Page 1


! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

"!#$%&'!()!*+$,+&--!./!0(123!45''()!6!*&1&+!78!439),:! 439;1&+-!<$5+1&&)!6!<(=1&&)! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !


! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >?@A! ! !

B/! C:DE! ()! 13&! &%&)(),F! G$5(-9! 39H! 9'+&9H/! 29''&H! 13&! 3$5-&! I$+&! 139)!

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³6KXQJP/$F! ;(2J! 5;8! ! Q$5! -3$5'H! 9'L9/-! 9)-L&+! (=! 7! 29''8! ! R3&+&! 9+&! /$5S! ! *(2J! 5;8! ! T(H! /$5! 3&9+! I/! I&--9,&S! ! T$)M1! =$+,&1! 13&! )&L! .$LF! 9)H! H$)M1! =$+,&1! 1$! 2$I.! /$5+! 39(+! '(J&! 7! 1$'H! /$5F! 9)H! .&11&+! )$1! .&! '91&8! ! "+&!/$5!-1(''!13&+&S! ! ")-L&+!13&!;3$)&8! ! *(2J!5;²´!


!

#$L! 13&! 2'$2J! 39),(),! 9.$%&! 13&! '$.-1&+! 19)J! (-! %&+,(),! $)! C:DUF! .51!

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

³)UDQFLVP\VRQKDVQ¶WFDOOHGKHUHIRUPHKDVKH"´!

!

³1R , GRQ¶W WKLQN VR´  +H JODQFHV DFURVV WKH IR\HU WR ZKHUH 0UV &KRZ

-(1-!$)!9!-1$$'!.&3()H!13&!29-3!+&,(-1&+F!3&+!;5I;J()P-39;&H!3&9H!'$L&+&H!L3('&! GXWLIXOO\RUJDQL]LQJUHFHLSWV  ³+DV/RXLVD¶VVRQFDOOHG"´! !

R(13$51! '$$J(),! 5;F! 0+-8! 43$L! -39J&-! 3&+! 3&9H! ()! '(11'&! .+5-Y5&!

I$%&I&)1-8! !

³, JXHVV QRW´  KH WHOOV /RXLVD VKUXJJLQJ KLV VKRXOGHUV  ³,V WKHUH D

SUREOHP"´! !

³1R!QRHYHU\WKLQJ¶VILQH´  VKHVD\VDEUXSWO\KHUYRLFHXQFRQYLQFLQJ  ³,

DVNHGKLPWRFDOOEHIRUHWDNLQJWKHEXVEXWKHSUREDEO\IRUJRWRULW¶VSRVVLEOHWKH


OLQHZDVEXV\DQGKHFRXOGQµWJHWWKURXJK  ,¶PVXUHLW¶VDOOULJKW´! !

$Q H[SUHVVLRQ RI V\PSDWK\ HPHUJHV RQ )UDQFLV¶ IDFH  ³<RX VKRXOGQ W EH

VRQHUYRXV´  KHVD\VUHDVVXULQJO\  ³:H¶UHDOOJRLQJWRKDYHIXQWRQLJKW´  7KHQ DV LI WR LPSDUW DQ LQWLPDWH VHFUHW KH OHDQV LQ FORVH DVNLQJ  ³+DV DQ\RQH XVHG $5+!='(&+-!=$+!9!=+&&!GULQN"´! !

([FHSW/RXLVDLVQ¶WJLYHQDFKDQFHWRDQVZHUKLVTXHVWLRQIRUDWWKDWVDPH

I$I&)1! 13&! H$$+! 23(I&! +&-$5)H-! 9-! 9! ,+$5;! $=! =$5+! 1&&)9,&+-! 5-3&+! ()1$! 13&! +&-195+9)18! ! <+9)2(-!'&9%&-!3&+!-(H&!91!$)2&!1$!L&'2$I&!13&IF!'(=1(),!=$5+!=(),&+-! ()! 13&! 9(+F! VD\LQJ  ³)RXU RI \RX"´  $QG ZLWK WKDW VKH KHDGV EDFN WR KHU MRE LQ 13&! H()(),! +$$IF! H+(=1(),! .&1L&&)! 19.'&-F! 9-J(),! 25-1$I&+-! (=! 13&(+! I&9'-! 9+&! 922&;19.'&F! )$1(),! L3(23! ,'9--&-! )&&H! +&=(''(),! 9)H! L3(23! ;'91&-! -3$5'H! .&! +&I$%&H²L3('&!)$L!9L9+&!1391!)$1!9!-(),'&!='(&+!39-!.&&)!5-&H!1$!+&H&&I!&(13&+! 9!=+&&!/59)!/9),!$+!9!=+&&!(2&H!1&98! !

Z+9H59''/F!-3&!L()H-!=+$I!$)&!&)H!$=!13&!+$$I!1$!13&!$13&+F!=()9''/!2$I(),!

1$! ;95-&! ()! =+$)1! $=! 13&! ;'92&! 1391! <+9)2(-! 39-! ;+&;9+&H! =$+! 13&! ;&+=$+I9)2&8! ! W3+&&! 19.'&-! 39%&! .&&)! +&I$%&H! 1$! 2+&91&! 9! L(H&! -;92&! 91! 13&! +&9+! $=! 13&! +&-195+9)1F!9)!$%&+3&9H!'(,31!=(X15+&!29-1-!9!.+(,31!2(+25'9+!;911&+)!$)!13&!I9+$$)! 29+;&1! L3&+&! K9I5&'! (-! I&9)1! 1$! -19)H! L(13! 3(-! %($'()F! 9)H! 13&! '9+,&! 9Y59+(5I! 19)J-! -;+&9H! 9'$),! 13&! L9''! L(''! =5)21($)! 9-! 9! J()H! $=! .5..'(),! .92JH+$;! 1$! 3(-! UHFLWDO  7R WKH OHIW RI 6DPXHO¶V VSRWOLJKW LV D VWRRO XSRQ ZKLFK VLWV DQ HPSW\ H+()J!;(123&+²13&!2'&9+!;'9-1(2!2$)19()&+!9H$+)&H!L(13!9!L3(1&!'9.&'!1391!H(-;'9/-! 13&!L$+H!!"#$!()!13&!.+$9H!L+(1(),!$=!9!,+&&)!I9,(2!I9+J&+8! !

0$''/! 9;;&9+-! .&-(H&! 3&+F! I$1($)(),! 9! 39)H! 91! 13&! 1(;! N9+F! 9)H! ()! 9)!

H[DJJHUDWHG LQJUDWLDWLQJ WRQH WKDW /RXLVD GLVOLNHV VKH VD\V  ³<RXU VR OXFN\ 


0/! 13(+H! -$)F! 7! I9J&! 3(I! '&9+)! ;(9)$8! ! "=1&+! 1L$! I$)13-! 3&! L9)1-! 1$! Y5(1F! H$&-)M1!L9)1!1$!H$!(1VD\VLW VWRRKDUG  1RWDOHQWVRZKDWFDQ,GR"´! !

³0D\EHLW VIRUWKHEHVW  /HVVRQVFRVWDORWRIPRQH\´!

!

³7KDW VWUXHEXW,HQY\\RXDQG\RXUSUHFLRXVVRQ  +H¶VVRREHGLHQWDQG

VRWDOHQWHG  +RZFRPH\RXDQG\RXUKXVEDQGGRQ¶WKDYHDQRWKHUFKLOG"´! !

7)! 9! -;'(1! -&2$)HF! G$5(-9M-! I()H! +&;'9/-! 13&! 2$I;'(291($)-! -5++$5)H(),!

