The McGill Tribune Vol. 24 Issue 15

Page 1

NEWS: Activism-Huffing & puffing might not be the best tactic.

g

h

Curiosity delivers. Vol. 24 Issue 15

A&E: Is it bad that we still want to marry Jordan Knight?

T r ib u n e

SPORTS: You don't get stems like this without the slut's workout.

PUBLISHED BY THE STUDENTS' SOCI ETY OF MCGI LL UNIVERSITY

2 17 21

W ednesday, Janu ary 5, 2005

Daily wins autonomy referendum But J-Board seals opt- ut question results LA U R A SABA

BENII FEIDMAN

M cG ill Daily Double: I'll take "autonomy and a mandatory fee" for $10

per student per year, Alex. A drawn-out referendum finally ends.

Deeming the opt-out question unclear, the Students' Society Judicial Board decided never to disclose the results of the November referendum question seeking to make optional the Daily Publications Society's $ 10 per student yearly fee. The results of the autonomy question, posed by the DPS in response to the optout question, have been released, revealing that of the 3 ,6 2 6 stu­ dents who voted, 7 8 per cent were in support of the DPS's autonomy from SSM U. The J-Board had ordered Elections M cG ill to tem­ porarily seal the results of both questions hours before they were set to be announced on November 3. On December 1 1, J-Board released its decision recognizing Elections M cGill's diligence in their handling of the ques­ tion but declaring it null and void. In October, current DPS members and former SSM U executives Vivian Choy, Rodrigo DeCastro, and M ia G ew ertz submitted a non-binding referendum ques­ tion that asked students whether they should be allowed to opt out of the DPS's annual $ 10 fee. The DPS pub­ lishes the M cG ill Daily and le Délit Français. Elections M cG ill Chief Returning Officer Andrew C arva jal said that the initial phrasing of the question mandated the DPS to change its fee structure, which a SSM U referendum does not have the power to do. Instead, the DPS's constitution states that students who want to change the DPS fee structure must approach its Board of Directors. The three students rewrote the referendum question, but did not include wording referring to SSMU's role in the process. Elections M cG ill approved the question, as they felt that it did not violate the SSM U constitution. During the cam paign, M cG ill Daily Coordinating Editor Daniel Cohen and DPS Board chairperson MarieEve Clavet submitted a petition asking the J-Board to invalidate the question because they felt it w as mislead­ ing.

A

brand spankin' new year and the same recycled slew of vices w e vow to absolve ourselves of each January 1. But this year will be different, you say to yourself. Think again. Every year, it's the

same, yet inevitable, tired old dance. Stop kidding yourself-that Freshman 15 is here to stay. Rather, join us in wishing for a better 2 0 0 5 , with strippers available at our beck and call, the comeback of Howard Dean, and the rise of The Random Dude.

"I think that in the province of Q uebec, w e have come to value the clarity of a referendum question," said Cohen. “Students did not have a fair chance to know what they were voting on, and the question needed to be more clear." C arva jal said that he respected the decision to per­ manently seal the results. "W e had warned the people who brought the question forward about this," he said, 'but there w as nothing on the document that prevented it [from] being placed on the ballot." He said that Elections M cG ill w a s only given 2 4

hours to make a decision on the question, whereas the J-Board had a w eek to study the question. The question purposely did not include words spec­ ifying the role of SSM U , said Choy. "Given that it is the accredited representative body for all undergraduate students, a referendum question by w a y of the fact that it is placed before all undergradu­ ates should implicate the SSM U whether that is stated or not," she said. In addition, she said, the results could have been interpreted and considered on their merits by anyone, including the DPS, since the issue affected all students.

A repeat possible, but not likely C hoy said that she would not pursue a similar ref­ erendum question in the future. "M y goal in all of this w as not restricted to the pass­ ing of a referendum question," she said. Cohen hopes that referendum questions surround­ ing the DPS will not appear on SSM U ballots ag ain. He said that students have been educated about the DPS and its fee structure because of the controversy surround­ ing the referendum. "As a result, people who are acting in good faith and really believe that the fee is unfair for any reason will now understand how to go about making a change," he said. The opt-out referendum effort w as not in vain, said Choy. "That this question w a s rejected is irrelevant to the fact that this year's crew of freshman students will be watching and reading where their money is going for the next four years," she said.

Autonomous, just like the last time you checked The J-Board allowed Elections M cG ill to release the results of another referendum question, which w as sub­ mitted by Cohen and Clavet on behalf of DPS and asked students whether the publisher should remain autonomous from SSM U. O nly 1 7 .5 per cent of students voted "N o ," while 4 .3 per cent of the ballots were spoiled. Cohen said that the results showed "that students aren't interested in giving governing bodies such as SSM U and the Board of Governors a mandate to inter­ fere with the DPS. It's n<jt fair, it's not legal, and it's not going to fly with students." Choy congratulated the DPS "Yes" committee, but said that the DPS's autonomy w as never in jeopardy. "[The DPS's] fear that it could be w as of their own doing," she said, "since they placed that referendum before the undergraduate electorate." ■

I


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.