Vol 35 issue 2

Page 1

The Voice of the University of Toronto at Mississauga

MEDIUM THE

MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 8, 2008

VOLUME 35, ISSUE 2

www.mediumonline.ca

Even babies enjoy V-fest

Vote for the enviroment

Blues prevent the big five-oh

Page 6

Page 9

Page 11

Photo/Matthew Filipowich

UTM students doing the wave as they flood the streets of Toronto during the frosh parade.

APUS wins lawsuit to reclaim membership at UTM MEREDITH LILLY NEWS EDITOR The planned merger between the Association of Part-Time Undergraduate Students’ (APUS) and the UTM Student Union (UTMSU) has been left unsettled as a Superior Court decision overturned referendum results. On Wednesday August 27, The Ontario Superior Court upheld an application by APUS to retain its membership at the University of Toronto Mississauga (UTM). The application concerned a referendum that took place February 5 and 6 of this year. UTMSU called upon part-time students to vote in favour of a merger between the Erindale Part-Time Student Union (EPUS) and UTMSU. EPUS is an organization affiliated with APUS, a union that represents part-time students on all three University of Toronto campuses, and is not affiliated with UTMSU. APUS executive director Yolisa Dalamba further clarified the organization’s position: “EPUS operates as an autonomous organization but provides services through APUS’ assistance. EPUS members benefit from APUS by way of the health and dental plan, management and financial support, advocacy on behalf of students, events, cam-

paigns, representation at the Canadian Federation of Students (CFS) as it relates to serving part-time students, and more.” The February referendum asked if part-time students wished to be represented along with full-time undergraduate students by UTMSU or remain represented by a separate organization, EPUS. In a January 28 letter to the editor published in The Medium, thenUTMSU President Walied Khogali stated that the referendum “was endorsed by both organizations through their Executive Committee, Board of Directors, and membership at our respective annual general meetings.” However, in a recent press release following the lawsuit, APUS stated that “students were denied the right to make an informed decision, as APUS had not been given an opportunity to participate and campaign against folding EPUS for membership in UTMSU.” “APUS was not properly informed about the referendum held by UTMSU. Ironically, on several occasions, UTMSU officially claimed the referendum had nothing to do with APUS, which was clearly not the case,” says Dalamba. Following the referendum, Khogali stated that the decision to merge EPUS with UTMSU was “endorsed by nine-

ty-five percent of the part-time students that participated.” The ninety-five percent cited as participants in the referendum represented fewer than 10 percent of the part-time student population, however, as only 57 out of 1000 voted. In an interview with The Medium, published on February 13, 2007, Khogali detailed efforts to consolidate the university’s student governments, which included UTMSU taking over the duties and representation of the University of Toronto Students’ Union (UTSU) at UTM and EPUS. Khogali believed these measures “would add to better allocation of student money.” Although UTMSU was optimistic about the merger, APUS did not feel the same. The decision to merge the part-time and full-time student unions at UTM came as a surprise to Dalamba. “APUS only heard from [the president of EPUS] a month after the EPUS office had been closed when we had already begun receiving complaints from students who desperately needed services.” The referendum results were approved by the university’s Governing Council and University Affairs Board, two of the highest decision-making bodies at the University of Toronto. Dalamba is critical of the uni-

versity administration, which she claimed could have examined the referendum more closely before approving the results. “The administration quickly approved what the Superior Court agreed was an illegitimate referendum through Governing Council and University Affairs Board. In order to justify this they acknowledged they would reinstate our membership in the event that we won the case, which we did.” In preparation for the result of the referendum, UTMSU elected an additional VP to student council to represent part-time students, Mubashir Ali. There were concerns about one representative managing the tasks of an entire union, especially as UTM’s population increases steadily with each passing year. “APUS must take lead on issues affecting our members and certainly after forty years of service it is clear that part-time students need organizational support and cannot be served by one person, no matter how dedicated they are,” says Dalamba. APUS remains open to discussion with UTMSU, and hopes to resolve the matter in a way that best serves parttime students. “As far as APUS is concerned, this is not about being one big union or smaller union. It is about ensuring our

members with distinct needs are represented. Sadly, the status quo (the default) all across campuses at the university, is full-time,” says Dalamba. “Our union challenges this pervasive concept and creates a vital space for learners who do not fit this definition. What this court case proves is that too few still understand the uniqueness of part-time students, the challenges they face, and their experiences.” At the time of publication, the matter had not been resolved between the two unions. In a statement issued to The Medium, UTMSU president Wasah Malik explains: “The merger between UTMSU and EPUS has been recognized by the U of T which means UTMSU is representing part-time students at UTM. The court's decision only affects APUS's fees collected at UTM. UTMSU is in the process of collaborating to ensure part-time students receive both the services and representation they deserve.” Malik continues, “Last year's referendum was done based on University of Toronto guidelines as requested by EPUS. The courts confirmed that UTMSU and EPUS acted in good faith, despite APUS's claims. However, due to a technicality, UTM students, according to the ruling, would still have to pay fees to APUS despite the referendum result.”


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Vol 35 issue 2 by The Medium - Issuu