NAT IONA L CAT HOL IC R EGIST ER , J U LY 17, 2022
3
NATION
Questions Abound in the Wake of Msgr. Burrill’s Return to Active Ministry BY J U DY R O B E R T S REGISTER CORRESPONDENT
LA CROSSE, Wis. — A decision to restore Msgr. Jeffrey Burrill to active ministry in his home diocese in Wisconsin, less than a year after a scandal involving his alleged use of the “hook-up” app Grindr, has raised questions about the prudence of the move and the way in which it was implemented. Bishop William Callahan of La Crosse told members of St. Teresa of Kolkata parish June 11-12 that Msgr. Burrill would be their new parochial administrator. He further expressed confidence in his ability to accompany them in their journey toward Christ. However, although he said in a brief statement published on the parish website that Msgr. Burrill had most recently served the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in Washington, he did not mention the priest’s resignation last July as general secretary immediately preceding an investigative report in The Pillar. According to that report, Msgr. Burrill allegedly had engaged in inappropriate behavior and frequent use of Grindr, which describes itself as “the world’s largest socialnetworking app for gay, bi, trans and queer people.” The bishop’s statement also did not say what Msgr. Burrill did during an “extended leave” from active ministry other than to state he “engaged in a sincere and prayerful effort to strengthen his priestly vows” and responded favorably to every request made by Bishop Callahan and the diocese. Those requests were not specified. Finally, although the diocese had pledged full cooperation with the USCCB last year to investigate and address the claims against Msgr. Burrill, the statement said only that the diocese has received no allegations of illegal misconduct by him. Since the announcement of Msgr. Burrill’s appointment, there has been no apparent response from parishioners at St. Teresa of Kolkata. Nothing has appeared on the parish Facebook page, though a post about the appointment on the diocese’s Facebook page generated more than a dozen comments and reactions, most of them expressing surprise, anger or sadness, but none were identified as coming from a parishioner. Non-parishioner Monica Mohan responded to the diocese’s post
BACK IN A PARISH. Msgr. Jeffrey Burrill, shown reading a tally during the U.S. bishops’ June 2021 virtual assembly, has returned to active ministry in his home diocese in Wisconsin, less than a year after a scandal involving his alleged use of a ‘hook-up’ app. Screenshot via USCCB/YouTube with a link to an article about the appointment from LifeSiteNews, which contrasted Bishop Callahan’s support for Msgr. Burrill with his censure of Father James Altman, another priest of the diocese. Bishop Callahan removed Father Altman as pastor of St. James the Less parish and removed his priestly faculties last July after seeking to correct him privately for inflammatory commentary on multiple socialmedia platforms. Mohan, of Fall Creek, Wisconsin, also mentioned the Father Altman dismissal in a letter to the La Crosse Tribune, criticizing the bishop’s handling of both it and the Msgr. Burrill appointment. “A good bishop protects — is transparent,” she wrote.
Incomplete Accounting Father Gerald Murray, a canon lawyer and pastor of Holy Family Church in New York, told the Register he sees Bishop Callahan’s statement as lacking in candor and avoiding a plain accounting for the public scandal that Msgr. Burrill occasioned. It also leaves the impression, he added, that because no one sent the diocese allegations of illegal misconduct, there was nothing more to be done. Furthermore, he said, it raises such questions as whether an investigation was done by a qualified professional, independent expert, whether it covered the potential use of Church or USCCB funds for immoral activity and whether Msgr. Burrill sought and received professional help for a possible sexual addiction. Likewise, Father Murray said, there was no reference to the
Church’s Canon 1395-2, which provides for penalties, not excluding dismissal from the clerical state, against clerics who publicly offend against the Sixth Commandment. Absent also from Bishop Callahan’s statement, he said, is whether Msgr. Burrill will be closely monitored by a diocesan official, whether parishioners will have a way to raise concerns about his behavior and where he will be residing. Efforts by the Register to obtain answers to such questions about Msgr. Burrill’s appointment have been met with silence on the part of the Diocese of La Crosse as well as St. Teresa of Kolkata parish. Repeated calls and emails have not been returned. “The assignment of Msgr. Burrill to a leadership position of pastoral responsibility without a full accounting for what he did and without a sincere expression of public regret by Msgr. Burrill himself,” Father Murray said, “strikes me as extremely imprudent and seems to follow the all-too-familiar pattern of bishops protecting clerics known to have engaged in grave sexual immorality while asking the faithful to trust their judgment.”