K9I5&'M-! .(+13:! ! 13&! 5;-(H&PH$L)! ;$-(1($)! $=! 3(-! .$H/! ()-(H&! 3&+! L$I.F! 13&! 5I.('(29'!2$+H!L+9;;&H!'(J&!9!)$$-&!9+$5)H!3(-!)&2JF!13&!/$5),!=&I9'&!H$21$+M-! ()-(-1&)2&!1391!13&!.9./!L$5'H!9++(%&!-1(''.$+)!9)HF!13&+&=$+&F!13&!;9+1-!I5-1!.&! +&I$%&H! ;(&2&! ./! ;(&2&! =$+! 3&+! -9=&1/²9)H! 3&+! &Y59'! ()-(-1&)2&! 9.$51! 13&! .9./! .&(),! 9'(%&F! 9),+('/! H(-I(--(),! 13&! -5,,&-1($)! $=! 9)! 9.$+1(%&! ;+$2&H5+&F! &%&)! (=! -3&! I(,31! H(&8! ! "-! 9)! 9-/II&1+(29'! -$5%&)(+! $=! 1391! 1$+15$5-! '9.$+F! 9! 13()F! FURRNHGVFDUUXQVIURPKHUDEGRPHQWRKHUVWRPDFKGHILQLQJ6DPXHO¶VSRLQWRI &)1+/! ()1$! 13(-! L$+'HF! 9)H! -&+%&-F! 1$$F! 9-! 9! 2$)-19)1! +&I()H&+! $=! 3$L! 3&! L(''! 9'L9/-!$L&!3(-!&X(-1&)2&!1$!3&+!()!I$+&!L9/-!139)!N5-1!3(-!.(+138! ! KI('(),!;$'(1&'/! DW0ROO\VKHVD\V  ³2QHLVHQRXJK´! !

³<HV ER\V DUH D ORW RI WURXEOH´  0ROO\ FKXFNOHV DQG WXUQLQJ WR JR VKH

DGGV  ³7U\KDYLQJWKUHH´! !

<$+!9!L3('&F!G$5(-9!J&&;-!3&+!,9[&!=(X&H!$)!13&!1(;!N9+F!39)H-!3(HH&)!L(13()!

13&!;$2J&1-!$=!3&+!.'92J!9;+$)F!)$L!(I9,()(),!13&!.$13&+-$I&!H()!$=!%$(2&-!9)H! FOLQNLQJ RI XWHQVLOV IDOOLQJ VLOHQW XQGHU 0HVVHQHW¶V PDMHVWLF VSHOO  3UHVHQWO\ 13$5,3F!-3&!(-!-5II$)&H!1$!9!19.'&!L3&+&!13+&&!,'9--&-!$=!L91&+!9+&!+&Y5&-1&H8! ! "1!9)!9HN92&)1!19.'&!-$I&$)&!&'-&!9-J-!3&+!1$!+&1+(&%&!9)!&X1+9!-&1!$=!23$;-1(2J-! 9)H!1L$!=$+J-F!L3('&!9!-I9''!,(+'!91!/&1!9!H(==&+&)1!19.'&!J)$2J-!$%&+!9!,'9--!$=!I('J!


1&98! ! B51! 9-! -$$)! 9-! 13&! L9''! 2'$2J! +&923&-! C:@U²3&+! L+(-1L9123! 9;;+$923(),! C:@@²-3&!H$&-!9)!9.$51P=92&!$)!13&!='$$+F!9.9)H$)(),!3&+!-191($)!1$!.+&&[&!;9-1! 0+-8!43$LF!-1&;;(),!$51-(H&!()!13&!3$;&!$=!-;$11(),!K9I5&'8! !

4+9)(),! 3&+! )&2JF! G$5(-9! ,'9)2&-! H$L)! 13&! .5-/! -(H&L9'J! L(13! 9! +&-1'&--!

&X;+&--($)F!H9+1(),!3&+!,9[&!9I$),!13&!=$$1!1+9==(2!$=!;&$;'&!&)N$/(),!9)!&%&)(),! -1+$''! 9=1&+! 9)! 5)-&9-$)9.'/! 3$1! H9/F! 9)H! 29)%9-&-! 13&! &)1(+&! 39'=! .'$2J! =+$I! L3&+&!-3&!-19)H-!1$!13&!2'$-&-1!.5-!-1$;8! ! <$+!9!-&2$)H!3&+!=&915+&-!'(,31&)!L3&)! -3&! -&&-! 9! 3&9H! L&9%(),! N5-1! 9.$%&! L9(-1! '&%&'! $=! 13$-&! L9'J(),! ()! =+$)1! 9)H! .&3()H! $=! (1F! &X2&;1! 9'I$-1! 9-! Y5(2J'/! -3&! H(-2&+)-! 1391! 13&! 3&9H! .&'$),-! 1$! VRPHRQH LQ D ZKHHOFKDLU JRLQJ WKH RSSRVLWH ZD\  'RQ¶W ZRUU\ VKH WULHV ;&+-59H(),! 3&+-&'=8! ! W3&! )&X1! .5-! L(''! .+(),! 3(I! 3&+&8! ! \%&)! -$F! -3&! H&2(H&-! (1! ZRXOGQ¶W KXUW WR FDOO WKH KRXVH RQFH DJDLQ  7KHQ VHQ-(),! 1391! -3&! 39-! .&&)! $51-(H&! 1$$! '$),F! 9)H! 1391! ./! )$L! 25-1$I&+-! 9+&! &X;&21(),! 3&+! 911&)1($)F! -3&! +&15+)-! 1$! 13&! +&-195+9)1F! ;5''(),! 13&! )$1&! ;9H! =+$I! 3&+! 9;+$)! ;$2J&1! 9-! 9)! &X25-&!1$!./;9--!13&!H()(),!9+&9!L(13$51!+9(-(),!9)/!&/&.+$L-8! ! ! !

]$L&%&+F! L3&)! 35++/(),! 1$L9+H! 13&! J(123&)! L(13! 13&! )$1&! ;9H! ()! 39)HF!

G$5(-9!)$1(2&-!<+9)2(-!)&9+!13&!'$.-1&+!19)JF!911&)1(%&'/!-5+%&/(),!13&!25-1$I&+-! 9)H! 13&! -19==! L3('&! H9..(),! 9! +&H! -&+%(&11&! 9,9()-1! 3(-! =$+&3&9H8! ! ]&F! ()! 15+)F! 19J&-!)$1(2&!$=!3&+!+5-3(),!92+$--!13&!='$$+!9-!(=!-3&!L&+&!H&'(%&+(),!9)!$+H&+F!9)H! QRGV ZLWK D VPLOH WKDW WHOOV KHU  ³,W V RND\ JR DKHDG DQG XVH WKH WHOHSKRQH´  ")H! -3&! )$H-! .92J! 91! 3(I! .&=$+&! ;9--(),! 13+$5,3! 13&! -L(),(),! J(123&)! H$$+-F! ,+91&=5'! =$+! 3(-! J()H)&--! 9)H! ;91(&)2&8! ! K523! 9! 35I9)&! H(-;$-(1($)F! -3&! 39-! 13$5,31F!I5-1!.&!9!;+$H521!$=!=91&²-$I&13(),!/$5!9+&!.$+)!L(13F!9!L&''PH&-&+%&H! +&2$I;&)-&!=$+!13&!,&)&+$5-!H&&H-!=+$I!9!;+&%($5-!'(=&8!


!

Q&1! G$5(-9F! )$+! 9)/$)&! &'-&! L$+J(),! 9'$),-(H&! 3&+F! L$)M1! '&9+)! 5)1('! (1M-!

