of beta, a useful analytical baseline is represented by a beta of 1. Beta of 1 indicates

an asset whose systemic volatility, or sensitivity to risk, is exactly the same as that of the broader market.33 positive values for beta below 1—that is, 0 < β < 1—indicate an asset that moves in the same direction as the broader market but is not as sensitive to the market’s movements. Values for beta greater than 1 indicate greater sensitivity.34

2.4 t he c apital a sset p ricing M odel

Beta plays a pivotal role in one of the most important expressions of modern portfolio theory, the capital asset pricing model (CapM).35 the CapM expresses return on an asset as a function of risk, which in turn can be expressed as volatility, beta, or some other measure. the independent development, particularly by William Sharpe and John lintner,36 of “general models represent[ing] equivalent approaches to the problem of capital asset pricing under uncertainty” gave rise to what we recognize today as the CapM.37

the CapM quantifies the premium demanded by the market for shouldering that asset’s volatility over a benchmark represented by the return on a risk-free investment:38

where Ra, Rm, and Rf respectively represent returns on the asset, on the broader market of comparable investments, and on a risk-free investment, and where βa represents the individual asset’s beta vis-à-vis a portfolio based on the broader market.39 this formula takes the form of a linear equation where the return on an asset (Ra) is expressed as a function of the premium over a risk-free baseline (Rm Rf).40

Within the CapM, beta (βa) represents the slope of the linear function, and the risk-free return (Rf) is a constant that defines the function’s y-intercept.41 this graphical representation of the CapM is known as the security market line (Fig. 2.1).42

Modest algebraic rearrangement of the CapM yields the following relationship:

Another random document with no related content on Scribd:

My life grew rich with her, unbribed by hope Of other guerdon save to think she knew One grateful votary paid her all her due; Happy if she, high-radiant there, resigned To his sure trust her image in his mind. O fairer even than Peace is when she comes Hushing War’s tumult, and retreating drums Fade to a murmur like the sough of bees Hidden among the noon-stilled linden-trees, Bringer of quiet, thou that canst allay The dust and din and travail of the day, Strewer of Silence, Giver of the dew

That doth our pastures and our souls renew, Still dwell remote, still on thy shoreless sea Float unattained in sacred empery, Still light my thoughts, nor listen to a prayer Would make thee less imperishably fair! II.

Can, then, my twofold nature find content In vain conceits of airy blandishment? Ask I no more? Since yesterday I task My storm-strewn thoughts to tell me what I ask: Faint premonitions of mutation strange Steal o’er my perfect orb, and, with the change, Myself am changed; the shadow of my earth Darkens the disc of that celestial worth Which only yesterday could still suffice Upwards to waft my thoughts in sacrifice; My heightened fancy with its touches warm Moulds to a woman’s that ideal form; Nor yet a woman’s wholly, but divine With awe her purer essence bred in mine. Was it long brooding on their own surmise, Which, of the eyes engendered, fools the eyes, O h I th h th t t l t i

Or have I seen through that translucent air A Presence shaped in its seclusions bare, My Goddess looking on me from above As look our russet maidens when they love, But high-uplifted o’er our human heat And passion-paths too rough for her pearl feet?

Slowly the Shape took outline as I gazed At her full-orbed or crescent, till, bedazed With wonder-working light that subtly wrought My brain to its own substance, steeping thought In trances such as poppies give, I saw Things shut from vision by sight’s sober law, Amorphous, changeful, but defined at last Into the peerless Shape mine eyes hold fast. This, too, at first I worshipt: soon, like wine, Her eyes, in mine poured, frenzy-philtred mine; Passion put Worship’s priestly raiment on And to the woman knelt, the Goddess gone. Was I, then, more than mortal made? or she Less than divine that she might mate with me? If mortal merely, could my nature cope With such o’ermastery of maddening hope? If Goddess, could she feel the blissful woe That women in their self-surrender know? III.

Long she abode aloof there in her heaven, Far as the grape-bunch of the Pleiad seven

Beyond my madness' utmost leap; but here Mine eyes have feigned of late her rapture near, Moulded of mind-mist that broad day dispels, Here in these shadowy woods and brook-lulled dells.

Have no heaven-habitants e’er felt a void In hearts sublimed with ichor unalloyed?

E’er longed to mingle with a mortal fate Intense with pathos of its briefer date? Could she partake, and live, our human stains?

