Everything Beautiful is Far Away [1, 2013 | Vol. 9]

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

"!#$%&'!()!*+$,+&--!./!0(123!45''()!6!*&1&+!78!439),:!

439;1&+-!<=&)1/!1$!<=&)1/>?$5+! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! @ABC! ! #$13(),! D$+&! (-! -9(E! E5+(),! 13&! -3$+1F! 1&++(.'&! =9'G! 3$D&8! ! 4'5123(),! H9D5&'! ./! 9! =+(-1F! I$5(-9! '&9E-! 13&! =9/! '(G&! 9! ;&1! $=)&+! .(11&+'/! E+9,,(),! 9! -15..$+)! 9)(D9'! $)! 9! '&9-3F! ;5''(),! 3(D! J$+=9+E! 9-! 13&! -G91&-! 2'911&+! 92+$--! 13&! -(E&=9'G8! ! #$=! 13&! '$),! &%&)(),! $J! 13&(+! D5159'! -&9+23(),! 39-! +&923&E! 9! 2$)2'5-($)F! 9)E! 9! =9+D! .+&&K&!

9;;+$923&-! J+$D! .&3()EF! 9E%9)2(),! ()! .+(&J! ,5-1-! 1$! )5E,&! 9,9()-1! 13&(+! .92G-8! !

4+5D;'&E! 1+9-3! -G(11&+-! E$=)! 13&! ,511&+! 9)E! ;9%&D&)1! =(13! -5EE&)! J(1-! 9)E! -1$;-8! ! <3&)! 13&/F! 1$$F! J'$=! =(13! 13&! J'521591($)-! $J! 13&! .+&&K&²J9-1&+! 9)E! -'$=&+F! J9-1&+! 9)E! -'$=&+8! ! "+$5)E! 13&D! ;9--&-! 9! 0&L(29)! D9)! 1+9%&'(),! $)! 9! -G91&.$9+EF! 9! ;9(+! $J! 1&&)9,&!.$/-!M$,,(),!1$,&13&+F!9)!$'E&+!;&+-$)!$J!()E&J()(1&!-&L!;5-3(),!9!-3$;;(),!29+1F! 9!/$5),!43()&-&!2$5;'&!+(E(),!.(2/2'&-8! ! "1!$)&!;$()1!-$D&!.+$G&)!,'9--!J'(2G&+-!()!13&!

JXWWHU WKH IODVK RI KHDGOLJKWV GD]]OLQJ WKH VFDWWHUHG UHPQDQWV 7KURXJK 6DPXHO¶V 1&9+-F!13&!2'&9+!-39+E-!9;;&9+!'(G&!,'(11&+(),!,&D-!-;+&9E!9'$),!13&!+$9E-(E&8! !

")E! =3('&! 13&/! 1+9%&+-&! 13&! J9D('(9+! +$51&F! 13&! %92(''91(),! .+&&K&! +&'9/-! 13&!

-$5)E-! $J! -&%&+9'! 13(),-²29+-F! +9E($-F! ;9+1(),! -3$51-! J+$D! ;9+G(),! '$1-F! E$,-! .9+G(),F! 9)EF!9'D$-1!9-!35-3&E!9-!13&!.+&&K&!(1-&'JF!=391!-&&D-!'(G&!9!=$D9)!-;&9G(),!$.-25+&'/!

J$+!)$!$)&!.51!3&+-&'JF!13&!=$+E-!$+!E(9'&21!(D;$--(.'&!1$!D9G&!$518! ! N)'/!9J1&+!+&923(),!

13&! +&'91(%&! O5(&1! $J! 13&(+! -1+&&1! E$&-! H9D5&'! 13()G! 13&! &13&+&9'! %$(2&! D(,31! .&! 3(-!

PRWKHU V JUXPEOLQJ ORZ DQG ZKLVSHU\ DOWKRXJK KH LVQ¶W VXUH ,W PLJKW DOVR EH OLWWOH &'-&! 139)! 13&! -$J1! '9),59,&! $J! 13&! .+&&K&8! ! P9'J! '(-1&)(),F! 3&! ,5';-! .92G! 13&! -$.-! 1391!

-;9-D! 5;! 3(-! 13+$91! '(G&! .('&²)$(-&'&--'/F! ;9()J5''/²9)E! 13&! 2'$-&+! 13&/! ,&1! 1$! 13&!

KRXVH KH UHSHDWHGO\ OLIWV KLV WUDJLF IDFH SHHULQJ DW /RXLVD¶V WXUQHG DZD\ KHDG ZLWK DQ

5)-&&)! &L;+&--($)! $J! 1&9+J5'! ;&)9)2&F! 9-! (J! 3&! =&+&! 9! E$$D&E! ;+(-$)&+! .&(),! &-2$+1&E! 1$=9+E!13&!,9''$=-!9)E!E&-;&+91&!J$+!2'&D&)2/8! !

:KHQ WKH\ ILQDOO\ DUULYH KRPH 6DPXHO¶V VNDWHV DUH DEDQGRQHG RQ WKH SRUFK KLV

<>-3(+1!9)E!-=&91!;9)1-!9)E!D5'1(;'&!-$2G-!(DD&E(91&'/!15,,&E!$JJ!3(-!.$E/F!'&9%(),!3(D! WR VWDQG PRVWO\ QDNHG LQ WKH PLGGOH RI WKH OLYLQJ URRP ³<RX VWD\ WKHUH ´ /RXLVD -)9+'-! .&J$+&! 29++/(),! 3(-! 2'$13(),! $51! $J! %(&=²-1$D;(),! $%&+! 13&! G(123&)! '()$'&5DF! ,$(),!()1$!13&!'95)E+/!)$$G²=3&+&!3&!-$$)!3&9+-!13&!=9-3&+!'(E!-O5&9G!$;&)!9)E!13&)! .9),! 2'$-&8! ! H3&! ;+$D;1'/! +&15+)-! =(13! 13&! -9D&! ;$5)E(),! -1&;-F! D9+23(),! ;9-1! 3(-!

VOXPSHG IRUP VD\LQJ FROGO\ ³'RQ¶W PRYH ´ 6KH KHDGV IRU WKH WHOHSKRQH XQLW RQ D -(E&!19.'&!./!13&!2$523²13&!+&E!'(,31!$J!(1-!9)-=&+(),!D923()&!.'()G(),!9,9()!9)E!9,9()F! -(,)9'(),!13&!)5D&+$5-!5)3&9+E!D&--9,&-!1391!-3&!39E!'&J1!13+$5,3$51!13&!E9/8! !

Q51!J92(),!13&!$;;$-(1&!E(+&21($)F!H9D5&'!29)!$)'/!$.-&+%&!I$5(-9!+&J'&21&E!E(D'/!

$)! 13&! %929)1! <R! -2+&&)F! 13&! ;3$)&! 39)E-&1! 3&'E! )&9+! 3&+! J92&! 9-! 9! )5D.&+! (-! E(9'&E8! ! ")EF! 1$$F! 3&! 29)! -&&! 3(D-&'J! 13&+&F! %5')&+9.'&! 9)E! -D9''F! -1+(;;&E! .9+&! -9%&! J$+! 3(-!

5)E&+=&9+!9)E!13&!)/'$)!-1+(),!E9),'(),!13&!3$5-&!G&/!91!3(-!23&-18! ! "!D$D&)1!'91&+F! 3&! 3&9+-! 3(-! D$13&+! -;&9G(),F! 3&+! .+(11'&! %$(2&! 239),&E! ()! 9)! ()-19)1! 9)E! )$=! ;$'(1&F! E&J&+&)1(9'8! !

³<HV \HV ´ /RXLVD VD\V FRQWLQXDOO\ QRGGLQJ DV LI )UDQFLV LV ULJKW LQ IURQW RI KHU

³KH VHHPV ILQH²7! J$5)E! 3(D! )$1! 1$$! J9+! J+$D! $5+! 3$5-&²7! 13()G! 3&! ,$1! '$-1!

-$D&3$=²/&-²,¶P VR VRUU\ ERVV²KH GRHVQ¶W NQRZ KLV ZD\ DURXQG KHUH YHU\! =&''²SOHDVH IRUJLYH KLP LWµV P\ IDXOW²13&!.$/!,&1-!2$)J5-&E!&9-('/²7!9;$'$,(K&!J$+!9''!

13&! 1+$5.'&! 3&! 39-! 295-&E! /$5! 1$E9/²$J! 2$5+-&F! /&-²/&-F! 7! =(''²1$D$++$=!

9J1&+)$$)²/&-F!139)G! /$5²/&-²139)G!/$5²/&-²$G9/F!$G9/²/&-²139)G!/$5²-&&!/$5!

1$D$++$=²E\H E\H ´! !

I$5(-9! 39),-! 5;! 13&! ;3$)&8! ! "J1&+! 9! J&=! -&2$)E-F! -3&! -&(K&-! 13&! 39)E-&1! $)2&!

D$+&F! 9)! ()E&L! J(),&+! 5+,&)1'/! ;5)23(),! 13&! G&/;9EF! 13(-! 1(D&! &)1&+(),! 9! '$),&+! )5D.&+8! ! <3&)!-(,3(),!E&&;'/F!-3&!=+9;-!13&!&'9-1(2!2$('-!$J!13&!;3$)&!2$+E!9+$5)E!1=$! &L1&)E&E!J(),&+-F!=9(1(),!J$+!13&!$13&+!&)E!1$!9)-=&+8! ! Q51!H9D5&'!9'+&9E/!G)$=-!=3$!

(1!(-!1391!3(-!D$13&+!39-!29''&E8! ! P&!G)$=-!1391!3(-!J913&+!(-!5-59''/!2$)1921&E!=3&)&%&+!

VKH EHFRPHV WRR IUXVWUDWHG RU XSVHW DQG KH DOVR NQRZV WKDW VKH ZRQ¶W UHDFK KLP \HW ,W (-!13&!)&L1!E9/!()!<9(;&(F!-$!3(-!J913&+!(-!-1(''!91!=$+G!$)!9!0$)E9/!9J1&+)$$)F!;+$.9.'/!

19G(),!9!'5)23!.+&9G8!

!

³&KXQ>WH \RX FDOO ZKHQ \RX JHW KRPH ´ /RXLVD VXGGHQO\ EOXUWV DW WKH

+&2&(%&+²3&+! 2$)1&)1($5-! %$(2&! +&&D&+,(),F! 2+$--(),! 1(D&! 9)E! 13&! *92(J(2! $2&9)F! 1+9)-D(11(),!()1$!13&!J515+&!9)E!+&-$)91(),!J+$D!9)!9)-=&+(),!D923()&!.&-(E&!13&!.&E! VKH KDG VKDUHG ZLWK KHU KXVEDQG ³<RXU VRQ LV QRWKLQJ EXW D SUREOHP +H LVQ¶W $.&/(),! D&8! ! P&S-! .&&)! D(--(),! 9''! E9/8! ! <3(-! G(E! E(-9;;$()1-! D&! 1$! )$! &)E8! ! P&S-!

239)JHG +H¶V D ELJ SUREOHP IRU HYHU\RQH KHUH , GRQ¶W OLNH KLP DQ\PRUH &KXQ>1&8! ! 7!

GRQ¶W <RX UH KLV IDWKHU VR \RX FDOO ZKHQ \RX JHW WKLV DQG WDON WR KLP , UHDOO\ FDQ W WDNH LW DQ\PRUH ´! !

I$5(-9S-! 39+-3! =$+E-F! 3&+! ;$()1&E! E&'(%&+/F! 13&! =9/! H9D5&'! -&&-! 3&+! ,'9+(),! 91!

3(D!$)!13&!<R!-2+&&)!=3('&!+&2$+E(),!3&+!,+(&%$5-!D&--9,&²13&!&)1(+&!;&+J$+D9)2&!(-! ()1&)E&E!9-!D523!J$+!3(D!9-!(1!(-!J$+!3(-!J913&+F!9)E!()!13&!-('&)2&!1391!J$''$=-!13&!29''F! 13&!35+1J5'!9J1&+D913!$J!3&+!+&.5G&-!2$)%5'-&!95E(.'&!-$.-!J+$D!3(D8! !

$V LI GHVSLVLQJ KLV WHDUV EH\RQG HYHU\WKLQJ HOVH VKH VD\V ³6KXW XS ´ DQG VODPV

WKH KDQGVHW GRZQ ³:KDW GR \RX KDYH WR FU\ DERXW" <RX GRQ¶W FDUH DERXW DQ\RQH H[FHSW \RXUVHOI ´! !

P&!-&9'-!3(-!&/&'(E-F!-O5()23(),!3(-!J92&F!9)E!.(1&-!3(-!.$11$D!'(;!1$!%9)O5(-3!13&!

-$..(),8! !

³0D\EH \RX FU\ EHFDXVH /$5+! J913&+! (-! ,$(),! 1$! .&! D9E8! ! 7-! 1391! =3/T! ! U$5!

VKRXOG¶YH WKRXJKW DERXW WKDW EHIRUH PDNLQJ DOO WKHVH SUREOHPV ,W¶V WRR ODWH IRU \RX WR FKDQJH ZKDW \RXµYH GRQH ´ ! !

7KRXJK LW LVQ¶W KLV IDWKHU WKDW 6DPXHO!J&9+-F!.51F!+913&+F!13&!2$D;'&1&!9.-&)2&!$J!

KLV IDWKHU ,Q WKH SDVW ZKHQHYHU KH KDG H[KDXVWHG /RXLVD¶V SDWLHQFH LW ZDV &KXQ>1&! =3$! 1$$G! 2$)1+$'! $J! 13&! -(1591($)F! 19G(),! 3(D! 9-(E&! J$+! 9! ;91&+)9'! '&215+&F! -;&9G(),!

29'D'/! /&1! 9E9D9)1'/8! ! <$)(,31F! 3$=&%&+F! 13&+&! (-! )$! $)&! &'-&! 1$! &)1&+! 13&! J+9/! '(G&! 9! +&J&+&&F!1$!=9%&!3(-!D$13&+!$JJ!(J!3&+!2$DD&)1-!.&2$D&!O59++&'-$D&F!$+!1$!,(%&!3(D!9!

2$%&+1! =()G! $J! 9''(9)2&! 9-! -3&! -2$='-! -$D&=3&+&! ()! 13&! .92G,+$5)E8! ! ")E! 91! 13(-!

D$D&)1F!'(G&!&%&+/!D$D&)1!-()2&!D$%(),!9.+$9EF!(1!(-!M5-1!13&!1=$!$J!13&D!)$=F!9'$)&!

9)E!1$,&13&+F!=(13!)$!+&9-$)9.'&!.5JJ&+!.&1=&&)!13&D8! !

³6R \RX EHWWHU WHOO PH HYHU\WKLQJ ´ /RXLVD VD\V ³1R OLHV EHFDXVH ,µOO NQRZ

7HOO PH ZKHUH \RX ZHQW ´ +HU YRLFH FRPHV QHDUHU VZHHSLQJ DURXQG KLP ³:KDW Z&+&! /$5!E$(),T! ! V3$!=&+&!/$5!=(13F!H35),>\R"´ ! !

P&-(19)1'/F!H9D5&'!2+92G-!3(-!=&''(),!&/&-F!J()E(),!I$5(-9!-19)E(),!9.$%&!3(D!9-!

9!=9%&+(),F!.'5++/!J(,5+&!1391!.&,()-!;92(),!13&!29+;&1²3&+!9+D-!,&-1(25'91(),!=('E'/!9-!

-3&! 19'G-! J5+($5-'/! 91! 3(DF! 39)E-! +(-(),! 9)E! J9''(),! 5),$%&+)9.'/! '(G&! 9)! &++9)1!

-/D;3$)/! 2$)E521$+8! ! <3&)! ;5)21591&E! $)'/! ./! 9),+/! ;95-&-! =3('&! J+9,D&)1&E! +&-;$)-&-!,9-;!13+$5,3!3(-!=&&;(),F!3&+!&)+9,&E!()1&++$,91($)!2$D&-!()!-3+(''!J'5++(&-F! %$''&/&E! J+$D! $)&! -(E&! $J! 13&! '(%(),! +$$D! 1$! 13&! $13&+F! '(G&! 2'5-1&+! .$D.-! ()E(-2+(D()91&'/!-&&G(),!9!3(EE&)!19+,&18! ! <3&!.9++9,&!$J!O5&-1($)-!+9()-!E$=)!$)!3(D! DV LI VDWLVI\LQJ KHU KHDUW¶V FRQWHQW VWULGHQW DQG XQUHOHQWLQJ PDGH DOO WKH PRUH SRWHQW =(13$51!3(-!J913&+S-!D&9-5+&E!;+&-&)2&!13&+&!1$!1&D;&+!3&+!=+9138! ! !

V391! =9-! 3&! 13()G(),T! ! 7-! 3&! -15;(ET! ! ")E! =3&+&! &L921'/! 39E! 3&! .&&)T! ! V3/!

GLGQ¶W KH FDOO KHU" :K\ GLGQ W KH SLFN XS WKH SKRQH ZKHQ VKH FDOOHG" :K\ ZDVQ W KH 91!3$D&T! ! ")E!=3/!E(E)S1!3&!E$!=391!-3&!39E!1$'E!3(D!1$!E$T! ! 7-!3&!E5D.T! ! V3/!E(E! 3&! =$++/! 3&+! -(2G! 9)E! D9G&! 3&+! '&9%&! =$+G! &9+'/T! ! W(E! 3&! 29+&! 3$=! D523! 1+$5.'&! 3&!

295-&E! 3&+! 9)E! 3&+! .$--! 9)E! 13&! 25-1$D&+-! 1391! 29D&! 1$! 3&9+! 3(D! ;'9/T! ! 7-! 3&! +&9''/!

WKDW VHOILVK" :KDW¶V ZURQJ ZLWK KLP" 'RHV KH KDWH KHU WKDW PXFK" 'RHV KH ZDQW KHU 1$!'$$G!'(G&!9!J$$'T! ! N+!,&1!3&+!J(+&ET! ! ")E! =3$!,9%&!3(D!1391!D$)&/T! ! V391!G()E!$J! SHUVRQ JLYHV DZD\ VR PXFK PRQH\ WR D ER\" $QG ZK\¶G WKH\ JLYH LW WR KLP DQ\ZD\" V391!E(E!3&!E$T! ! V391!E(E!13&/!E$!1$!3(DT! ! V391!39;;&)&ET! ! ")E!=3/!E$&-!3&!,(%&!

3&+!-$!D523!&D.9++9--D&)1!9)E!-39D&T! ! ")E!(J!3&!13()G-!13&+&!9+&!.&11&+!D$13&+-!$51!

WKHUH WKHQ ZK\ GRHVQ¶W KH JR ILQG WKHP" $QG ZK\ GRHV KH VPHOO OLNH FLJDUHWWHV DQG .&&+F!9)E!=3/!(-!3&!-$!E5D.F!9)E!=3$!13&!3&''!E$&-!3&!13()G!3&!(-!9)/=9/T! !

Q51!()!13(-!$)&>-(E&E!2$5+1!$I /RXLVD HYHQ 6DPXHO¶V KRQHVW DQVZHUV ULQJ KROORZ

9.-5+EF! '(G&! (''>2$)2&(%&E! J9.+(291($)-! 1391! ,+$=! ()2+&9-(),'/! ;913&1(2! 5;$)! &923!

911&D;1&E! 1&''(),8! ! X&11(),! '$-1F! N'E! Y)2'&F! 13&! D93M$),! ;9+'$+F! 13&! -1+9),&+F! 13&! .$LF! '&,'&--! Q(,! ?91F! 13&! +(E&! 3$D&F! 13&! D$)&/²)$)&! $J! (1! -$5)E-! %&+/! ;'95-(.'&F! '&1! 9'$)&!

2$)%()2(),8! ! Z%&+/13(),!3&!13&)!511&+-!3$'E-!'(11'&!%9'5&F!&-;&2(9''/!=3&)!13&!.'5..&+(),!

J921-!&)J$'E!3(-!$=)!E&2&;1($)-F!13&!%9,5&!1+513!.&2$D(),!;&+2&(%&E!9-!$)&!,+&91!'(&!1391! ,(%&-!.(+13!1$!$13&+!'(&V 1R KH KDGQ¶W VSHQW WKH GD\ UHDG\LQJ KLPVHOI IRU WKH HYHQLQJ +&2(19'!'(G&!-3&!39E!1$'E!3(DF!9)EF!)$F!3&!39E!)&%&+!39)E&E!$51!13&!J'(&+-!91!-23$$'!'(G&!

-3&! 39E! 13$5,318! ! 7)-1&9EF! 3&! 39E! ,$)&! $JJ! 1+92G! &9+'(&+! 9J1&+! -1(2G(),! 13&! J'(&+-! ()-(E&!

D9('.$L&-! 9)E! 5)E&+)&913! =()E-3(&'E! =(;&+-F! 9)E! 3&! 39E! -G91&E! J9+! J+$D! 3$D&F! ,$1!

WXUQHG DURXQG FRXOGQ¶W ILQG KLV ZD\ EDFN !"#$%&#'(%)"&*# # ! !

³$QG KRZ¶G \RX JHW WKHP" :KR JDYH WKHP WR \RX 6KXQJ>/$T! ! V391! J$+T! !

([SODLQ LW ´! !

H3&! .'$2G-! 13&! 1&'&%(-($)F! 39)E-! .5)23&E! 9,9()-1! 3&+! 3(;-F! -(,3(),! ;$)E&+$5-'/!

=3('&!9=9(1(),!13&!9)-=&+!1391!H9D5&'!E+&9E-!13&!D$-1²13&!D&9)&-1!$J!3(-!E&2&;1($)-F! 13&! .'92G&-1! '9/&+! $J! (2(),! 91$;! 9)! 9'+&9E/! E$$D>3&9;&E! 29G&8! ! Q51! 3&! 39-! )$! 23$(2&F! 9)E!)$!9'1&+)91(%&!9)-=&+!;+&-&)1-!(1-&'J!1$!'&--&)!13&!(D;921!$J!=391!(-F!5)O5&-1($)9.'/F! 3(-! =$+-1! 1+9)-,+&--($)! $J! 9'':! ! -1&9'(),! J+$D! 3(-! $=)! D$13&+8! ! ?$+! 9! 1(D&F! 3&! (-!

D$1($)'&--!=3&+&!3&!-19)E-F!-19+(),!E$=)=9+E8! ! H39E$=-!-5++$5)E!3(-!.9+&!J&&1!'(G&!9!

E9+G!-19()!$)!13&!=3(1&!-39,!29+;&18! ! <3&)!=(13!3&9%/>3&9+1&E!-)(JJ'&-F!3&!'(J1-!9)!9+DF! ;$()1(),! 9! +&'5219)1! J(),&+! 91! 13&! &)2'$-&E! E(-;'9/! 29.()&1! )&9+! 13&! <RF! /&1! 3(-! 3&9E! UHPDLQV FUHVWIDOOHQ DV KH PXPEOHV ³7UDGHG WKHP²IRU WKHP ´! !

³, GRQ¶W XQGHUVWDQG ´ VKH VD\V ORRNLQJ VXGGHQO\ FRQIXVHG DQG J'9)2&-!1$=9+E!

13&! 29.()&1F! -5+%&/(),! 13&! -3&'%&-! $J! 2+/-19'! .511&+J'(&-F! ;&),5()-F! W(-)&/! 239+921&+-F! ;&9+'>.9+(),! $/-1&+-F! 3$+-&-F! 1+9)-'52&)1! 23('E+&)F! 43+(-1D9-! 1+&&-F! J'$=&+-F! %9+($5-!

PLUWKIXO FUHDWXUHV ³:KDW DUH \RX WDONLQJ DERXW"´ 6WHSSLQJ RYHU WR!13&!29.()&1!J$+!9!

2'$-&+! ()-;&21($)F! 3&+! ,9K&! )9++$=-! $)! 13&! D(EE'&! E(-;'9/! -3&'JF! 19G(),! ()%&)1$+/F! &%&)159''/! ;&&+(),! 39+E! 91! 13&! &D;1/! -;$1-! =3&+&! 9! J92&1&E! 2'&9+>2+/-19'! .&9,'&! 9)E! +3$E(5D>;'91&E! ?$+,&1>0&>#$1! J'$=&+! ;$1! 39E! .&&)! ;'92&E8! ! H3&! -39G&-! 3&+! 3&9EF! -'$='/F!9-!(J!E5D.J$5)E&E!./!9!-&)-&!$J!.&1+9/9'F!13&)!15+)-!3&+-&'J!M5-1!9-!-'$='/!1$!9-G! LQ GLVEHOLHI ³<RX WUDGHG P\ WKLQJV" )RU WKRVH GLUW\ VNDWHV"´! !

7)29;9.'&! $J! D&&1(),! 3&+! &/&-F! H9D5&'! )$E-! ;(1(J5''/F! -)(JJ'(),! 9,9()F! 9)E! =(;&-!

3(-!+5))/!)$-&!=(13!13&!.92G-(E&!$J!9!39)E8! !

³:KR DUH \RX"´ VKH VD\V KHU KRVWLOH YRLFH IDOWHULQJ LQWR D GLVFRQFHUWHG EDIIOHG

WRQH ³<RX KDG QR ULJKW 7KH\¶UH PLQH 6KXQJ>\R ´! !

<RXµG QHYHU QRWLFH LI , GLGQµW WHOO \RX KH WKLQNV <RX ZRXOGQ¶W !

!

³*HW WKHP EDFN :KHUH DUH WKH\"´!

!

H9D5&'! +9(-&-! 3(-! 3&9EF! -5+;+(-&E! ./! 13&! 35+1! &L;+&--($)! 29-1! 5;$)! 3(DF! 3(-!

PRWKHU¶V IXUURZHG EURZ KHU DSSUHKHQVLYH VWDUH FRQYH\LQJ ORVV DQG LQFRPSUHKHQVLRQ ³3DZQVKRS ´ KH PXWWHUV WKH XQDGRUQHG VRXQG RI LW IHHOLQJ FUXHOHU WKDQ DQ/!=$+E!1391!

KDV HYHU SDVVHG KLV OLSV %XW WKLV LVQ¶W KRZ WKH QLJKW ZDV VXSSRVHG WR JR²)$1!=3&)!3&!

39E! $JJ&+&E! 3&+! 9''! $J! =391! 13&! -1+9),&+! 39E! ;9(E! 3(DF! )$1! =3&)! -3&! 39E! ;(2G&E! 13&!

D$)&/!$JJ!13&!-(E&=9'G!9J1&+!13&!.(''-!=&+&!E+$;;&E!91!3&+!J&&18! ! V(13!13&!1=$!35)E+&E! E$''9+-! K(;;&E! 5;! ()-(E&! 3&+! ;5+-&F! -3&! -3$5'E)S1! 2$D;'9()! 9.$51! 9)/13(),! 3&S-! E$)&!

1$E9/!$+!921!-$!.$13&+&E8! ! <39)G-!1$!3(DF!-3&!2$5'E!.5/!'$1-!$J!)&=!J(,5+()&-²91!'&9-1!

13+&&!1(D&-!9-!D9)/!9-!13&!1=$!3&!39E!+&D$%&E!J+$D!3&+!2$''&21($)8! !

³*LYH PH WKH UHFHLSW ´ VKH GHPDQGV WKUXVWLQJ KHU IODWWHQHG OHIW KDQG RXWZDUG

'(G&!9!.&,,9+F!-39G(),!(1!()!3(-!E(+&21($)²13&!-G()!+&E!9)E!E+/F!13&!J(),&+-!'92G(),!+(),-!

9)E!)9('!;$'(-38! !

³1R UHFHLSW ³ KH VD\V GLIILGHQWO\ DOPRVW ZKLVSHULQJ ³, WUDGHG ´!

!

<3&)! =391! $225+-! )&L1! D9G&-! H9D5&'! 2+(),&F! 3(-! .$E/! +(,$+(),! $)2&! 9! '$$G! $J!

SXUH KDWUHG EXUQV WKURXJK WKH FRQIRXQGHG H[SUHVVLRQ RQ /RXLVD¶V IDFH ³6RPHWKLQJ LV ZURQJ ZLWK \RX ´ VKH VKRXWV WKH H[WHQGHG OHIW KDQG IOLSSLQJ DURXQG DQG FUDQLQJ XS DW 3&+! -(E&²J(),&+-! +(,(EF! ;9'D! 1951²DV WKRXJK VKH ZHUH SOHGJLQJ DQ RDWK RI RIILFH ³, GRQ¶W NQRZ ZKR \RX DUH ´ 6KH UXVKHV IRUZDUG WKH KDQG VZLQJLQJ KLJK RQO\ WR ILQG 3&+-&'J!13=9+1&E!./!3(D!9,9()8! ! 09123(),!&923!$J!3&+!35++(&E!-1&;-!92+$--!13&!29+;&1F!3&! ()-19)19)&$5-'/!-'9;-!3(-!+(,31!23&&GF!3(-!'&J1!23&&GF!3(-!+(,31!23&&G²E&'(%&+&E!=(13!3(-! $=)!J'9('(),!;9'D-F!-1+(G(),!3(D-&'J!-$!39+E!1391!-)$1!(-!M$'1&E!$)1$!3(-!5;;&+!'(;!9)E!13&! =3(1&!(D;+()1-!$J!J(),&+-!D9+G!3(-!J'5-3&E!-G()8! ! #$=!(1!(-!-3&!=3$!2+(),&-!.&J$+&!3(DF! VWRSSHG GHDG LQ KHU WUDFNV DQG PRUWLILHG DW WKH VLJKW RI KLV VHOI DEXVH ³6KXQJ>/$F! VWRS ´ VKH \HOOV JUDEELQJ ERWK KLV ZULVWV ZKLOH KH VWUXJJOHV KDOIKHDUWHGO\ IRU D D$D&)1F!1$!'9)E!9)$13&+!-'9;8! !

?()9''/! H9D5&'! +&'&)1-F! -'92G&)(),! 3(-! 9+D-8! ! P&! J(L&-! 9! 3&';'&--! -19+&! $)! 13&!

%&L&E!,9K&!$J!I$5(-9F!3&+!39)E-!1(,31'/!-O5&&K(),!3(-!=+(-1-8! ! ?+$D!3(-!;&+-;&21(%&F!13&!

J'5$+&-2&)1!2&('(),!'(,31!,'$=-!=(13()!3&+!5)1(E/!39(+F!;+$E52(),!9!J9()1!39'$!9.$%&!13&!

ZLVS\ IULQJHV ³0D ´ KH VD\V UDJJHGO\ IHHOLQJ WK&!)&&E!1$!2+/!9,9()!/&1!)$!'$),&+!9.'&!