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²&%&)! 9-! 13&! ;+$,)$-(-! (-! .&/$)H! H(+&8! ! 7)! 13&! 2$I(),! L&&J-! 3(-! ;3/-(29'! 2$)H(1($)! L(''! H&1&+($+91&!+9;(H'/F!Y5(1&!;+$.9.'/!H+$;;(),! 3(I!'(J&!9!-L911&H!='/! ./!13&!/&9+M-! &)H8! ! B51! -1(''F! 3&! 13()J-F! 13&+&! (-! )$! +&9-$)! 1$! H&-;9(+! L3&)! 13&! L$+'H! 9+$5)H! 3(I!+&I9()-!-$!L$)H&+=5'!9)H!9==(+I(),:! ! =+(&)H-F!=9I('/F!9!H&%$1&H!'$%&+F!L$+J! 3&! &)N$/-F! '95,31&+F! =$$HF! .+(,31! I$+)(),-F! -;+(),! +9()F! ;&+=&21! -5)-&1-F! 9)HF! )915+9''/F!13&!,(=1!$=!I5-(28! ! W3&)!'(J&!13&!2'$2J!1(2J(),!9L9/!13&!I()51&-!$)!13&! L9''F! 13&! I&1+$)$I&! $=! 3(-! 3&9+1! 2$)1()5&-! 1$! -1&9H('/! ,5(H&! 3(I! =$+L9+HF! J&&;(),!+3/13I!L(13!9!=515+&!1391!(-!-$I&3$L!.$13!J)$L9.'&!9)H!5)(I9,()9.'&8! ! G$L&+(),! 13&! -&+%(&11&F! 3&! .&,()-! =(),&+(),! 13&! .&9H-! $)! 3(-! ;+9/&+! .9)HF! $)&! 9=1&+!13&!$13&+F!9''!13&!L3('&!(I9,()(),!3(-!'(=&!9-!)$13(),!I$+&!139)!I$+)(),!H&L! &%9;$+91(),!$)!13&!;&19'-!$=!9!'$15-!='$L&+F!9)H!H&913!9-!-(I;'/!9!;913L9/!()!13&!


-J/8! !

_5-1! 13&)! 9! I(HH'&P9,&H! 2$5;'&! &)1&+-! 13&! +&-195+9)1F! 9)H! <+9)2(-!

;+$I;1'/!I$%&-!1$!()1&+2&;1!13&IF!+9(-(),!1L$!=(),&+-!()!13&!9(+!9-!3&!9H%9)2&-F! VD\LQJ  ³7ZR"´! !

W3&!I9)!9)H!L$I9)!)$H!91!13&!-9I&!1(I&8!

!

³7KLVZD\SOHDVH´  )UDQFLVVD\V!-1$$;(),!.+(&='/!L3('&!,'(H(),!9!;9'I!$51!

=+$I! 3(-! L9(-1F! &X1&)H(),! 3(-! 9+I! 2$+H(9''/! ()! 13&! H(+&21($)! $=! 13&! H()(),! 9+&98! ! $IWHUZKLFKKHOHDGVWKHFRXSOHWRDWDEOHVD\LQJDVWKH\JR  ³,KRSH\RXHQMR\ I5-(2F! .&295-&! 13(-! &%&)(),! L&! 39%&! 9! =+&&! %($'()! 2$)2&+1$8! ! 7)! =921F! 7! .&'(&%&! (1! VKRXOGEHVWDUWLQJSUHWW\VRRQ´! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !


! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >?OA! ! !

W3$+$5,3'/! 9(I'&--! ()! H(+&21($)! /&1! ()1&)1! 1$! J&&;! I$%(),F! K9I5&'! +92&-!

3&9H'$),! 9,9()-1! 9)! $229-($)9'! .+&&[&! 1391! ,+$L-! -1&9H(&+! L(13! 13&! ()2+&9-&H! %&'$2(1/!$=!13&!-J91&-F!3(-!1&9+-!-I$$13&H!H+/!./!13&!25++&)1-!9'I$-1!9-!Y5(2J'/!9-! WKH\ ZHOO XS  6WXSLG KH WKLQNV  ³<RX¶UH VR VWXSLG´  KH XWWHUV DW KLPVHOI DQG 39%(),! -J91&H! ()! -('&)2&! =$+! 9! L3('&F! 3&! =()H-! 13&! ,+5I.'(),! $=! 3(-! $L)! %$(2&! 2$I=$+1(),8! ! #$L! 13&! I()51&-! -&&I! -$I&3$L! &)H'&--! 9)H! 1+9)-(1$+/F! 9-! (=! 13&! =9.+(2! $=! 1(I&! 39-! .&,5)! 1$! &'$),91&! L3('&! 9'-$! 25+%(),! .92J! $)! (1-&'=8! ! K1(''F! 3&! ;+&--&-! =$+L9+HF! 13+$L(),! 3(-! &)1(+&! .$H/! ()1$! 13&! 19-JF! 2$%&+(),! .'$2J! 9=1&+! .'$2J²H&+&'(21!.5('H(),-F!L&&H/!'$1-F!-35HH&+&H!-1$+&=+$)1-²-Y5()1(),!L3&)&%&+! $)2$I(),! 3&9H'(,31-! -L&&;! 92+$--! 3(-! =92&8! ! ](,3! 9.$%&! 3(IF! ()! 9! )(,31! -J/! L9-3&H!$51!9)H!I9H&!()H(-1()21!=+$I!13&!I&1+$;$'(-!+9H(91(),!.&'$L!(1F!()%(-(.'&! 9(+;'9)&-! 2+(--2+$--! 13&! =(+I9I&)1F! H(-2'$-(),! 13&(+! '$291($)-! 13+$5,3! 13&! .'()J(),! $=! L3(1&F! +&HF! 9)H! ,+&&)! -1+$.&-! 1391! H$I()91&! 13&! ;'92&-! L3&+&! -19+-! -3$5'H! 3$'H! -L9/8! ! #&%&+13&'&--F! 3&! -;(&-! 13&! I$$)! 9-! 9! '5I()$5-! -'(%&+! ()! 13&!


&9-1F!39),(),!13&+&!'(J&!9!2$'$--9'F!H(-29+H&H!=(),&+)9('!.5$/&H!./!13&![&+$!,+9%(1/! $=!-;92&8! !

B&=$+&! '$),F! 13$5,3F! %9+($5-! ;9+1-! $=! K9I5&'! 2$)-;(+&! 1$! 39I;&+! 3(-!

I$I&)15I²-39J/! J)&&-F! 13+$..(),! 9)J'&-²5'1(I91&'/! -'$L(),! 3(I! ()! -;(1&! $=! 3(-!-(),'&PI()H&H!H&-(+&!)$1!1$!-1$;8! ! B51!+&,9+H'&--!$=!L391!3(-!.+9()!H(2191&-F! 13&!+&-1!$=!3(I!39-!39H!&)$5,38! ! ](-!23&-1!.5+)-F!9)H!3(-!.+&913!&-29;&-!3(I!()! -3$+1F! ;5)21591&H! ,9-;-8! ! ]5),&+! ;9),-! -L(+'! 9+$5)H! 3(-! =9I(-3&H! -1$I9238! ! \%&)!3(-!1$&-!35+18! ! #$)&!$=!13&-&!;3/-(29'!H(-2$I=$+1-F!3$L&%&+F!9+&!9-!9251&!9-! 13&! &X1+&I&'/! 1+$5.'(),! (I;+&--($)! $%&+19J(),! 3(-! 13$5,31-²9)! 5);'&9-9)1! )$1($)!-5,,&-1(),!1391F!)$!I911&+!3$L!=9-1!$+!=9+!13&!-J91&-!,$F!3&!L(''!)&%&+!,&1! 2'$-&+!1$!3$I&8! ! W3&)!'(J&!9!I$1$+!+5))(),!$)!=5I&-F!3(-!=&&1!2&9-&!1$!9'1&+)91&! .92J! 9)H! =$+13F! 3(-! '&,-! .&2$I&! +(,(HF! 9)H! 3$'H(),! 3(I-&'=! 5;+(,31F! 3&! 2$9-1-! -&%&+9'! /9+H-! 5)1('! +&923(),! 9! -19)H-1(''! )&9+! 13&! -I9''! 2$5+1/9+H! $=! 9)! ()921(%&F! $;&)P9(+!I&+29H$8! !

G(,31P3&9H&H! 9)H! ;9)1(),! 39+HF! K9I5&'! ;&&+-! ()1$! 13&! &)2'$-5+&! L3&)!