Even with the thought there tingles through my veins Sense of unwarned renewal; I, the dead, Receive and house again the ardor fled, As once Alcestis; to the ruddy brim Feel masculine virtue flooding every limb, And life, like Spring returning, brings the key That sets my senses from their winter free, Dancing like naked fauns too glad for shame. Her passion, purified to palest flame, Can it thus kindle? Is her purpose this? I will not argue, lest I lose a bliss That makes me dream Tithonus' fortune mine, (Or what of it was palpably divine Ere came the fruitlessly immortal gift;) I cannot curb my hope’s imperious drift That wings with fire my dull mortality; Though fancy-forged, ’tis all I feel or see.

My Goddess sinks; round Latmos' darkening brow

Trembles the parting of her presence now, Faint as the perfume left upon the grass

By her limbs' pressure or her feet that pass By me conjectured, but conjectured so

As things I touch far fainter substance show. Was it mine eyes' imposture I have seen

Flit with the moonbeams on from shade to sheen

Through the wood-openings? Nay, I see her now

Out of her heaven new-lighted, from her brow

The hair breeze-scattered, like loose mists that blow

Across her crescent, goldening as they go

High-kirtled for the chase, and what was shown, Of maiden rondure, like the rose half-blown.

If dream, turn real! If a vision, stay!

Take mortal shape, my philtre’s spell obey!

If hags compel thee from thy secret sky

With gruesome incantations, why not I, Whose only magic is that I distil

A potion, blent of passion, thought, and will,

Deeper in reach, in force of fate more rich, Than e’er was juice wrung by Thessalian witch

From moon-enchanted herbs,—a potion brewed

Of my best life in each diviner mood?

Myself the elixir am, myself the bowl

Seething and mantling with my soul of soul. Taste and be humanized: what though the cup, With thy lips frenzied, shatter? Drink it up!

If but these arms may clasp, o’erquited so, My world, thy heaven, all life means I shall know.

Sure she hath heard my prayer and granted half, As Gods do who at mortal madness laugh. In sleep she comes; she visits me in dreams, And, as her image in a thousand streams, So in my veins, that her obey, she sees, Floating and flaming there, her images Bear to my little world’s remotest zone Glad messages of her, and her alone. With silence-sandalled Sleep she comes to me, (But softer-footed, sweeter-browed, than she,) In motion gracious as a seagull’s wing, And all her bright limbs, moving, seem to sing. If life’s most solid things illusion seem, Why should not substance wear the mask of dream? Let me believe so, then, if so I may With the night’s bounty feed my beggared day. In dreams I see her lay the goddess down With bow and quiver, and her crescent-crown Flicker and fade away to dull eclipse As down to mine she deigns her longed-for lips; And as her neck my happy arms enfold, Flooded and lustred with her loosened gold, She whispers words each sweeter than a kiss: Then, wakened with the shock of sudden bliss, My arms are empty, my awakener fled, And, silent in the silent sky o’erhead, But coldly as on ice-plated snow, she gleams, Herself the mother and the child of dreams.

Gone is the time when phantasms could appease My quest phantasmal and bring cheated ease; When, if she glorified my dreams, I felt Through all my limbs a change immortal melt

At t h f h ill i t ith l

At touch of hers illuminate with soul. Not long could I be stilled with Fancy’s dole; Too soon the mortal mixture in me caught Red fire from her celestial flame, and fought For tyrannous control in all my veins: My fool’s prayer was accepted; what remains? Or was it some eidolon merely, sent By her who rules the shades in banishment, To mock me with her semblance? Were it thus, How ’scape I shame, whose will was traitorous? What shall-compensate an ideal dimmed? How blanch again my statue virgin-limbed, Soiled with the incense-smoke her chosen priest Poured more profusely as within decreased The fire unearthly, fed with coals from far Within the soul’s shrine? Could my fallen star Be set in heaven again by prayers and tears And quenchless sacrifice of all my years, How would the victim to the flamen leap, And life for life’s redemption paid hold cheap!

But what resource when she herself descends From her blue throne, and o’er her vassal bends That shape thrice-deified by love, those eyes Wherein the Lethe of all others lies?

When my white queen of heaven’s remoteness tires, Herself against her other self conspires, Takes woman’s nature, walks in mortal ways, And finds in my remorse her beauty’s praise? Yet all would I renounce to dream again The dream in dreams fulfilled that made my pain, My noble pain that heightened all my years With crowns to win and prowess-breeding tears; Nay, would that dream renounce once more to see Her from her sky there looking down at me!

VII.

Goddess, reclimb thy heaven, and be once more An inaccessible splendor to adore, A faith, a hope of such transcendent worth As bred ennobling discontent with earth; Give back the longing, back the elated mood That, fed with thee, spurned every meaner good; Give even the spur of impotent despair That, without hope, still bade aspire and dare; Give back the need to worship that still pours Down to the soul that virtue it adores!