1$!;+$E52&!9!-(),'&!1&9+²13&!=&''!$J!3(-!-$++$=!19;;&E!E+/F!.9++&)F!&)2+5-1&E!./!J91(,5&8! !

")E! '(G&! 1=$! 2$D;&1(),! +9D-! 1391! 39%&! '$2G&E! 3$+)-! =(13$51! &(13&+! ,9()(),! 9!

2'&9+!%(21$+/F!9!;9';9.'&!-&)-&!$J!D5159'!&L395-1($)!E&-2&)E-!5;$)!13&D8! ! "!;+$'$),&E! .+&913! .'$=-! J+$D! I$5(-9F! 9)E! -39G(),! 3&+! 3&9EF! 3&+! %$(2&! '$=! .51! E&J(9)1F! -3&! -9/-F! ! ³<RX WKLQN \RX¶UH JURZQ XS GRQµW \RX" <RX WKLQN \RXU ZLQJV DUH KDUGHQHG KXK" <RXU IDWKHU KDV QR LGHD \RX¶YH EHFRPH DQ ROG RLO VWULS H[FHSW KH ZLOO DQG \RXµOO VHH ZKDW KDSSHQV ´ 6KH UHOHDVHV KLV ZULVWV DQG KLV DUPV GURS OLNH OHDG EDOORRQV ³<RX JR VKRZHU DQG \RX JR WR EHG 1R GLQQHU IRU \RX *R RQ <RXU IDFH VLFNHQV PH ´! !

NJ!9''!13&!;9+1(),!()-5'1-!1391!I$5(-9!2$5'E!39%&!23$-&)!$)!-523!9!)(,31F!H9D5&'!

(-)S1!O5(1&!-5+&!=3/!9)!$'E!$('!-1+(;!-3$5'E!.&!3&+!5'1(D91&!M5E,D&)1!9,9()-1!3(D8! ! P&!

15+)-! E&M&21&E'/! 9)E! -)(JJ'&-! $51! $J! 13&! '(%(),! +$$DF! 9)L($5-'/! E&;9+1(),! 3&+! ,'$=&+(),! ;+$L(D(1/! /&1! E$(),! -$! ()! 9! -35JJ'(),F! '9),5(E! D9))&+8! ! H1(''F! 13&! +&D9+G! $225;(&-! 3(-!

D()E! '(G&! 9! ;5KK'&8! ! <3&! $)'/! $('! -1+(;! G)$=)! 1$! 3(D! (-! 9! 19-1/! .+&9GJ9-1! J$$EF! 9!

E&&;>J+(&E! .+&9E! -1(2G! &)M$/&E! 13+$5,3$51! 3(-! 23('E3$$EF! '(,31'/! -9'1&EF! &91&)! 9-! 9)!

922$D;9)(D&)1!J$+!+(2&!2$),&&!$+!-$/!D('G8! ! ")!$'E!$('!-1+(;F!3$=&%&+F!(-!-$D&13(),!&'-&!

9'1$,&13&+:! ! -19'&F!2$'EF!5-&'&--F!9!J9%$+(1&!1+&91!,$)&!.9E!9)E!)$!,$$E!J$+!9)/$)&8! ! <391!

(-!3$=!-3&!=(''!9'=9/-!%(&=!3(D[!1391!(-F!3&!2$)2'5E&-F!3(-!'9-1(),!J91&8! ! V3('&!29++/(),!

13(-!5)=9)1&E!)$1($)!$J!3(D-&'J!;9-1!13&!.913+$$D!E$$+=9/²1$!13&!1$('&1!-&91F!13&)!1$!

13&! -()GF! 13&)! .&3()E! 13&! -3$=&+! 25+19()²9! E&;+&--(),F! =$+13'&--! -&)-91($)! &)=+9;-!

KLP SXOVLQJ DW HYHU\ PROHFXOH DQG HYHQ WKH VWUHDPLQJ KRW ZDWHU DQG VRDS\ ODWKHU FDQ¶W =9-3!13&!5)E&+'/(),!J&&'(),!9=9/8! ! 71!-&&D-!9-!(J!3(-!D$13&+!39E!=9%&E!9!D9,(2!=9)EF! 9'1&+(),!3(D!2$D;'&1&'/8! ! 7)!13&!.'()G!$J!9)!&/&F!3&!=9-!1+9)-J$+D&E!J+$D!9)!$.&E(&)1!

-$)!.$5)E!./!3&+!&L921(),!2$DD9)E-!1$!-$D&13(),!+$11&)!1391!-3$5'E!.&!1$--&E!9D$),!

13&!=&&G'/!1+9-38! !

#&%&+13&'&--F! 9! 2$5)1&+! )$WLRQ SUHVHQWO\ HQWHUV 6DPXHO¶V PLQG DQ DFXWH GHVLUH

)$1!5)'(G&!3(-!(DD&9-5+9.'&!=(-3!J$+!13&!;+$;&+!+$51&!3$D&²&L2&;1!=3$''/!E(JJ&+&)1!()!

(1-! 1+9M&21$+/F! '(G&! 9! )&,91(%&! (D9,&! +&%&+-(),! '(,31! 9)E! E9+G8! ! ")/=3&+&! .51! 3&+&F! (1!

-5,,&-1-8! ! ")/=3&+&! .51! 13(-! 3$5-&8! ! ")/$)&! .51! 3&+8! ! X+9.! 13&! -G91&-! '91&+! 1$)(,31F! +5)9=9/F!E(-9;;&9+!J$+&%&+8! !

P$=! -1+9),&F! 13&)F! 1$! -5EE&)'/! D(--! .&(),! '$-1F! 1$! +&9'(K&! 1391F! =3&)! +$9D(),!

9-1+9/!$)!13&!2(1/!-1+&&1-F!3&!)&%&+!J&'1!9-!=+&123&E!9)E!E&-;(-&E!9-!3&!E$&-!+(,31!)$=8! ! <3&)! 1$=&'(),! 3(D-&'J! E+/F! 3&! 1+(&-! (D9,()(),! 13&! ;+&2(-&! '$291($)-! $J! 13$-&! -(),5'9+! &-19.'(-3D&)1-²13&! D&+29E$F! 13&! D93M$),! ;9+'$+F! #()&! H;+(),-! X+$11$²3$;(),!

VRPHKRZ WKDW D PDS PLJKW EH GLYLQHG LQ KLV KHDG GLUHFWLQJ KLP EDFN ³:KHUH DUH WKHVH SODFHV"´ /R5(-9! 39E! E&D9)E&EF! J+5-1+91&E! ./! 3(-! ()9.('(1/! 1$! $JJ&+! -;&2(J(2-8! ! ³7HOO PH H[DFWO\ ´ %XW DW WKLV PRPHQW MXVW OLNH HDUOLHU ZLWK KLV PRWKHU DQ HQGOHVV D9K&! $J! 2+/;1(2! -1+&&1-F! 9''&/-F! 9)E! .5('E(),-! 5)J$'E-! 9)E! -1+&123&-! $51=9+E! ()1$! 9!

2$9'>.'92G! %$(E²9-! ()J()(1&F! D/-1&+($5-F! 9)E! J9+>UHDFKLQJ DV WKH XQLYHUVH LWVHOI +H¶G ;+$.9.'/! 39%&! .&11&+! '52G! 9(D(),! 9! J(),&+! 91! 13&! 3&9%&)-F! +9)E$D'/! ;(2G(),! $51! -19+-F! VD\LQJ ³8S WKHUH 0D 7KRVH DUH WKH SODFHV²13&+&F!9)E!13&+&²DQG WKHUH ´! !

"J1&+!;911(),!13&!1$=&'!5;$)!3(-!23&-1F!9!-'(,31!35),&+!;9),!-=(D-!9+$5)E!=(13()!

3(DF! -5+J92(),! .&-(E&! 13&! .&''/.511$)! '(G&! 9! -&9! 2+&915+&! =+(13(),! J+$D! 13&! E&;13-F!

2+(--2+$--(),! 13&! -1$D923! 1=(2&! .&J$+&! -5.D&+,(),! .&'$=! 9! '$=&+! +(.8! ! 7J! 13&! -1&9D/!

VKRZHU KDGQ¶W DFFHOHUDWHG KLV D.-$'51&! 1(+&E)&--F! (1-! J'&&1(),! E(-2$DJ$+1! D(,31! 29;15+&!

3(-! 911&)1($)8! ! ZL2&;1! 3(-! 13$5,31-! 9+&! ;+&$225;(&EF! 9)EF! 1$$F! 3(-! .$E/! 923&-! =$+-&! &'-&=3&+&[!3(-!J&&1F!9)G'&-F!9)E!29'%&-!13+$.!-39+;'/F!9-!13$5,3!13&!-1+&9D-!$J!3$1!=91&+!

39E! ()J'9D&E! 13&D8! ! P&! E+9;&-! 13&! 1$=&'! $)! 9! +92G! )&9+! 13&! %9)(1/F! -2$$;-! 13&! )/'$)!

-1+(),!9)E!3(-!5)E&+=&9+!$JJ!13&!J'$$+F!13&)!2+&&;-!)9G&E!()1$!13&!5)'(1!39''=9/F!D$%(),!

VWHDOWKLO\ ZKLOH SUD\LQJ KLV PRWKHU ZRQ¶W VXPPRQ KLP 7KH 79 LV RQ JORZLQJ EHKLQG 3(D! 9)E! 13+$=(),! (1-! J'(2G&+(),! '(,31! $%&+! 13&! '(%(),! +$$D! 13+&-3$'E8! ! P&! 3$..'&-!

J$+=9+EF!3&9+(),!13&!(D;9--($)&E!E(9'$,5&!$J!9!\9;9)&-&!D&'$E+9D9F!9!J&+%&)1!E$D&-1(2!

9+,5D&)1! =&''! 5)E&+=9/F! 13&! 5);'&9-9)1! -$5)E-! $J! -$D&$)&! &'-&! .&(),! -39D&E! ./! 9!

E(-9;;$()1&E!J9D('/!D&D.&+8! !

Q51!$)2&!-9J&'/! ()-(E&! 3(-!.&E+$$D²13&!E$$+!&9-&E! -351F!13&!)/'$)!-1+(),!35),!

$)!13&!G)$.²H9D5&'!(-!92159''/!+&'(&%&E!1$!.&!3$D&F!$+!91!'&9-1!,'9E!1$!.&!+&5)(1&E!=(13!

3(-! D$-1! %9'5&E! .&'$),(),-8! ! <3&! 0(2G&/! 0$5-&! 29;8! ! <3&! W(-)&/'9)E! ;$-1&+-8! ! <3&!

W$+9&D$)! ;&))/! .9)G8! ! <3&! 2$'$+&E! ;&)-F! 2+9/$)-F! 9)E! ;&)2('-8! ! "! '$),! ;&+($EF! (1!

J&&'-F!39-!;9--&E!-()2&!3&!39E!'9-1!-1$$E!13&+&F!9)E!&%&+/13(),!'$$G-!.$13!()1(D91&!9)E! +&D$1&²'(G&! ;&+-$)9'! $.M&21-! J+$D! /&9+-! 9,$! ;+&-&+%&E! ()! 9! 1(D&! 29;-5'&F! ;+&%($5-'/!

(D;$+19)1! 13(),-! 1391! =&+&! $51,+$=)! /&1! -1(''! ;$--&--! D&9)(),8! ! ?(,31(),! 1$! 3$'E! 3(-! &/&-!$;&)F!3&!E+9,-!3(D-&'J!1$=9+E!13&!.&EF!J'(),(),!3(-!5)E&+=&9+!$)!1$;!$J!9!'95)E+/! ;('&! 9'$),! 13&! =9/F! 9)E! $)'/! 13&)F! +(,31! .&J$+&! -'(;;(),! .&1=&&)! 13&! -3&&1-F! E$&-! 3&! +&9'(K&! -$D&13(),! 2$DD$);'92&! (-! D(--(),²-$D&13(),! 1391F! '(G&! 2'$2G=$+GF! 9'D$-1! )&%&+! J9('-! 1$! .$13&+! 3(D! ()! 13&! D$+)(),-F! 9J1&+)$$)-F! 9)E! )(,31-:! ! 13&! D$5-&!

J+9)1(29''/!-2+9123(),!91!13&!29,&F!(D;'$+(),!3(D!J$+!J$$E8! !

#$=!9)!$D()$5-!-('&)2&!J(''-!13&!+$$DF!.9)(-3(),!13&!E5''&E!D$E5'91($)-!$J!13&!

<R8! ! 4'(D.(),! E$=)! J+$D! 13&! .&EF! H9D5&'! 2+9='-! 1$! 13&! 29,&F! 9)E! ;&&+-! 13+$5,3! 13&! =(+&>13()!.9+-F!-;$11(),!13&!D$5-&!25+'&E!()!9!2$+)&+F!9!.'92G>9)E>=3(1&!2'5D;!)&-1'&E! DPLGVW VKUHGGHG QHZVSDSHU ³0RXVH ´ +H QXGJHV WKH FDJH ! ³+H\ PRXVH ´ $QG =3&)! (1! D$%&-F! E9+G! &/&-! ;&&G(),! 9.$%&! 13&! )&=-;9;&+! -2+9;-F! 9! +&E&D;1(%&! -(,3! &-29;&-! 3(D8! ! P&! ,+9.-! 13&! .$L! $J! J$$E! ;&''&1-! .&-(E&! 13&! 29,&F! -39G(),! 9! '9+,&+! 139)! )$+D9'! ;$+1($)! ()1$! 9! ;9'DF! 13&! )$(-&! $J! =3(23! -1(+-! 13&! D$5-&! 9-! 13$5,3! (1! =&+&!

SURGGHG E\ HOHFWULFLW\ ³+HUH ´ KH VD\V XQIDVWHQLQJ WKH PHVKHG HQWUDQFH +H GXPSV 13&! J&&E! ()-(E&F! =9123(),! 9-! 13&! D$5-&! -29D;&+-! J$+! 13&! ;&''&1-F! (1-! )$-&! -)(JJ(),! 9)E!

WZLWFKLQJ ³'RQ¶W KDWH PH ´ KH ZKLVSHUV ZLWKGUDZLQJ KLV KDQG DQG FORV&-!13&!29,&8! ! ³,¶P VRUU\ ´! !

P&! +&15+)-! 1$! 13&! .&EF! 2+9='(),F! ;5''(),! 3(D-&'J! 5;$)! 13&! D911+&--8! ! P(-! 923/F!

=&9+/!.$E/!-;+&9E-!.&)&913!13&!-3&&1-!'(G&!9!;5EE'&8! ! H()G(),!3(-!3&9E!()1$!13&!;(''$=F! 3&!-19+&-!13$5,31'&--'/!91!13&!$%&+3&9E!2&('(),!J(L15+&F!13&!-;&21+9'!-39;&-!$J!E&9E!.5,-!

E$11(),! 13&! J+$-1&E! ,'9--8! ! H$$)! 3(-! &/&'(E-! -9,! 9)EF! ,&)1'/F! 2+&9-&! 1$,&13&+! =3('&! 13&!

E&%$5+(),! $J! ;&''&1-! 2+5)23&-! 9.$51! 3(-! D()E²13&! '9-1! E(-2&+)9.'&! -$5)E! .&J$+&! 3(-!

2$)-2($5-)&--!J'511&+-!'(G&!9!J'9D&!9)EF!=(13!9!-(),'&!()95E(.'&!;5JJF!.5+)-!$518! ! <3&)F! J$+!9!1(D&F!)$13(),!29)!.+&923!3(-!9;;9+&)1'/!'(D(1'&--!-'&&;8! ! #$!E+&9D-F!)$!-3(J1(),!$J! 3(-!-$+&!'(D.-F!)$!E&'(2($5-!$E$+-!-(KK'(),!J+$D!13&!G(123&)8! !

#$+! =(''! H9D5&'! 3&9+! 3(-! D$13&+! 9-! -3&! ;5-3&-! 13&! E$$+! 9M9+! 1$! 2'(2G! $JJ! 13&!

.&E+$$D!'(,318! ! Q51!-3&!=(''!3&9+!3(D²9!J(),&+!'$(1&+(),!91!13&!-=(123F!3&+!E+$=-/!,9K&!

2$)1&D;'91(),! 3(D8! ! "! -$)$+$5-F! +&;&1(1(%&! -)$+(),! ;5++-! J+$D! 13&! .&EF! %(.+91(),! 13&!

9(+8! ! #&%&+!()!3(-!=3$'&!'(J&F!-3&!+&2$,)(K&-F!39-!-3&!3&9+E!3(D!-)$+&!O5(1&!13(-!'$5EF!13&!

-3&&+! %$'5D&! +(%9'(),! 13&! 3$9+-&! )$215+)9'! &L39'91($)-! $J! 3&+! 35-.9)E8! ! I&9)(),!

9,9()-1!13&!E$$+=9/F!-3&!)$=!J()E-!3&+-&'J!391(),!3$=!;&$;'&!239),&!=(13$51!=9+)(),F! 3$=! 13&/! J(+-1! 9;;&9+! 9-! $)&! G()E! 9)EF! 5)J$+15)91&'/F! .&2$D&! 9)$13&+²'(G&! 1391!

ODPHQWDEOH PRPHQW ZKHQ WKH VZHHW IODYRU RI PLON RQ D FKLOG¶V EUHDWK EHJLQV WR DOZD\V -D&''!-$5+F!$+!=3&)!13&!$)2&!J9(13J5'!9+E$+!$J!9!D9++(&E!D9)!-19+1-!;5+-5(),!2'9)E&-1()&!

J5'J(''D&)1! .&/$)E! 13&! 3$D&8! ! ")E! J'(2G(),! 13&! -=(123F! 13&! -5EE&)! E9+G)&--! $J! 3(-! .&E+$$D!-&&D-!1$!+&923!$51!J$+!3&+F!-$!-3&!O5(2G'/!&9-&-!13&!E$$+!-351F!+&1+&91(),!9'$),!

13&!39''=9/!9-!(J!.&(),!239-&E!./!9!,3$-18! !

"!J&=!3$5+-!'91&+F!13$5,3F!13&!.&E+$$D!E$$+!-=(),-!=(E&!9,9()8! ! <3&!$%&+3&9E!

'(,31!2'(2G-!$)F!-3()(),!.+(,31'/!=3&+&!H9PXHO VWLOO VQRUHV KLV OLSV SDUWHG ³6KXQJ>\R ´ /RXLVD VD\V LPSDWLHQWO\ ³JHW XS ´ :HDULQJ KHU ZKLWH FRWWRQ QLJKWVKLUW H\HOLGV SXII\ DQG KDLU WXVVOHG IURP VOHHS VKH FRPHV WR VWDQG DW WKH IRRW RI WKH EHG ³6KXQJ>\R LW¶V \RXU IDWKHU +HµV ZDLWLQJ IRU \RX ´ 6KH MRVWOHV WKH PDWWUHVV TXDNLQJ KLP 7KH -)$+(),! +&2&E&-! ()1$! 13&! .92G! $J! 3(-! 13+$91F! J9E(),! 9=9/8! ! H3(J1(),! 9=9G&F! 3&! '(J1-! 3(-!

KHDG D ELW VTXLQWLQJ DQG ORRNV ERWK VWDUWOHG DQG GLVRULHQWHG ³6KXQJ>/$F!/$5+!J913&+!

LV ZDLWLQJ +XUU\ ´! !

P&! -(1-! 5;F! ()%$'5)19+('/! &L(1(),! 3(-! E+&9D'&--! -'5D.&+F! .'()G(),! =(13!

EHIXGGOHPHQW DV KLV PRWKHU OHDYHV WKH EHGURRP ³PXUU\ ´ VKH FDOOV LQ WKH KDOOZD\

"J1&+!-2$$1(),!3(D-&'J!$51!$J!13&!-3&&1-F!3&!J(-3&-!9!;9(+!$J!'(D&>,+&&)!-=(DD(),!1+5)G-!

J+$D! 13&! '95)E+/! ;('&F! ;5''(),! 13&D! $)! =(13! &/&-! .9+&'/! $;&)F! 9)EF! =3('&! E$(),! -$F! 3&!

DOPRVW VWXPEOHV EDFNZDUGV WR WKH EHG OLNH D GUXQNDUG ³6KXQJ>\R KXUU\ ´ VKH EDUNV LQ WKH OLYLQJ URRP ³'RQ¶W PDNH \RXU IDWKHU ZDLW ´! !

<3&)! '(G&! 9! -'&&;=9'G&+F! 3&! ;9E-! -'5,,(-3'/! E$=)! 13&! 39''=9/F! 39'J! &L;&21(),! 1$!

E(-2$%&+! 3(-! J913&+! +&2'()(),! 91! 9)! &)E! $J! 13&! 2$523F! '&,-! 2+$--&EF! -D$G(),! 9! 2(,9+&11&8! !

Q51! =3&)! &)1&+(),! 13&! '(%(),! +$$DF! 3&! -&&-! $)'/! 3(-! D$13&+! -19)E(),! 13&+&F! 13&!

WHOHSKRQH KDQGVHW SUHVVHG DJDLQVW KHU IDFH ³+HUH KH LV ´ VKH DQQRXQFHV JUDYHO\ DQG 13+5-1-!13&!39)E-&1!1$=9+E!3(D8! !

"22&;1(),! 13&! ;3$)&F! 3&! 3&-(191&-! 9! D$D&)1! .&J$+&! -;&9G(),! ()1$! 13&! +&2&(%&+F!

VKHHSLVKO\ PXWWHULQJ ³+HOOR ´! !

³6KXQJ>\R ´ KH KHDUV KLV IDWKHU UHVSRQG VRIWO\ WKH LQQDWH ZDUPWK RI &KXQ>WH¶-!

%$(2&!E(D()(-3(),!13&!$;;+&--(%&!91D$-;3&+&!1391!39E!.&,5)!1$!;&+D&91&!&%&+/!()23!$J! WKH KRXVH ³6KXQJ>\R ´ KLV QDPH LV UHSHDWHG WKLV WLPH D WRQH RI GLVDSSRLQWPHQW +&,(-1&+(),8! !

³0P ´ KH DQVZHUV QRGGLQJ !

!

")E! =(13! I$5(-9! '$$D(),! )&9+./²9+D-! J$'E&E! .&'$=! 3&+! .+&9-1-F! 13&! -9D&!

J5+($5-! &L;+&--($)! J(L&E! 5;$)! 3(D! 1391! -3&! 39-! =$+)! 9''! )(,31²9)/! $%&+1! -(,)! $J! LQDWWHQWLYHQHVV RQ KLV SDUW ZRQ¶W JR XQQRWLFHG DQG VR GHVSLWH KLV GR]\ VWDWH 6DPXHO J$+2&-!3(D-&'J!1$!'(-1&)!()1&)1'/F!9)1(2(;91(),!13$-&!E&'(.&+91&!;95-&-!()!=3(23!'(11'&!D$+&!

(-! +&O5(+&E! J+$D! 3(D! 139)! D&9,&+! 9JJ(+D91($)-8! ! Q51! (J! 3(-! D$13&+! 2$)1()59''/! 35+'-! ,+&)9E&>OLNH TXHVWLRQV WKDW GRQ¶W DOORZ PXFK URRP IRU PHDQLQJIXO DQVZHUV KLV IDWKHU¶V 9;;+$923!(-!J9+!'&--!()M5+($5-:! ! 9!-&+(&-!$J!2$)2(-&F!+913&+!.+$9E!-191&D&)1-!-;$G&)!'(G&! ,+&91!1+513-F!29'D'/!9)E!&9+)&-1'/F!+9+&'/!J+9D&E!9-!O5&-1($)-!$+!=9++9)1(),!9)-=&+-!()!

UHSO\ 'RQ¶W FDXVH SUREOHPV %HKDYH OLNH D PDQ 'R ZKDW \RXU PRWKHU DVNV %H ,$$E8! ! W$! ,$$E8! ! <9G&! 29+&! $J! /$5+-&'J8! ! H15E/! 39+E8! ! V$+G! 39+E8! ! Q&! =&9'13/!

-$D&E9/8! ! 09G&!/$5+!;9+&)1-!39;;/8! !

I(G&! 13&! 29123/! +&J+9()! $J! 9! E91&E! ;$;! -$),! 1391! -1(2G-! 9))$/(),'/! ()! 13&! D()E!

=3&)&%&+! (1-! ;'9/&EF! 435)>WHµV FXVWRPDU\ UHPDUNV IORZ WKURXJK WKH SKRQH ³0P ´ H9D5&'! -9/-F! -(),(),! 39+D$)/! E5+()J WKH DSSURSULDWH EUHDNV ³0P ´ <HW DV KLV H\HOLGV ODJ DQG WKHQ VSULQJ EDFN ZLWK ORQJHU LQFUHDVLQJO\ OHWKDUJLF LQWHUYDOV LW LVQ¶W E(JJ(25'1!&)%(-($)(),!3(-!J913&+!13&+&8! ! H&91&E!E(+&21'/!()!J+$)1!$J!3(DF!&'.$=-!+&-1(),!$)!

13&!G)&&-!$J!9!E9+G!.5-()&--!-5(1F!435)>1&!'&9)-!J$+=9+E!9-!13$5,3!1$!(D;9+1!9!-&2+&1²9! .'5&>,+&&)! )&2G1(&! 2'&9%(),! 13&! '&),13! $J! 9! =3(1&! E+&--! -3(+1F! (1-! 2$'$+(),! '(G&! ;'92(E! 1+$;(29'! =91&+8! ! W&-;(1&! 9! 3&21(2! =$+G! -23&E5'&F! 3(-! J913&+! 9'=9/-! ;+&-&)1-! 9! =&''>,+$$D&E! 9;;&9+9)2&²3(-! -3$+1F! 13())(),! 39(+! ;&+J&21'/! 2$D.&E! 1$! $)&! -(E&F! 3(-!

2'$13&-!J()&'/!19('$+&E! 9)E!5)=+()G'&E²9)E! +&,9+E'&--!$J!13&!-(1591($)F!9!'(,31>3&9+1&E! ,+()! (-! 5-59''/! 91! 13&! +&9E/8! ! ZL2&;1! )$=! 3(-! J913&+! J+$=)-! =(13! 2$)2&+)F! 9)E! 9J1&+! &L39'(),! 9! J+&1J5'! .+&913F! 9)! 5)&L;&21&E! O5&-1($)! (-! J()9''/! -'(;;&E! 9D$),! 13&! +&,5'9+! ;'91(15E&-8! !

³6KXQJ>/$F! 13&-&! D&)! =3$! ,9%&! /$5! E+()G-! 9)E! 1391! D$)&/²E(E! 13&/! E$!

DQ\WKLQJ WR \RX"´! !

³1R ´!

!

³1R VRUW RI WRXFKLQJ \RX DQ\ZKHUH LQ D EDG ZD\"´!

!

³1R ´!

!

³, VHH , VHH *RRG <RXU PRWKHU LV! %&+/! =$++(&E8! ! Q51! 7! 1$'E! 3&+! 9'+&9E/! /$5!

ZRQ¶W OHW VRPHRQH GR WKDW WR \RX <RX NQRZ EHWWHU DQG \RXµG WHOO KHU RU PH LI VRPHRQH WULHG WKDW ´! !

³0P ´ 6DPXHO VD\V VWUXJJOLQJ WR VWD\ DZDNH !

!

³*RRG ´ 7KH FRQFHUQHG ORRN KLV IDWKHU H[SUHVVHV FDQ¶W TXLWH PDVG! 13&! ,+91&J5'!

VPLOH IRUPLQJ EHQHDWK LW ³6R QR PRUH WDNLQJ WKLQJV WKDW DUHQ W \RXUV DQG GRQ W JR +5))(),! $JJ! 9,9()! '(G&! 13918! ! "D&+(29! 29)! .&! 9! E9),&+$5-! ;'92&8! ! *&$;'&! 9+&! E(JJ&+&)1!

13&+&F!-$D&1(D&-!9!'(11'&!2+9K/8! ! H$!/$5!39%&!1$!'(-1&)!1$!3&+F!9)E!.&39%&!/$5+-&'JF!9)E!.&!

FDUHIXO 'R ZKDW VKH VD\V ,W¶OO PDNH \RXU OLIH HDVLHU DQG LW¶OO PDNH P\ OLIH HDVLHU , NQRZ \RX XQGHUVWDQG ZKDW , PHDQ ´! !

³0P ´!

!

³<RX MXVW KDYH WR EH VPDUW 'RQ¶W XSVHW KHU DQ\PRUH 6KH¶V WDNLQJ FDUH RI \RX

DQG VKHµV ZRUNLQJ K9+E! 9''! 13&! 1(D&8! ! ")E! /$5! D5-1! =$+G! 39+E! 9''! 13&! 1(D&F! 1$$F! 9)E! PDNH PH DQG \RXU PRWKHU SURXG <RX GR WKH ULJKW WKLQJ VRPHGD\ \RX¶OO KDYH ORWV RI D$)&/!$J!/$5+!$=)8! ! U$5!29)!.&!+(23!(J!/$5!=$+G!39+E!&)$5,3!9)E!-&1!/$5+!D()E!1$!(1F! WKHQ \RX ZRQµW FDUH DERXW DQ\RQH HOVHµV PRQH\ EXW \RXUV ´! !

³0P ´!

!

³<RX XQGHUVWDQG PH ´!

!

³0P ´!

!

³*RRG JRRG 7RPRUURZ \RX VWXG\ KDUG IRU PH DW VFKRRO 0DNH XV SURXG

$OZD\V GR WKH ULJKW WKLQJ %H D PDQ ,WµV LPSRUWDQW ´ $Q DIIHFWLRQDWH ZLQN IODVKHV DW 435)>WHµV ULJKW H\H ! 9)E! 13&)F! M5-1! 9-! -=(J1'/! 9-! 1391! ()-19)19)&$5-! =()GF! 3(-! J913&+! %9)(-3&-! &)1(+&'/F! '&9%(),! .&3()E! 9! E(-19)1! %$(2&! 1391! (-! +&E52&E! 1$! 9! 1())/! 1$)&F! 13&!

-191(2>WLQJHG ZRUGV FUDFNOLQJ IURP WKH KDQGVHW OLNH D G\LQJ WUDQVPLVVLRQ ³6KXQJ>/$F! '&1!D&!19'G!1$!/$XU PRWKHU 3XW KHU EDFN RQ WKH SKRQH ´! !

P&! ,'9)2&-! 5;! 91! I$5(-9F! ;+$JJ&+(),! 13&! 39)E-&1F! .51! 3&+! D9'&%$'&)1! -19+&!