'$(1&+(),! .&1L&&)! 13&! ;'9-1&+! 2$'5I)-! $=! 13&! I&+29H$M-! ,91&'&--! 13+&-3$'H8! ! \+&21&H! 9I(H! 13&! 2$'$+=5'! I$-9(2! 1('&-! 2$%&+(),! 13&! ,+$5)H! 93&9H! $=! 3(IF! 9! -1$)&P29+%&HF!13+&&P1(&+!\-;'9)9H&!=$5)19()!$225;(&-!13&!2$5+1/9+HM-!2&)1&+F! 9)H! .&/$)H! (1²$)&! 91! 13&! )$+13L&-1! 2$+)&+F! 9)$13&+! 91! 13&! )$+13&9-1! -(H&²9+&! %95'1&H! ;9--9,&-! '&9H(),! 1$! 5)'(1! L9'JL9/-! 1391! -1+&123! 9L9/! =+$I! 13&! ,'$L! $=! -1+&&1'(,31-8! ! "! -35=='(),! )$(-&! (II&H(91&'/! H9+1-! 3(-! -19+&! ;9-1! 13&! =$5)19()F! =(X(),!(1!$)!13&!-39;&!$=!9!+91!-25++/(),!$%&+!13&!1('&-F!1+9('&H!./!9!-&2$)H!+91F!9)H! 13&)!9!13(+H!+91²9''!13+&&!='&&(),!H$L)!9!2$+)&+!;9--9,&!'(J&!2+(I()9'-!&X&251(),! 9!;+(-$)!.+&9J8! ! "=1&+!13&!+$H&)1-!39%&!,$)&F!13&!$)'/!-$5)H!3&!3&9+-!(-!3(-!$L)!


'9.$+&H!;5==(),8! ! W3&!35-3&H!2$5+1/9+HF!(1!13&)!-&&I-F!(-!'(J&!9!39%&)!&X(-1(),!1$! ,(%&!3(I!+&=5,&!=+$I!13&!-1+&&1²-3&'1&+&H!.&)&913!1L$!;9'I!1+&&-F!(1-!=95X!9H$.&! L9''-! &)%&'$;&H! ./! 2+&&;(),! %()&-²9;;&9+(),! I$+&! L&'2$I(),! 139)! 9)/;'92&! &'-&! 1391! 3&! 39-! &)2$5)1&+&H! L3('&! 1+9%&'(),! 13&! -(H&L9'J-8! ! R(13! 9! .5+,&$)(),! -&)-&! $=! 39%(),! H(-2$%&+&H! 9)! 5+.9)! $9-(-! )$L! 29'I(),! 3(IF! 13&! 3&9%(),! $=! 3(-! .+&913! H(I()(-3&-F! 9-F! 1$$F! H$&-! 13&! .$13&+-$I&! 921(%(1/! 2$)=$5)H(),! 3(-! 13$5,31-8! ! <$+!9!'(11'&!.(1F!3&!H&2(H&-F!13&!-J91&-!9)H!13&!'9/&+-! $=!-$2J-!I5-1!.&! +&I$%&H^!3(-!9)J'&-F!'&,-F!13(,3-²&%&+/!;9+1!1391!923&-²-3$5'H!+&-1!$)!13&!-1$)&! .9-()! &)2(+2'(),! 13&! =$5)19()F! 9)HF! =()9''/F! 3&! 29)! Y5&)23! 3(-! 13(+-1! L3('&! 9'-$! -$9J(),!3(-!-$+&!1$&-!()!L391!I5-1!.&!%&+/!2$$'!L91&+8! !

B51! 5)H&+! =&L! 2(+25I-19)2&! 2$5'H! K9I5&'! (I9,()&! L9'J(),! $51-(H&!

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²1$!,&)1'/!&X1+921!3(-!13(2J'/!;9HH&H! =&&1F! +&'(&%(),! 13&! -1+9()! 1391! (I;&H&-! 3(-! ;+$,+&--²(-! 9! +913&+! I()$+! 1+9)-,+&--($)!./!2$I;9+(-$)8!


!

V)2&!13&!-J91&-!9+&!15,,&H!$==F!9!-1+$),!$H$+!L9=1-!=+$I!13&(+!29%(1(&-F!9)!

5)L3$'&-$I&! I(X15+&! $=! -L&91F! =$$1! $H$+F! 9)H! H9I;! '&913&+8! ! *&+-;(+91($)! H+&)23&-! 13&! I9)/! -$2J-F! 13&! -$HH&)! 2$11$)! -Y5(-3(),! '(J&! 9! -;$),&! L3&)! K9I5&'! +(-&-! L(13! L9%&+(),! '&,-! 9)H! ='911&)-! 13&I! 9,9()-1! 13&! -(H&L9'J8! ! W3&)! ,+9-;(),! 13&! -J91&-! ()! 3(-! +(,31! 39)HF! 3&! 1(;1$&-! 9-! (=! -)&9J(),! $)1$! ;+(%91&! ;+$;&+1/²13&! (++&,5'9+! I$-9(2! 1('&-! ;$J(),! 13&! .9''-! $=! 3(-! =&&1F! ;5-3(),! )$1! 5)2$I=$+19.'/!$)!13&!-$2J-²9)H!,$&-!=5+1(%&'/!1$L9+H!13&!=$5)19()F!;(%$1(),!3(-! 3&9H! L(13! 9! %(,('9)1! -19+&8! ! "1! =(+-1! ,'9)2&! )$13(),! 2$%&+1! (-! '5+J(),! 9'$),! 13&! H5-J/!=+(),&-F!9-(H&!=+$I!13+&&!I&19'!;9+J!.&)23&-F!&923!L(13!(1-!$L)!'(11&+!.()8! ! B51! -$$)! 9! I5+9'! H&2$+91(),! 13&! &9-1P=92(),! ()1&+($+! L9''! ;&)&1+91&-! 3(-! %(-($)F! 13&!'$$I(),!-(,31!$=!L3(23!;9+9'/[&-!3(I!I$I&)19+('/F!;+$H52(),! ,$$-&!.5I;-! $)! 3(-! 9+I-F! 9)H! 39-1&)-! 3(-! 3&9+1.&91:! ! 9)! (I;$-(),! `9;91(-19! &I&+,&-! 13&+&! =+$I! 13&! -39H$L-F! ,9[(),! -1&+)'/! ()1$! 13&! 2$5+1/9+HF! 9! +(='&! ,+(;;&H! ./! 25+'&H! =(-1-^! 13&! $%&+-([&H! 29+(2915+&! -;$+1-! 9! .5-3/! I$5-1923&! 9)H! L&9+-! 9! -$I.+&+$! .(,! &)$5,3! =$+! 1L$! -/I.$'(2! .9))&+-! 1$! 5)=5+'! 92+$--! (1-! I9--(%&! .+(I²9! 0&X(29)! 9)H! 9)! "I&+(29)! ='9,F! +&-;&21(%&'/8! ! W3&! L$+H-! %&' á() *+,+'+) 9+&! GLVSOD\HG LQ EROG FXUVLYH VWURNHV RQ WKH VRPEUHUR¶V KLJKP2+$L)F! 9)H! -'&)H&+! %()&-! L+9;! -/II&1+(29''/! 9+$5)H! 13&! I5+9'F! ,(%(),! (1! 13&! (''5-($)! $=! .&(),! 9! JXDUGHG SRUWDO WKDW IHZ FRXOG HYHU KRSH WR SDVV  ,W¶V RND\ KH WHOOV KLPVHOI =$+2(),!9!Y5(2J!)$H!$=!KLVKHDG  ,W¶VTXLHWKHUHDQGVDIH ! !

\%&)! -$F! K9I5&'! 29)M1! Y5(1&! '$-&! 13&! =&&'(),! 1391! 13&! `9;91(-19M-! &/&-! 9+&!

5;$)! 3(IF! L9123(),! 2'$-&'/! 9-! 3&! ;+$2&&H-! 1$! 13&! =$5)19()8! ! W3(-! H(-Y5(&1(),! -&)-91($)!(-!3&(,31&)&H!L(13!13&!(I;+$I;15!29L(),!$=!9!.(+HF!13&!-Y59''!.+&9J(),! 13&! 2$5+1/9+HM-! -('&)2&^! 9-! (=! -5II$)&H! 9L9J&! ./! (1-! -1+(H&)1! 2+/F! $.-25+&!