Nay, brightest and most beautiful, deem naught These frantic words, the reckless wind of thought; Still stoop, still grant,—I live but in thy will; Be what thou wilt, but be a woman still! Vainly I cried, nor could myself believe That what I prayed for I would fain receive. My moon is set; my vision set with her; No more can worship vain my pulses stir. Goddess Triform, I own thy triple spell, My heaven’s queen,—queen, too, of my earth and hell!

THE BLACK PREACHER.

A BRETON LEGEND.

A Carnac in Brittany, close on the bay, They show you a church, or rather the gray Ribs of a dead one, left there to bleach With the wreck lying near on the crest of the beach, Roofless and splintered with thunder-stone, ’Mid lichen-blurred gravestones all alone; ’Tis the kind of ruin strange sights to see That may have their teaching for you and me.

Something like this then my guide had to tell

Something like this, then, my guide had to tell, Perched on a saint cracked across when he fell; But since I might chance give his meaning a wrench, He talking his patois and I English-French, I’ll put what he told me, preserving the tone, In a rhymed prose that makes it half his, half my own.

An abbey-church stood here, once on a time, Built as a death-bed atonement for crime: ’Twas for somebody’s sins, I know not whose; But sinners are plenty, and you can choose. Though a cloister now of the dusk-winged bat, ’Twas rich enough once, and the brothers grew fat, Looser in girdle and purpler in jowl, Singing good rest to the founder’s lost soul.

But one day came Northmen, and lithe tongues of fire Lapped up the chapter-house, licked off the spire, And left all a rubbish-heap, black and dreary, Where only the wind sings miserere.

No priest has kneeled since at the altar’s foot, Whose crannies are searched by the nightshade’s root, Nor sound of service is ever heard, Except from throat of the unclean bird, Hooting to unassoiled shapes as they pass In midnights unholy his witches' mass, Or shouting “Ho! ho!” from the belfry high As the Devil’s sabbath-train whirls by.

But once a year, on the eve of All-Souls, Through these arches dishallowed the organ rolls, Fingers long fleshless the bell-ropes work, The chimes peal muffled with sea-mists mirk, The skeleton windows are traced anew On the baleful flicker of corpse-lights blue, And the ghosts must come, so the legend saith, To a preaching of Reverend Doctor Death.

Abbots, monks, barons, and ladies fair

Hear the dull summons and gather there: No rustle of silk now, no clink of mail, Nor ever a one greets his church-mate pale; No knight whispers love in the châtelaine’s ear

His next-door neighbor this five hundred year; No monk has a sleek benedicite

For the great lord shadowy now as he; Nor needeth any to hold his breath, Lest he lose the least word of Doctor Death.

He chooses his text in the Book Divine, Tenth verse of the Preacher in chapter nine:— “'Whatsoever thy hand shall find thee to do, That do with thy whole might, or thou shalt rue; For no man is wealthy, or wise, or brave, In that quencher of might-be’s and would-be’s, the grave.'

Bid by the Bridegroom, 'To-morrow,' ye said, And To-morrow was digging a trench for your bed; Ye said, 'God can wait; let us finish our wine;' Ye had wearied Him, fools, and that last knock was mine!”

But I can’t pretend to give you the sermon, Or say if the tongue were French, Latin, or German; Whatever he preached in, I give you my word The meaning was easy to all that heard; Famous preachers there have been and be, But never was one so convincing as he; So blunt was never a begging friar, No Jesuit’s tongue so barbed with fire, Cameronian never, nor Methodist, Wrung gall out of Scripture with such a twist.

And would you know who his hearers must be?

I tell you just what my guide told me:

Excellent teaching men have, day and night, From two earnest friars, a black and a white, The Dominican Death and the Carmelite Life;

e o ca eat a d t e Ca e te e; And between these two there is never strife, For each has his separate office and station, And each his own work in the congregation; Whoso to the white brother deafens his ears, And cannot be wrought on by blessings or tears, Awake in his coffin must wait and wait, In that blackness of darkness that means too late, And come once a year, when the ghost-bell tolls, As till Doomsday it shall on the eve of All-Souls, To hear Doctor Death, whose words smart with the brine Of the Preacher, the tenth verse of chapter nine.

ARCADIA REDIVIVA.

I, the familiar street, While a crammed horse-car jingled through it, Was lifted from my prosy feet And in Arcadia ere I knew it.