2$)O5&+-!3(-!%929)1!,9K&F!.5+)(),!-1+9(,31!()-(E&!3(DF!9))(3('91(),!13&!-D9''!9D$5)1!$J! J+9,('&! ;&92&! 1391! 3(-! J913&+! 39E! .&-1$=&E! 5;$)! 13&! 3RXVH ³*R WR EHG ´ VKH VD\V -)9123(),!13&!39)E-&18! ! !

")E!=(13!1391F!H9D5&'!'$=&+-!3(-!3&9EF!9.$51>J92(),F!1+5E,(),!$%&+!13&!29+;&1!'(G&!

9!E$,! -3$$&E!$51-(E&! =3&)!295,31!;('J&+(),! E())&+!-2+9;-!$JJ!13&!19.'&8! ! <$523&E! ()! 9! .9E!=9/F!3&!13&)!J()E-!3(D-&'J!13()G(),!=3('&!=9)E&+(),!13&!39''=9/F!()29;9.'&!91!13(-!

D$D&)1!$J!E(-2&+)(),!13&!5)-;$G&)!(D;'(291($)-8! ! P(-!&/&'(E-!)$=!2'$-&!9-!3&!239+1-!9! .'()E! 2$5+-&! J$+! 13&! .&E+$$DF! J(),&+1(;-! J&&'(),! 9+$5)E! 3(-! J92&! 9)E! .+5-3(),! 13$-&!

1&)E&+!;'92&-!=3&+&!3(-!D$13&+¶V KDQGV KDG VWUXFN KLP 1RERG\ HOVH H[FHSW KHU KDG 92159''/!1$523&E!3(D!()!9!.9E!=9/!1$)(,318! ! H3&S-!13&!$)'/!$)&!295-(),!;+$.'&D-8! ! H3&S-!

EHFRPH URWWHQ DQ ROG RLO VWLFN WKDW¶V ZKDW KH ZLVKHV KH KDG WROG KLV IDWKHU²WKDW¶V ZKDW +&9''/!)&&E&E!1$!.&!-9(E8! !

H$$)F! 3$=&%&+F! &%&)! 13&! .(11&+&-1! $J! 3(-! 13$5,31-! 9+&! -2911&+&E! &'-&=3&+&F! '(G&!

=(13&+&E! '&9%&-! .'$=)! 92+$--! /9+E-8! ! P&! E+$;-! 1$! 13&! D911+&--F! =+9;;(),! 3(D-&'J! 9)E! 13&!'(D&>,+&&)!-=(DD(),!1+5)G-!()!13&!-3&&1-8! ! P(-!)$-&!9)E!D$513!2+5-3!13&!;(''$=F! 3(-! 25+%&E! .$E/! ;+$D;1'/! ,$(),! '(D;8! ! V(13! '&,-! 9)E! 9+D-! .&)1F! E+9=)! 1$=9+E! 3(-!

23&-1F! 9! ;'&9-9)1F! +&9--5+(),! J9)2/! -'()G-! J$+13F! &)1&+19()(),! 3(D! 5)1('! 3(-! D()E! -351-!

E$=)8! ! <&&1&+(),!$)!13&!;+&2(;(2&!$J!%9-1!-'&&;F!13&!.&E!-3&&1!2$%&+(),!3(-!-G()!(-!)$=!

13&! VWUDQJHU¶V VKLUW SUHVVLQJ DJDLQVW KLP 7KH VWHDG\ EUHDWKLQJ KH IHHOV LVQ¶W KLV RZQ .51F!()-1&9EF!1391!$J!3(-!.&,5('(),!.(,!.+$13&+8! !

³<RX DQG , ´ WKH VWUDQJHU ZKLVSHUV IURP EH\RQG ³ZH DUHQ¶W VR YHU\ GLIIHUHQW ´!

!

³0P ´ 6DPXHO PXPEOHV LQWR WKH SLOORZ ! ³QRW VR YHU\ GLIIHUHQW DW DOO ´!

!

<3&)! 13&! D$D&)1-! 9)E! E&19('-! $J! 13&! E9/! .&,()! .+&9G(),! 9;9+1F! E(-;&+-(),! '(G&!

-3+9;)&'! .'$=)! ()1$! 13&! )(,318! ! ")E! =391! +&D9()-! (-! $)'/! 13&! -39;&! $J! 13&! -1+9),&+S-!

25+($5-! .9'-9! =$$E! .$LF! J'$91(),! 3(,3! 9.$%&! 3(-! .&E! =3('&! &D9)91(),! 9! .+(,31F! ,$'E&)!

'(,31!J+$D!=(13()8! ! <3&+&!()!13&! E9+G)&--F!13&+&!9D$),!13&! 2$)19()&E!'5D()&-2&)2&!$J! WKH ER[ D SURSXOVLYH KHDUW EHDWV GRZQ DW KLP DV KH VOHHSV %XW LW LVQ¶W WKH LQHIIHFWXDO ODQJXDJH RI D ER\¶V KHDUW WKDW SXOVDWHV WR HYHU\ FRUQHU! $J! 13&! +$$D²)$1! 13&! ;5D;(),!

2$)1+921($)-! $J! 9)/! 23('E! $+! J9+D! 9)(D9'[! (1! (-F! +913&+F! 13&! 2$D;'(291&E! +3/13D! $J! 9)!

9E5'1! 3&9+1! D9G(),! (1-&'J! G)$=)F! 9-! 13$5,3! &)29-&E! ()! 9D.&+! 9)E! ;+&-&+%&E! J$+! 3(D! 9'$)&! 13+$5,3! 1(D&².&91(),F! &L;9)E(),F! 2(+25'91(),! .'$$EF! 9)E! ,'$=(),! =(13! 9! %(.+9)1! &)&+,/!1391!=(''!&%&)159''/!.&!3(-!1$!;$--&--F!3(-!1$!51('(K&F!9)E!3(-!1$!;+$J$5)E'/!J&&'!9)E! E&J()&!9-!3(-!%&+/!$=)!-$D&E9/8! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! @A]C! !

7KH QH[W PRUQLQJ WKH VRUHQHVV RI 6DPXHO¶V OHJV FUDFN KLV H\HV RSHQ DV WKRXJK WKH DFKHV 39E!.&&)!-&1!$)!9!1(D&+!1$!=9G&!3(D!5;!J$+!-23$$'8! ! P&!2+(),&-!=3&)!+9(-(),!3(-!3&9E! $JJ! 13&! ;(''$=F! -1(++(),! ()1$! 9! =$+'E! -&&D(),'/! E&%$(E! $J! -$5)E8! ! <3&! .(+GV DUHQ¶W WZLWWHULQJ RXWVLGH WKH ZLQGRZV &DUV GRQ¶W ]RRP DORQJ WKH VWUHHW PRWRUV JQDUOLQJ 7KH PRXVH KDVQ¶W EHJXQ FODZLQJ DW WKH FDJH 7KHQ WKH VLOHQFH UHVWV LWV IXOO ZHLJKW XSRQ 3(DF!13&!.&E+$$DF!13&!&)1(+&!3$5-&F!'(G&!9)!9)%('!2+5-3(),!;9;&+²9!-(),5'9+!9)%('!D9E&! $J! J'&-3! 9)E! .$)&F! &L3(.(1(),! 9! 35D9)! -39;&8! ! H3&! D5-1! .&! 3&+&F! 3&! 13()G-! =3('&!

FOLPELQJ SDLQIXOO\ IURP EHG 6KH KDVQ¶W JRQH WR ZRUN \HW ! !

N)'/! 13&! D&+25+(9'! ;+&-&)2&! $J! 3(-! D$13&+! 2$5'E! -5DD$)! -523! 5)/(&'E(),!

-1('')&--F!'(G&!9!.&9+!(E'(),!9D$),!9!-5))/!D&9E$=!9)E!O5&''(),!13&!J$+&-1!9)(D9'-!1391!

KLGH QHDUE\ %XW LW ZRQ¶W ODVW IRUHYHU KH NQRZV DQG HYHQWXDOO\ VRPHWKLQJ ZRXOG EH -9(EF! -$D&13(),! 5);'&9-9)1F! -$D&13(),! 13&! 9.-&)2&! $J! '9),59,&! 2$5'E! )$! '$),&+!

9225+91&'/!&L;+&--8! ! ?$+!13&!1(D&!.&(),F!13$5,3F!-3&!=(''!5-&!13&!9.-$'51&!O5(&1!9,9()-1!

3(DF!M5-1! 9-!3&!39E! -&&)!3&+!E$!$)!13$-&!E(-D9'!D$+)(),-!9J1&+!3(-!J913&+!39E! 9++(%&E! 3$D&! D523! '91&+! 139)! &L;&21&EF! 9J1&+! 3(-! ;9+&)1-! 39E! 9+,5&E! 9)E! -'9DD&E! E$$+-!

13+$5,3$51! 13&! ;+&%($5-! )(,31[! 13&! -5.-&O5&)1! -('&)2&! .&(),! -(D;'/! 9! E+9=)! $51! ;+$'$,5&!J$+!13&!3&91&E!=$+E-!1391!9'=9/-!J$''$=&E!(18! !

^&;'92(),! 13&! -=(DD(),! 1+5)G-! =(13! +&'91(%&'/! 2'&9)! 5)E&+=&9+F! 3&! E+&--&-!

.&-(E&! 13&! .&EF! ;511(),! $)! 13&! 2'$13&-! 3&! 39E! =$+)! '9-1! =&&G².511$)>5;! =3(1&! -3(+1F! .'92G! -$2G-F! E+&--! -'92G-²9)E! 13&)! ,$&-! 1$! +&1+(&%&! 3(-! .92G;92G! J+$D! 13&! E&-G8! !

"22$+E(),! 1$! 13&! 9'9+D! 2'$2G! )&9+! W$+9&D$)! (1! (-! _:A`F! 13&! .'()G(),! E(,(19'! )5D.&+-!

E+(%(),!3$D&!13&!;$()1!1391!3&!39E!$%&+-'&;18! ! X+9..(),!3(-!-23$$'!.$$G-F!-'(;;(),!13&D!

()-(E&!13&!.92G;92GF!3&!)$1(2&-!13&!5)5-&E!.5-!J9+&!3(-!D$13&+! 39E!'&J1!3(D!/&-1&+E9/!

-(11(),! 91! 9! 2$+)&+! $J! 13&! E&-G8! ! ")E! .&J$+&! 3$(-1(),! 13&! .92G;92GF! 3&! 29'25'91&-! 13&!

D$)&/!1391!39E!,+92&E!3(-!;9'D!/&-1&+E9/8! ! <3&!J(%&!E$''9+!.(''!J$5)E!()!13&!,511&+F!13&!

WZR TXDUWHUV 2OG 8QFOH KDG JLYHQ KLP WKH VWUDQJHU¶V KXQGUHGV²9''!$J!(1!39E!.&&)!3(-!1$!

G&&;F! 9''! $J! (1! 39E! .&&)! 19G&)! 9=9/8! ! "! '(11'&! -$D&13(),! (-! .&11&+! 139)! )$13(),F! 3&! &)2$5+9,&-!3(D-&'JF!J&&E(),!W$+9&D$)!13&!.5-!J9+&8! ! "!-D9''!;+$J(1!(-!-1(''!9!;+$J(18! !

#$=!13&!D()51&-!E(--$'%&!'(G&!-&2$)E-F!13&!()1&+D()9.'&!-('&)2&!.+$G&)!-$'&'/!./!

13&!39-1/!)$(-&-!3&!2+&91&-8! ! <3&!5+()&!1()G'(),!()1$!13&!1$('&1!.$='8! ! "!2$D.!-2+9123(),!

9! 2+$$G&E! ;9+1! 9'$),! 3(-! 39(+8! ! <3&! 1$$13.+5-3! -2+5..(),! 91! 3(-! 1&&138! ! Z%&)! =(13! 13&! .913+$$D! E$$+! -351F! 3&! -5EE&)'/! 29123&-! 13&! =9J1(),! 9+$D9! $J! J$$EF! $J! 9! =9+D! .+&9GJ9-1F! 3$;&J5''/F! 2$$G&E! J$+! 3(D8! ! <3&! +9%&)$5-! ;$2G&1-! +(EE'(),! 3(-! -1$D923!

9)-=&+!13&!'5+(),!-D&''F!'(G&!E(-1+&--&E!-3$51-!&23$(),!J+$D!9!29%&+)8! ! <3&)!3(-!35),&+! $%&++(E&-!13&!D$5)1(),!E+&9E!1391F!D$D&)1-!&9+'(&+F!39E!5+,&E!3(D!1$!J$+,$!.+&9GJ9-1! &)1(+&'/!9)E!&L(1!13&!3$5-&!9-!-=(J1'/!9-!;$--(.'&8! ! V&9+(),!3(-!.92G;92GF!3&!35++(&-!$51! $J!13&!.913+$$D²./;9--(),!13&!;'9))&E!&-29;&!+$51&!13+$5,3!13&!'(%(),!+$$DF!()-1&9E! 239+1(),!9!E(+&21!;913!E$=)!13&!39''=9/F!92+$--!13&!G(123&)²9++(%(),!91!13&!E()(),!19.'&! =3&+&! 9! ,'9--! $J! D('G! 9)E! 9! ;'91&! 2$)19()(),! 1=$! -5))/>-(E&! 5;! &,,-F! J+(&E! 39DF! 9)E! 1$9-1!9=9(1-!3(D8! !

7KLV PRUQLQJ KRZHYHU FDUWRRQV ZRQ¶W EH SOD\LQJ LQ WKH EDFNJURX)E! =3&)!

H9D5&'! -(1-! E$=)8! ! ^913&+F! (1! (-! 13&! ()J&+)9'! 35-3! $J! I$5(-9! ;+$1&-1(),! =(13$51! -$5)E! 1391!;+$%(E&-!13&!.+&9GJ9-1!-$5)E1+92GF!-&11(),!13&!1$)&!J$+!13&!E9/8! ! ")E!13&+&F!1$$F!-3&!

-(1-!9'D$-1!=(13()!+&923F!$225;/(),!3&+!5-59'!;'92&!$)!13&!$13&+!-(E&!$J!13&!19.'&F!&91(),!

1$9-1!9)E!9;;'&!-'(2&-8! ! Q51!-3&!39-)S1!E+&--&E!3&+-&'J!/&1F!13&!'$),!)(,31-3(+1!2$%&+(),!

3&+!.$E/!'(G&!9!3$-;(19'!,$=)8! ! P&+!-'&;1>$)!39(+!39),-!29+&'&--'/!9+$5)E!3&+!'$=&+&EF! 5)9E$+)&E!J92&[!13&!1(;!$J!9)!&9+!;$G&-!J+$D!13&!13(2G!-1+9)E-F!9;;&9+(),!(-$'91&E!9)E! GHOLFDWH 6KH¶OO ZRUN ODWH WRQLJKW KH WKLQNV GLJJLQJ FKRSVWLFNV LQWR WKH KDP 6KH ZRQ¶W JHW UHDG\ IRU ZRUN XQWLO WKLV DIWHUQRRQ 6HDOLQJ KHU OLSV DIWHU HYHU\ VPDOO QLEEOH -3&!.+&913&-!J+$D!3&+!)$-&!=3('&!23&=(),F!)&%&+!$)2&!'$$G(),!3(-!=9/!$+!92G)$='&E,(),!

3(-!;+$L(D(1/8! !

³<RX GRQ¶W PHDQ DQ\WKLQJ WR PH ´ LW VHHPV VKH LV WHOOLQJ KLP ³<RX DUHQ¶W P\

VRQ DQ\PRUH ´! !

ZL2&;1!H9D5&'!J()E-!13(-!'92G!$J!2$DD5)(291($)!9)E!&/&!2$)1921!;+&J&+9.'&8! ! 7)!

VRPH VHQVH WRGD\¶V PHDO LV QR G(JJ&+&)1! 139)! ;+($+! D&9'-! 13&/! 39%&! -39+&E! 1$,&13&+F! 13$-&! $J1&)! O5(&1! 9JJ9(+-! =3&+&! J&=F! (J! 9)/F! =$+E-! 9+&! -;$G&)²5)'&--F! $J! 2$5+-&F! -3&! (-!

9))$/&E!=(13!3(D8! ! W&%$5+(),!3(-!.+&9GJ9-1F!3&!G)$=-!.&11&+!139)!1$!,(%&!3&+!9)/13(),!

D$+&! 139)! 9! J5+1(%&! ,'9)2&F! $+! 1$! =9-1&! 9! -&2$)E! (E'(),! .&1=&&)! .(1&-! $J! J$$E8! ! )RUWXQDWHO\ WKHUH LVQ¶W PXFK WLPH OHIW IRU WKHP WKLV PRUQLQJ DQG ZUDSSHG LQ KHU PXWHG FRFRRQ KH LV IDLUO\ FHUWDLQ VKH ZRQµW HPHUJH OLNH D ZUDWKIXO EXWWHUIO\ XQWLO WRQLJKW RU WRPRUURZ 7KDW¶V QRUPDOO\ =391! 1+9)-;(+&E! =3&)&%&+! 3(-! J913&+! =9-! $)! 13&! +&2&(%(),! &)E!$J!3&+!$51+9,&F!9!G()E!$J!2'$2G=$+G>'(G&!J$+D5'9²9!)(,31!$J!9),&+F!9!E9/!$J!-('&)2&F! 9)$13&+! )(,31! $J! 9),&+F! 9)EF! J()9''/F! 13&! +&-5D;1($)! $J! 9)! 5)&9-/! 1+52&! 1391! ,+9E59''/! .+$5,31!;&92&!1$!13&(+!'(%&-F!3$=&%&+!1&D;$+9+/8! !

Y;$)! &D;1/(),! 13&! ,'9--! $J! D('GF! 3&! '&9%&-! 13&! 19.'&! =(13! 3(-! D$513! -1(''! J5''F!

23&=(),! 9)E! -=9''$=(),! 13&! '9-1! $J! 13&! .+&9GJ9-1! 1$9-18! ! P&! 2+$--&-! 13&! '(%(),! +$$DF! -35JJ'(),! ()1$! 13&! &)1+/8! ! H1$$;(),! J$+! 3(-! 1&))(-! -3$&-F! 3&! 29)! J&&'! 3&+! &/&-! -3$$1!

-(E&=9/-! 91! 13&! 19.'&F! 13&! -1+&),13! $J! 3&+! )9++$=! -19+&! -5EE&)'/! 239+,(),! J+$D! 13&!

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

<RX¶UH D WKLHI KH WKLQNV ZKLO&!-1$D;(),!E$=)!13&!;$+23!-1&;-F!(D9,()(),!I$5(-9!

JULQQLQJ DW WKH GLQLQJ WDEOH VXUHO\ SOHDVHG E\ KHUVHOI ³, KDWH \RX ´ KH PXWWHUV DORQJ 13&! =9'G=9/F! ,'9)2(),! .(11&+'/! 91! 13&! 3$5-&! J$+! 9! -&2$)EF! =(-3(),! 3&! 39E! 13&! ;$=&+! 1$!

D9G&! 13&! =3$'&! ;'92&! &L;'$E&! .HIRUH KLV H\HV ³,¶OO ILQG WKHP \RX ZDLW DQG VHH ´ H9D5&'!2$)1()5&-!J$+=9+EF!13$5,31-!$J!%&),&9)2&!)$=!-=(+'(),!=('E'/!E5+(),!13&!-3$+1! =9'G8! ! P&!(D9,()&-!-D9-3(),!3&+!J(,5+()&-!=(13!13&!=3&&'-!$J!13&!-G91&-F!-'9;;(),!3&+!

J92&! '(G&! -3&! 39E! -'9;;&E! 3(DF! -&11(),! 3(-! %($'()! 9.'9K&! 9-! -3&! =9123&-! 3$++(J(&E8! ! Q51!

-$$)!13&!3&J1!$J!13&!.92G;92G!9)E!13&!-1(JJ)&--!()!3(-!'&,-!-'$=-!3(-!;+$,+&--F!9)E!$)'/!

13&)! E$&-! (1! -&&D! '(G&! -3&! (-! 13&! $)&! &L921(),! +&%&),&F! ;5-3(),! 91! 3(-! -;()&F! +(E(),!

E(-E9()J5''/!$)!3(-!.92G!J$+!&%&+/$)&!1$!=(1)&--!&L2&;1!3(D8!

!

<3&+&9J1&+²=3('&!3&! =9)E&+-!13&!-23$$'!2$++(E$+-F!-(1-!13+$5,3!13&!ZHI!'&--$)F!

5-&-! 13&! 1$('&1! .&1=&&)! 2'9--&-²I$5(-9! '5+G-! $%&+! 3(-! -3$5'E&+-! '(G&! 9)! $;;+&--(%&!

-39E$=8! ! ")E! ()! 13&! 29J&1&+(9! 9)E! $)! 13&! ;'9/,+$5)EF! 3&! -&)-&-! 3&+! )$EE(),!

-/D;913&1(29''/!91!13&!-15E&)1-!=3$!9'=9/-!-35)!3(-!-$'(19+/!;+&-&)2&F!9-!13$5,3!1$!-9/F! ! ³, GRQµW EODPH \RX IRU QRW OLNLQJ KLP -XVW ORRN KRZ KH WUHDWV PH KLV YHU\ RZQ PRWKHU ´ ,W GRHVQ¶W PDWWHU KH WKLQNV ZKHQ VWHDOLQJ JODQFHV IURP Z3&+&!3&!&91-!'5)23!

9'$)&F! &/&(),! 13&! 2$5)1'&--! $13&+! .$/-! 1391! 2$DD5)&! ()! ,+&,9+($5-! ,+$5;-! 9)E! M$G&!

ORXGO\ WRJHWKHU 7KH\µUH DOO VWXSLG DQ\ZD\ KH UHDVVXUHV KLPVHOI ODWHU ZKHQ REVHUYLQJ 13&D!1&9+!9.$51!13&!;'9/,+$5)EF!29+&&)(),!3&+&!9)E!13&+&F!E(+1/!39)E-!-1+&123(),!$51!1$! ,+9-;!13&!-3(+1!$J!9!J+(&)E8! !

H19)E(),!)&9+!13&!D$)G&/!.9+-F!3&!-3+5,-!=(13!+&-$'%&!9-!(J!1+/(),!1$!.$5)2&!3&+!

$JJ!3(-!-3$5'E&+-F!2$)J(E&)1!)$=!1391!3&!(-!=&''!.&/$)E!3(-!;&&+-8! ! P&!39-!9'+&9E/!D$%&E! ()! .+$9E&+! 2(+2'&-F! E+9)G! .&&+F! ()39'&E! -D$G&! .'$=)! ./! D&)! J9+! ,+&91&+F! +(23&+F! 9)E! D$+&! 25))(),! 139)! 9)/! .$/! -;+()1(),! +&2G'&--'/! 92+$--! 13&! '(D(1&E! &9+13! $J! \&JJ&+-$)!

W&=&/!0(EE'&!H23$$'8! ! I&11(),!13(-!.&'(&J!19G&!+$$1F!J$-1&+(),!(1!J$+!13&!+&D9()E&+!$J!3(-!

2'9--!1(D&F!13&!-&)-91($)!$J!I$5(-9!;+&--(),!()1$!3(D!,+9E59''/!'&--&)-²,+$=(),!'(,31&+!

9)E!'(,31&+F!5'1(D91&'/!5-3&+&E!9=9/!'(G&!9!J&913&+!1$--&E!1$!13&!=()E8! ! P&!13&)!+&D()E-!

KLPVHOI WKDW VKH¶OO KDYH GHSDUWHG WKH KRXVH EHIRUH KLV ODVW SHULRG HQGV JLYLQJ KLP D 29+&J+&&!9J1&+)$$)!9)E!&%HQLQJ 6RRQ WRR KH¶OO GLVFRYHU ZKHUH WKH VNDWHV DUH KLGGHQ DQG RQFH VKH FRPHV KRPH WRQLJKW KH¶OO SUREDEO\ EH UHVWLQJ LQ EHG ,I OXFN LV RQ KLV VLGH KH¶OO DZDNH WRPRUURZ PRUQLQJ DQG OHDYH ZKLOH VKH¶V VWLOO IDVW DVOHHS DYRLGLQJ KHU 2$D;'&1&'/8! ! 7J! 3&¶V WUXO\ IRUWXQDWH WKH\ PLJKW QRW FURVV SDWKV DJDLQ XQWLO SHUKDSV -$D&1(D&!1$D$++$=!)(,318! !

")EF!&%&)159''/F!=3&)!13&!J()9'!.&''!J'$$E-!13&!D9()!2$++(E$+-!=(13!-15E&)1-F!(1!(-!

9!J&&'(),!$J!.5$/9)2/!1391!J'$91-!H9D5&'!$51!9D$),!13&DF!29++/(),!3(D!.+(-G'/!J+$D!13&! .5('E(),8! ! P(-! .92G;92G! (-! )$! '$),&+! -$! 25D.&+-$D&F! 9)E! 3(-! '&,-! 9+&! )$=! -$D&=391! '(D.&+F!9,('&F!$)'/!M5-1!9!'(11'&!-$+&8! ! W9-3(),!J$+13F!3&!-O5()1-!5)E&+!13&!%(%(E!9J1&+)$$)!

VXQ DQ[LRXV WR PDNH D IDVW UHWUHDW GRZQ WKH VFKRRO¶V ZLGH JUD\ VWHSV ! I5''(),!%(-($)-!$J! +$,-&"./%)'#9)E!+$"#+.%-'01.2".'#IOLFNHU DERXW KLV PLQG DV GR 5HHVH¶V 3HDQXW %XWWHU 45;-F!;()&9;;'&!29G&-F!9)E!.5..'(),!*&;-(²13&!<R!+&D$1&!3&'E!()!9!'9L!39)EF!13&!-G91&-! &D.&''(-3(),!3(-!J&&1!'(G&!9!J9%$+(1&!;9(+!$J!-'(;;&+-8! !

Q51! =(13$51! =9+)(),! 9)$13&+! %(-($)! 9;;&9+-F! D9)(J&-1(),! .&/$)E! 3(-! 13$5,31-F!

&+9E(291(),!13$-&!9''5+(),!E(%&+-($)-!9'1$,&13&+8! ! <3&)!(1!-&&D-!9-!(J!13&!3&9%/!-39E$=!

1391!39E!'&J1!3(D!&9+'(&+!39-!-5EE&)'/!+&15+)&E!1$!E9+G&)!13&!;9%&D&)1!()!J+$)1!$J!13&!

-23$$'F!9)E!3&!J+&&K&-!$)!13&!-1&;-F!+&2$('(),!91!13&!-(,31!$J!3(-!D$13&+!9=9(1(),!.&'$=!./!

13&! J'9,;$'&8! ! H15E&)1-! 2+(--2+$--! 9+$5)E! 3&+F! /&1! I$5(-9! (-! 9-! D$1($)'&--! 9-! 9! -1915&F! D$513! E+9=)! 1(,31! 9)E! &/&-! ,'9+(),! 1$=9+E! 3(DF! J(),&+-! 2'9-;(),! 3&+! ;5+-&! -1+9;8! !

V&9+(),! 3&+! =$+G! 5)(J$+DF! -3&! ,+(;-! 9! +$''&E! 5;! ,+$2&+/! -92G! ()! 9! 39)EF! (1-! .5'G/!

2$)1&)1-!-9,,(),!13&!.+$=)!;9;&+!.$11$D8! ! P&!;'$E-! E$=)!13&!-1&;-F!)&+%$5-'/!.(1(),!

3(-!'(;!=3('&!'$=&+(),!3(-!-19+&8! !

³+XUU\ XS ´ VKH DEUXSWO\ LQVLVWV ZKHQ KH DSSURDFKHV ³H3$=! D&! 1391!

SDZQVKRS 7DNH PH WKHUH ´! !

1R KH UHDOL]HV VKH KDVQ W EHHQ VKRSSLQJ 7KH VDFN GRHVQ¶W FRQWDLQ IRRG IRU

3(DF! )$! -)92G-F! )$13(),! E&'(2($5-! 1$! -91(-J/! 3(D! E5+(),! 13&! &%&)(),8! ! <3&+&! (-! )$!

E(,&-1(.'&!J$+D!$J!D$13&+'/!9JJ&21($)!=(13()!13&!-92G!91!9''F!O5(1&!13&!$;;$-(1&8! ! ! !

³/HWµV JR ´ VKH VD\V !

!

")E! G)$=(),! )$=! 1391! 3&+! ;5)(-3(),! -('&)2&! 39E! 39+.$+&E! ;'9)-! J$+! 9! D523!

PHDQHU FRXQWHUDWWDFN WKDQ KH¶G H[SHFWHG 6DPXHO KDV QR FKRLFH EXW WR PLVHUDEO\ OHDG 13&!=9/!()!E&J&91F!3(-!D$13&+!-1+(E(),!2'$-&!.&3()E!3(D!9-!13&/!-19+1!D9+23(),8! ! H3$+1'/F! 13&/!+$5)E!9! 2$+)&+²D(,+91(),!J+$D!13&!3&+E!$J!23('E+&)F!13&!(E'(),!-23$$'!.5-&-F!13&!

1+9JJ(2!M9D!$J!9++(%(),!;9+&)1-²1+9%&'(),!5;$)!9!+&-(E&)1(9'!-(E&=9'GF!-G(+1(),!3$D&=9+E! .$5)E!-15E&)1-!9)E!.+5-3(),!.&-(E&!9!'$),F!-=9/(),!+$=!$J!$'&9)E&+-8! ! <3&!+9;(E!;911&+!

RI /RXLVD¶V VKRHV QHYHU DOWHUV QRU GRHV KHU SDFH DOORZ KLP WR FDWFK D EUHDWK²&%&)! 9-!

13&!E$+D9)1!923&-!$J!3(-!'&,-!9+&!+&()%(,$+91&EF!13&!.92G;92G!-$D&3$=!;511(),!$)!&L1+9! =&(,31!=(13!&923!.'$2G!13&/!=9'G8! ! Q/!13&!1(D&!13&/!+&923!13&!)&9+&-1!.5-/!()1&+-&21($)F! 15+)(),! 9)E! 13&)! 2$)1()5(),! $)=9+E! 9'$),-(E&! -1$+&J+$)1-F! 13&! E(-2$DJ$+1! 3&! J&&'-! (-!

9'D$-1!5).&9+9.'&8! !

"2+$--!-3$;!=()E$=-! 3&+!1+9)-;9+&)1!+&J'&21($)!39-1&)-! 9.$%&!3(DF!E&1&+D()&E!