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²L3&+&F!()-1&9H!$=!1$523(),!L91&+F!3(-!=(),&+1(;-!L+(,,'&! ()!13&!9(+8! ! V)'/!13&)!H$&-!13&!=$5)19()M-!9.-$'51&!Y5(&1!()1&)-(=/!L(13!9!1&++(.'&! I&9)(),8! ! K'$L'/F!3(-!39)H!-'(H&-!9L9/!=+$I!13&!'$L&+!1(&+F!H+$;;(),!91!3(-!-(H&8! ! 7KHZDWHUKHUHDOL]HVLVQ¶WWULFNOLQJOLNHUDLQIDOOFDVFDGLQJIURPWLHUWRWLHUDQG ,&)&+91(),! 9! -$$13(),! +3/13I! 1391! -5.H5&-! 13&! 2$5+1/9+H8! ! G$L&+(),! 3(-! -19+&F! 3&! -2+51()([&-! 13&! I5+J/! .9-()! .&'$L! 3(-! J)&&-F! ;&+2&(%(),! (1-! H&;13-! 9-! 9! -19,)9)1! ;$$'²9)! $;1(29'! &==&21! 1391! .&2$I&-! 9;;9+&)1! L3&)! 3(-! &/&-! 9HN5-1F! +&%&9'(),!9!H&;'&1&H!+&-&+%$(+!-2911&+&H!L(13!;'9-1(2!25;-F!9!2+5I;'&H!02T$)9'H¶V .9,-F!;9;&+!)9;J()-F!9)H!9)!$'H!.'5&!-'&&;(),!.9,8! ! ! !

W3&)! -19+(),! H$L)L9+H! 91! 13&! L91&+'&--! .9-()! 9-! (=! 2$)1&I;'91(),! 9)!

XQIDWKRPDEOH YRLG D VXUJH RI FKLOOV ZDVKHV RYHU 6DPXHO¶V VSLQH VKDNLQJ KLP 5)1('! &%&+/! N$()1! =&&'-! '(J&! (1! I(,31! 5)3(),&8! ! W3&! I/-1&+/! .(+H! 29L-! 1L(2&! =+$I! WKHQLJKWDQGZKLOHKHOLVWHQVWRLWKLVOLSVWUHPEOHDSDUWDQVZHULQJWKHELUGµVFU\ ()! 9! -&+(&-! $=! ;+$'$),&HF! ,5';(),! -$.-! 1391! &23$! 9.$51! 13&! 2$5+1/9+H8! ! W&9+-! ()-19)1'/!,5-3!=$+13F!;'5II&1(),!$==!3(-!)$-&!9)H!23()F!-;+()J'(),!13&!.9-()!'(J&! 13&/! 9'$)&! 2$5'H! +&;'&)(-3! 13&! =$5)19()8! ! ")H! L(13$51! +(-(),! $+! -1(='(),! 3(-! L&&;(),F!3&!;+&-&)1'/!15+)-!3(I-&'=!$)!13&!'&H,&F!L9HH'(),!9+$5)H!L3&)!&),()&-!


,+$L'! -$I&L3&+&! 5;! 13&! -1+&&1! 9)H! H+9L! )&9+8! ! "! L$'=! ;92J! $=! I$1$+2/2'&-! -5HH&)'/! +$9+-! ./! 13&! I&+29H$M-! =+$)1! 2$'5I)-F! 13&(+! .+(,31! '(,31-! =('1&+(),! 13+$5,3! 3(-! 1&9+-! 1$! =$+I! H(9I$)HP-39;&H! ;911&+)-! .&=$+&! -;&&H(),! =+$I! %(&L8! ! <$+!-&%&+9'!-&2$)H-!13&+&9=1&+F!3&!3&9+-!13&!=5''P13+$11'&H!&),()&-!,+$L(),!=9()1&+! 9)H!=9()1&+F!()&%(19.'/!H+$)(),!$51!$=!&9+-3$1!9'1$,&13&+8! !

"! -('&)2&! 1391! (-! -$I&3$L! '$5H&+! 139)! 13&! I$1$+2/2'&-! H&-2&)H-! 9,9()F!

DQG LWV UHVXUJHQFH EURDGHQV 6DPXHO¶V GHVSDLU  %HWZHHQ WKH VKDOORZ JDVSV ;5)21591(),!3(-!-$.-F!3(-!.'5++/!,9[&!9.-&)1'/!+$9I-!13&!&)2'$-5+&F!-29))(),!13&! 1('&-F! 9-2&)H(),! 13&! L9''-F! 91! '9-1! -&11'(),! $)! 13&! I5+9'8! ! \%&)! L3&+&! 3&! -Y591-F! 3(-!.$H/!-35HH&+(),!L(13!&923!2$)%5'-(%&!.+&913F!13&!`9;91(-19!(-!9--&--(),!3(I^! (1-! '9+,&F! 5)+&I(11(),! &/&-! ;(&+2&! 13&! ,'$$I²1L$! 9'I$)H! -39;&-! .+&923(),! 13&! H9+J)&--F!29-1!()!3(-!H(+&21($)²RIIHULQJQRKLQWRISLW\  %XWLW¶VKLVPRWKHU¶VH\HV 1391!3&!.+(&='/!&)%(-($)-F!13&!-1&&'/!,'()1!1391!1+9)-=$+I-!3&+!=92&!9)H!1(,31&)-!3&+! -19+&!()1$!9!'9-&+!.&9I²9-!(=!-3&!;+&=&++&H!3(I!H&9H!+913&+!139)!9'(%&F!9-!(=!-3&! 2$5'H!$)'/!=()H!-91(-=921($)!./!H(-9%$L(),!3(I!2$I;'&1&'/F!,'$L&+(),!=+$I!9.$%&! DQG UDYDJLQJ KLV QHUYRXV V\VWHP IRU RIWHQ WKH VPDOOHVW RIIHQVH  ³+RZ GLG \RX EHFRPH WKLV GXPE"  :KR PDGH \RX OLNH WKDW"  , NQRZ LW ZDVQ¶W PH RU \RXU =913&+a! ! R391! L&+&! /$5! 13()J(),S! ! #$F! )R \RX DUHQ¶W P\ VRQ²DQG LW¶V YHU\ REYLRXV\RXQHYHUZHUH´! !

W3&-&! 2$5+1/9+H! &/&-F! 3$L&%&+F! 9+&! I523! I$+&! 2$)2'5-(%&! ()! 13&(+!

N5H,I&)1²-2$+)(),! K9I5&'M-! &X(-1&)2&! L3('&! 9-J(),! 3(I! )$13(),²H&'(%&+(),! 9! I&+2('&--! %&+H(21! -$! ()2$I;+&3&)-(.'&! 1391F! 9-! (1! +&,(-1&+-F! 9)/! -$..(),! (-! WHPSRUDULO\ FXUEHG  <RX¶YH EURXJKW VKDPH RQ \RXUVHOI DQG \RXU SRRU SDUHQWV WKH\UHVRXQGLQVLGHKLVKHDG  <RX¶YHPDGHDIRRORIHYHU\RQHZKRFDPHWRWKH


UHVWDXUDQWWRZDWFK\RXUSHUIRUPDQFHDQG\RX¶YHKXUW\RXUPRWKHUEDGHQRXJK WKDW VKH ZRQ¶W IRUJLYH \RX RU ZDQW \RX EDFN  7KDW¶V \RXU SXQLVKPHQW IRU WKH SUREOHPV\RXµYHFDXVHGWRGD\DQGWKDW¶V\RXUVWXSLGIDWH  ,W VWRRODWH  7KHUH V )$L3&+&!/$5!29)!,$!)$LF!)$1!&%&)!3$I&F!-$!/$5!I(,31!9-!L&''!N5-1!J(''!/$5+-&'=! 3&+&8! !