Fresh sward for gravel soothed my tread, And shepherd’s pipes my ear delighted; The riddle may be lightly read: I met two lovers newly plighted.

They murmured by in happy care, New plans for paradise devising, Just as the moon, with pensive stare, O’er Mistress Craigie’s pines was rising.

Astarte, known nigh threescore years, Me to no speechless rapture urges; Them in Elysium she enspheres, Queen, from of old, of thaumaturges.

The railings put forth bud and bloom, The house-fronts all with myrtles twine them, And light-winged Loves in every room

And light-winged Loves in every room Make nests, and then with kisses line them.

O sweetness of untasted life!

O dream, its own supreme fulfilment!

O hours with all illusion rife, As ere the heart divined what ill meant!

“Et ego,” sighed I to myself, And strove some vain regrets to bridle, “Though now laid dusty on the shelf, Was hero once of such an idyl!

“An idyl ever newly sweet, Although since Adam’s day recited, Whose measures time them to Love’s feet, Whose sense is every ill requited.”

Maiden, if I may counsel, drain

Each drop of this enchanted season, For even our honeymoons must wane, Convicted of green cheese by Reason.

And none will seem so safe from change, Nor in such skies benignant hover, As this, beneath whose witchery strange You tread on rose-leaves with your lover.

The glass unfilled all tastes can fit, As round its brim Conjecture dances; For not Mephisto’s self hath wit To draw such vintages as Fancy’s.

When our pulse beats its minor key, When play-time halves and school-time doubles, Age fills the cup with serious tea, Which once Dame Clicquot starred with bubbles.

“Fie, Mr. Graybeard! Is this wise?

Is this the moral of a poet, Who, when the plant of Eden dies, Is privileged once more to sow it?

“That herb of clay-disdaining root, From stars secreting what it feeds on, Is burnt-out passion’s slag and soot Fit soil to strew its dainty seeds on?

“Pray, why, if in Arcadia once, Need one so soon forget the way there? Or why, once there, be such a dunce As not contentedly to stay there?”

Dear child, ’twas but a sorry jest, And from my heart I hate the cynic Who makes the Book of Life a nest For comments staler than rabbinic.

If Love his simple spell but keep, Life with ideal eyes to flatter, The Grail itself were crockery cheap To Every-day’s communion-platter.

One Darby is to me well known, Who, as the hearth between them blazes, Sees the old moonlight shine on Joan, And float her youthward in its hazes.

He rubs his spectacles, he stares,— ’Tis the same face that witched him early! He gropes for his remaining hairs,— Is this a fleece that feels so curly?

“Good heavens! but now ’twas winter gray, And I of years had more than plenty; The almanac’s a fool! ’Tis May! Hang family Bibles! I am twenty!

“Come, Joan, your arm; we’ll walk the room— The lane, I mean—do you remember? How confident the roses bloom, As if it ne’er could be December!

“Nor more it shall, while in your eyes My heart its summer heat recovers, And you, howe’er your mirror lies, Find your old beauty in your lover’s.”

THE NEST.

When oaken woods with buds are pink, And new-come birds each morning sing, When fickle May on Summer’s brink Pauses, and knows not which to fling, Whether fresh bud and bloom again, Or hoar-frost silvering hill and plain,

Then from the honeysuckle gray

The oriole with experienced quest Twitches the fibrous bark away, The cordage of his hammock-nest, Cheering his labor with a note Rich as the orange of his throat.

High o’er the loud and dusty road

The soft gray cup in safety swings, To brim ere August with its load Of downy breasts and throbbing wings, O’er which the friendly elm-tree heaves An emerald roof with sculptured eaves.

Below, the noisy World drags by

In the old way, because it must, The bride with heartbreak in her eye, The mourner following hated dust: Thy duty, wingëd flame of Spring, Is but to love, and fly, and sing.

Oh, happy life, to soar and sway

Above the life by mortals led, Singing the merry months away, Master, not slave of daily bread, And, when the Autumn comes, to flee Wherever sunshine beckons thee!

PALINODE.—DECEMBER.

Like some lorn abbey now, the wood Stands roofless in the bitter air; In ruins on its floor is strewed

The carven foliage quaint and rare, And homeless winds complain along The columned choir once thrilled with song.

And thou, dear nest, whence joy and praise

The thankful oriole used to pour, Swing’st empty while the north winds chase Their snowy swarms from Labrador: But, loyal to the happy past, I love thee still for what thou wast.