DQG PRURVH ,W¶V /$5+! J95'1F! -3&! (-! 2'&9+'/! 13()G(),8! ! U$5! .+$5,31! 13(-! $)! /$5+-&'JF! H35),>/$8! ! P&+!-25++/(),!J(,5+&!395)1-!13&!,'9--!$J!9!2$JJ&&!-3$;F!9!)$$E'&!+&-195+9)1F!9!

J$$1! D9--9,&! ;9+'$+F! 9! %(E&$! -1$+&F! J()9''/! -'$=(),! =3&)! H9D5&'! -1$;-! ()! J+$)1! $J! 13&! ;9=)-3$;!9)E GURSSLQJ KLV FKLQ DLPV DQ RXWVWUHWFKHG ILQJHU DW LWV HQWUDQFH ³&RPH RQ ´ VKH VD\V DQG RQO\ WKHQ GRHV VKH DVVXPH WKH OHDG DQJOLQJ DKHDG RI KLP RQFH WKH\ -1&;!()-(E&F!.5-1'(),!J$+=9+E!;9-1!13&!1&++9>2$119!=9++($+!,59+E(),!13&!E$$+=9/F!9-!(J!1$!

=()!9!+92&8! !

P&+! -3$&-! ;$5)E! 13&! J'$$+F! +&%&+.&+91(),! '$5E&+! 139)! 13&! .$$D! .$L! 1391! -1(''!

SOD\V $QLWD 0XL¶V KLWV 3XIILQJ RQ D FLJDUHWWH WKH )LOLSLQR VOLGHV OD]LO\ IURP KLV VWRRO =3('&!-3&!9E%9)2&-F!2$2G(),!9)!&/&.+$=!$%&+!3(-!$)&!,$$E!&/&F!9)E!9J1&+!I$5(-9!$;&)-!

13&! ,+$2&+/! -92GF! ;+$D;1'/! E&;$-(1(),! 13&! -G91&-! $)! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;! .&1=&&)! 13&DF! 9!

2$)2&+)&E!&L;+&--($)!;5KK'&-!3(-!5)-39%&)!J92&8! !

³6SHDN &KLQHVH"´ VKH DVNV WKH PDQ VRXQGLQJ FXUW !

!

³, GR ´ KH SROLWHO\ DQVZHUV QRGGLQJ ³+RZ FDQ , KHOS \RX"´!

!!!!

³<RX WDNH WKHVH EDFN ´ VKH GHPDQGV SXVKLQJ WKH VNDWHV DW WKH PDQ ³DQG JLYH

D&! D/! 2+/-19'! ;(&2&-8! ! 0/! -$)! 39E! )$! +(,31! E$(),! .5-()&--! 3&+&8! ! P&! -1$'&! 13$-&!

FU\VWDOV IURP PH ´! !

³+PP , VHH ´ WKH PDQ VD\V VFUDWFKLQJ KLV QHFN WKHQ SDXVHV IRU D GUDJ RQ WKH

2(,9+&11&8! ! <3&! ,$$E! &/&! -29)-! 13&! -G91&-! =(13! 9! 2$)1&D;'91(%&! -O5()1F! .51! (1-! ,'9--! '$$G>9'(G&! (-! =(E&! $;&)! 9)E! -G&=&E! 1$=9+E! H9D5&'²29'D'/F! ()E(JJ&+&)1'/²=3&+&! 3&!

QRZ VWDQGV EHVLGH /RXLVD KLV KHDG ERZHG ³7KHUH¶V D SUREOHP ´ WKH PDQ VD\V .+&913(),!-D$G&8! !

³:KDW SUREOHP"´!

!

³7KDW OLWWOH GRJ DQG IORZHU²WKH\ JRW VROG ,µP VRUU\ ´!

!

³:KDW GR \RX PHDQ VROG"´!

!

³6RPHRQH ERXJKW WKHP ´!

!

³%RXJKW" +RZ LV LW SRVVLEOH"´!

!

I$5(-9!;&&+-!39+E!91!13&!D9)F!9'13$5,3!13&!()E(,)91($)!$J!3&+!&L;+&--($)!=9%&+-!

-'(,31'/! 9-! 13H )LOLSLQR¶V PLVPDWFKHG H\HV VXUSULVH KHU²$)&! ;5;('! +&15+)(),! 3&+! ()J'&L(.'&!-19+&F!13&!$13&+!'$''(),!;9--(%&'/!$JJ!1$!13&!-(E&!'(G&!(1-!+&19+E&E!1=()!.+$13&+8! !

³6RPHRQH ERXJKW WKHP ´ WKH PDQ VD\V DJDLQ SODLQO\ DQG VKUXJV !

!

V391! -$+1! $J! ;&+-$)! 9+&! /$5T! ! VKH WKLQNV VWXG\LQJ WKH )LOLSLQR¶V RYDO IDFH

J+$=)(),!91!3(-!235../!-1$D923!2+&9-&E!9,9()-1!13&!2$5)1&+1$;8! ! V391!G()E!$J!.5-()&--!

DUH \RX UXQQLQJ" ³<RX¶UH VXSSRVHG WR NHHSV WKLQJV IRU SHRSOH ´ VKH WHOOV KLP ³<RX GRQ¶W VHOO WKHP ULJKW DZD\ ´! !

³7KDW¶V WUXH ´ WKH PDQ UHSOLHV WDSSLQJ WKH WLS RI WKH FLJDUHWWH DQG OHWWLQJ WKH

ZKLWH DVK IDOO OLNH VQRZ ³([FHSW WKLV VLWXDWLRQ LV GLIIHUHQW <RXU NLG WUDGHG LQ WKH OLWWOH ILJXUHV DQG D ERZ DQG D IHZ GROODUV ´!

!

³:KDW ERZ"´!

!

³$Q ROG YLROLQ ERZ ,W ZDV D WUDGH PRVWO\ ´!

!

I$5(-9! -3$$1-! 9! '$$G! $J! 2$)1&D;1! 1$! H9D5&'F! =3$! (-! 35)23&E! -('&)1'/! ()! -39D&F!

-52G(),!3(-!.$11$D!'(;!-$!13$+$5,3'/!1391!(1!39-!%9)(-3&E!J+$D!3(-!J92&8! ! <3&)!-15))&E! E\ KHU VRQµV VHHPLQJO\ GHSWKOHVV NQDFN IRU GHFHLW VKH IL[HV D VXVSLFLRXV VWDU&! $)! 13&! )LOLSLQR VD\LQJ ³+H JDYH \RX PRQH\ KXK" +RZ PXFK"´! !

³, GRQ¶W UHPHPEHU ´ WKH PDQ DQVZHUV OLIWLQJ WKH FLJDUHWWH IRU D GUDJ ³1RW

PXFK ´! !

³:KDW NLQG RI SDZQVKRS LV WKLV"´!

!

<3&!D9)!-3+5,-8!

!

")E! =3('&! I$5(-9! -39G&-! 3&+! 3&9E! =(13! .$13! E(-,5-1! 9)E! 2$)-1&+)91($)F! 13&!

?('(;()$! &L39'&-! 9! -1+&9D! $J! -D$G&! 1391! J'$=-! -(D5'19)&$5-'/! 13+$5,3! 3(-! D$513! 9)E! )$-1+('-²)&(13&+! $)&! ;9/(),! 911&)1($)! 1$! 13&! -5.E5&EF! -$D&=391! 9JJ&21&E! -)(JJ'&-! )$=! +&,(-1&+(),!.&'$=!13&D8! !

³, GRQ¶W XQGHUVWDQG 'RQ¶W \RX ZULWH DQ\W3(),!E$=)T! ! N+!,(%&!;&$;'&!+&2&(;1-T! !

6KRXOGQ¶W VRPHRQH EH DEOH WR FRPH EDFN DQG JHW WKHLU VWXII"´! !

³<HV RI FRXUVH ´ WKH PDQ VD\V QRGGLQJ D IHZ WLPHV ³%XW \RXU NLG GLGQ¶W KDYH

HQRXJK IRU WKH UROOHUEODGHV KH ZDQWHG 6R , WROG KLP ,¶E!E$!3(D!9!J9%$+!9)E!1+9E&!3(D! WKHVH VNDWHV IRU ZKDW KH KDG ,W¶V D IDLU WUDGH QRW D SDZQ 7KDW ZDV WKH GHDO VLPSOH DV WKDW $QG ZKDW KH WUDGHG JRW VROG H[FHSW WKH ERZ ´! !

³:KR FDUHV DERXW DQ ROG ERZ , ZDQW P\ FU\VWDOV <RX KDG QR ULJKW DFFHSWLQJ

13HP LQ WKH ILUVW SODFH ´ 6KH JODUHV GRZQ DW 6DPXHO SURGGLQJ KLV WHPSOH ZLWK WZR J(),&+-F!)5E,(),!9!-(),'&!+&J'&L(%&!-$.!J+$D!3(D!1391!911&D;1-!1$!J&(,)!9!,+&91&+!-9E)&--8! ! ³<RX ORRN DW \RX ´ VKH VD\V VKDNLQJ KHU KHDG ³&U\ :KDW¶V FU\LQJ JRRG IRU" 4U\LQJ GRHVQ¶W KHOS OLDUV ´ 7KHQ KHU PLVWUXVWLQJ VWDUH QDUURZV RQ WKH )LOLSLQRµV JRRG &/&F!9-!(J!3&+!1=$!J5''/!J5)21($)(),!;5;('-!2$5'E!J$+2&!(1-!-(),5'9+!,9K&!()1$!-5.D(--($)8! ! ³+RZ FDQ WKH FU\VWDOV EH VROG VR TXLFNO\" +H ZDV MXVW LQ KHUH ´! !

³7KRVH FXWH WKLQJV VHOO ´ WKH PDQ UHSOLHV D FROG VPLOH VSUHDGLQJ OLNH D WKLQ FUDFN

RQ D SODVWHU ZDOO ³, JRW D FXVWRPHU ZKR FROOHFWV WKHP 6KH¶V D UHJXODU DQG VKH ERXJKW WKHP 7KDW¶V LW 7KDWµV KRZ LW ZRUNV $Q\ZD\ ZK\ DP , UHVSRQVLEOH IRU ZKDW \RXU G(E!E$&-T! ! 7KDWµV \RXU SUREOHP ´! !

)HHOLQJ KHU EORRG EHJLQ WR ERLO VKH VFUXWLQL]HV WKH )LOLSLQR¶V IDFH DV LI VHDUFKLQJ

J$+! 9! -&2+&1! ;9--9,&! 1391! D(,31! ,5(E&! 3&+! 1$! 13&! J(,5+()&-8! ! U$5! J$$'F! /$5! $)'/! ,$1! $)&! &/&F! -3&! =9)1-! 1$! /&''! 91! 13&! D9)8! ! U$5! $)'/! -&&! 39'J! 13&! ;(215+&8! ! Q51F! ()-1&9EF! -3&! .+(&J'/! =$..'&-! 13&! -G91&-F! 13&! =3&&'-! 135EE(),! $)! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;F! 5'1(D91&'/! -9/(),F! ! ³<RX NHHS WKHVH *LYH PH WKH PRQH\ DQG ERZ ´! !

³1R , FDQ¶W WDNH EDFN D GHDO ´ LV WKH PDQµV VWXEERUQ UHSO\ ³6RUU\ ´!

!

"! 35JJ! $J! J+5-1+91&E! 9LU EORZV IURP /RXLVD SXVKLQJ WKH )LOLSLQRµV OLQJHULQJ

2(,9+&11&! -D$G&! 9-(E&8! ! H39G(),! 3&+! 3&9E! 9)E! E+$;;(),! 13&! &D;1/! ,+$2&+/! -92G! 1$! 13&!

IORRU VKH JUDSSOHV KHU SXUVH XQ]LSSLQJ LW ZLWK DJLWDWHG ILQJHUV %HFDXVH ZH¶UH QHZ 3&+&F! -3&! +&9-$)-F! -15;(E! D&)! '(G&! /$5! 19G&! 9E%9)19,&! $J! E&2&)1! ;&$;'&! '(G&! 5-8! ! U$5!

PXVW WKLQN ZH¶UH SRRU QR EHWWHU WKDQ KXPDQ JDUEDJH ! !

")E!M5-1!13&)F!=3('&!-3&!+(J'&-!()-(E&!3&+!;5+-&F!H9D5&'!J&&'-!13&!,+$5)E!-35EE&+!

J$+! 9! D$D&)1! 5)E&+! 3(-! J&&1F! &%&+! -$! '(,31'/8! ! <3&! J9()1! +5D.'(),F! 3&! (D9,()&-F! $J! 13&! )LOLSLQR¶V PDQ\ WHUUD>2$119!=9++($+-!-1(++(),!1$!'(J&F!9!.+$=)(-3>$+9),&!E5-1!-=(+'(),!$JJ! 13&(+!.$E(&-!9-!13&/!-1&;!J$+=9+E!()!J$+D91($)8! ! Q+(2>9>.+92!+911'&-!-$J1'/!$)!13&!-3&'%&-F! +3/13D(2! 9)E! -1+9),&'/! D5-(29'F! J9''(),! O5(&1! 9''! 91! $)2&8! ! I9;-(),! J+$D! 3(-! $.'(,91$+/!

E(-;'9/! $J! 35D('(91($)F! 3&! '(J1-! 9! J$+'$+)! /&1! 1&9+'&--! ,9K&F! (D;'$+(),! 3&+! 1$! .&! 29+&J5'!

ZLWK SDUWHG OLSV WKDW GRQµW GDUH XWWHU KLV DFWXDO WKRXJKWV :DWFK ZKDW \RX GR 0D 7KHUH¶V D ZKROH DUP\ KLGLQJ WKHUH EHKLQG KLP ! !

"-! 13$5,3! 13&! =9+)(),! 39E! .&&)! +&2&(%&EF! I$5(-9! ;95-&-F! 9! 39)E! .5+(&E! E&&;!

=(13()!13&!;5+-&8! ! P&+!&/&-!E9+1!9+$5)E!)&+%$5-'/!.&J$+&!'$2G(),!$)!H9D5&'8! ³$IWHUVKRFN ´ WKH PDQ PXWWHUV VRXQGLQJ XQFRQFHUQHG /LNH WKH WHPSRUDU\ J'521591($)-! .&)&913! 13&! &9+13F! 13&! ;&&%(-3)&--! $J! 3&+! &L;+&--($)! &..-! &'-&=3&+&F! UHSODFHG E\ D UHOLHYHG ORRN WKDW DOVR SDVVHV ZKHQ VKH REVHUYHV KHU VRQ¶V SLWLDEOH IDFH P&+! -19+&! 13&)! 39+E&)-! 5;$)! 3(DF! ()-19)1'/! '$=&+(),! 3(-! 3&9E! 9,9()F! -&&D(),! 1$!

2$DD5)(291&!(1-!$=)!=9+)(),:! ! U$5!-KXW XS 'RQ¶W HYHU WHOO PH ZKDW WR GR ! !

$ VHFRQG ODWHU WKH VWUDQJHU¶V PRQH\ PDWHULDOL]HV IURP WKH SXUVH XQIROGHG DQG

VWUDLJKWHQHG RXW E\ WUHPEOLQJ ILQJHUV ³, ZDQW P\ FU\VWDOV ´ VKH VD\V VODSSLQJ WKH 35)E+&E!E$''9+!.(''-!$)!13&!2$5)1&+1$;F!)$EE(),!-39+;'/!9-!(J!39%(),!-522&--J5''/!29''&E! WKH PDQ¶V EOXII ³+RZ PXFK"´! !

7KH )LOLSLQR JODQFHV DW WKH PRQH\ LUULWDWLRQ ZULQNOLQJ KLV EURZ ³:KDW DP ,

VXSSRVHG WR GR" , WROG \RX , GRQ¶W KDYH WKHP DQ\PRUH 7KH\ DOUHDG\ EHORQJ WR VRPHRQH HOVH ´!

!

/RXLVD¶V IDFH UHGGHQV ³+RZ FDQ \RX GR EXVLQHVV OLNH WKLV"´ 6KH VQDWFKHV WKH

.(''-F!,+9-;(),!13&D!()!9!2'&)23&E!J(-1!1391!=9,-!E&J(9)1'/!()!J+$)1!$J!13&!D9)F!3&+!%$(2&!

JURZLQJ ORXGHU DV VKH VSHDNV ³<RX VKRXOGQ¶W DFFHSW WKLQJV FKLOGUHQ EULQJ WR \RXU VKRS ,¶P VXUH! LW¶V DJDLQVW WKH ODZ :KDW NLQG RI ER\ RZQV FU\VWDOV OLNH WKDW" <RX PXVW¶YH NQRZQ WKH\ ZHUH VWROHQ GLGQ¶W \RX" <RX WKLQN ,¶P WKDW VWXSLG KXK" ,¶OO UHSRUW \RX WR WKH SROLFH ´! !

*UXQWLQJ RQFH ZLWK HTXDO DPRXQWV RI DQQR\DQFH DQG DPXVHPHQW WKH )LOLSLQR¶-!

D$513!1=(-1-!-'(,31'/!9-!3&!13&)!=9%&-!3(-!2(,9+&11&!39)E!9.$%&!13&!2$5)1&+F!-9/(),!()!9! !

UHVWUDLQHG EXW GHOLEHUDWH WRQH ³*R DKHDG 'R \RX HYHQ VSHDN (QJOLVK" <RX ZDQW PH 1$! 29''! 13&D! J$+! /$5! 9)E! 19'G! 1$! 13&D! D/-&'JT! ! 09/.&! 7! 29)! +&;$+1! /$5! 9)E! /$5+! G(E8! !

6RXQGV OLNH KHµV WKH UHDO FURRN KHUH DQG \RX UDLVHG KLP , ZRQGHU ZKR WDXJKW KLP WR VWHDO OLNH WKDW"´! !

³1RQVHQVH ´ VKH EOXVWHUV JLYLQJ WKH PDQ D ODVW ZDJ RI KHU ILVW !

!

%XW NQRZLQJ VKH¶V EHHQ RXWPDQHXYHUHG DQ H[DVSHUDWHG VLJK GUDLQV WKH DQJHU

J+$P /RXLVD¶V IDFH $ QHDU VLOHQFH GHVFHQGV RQ WKH SDZQVKRS HQKDQFLQJ $QLWD 0XL¶V ;&+J$+D9)2&!$J! 3,-'")# 4"51&6# ()!13&!.92G,+$5)EF!13&!49)1$)&-&!'/+(2-!'$-1!$)!3&+!/&1!

J9D('(9+!9''!13&!-9D&8! ! 7!'$%&!13(-!-$),F!-3&!J()E-!3&+-&'J!13()G(),!=3('&!-'(;;(),!13&!.(''-! .92G!()-(E&!3&+!;5+-&F!9)E!-3(J1-!3&+!)$=!+&-(,)&E!,9K&!9+$5)E!13&!-3$;8! ! <3&!.(2/2'&-!

-5-;&)E&E! $)! 3$$G-8! ! <3&! +&D$1&>2$)1+$'! 9(+;'9)&-! E9),'&E! ./! J(-3(),! =(+&8! ! <3&!

-3&'%&-! 2+9DD&E! =(13! M5)G8! ! H9D5&'! E$=)29-1! 9)E! D$1($)'&--! )&L1! 1$! 3&+8! ! <3&! $)&>&/&E!)LOLSLQR¶V SHFXOLDU VWDUH PLQGLQJ KHU HYHU\ PRYH ! !

³+RZ PXFK FDQ , JHW IRU WKH VNDWHV"´ VKH ILQDOO\ DVNV PXPEOLQJ LQ DQ DOPRVW

&D.9++9--&E!D9))&+8! !

7KH )LOLSLQR VKUXJV IOLFNLQJ WKH ILQLVKHG FLJDUHWWH WR WKH IORRU ³+PP , GRQ¶W

NQRZ ´ 7KH JRRG H\H EO()G-! -&%&+9'! 1(D&-F! +&,9+E(),! 13&! -G91&-! 13$5,31J5''/! J$+! 9!

PRPHQW ³)RXU GROODUV ´! !

³)RXU GROODUV LV XVHOHVV &DQ , WUDGH IRU WKH ERZ"´!

!

³$OO ULJKW DOO ULJKW ,¶OO GR \RX D IDYRU ´ WKH PDQ VD\V WKH ZRUGV FKXFNOLQJ RXW RI

3(D! 9-! (J! &%&+/13(),! 39E! .&&)! 9! .(,! M$G&! 91! 3&+! &L;&)-&²9-! (J! 13&/! =&+&! $'E! J+(&)E-8! ! ³,¶P QRW XQUHDVRQDEOH +RZ DERXW , WUDGH WKH ERZ IRU WKH VNDWHV DQG , JLYH \RX IRXU GROODUV IRU \RXU WURXEOH ´! !

6KH VKDNHV KHU KHDG WZLFH D WLUHG ORRN EXUGHQLQJ KHU IDFH ³)RUJHW DERXW \RXU

D$)&/ , GRQ¶W QHHG LW -XVW WDNH WKHVH VNDWHV DQG JLYH PH WKH ERZ , GRQ¶W HYHU ZDQW WR VHH WKHP DJDLQ ´! !

<3&!?('(;()$!$JJ&+-!9)!9--&)1(),!)$EF!9)EF!=3&)!E$(),!-$F!1(D&!-&&D-!1$!+&%&+-&!

(1-&'J!J$+!H9D5&'8! ! *&&G(),!5;!.&-(E&!3(-!D$13&+F!-3$=(),!)$!&L;+&--($)!=391-$&%&+F!3&! =9123&-! 13&! 1+9)-921($)! $225+! .&1=&&)! 13&D! =(13$51! 9)/13(),! &'-&! .&(),! -9(E²13&!

-G91&-!E(-9;;&9+(),F!13&!$'E!%($'()!.$=!-$$)!-'(E(),!92+$--!13&!-;$1!=3&+&!13&!+&E!=3&&'-!

39E! ,+92&E! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;8! ! ! <3&)! '(G&! 9! ;9()J5'! +&D()E&+! $J! 13&! 5)9'1&+9.'&! D9-1&+!

SODQ WKDW VKH KDG LPSUHVVHG XSRQ KLV OLIH WKH ERZ LV WKUXVW LQWR KLV KDQGV ³/HW¶V JR ´ -3&! 2$DD9)E-F! 9)E! 9J1&+=9+E! 13&/! +&1+&91! J+$D! 13&! 2$5)1&+F! '&9%(),! 13&! E(-29+E&E! ,+$2&+/! -92G! 9)E! 13&! D9)! .&3()EF! =9)E&+(),! ./! E5-1/! 1&'&%(-($)-F! %(E&$! ,9D&! 5)(1-F! 95E($! &O5(;D&)1F! 9)E! -192G-! $J! RPH! 19;&-²-1&;;(),! .&/$)E! 13&! =9++($+! 91! 13&! &)1+9)2&F!+&2&E(),!1$,&13&+!9-!9!=91&+/!+&J'&21($)!()!9)!()E$'&)1!,'9--!&/&8! !

%XW EHIRUH WKH\ FDQ SURFHHG PXFK IDUWKHU RQ WKH VLGHZDON WKH )LOLSLQR¶V YRLFH

-5EE&)'/! 29''-! $518! ! H19+(),! $%&+! 9! -3$5'E&+F! I$5(-9! -&&-! 13&! 235../! D9)! -19)E(),! ()!

J+$)1!$J!13&!;9=)-3$;F!D$1($)(),!=(13!9)!9+E&)1!&L;+&--($)²9)!9+D!3&'E!3(,3F!J(),&+-! ,+(;;(),!9!-D9''!;(&2&!$J!;9;&+²'(G&!-$D&$)&!=9%(),!,$$E./&!91! 9!1+9()!-191($)8! ! <3&! (+G-$D&! -(,31! $J! 3(D! D9G&-! 3&+! =9)1! 1$! G&&;! =9'G(),8! ! 7)-1&9EF! 13$5,3F! -3&! )5E,&-!

H9D5&'F!9)E!13&/!.$13!15+)!9+$5)EF!3&9E(),!.92G8! !

³:KDW LV LW"´ VKH DVNV JODQFLQJ ZDULO\ DW WKH SDSHU WKH )LOLSLQR QRZ KROGV

WRZDUG KHU ³, GRQ¶W QHHG D UHFHLSW ´! !

³1R QR LW¶V QRW WKDW ´ WKH PDQ UHVSRQGV D VLQFHUH WRQH FDUU\LQJ KLV ZRUGV

³$Q\ZD\ , VKRXOGQ¶W GR WKLV H[FHSW , EHOLHYH , EHDU VRPH UHVSRQVLELOLW\ IRU \RXU ;+$.'&D8! ! 7!9'=9/-!1+/!1$!+5)!9)!3$)&-1!.5-()&--F!9)E!7!9'=9/-!1+/!1$!.&!J9(+!1$!;&$;'&F! )$!D911&+!=3$!13&/!9+& ,µP QRW D EDG SHUVRQ OLNH \RX WKLQN 6R SOHDVH WDNH WKLV ´ $ )(2$1()&>VWDLQHG KDQG VOLSV KHU WKH SLHFH RI SDSHU DQ DGGUHVV ZULWWHQ RQ LW ³,W¶V WKH '9E/!=3$!.$5,31!13&!'(11'&!J(,5+&-8! ! 0+-8!I&&8! ! 09/.&!/$5!$+!/$5+!G(E!29)!&L;'9()!/$5+! ;+$.'&D!1$!3HU DQG UHDFK DQ DJUHHPHQW ,¶P VXUH VKHµOO XQGHUVWDQG KRZ \RX IHHO 7HOO KHU /HRQDUG VHQW \RX ´! !

³0UV /HH"´ /RXLVD VD\V ³&KLQHVH"´!

!

³1R $PHULFDQ :KLWH 0DULRQ /HH ´!

!

³2K 6KH VSHDNV &KLQHVH"´!

!

³, GRQ¶W WKLQN VR ´!

!

³2K ´!

!

³'RQ¶W ZRUU\ VKH¶V D YHU\ QLFH ODG\ ,W FRXOGQ¶W KXUW WR JR YLVLW KHU , GR

.5-()&--!=(13!3&+!9''!13&!1(D&8! ! U$5!1&''!3&+!I&$)9+E!1$'E!/$5!1$!19'G!1$!3&+8! ! H3&!G)$=-!

PH SUHWW\ JRRG 6KH WUXVWV PH ´! !

³7KDQN \RX ´ VKH VD\V IROGLQJ WKH SDSHU LQ KDOI ³+RZ IDU LV LW"´!

!

³1RW IDU ´!

!

<3&!D9)!;$()1-!-1+9(,31!E$=)!13&!-(E&=9'GF!9)E!-3&!15+)-!1$!J$''$=!13&!E(+&21($)!

$J!3(-!()E&L!J(),&+F!,9K(),!;9-1!13&!+$=!$J!-1$+&J+$)1-8! ! !

³*R ULJKW DW WKH FRUQHU XS WKHUH²WKDW¶V 6WHYHQV 6WD\ RQ 6WHYHQV QR PRUH WKDQ

9!.'$2G8! ! <3&!.5('E(),!(-! 6WHYHQV 9HU\ FORVH ´! !

")E! =3('&! I$5(-9! (-! .5-/! 19'G(),! 1$! 13&! ?('(;()$F! H9D5&'! (E'&-! 9! J&=! J&&1! 9=9/!

J+$D!13&DF!;&&+(),!91!13&!2'511&+&E!E(-;'9/!$)!13&!$13&+!-(E&!$J!13&!;9=)-3$;!=()E$=8! !

Z%&+/13(),!(-!9'D$-1!&L921'/!9-!(1!39E!.&&)!'9-1!=&&GF!-9%&!J$+!$)&!(D;$+19)1!13(),8! ! <3&!

5-&E! M5)($+! ()'()&! -G91&-²-'&&G! 9)E! .'92G! ()! 3(-! D&D$+/F! E&-(,)&E! =(13! 9&+$E/)9D(2! ,+$$%&-! 9)E! ,$'E>1+(DD&E! =3&&'-²9+&! )$=3&+&! 1$! .&! -&&)8! ! H$D&$)&! (-! -$! '52G/F! 3&! )$=!13()G-!9)E!19;-!13&!$'E!.$=!D('E'/!9,9()-1!13&!=()E$=8! ! \5-1!)$1!D&8! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! @AAC! !

Q/!13&!1(D&!I$5(-9!2'(D.-!9.$9+E!9!1+9)-(1!.5-!=(13!H9D5&'!J$''$=(),!2'$-&!.&3()EF!13&! <$>W$! '(-1! 1391!-3&!39E!2$D;('&E!()!3&+!3&9E!'91&!'9-1! )(,31²WKLV DIWHUQRRQ¶V LWLQHUDU\ 1391! -3&! 39E! G&;1! -('&)1'/! 1$! 3&+-&'J²39-! ;+&11/! D523! .&&)! 2$D;'&1&E8! ! "'13$5,3F! -$!

IDU KHU SODQV KDYHQ¶W WXUQHG RXW TXLWH DV HIIRUWOHVV RU UHFRQFLODEOH DV VKH¶G KRSHG #&%&+13&'&--F!-3&!29)!)$=!9EE!9!D&)19'!23&2GD9+G!9'$),-(E&!13&!D$+&!D()$+!$.M&21(%&-! $J! 13&! E9/8! ! X&1! H9D5&'! $)2&! 3(-! 2'9--&-! 9+&! E$)&8! ! /$"7(8! ! ?()E! 13&! ;9=)-3$;8! ! /$"7(8! ! ^&15+)!13&!-G91&-8! ! /$"7(8! !

Q51!13&+&!-1(''!&L(-1-!13&!D911&+!$J!3&+!D(--(),!J(,5+()&-8! ! ")EF!1$$F!9)!5)J$+&-&&)!

VLGH WULS WR WKH $PHULFDQ ZRPDQ¶V VHFRQG>J'$$+! 9;9+1D&)1! 39E! +(-G&E! E(%&+1(),! 3&+!

1(,31'/! -23&E5'&E! 9,&)E9F! 19G(),! 13&D! $JJ! 2$5+-&! =3&)F! ()-1&9EF! 13&/! -3$5'E! 39%&!

9'+&9E/! 9++(%&E! &9+'/! 91! 13&! 23(&J! E&-1()91($)! $)! 13&! '(-1:! ! 3&+! =$+G;'92&8! ! "-! (1!

39;;&)&EF! 13$5,3F! 13&! 9;9+1D&)1! .5('E(),! =9-! M5-1! 9! J&=! D()51&-! =9'G! J+$D! 13&!

