The McGill Tribune Vol. 20 Issue 11

Page 1

Soccer teams finish 4th at N ationals

D ido

119

prize pack giveaway V

T ♦ H ♦E

T

u e s d a y

o l u m e

, 14

N

20

I

ssue

o v e m b e r

11

2 0 0 0

R IB U N E

L P u b lis h e d b y th e S t u d e n t s ’ S o c ie ty o f M c G ill U n i v e r s i ty

O N L IN E

h t tp : // tr i b u n e .m c g il l.c a

SSMU 'insensitive' — BSN By S hehryar Fazli

Canadian Fortes Private Anelas bows his head during a Remembrance day ceremony in Dominion Square on Saturday

Patrick Fok

The Black Students’ Network questioned the Students’ Society of McGill University’s sensitivity towards minority issues when the Students’ Society chose not to rati­ fy the group’s constitution in coun­ cil last week. One month ago, the BSN unanimously passed its new consti­ tution before its general assembly. Expecting the constitution to then be ratified by SSMU, the organiza­ tion was caught off guard last Thursday when the document was excluded from discussion at SSMU council. According to Akin Alaga, chair of the BSN Constitutional Committee, SSMU articulated that it chose not to approve the BSN constitution on the grounds that its preamble is inflammatory in its ref­ erence to James McGill, the University’s founder, as a slave owner. Alaga explained that he was also told that the student gov­ ernment believes the preamble conveys an impression that the group is exclusionary in a fragment that reads: "...we are dedicated to fully assume our responsibilities as Blacks on the McGill campus." SSMU’s argument, according to Alaga, was that the BSN was liable to give non-black students a feeling of being unwelcome in the club, if the preamble claimed that black students have unique respon­ sibilities to be fulfilled at the University. Jeremy Farrell, SSMU VP community and government affairs and a member of the BSN, expressed his concerns about the constitution. "The constitution, on the whole, is great, but... the preamble is problematic," Farrell stated. "The preamble is supposed to be a document alluding to what the con­ stitution is about. It should be a lit­ tle more clear and concise. This one isn’t, and at times, it sounds like the BSN is really only for black students, and it’s not, it’s to deal with the issues of a black stu­ dent. [The premble] sounds a little too inflammatory..." Alaga rejected the notion that the preamble would have been more appropriate if it had been

This Week's Special: Asian G ourm et Soup

n ’ N o o d le s c o o k e d f r e s h b e fo r e y o u r e y e s !

M a k e u p y o u r o w n c o m b o a t th e H o t T a b le .

N o w in t h e o n l y f o o d c o u r t o n t h e M c G ill c a m p u s !

• G e n e ra l

more carefully worded. "Rewording of the preamble would amount to the repression of the Black experience of McGill students and the suppression of Black history in Quebec," he said. "In fact, if the notion of unique responsibilities was exclusionary, then indeed the whole notion of a Black Student Network must be called into question." SSMU Equity Commissioner Amarkai Laryea also spoke of the sense of identity that the fragment emphasizes, and argued that it is exactly this sense of identity that clubs like the BSN are founded upon. "[SSMU] has not provided a critical race analysis," he said. "It has failed to look through the eyes of a racial minority to [determine] how the constitution looks through their eyes... If the constitution did not state such a thing, it would be just like any other network, and not the Black Students’ Network." Both Laryea and Alaga stress that the body of the constitution specifically states, in Article III, that: "BSN is a resource center that is open to the entire McGill com­ munity. While the mandate of the Network is dedicated to addressing the needs and interests of Black peoples, all interested parties irre­ spective of race, culture, or creed are encouraged to participate in the organization." Contrary to Farrell’s point of view, SSMU VP Clubs and Services Chris Gratto argued that Alaga misinterpreted SSMU’s motives, maintaining that the stu­ dent government’s decision not to ratify the proposed BSN constitu­ tion was strictly related to proce­ dural considerations. "Normally when a club that is established changes their constitu­ tion, I get a letter from the President, or Coordinator, or exec­ utive to say that quorum was met... and [that] procedure was followed," he explained. "I didn’t get this letter [from the BSN]." According to Gratto, the docu­ ment was returned to the BSN, and some suggestions were made on how to improve upon the docu­ m ent’s provisions to make it C ontinued on Page 2

.9 9 + t x

T a o 's C h ic k e n

■M i x e d v e g e ta b le s

• C h o ic e

o f r ic e o r n o o d le s

$

4 Sp rin g roll o n ly

S h a t n e r B u i l d in g 3 4 8 0 M c T a v is H , 2 n d f lo o r

extra.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.