Clericalist Approach? Indeed, Andrew Petiprin, who wrote about the Msgr. Burrill appointment in a recent Catholic World Report column, told the Register that such situations reinforce the perception that the Church hierarchy has a problem of clericalism. “It just seems to me that Msgr. Burrill’s bishop has really put his concern for his priests ahead of the greater good for the people in his
diocese.” A former Episcopal priest who came into full communion with the Church in 2019, Petiprin said he is speaking as a concerned layman who believes the mercy shown to Msgr. Burrill needs to be balanced with the needs of the people of God. He said, “I think it’s important, obviously, for his bishop to care about him and desire the best for him, but he also has a major responsibility to care for the souls of the people in his diocese and also to care about the perception of things in the eyes of the world.” Petiprin said it’s not that some kind of rehabilitation is out of the question for Msgr. Burrill. “But it does seem a little strange that less than a year after he was exposed in a public scandal that he be returned to active ministry.” A priest with expertise in priestly formation, ethics and canon law who asked not to be named said he was less bothered by the brevity of time between Msgr. Burrill’s USCCB resignation and his return to ministry than by the lack of information being made available about the situation. “It seems like the People of God are being gaslit, as though this never happened,” he said. “This was made public, and, therefore, the public needs a response from the Church as far as what happened.” The priest said the statement that no allegations of illegal misconduct were received indicates passivity on the part of the diocese and not that there was an investigation. If an investigation did take place and it identified people who were involved with Msgr. Burrill, the priest said there could be reasons to keep it quiet to protect them. However, he said, there also is an obligation to clarify that the Church does not approve of this behavior and will not sanction it, meaning some penalty was inflicted
BY C AT H O L I C N E W S AG E N C Y
HIGHLAND PARK, Ill. — Pope Francis expressed shock and sadness over the mass shooting that led to the deaths of at least seven people and wounded more than 30 others at a Fourth of July parade in the Chicago suburb of Highland Park. In a telegram sent on behalf of the Holy Father to Cardinal Blase Cupich, the archbishop of Chicago, the Pope condemned the “senseless shooting,” appealing for a rejection of all forms of violence. The telegram was sent on his behalf by Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin, reported Vatican News. Pope Francis asked the cardinal to convey his spiritual closeness to all affected by this attack. Robert E. Crimo III, a 21-year-old local, has been charged with seven counts of first-degree murder. He is
being held without bail. The Pope’s telegram said he joined “the entire community in praying that Almighty God will grant eternal rest to the dead and healing and consolation to the injured and bereaved.” “With unwavering faith that the grace of God is able to convert even the hardest of hearts, making it possible to depart from evil and do good,” the message continued, Pope Francis prayed “that every member of society will reject violence in all of its forms and respect life in all of its stages.” Pope Francis concluded by sending his apostolic blessing “as a pledge of strength and peace in the Lord.” Highland Park is an affluent suburb about 25 miles north of Chicago along Lake Michigan. In a July 4 statement, Cardinal Cupich said he was praying for the
victims and first responders. He also spoke out strongly against the scourge of gun violence. “What should have been a peaceful celebration of our nation’s founding ended in unspeakable tragedy,” the cardinal said. “Please join me in praying for the victims and their loved ones, who never imagined a July 4 celebration could become a killing ground. Pray too for the safety of first responders. ... They bravely rushed into the danger to treat victims and to protect others from harm.” On July 5, Cardinal Cupich co-celebrated a Mass for the grieving community at Highland Park’s Immaculate Conception Catholic Church. The parish became a safe haven in the immediate aftermath of the shooting, CBS 2 Chicago reported. Register staff added to this report.
Judy Roberts writes from Graytown, Ohio.
—
◆ THE SONG OF
◆ DEATH OF A
Lives of Rage and Stillness
A Father Gabriel Mystery
TO PURGATORY
ASCENTS
A
T
A Novel
Pope Francis Prays for Victims of July 4th Parade Attack in Suburban Chicago
Therapeutic Perspective Peter Kleponis, a licensed clinical therapist who has worked with priests, religious and seminarians and specializes in pornography addiction recovery, said he could not say whether Msgr. Burrill is being restored to ministry too soon. In some cases, he told the Register, a year of good, healthy sobriety may be enough to justify a return for someone who has struggled with sexual addiction. However, he said he sees several red flags in Msgr. Burrill’s case. Among these is that although the priest is not believed to have engaged in illegal activity, his alleged use of Grindr suggests a moral violation. “Did the diocese investigate that?” Kleponis said. “Morally, a priest who’s about chaste celibacy should not be on something like Grindr.” Kleponis said there also has been no indication that Msgr. Burrill received a psychological assessment, adding, “If a person is on Grindr every day, possibly there could be sexual addiction here, but that needs to be evaluated.” According to The Pillar report, a mobile device correlated to Msgr. Burrill emitted app data signals from
Grindr on a near-daily basis during parts of 2018, 2019 and 2020, and an analysis showed he also visited gay bars and private residences while using the app during that time. In being returned to ministry, Kleponis said Msgr. Burrill and his use of technology should be monitored regularly. “Where he goes and what he does needs accountability.” Because the availability of technology and the internet can make it easy to get involved in and addicted to pornography or apps like Grindr, Kleponis said he would like to see the Church institute more formal guidelines to help priests in such situations. “The Church needs some policy for helping these people,” he said. “A lot of dioceses just ship them away to a treatment center for six months, but even that is not helpful. There need to be new policies based on current research ... and every diocese needs to have a policy on how to handle these situations.” Helping priests does not necessarily mean they ultimately will return to ministry, because some may not be able to do so, Kleponis said, but they should not be automatically dismissed because they are identified as having such problems. “In my practice, I work with many priests who struggle with pornography addiction, and many of them come to me secretly. They don’t want their diocese knowing. They’re afraid of what will happen to them and afraid they will lose their ministry — and some have.” Nonetheless, Kleponis said he advises such priests to let their bishops know about their struggles. “It does lead to some being dismissed — and some should be. Some are so entrenched that they need to step away for a while. Some may even need inpatient treatment.”