SDZQVKRS DQG DV LW DOVR KDSSHQHG WKH ZRPDQ¶V GRRU QHYHU FUDFNHG RSHQ IRU /RXLVD -$D&13(),! -3&! J$5)E! 3&+-&'J! =&'2$D(),! =(13! ()&L;+&--(%&! +&'(&J8! ! ³<RX UHPHPEHU WKLV SODFH ´ VKH WKHQ WROG 6DPXHO DIWHU GHVFHQGLQJ DQ RXWVLGH VWDLUFDVH UHWXUQLQJ &D;1/>KDQGHG WR ZKHUH KH KDG EHHQ OHIW ZDLWLQJ VXOOHQO\ RQ WKH ERWWRP VWHS ³'RQ¶W \RX IRUJHW ´! !

7J!'(11'&!&'-&F!-3&!.&'(&%&E!13&!9.-$'51&!;'9())&--!$J!13&!E(),.91!.5('E(),!D9E&!(1!

+913&+! D&D$+9.'&:! ! )$! ,91&E! &)1+9)2&F! )$! 2$5+1/9+EF! )$13(),! &)2'$-&E²-(D;'/! 9! )$)E&-2+(;1! .+$=)>-1522$! .$LF! )9D&'&--! &L2&;1! J$+! 13&! '9+,&! 9EE+&--! $J! ]aBA! &D.'9K$)&E! 3(,3! 5;$)! 9! =9''F! 9)E! +&)E&+&E! $.-$'&1&! ./! 13&! D$E&+)>'$$G(),! 1$=)!

3$D&-! 5)E&+! 2$)-1+521($)! ()! 9)! 9EM92&)1! '$18! ! Z(,31! 5)(1-! J92&E! -$513²J$5+! 5;-19(+-F!

J$5+! E$=)-19(+-8! ! Z(,31! -(),'&>+$$D! 9(+! 2$)E(1($)&+-! M511&E! .&'$=! &(,31! =()E$=-8! !

Q+92G&1(),! &(13&+! &)E! $J! 13&! .5('E(),! =&+&! =+$5,31>(+$)! -19(+29-&-F! 13&! 2$)2+&1&! -1&;-!

J(--5+&E!9)E!)&&E(),!-$D&!+&;9(+8! !

6KH SRLQWHG EDFN XS WKH VWDLUV GLUHFWLQJ KHU VRQ¶V PRURVH DWWHQWLRQ ³7KH GRRU

+(,31! 13&+&²)5D.&+! _8! ! ^&D&D.&+! )5D.&+! _8! ! U$5! 2$D&! 3&+&! 1$D$++$=! 9)E! ,&1! D/!

FU\VWDOV 1R H[FXVHV ´ $QG VKRUWO\ WKHUHDIWHU ZKLOH WKH\ KXU+(&E! 9'$),! 13&! -(E&=9'GF! -3&!39)E&E!$%&+!13&!;(&2&!$J!;9;&+!1391!13&!?('(;()$!39E!,(%&)!3&+F!=9+)(),!3(D!1=(2&! )$1!1$!'$-&!(18! !

#$=! -19)E(),! ./! 13&! +&9+! &L(1! $)! 13&! 2+$=E&E! .5-F! I$5(-9! ,+(;-! 9! ;$'&! .&-(E&!

H9D5&'S-!35)23&E!J$+D8! ! #$+D9''/!13&!.+(&J!+(E&!(-!3&+!'9-1!$;;$+15)(1/!1$!-(1!J$+!9!-;&''F! +&-1(),!3&+!J&&1!.&J$+&!13&!'$),!-3(J1!93&9EF!.51!91!13(-!3$5+!13&!-&91-!9)E!9(-'&!9+&!J5''!$J! E(-+5;1(%&! 3(,3! -23$$'! G(E-8! ! H3&! ,'9)2&-! 9.$51F! -2$+)J5''/! +&,9+E(),! 13$-&! 1&&)9,&+-!

1391!'$$G!9)E!.&39%&!-$!E(JJ&+&)1'/!139)!3&+!$=)!-$)²'(G&!9!-&;9+91&!-;&2(&-!9'1$,&13&+F! '(G&! 5)+5'/! -1+9/-! .+&E! ()! 13&! =('E&+)&--²9)! $EE! 9--$+1D&)1! $J! 5)152G&E! 4913$'(2!

-23$$'! 5)(J$+D-F! .9,,/! M&9)-F! 2+$$G&E! .9-&.9''! 29;-F! 9)E! 1$$! D523! D9G&5;8! !

P&9E;3$)&-!.'9+(),8! ! 0$513-!2$)-19)1'/!D$%(),8! ! Q$E(&-!239+,&E!=(13!&++91(2!D$1($)8! !

7KH\¶UH IRROLVK VKH WKLQNV 8QGLVFLSOLQHG DQG UXGH DQQR\LQJ 6XUHO\ LQ QR RWKHU ;+$;&+! 2$5)1+/! .51! "D&+(29! =$5'E! 13&/! .&! 9''$=&E! -523! E$D()9)2&! $)! ;5.'(2!

1+9)-;$+191($)F! )$1! 9! -(),'&! $)&! $JJ&+(),! 13&(+! -&91! 1$! 13&! &'E&+'/! $+! D$13&+-!

922$D;9)/(),!23('E+&)8! ! H(11(),!)&9+./F!13+&&!$J!13&!.9,,/>M&9)!.$/-!.&,()!;&+J$+D(),!

9!2$''&21(%&!+9;F!-;9-D$E(2!39)E-!9)E!J(),&+-!,&-1(25'91(),!13&!+9;(E>J(+&!=$+E-F!9)E!-3&!

ZRQGHUV LI ZKDW WKH\¶UH VD\LQJ LV HYHQ LQ (QJOLVK²(J! 13&! M5D.'&E! -$5)E-! 13&/! 9+&! +3/13D(29''/!239)1(),!39%&!9)/!+&9'!D&9)(),!91!9''8! !

H3&!'$=&+-!3&+!E(-E9()J5'!-19+&F!-&11'(),!(1!$)!H9D5&'!=3$!-5'G-!.&)&913!3&+!9)E!

9;;&9+-! 2$D;'&1&'/! $.'(%($5-! 1$! &%&+/13(),! 9+$5)E! 3(D8! ! H()2&! '&9%(),! 13&! ;9=)-3$;F! 3(-!3&9E!39-!+&D9()&E!D$-1'/!()2'()&EF!3(-!,9K&!'$(1&+(),!91!3(-!J&&1!9-!13$5,3!3&!=&+&!

JULHYLQJ IRU WKH VNDWHV WKDW ZRXOG QHYHU DJDLQ VDLO KLP GRZQ VLGHZDONV <RX DUHQ¶W D OLWWOH NLG DQ\PRUH VKH FRQVLGHUV VFROGLQJ KLP <RX¶OO EH D PDQ VRRQ VR \RX EHWWHU VWDUW 921(),!'(G&!$)&8! !

Q51! =3('&! 13&! .9,,/>M&9)! .$/-! -;&=! 13&(+! .$13&+-$D&! +92G&1F! I$5(-9! .&2$D&-!

9=9+&!1391!3&+!9),&+!1$=9+E!3(D²13&!E&&;!E(-9;;$()1D&)1F!13&!-&)-&!$J!.&(),!1&++(.'/! =+$),&E²GRHVQ¶W VHHP DV DFXWH RU LQVXUPRXQWDEOH DV LW KDG PLQXWHV DJR 6KH UXQV

3&+!&/&-!92+$--!3(-!-$D&=391!E(-3&%&'&E!39(+F!J&&'(),!9)!(D;+$D;15!E&-(+&!1$!2$D.!13&!

5)19D&E!-1+9)E-8! ! "!13()!,+(D/!-1+&9G!D9+-!3(-!5-59''/!2'&9)!)&2G'()&F!9)E!-3&!+&-(-1-! '(2G(),! 9! 135D.! -$! 1391! 3&+! -;(1! 29)! -D&9+! (1! 9=9/8! ! H5)'(,31! -'9)1-! 9,9()-1! 13&!

5).'&D(-3&E! -G()! $J! 3(-! +(,31! 23&&GF! '(G&! .+(,31! /&''$=! ;9()1! -;+&9E! 5;$)! 9! -D$$13! ;$+2&'9()!-5+J92&8! ! <3&)!9J1&+!)$1(2(),!3$=!13&!.92G;92G!-'5D;-!3(-!.$E/!J$+=9+EF!3&+! &L;+&--($)! -$J1&)-! =3&)! -3&! +&D()E-! 3&+-&'J! 1391! 3&! (-F! 92159''/F! )$=3&+&! 2'$-&! 1$! 9! ,+$=)! D9)! /&18! ! P&! (-! -1(''! $)'/! 9! '(11'&! G(E! =(13! 9! =$+)>$51! %($'()! .$=! ,+9-;&E! ()! 9!

39)EF!9)EF!9-!-523F!3&!39-!;+$.9.'/!.&&)!;5)(-3&E!&)$5,38! ! "'D$-18! !

<3&!.5-!15+)-!-39+;'/F!-=9/(),!13&!-19)E(),!;9--&),&+-!'(G&!2$+)-19'G-!15--'&E!./!

9!-5EE&)!,5-1F!9)E!()!13&!D(GVW RI LWV VKLIWLQJ PRYHPHQW /RXLVD¶V WKRXJKWV DOVR FKDQJH GLUHFWLRQ <RX¶UH ULJKW VKH QRZ WKLQNV DV LI UHDGLQJ 6DPXHO¶V DQJXLVKHG PLQG LW LVQ¶W YHU\ IDLU PDNLQJ \RX UHWXUQ DORQH IRU P\ FU\VWDOV <RX GRQ W VSHDN WKH ZRPDQ¶V '9),59,&F! 29)S1! &L;'9()! =3/! \RX YH FRPH DUHQ¶W HYHU OLNHO\ WR JHW WKHP EDFN DQ\ZD\ 6KH WRR KDG IHOW JUHDW DQ[LHW\ DERXW NQRFNLQJ RQ WKH XQNQRZQ ZRPDQµV DSDUWPHQW E$$+F! G)$=(),! ;9()J5''/! =&''! 1391! 3&+! D&9)-! $J! 2$DD5)(291($)! .&/$)E! 09)E9+()! 9)E! <9(=9)&-&! 9+&F! 91! .&-1F! '(D(1&E8! ! ")E! 39E! 13&! E$$+! -=5),! $;&)F! -3&! =$5'E! 39%&! 13&)!

-1$$E!13&+&!'(G&!-$D&!-19DD&+(),F!39'J!D51&!2+&915+&!J+$D!9!E(-19)1!=$+'EF!9'1&+)91(),!9!

J'5-1&+&E! -D('&! =(13! 9! 2$)J5-&E! '$$G²MXVW DV VKH¶G UHSHDWHGO\ IRXQG KHUVHOI GRLQJ =3&)&%&+! )91(%&! Z),'(-3! -;&9G&+-! &)E&E! 5;! $225;/(),! 3&+! 9--(,)&E! 19.'&-F! +&O5(+(),! ?+9)2(-!$+!0$''/!1$!5'1(D91&'/!19G&!E$=)!13&(+!$+E&+-!J$+!3&+8! !

?$+15)91&'/F! 13&! E$$+! =9-! )&%&+! 9)-=&+&EF! 9)E! =(13$51! H9D5&'! G)$=(),! (1F!

/RXLVD KDGQ¶W UHDOO\ NQRFNHG LQ WKH ILUVW SODFH ,QVWHDG ZKLOH KH ZDLWHG!E$=)-19(+-!91!

KHU LQVLVWHQFH VKH GLVFUHHWO\ WDSSHG D ILQJHUQDLO DJDLQVW WKH ZRPDQ¶V GRRU²J$5+!1(D&-F! 9-!O5(&1!9)E!()&JJ&2159'!9-!;+&--(),!9!.+$G&)!;(9)$!G&/²KRSLQJ LW ZDVQµW ORXG HQRXJK WR VXPPRQ DQ\RQHµV DWWHQWLRQ %XW EHIRUH FOLPELQJ WKH DSDUWPHQW VWDLUV E\ KHUVHOI VKH¶G 9'+&9E/!E&2(E&E!1391!13&!-&&D(),'/!(D;$--(.'&!19-G!$J!9EE+&--(),!13&!"D&+(29)!=$D9)!

PXVW EH KHU VRQ¶V REOLJDWLRQ KLV SXQLVKPHQW DQG VHOI>E&J&91(),! .5+E&)F! )$1! 3&+! +&-;$)-(.('(1/8! ! <3&! D$-1! -3&! =$5'E! E$! =9-! -3$=! 3(D! 13&! =9/F! ;$()1(),! $51! 13&! +(,31!

E$$+! J$+! 3(D! 1$! 9;;+$923! 1$D$++$=! 9J1&+! -23$$'F! 9)E! -3$5'E! 3&! E9+&! .9'G! 9.$51! +&15+)(),!$)!3(-!$=)²ZKLFK KH KDVQ¶W GRQH \HW²9)!()2+&E5'$5-!+&;'/!=(''!-;+(),!J+$D! KHU PRXWK OLNH D VNLOOIXOO\ ODLG WUDS ³6KXQJ>/$F!(J!7!29)!D9G&!D/-&'J!,$!5;!9)E!G)$2G! RQ WKDW GRRU \RX FDQ WRR ´!

!

ZL2&;1! 13&! O5&-1! J$+! 13&! J(,5+()&-! (-! J&&'(),! D$+&! 9)E! D$+&! '(G&! 9! '$-1! 295-&F! 9!

=9-1&! $J! 3&+! &)&+,/! 9)EF! 13&+&J$+&F! 5)(D;$+19)18! ! H3&! =$5'EF! $J!2$5+-&F! .&! ;'&9-&E! 1$!

39%&!13&D!.92G!()!3&+!E(-;'9/!29.()&1F!9'13$5,3!-3&! (-!2&+19()!1391!=$)S1!$225+8! ! <3&/!

DUH QRZ VRPHRQH HOVH¶V FROOHFWLEOHV DQRWKHU ZRPDQ¶V SUL]HG SRVVHVVLRQV 3OXV QHZHU ILJXULQHV KDYH EHJXQ HQWLFLQJ KHU PLQG QLFHU RQHV H[SHQVLYH SLHFHV VKH FRXOGQ¶W KDYH 9JJ$+E&E!5)1('!/&-1&+E9/!)(,31²9!-&1!$J!.9./!;&),5()-F!9!+3$E(5D>;'91&E!+$2G(),!3$+-&F! 2+/-19'!-)9('-!$)!9!2+/-19'!'&9J²9''!2$-1(),!9!.(1!'&--!139)!13&!1=$!35)E+&E!E$''9+-!()-(E&!

3&+! ;5+-&8! ! Q51! =391! E$&-! +&D9()! (D;$+19)1! (-! 13&! -(,)(J(29)2&! $J! 3&+! -$)! 91! '&9-1!

-1+(%(),!1$!2$++&21!3(-!D(-19G&-F!E&-;(1&!13&!$512$D&8! !

")E! -$F! I$5(-9! +&9-$)-F! (J! H9D5&'! (-! .5('1! ;9+1'/! =(13! 3&+! J'&-3! 9)E! .'$$EF! 3&! (-!

DOVR VKDSHG HTXDOO\ E\ KLV IDWKHU¶V ZHDNHU GLVSRVLWLRQ²13$-&! &++9)1! D9'&! 1+9(1-! 1391! )&&E'&--'/! 2$D;'(291&! 3&+! '(J&8! ! U&1! -3&! 39-! E$)&! 3&+! .&-1! 1$! -3(&'E! 3&+! -$)! J+$D! 435)>WH¶V KXUWIXO DFWLRQV²13&! -5-;&21&E! .&1+9/9'-F! 13&! 1+9)-;9+&)1! '(&-².&'(&%(),! 3&+!

-1&+)F! +&'&)1'&--! ,5(E9)2&! =(''! .&9+! J+5(1! ()! 13&! J515+&F! D9G(),! 3(D! -1+$),&+! 9)E! =(-&+!

139)!=391&%&+!+&2G'&--!1+92&-!$J!3(-!J913&+!D(,31!-1(''!;5D;!13+$5,3!3(-!%&()-8! ! <$=9+E! 1391! &)EF! 13&+&! 9+&! ()%9'59.'&! 13(),-! 3&! D5-1! '&9+)F! 2$)-&O5&)2&-! 3&! D5-1! J92&F! -$D&!

-$$)&+!9)E!-$D&!'91&+!$):! ! 9'=9/-!.&!E51(J5'²GRQ¶W OLH GRQ¶W VWHDO GRQ¶W GLVDSSHDU IRU 3$5+-F! E$)S1! -'&&;! 9+$5)E! E5+(),! D9++(9,&8! ! <3&)! -$D&ED\ KHµOO XQGHUVWDQG ZK\ VKH ZDV VR VWULFW ZLWK KLP DV D ER\ +HµOO DSSUHFLDWH KHU HIIRUWV ZKHQ UHDOL]LQJ KH ZDV UDLVHG WR KROG KLPVHOI DFFRXQWDEOH DQG KH¶OO NQRZ WKDW KHU UHSHDWHG FODLPV RI E(-9;;$()1D&)1! =&+&! ()1&)E&E! -$'&'/! J$+! 3(-! .&11&+D&)1²'(G&! )&2&--9+/! -(,);$-1-!

E(+&21(),!3(D!-9J&'/!9'$),!13&!39K9+E$5-!;913!1391!=()E-!()1$!D9)3$$E8! !

³&RPH ´ /RXLVD VD\V DV WKH UHDU H[LW RSHQV ZLGH DW WKHLU VWRS 6KH EUXVKHV SDVW

H9D5&'! 9)E! '&9E-! 3(D! E$=)! 13&! -1&;-! 9)E! $51! $J! 13&! .5-8! ! N)2&! 13&/! 9+&! $)! 13&!

-(E&=9'GF! 3&9E(),! 1$! 13&! +&-195+9)1F! -3&! .'5)1'/! &L;'9()-! =391! (-! )$=! &L;&21&E! J+$D! 3(D8! ! P&! D5-1! -19)E! .&J$+&! 3&+! .$--! 9)E! 9;$'$,(K&8! ! P&! D5-1! -3$=! +&,+&1F! 9.-$'%(),!

3(D-&'J²! 9)E! 3&+²$J! 3(-! 13$5,31'&--F! -15;(E! 921($)-8! ! P&! D5-1! .&! 35D.'&F! 9-39D&EF! ;+$J$5)E'/! -$++\ ³,I \RX GRQ¶W \RX MXVW ZDLW DQG VHH ´ $QG ZDONLQJ EHVLGH KHU KH '(-1&)-! =(13! 9! .'9)G! &L;+&--($)F! ,9K(),! E$=)! =3('&! 2'5123(),! 13&! .$=! 9-! (J! (1! =&+&! 9!

-=$+EF!3(-!.$11$D!'(;!M511(),8! !

$ PRPHQW ODWHU WKH\ SURFHHG WKURXJK WKH UHVWDXUDQW¶V IR\HU VRRQ ZD)E&+(),!

.&1=&&)!&D;1/!19.'&-8! ! Z%&+/13(),!(-!35-3&E8! ! W(-3&-!2'()G!-;$+9E(29''/!()!13&!G(123&)8! !

"O59+(5D-! .5..'&! D&''(J'5$5-'/! 9,9()-1! 13&! =9''-8! ! <3&! -;92($5-! D9()! +$$D! (-! ;+&11/!

D523! E&-&+1&E! -9%&! J$+! 9! -D911&+(),! $J! 9J1&+)$$)! E()&+-F! 13&! '5''! ;+($+! 1$! 13&! &%&)(),! +5-3!-1&&;(),!13&!;'92&!=(13!9!'(-1'&--F!2'$-&E>J$+>.5-()&--!95+98! ! H&91&E!9+$5)E!9!'9+,&!

2(+25'9+! 19.'&! 91! 13&! .92GF! D$-1! $J! 13&! -19JJ! 9+&! &91(),! 9! '91&! 2$DD5)9'! '5)23F! 9)E! 9-!

I$5(-9!9)E!H9D5&'!9;;+$923F!O5(KK(29'!&/&-!'(J1!9.$%&!.$='-!9)E!;'91&-F!3&9E-!15+)(),8! !

0$''/8! ! ?$5+! 0&L(29)! )91($)9'-8! ! <=()! .+$13&+-! J+$D! P$),! b$),8! ! "!

43()&-&>09'9/-(9)!=9(1&+!)9D&E!\9/8! ! "!?('(;()$!.5-.$/!29''&E!W9+=()8! !

?+9)2(-!-&1-!3(-!23$;-1(2G-!9-(E&8! ! "J1&+!E9..(),!3(-!D$513!=(13!9!+&E!-&+%(&11&F!

3&! 1=(-1-! $)! 13&! FKDLU WR JUHHW WKHP VPLOLQJ SOHDVDQWO\ ³7KHUH \RX DUH ´ KH VD\V ORRNLQJ VWUDLJKW DW 6DPXHOµV FKDVWHQHG IDFH ³,¶YH EHHQ ZDLWLQJ IRU \RX , WKLQN ZH DOO KDYH ZDLWHG ´! !

6WRSSLQJ QHDU WKH WDEOH /RXLVD QRGV DSRORJHWLFDOO\ WKHQ VKH QXGJHV 6DPXHO¶V

-3$XOGHU KHU QRZ GHPXUH YRLFH VD\LQJ ³7HOO KLP ´! !

V(13!9!-1$'(E!95E(&)2&!=9123(),!3(DF!H9D5&'!E+(J1-!J$+=9+E!9-!(J!()!9!-15;$+F!&923!

VWHS FUDQNLQJ KLV KHDG ORZHU DQG ORZHU XQWLO KLV VWDUH IUHH]HV RQ )UDQFLV¶ EODFN GUHVV VKRHV ³6RUU\ VLU ´ WKH ZRUGV ZKLVSHU IURP KLP OLNH D VHFUHW ³6RUU\ ´! !

³*R RQ ´ VKH TXLHWO\ XUJHV !

!

³6RUU\ , PDGH VR PXFK WURXEOH ´ 6DPXHO XWWHUV DW WKH VKRHV ZKLFK DUH SROLVKHG

WR VXFK D KLJK VKHHQ WKDW KH FDQ VHH KLPVHOI UHIOHFWHG GDUNO\ XSRQ WKHP ³,¶P -15;(E²VRUU\ ´! !

"!E&2(-(%&!QRG MROWV /RXLVDµV KHDG /$"7(*!

!

I(G&!9!-5++$,91&!D$13&+F!0$''/F!1$$F!(D;9+1-!-&%&+9'!-91(-J(&E!)$E-!=3('&!-2$$;(),!

J+(&E!+(2&!$)!1$!3&+!;'91&8! ! Q51!?+9)2(-!J'(2G-!9!E(-D(--(%&!39)EF!,+())(),!=3&)!3&!-9/-F! ! ³1R QR JHWWLQJ ORVW LV D PLVWDNH QRWKLQJ HOVH ,W GRHVQ¶W PHDQ \RX¶UH VWXSLG (YHU\ERG\ JHWV ORVW VRPHWLPHV ´! !

³0P ´ 6DPXHO PXPEOHV ³D PLVWDNH 6RUU\ ´!

!

³7KHVH WKLQJV KDSSHQ ,¶P MXVW JODG \RX¶UH ILQH <RX KDG XV YHU\ ZRUULHG

HVSHFLDOO\ \RXU PRWKHU KHUH ´! !

³6RUU\ ´!

!

")E!9-!13&!$13&+-!+&15+)!1$!13&(+!D&9'-F!?+9)2(-!'&9)-!2'$-&+F!)9++$=(),!3(-!,9K&!

RQ 6DPXHO DV LI SHHULQJ WKURXJK D KROH LQ D ZDOO ³/LVWHQ GRQ¶W VD\ VRUU\ DQ\PRUH :KDWµV GRQH LV GRQH ,µP QRW PDG DW \RX ´!

!

"-!(J!5)2$)%()2&EF!H9D5&'!D9)9,&-!9!-'(,31!)$E!=(13$51!'$$G(),!5;F!&/&-!E9+1(),!

QHUYRXVO\ <HW D UHOLHYHG ORRN OLJKWHQV /RXLVD¶V IDFH DQG D JUDWHIXO VPLOH IRUPV RQ KHU '(;-8! !

³1R YLROLQ WRGD\ KXK"´ )UDQFLV WKHQ VD\V +H UHDFKHV GRZQ EUXVKLQJ D ILQJHU

DJDLQVW WKH IUD\HG ZKLWH KDLUV RI WKH ROG ERZ ³0D\ , VHH LW"´ ! !

H9D5&'! +9(-&-! 3(-! 23()F! -O5()1(),! 9-! (J! -19+(),! 91! -$D&13(),! $)! 13&! 3$+(K$)8! !

)UDQFLV¶ KDQGV VSUHDG LQ IURQW RI KLP SDOPV RSHQ DQG IODW DQG WLPLGO\ KH OD\V WKH ERZ 92+$--!13&D8! !

H1+9(,31&)(),! 3(-! -;()&F! ?+9)2(-! ;95-&-! 9! D$D&)1! 1$! &L9D()&! 13&! .$=F! -'$='/!

UXQQLQJ D KDQG DORQJ WKH OHQJWK RI LW DQG ILQDOO\ DVNV ZLWK D JHQWOH YRLFH ³+RZ ORQJ KDYH \RX KDG WKLV"´! !

H9D5&'!-3+5,-!$)2&F!-39G(),!3(-!3&9E8!

!

³2K ORQJ WLPH ´ /RXLVD VXGGHQO\ DQVZHUV ³+H XVHG LW DW WKH 7DLSHL &LW\

4$D;&1(1($)8! ! <3&!<9(=9)!#91($)9'!R($'()!4$D;&1(1($)F!1$$²1391!-9D&!.$=8! ! P&!=9-!9!

ILQDOLVW %RWK WLPHV ´! !

³9HU\ LPSUHVVLYH ´ )UDQFLV VD\V JLYLQJ 6DPXHO DQ DGPLULQJ ORRN ZKLOH

&L1&)E(),!13&!.$=!J$+!3(D!1$!19G&!.92G8! !

³0PP ´ 0ROO\ FRQFXUV IURP QHDUE\ FKHZLQJ DQG QRGGLQJ !

!

<3&)!$)2&!13&!.$=!39-!.&&)!922&;1&EF!?+9)2(-!.&)E-F!39)E-!2$D(),!1$!+&-1!$)!3(-!

NQHHV HOERZV RXW ³<RX NQRZ 6DPXHO , KDYH D VPDOO IDYRU 'R \RX PLQG PH DVNLQJ \RX"´! !

³2I FRXUVH QRW ´ /RXLVD FRPPHQWV ³<RX GRQ¶W PLQG GR \RX"´!

!

³, GRQ¶W PLQG ´ 6DPXHO UHSOLHV D&239)(29''/F!'$=&+(),!13&!.$=!91!3(-!-(E&F!9)E!

=9123&-! 9-! 9! 2$)2&)1+91&E! &L;+&--($)! D91&+(9'(K&-! .&J$+&! 3(DF! -$D.&+! /&1! ()1&)1! &/&-! )$=!-19+(),!()1$!3(-!&/&-8! !

³,W¶V QRWKLQJ PXFK UHDOO\ ´ )UDQFLV VD\V VRIWO\ ³%XW VRPHGD\ VRRQ ,¶G OLNH \RX

1$!;'9/!/$5+!YLROLQ RQO\ IRU PH QR RQH HOVH , FDQ¶W VD\ H[DFWO\ ZKHQ IRU VXUH SUREDEO\ VRPHWLPH ZLWKLQ WKH QH[W IHZ PRQWKV <RX FDQ SOD\ DQ\WKLQJ \RX ZDQW LW GRHVQµW PDWWHU 7KDW¶V DOO :KDW GR \RX WKLQN"´! !

<3&! +&O5&-1! -$5)E-! -$! -(D;'&! 9)E! ;$'(1&! 1391! (1! 9'D$-1! 295-&-! I$5(-9! 1$! .'5-38! !

³,W¶V QR SUREOHP ´ VKH UHVSRQGV ³+H¶OO SOD\ IRU \RX ERVV DQ\WLPH :RQ¶W \RX H35),>\R"´!

!

³0P ´!

!

³*RRG , DSSUHFLDWH LW ´ $Q DUWLILFLDO VPLOH FXUYHV )UDQFLVµ!D$513F!2+&9-(),!13&!

FRUQHUV RI KLV H\HV DQG KH REVFXUHO\ DGGV ³<RXU PRWKHU VKRXOG NQRZ ZKHQ LW¶V WKH ULJKW WLPH GRQµW ZRUU\ ´ 6KLIWLQJ XSULJKW KH SDWV 6DPXHO¶V OHIW VKRXOGHU ³1RZ FRPH VLW DQG KDYH VRPHWKLQJ WR HDW ´! !

³<HV HDW HDW ´ 0ROO\ VD\V ! ! ³7KHUH¶V HQRXJK IRU HYHU\RQH ´!

!

³1R QR LW¶V RND\ ´ $Q XUJHQW WRQH UDLVHV /RXLVD¶V YRLFH ³+H PXVW EH JRLQJ

KRPH VRRQ ORWV RI VWXG\LQJ ´ 6KH VWHSV WR 6DPXHO WXJJLQJ KLP OLJKWO\ E\ D VKLUW VOHHYH ³,¶OO MXVW JR SD\ KLV EXV IDUH ´! !

³, VHH ´ )UDQFLV! VD\V ³6WXG\LQJ LV JRRG EXW VWXG\LQJ RQ DQ HPSW\ VWRPDFK

LVQµW KHDOWK\ 3OHDVH JLYH PH D PRPHQW ´ :LWK D TXLFN ZDYH RI KLV KDQG DQG LQ D D911&+! $J! -&2$)E-F! 13+&&! 19G&$51! .$L&-! 9+&! .+$5,31! 1$! 3(D8! ! I(G&! 2'$2G=$+G!13&! .$L&-! .&,()! 2(+2'(),! 13&! 19.'&²+(2&F! ;$+GF! %&,&19.'&-F! 9! '(11'&! &L1+9! +(2&²&923! $)&! +&%$'%(),! .92G! 1$! ?+9)2(-F! 3(-! J(),&+-! 29+&J5''/! -192G(),! 13&D! ()-(E&! 9! ;'9-1(2! .9,! 1391! (-!

VXEVHTXHQWO\ NQRWWHG DW WKH WRS DQG SDVVHG LQWR 6DPXHO¶V IUHH KDQG ³7KHUH 7DNH WKDW KRPH DQG HQMR\ LW ´! !