W3&! -$.-! UHVXPH SXPSLQJ IURP 6DPXHO OLNH D VWXWWHUHU¶V SDQLFNHG

()9+1(25'91($)-8! ! ]&!H+$;-!3(-!23()!9)HF!1&9+-!-1+&9J(),!3(-!=92&F!H&2(H&-!(1-!.&-1! WR DYRLG ORRNLQJ DW WKH PXUDO  ,W¶V QRW DOO P\ IDXOW KH WKLQNV DQG LW¶V QRW =9(+²DQG ,¶P D JRRG VRQ²9)H! 09! -3$5'H)M1! 391&! I&! =$+&%&+8! ! 7)! 9! -3$+1! 1(I&F! 13$5,3F! 13&! ,9-;-F! ,5';-F! 9)H! 1&9+-! +5)! $51! $=! -1&9I²13&! 2$+)&+-! $=! 3(-! &/&-! VWLQJ KLV WKURDW IHHOV DV LI LW¶V EHHQ SXQFKHG²/&1! 3&! 2$)1()5&-! -35HH&+(),! L(13! 9=1&+-3$2J-!=$+!9!'(11'&!'$),&+F!13&!HL()H'(),!1+&I$+-! ,+9H59''/!+&2&H(),!()1$!13&! =9I(-3&H!;(1!$=!3(-!-1$I9238! ! ]&!911&I;1-!1$!;5''!3(I-&'=!1$,&13&+F!1$!19J&!H&&;! .+&913-F! 1$! +&,9()! -$I&! 2$I;$-5+&! L3('&! 922&;1(),! 3(-! 29-19L9/! =91&8! ! b-(),! 9! -'&&%&F! 3&! H9.-! 3(-! &/&-! H+/F! L(;&-! 3(-! 23&&J-! 9)H! )$-&F! 9)H! $)2&! 3(-! -&)-&-! +&15+)F!-$!1$$!H$&-!13&!13+$.-!9)H!923&-!;5'-91(),!13+$5,3$51!3(-!.$H/8! ! ! !

")!9I.5'9)2&!-(+&)!L3()&-!()!13&!H(-19)2&F!;+$%$J(),!9!-;$+9H(2!23$+5-!$=!

H$,! 3$L'-!1391!'(),&+-!39'=P3&9+1&H'/!L3&)! (1!I$%&-!;9-18! ! "-!13&! -(+&)!=9H&-F! 9! -2&)&! $=! 29+)9,&! I9)(=&-1-²$=! -I9-3&H! I$1$+2/2'&-! .'$2J(),! 9)! ()1&+-&21($)F! L3&&'-! -1(''! -;())(),F! 13&(+! '(=&'&--! +(H&+-! .5+(&H! 9I$),! 13&! 19),'&H! L+&2J9,&²DQG 6DPXHO FDQ¶W KHOS EXW EUHDWKH HDVLHU DW WKH WKRXJKW RI RWKHUV 39%(),! 9! L$+-&! )(,31! 139)! 3&8! ! W3&)! '(J&! 13(-! +&I$1&! ;$2J&1! $=! 13&! 2(1/! L3&+&! &%&)! 13&! .5('H(),-! 9)H! -1+&&1-! -&&I! 9-'&&;F! 9! L&9+()&--! 9.-$+.-! 3(-! '(I.-F! H5''! 9)H! 3&9%/8! ! ]&! '$L&+-! 13&! -J91&-F! '&9%(),! 13&I! 5;+(,31! $)! 13&! ,+$5)HF! 9)H!


VSUHDGV KLPVHOI DFURVV WKH EDVLQ¶V FXUYHG OHGJH UHVWLQJ ZLWK KLV EDFN WR W3&! =$5)19()F! 9! =$'H&H! 9+I! ;+$;;(),! 3(-! 3&9H! '(J&! 9! ;(''$L8! ! K3$5'H! 13&! )(,31! 15+)! 23(''/F!3&!39-!9'+&9H/!;'9))&H!93&9H^!13&+&!(-!9'L9/-!13&!$'H!-'&&;(),!.9,!()!13&! .9-()F! 9! L9+I! &)$5,3! +&1+&91! 5)1('! 13&! I$+)(),! 9++(%&-F! 9'13$5,3! 13&! (H&9! $=! 3(.&+)91(),!()-(H&!(1!I9J&-!3(-!-J()!2+9L'8! ! ! !

WL$!$+!13+&&!2+&915+&-!-25++/!$%&+!13&!1('&-F!9!;911&+(),!;+$2&--($)!+5-3(),!

DORQJVLGH WKH ERUGHU RI WKH PHUFDGR¶V PDLQ ZDOO  0RUH UDWV 6DPXHO DVVXPHV L(13$51! -1(++(),! 1$! '$$JF! 9)H! 13&)! =()H-! 3(I-&'=! 13()J(),! 9.$51! 3(-! ;&1! I$5-&F! Y5&-1($)(),!L3&13&+!3&!39H!'&=1!-$I&!=$$H!=$+!(1!13(-!I$+)(),8! ! B51!13&!35),&+! ;'52J(),!9L9/!91!3(-!$L)!-1$I923F!'(J&!13$-&!1()/!2'9L-!+&;&91&H'/!-2+9123(),!13&! 29,&!.9+-F!$)'/!3&';-!1$!-192J!9)$13&+!'9/&+!$=!,5('1!9I$),!3(-!13$5,31-F!I9J(),! KLP IDLUO\ FHUWDLQ WKDW WKH PRXVH KDG SUREDEO\ QRW EHHQ IHG  ³,¶P VRUU\´  KH 511&+-!I(-&+9.'/F!.5+/(),!3(-!)$-&!()1$!13&!2+&9-&!$=!3(-!9+I8! ! K$$)F!3$L&%&+F!3(-! &/&-!-351F!9)H!13&!I()51&-!.&,()!-'(;;(),!9L9/F!13&!;9--(),!$=!&923!-(X1/!-&2$)H-F! KH

LPDJLQHV

GLVWLQJXLVKHG

E\

KLV

VWRPDFK¶V

F\FOLFDO

JUXPEOH 

V)&²1L$²13+&&²=$5+²! ! ! !

6DPXHO¶VEUHDWKLQJVORZVWRDUHOD[HGPHDVXUHKLVFKHVWVZHOOVDQGIDOOVLQ

JHQWOH ZDYHV  ([FHSW KLV PLQG ZRQ¶W VWRS ZRUN(),²N5I;(),! 3&+&! 9)H! 13&+&! 91! +9)H$I!'(J&!9)!()=&+)9'!I923()&F!='9-3(),!%9+($5-!I$I&)1-!9-!(=!13&/!L&+&!=+$I! D WLUHVRPH VOLGHVKRZ KH¶G UDWKHU QRW ZDWFK  7KH SD\SKRQH VZDOORZLQJ KLV 239),&8! ! V'H!b)2'&M-! H&2&;1(%&!-I('&8! ! W3&! .'92J!.5-!H+(%&+!-3$$(),!3(I!1$!13&! 25+.8! ! W3&!I$)&/!()!13&!,511&+8! ! W3&!.$/-!;'9/(),!.9-J&1.9''8! ! ](-!3$5-&8! ! ](-! EHG  7KH 79  7KH VLJQLILFDQW SOHDVXUH RI KLV PRWKHU¶V XQPDWFKHG FRRNLQJ  W3&!'&=1$%&+-!$)!9!+&=+(,&+91$+!-3&'=8! ! 09;$! 1$=5!()!9!.$L'8! ! 43$L!=5)!L(13!-$/!