STORiES THAT ENTERTAiN, ENGAGE, ENLiGHTEN
◆ A HIKER’S GUIDE
GRIEVING COMMUNITY. Flowers are seen July 5 near the scene of the mass shooting at the Fourth of July parade in Highland Park, Illinois. Jim Vondruska/Getty Images
and instruments were put in place to make sure it doesn’t happen again. For example, he said, “I would have expected someone in authority to say that priests shouldn’t be using these apps, and the minimum would be that Msgr. Burrill has erased these apps from his phone.” The priest also said any sense of sin seems to have been lost in the way in which Msgr. Burrill’s case has been handled. “It would be helpful to have had a statement from him saying he is sorry and that he is committed to being a faithful priest.”
fter lying unconscious in a hospital, 77 yr. old attorney Dan Geary finds himself in the middle of a rolling, polychrome landscape, and realizes he is in the afterlife. With a hiking pack on his back, he starts walking toward the far-off mountains, but he finds there is no trail, no map, no signage, and feels in his bones: this is Purgatory. Surprised by so much beauty and the feeling of deep hope, yet he starts recognizing his tangled, imperfect, often wasted life, and wonders if he will ever be ready to meet God. With confessional honesty and a sense of humor, author Michael Norton reimagines the purification of the afterlife as a tough journey, saturated with faith, hope, and love— and with overwhelming beauty.
HGPP . . . Sewn Softcover, $16.95
“A book of rare value, a you-arethere broadcast from the beyond. But be warned: this soul has lots to learn!” —David Pinault, Author, Providence Blue: A Fantasy Quest “This is both a narrative ‘page turner’, and a theologically orthodox picture of Purgatory that’s positive, even happy.” — Peter Kreeft, Author, Heaven: The Heart’s Deepest Longing
his book tells the powerful stories of lives laid bare by love, that spurred acclaimed English biographer Tom Hiney up the ragged mountain of his own conversion from atheism to Catholicism. This is a visceral study of faith in which the holiness of other people leads Hiney to learn that, amidst great challenges, anything is possible with God. A medieval king awaiting a Viking invasion, a Jesuit evangelist at the court of Akbar, a composer in Communist Poland, a trapped Arctic whaling vessel, and more, become unlikely companions in Hiney’s dramatic journey to Christ.
SOAP . . . Sewn Softcover, $17.95
“A cogent and courageously written book, Storytelling and truth-seeking at its best!” —Joseph Pearce, Author, Literary Converts “Written with deep insights and the masterful pen of an accomplished biographer. A delightful and heart-pulsing read!” —Steve Ray, Author, Crossing the Tiber
SCHOLAR
W
hile spending a few days of relaxation at his old Cambridge College with Arthur Kingsley, his friend from student days and a respected scientist, Father Gabriel gets the shattering news that Kingsley’s brilliant young protégé has been found dead in her laboratory, after what appears a tragic accident. But Gabriel’s instincts tell him that her death was a little too perfectly staged to have been an accident, and he struggles to lay aside his personal loyalties and confront the possibility that there are dark secrets lurking behind her death. This fourth book in the popular Father Gabriel series by Fiorella De Maria examines the moral minefield of the complicity of scientists in the manufacture of weapons of mass destruction. DASP . . . Sewn Softcover, $16.95
“Evocative of the golden age of detective fiction. This intriguing murder mystery entertains while exploring the legacy of war and the need for justice and reconciliation.” —Rhonda Ortiz, Author, In Pieces
www.ignatius.com P.O. Box 1339, Ft. Collins, CO 80522
(800) 651-1531