³7KDQN \RX ERVV ´ /RXLVD VD\V ³6D\ WKDQN \RX 6KXQJ>\R ´!

!

³7KDQN \RX ´ 6DPXHO UHSOLHV RQ DXWRSLORW !

!

?+9)2(-! -D$$13&-! 13&! +&E! -&+%(&11&! 92+$--! 3(-! '9;! =3('&! )$EE(),! 91! .$13! D$13&+!

9)E! -$)F! +&-;&21(%&'/8! ! <3&)! 3&! 15+)-! 1$! J92&! 3(-! ;'91&F! 9.-&)1'/! +&2'9(D(),! 3(-!

23$;-1(2G-8! !

")E!=(13!1391F!I$5(-9!9)E!H9D5&'!D$%&!9=9/!J+$D!13&!19.'&F!9'13$5,3!)$1!.&J$+&!

-3&!$JJ&+-!9!E&;9+1(),!+$5)E!$J!2$)1+(1&!)$E-F!9,9()F!1$!13$-&!=3$!9+&!-&91&E!13&+&²13&! ,&-15+&!,$(),!D$-1'/!5))$1(2&EF!13&!$13&+-!9;;&9+(),!9-!;+&$225;(&E!9)E!()E(JJ&+&)1!9-!

13&! J(-3! -=(DD(),! ()! 13&! 19)G-! 9+$5)E! 13&D8! ! *+&-&)1'/F! 13&/! &L(1! 13&! +&-195+9)1F! =9)E&+(),!1$=9+E!13&!)&9+&-1!.5-!-1$;F!=&9+(),!%929)1!&L;+&--($)-!9)E!-9/(),!)$13(),8! ! "!=9+D!J&&'(),F!3$=&%&+F!-1(+-!()-(E&!3&+!E5+(),!13&!-3$+1!=9'GF!9!25+($5-!D(L!$J!'$),(),!

9)E!2$)1&)1D&)1F!J$-1&+&E!./!13&!D&+&!13$5,31!$J!?+9)2(-²3(-!;91(&)2&F!G()E)&--F!9)E! LPPDFXODWH ORRNV WKDW XQWLO \HVWHUGD\ KDGQ¶W UHDOO\ VWUXFN KHU DV DQ\WKLQJ PRUH WKDQ SURIHVVLRQDO FRXUWHV\ %XW ODVW HYHQLQJ KH¶G VKRZQ JHQXLQH FRQF&+)! =3&)F! ()! J921F! 3&!

VKRXOG¶YH EHHQ IXULRXV DW KHU DQG 6DPXHO 7R KHU VRQ WRR KH GLVSHQVHG TXLHW J$+,(%&)&--! 9)E! 5)E&+-19)E(),F! 9;;&9-(),! 13&! .$/! ()! D523! 13&! -9D&! D9))&+! 9-! 3&+!

35-.9)E!39E!$J1&)!E$)&²/&1!=(13$51!13&!'(),&+(),!E(-19-1&!1391!435)>WH¶V KD'J3&9+1&EF! ()9E&O591&!9ED$)(-3D&)1-!5-59''/!'&9%&!.&3()E8! !

³*R VWUDLJKW KRPH ´ VKH FRPPDQGV 6DPXHO RQFH WKH\ UHDFK WKH EXV VWRS

?+$D! 3&+! 2$()! ;5+-&! -3&! ,(%&-! 3(D! &L921! 239),&! J$+! 13&! +(E&F! D9G&-! 3(D! =9(1! $)! 13&! .&)23F! 9)E! +&D()E-! 3(D! 1391! 13&+&! 9+&! 9'-$! '&J1$%&+-! ()-(E&! 13&! +&J+(,&+91$+F! ;'&)1/! $J! ULFH LQ WKH HOHFWULF VWHDPHU ³,¶OO FDOO \RX DW VL[ VR \RX DQVZHU WKH SKRQH ´ VKH VD\V EULVNO\ DV LI DQRWKHU VHFRQG FDQ¶W EH ZDVWHG ! !

<3&)! =3('&! 3&9E(),! .92G! 1$! =$+GF! I$5(-9! ,'9)2&-! $%&+! 9! -3$5'E&+! 9)E! $.-&+%&-!

3(D! -(11(),! 9'$)&! 91! 13&! 2&)1&+! $J! 13&! .&)238! ! X9K(),! E$=)=9+EF! 3&! (-! -=(),(),! 13&! ;'9-1(2!19G&$51!.9,!.&1=&&)!3(-!G)&&-F!13&!.$=!;'92&E!.&-(E&!3(D8! ! Q51!9J1&+!9(D(),!3&+!

VWDUH IRUZDUG VKH VXGGHQO\ IHHOV XQHQFXPEHUHG E\ KHU VRQ¶V SORGGLQJ SUHVHQFH -5EE&)'/! 29+&J+&&! 9)E! 5)911923&EF! 9)E! )$=! =$)E&+-! (J! 3&+! '(J&! D(,31! 39%&! .&&)!

VRPHKRZ GLIIHUHQW :KDW LI VKH¶G FRPH WR /RV $QJHOHV \HDUV HDUOLHU DUULYLQJ KHUH DV QR RQH¶V ZLIH RU PRWKHU" :KDW LI DV D \RXQJHU ZRPDQ LW ZDV )UDQFLV VKH¶G PHW ILUVW ()-1&9E!$J!435)>1&T! ! ")E!=391!(JF!;$--(.'/F!-3&!2$5'E!-19+1!&%&+/13(),!9)&=T! !

<3&-&!)$1($)-!.$13!9D5-&!9)E!+&;&'!3&+8! ! #$F!)$1!()!13(-!'(J&F!I$5(-9!13()G-!=3('&!

,+())(),! 1$! 3&+-&'J8! ! 09/.&F! 13$5,3F! ()! 9! J515+&! '(J&1(D&²2$)2&(%9.'/! 3&+! )&L1! 35D9)! ()29+)91($)²VKH¶O'!.&!+&=9+E&E!=(13!-$D&$)&!E&2&)1!J$+!9!-;$5-&F!-$D&$)&!'(G&!?+9)2(-!

9-! 9! 2$D;9)($)! 9)E! 13&! -1&9EJ9-1! J913&+! $J! 3&+! $)'/! 23('E8! ! *&+39;-! 13&)F! ()! 1391!

5)G)$=9.'&!9)E!%9-1'/!E(JJ&+&)1!&L(-1&)2&F!3&+!/$513!9)E!3&+!$;1(D(-D!9.$51!'$%&!9)E! 3&+!-&)-&!$J!3$;&J5')&--!D(,31!.&!+&-1$+&E!1$!3&+8! ! #&%&+13&'&--F!-523!+5D()91($)-!9+&!

SURPSWO\ OHIW RQ WKH VLGHZDON GLVSHUVLQJ LQ IURQW RI WKH UHVWDXUDQW¶V HQWUDQFH²J$+,$11&)! =(13!13&!1/(),!$J!3&+!9;+$)F!13&!1&-1!-2+9123!$J!9!.9'';$()1!;&)!5;$)!3&+!)$1&;9E8! !!

H$$)! 13&! &%&)(),! +5-3! 2$DD&)2&-! 9-! 9! '91&! 9J1&+)$$)! 1+(2G'&8! ! 4$)E(D&)1-! 9+&!

+&J(''&EF!-&+%(&11&-!J$'E&EF!=91&+!,'9--&-!+&9E(&E8! ! ")E!$)'/!=3&)!13&!D9()!E()(),!+$$D! ,+$=-! 2+$=E&E! E$&-! I$5(-9! ;95-&! 9D$),! 13&! 19.'&-F! 3&+! ,9K&! 1+9%&'(),! J+$D! 13&! 2'$2G! 9.$%&! 13&! '$.-1&+! 19)G²c:aa²1$! 3&+! =+(-1=9123:! ! c:a]8! ! "+$5)E! 13&! -9D&! 1(D&! /&-1&+E9/F!-3&!+&9'(K&-F!3&+!=$+-1!J&9+-!2$)2&+)(),!H9D5&'!39E!9'+&9E/!.&,5)F!13&!;9)(2! ()2+&9-(),! D()51&! ./! D()51&8! ! Q51! 1$E9/! E5+(),! =$+GF! -()2&! '&9%(),! 3(D! 9'$)&! 91! 13&!

EXV VWRS KH KDGQ¶W UHDOO\ FU$--&E!3&+!D()EF!1$!13&!;$()1!=3&+&!3&+!;3$)&!29''!3$D&!(-! )$=!=&''!;9-1!E5&8! !

"D(E!13&!2+9D;&E!9(-'&!$J!19.'&-F!?+9)2(-!()9E%&+1&)1'/!.5D;-!9,9()-1!3&+!=3('&!

FDUU\LQJ D WHDSRW VD\LQJ ³:DWFK RXW ´ DV KH SURFHHGV IRUZDUG WKH ILQJHUV RI KLV IUHH 39)E!.+5-3(),!3&+!+(,31!=+(-18! !

³([FXVH PH ´ VKH UHSOLHV DQJOLQJ DVLGH \HW WKHUH LV D FROGQHVV LQ KLV IOHHWLQJ

1$523! 1391! -19+1'&-! 3&+! '(G&! 9! -3$2G! $J! -191(2F! 295-(),! 3&+! 1$! +&J'&L(%&'/! 2$%&+! 13&! =+(-1! =(13!3&+!$13&+!39)E!9)E!,+9-;!(1!9-!(J!-3&!=&+&!2$D;+&--(),!9!=$5)E8! ! <3&)!9''!91!$)2&!

9! -5+,&! $J! ()&L;'(29.'&! .'92G)&--F! $J! &)E'&--! -('&)2&! 9)E! (D;&)E(),! 1+9,&E/F! ;$5+-!

92+$--!3&+!2$)-2($5-)&--!'(G&!.91-!-=9+D(),!J+$D!9!29%&!()1$!13&!)(,318! ! V391!(-!13(-T! !

VKH DVNV KHUVHOI :KDW¶V KDSSHQLQJ" :KHUH¶V 6KXQJ>/$T! !

H3&!35++(&-!$JJ!13&!D9()!J'$$+F!,$(),!1$!13&! -19JJ!1&'&;3$)&!()!13&!G(123&)8! ! P&+!

J(+-1!911&D;1!91!29''(),!3$D&!(-!13=9+1&E!./!13&!922(E&)19'!;5-3(),!$J!9!=+$),!E(,(1F!-$!

-3&!39-!1$!39),!5;!.&J$+&!1+/(),!9,9()8! ! <3&!-&2$)E!911&D;1F!3$=&%&+F!(-!9!-522&--F!9)E! -3&!=9(1-!(D;91(&)1'/!J$+!=391!-&&D-!9)!()1&+D()9.'&!;&+($EF!19G(),!9!E&&;!.+&913!=3('&!

13&!29''!+(),-!13+$5,38! !

³+HOOR ´ 6DPXHO DQVZHUV FXWWLQJ WKH WKLUG ULQJ VKRUW !

!

<3&!-$5)E!$J!3(-!%$(2&!(DD&E(91&'/!+&'&9-&-!3&+!.+&913F!3(-!)9D&!&L39'&E!9-!9)!

9''&YLDWHG DOPRVW JDVSLQJ TXHVWLRQ ³6KXQJ>\R"´! !

³+H\ PD ´ KH VD\V ORZO\ WKH WHOHYLVLRQ SOD\LQJ LQ WKH EDFNJURXQG !

!

\5-1!13&)!13&!2$)J$5)E(),!9)E!;$+1&)1!E9+G)&--!-5.-(E&-F!;9--(),!'(G&!9!1+9)-(&)1!

FORXGEXUVW RQ DQ RWKHUZLVH VXQQ\ GD\ %XW VKH ZRQ¶W DSRO$,(K&!J$+!29''(),!'91&F!)$+!=(''!

VKH H[SUHVV WKDQNIXOQHVV DERXW NQRZLQJ KH¶V RND\ HYHQ WKRXJK HYHU\ LQFK RI KHU 2$5+-&-!=(13!+&'(&J8! ! <3&!.&-1!-3&!29)!E$!(-!9EE+&--!3(D!()!13&!-$'&!D9))&+!9%9('9.'&!1$!

3&+²13&! .'5)1! 1$)&! 92O5(+&E! J+$D! 3&+! $=)! D$13&+! 1391! ()-1()21(%&'/! -9J&,59+E-! 3&+! %5')&+9.('(1(&-F! 3&+! ()-&25+(1(&-F! /&1! $J1&)! 2$)J5-&-! J&&'(),-! $J! 1&)E&+)&--! J$+! -(,)-! $J! =&9G)&--8! !

³<RX ORFN WKH IURQW GRRU"´!

!

³0P ´!

!

³%DFN GRRU"´!

!

³0P ´!

!

³6R KRZ FRPH \RX¶UH ZDWFKLQJ 79" +RZ PXFK GLG \RX VWXG\ WRQLJKW"´!

!

³)LQLVKHG DOUHDG\ ´!

!

³<RX SUDFWLFH WKH YLROLQ WRR"´!

!

³0P ´!

!

³(QRXJK OLHV , GRQ¶W EHOLHYH \RX $UH \RX O\LQJ"´!

!

6DPXHO GRHVQ¶W VD\ DQ\WKLQJ !

!

³6KXQJ>\R ´ /RXLVD WHOOV KLP ³GRQ¶W ZDVWH \RXU OLIH 3HRSOH ZKR ZDVWH WKHLU

OLYHV DOVR ZDVWH WKHLU SDUHQWV¶! WLPH DQG PRQH\ 'RQ¶W EH OLNH WKDW <RX JR SUDFWLFH QRZ DQG PDNH VXUH WKH GRRUV DUH ORFNHG ´ 6KH SDXVHV H[SHFWLQJ KLP WR VD\ VRPHWKLQJ EXW KHDUV RQO\ WKH IDLQW 79 QRLVHV LQ WKH OLYLQJ URRP ³<RX JR WR EHG HDUO\ ´ VKH ILQDOO\ VD\V ³,¶OO EH KRPH ODWHU ´! !

³0P ´!

!

")E!9J1&+!-(,3(),!J$+!)$!92159'!+&9-$)F!-3&!39),-!5;!13&!;3$)&8!

! !! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! @AdC! !

V(13! 13&! 3()E-(,31! $J! D9)/! /&9+-F! H9D5&'! =(''! 23$$-&! 1$! +&D&D.&+! 13(-! ;9+1(25'9+! <5&-E9/! 9-! .&(),! 3$1! 9)E! -1(J'(),8! ! P&! =(''F! =(13! 2$D;'&1&! 2'9+(1/F! +&29''! 3(-! .92G;92G! =&(,3(),! 3&9%/! 5;$)! 3(DF! -=&91! E+(;;(),! J+$D! 3(-! J$+&3&9E! 5)E&+! 9! .'9K(),! -5)F! 9)E! KH¶O'! &JJ$+1'&--'/! +&29;15+&! 13&! 9)L(&1/! 1391! ;'9,5&E! 3(D! =3&)! =9'G(),! 9'$)&! 1$! 13&!

"D&+(29)! =$D9)S-! 9;9+1D&)18! ! Q51! ()! +&9'(1/! 1$E9/! (-! 5)-&9-$)9.'/! 2$$'²9)! "'9-G9)!

-1$+D!J+$)1!39%(),!-9('&E!13+$5,3!13&!%9''&/!$%&+)(,31F!(1-!=9G&!.'$=(),!13&!+5-3!3$5+!

-D$,! J9+! ()'9)E! 1$=9+E! 13&! E&-&+1F! '&9%(),! .&3()E! 9! 2'$5E'&--! .'5&! -G/! 9)E! 9! D('E! DIWHUQRRQ EUHH]H 7KHUH LVQ¶W UHDOO\ DQ\ VZHDW JOLVWHQLQJ RQ KLV IRUHKHDG QRU GRHV KLV EDFNSDFN EXUGHQ KLP XQGXO\ 7KH DQ[LHW\ KRZHYHU H[LVWV H[DFWO\ OLNH KH¶OO DOZD\V +&2$''&21!(1²13&!1$+15$5-!9;;+&3&)-($)F!9!;+$J$5)E!-&)-91($)!$J!(D;&)E(),!35D('(91($)!

9)E!J9('5+&²JDWKHULQJ VWUHQJWK RQ WKH UHVLGHQWLDO VLGHZDONV VORZLQJ KLP ,W¶V QRW IDLU KH WKLQNV DJDLQ DQG DJDLQ ,W¶V QRW IDLU ! !

7++(191($)! 15,-! 91! 3(-! J92&F! 1=(123(),! 9D$),! 9! E(-2$)2&+1&E! &L;+&--($)8! ! P$=!

$J1&)! 39E! 3(-! D$13&+! 2951($)&E! 3(D! 9.$51! D&&1(),! -1+9),&+-T! ! "! 13$5-9)E! 1(D&-T! !

09/.&! D$+&T! ! U&1! )$=! 13$-&! +&;&91&E! =9+)(),-! D&9)! )$13(),8! ! 7)-1&9EF! -3&! (-! ()-(-1(),! 1391! 3&! G)$2G! $)! 13&! E$$+! $J! 9! 1$19'! -1+9),&+F! ;+&-&)1(),! 3(D-&'J! 1$! -$D&!

ZRPDQ ZKR SUREDEO\ ZRQ¶W FRPSUHKHQG D ZRUG KH WHOOV KHU H[FHSW ³+D>'$8! ! 0/! )9D&²8'²H9D>&&'²´ $QG WKHQ ZKDW LV KH VXSSRVHG WR GR" $QG ZKDW LI KH FDQ¶W JHW 13&!J(,5+()&-T! ! <3&)!=391!39;;&)-T! ! ,W¶V QRW IDLU8! !

Z)2$5)1&+(),! )$! $13&+! -$5'! J$+! 9! =3$'&! .'$2GF! H9D5&'! J()9''/! 9++(%&-! 91! 13&!

9;9+1D&)1!.5('E(),!9)EF!-52G(),!$)!3(-!.$11$D!'(;F!-'()G-!9'$),!13&!=9'G=9/!1$!-19)E!()!

13&!+&'91(%&!-39E&!$J!(1-!'92G'5-1&+!J929E&8! ! P&!;95-&-!13&+&F!-5++&;1(1($5-'/!E9+1(),!3(-!

-19+&!.92G!9)E!J$+13F!-29))(),!13&!J(+-1!J'$$+!5)(1-!'(G&!9!13(&J!;$)E&+(),!9)!&)1+/!;$()18! !

Z923! =()E$=! 25+19()! (-! -3518! ! <3&! M511(),! 9(+! 2$)E(1($)&+-! 9+&! ()921(%&8! ! <3&! $)'/! $.-&+%9.'&! -(,)! $J! '(J&! 3&! -;(&-! (-! 9! ;'5D;F! ,+9/(-3! 19../! 291! 1391! '$5),&-! 3(,3! $)! 13&! )&9+&-1!-19(+29-&F!(1-!-3()/!J5+!1(),&E!./!-5)'(,318! ! I9K(),!92+$--!9!D(EE'&!-1&;F!13&!291F! 1$$F! (-! -19+(),! =(13! 9! -1&9'13/! ,9K&! J+$D! =3&+&! (1! +&-1-F! ,+&&)! &/&-! 39'J! 2+92G&E! 9)E! =9123(),!3(D!.&'$=8! !

%XW ZKHQ KH PRYHV LQ WKH GLUHFWLRQ RI WKH VWDLUV WKH FDW¶V KHDG VZLIWO\ OLIWV !9''!91!

$)2&! (1-! 2$+;5'&)1! .$E/! -;+(),-! ()1$! 921($)²$)&! D$D&)1! +&'9L&E! 9)E! (E'&F! 13&! )&L1!

D$D&)1!E9-3(),!5;!13&!-1&;-F!,$)&8! ! H9D5&'!-19+1-!2'(D.(),!13&!-19(+29-&²-'5,,(-3'/F! D$+.(E'/²'$$G(),! E$=)! =3('&! ,'(E(),! 9! ;9'D! $%&+! 13&! =+$5,31>(+$)! 39)E+9('F! 3$;(),!

EH\RQG KRSH WKDW WKH ZRPDQ LVQ¶W DURXQG WR DQVZHU KLV NQRFN 3OHDVH KH WKLQNV GRQ¶W .&!3$D&F!;'&9-&8! ! P&!+9(-&-!3(-!23()!M5-1!.&J$+&!D$5)1(),!13&!1$;!-1&;!9)E!29123&-!-(,31! $J!13&!291!9,9()8! ! 71!-(1-!-&%&+9'!J&&1!9=9/!$)!9!.+$=)!V&'2$D&!D91F!J92(),!9)!$;&)!J+$)1!

E$$+! 9-! (J! =9(1(),! J$+! 3(D! 1$! J$''$=8! ! ^(,31! 9J1&+! 3&! +&923&-! 13&! -1$$;F! 13&! 291! .$'1-!

13+$5,3! 13&! E$$+=9/F! E(-9;;&9+(),! ()-(E&! 13&! %&+/! 9;9+1D&)1! 1391! 3(-! D$13&+! 39E! ;$()1&E!$51!1$!3(D!/&-1&+E9/:! ! e_8! !

"'13$5,3! -()2&! 13&! E$$+! (-! ;5''&E! =(E&F! J9-3($)(),! 9! E9+G! 9)E! +&219),5'9+! ,9;!

9D(E!9!+$=!$J!2'$-&E!15+O5$(-&!E$$+-F!(1!19G&-!9!=3('&!J$+!13(-!1$!-()G!()8! ! "!-;92&!$J!9!

J&=! -&2$)E-! ,$&-! ./! 5)1('! 3&! +&9'(K&-! =3(23! 9;9+1D&)1! 3$'E-! 13&! J(,5+()&-F! 13$-&!

E&'(.&+91(%&!-&2$)E-!9.-$+.&E!=(13!9!,+5E,(),!-1('')&--8! ! P&!,'9)2&-!91!13&!$13&+!13+&&!

9;9+1D&)1!E$$+-²efF!ecF!e`²13&)!J(L&-!3(-!,9K&!$)!13&!)5D.&+'&--!%$(EF!9)E!-5EE&)'/!

13&!-G()!9+$5)E!3(-!D$513!1(,31&)-F!9)E!3(-!-1$D923!E+$;-F!9)E!9!J&&'(),!$J!E$$D!-;(''-!

J+$D! 3(-! -G5''! 1$! =9-3! 92+$--! 3(-! &)1(+&! .$E/8! ! P$=&%&+F! 9-! (J! 13&/! 1$$! 39%&! 9! =(''! $J! 13&(+!$=)F!3(-!1&))(-!-3$&-!;+&-&)1'/!()23!J$+=9+E!E&-;(1&!3(-!+&'5219)2&F!-35JJ'(),!3(D! ()! J5+1(%&! -19+1-! 9)E! -1$;-8! ! H35JJ'&F! -35JJ'&F! -1$;8! ! H35JJ'&F! -35JJ'&F! -1$;8! ! H35JJ'&F! -35JJ'&²! !

";;+$923(),! 91! 9)! ()E(+&21! 9),'&F! 3&! &9-&-! $)1$! 13&! V&'2$D&! D91! 9)E! ;&&G-!

2951($5-'/! ;9-1! 13&! E$$+=9/F! -O5()1(),! =3('&! 3(-! &/&-! 9EM5-18! ! <3&! 9;9+1D&)1! (-! E(DF! 9'D$-1!=(13$51!9)/!(''5D()91($)8! ! ?9+13&+!.92GF!.&/$)E!13&!-39;&-!$J!J5+)(15+&F!3&!29)!

-&&!-5)'(,31!,'$=(),!J9()1'/!.&3()E!E+9=)!25+19()-F!29-1(),!&%&+/13(),!()!-('3$5&11&8! ! "!

2+$--! .+&&K&! E+(J1-! $51! $J! 13&! E$$+=9/F! 9)E! 3(-! -&)-&! $J! -D&''! ()1&)-(J(&-F! E&1&21(),! 9!

-5.1'&F!-(2G'/!-=&&1!$E$+²'(G&!J+5(1!1391!39-!+(;&)&E!1$$!'$),F!'(G&!E&29/8! ! Q51!)$!35D9)!

D$%&D&)1! (-! 9;;9+&)1! ()-(E&8! ! ")E! 13&+&! (-! )$! 1+92&! $J! 13&! 291! 1391! 39E! J'&E! ()1$! 13&!

DSDUWPHQW¶V VKDGRZV DQG DEVROXWH TXLHW ! !

:LWK JURZLQJ WUHSLGDWLRQ 6DPXHO PXWWHUV ³+D>OR ´ VR VRIWO\ WKDW KH FDQ

EDUHO\ KHDU LW KLPVHOI ³+D>OR ´ KH UHSHDWV UDLVLQJ KL-!%$(2&!9!'(11'&8! !

H('&)2&8!

!

+H NQRFNV OLJKWO\ RQ WKH GRRU IUDPH ³+D>OR ´!

!

<3&!-('3$5&11&-!+&D9()!-191(28! ! #$1!9!-(),'&!-$5)E!&)'(%&)-!13&!;'92&8!

!

U&1!-$D&13(),!9.$51!13&!-('&)2&!.&,()-!1$!J&&'!%9,5&'/!(++(191(),F!9)E!9-!9!+&-5'1!

3(-!G)52G'&-!E&'(%&+!13+&&!-$'(E!+9;-!$)!13&!E$$+!J+9D&F!13&!)$(-&!+&-$)91(),!'$5E&+!139)!

3&!39E!()1&)E&E8! ! "!=9%&!$J!-5+;+(-&!M$'1-!3(-!'(D.-F!.+(&J'/!(DD$.('(K(),!3(D8! ! H&%&+9'!

5)&9-/! -&2$)E-! ;9--8! ! "3&9E! $J! 3(D! 13&! 25+19()-! +(;;'&! =(13! 9! E5-G/! 35&F! .51! 9-(E&!

J+$D! 13&! .+&&K&! )$13(),! &'-&! D$%&-! 1$=9+E! 3(D8! ! ^&'(&%&EF! H9D5&'! 19G&-! ()! 9! .+&913!

9)E!3(-!-3$5'E&+-!-'92G&)8! ! <3&!1&)-&!'$$G!$)!3(-!J92&!+&1+&91-F!13$5,3!9!D$D&)1!'91&+!

13&!&L;+&--($)!+&15+)-!9-!3&!J()E-!3(D-&'J!=$)E&+(),!=391!1$!E$!)$=8! ! <3&!=$D9)F!(1!

VHHPV LVQ¶W KRPH ZL2&;1! =3/! (-)S1! 13&! E$$+! -351T! ! V3/! (-)S1! (1! '$2G&ET! ! 09/.&!

VRPHRQH UREEHG WKH DSDUWPHQW 2U PD\EH WKH GRRU ZDVQ¶W FORVHG VHFXUHO\ ZKHQ VKH OHIW DQG WKH ZLQG HYHQWXDOO\ VZXQJ LW RSHQ 2U PD\EH LW¶V NHSW RSHQ IRU WKH FDW %XW =3/T! !

I(G&! 9! '&%&&! 9.+5;1'/! -;+(),(),! 9! '&9GF! 9! +9-3! (D;5'-&! J'$$E-! ()1$! 3(-! ;+5E&)1!

D()EF! 91! J(+-1! ()9+1(25'91&! 9)E! 5)J$25-&E8! ! <3&)! 9! J+9)1(2! 13$5,31! .5+-1-! J$+13! 9)E! 29+&&)-!=('E'/!9-!(J!(1!=&+&!9!-23$$'!$J!+9;92($5-!J(-3!;5+-5(),!9!-(),5'9+!$.M&21(%&:! ! 91# 9")# )$"# 7.6')%5':# $,..68! ! ?+$D! =391! 3(-! &/&-! E(-2&+)F! 13&! 9;9+1D&)1! 9;;&9+-! +913&+! )9++$=F! -D9''&+! 139)! 9)! 9%&+9,&>-(K&E! <9(;&(! J'918! ! "''! 3&! 39-! 1$! E$! (-! &)1&+! 13&! ;'92&F! TXLFNO\ ILQG KLV PRWKHU¶V FROOHFWLEOHV DQG GDVK EDFN RXW ZLWK WKHP &DQ W EH WRR KDUG 3&!2$)2'5E&-²5)'&-V RI FRXUVH WKH ZRPDQ FRPHV KRPH ZKLOH KHµV LQVLGH 7KH LGHD RI WKDW KDSSHQLQJ GDPSHQV WKH LPSXOVH D ELW ,Q IDFW KH FDQ¶W LPDJLQH D ZRUVH IDWH WKDQ .&(),! 295,31! -1&9'(),F! &-;&2(9''/! -()2&! 3&! 39-! 9'+&9E/! .&&)! -39D&E! 9)E! ;5)(-3&E! &)$5,3! E5+(),! 13&! ;+&%($5-! 1=$! E9/-8! ! ")E! /&1! -3$5'E! 3&! 1+5'/! =9)1! 1$! 1&D;&+! 3(-!

PRWKHU¶V OLQJHULQJ UHVHQWPHQW²1$!91!'&9-1!E(D()(-3!3&+!-2$+)!J$+!3(DF!1$!+&-1$+&!-$D&!

9D$5)1!$J!;&92&!91!3$D&²WKHUH LVQ¶W PXFK FKRLFH ! !

P(-!1&))(-!-3$&-!,(),&+'/!.+&923!13&!13+&-3$'EF!-()G(),!E$=)!$)!,+&&)>.'5&!-39,!

29+;&1F!9)E!$)2&!3&!2+$--&-!13+$5,3!13&!E$$+=9/!13&!9;9+1D&)1!.+(,31&)-!9+$5)E!3(D8! !

<3&! -('3$5&11&-! -'$='/! +&%&9'! 13&D-&'%&-F! 13&! D5+G()&--! 9.91(),! =3&)! 3&! 2+&&;-!

IRUZDUG ³+D>OR ´ KH VD\V LQ D VXEGXHG TXHVWLRQLQJ YRLFH WKH ZHLUG RG$+!()2+&9-(),!

9-! 3&! 2$)1()5&-! D$%(),8! ! Q51! )$! $)&! 9)-=&+-! 3(DF! )$13(),! (-! 3&9+E! =391-$&%&+8! ! "!

'9+,&! D93$,9)/! E()(),! 19.'&! -1+&123&-! .&-(E&! 3(DF! ;('&E! 3(,3! J+$D! &)E! 1$! &)E! =(13!

-192G-!$J!)&=-;9;&+-F!D9,9K()&-F!9)E!M5)G!D9('8! ! N)!3(-!$13&+!-(E&F!9,9()-1!9!=9''F!9+&!