-952&! 9)H! .&&=8! ! K1&9I(),! +(2&8! ! Z'9--&-! $=! L91&+8! ! W3&! '$.-1&+! 19)J! 91! #&L! c9),! c9),! Z9+H&)8! ! ](-! I$13&+! L9(1(),! 19.'&-8! ! ](-! I$13&+! L9(1(),! =$+! 3(I8! ! ](-! I$13&+! -1+9(,31&)(),! 3(-! 39(+! .&=$+&! 9! +&2(19'8! ! W3&! %($'()! '(=1(),! =+$I! (1-! 29-&8! ! W3&!.+9)H!)&L!.$L8! ! "!-;$1'(,31!-3()(),!$)!3(I8! ! ]9)H-!2'9;;(),!9-!13&! %($'()! (-! )&-1'&H! 9,9()-1! 3(-! 2$''9+! .$)&! 9)H! N9L! '()&8! ! W3&! .$L! -L9/(),8! ! W3&! 2+$$J!$=!9!135I.!-'(H(),!9'$),!13&!=(),&+.$9+H8! ! W3&!=$5+!-1+(),-!Y5(%&+(),!'(J&! VSLGHU¶V VLON GLVWXUEHG E\ WKH ZLQG  6ZHDW JUHDVLQJ WKH! 23()+&-18! ! T$''9+! .(''-! 9)H! 2$()-! ='511&+(),! ()1$! 13&! %($'()! 29-&! L3('&! 3&! ='9L'&--'/! ;&+=$+I-! 9! -(I;'&! ;(&2&! 1391! 3&! 39-! )&%&+! '&9+)&H! .51! 29)! )$L! 3&9+8! ! R391! (-! 13&! -$),S! ! 3&! L$)H&+-F!2+92J(),!$;&)!3(-!&/&-8! ! R391!9I!7!;'9/(),S! !

"! -1+9),&! +&=+9()! L3(-;&UV IURP ZLWKLQ WKH PHUFDGR¶V RSDTXH FRUH D

-$5)H! -$! )&9+'/! ()95H(.'&! 1391! (1! 19J&-! K9I5&'! 9! L3('&! 1$! 9;;+&3&)H! 13&! %($'()! I5-(2! 9-! -$I&13(),! $13&+! 139)! 9! ;+$H521! $=! 3(-! (I9,()91($)8! ! R391! (-! (1S! ! 3&! WKLQNV  :KHUH¶VLWFRPLQJIURP"  7KHQRWHVDQGFKRUGVD+&!()&'&,9)1!./!H&-(,)F! +5H(I&)19+/! 9'13$5,3! -J(''=5''/! 922$I;'(-3&HF! 9)H! 3(-! $L)! =(),&+-! I(++$+! 13&I! RQ WKH EDVLQ OHGJH PHFKDQLFDOO\ WDSSLQJ WKH VWRQH OLNH D SOD\HU SLDQR¶V DXWRPDWHG KDPPHUV  %XW ZKDW H[DFWO\ WKH VRQJ LV KH FDQ¶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


1+&9H-! 29+&=5''/! =+$I! 13&! =$5)19()²-1&&+(),! 9! 1&)191(%&! 2$5+-&! =$+! 13&! 2$+)&+! ;9--9,&F!(1-!+&2&--&-!9;;&9+(),!9-!()922&--(.'&!9-!13&!3&9%&)-!9.$%&8! !

"=1&+! 2+$--(),! .&)&913! 13&! %95'1&H! &)1+9)2&F! K9I5&'! =$''$L-! 13&! I5-(2!

H$L)! 9! 2$)2+&1&! L9'JL9/! 1391! -1+&123&-F! 9-! (=! &)H'&--'/F! ()1$! H9+J)&--²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²1391! 25+($5-! =5-($)! $=! +9()F! 35I(H(1/F! =(-3F!.'$$HF!9)H!)$$H'&-8! ! ]&!-I&''-!9)H!+&29''-!(1!&==$+1'&--'/F!2$)N5+(),!='(;P='$;-! I9+23(),F! H(+1/! L91&+! -'(13&+(),! ()1$! I$'H/! H+9()-F! -)9J&-! 39),(),! '&),13L(-&! =+$I! I&H(2()9'! -)9J&! -3$;! 9L)(),-F! %$(2&-! 39,,'(),! .&-(H&! I$5)19()-! $=! H+(&H! -Y5(H!-3+&H-8! !

W3(-! ;'92&F! $)! 13&! $13&+! 39)HF! (-! 9-! -('&)1! 9-! 13&! 2$5+1/9+HF! -9%&! =$+! 13&!

VKXIIOLQJ RI 6DPXHO¶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


I9/.&! =(%&²13&! -9I&! -2(--$+! ,91&-! $.-&+%&H! 9,9()! 9)H! 9,9()! $)! &(13&+! -(H&F! QXUWXULQJ WKH YDJXH LPSUHVVLRQ WKDW KH LVQ¶W UHDOO\ DGYDQFLQJ²5)1('F! 9''! $=! 13&! -5HH&)F! 13&! L9'JL9/! &)H-! 91! 9)! ()1&+-&21(),! 9''&/8! ! "! ;9(+! $=! 35'J(),F! 1+9-3PVWXIIHGGXPSVWHUVVLWQHDUWKHPHUFDGR¶VUHDUH[LWEH\RQGZKLFKLVDQRSHQ '$1! $=! %929)1! ;9+J(),! -;92&-8! ! W$! 13&! '&=1! 9)H! 1$! 13&! +(,31F! 13&! 9''&/! H(%(H&-! 13&! =92(),! .92J-(H&-! $=! .5('H(),-F! 9)H! H(+&21'/! 92+$--! (1! (-! 9! +&HP.+(2J! L9''! 1391! &X1&)H-!5;L9+HF!I&-3(),!L(13!13&!'&9H&)!-J/8! !

W3&! I5-(2! -&&I-! +(,31! ()! =+$)1! $=! K9I5&'F! 9-! (=! (1! L&+&! -&&;(),! 13+$5,3!

39(+P'()&! =(--5+&-! 9+$5)H! 13&! .+(2J-8! ! R3&)! 3&! ;+$2&&H-! 1$L9+H! 13&! L9''F! 9! I$5)1&H! -&25+(1/! ='$$H'(,31! 2'(2J-! $)! =+$I! $%&+3&9HF! (''5I()91(),! 3(-! 9;;+$923! 9)H! -19+1'(),! 3(I8! ! K1(''F! 3&! +&I9()-! H95)1'&--F! .+(),(),! 3(I-&'=! 1$! 13&! L9''F! ORLWHULQJ WKHUH OLNH VRPHRQH ZKR LV VQHDNLQJ D SLVV  -XVW WKHQ WKH PXVLF¶V 5)-5),! '/+(2-! -;+(),! ;9-1! 13&! 1(;! $=! 3(-! 1$),5&F! 13&! L$+H-! 2$++&-;$)H(),! L(13! ZKDWWKHYLROLQQRZVRREYLRXVO\SOD\VDQGXQGHUKLVEUHDWKKHPXPEOHV  ³0XG H$''F!I5H!H$''F!9!-(),'&!I5H!H$''²´  ,WLVD7DLZDQHVHFKLOGKRRGIDYRULWHDIRON -$),!195,31!1$!J(H-!91!-23$$'F!$+!./!13&(+!I$13&+-F!$+F!()!KLVFDVHE\KLVPRWKHU¶V I$13&+8! ! 6KHWRRKDVH\HVEXWVKHFDQ¶WZLQN  6KHWRRKDVDQRVH  6KHWRRKDV DPRXWKEXWVKHFDQ¶W-;&9J8! ! ")H!9-!13&!'/+(2-!&%$J&!3(-!3$I&'9)H!9)H!/$5),&+! -&'=F!13&/!9'-$!+&)H&+!9!;$1&)1!+&2$''&21($)!$=!-L&'1&+(),!2$5)1+/-(H&!%9291($)-F!$=! KLV JUDQGSDUHQWV¶ FOXWWHUHG PLQND KRXVH DQG VSHFLILFDOO\ KLV JUDQGPRWKHU ]9(P/5&)! +&'9X(),! 2+$--P'&,,&H! $)! 9! 1919I(! 9=1&+! 9)! &%&)(),! .913²)9J&H! =+$I! 13&!L9(-1!5;!L(13!3&+!L&(,31/!.+&9-1-!-9,,(),!'(J&!39'=P=5''!.9,-!$=!='$5+F!9!2$('&H! L9-3!1$L&'!39),(),!91!3&+!)&2J²-(),(),!=$+!13&!%(-(1(),!,+9)H23('H+&)!-;+9L'&H! .&=$+&! 3&+! L(13()! 13&! PDLQ URRP  ³6KH LV D IDNH EDE\ QRW! 9! +&9'! .9./8! ! K3&!