Ah, when the Summer graces flee From other nests more dear than thou, And, where June crowded once, I see Only bare trunk and disleaved bough; When springs of life that gleamed and gushed Run chilled, and slower, and are hushed;

When our own branches, naked long, The vacant nests of Spring betray, Nurseries of passion, love, and song That vanished as our year grew gray; When Life drones o’er a tale twice told O’er embers pleading with the cold,—

I’ll trust, that, like the birds of Spring, Our good goes not without repair, But only flies to soar and sing Far off in some diviner air, Where we shall find it in the calms Of that fair garden ’neath the palms.

A YOUTHFUL EXPERIMENT IN ENGLISH HEXAMETERS.

IMPRESSIONS OF HOMER.

S come pauses of calm, when the rapt bard, holding his heart back,

Over his deep mind muses, as when o’er awestricken ocean Poises a heapt cloud luridly, ripening the gale and the thunder; Slow rolls onward the verse with a long swell heaving and swinging, Seeming to wait till, gradually wid’ning from far-off horizons, Piling the deeps up, heaping the glad-hearted surges before it, Gathers the thought as a strong wind darkening and cresting the tumult. Then every pause, every heave, each trough in the waves, has its meaning; Full-sailed, forth like a tall ship steadies the theme, and around it, Leaping beside it in glad strength, running in wild glee beyond it, Harmonies billow exulting and floating the soul where it lists them, Swaying the listener’s fantasy hither and thither like driftweed.

BIRTHDAY VERSES.

WRITTEN IN A CHILD’S ALBUM.

’Twas sung of old in hut and hall How once a king in evil hour Hung musing o’er his castle wall, And, lost in idle dreams, let fall Into the sea his ring of power.

Then, let him sorrow as he might, And pledge his daughter and his throne To who restored the jewel bright, The broken spell would ne’er unite; The grim old ocean held its own.

Those awful powers on man that wait, On man, the beggar or the king, To hovel bare or hall of state A magic ring that masters fate With each succeeding birthday bring. Therein are set four jewels rare: Pearl winter, summer’s ruby blaze, Spring’s emerald, and, than all more fair, Fall’s pensive opal, doomed to bear A heart of fire bedreamed with haze.

To him the simple spell who knows The spirits of the ring to sway, Fresh power with every sunrise flows, And royal pursuivants are those That fly his mandates to obey.

But he that with a slackened will Dreams of things past or things to be, From him the charm is slipping still, And drops, ere he suspect the ill, Into the inexorable sea.

ESTRANGEMENT.

T path from me to you that led, Untrodden long, with grass is grown,— Mute carpet that his lieges spread Before the Prince Oblivion When he goes visiting the dead.

And who are they but who forget? You, who my coming could surmise Ere any hint of me as yet Warned other ears and other eyes, See the path blurred without regret.

But when I trace its windings sweet With saddened steps, at every spot That feels the memory in my feet, Each grass-blade turns forget-me-not, Where murmuring bees your name repeat.

PHŒBE.

E pales in Heaven the morning star, A bird, the loneliest of its kind, Hears Dawn’s faint footfall from afar While all its mates are dumb and blind.

It is a wee sad-colored thing, As shy and secret as a maid, That, ere in choir the robins ring, Pipes its own name like one afraid.

It seems pain-prompted to repeat The story of some ancient ill, But Phœbe! Phœbe! sadly sweet Is all it says, and then is still.

It calls and listens. Earth and sky, Hushed by the pathos of its fate, Listen: no whisper of reply Comes from its doom-dissevered mate.

Phœbe! it calls and calls again, And Ovid, could he but have heard, Had hung a legendary pain About the memory of the bird; A pain articulate so long In penance of some mouldered crime Whose ghost still flies the Furies' thong Down the waste solitudes of time.

Waif of the young World’s wonder-hour, When gods found mortal maidens fair, And will malign was joined with power Love’s kindly laws to overbear,

Like Progne, did it feel the stress And coil of the prevailing words Close round its being, and compress Man’s ampler nature to a bird’s?

One only memory left of all The motley crowd of vanished scenes, Hers, and vain impulse to recall By repetition what it means.

Phœbe! is all it has to say In plaintive cadence o’er and o’er, Like children that have lost their way, And know their names, but nothing more.

Is it a type, since Nature’s Lyre Vibrates to every note in man, Of that insatiable desire, Meant to be so since life began?

I, in strange lands at gray of dawn, Wakeful, have heard that fruitless plaint Through Memory’s chambers deep withdrawn Renew its iterations faint.

So nigh! yet from remotest years It summons back its magic, rife With longings unappeased, and tears Drawn from the very source of life.

DAS EWIG-WEIBLICHE.

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.