1=$!(E&)1(29'!-&2+&19+/!E&-G-F!.$13! 9'-$!.5+(&E!5)E&+!9)!9225D5'91($)!$J!2'511&+8! ! <3&!

E&-G-!9)E!19.'&!J$+D!9!2+9D;!;9--9,&F!9)E!H9D5&'!D5-1!15+)!3(-!.$E/!-'(,31'/!()!$+E&+!

1$!;9--!.&1=&&)!13&D8! !

P&! -$$)! ,$&-! .&/$)E! 9! ;9(+! $J! D9123(),! '92O5&+&E! .$$G29-&-! 1391! E(%(E&! 13&!

+$$DF!&D&+,(),!=3&+&!13&!'$),!=3(1&!25+19()-!J'511&+!)&9+!9)!$'E!.+$=)!+&2'()&+!239(+!

9)E!9)!&%&)!$'E&+!<R!2$)-$'&8! ! <3&!.+&&K&!2+92G-!13&!25+19()-! ()1&+D(11&)1'/!1$!13+$=!

J'9-3&-!$J!'(,31!92+$--! 13&!9O59>2$'$+&E!29+;&1F!'(G&!E&;13! 239+,&-! &L;'$E(),!.&)&913!9! )$215+)9'!-&98! ! <3&)!3(-!()1&)1!,9K&!35++(&-!=(13!3(D!()!13&!-9D&!E(+&21($)F!$.'(%($5-!91!

13(-!D$D&)1!1$!&%&+/13(),!&'-&!-9%&!J$+!13&!E$('/>2$%&+&E!1$;!$J!13&!<R!2$)-$'&8! ! 7)!3(-!

KDVWH KH GRHVQ¶W QRWLFH WKH KDOOZD\ RYHU WR WKH '&J1F! 13&! G(123&)! $JJ! 1$! 13&! +(,318! ! <3&!

J+9D&E! ;(215+&-! 39),(),! $)! 13&! =9''-²J92&-F! 9)(D9'-F! '9)E-29;&-²GRQµW GUDZ KLV DWWHQWLRQ $QG KH LVQ¶W DZDUH WKDW WKH FXUWDLQV FRQFHDO PRUH WKDQ DQ RSHQ ZLQGRZ RU 1391! 13&! -;&21+9'>'(G&! $51'()&! )$=! 9-2&)E(),! .&3()G WKHP RQ WKH DSDUWPHQW¶V EDOFRQ\ 39-!.&&)!2+$523&E!13&+&!9D$),!;$11&E!J'$=&+-²(1-!,+9E59'F!5)$.-&+%&E!D$%&D&)1-!9-! ()2$)-&O5&)1(9'!1$!3(D!9-!9!2'$5E!E(DD(),!13&!-5)8! !

N+,9)(K&E!)&91'/!.&J$+&!3(D!$)!13&!E$('/!9+&!%9+($5-!-D9''!G&&;-9G&-F!13&!G()E!$J!

251&! 13(),-! 3(-! $=)! D$13&+! =$5'E! 39;;('/! 2$%&1! 9)E! -3$=29-&8! ! ")! 9++9/! $J! 3$'(E9/! $+)9D&)1-8! ! P9)E>;$'(-3&E! D9+.'&F! $)/LF! 9)E! -1$)&! &,,-8! ! *$+2&'9()! 13(D.'&-8! ! U&1!

3(-! ,9K&! (-! 1+9)-J(L&E! $)'/! ./! 13&! 1=$! 2$''&21(.'&-! 1391! 9+&! E(-;'9/&E! 91! 13&! J$+&J+$)1! $J! 13&! 2$)-$'&! 1$;²/RXLVDµV FU\VWDO EHDJOH KHU )RUJHW>0&>#$1! 2+/-19'! J'$=&+! ;$1²&923! ;$-(1($)&E! ;+$D()&)1'/! 93&9E! $J! 9''! 13&! $13&+! ;(&2&-F! '(G&! 9.-5+E! ,&)&+9'-! '&9E(),! 9)! &O59''/!9.-5+E!9+D/8! ! P&!'(J1-!9)!9+DF!+&923(),!1$!,+9.!13&!J(,5+()&-!=(13$51!9!-&2$)E! 13$5,318! ! Q51!M5-1!13&)!13&!25+19()-!-35EE&+!9;9+1!9'$),!13&!2&)1&+F!,(%(),!3(D!-523!9!

-19+1!1391!3(-!9+D!+&J'&L(%&'/!E+$;-F!3(-!J(),&+-!J$'E(),!()1$!9)!&D;1/>39)E&E!J(-18! ! ?$+!

9)! ()-19)1! 13&! 2$+)&+! ()! =3(23! 3&! -19)E-! (-! -&1! 9,'$=! =(13! ,'9+(),! '(,31F! 9)E! =3&)! 13&!

25+19()-! -'(;! .92G! ()1$! ;'92&F! 9! 1+$5.'(),! -39E$=! J9''-! 5;$)! 3(DF! ,(%(),! 3(D! 9)$13&+!

-19+18! ! !

!

³2K P\ ´ D IUDLO VFUDWFK\ YRLFH VXGGHQO\ VD\V ³2K P\ ´!

!

H&(K&E!./!;9)(2F!H9D5&'!1=(-1-!3(D-&'J!9+$5)E8! ! P&!-3$$1-!9!,9;(),!-19+&!1$=9+E!

13&! 25+19()-F! ()(1(9''/! ;&+2&(%(),! 9! -=913! $J! (D;&)&1+9.'&! 2'$13²9)! 95-1&+&! ,9+E&)(),!

9;+$)F!9-!.'92G!9-!13&!)(,31!-G/²13&)!,3$-1'/!=3(1&!39)E-F!13&!-'(D!J(),&+-!,+(;;(),!9)!

9'5D()5D! =91&+(),! 29)8! ! #&%&+13&'&--F! (1! (-! 13&! =+()G'&EF! ;9'&! J92&! )$=! 3$'E(),! 3(-!

-19+&! 1391! ;+$%(E&-! 13&! ,+&91&-1! %&L91($)²13$-&! -3()(),F! 9)(D91&E! &/&-! ;&&+(),! ;'&9-9)1'/! 91! 3(DF! 13&! ,&)(9'(1/! 2$)%&/&E! ./! 9)! 5)2$D;'(291&E! -D('&! E&%$(E! $J! &L;&2191($)-²9;;&9+(),!'(G&!13&!-91(-J(&E!&L;+&--($)!$J!9!'(11'&!G(E!=3$!39-!M5-1!+&2&(%&E! 9!E&-(+&E!1+&91F!/&1!.&'$),(),!()-1&9E!1$!9!%&+/!$'E!=$D9)!()!9!,+9/!3$5-&E+&--8! !

³,VQ¶W LW VRPHWKLQJ ´ 0DULRQ VD\V VRXQGLQJ ERWK DPD]HG DQG FHUWDLQ ³,W¶V \RX

6DP <RX¶UH DFWXDOO\ KHUH 2K P\ ´! !

/LNH D GHHU FDXJKW E\ FDU EHDPV 6DPXHO GRHVQ¶W DOWHU KLV SHWULILHG JD]H RU

+&-;$)E! =(13! 9-! D523! 9-! 9! .'()G8! ! P(-! .+9()! 2&''-! -2+9D.'&! ()! 239$-F! 5+,(),! 9! -;&&E/! +&1+&91F!&L2&;1!3(-!'&,-!9+&!J+$K&)F!3(-!3&9+1!.&91(),!J9-18! !

³/HW¶V VHH \RX \HV ´!

!

09+($)!;51-!13&!=91&+(),!29)!$)!13&!+&2'()&+!-&91F!9!+(),!$J!D$(-15+&!=&11(),!13&!

25-3($)8! ! b&&;(),! 3&+! ,'&9D(),! &/&-! 9(D&E! 91! 3(DF! -3&! 1$11&+-! 1$! 13&! 25+19()-F! -3$5'E&+-! 35)23&EF! 9)E! -;+&9E-! 13&D! &)$5,3! -$! 1391! 13&! +$$D! .&2$D&-! +9E(9)18! !

H9D5&'! -O5()1-! 5)2$DJ$+19.'/F! J&&'(),! &%&)! D$+&! &L;$-&E! 9)E! %5')&+9.'&! =(13()! 13&!

9J1&+)$$)!'(,31F!9-!(J!3&!=&+&!)$=!-19)E(),!)9G&E!()!J+$)1!$J!3&+8! ! ! !

³,W V ZRQGHUIXO ´ VKH VD\V FRPLQJ IRUZDUG DEVHQWO\ ZLSLQJ KHU SDOPV DFURVV WKH

DSURQ ³<RX GLG LW <RX IRXQG PH $UHQ W \RX VRPHWKLQJ ´! !

+H FDQ¶W IDWKRP PRVW DQ\WKLQJ WKLV SHFXOLDU ZRPDQ LV FRPPXQLFDWLQJ²9''!$J!(1!

(D;9+1&E! '(G&! +(EE'&-! ./! 9! +9-;/! "D&+(29)! %$(2&F! 13&! 1$)&! O5(%&+(),! 9-! '$='/! 9-! ()-&21! =(),-8! ! N)'/! -&%&+9'! 23$(2&! =$+E-! 39E! D9)9,&E! 1$! .+&9G! 13+$5,3! 13&! '9),59,&! .9++(&+²1$F!;F!61,F!2"F!26F!8)F#6"'²9'13$5,3!3&+!.&91(J(2!&L;+&--($)!1&''-!3(D!1391!-3&!

LVQ¶W DQJU\ WKDW KLV LQWUXVLRQ LV IRU VRPH RGG UHDVRQ ZHOFRPHG UDWKHU WKDQ DEKRUUHG ! !

³2K \HV KHUH \RX DUH ´!

!

?+$D!9!J&=!J&&1!9=9/!-3&!39E!-&&D&E!19''&+8! ! Q51!=3&)!()23(),!2'$-&+!-3&!.&,9)!

1$! -3+()GF! -D9''&+! 9)E! -D9''&+F! 5)1('! 13&(+! &/&-! 9+&! 9'D$-1! '&%&'F! 13&(+! 3&9E-! 9)E! -3$5'E&+-!9'D$-1!9'(,)&E8! ! P&+!.5)23&E!39(+!+&-&D.'&-!+9=!-('GF!9)E!3&+!-G()F!2$%&+&E! ./!9!=&.!$J!=+()G'&-F!(-!-$!;9'&!9)E!13()!1391!(1!2$5'E!.&!D9E&!$J!+(2&!;9;&+[!-3&!'$$G-!

'(G&! E+(&E>5;! %&,&191($)F! .+(11'&! 9)E! -'&)E&+F! 9-! 13$5,3! -3&! D(,31! 2+5D.'&! ()1$! ;(&2&-!

-3$5'E!13&!.+&&K&!;5-3!39+E!9,9()-1!3&+8! ! P&+!2$'$+'&--!&/&-!9+&!)$=!'$2G&E!J(+D'/!5;$)!

3(D! 91! 2'$-&! +9),&8! ! P&+! '(;-! D$%&F! 1+&D.'(),F! /&1! )$13(),! (-! -;$G&)! J$+! 9! D$D&)18! ! )LQDOO\ LQ DQ DGPLULQJ WRQH VKH PXUPXUV ³7KH \RXQ,! H9D! 7! )&%&+! D&18! ! P$=!

KDQGVRPH \RX DUH ´ 6KH VWURNHV KLV OHIW FKHHN ZLWK WKH EDFN RI D KDQG DQG VWLOO ;&1+(J(&EF!3&!2+(),&-!9!.(1!9-!3&+!G)52G'&-!9)E!J(),&+-!&9-&!,&)1'/!E$=)!3(-!J92&F!-D&''(),! '$1($)F!9)E!;&+J5D&F!9)E!13&!-(2G'/!$E$+!1391!()39.(1-!13H SODFH ³,W¶G EH QLFH LI \RX¶G VWD\ D OLWWOH ZKLOH 'R \RX WKLQN LW¶V SRVVLEOH"´! !

7KHQ 0DULRQ¶V H\HV VTXHH]H VKXW +HU OLSV WZLWFK ZKLOH VKH UHWUDFWV KHU KDQG

9)E!2'9D;-!(1!$%&+!3&+!D$5138! ! "!-&+(&-!$J!,5115+9'!2$5,3-!+911'&!J+$D!E&&;!()-(E&!3&+F! 2+92G'(),!13+$5,3!3&+!23&-1!9-!(J!13&/!=&+&!-3911&+(),!.$)&-F!&+5;1(),!91!3&+!;9'D!=(13!

-523! %$'5D&! 1391! H9D5&'! (-! -39G&)! $51! $J! 3(-! ;9+9'/K&E! -191&8! ! <,-=! ! 3(-! .+9()!

-5EE&)'/!(D;'$+&-!3(D8! ! 5XQ 6KH¶V WRR ZHDN 6KH ZRQ W FDWFK \RX ! ! Q51!3&!+&-(-1-!

13&! (D;&15-! 1$! (DD&E(91&'/! J'&&F! &-;&2(9''/! -()2&! (1! =$5'E! D&9)! '&9%(),! =(13$51! 13&!

ILJXULQHV %HVLGHV WKH ZRPDQ GRHVQ¶W IHHO WKDW IULJKWHQLQJ DQ\PRUH MXVW XQXVXDO $QG PD\EH LI KH FDQ QRZ H[SODLQ KLV SUHGLFDPHQW VKHµG KDYH V\PSDWK\ IRU KLV -(1591($)8! ! 7J! 3&! 2$5'E! -$D&3$=! &L;+&--! 3(D-&'J! ()! 9)! 5)E&+-19)E9.'&! =9/F! -3&! D(,31!

G()E'/!9''$=!3(D!1$!19G&!13&!J(,5+()&-!3$D&8! !

³2K JRRG \RX GLGQ¶W GLVDSSHDU ´ 0DULRQ VD\V DIWHU RSHQLQJ KHU H\HV KHU YRLFH

PXIIOHG E\ WKH SDOP WKDW SUHVVHV RQ KHU PRXWK ³3DUGRQ PH ´ 63&!'$=&+-!3&+!39)EF! +&%&9'(),!9!.(,!,+()F!9)E!=(;&-!13&!;9'D!92+$--!3&+!9;+$)8! !

³8P ´ 6DPXHO PXWWHUV QHUYRXVO\ ³8P²´ 7KH (6/ FODVV KDGQ¶W \HW SUHSDUHG

3(D!J$+!13(-!-$+1!$J!2$)%&+-91($)F!)$+!39E!7KUHH¶V &RPSDQ\8! ! 7)2'()(),!3(-!3&9E!=(13!9!

2$)-1&+)91&E!&L;+&--($)F!3&!,&-15+&-!1$=9+E!13&!J(,5+()&-!.&3()E!3(DF!.'()E'/!,/+91(),!

9)!9+D!9.$%&!13&!<R!2$)-$'&!()!9!2(+25'9+!D$1($)8! ! P(-!&/&-!)9++$=!9-!3&!-&9+23&-!3(-!

D&D$+/F! -1+(%(),! 1$! E(%()&! 13$-&! 2$D;'(291&E! =$+E-! 9)E! -&)1&)2&-! 1391! 3&! -(D;'/!

GRHVQ¶W NQRZ ³8D²´! !

09+($)!)$E-F!,'9)2(),!91!3(-!D$1($)(),!9+DF!91!13&!$.M&21-!$)!13&!E$('/F!91!3(D8! !

³<RX UHPHPEHU PRVW RI WKRVH GRQ¶W \RX"´ +HU ORWLRQ>-2&)1&E!J(),&+-!2+$--!13&!-;92&!

EHWZHHQ WKHP DQG DUFK KLV FKLQ ³, KDYHQ¶W TXLW FROOHFWLQJ \RX NQRZ 2XU FROOHFWL$)!

NHHSV JURZLQJ ´! !

H9D5&'! 3&-(191&-! J$+! 9! 1(D&F! )$=! -19+(),! ()1$! ;5;('-! 1391! 9+&! 39+E'/! D$+&! 139)!

%925$5-!E$1-8! ! P&!-1$;-!,&-15+(),!9)E!=(13E+9=-!3(-!9+DF!E$(),!-$!9-!3&+!J(),&+-!E+(J1!

J+$D!3(-!23()8! ! <3&)!3&!;'5),&-!93&9EF!511&+(),!13&!$)'/!D&9)(),J5'!13(),!1391!+&9E('/!

SUHVHQWV LWVHOI ³+D>OR ´ KH VD\V SODLQO\ ! !

³+HOOR 6DP ´ VKH UHSOLHV VZD\LQJ OLNH D ZLOWHG IORZHU ³,¶YH PLVVHG \RX ,WµV

EHHQ WRR ORQJ ´! !

³8P²7²7!E$)²-;&&G²7!E$)!'>""(²Z)>'(-38! ! ?-58'$ ´!

!

³2I FRXUVH WKDW¶-!+(,318! ! #$1!/&1!9)/=9/8! ! H$$)!/$5!=(''F!/$5S''!-&&8! ! R&+/F!%&+/!

VRRQ ´! !

³8P²D/²D/!)9D&²(-²8'²H9D²&&'8! ! 3%2""58! ! N3>ND\"´!

!

³, NQRZ GHDU ´ 0DULRQ DQVZHUV ZLWK KHU EHQLJQ XQZDYHULQJ JD]H RI

VHQVLWLYLW\ ³6WD\ D ZKLOH ZRQ¶W \RX"´! !

*'&9-&!J$+,(%&!D&F!H9D5&'!E&-;&+91&'/!=9)1-!1$!1&''!3&+8! ! <3$-&!1=$!2+/-19'-!13&+&!

DUH P\ PRWKHU¶V ,W¶V P\ IDXOW \RX ERXJKW WKHP EHFDXVH , WUDGHG WKHP DW WKH SDZQVKRS DQG VKH GLGQ¶W JLYH PH SHUPLVVLRQ WR GR WKDW DQG VKH V XSVHW DERXW ZKDW , GLG ,¶P VRUU\ <RX¶UH D QLFH ZRD9)F!-$!2$5'E!/$5!;'&9-&!'&1!D&!39%&!13&D!.92G!-$!D/!D$13&+! =$)S1!.&!-$!5;-&1T# !

%XW LQVWHDG KH VWDPPHUV ³8P²D/²D9²D/²5D²D/²D9>&".² ´ ZKLOH WKH

9.-$'51&! (D;$--(.('(1/! $J! 9+1(25'91(),! 3(D-&'J! -2+&=-! 5;! 3(-! J92&! =(13! 9! ;9()&E! '$$G8! ! ³8P²´ 6HQVLQJ KLV RZQ I51('(1/F! 3&! 9,9()! D$%&-! 9)! 9+DF! ()1&)E(),! 1$! 15+)! 9)E! ;$()1!

E(+&21'/! 91! 13&! 1=$! J(,5+()&-8! ! <3$5,3! .&J$+&! 3&! 29)! E$! -$F! 09+($)! 19G&-! 3$'E! $J! 3(-! +(-(),!39)EF!E+9=(),!(1!9)E!3(D!1$=9+E!3&+F!;9--(%&'/F! 9-!13$5,3!-3&!=&+&!922&;1(),!9! ,(J1!1391!2$5'E!&9-('/!.+&9G8! !

³:KDW HOVH GR \RX UHPHPEHU 6DP" , ZRQGHU ´!

!

4'9-;(),!3(-!39)E!91!3&+!-(E&F!-3&!3$..'&-!()!9!39'J!2(+2'&F!.+(),(),!3(D!=(13!3&+F!

9)E!29-1-!9!13$5,31J5'!-19+&!9.$51!13&!+$$D8! ! <3&!.+&&K&!+5-1'&-!13&!25+19()-F!5-3&+(),!

-$5)E'&--'/! 9+$5)E! 13&D8! ! W5-1! D$1&-! -=(+'! ()! 13&! -5)'(,31! '(G&! D(2+$-2$;(2! ;'9)&1-F! '(G&!9!5)(%&+-&!$J!5)G)$=)!9)E!)9D&'&--!=$+'E-8! ! !

³:KDW¶V FKDQJHG WKHVH ODVW WKLUWHHQ \HDUV" /HW¶V VHH QRZ 2K , NQRZ 7KH

NLWFKHQ ´! !

<3&)!9,9()-1!3(-!=(''!9)E!.&11&+!M5E,D&)1F!H9D5&'!J()E-!3(D-&'J!.&(),!'&E!9=9/F!

9'13$5,3!3&+!,+(;!J&&'-!-$!()-5.-19)1(9'!1391!(1!9'D$-1!-&&D-!9-!(J!13&!.+&&K&!(-!;('$1(),!

3(D8! ! V3('&! ;+$2&&E(),! ()1$! 13&! G(123&)F! 3&+! J'&-3! &D(1-! '(11'&! =9+D13F! 9)E! 3&+!

E(D()51(%&!39)E!(-!9''!.$)&²D&9,&+!2$))&21(%&!1(--5&F!;+$.9.'/!)$!39+E&+!1$!-)9;!139)!

9! ;&)2('²HQFDVHG ZLWKLQ D WUDQVSDUHQW OD\HU RI VNLQ $ VLQJOH VWHZHG FKLFNHQ¶V IRRW IODVKHV DFURVV KLV PLQG $ VWHZHG FKLFNHQ¶V IRRW GDQJOLQJ DW WKH HQG RI DQ ROG ZRPDQ¶V 9+DF! 3(-! J(),&+-! 25+'&E! 5;$)! (18! ! N)&! J9-1! ;5''F! 3&! (D9,()&-F! 9)E! 13&! -G()! =$5'E! -'(E&!

ULJKW RII WKH ERQH ,W¶V WKLV DZDUHQHVV RI KHU IUDJLOLW\ WKDW SUHYHQWV KLP IURP ZUHVWOLQJ 3(-!39)E!J+&&F!J+$D!+&-(-1(),!3&+!()!-;(1&!$J!13&!15+.5'&)2&!)$=!M$-1'(),!3(-!D()E!9-!13&!

J(,5+()&-!+&2&E&!.&/$)E!+&9238! !

"!D$D&)1!'91&+F!3$=&%&+F!13&!J(,5+()&-!9)E!3(-!$=)!D(-,(%(),-!9+&!&2'(;-&E!./!9!

-;&2192'&! $J! 2&+9D(2! 2$$G(&! M9+-8! ! 4$$G(&! M9+-! ;&+23&E! 3(,3! $)! 13&! +&J+(,&+91$+F! -5++$5)E(),! 13&! -1$%&F! 2+$=E(),! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;F! $225;/(),! 13&! 2$+)&+-! $J! 13&! J'$$+8! !

Z%&+/=3&+&8! ! <3(-!G(),E$D!$J!2$$G(&!M9+-!()39.(1-!9!,9''&/!G(123&)!1391!(-!-'(,31'/!'9+,&+!

139)! 9! =9'G>()! 2'$-&1F! 2$D;'&1&'/! $%&+-39E$=(),! 9)$13&+! (D;+&--(%&! 2$''&21($)! ()! 13&! +$$D:! ! 9! D5'1(15E&! $J! E&2$+91(%&! D9,)&1-! 2+(--2+$--(),! 13&! =3$'&! +&J+(,&+91$+F! 1$;! 1$! .$11$DF! '(G&! +9)E$D! J+9,D&)1-! J+$D! 9! 13$5-9)E! -&;9+91&! M(,-9=! ;5KK'&-! 9''! -3$%&E! 1$,&13&+8! !

I$$G(),! ;'&9-&EF! 09+($)! ;$()1-! 91! 2&+19()! M9+-²9! D('G! 2$=F! 13&)! 9! ;(,'&1F! 13&)!

-&%&+9'! .&&3(%&>-39;&E! $)&-²19'G(),! =(13! 9! -D('&F! &L;'9()(),! -$D&13(),! 9.$51! &9238! ! <HW ZKLOH KH FDQ¶W IROORZ ZKDW VKH¶V VD\LQJ WKHUH LV D VRRWKLQJ TXDOLW\ LQ KHU YRLFH D ORZ ;5++(),! 1$)&F! '(G&! 13&! ;'&9-9)1! =3(++(),! $J! 9)! &'&21+(2! J9)8! ! ")E! 9-! 3(-! .9JJ'&E! ,9K&!

E(,&-1-! 13&! 2$'$+J5'! 2$''&21($)-F! -3&! ;+&-&)1'/! '&1-! ,$! $J! 3(-! 39)EF! '&9)(),! $%&+! 13&!

2$5)1&+!$)!13&!.9''-!$J!3&+!J&&18! ! ! !

³:KHUH DUH \RX"´ VKH VD\V SOXFNLQJ WKH KHDGV IURP LQGLYLGXDO MDUV WR EULHIO\

SHHN LQVLGH WKHLU KROORZ EHOOLHV ³1R QRW KHUH ´ 6KH UHSODFHV %HWW\ %RRS¶V OLG ³0D\EH KHUH ´ 6XSHUPDQ¶V KHDG DQG VKRXOGHUV DUH UHPRYHG ³1R ´ *DUILHOG 13&!2918! !

7KH &RRNLH 0RQVWHU 7ZR GLIIHUHQW EXW LGHQWLFDO +DOORZHHQ SXPSNLQV ³1RSH ´ $W '9-1! 9! .'92G! D9DD/! (-! -&;9+91&E! 91! 3&+! 235../! =9(-1'()&F! 9)E! 09+($)! '&1-! $51! 9! -(,38! ! ³$K WKHUH \RX DUH 2I FRXUVH ´ $ SHSSHUPLQW VWDUOLJKW FDQG\ PDWHULDOL]HV EH1=&&)!

KHU ILQJHUV IORDWLQJ GRZQZDUG DV KHU KHHOV IODWWHQ ³)RU \RX ´ VKH WHOOV 6DPXHO DGYDQFLQJ WKH FDQG\ WRZDUG KLP ³7KH SHSSHUPLQW %UDFK¶V DUH DOZD\V \RXU IDYRULWH ´! !

"-! (J! 3&+! 9D(9.'&! &L;+&--($)! (-! 2$)19,($5-F! 9! -3&&;(-3! ,+()! -5EE&)'/! 2+92G-! $)!

H9PXHO¶V IDFH +H QRGV SROLWHO\ VK\O\ DQG DFFHSWV KHU RIIHULQJ PDNLQJ D GHWHUPLQHG &JJ$+1F! 13&)F! 1$! 5)=+9;! 13&! 29)E/! ()! 9! -&E91&! D9))&+! 1391! =$)S1! 9;;&9+! 1$$! &9,&+! $+!

+5E&8! ! ?&&'(),! '(G&! &%&+/! 2&+9D(2! &/&! (-! D$)(1$+(),! 3(DF! 3&! -&'J! 2$)-2($5-'/! &9-&-! 13&!

2$)J&21($)!;9-1!3(-!'(;-F!)$EE(),!$)2&!9,9()!1$!E(-;'9/!,+91(15E&F!9)E!+&15+)(),!3(-!)$EF! -3&!2'9(D-!13&!2+5D;'&E!;'9-1(2!=+9;;&+F!E&;$-(1(),!(1!()-(E&!9!;$2G&1!$J!3&+!,9+E&)(),!

9;+$)8! !

H3$+1'/!13&+&9J1&+F!=3('&!13&!;&;;&+D()1!J'9%$+!1(),'&-!3(-!D$513F!13&/!-&1!$JJ!$)!

9)! 9D.'(),! 1$5+²1+9%&'(),! 13&! 9;9+1D&)1! 39)E>()>39)EF! 2$D(),! 9)E! ,$(),! J+$D! (1-!

2$),&-1&E!+$$D-²'(G&!-(,31-&&+-!%(-(1(),!9!D5-&5D!=3&+&!1(D&!-&&D-!1$!39%&!,+$5)E!1$!

39'18! ! V(13()! 13(-! E(-3&%&'&E! ;'92&F! 13(-! E5-1/! 39%&)! J$+! .+(2>9>.+92F! 13&! 19;&-1+/! $J! 9!

VROLWDU\ DQG UHSHWLWLRXV OLIH XQIROGV (YHQ VR 0DULRQ LVQ¶W ZLWKRXW KHU RZQ SDUWLFXODU J$+D! $J! 2$D;9)($)-3(;F! 9! E(-2&+)D&)1! 1391! .&2$D&-! ()2+&9-(),'/! $.%($5-! =3&)! -3&! ,5(E&-!3(D!1$!13&!$51-(E&!.9'2$)/F!13+$5,3!13&!39''=9/!1$!3&+!.&E+$$DF!1$!9!39'J!$JJ(2&F! EDFN WR WKH URRP LQ ZKLFK KLV PRWKHU¶V WZR ILJXULQHV QRZ UHVLGH $ORQJ WKH ZD\ VKH ;$()1-!9)E!19'G-F!19'G-!9)E!;$()1-8! ! <3&-&F!-3&!-3$=-!3(D!=(13!9!=9%&!$J!3&+!39)EF!9+&!

3&+! ;$1-! $J! $+23(E-! 9)E! -;+(),! J'$=&+-F! 9)E! 13&-&! 9+&! 13&! 3&+.-! -3&! ;'9)1&E! 1$E9/8! ! <3&-&!9+&!3&+!9)1(O5&!.$11'&-F!3&+!+9,!E$''-F!3&+!-('G>5;3$'-1&+&E!'9123!.$L&-!2$)19()(),!

43()&-&! D9--9,&! .9''-8! ! ")E! 19G(),! 5;! 9! =9''! ()! 13&! 39'J! $JJ(2&F! 2$)-5D(),! 13+&&! .$$G29-&-F! 13&-&! 9+&! 13&! +&-1! $J! 3&+! 2+/-19'! 9)E! ;$+2&'9()! J(,5+()&-².(+E-F! 9)(D9'-F! 23('E+&)F! 9),&'-F! W(-)&/! 239+921&+-F! J'$=&+-F! 1+&&-F! ()-&21-²9)! &L1&)-(%&! -1915&11&!

2$DD5)(1/!'()(),!13&!-3&'%&-!9D$),!-(,)(J(29)1!D()$+(1(&-!$J!13(D.'&-F!-1$)&!&,,-F!-)$=! ,'$.&-F!9)E!,'$--/!P$'(E9/!$+)9D&)1-8! !

³,¶YH NHSW DW LW 6DP :DVQµW H9-/!=(13$51!/$5!3&+&!9)/D$+&F!&L2&;1!3$=!2$5'E!7!

HYHU TXLW , FRXOGQ¶W \RX NQRZ 7KH\ UHPLQG PH RI \RX DQG XV VR ZKDW HOVH DP , VXSSRVHG WR GR ´! !