GRHVQ¶W KDYH 9! H&9+! I9I9! $+! ;9;9²´  7R ERWK WKH PRUWLILFDWLRQ DQG GHOLJKW $=! 3&+! ,+9)H23('H+&)F! ]9(P\XHQ¶V YHLQ\ PDOOHDEOH EUHDVWV DUH FOXWFKHG LQ KHU SDOH 39)H-F!-Y5&&[&H!$51L9+H!./!3&+!13(2J!=(),&+-F!15,,&H!13(-!L9/!9)H!1391!L3('&!-3&! VLQJV  ³,¶''!.&!KHUPRWKHU´  7KHEUHDVWVMLJJOHWRWKHULJKW  ³,¶''!.&!KHUIDWKHU´  W3&!.+&9-1VMLJJOHWRWKHOHIW  ³/RYHKHUIRUHYHU´  7KHWZREURZQQLSSOHVFROOLGH 91!13&!2&)1&+!$=!3&+! 23&-1F!,/+91(),!1$,&13&+! 9-!(=!J(--(),!()!13&! 3&91&H!13+$&-!$=! ;9--($)8! !

K9I5&'! '9/-! 9! ;9'I! $)! 13&! .+(2J-F! &X;&21(),! 13&! I5-(2! 1$! %(.+91&! 9,9()-1!

3(-!-J()F!.51!$QO\IHHOVDFRDUVHDQGKDUGVXUIDFH  7KHQDLGHGE\WKHIORRGOLJKWµV 9),5'9+! +9H(9)2&F! 3&! 19J&-! 9! '$),! -1&;! .92JL9+H-F! -&9+23(),! 13&! .+&9H13! $=! 13&! L9''! =$+! 9)! 922&--! ;$()1²9! H$$+F! 9! L()H$LF! 9! -19(+29-&²=()H(),! ()-1&9H! &X(-1&)1(9'!,+9==(1(!1391!1&''-!3(I!)$13(),:! ! *VG74\!BdbW"G7WQ!\"WK!0Q!"KKaaa! ()!13()!-;+9/P;9()1&H! .'92J!'&11&+-F!9)H!13&!I$+&!9+1=5'F!-9)-!-&+(=!()-2+(;1($)!$=! "GKc7! .&'$L! (18! ! #&%&+13&'&--F! 13&! %($'()! I5-(2! &X(-1-! .&3()H! 13&! L9''F! ;'9/(),! =+$I!-$I&L3&+&!()-(H&!13&!.+(2J!.5('H(),F!9)HF!3&!UHDVRQVLIWKHUHLVQ¶WD GRRU 3&+&F!13&)!(1!I5-1!.&!$)!13&!$13&+!-(H&8! ! R(13$51!2$)-(H&+(),!L3(23!H(+&21($)!1$! ,$F!3&!()-1()21(%&'/!-19+1-!H$L)!13&!9''&/F!13&!-J91&-!H9),'(),!()!13&!9(+8!]&!15+)-! DWWKHEXLOGLQJ¶VFRUQHUHQWHULQJDGDUNE\ZD\WKDWLVED+&'/!L(H&!&)$5,3!=$+!1L$! ;&$;'&!9)H!+5)-!.&1L&&)!L9''-!'(J&!9!-'$;(),!,511&+8! ! ]&!1+5H,&-!,(),&+'/!9'$),! 13(-! 2$)=()(),! ;9--9,&F! -J(+1(),! 2+5-3&H! 9'5I()5I! 29)-! 9)H! L9HH&H! 2'5I;-! $=! 1$('&1!;9;&+F!()39'(),!9!23$J(),F!=&1(H!$H$+!L3('&!9H%9)2(),8! !

B51! 3&! H$&-)M1! L9'J! I523! =9+13&+! .&=$+&! -&&(),F! 5;! 93&9H! $)! 3(-! +(,31F! 9!

;$+19'! $=! '(,31! -'9)1(),! ()1$! 13&! ;913F! 13&! ;9''(H! L3(1&! ,'$L! &)39)2&H! ./! L(-;/F! -L(+'(),!25++&)1-!$=!-I$J&8! ! "1!&%&)!-523!9!-3$+1!H(-19)2&F!13&!'(,31!9;;&9+-!1$!.&!


&-29;(),!13+$5,3!13&!.+(2J-F!/&1!9-!3&!2$I&-!2'$-&+!13&!=+9I&!$=!9)!$;&)!H$$+L9/! 19J&-! -39;&F! +&I$%(),! 9)/! H$5.1! 9.$51! L3&+&! &X921'/! 13&! I5-(2! 29)! .&! =$5)H8! ! $PRQJ WKH OLJKW DQG VPRNH GULIWLQJ LQWR WKH SDWK WKH YLROLQ¶V UHVRQDQFH DOVR ='$91-!$51-(H&²)$L!;&+=$+I(),! !-.) /+012(.) 34&5.6F!9!-$),! 3&!J)$L-!L&''!9)H! 39-!;'9/&H!I9)/!1(I&-²922$I;9)(&H!./!13&!&++91(2!2'911&+!$=!.$)&!$+!;'9-1(2!1('&-! -J(II(),!5;$)!19.'&1$;-F!13&!5)I(-19J9.'&!N5I.'(),!$=!I93N$),!;(&2&-8! ! W3&)! -&%&+9'! =&&1! =+$I! 13&! H$$+L9/F! $)! 13&! $;;$-(1&! .5('H(),F! 3&! )$1(2&-! 9! '$L! L9+&3$5-&! L()H$LF! 9)H! L3&)! +&923(),! (1! 3&! ;95-&-! '$),! &)$5,3! 1$! '(=1! 3(I-&'=! L(13!3(-!1$&-!9)H!;&&J!()8! !

7KHUH EHWZHHQ WKH ZLQGRZ¶V FDJHP'(J&! '911(2&! .9+-F! K9I5&'! -;(&-! 9! ,+$5;!

$=!1L&)1/!$+!-$!/$5),!G91()9!L$I&)F!)$)&!9-!$'H!9-!3(-!I$13&+F!-&91&H!L(13()!9! H(),/! L$+J-3$;! +$$I! 9)H! -191($)&H! 91! 1L$! &X;9)-(%&F! 9HN$()(),! 29=&1&+(9P-1/'&! 19.'&-²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²'(J&!13&!H9+J)&--!$=!13&!./L9/F!'(J&!13&! ,9+.9,&! '(11&+(),! 13&! ;913²=&&'-! 1$$! ()2$),+5$5-! L(13! 13&! '$%&'/! I&'$H/! &)'(%&)(),! 13&! 9(+! 9+$5)H! 3(I8! ! ")H! 5+,&H! =$+L9+H! ./! 3(-! $L)! 25+($-(1/F! 3&! H&-2&)H-! 1$! 13&! ='91! $=! 3(-! =&&1! 9)H! 3&9H-! =$+! 13&! )&9+./! H$$+L9/F! 13&! -I&''! $=! -L&91!9)H!1$.922$!-$$)!%9)Y5(-3(),!13&!-1&)23!$=!L3&+&!3&!39-!N5-1!L9'J&H8! !


! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!"#$%&'$%'%"()#*)+,' -'³)./0'1/20'31/'(/4./3'567/0809:67;´' -'!968/24/7'<:=/>'9?'@A8B>'=4997'?90'CDEA@' -'E1/'F1A3/'E/0090'G/20>'+/.A>A3/7' -'H2I:/4'/63/0>'%A6/'H@0A68>'&09339 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !


Everything Beautiful is Far Away [10, 2012 | Vol. 6]  

EVERYTHING BEAUTIFUL IS FAR AWAY is a collaborative novel in progress from author Mitch Cullin and filmmaker Peter I. Chang, with monthly gu...

Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you