Q51!13&+&!9+&!13$-&!$13&+!2$''&21($)-!1391!-3&!E$&-)S1!.$13&+!;$()1(),!$51F!13$-&!

2'5-1&+-! $J! (1&D-! 1391! H9D5&'! ;9--&-! 9)E! +&,9+E-! =(13! ()O5(-(1(%&! ,'9)2&-8! ! <3&! ;+$,+&--(%&'/!3(,3&+!-192G-!$J!)&=-;9;&+-!-1+&123(),!E$=)!13&!39''=9/F!-$D&!1$=&+(),!

9.$%&! 3(DF! '(G&! -19(+-! '&9E(),! )$=3&+&8! ! <3&! 5)+&2$,)(K9.'&! J'$=&+-! =(13&+(),! 92+$--!

13&! 9;9+1D&)1! +$$D-F! D$-1'/! E&9E! /&1! -3$=29-&E! ()! %9-&! 9J1&+! %9-&8! ! "! E$K&)! $+! -$!

5D.+&''9-! 1('1(),! 5;+(,31! 9,9()-1! 9! 2$+)&+8! ! P91-8! ! H3$&-8! ! H&%&+9'! &D;1/! J(-3! 19)G-8! ! *9;&+! -92G-! 3$'E(),! 2+5-3&E! 9'5D()5D! 29)-F! *Z<! .$11'&-F! 9)E! J$'E&E! ;9;&+! -92G-8! ! *'9-1(2!,+$2&+/!.9,-!-15JJ&E!()-(E&!;'9-1(2!,9+.9,&!.9,-!1391!9+&!-15JJ&E!()-(E&!29+E.$9+E! .$L&-!1391!9+&!-15JJ&E!()-(E&!'9+,&+!29+E.$9+E!.$L&-8! ! R&+/!'(11'&!3&+&F!3&!+&9'(K&-F!,&1-!

13+$=)!9=9/8! ! H3&!1+&9-5+&-!)&9+'/!&%&+/13(),F!9'D$-1!)$)&!$J!(1!9'(%&8! !

#&%&+13&'&--F!H9D5&'!39E!=9123&E!9!=&''>J&E!291!&)1&+!13&!9;9+1D&)1F!13$5,3!3&!

KDVQ¶W REVHUYHG LW DQ\ZKHUH VLQFH &DWV DUHQ¶W VWXSLG KH WHOOV KLPVHOI ,W¶V KLGLQJ XQWLO 7! '&9%&8! ! ")E! D9/.&! 13&+&! 9+&! '$1-! $J! 5)-&&)! 291-! -2911&+&E! 9+$5)E! 3(D²2$=&+(),!

5)E&+)&913! J5+)(15+&F! '5+G(),! .&3()E! 13&! )5D&+$5-! ;('&-! $+! .(E(),! 1(D&! ()-(E&!

2'$-&1-²-(D;'/! .&295-&! -3&! M5-1! E$&-)S1! -&&D! '(G&! 13&! G()E! $J! =$D9)! =3$! =$5'E! $)'/!

2$''&21!$)&!J&'()&8! ! Q51!=3/F!3&!9-G-!3(D-&'JF!(-!-3&!-3$=(),!D&!13&-&!13(),-T! ! :KDW¶V VKH NHHS VD\LQJ" :KDW¶V VKH ZDQW"! ! "''!13&!-9D&F!=3('&!,&11(),!'&E!3&+&!9)E!13&+&!./!

13&! ()1(D91&! 1$=! $J! 3&+! 39)EF! 3&! J&&'-! 9)! 9JJ&21($)91&! -5+,&! J$+! 13(-! &'J(-3F! D511&+(),F! 25+($5-'/!.&)&%$'&)1!;92G!+91F!9)E!J()E-!3(D-&'J!9D9K&E!1391!-523!9!1()/!()E(%(E59'F!()!9!

J9(+'/!1()/!9;9+1D&)1F!2$5'E!J(''!3&+!'(D(1&E!-;92&!=(13!-$!D523!-15JJ8! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! @AaC! !

V3&)! 13&/! +&15+)! 1$! 13&! +&2'()&+! 9)E! 13&! <R! 2$)-$'&F! 9! -(E&'$),! ,'9)2&! 39-! H9D5&'! =$)E&+(),!91!09+($)!()E(+&21'/F!13&!;&;;&+D()1!29)E/!2'(2G(),!9,9()-1!3(-!1&&13F!9)E!3&! =$)E&+-! &%&)! D$+&! 9J1&+! -3&! ;95-&-F! 3&+! 39)E! +&'&9-(),! 3(-! 39)E8! ! P&+! %$(2&! J9''-!

-('&)1F! 13&! ,&)(9'! -D('&! ()%&+1(),! 9)E! 13&! 23&&G-! -'92G&)(),8! ! <3&! ,'(DD&+! ()! 3&+! &/&-!

J9'1&+-8! ! P&+! J&915+&-! 9+&! -5EE&)'/! 9-3&)! 9)E! E(-19)1! 9)E! &)19),'&E8! ! P&+! -19+&!

-39+;&)-! $)! 3(DF! -&9+23(),! 3(-! ;5KK'&E! J92&F! 9-! (J! -&&G(),! -$D&! (D;$+19)1! D(-'9(E! $.M&218! ! ")E!J$+!9!D$D&)1!-3&!'$$G-!511&+'/!'$-1²'(G&!-3&F!1$$F!39E!$)2&!-G91&E!J9+!J+$D! 3$D&F! .&2$D(),! &L395-1&E! 9)E! 2$)J5-&EF! /&1! -1(''! 39-! )&%&+! D9)9,&E! 1$! '$291&! 9! =9/! .92G8! !

+RZHYHU LW ZRQ¶W EH WKH UHFROOHFWLRQ RI 0DULRQ¶V PXGGOHG VRPHZKDW FDUHZRUQ

&L;+&--($)!1391!=(''!5'1(D91&'/!&123!13(-!9J1&+)$$)!5;$)!3(-!'9-1(),!D&D$+/8! ! #$+!=(''!(1! .&!13&!2$5)1'&--!2$''&21(.'&-!-;+&9E!13+$5,3$51!13&!9;9+1D&)1F!$+!13&!E95)1(),!;5+-5(1!

RI KLV PRWKHU¶V ILJXULQHV ,Q IDFW XS WR ULJKW QRZ QRWKLQJ PXFK DERXW WRGD\ ZRXOG -1+(G&!H9D5&'!9-!)$19.'&!$%&+!1(D&8! ! 7J!)$1!J$+!=391!1+9)-;(UHV QH[W VKH¶G HEE IURP KLV D()E!+913&+!&JJ$+1'&--'/F!J9E(),!()1$!13&!;9-1!'(G&!9)!()2$)-&O5&)1(9'!&D.&+!1391²-3$5'E! (1!&%&+!,&1!J9))&E²=$5'E!.9+&'/!-5DD$)!13&!%9,5&!,'$=!$J!9)!$EEF!;$--(.'/!2+9K/F!$'E! "D&+(29)!=$D9)8! ! Q51!9-!(1!39;;&)-F!9!;+&2(;(191&F!.+(,31!-D('&!+&2'9(D-!3&+!J&915+&-F! 2+&9-(),! 13&! J'&-3/! '9/&+-! $)! 3&+! J92&F! 9)E! =(13! (1! -$$)! 2$D&-! 13&! J(+-1! D/-1(J/(),! $225++&)2&!$J!9!3&+&1$J$+&!5)-;&21925'9+!<5&-E9/8! !

³7KHUH¶V VRPHWKLQJ HOVH 6DP 2QH PRUH WKLQJ ,¶P VXUH \RX¶OO HQMR\ ´!

!

H5)-3()&!.'9K&-!92+$--!13&!9O591(2!29+;&18! ! <3&!25+19()-!&E,&!J$+=9+E8! ! <5+)(),!

J+$D!3(DF!09+($)!-2511'&-!$%&+!1$!13&!'92O5&+!.$$G29-&-!1391!E(%(E&!13&!+$$DF!9)E!=3&)!

-3&!,$&-F!H9D5&'!9(D-!3(-!-19+&!91!13&!<R!2$)-$'&F!J+$=)(),8! ! *$-(1($)&E!=&''!=(13()!3(-! ,+9-;!/&1!+&D9()(),!5)9119()9.'&F!13&!(DD&E(92/!$J!13&!1=$!J(,5+()&-!J&&'-!-$D&3$=!'(G&!

D WDXQWLQJ MRNH ³0D>GHU ´ KH WKHQ SUDFWLFHV (QJOLVK XQGHU KLV EUHDWK WKH FDQG\ VOLGLQJ RQ KLV WRQJXH ³0\ 0\ 0D>13>&+8! ! 0/!D9>13&+²´! !

³2K \HV +HUH ZH JR ´!

!

P&+!%$(2&!;+$D;1'/!-3(J1-!3(-!911&)1($)8! ! W+9=(),!3(-!'(;-!1$,&13&+F!3&!=9123&-!9-!

09+($)!9;;+$923&-!=(13!9)!9%$29E$>2$'$+&E!;3$1$!9'.5D!()!3&+!39)E-F!13&!.'92G!;9,&-!

3&'E! $;&)8! ! H3&! )$E-! &9,&+'/! '(G&! 9! 23('E! 9)E! -(E'&-! )&L1! 1$! 3(D8! ! 0$%(),! 13&! 9'.5D! .&)&913! 3(-! 23()F! -3&! 19;-! 9! J(),&+)9('! $)! 9! -O59+&F! =9-3&E>$51! D$)$23+$D91(2! ;3$1$,+9;38! !

³6HH WKHUH \RX DUH 6R KDQGVRPH WRR ´!

!

")EF! ()E&&EF! 13&+&! 3&! (-8! ! N+! 91! '&9-1! 9! ,+())(),! .$/! =3$! '$$G-! +&D9+G9.'/! '(G&!

3(D²-9D&!9,&!,+$5;F!-9D&!3&(,31F!-9D&!=&(,31F!-9D&!+$5)E!3&9E8! ! Q51!(1!19G&-!9!J&=!

-&2$)E-! 5)1('! H9D5&'! )$1(2&-! 13&! &&+(&! +&-&D.'9)2&:! ! J$+! 13&! .$/! ()! 13&! ;(215+&! (-!

2+$523&E! 9D$),! 13+&&! $13&+! ,+())(),! 43()&-&! .$/-F! 9''! -3(+1'&--! 9)E! 35EE'&E! ./! 9! +(%&+.9)G! -$D&=3&+&F! 13&(+! 9+D-! ()1&+1=()&E! 9.$51! 13&(+! -5)19))&E! -3$5'E&+-8! ! P&+!

J(),&+)9('F!3$=&%&+F!J$25-&-!3(-!,9K&F!E(+&21(),!3(D!1$!1391!$)&!;9+1(25'9+!.$/F!1391!$)&!

5)D(-19G9.'&F!E(-1()21(%&!J92&8! ! <3&)!9-1$)(-3D&)1!.+$9E&)-!3(-!&/&-!.&J$+&!;&+%9E(),!

3(-!&)1(+&!&L;+&--($)8! !

P&+! J(),&+! ,'(E&-! E$=)! 13&! ;9,&F! -1$;;(),! 91! 9)$13&+! .'92G>9)E>=3(1&!

;3$1$,+9;38! ! ")E!13&+&!3&!(-!9,9()F!13(-!1(D&!9'$)&²;$-(),!J$+D9''/F!-19)E(),!&+&21!()!

9! 2$5+1/9+E²=&9+(),! 9! -23$$'! 5)(J$+D! $J! G)&&>'&),13! -3$+1-F! 9! 13()! .&'1F! 9)E! 9! =3(1&!

-3$+1>-'&&%&!-3(+1!=(13!9!)&2G&+23(&J!1(&E!91!13&!2$''9+8! !

")E!9,9()8!

!

P9(+! 2+$;;&E! 2'$-&! 1$! 3(-! -G5''! '(G&! 9! D$)GF! '95,3(),! 9)E! 39),(),! $JJ! 9! 1+&&!

.+9)23!./!3(-!9+D-²9!J$+&-1!$J!,(9)1!.9D.$$-!1$=&+(),!.&3()E!3(D8! !

H3&!J'(;-!1$!13&!D(EE'&!$J!13&!9'.5DF!9++(%(),!=3&+&!9!'9+,&!39)E>2$'$+&E!-15E($!

;$+1+9(1!$225;(&-!(1-!$=)!;9,&8! !

³$QG KHUH ZH DUH ´!

!

6DPXHO¶V GXPEIRXQGHG JD]H VFUXWLQL]HV WKH LPDJH H[FHSW KH GRHVQ¶W UHFRJQL]H

9)/13(),!$J!3(D-&'J!()!(18! ! P&!-&&-F!91!J(+-1F!1=$!D(-D9123&E!;&$;'&!J+$D!9!'$),!9,$!&+9F! 9!-1$2G/!"-(9)!D9)!'$(1&+(),!-1(JJ'/!'(G&!9!=9(1&+!)&9+!9!-&91&E!49529-(9)!'9E/8! ! V(13!3(-!

13(2G! 39(+! -=&;1! .92GF! 13&! D9)! 39-! $)! 9! G)(11&E! =9(-12$91! 5)E&+! 9! E9+G! =$$'! -5(1F! 9!

J'$=&+! 911923&E! 1$! 3(-! '&J1! '9;&'8! ! <3&! '9E/²=&9+(),! 9! J()&! =$$'! 2+&;&! 9)E! M92G&1F! 9!

J9-3($)9.'&! =(E&>.+(DD&E! 391! 1('1&E! 9.$%&! .'$)E&! 25+'-²3$'E-! 9! .$5O5&1! $J! ;$-(&-! ()!

3&+!'9;8! ! Y;$)!2'$-&+!()-;&21($)F!13&!D9)!-&&D-!J9D('(9+!J$+!-$D&!+&9-$)F!9'13$5,3!)$1!

9-! J9D('(9+! 9-! 13&! ;&1(1&! '9E/! =3$! (-F! 3&! )$=! +&9'(K&-F! 9! D523! /$5),&+! %&+-($)! $J! 13&!

-3+(%&'&E!=$D9)!3$%&+(),!.&-(E&!3(D8! !

³+DV>EDQ"´ KH!D9)9,&-!1$!9-GF!39%(),!+&923&E!13&!-$'&!2$)2'5-($)!1391!2$5'E!.&!

,'&9)&E!J+$D!13&!J'$=&+-F!2'$13(),F!9)E!;+$L(D(1/!$J!-523!9)!9)$D9'$5-!2$5;'&8! !

³<HV ´ VKH DQVZHUV VXGGHQO\ VRXQGLQJ YHU\ WLUHG ³0\ ZRQGHUIXO KXVEDQG RI

FRXUVH ´! !

³0P ´!

!

")! 9--&)1(),! )$G LQFOLQHV 0DULRQ¶V KHDG ³:H JHW IRUJHWIXO VRPHWLPHV GRQ¶W

ZH"´ VKH VD\V SDVVLQJ WKH DOEXP LQWR 6DPXHO¶V KDQGV DQG KH DFFHSWV LW ZLOOLQJO\ ³<RX KDYH D JRRG ORRN GHDU 7KHUH VKRXOGQ¶W EH DQ\ KXUU\ , KRSH QRQH ZKDWVRHYHU ´ <3&)! =3('&! 3&! 9)L($5-'/! J'(;-! 9''! 13&! ;9,&-! 91! $)2&F! 2$DD&)2(),! 13&! -&9+23! J$+! 3(-!

5)29))/!1=()!J+$D!13&!-19+1!$J!13&!9'.5DF!-3&!9D.'&-!9=9/F!-'$='/!9)E!E&'(.&+91&'/F!9-!(J! .&(),!.&2G$)&E!&'-&=3&+&8! ! U&1!3&!(-!1$$!.5-/!-15E/(),!&923!;3$1$,+9;3!1$!+&9''/!)$1(2&!

3&+!'&9%(),!3(-!-(E&²13&!;&;;&+D()1!29)E/!&%&)159''/!.+&9G(),!9;9+1!9)E!E(--$'%(),!9-! ()29'25'9.'&!/&9+-!;+$2&&E!=(13()!3(-!-19+&F!;9,&!9J1&+!;9,&8! !

<3&! &9+'(&-1! ;3$1$,+9;3-! -3$=! 9)2(&)1>'$$G(),! Z5+$;&9)! ;&$;'&8! ! V&913&+&E!

(DD(,+9)1! D&)! 9)E! =$D&)! -&&D(),'/! 29+%&E! $J! -1$)&8! ! ")&D(2! .9.(&-! 9)E! -D9''!

23('E+&)F! '(G&! 2+&&;/! 9)1(O5&! E$''-8! ! ?9D('(&-! ,913&+&E! $)! E(+1! +$9E-F! $+! =$$E&)! ;$+23&-F!$+!-5)>.'&923&E!'9=)-8! ! <=$!$+!13+&&!;9,&-!'91&+F!09+($)!&D&+,&-!./!E&,+&&-!

9D(E!13&!39+E!J92&-8! ! "!'(11'&!.'$)E&!,(+'!=(13!E9+G>39(+&E!-(.'(),-F!-D('(),!&%&)!=3&)!

13&! +&-1! 9+&! )$18! ! H'(,31'/! $'E&+! )$=F! .$/(-3! 9)E! -G())/! ()! 9! J'$=&+>;911&+)&E! E+&--F! J+&2G'&-! E$11(),! 3&+! 23&&G-F! 9'=9/-! -D('(),8! ! N'E&+! /&1²13&! 39;;/! ,(+'! -5++$5)E&E! ./! )5)-F! $+! ,(+'-! 3&+! 9,&²9)E! $'E&+F! 13&! J+&2G'&-! ,$)&F! 13&! -G()! ;$=E&+&EF! 13&! 39(+!

-1/'&E²5)1('!&%&+/!;3$1$,+9;3!J$+!9!=3('&!E&;(21-!%9+(91($)-!$J!1391!+&25++(),!-D('&!9)E! 13&! /$5),! =$D9)! =3$! ;$--&--&-! (18! ! Q51! -$D&! (D9,&-! 29;15+&! 3(-! -19+&! '$),&+! 139)! $13&+-²'(G&! 3&+! -&;(9>1$)&E! -&)($+! 2'9--! ;$+1+9(1F! $+! =3&+&! -3&! '&9)-! 9,9()-1! 13&! -'&&G! 3$$E!$J!9!43+/-'&+!"(+J'$=F!$+!-O5()1-!$)!5)(%&+-(1/!-1&;-F!$+!=&9+-!9!,+9/(-3!-3(+1!E+&--!

9)E!;+$5E'/!E(-;'9/-!9!YHN!9+D.9)E8! ! ?5++$=(),!3(-!.+$=F!3&!15+)-!13&!;9,&F!-29+2&'/!

.&'(&%(),!1391!9!;&+-$)!-$!E&2+&;(1!2$5'E!39%&!.&&)!-$!/$513J5'8! !

<3&)!1(D&!-3(J1-!'91&+9''/F!9)E!"-(9)!J&915+&-!9++(%&!$51!$J!13&!.'5&F!9-!(J!9!)&=&+!

(DD(,+9)1! 25'15+&! 39E! 1&D;$+9+('/! -5.'&9-&E! -;92&! ()-(E&! 13&! 9'.5D! J+$D! 9! D$+&! )915+9'(K&E!,+$5;8! ! H;&2(J(29''/F!(1!(-!D$-1'/!3(-!J92&!E$D()91(),!9!-(),'&!;9,&:! ! 13&!.$/!

1391! (-! $.%($5-'/! 3(DF! .51F! 9'-$F! )$1! 3(D8! ! V(13$51! 9! E$5.1F! 3&! 39-! )&%&+! .&J$+&!

2+$523&E!.&-(E&!9!+(%&+.9)G!=(13!J+(&)E-²)&%&+!=$+)!9!)&2G&+23(&JF!)&%&+!E9),'&E!$JJ!9!

1+&&!.+9)23²/&1!13(-!;&+J&21!+&J'&21($)!$J!3(D-&'J!(-!5))&+%(),F!-15))(),!()!(1-!'(G&)&--8! !

V3$! 9+&! /$5T! ! 13&! O5&-1($)! +&;&91&E'/! J'9-3&-! 92+$--! 3(-! D()E²+92(),! 1$! 13&! .$/F! 1$!

09+($)F! .92G! 1$! 3(D-&'J²9)E! ;&+-(-1-! 9-! 13&! ;3$1$,+9;3-! E&J/! 3(D! '(G&! 13&! $.-25+&!

(D;+()1!$J!J$+,$11&)!D&D$+(&-!1391!3&!29)S1!O5(1&!+&9'(K&8! !

ZL2&;1! M5-1! 13$-&! 13+&&! ,+9()/! (D9,&-! E&;(21! 13&! .$/F! 13+&&! &'5-(%&! ,'(D;-&-!

%9)(-3(),! =3&)! 13&! 2$9+-&! ;9;&+! -'(E&-! 9=9/! J+$D! 3(-! J(),&+1(;-! 1$! ;+&-&)1! 9)$13&+! ;9,&8! ! #$=!-19+(),!5;!91!3(D! (-! 9)!"D&+(29)!-&+%(2&D9)!=(13!-'9)1&E!&/&-²9!-'(,31'/!

1+(DD&+F!-$D&=391!/$5),&+!;$+1+DLW RI 0DULRQ¶V SODLQ>'$$G(),!-;$5-&F!9)!"(+!?$+2&!29;!

FRFNHG RQ KLV RYDO KHDG +HU KXVEDQG¶V IRUPDO H[SUHVVLRQ LV WKDW RI WKH ER\ SRVLQJ LQ 13&!2$5+1/9+EF! 9)E!9''! 91!$)2&!13&! 2$)-;(25$5-!'()G! (-! D9E&F!13&!E$1-!2$))&21&E!,(%(),!

-39;&! 1$! $)&! ;&+-$)8! ! Q51! 9;;+&3&)E(),! 13(-! J921! 29-1-! 9! ;9''! $)! 3(-! J9-2()91($)8! ! U$5! ,&1!5,'(&+F!3&!1&''-!3(D-&'J8! ! U$5!,&1!J911&+8! !

P&!2$)1()5&-!.+$=-(),!13&!9'.5D!=3('&!J+$=)(),F!;95-(),!$)'/!-3$5'E!13&!D9)!

9;;&9+:! ! D$=(),!9!'9=)F!+&9E(),!9!)&=-;9;&+!()!-=(DD(),!1+5)G-F!D$+&!$J1&)!139)!)$1!

-19)E(),! 9'$),-(E&! 3(-! 39;;/F! =9J&+>-'(D! =(J&8! ! *+$2&-->-19D;&E! E91&-! .&,()! E$11(),!

13&!.$+E&+-!$J!-&%&+9'!;3$1$,+9;3-8! ! H&;!a`F!09+!fBF!\9)!f]F!H&;!fd8! ! Q'9)23&E!2$'$+-!

-5;&+-&E&!13&!.'92G>9)E>=3(1&!35&-F!9)E!13&!/&9+-! 922&'&+91&!J$+!13&!2$5;'&8! ! 09/!caF! "5,! cc8! ! <3(2G! 39(+! ,+$=-! 13()F! -19+1-! ,$(),! ,+9/8! ! 09+! c`8! ! V+()G'&-! 1+9)-J$+D! -G()!

9)E!E&&;&)8! ! <3&!29-59''/!=$+)!2'$13(),!$J!./,$)&!E9/-!(-!+&;'92&E!./!13&!;+$;&+!911(+&! $J!13$-&!=3$!G)$=!.&11&+!139)!1$!2'(),!91!13&(+!'$-1!/$5138! ! 09/!_d8! ! U&1!3&+&!13&/!9+&!

-1(''F!9)E!3&+&F!9)E!3&+&:! ! -$D&1(D&-!$)&F!-$D&1(D&-!.$13F!-$D&1(D&-!)&(13&+!-9%&!J$+!

3(-!$+!3&+!-(),5'9+!;&+-;&21(%&!13+$5,3!9!29D&+9!'&)-8! ! "!.&9238! ! "!-G(!1+(;8! ! 49D;(),! ,+$5)E-8! ! ?(-3(),8! ! *+$J('&-! 9)E! -1&&+(),! =3&&'-8! ! P(,3! E&-&+18! ! <3&! ;+&2(;(2&! $J! 13&!

X+9)E! 49)/$)8! ! <&))(-! ,9D&-8! ! Q92G/9+E! .9+.&O5&-8! ! R&,&19.'&! ,9+E&)-8! ! ?'$=&+-8! ! "! 43()91$=)! ;9+9E&8! ! 4$JJ&&! 25;-! 9)E! 2(,9+&11&-8! ! 4$523&-8! ! ?$'E(),! 239(+-8! ! 49+E! 19.'&-8! ! ?'&9!D9+G&1-8! ! "!=3&&'239(+!;&+23&E!9.$%&!;$+23!-1&;-8!

!

")EF! J()DOO\ D SULYDWH KRVSLWDO URRP PHHWV 6DPXHO¶V VWDUH DQG DQ HPDFLDWHG

3$''$=!J92&!.9+(),!)$!1+92&!$J!13&!.$/!$)!13&!+(%&+.9)GF!13&!5).'&D(-3&E!-&+%(2&D9)F!$+!

13&!235../!,+$$D8! ! 0/!,+9)EJ913&+F!3&!13()G-8! ! U&-F!13&!D9)! 2$5'E!)$=!&9-('/!.&!3(-!

PRWKHU¶V IDWKHU DOWKRXJK KH NQRZV LW LVQ¶W UHDOO\ 7HQJ>35(8! ! ^&,9+E'&--!$J!.&(),!+913&+!

J+9('F! 3(-! ,+9)EJ913&+! (-! J9(+'/! 3&9'13/! 9)E! 9'(%&! ()! <9()9)8! ! <3&)! 9'D$-1! 9-! -$$)! 9-! 3&!

-&&-! 13&! 3$-;(19'! ;3$1$,+9;3F! 9! -35EE&+(),! -&)-91($)! +(;;'&-! E$=)! 3(-! -;()&! 9)E! 3(-!

J(),&+-!O5(2G'/!15+)!13&!;9,&!9-!(J!1$!&-29;&!3(-!$=)!E&D(-&8! ! Q51!1391!(-!13&!'9-1!(D9,&! ()-(E&! 13&! 9'.5D²9! D5KK/! *$'9+$(E! $J! 9! -(2G! $'E! D9)! +&-1(),! $)! 9)! &'&21+(2! .&EF! -5-19()&E!./!15.&-!9)E!D5-1&+(),!9!J&&.'&!,+()²9)E!13&+&!.&/$)E!(1!&L(-1-!&D;1/!-3&&1-F! '(G&! .'92G! .9))&+-! -(,)(J/(),! 13&! ;$()1! ()! =3(23! 1(D&! 39E! 2&9-&E! &L;9)E(),! J$+! 13&!

-D('(),!"D&+(29)!=$D9)!9)E!3&+!43()&-&!35-.9)E8! !

"! )5D.! J&&'(),! $%&+2$D&-! H9D5&'! 9-! 3&! 2'$-&-! 13&! 9'.5DF! 9! J&&'(),! $J!

ZHLJKWOHVVQHVV +H JODQFHV XS DQG QRWLFHV WKDW 0DULRQ LVQ¶1!.&-(E&!3(D8! ! H3&!+&D9()-F! 3$=&%&+F! ()! J5''! %(&=²+&;$-&E! $)! 13&! +&2'()&+! =(13! &/&-! -351F! 3&9E! $.'(O5&8! ! <3&! =91&+(),! 29)! -(1-! )&9+! 13&! ;'92&! =3&+&! 3&+! -'(;;&+-! E9),'&! $%&+! 13&! 29+;&1F! 9)E! -3&! (-!

E=9+J&E! ./! 13&! '9+,&! 239(+F! 13&! 25-3($)&E! 5;3$'-1&+/! 9.-$+.(),! 3&+! -D9''F! -191($)9+/!

J(,5+&! '(G&! 13&! ;9EE(),! $J! 9! 2$JJ()8! ! P&! =9123&-! 3&+! J$+! 9! D$D&)1F! -52G(),! 3(-! '(;-! ()=9+E!=3('&!9=9(1(),!-$D&!-(,)!$J!'(J&!1391!)&%&+!.&2$D&-!9;;9+&)18! !

H&2$)E-!'91&+F!3&!J()E-!3(D-&'J!-19)E(),!91!13&!239(+F!29+&J5''/!-&11(),!13&! ;3$1$!

DOEXP RQ KHU ODS VR DV QRW WR VWDUWOH KHU %XW HYHQ WKLV GRHVQ¶W DFWLYDWH DQ\ PRYHPHQW H3&! '$$G-! -&+&)&! 13$5,3! =3$''/! ()9)(D91&F! '(D;(E'/! E&2&9-&E8! ! "! E&'(.&+91(%&F! 5)-5+&!

-1('')&--!,913&+-!9+$5)E!3(D!.&J$+&!3&!.+(),-!9!J(),&+!5)E&+)&913!3&+!)$-&!1$!23&2G!J$+! .+&913(),²9)! ()2$)2'5-(%&! 1&-1! 39D;&+&E! ./! 13&! '(,31! .+&&K&! =9J1(),! .&1=&&)! 13&D8! ! ")E!=3&)F!=(13$51!=9+)(),F!-3&!2+92G-!3&+!&/&-!$;&)F!&%&+/!;9+1!$J!3(D!+&;&'-!()!-3$2GF! 3(-!J(),&+!+&1+&91(),!=(13!'(,31)(),!-;&&E8! !

³0XVW¶YH GR]HG RII ´ VKH PXPEOHV OLIWLQJ KHU IDFH ³, JXHVV ZH ERWK FRPH DQG

JR WKHVH GD\V GRQµW ZH"´! !

",9()! 13&+&! (-! 1391! -D('&! 2+&9-(),! ()! 3(-! E(+&21($)²13$-&! )&51+9'>2$'$+&E! ;5;('-!

,'()1(),!E&-;(1&!9'-$!-&&D(),!9.-1+921&EF!E+$=-/8! ! P(-!39++$=&E!&L;+&--($)!+&15+)-!3&+!

-19+&F! 9)E! H9D5&'! =9)1-! E&-;&+91&'/! )$=! 1$! 9-G! 9.$51! 13&! ;3$1$,+9;3-! $J! 3(-!

E$5.'&²J$+! 13&! =$D9)! 1$! &L;'9()! =391! 13&/! D&9)F! 3$=! 13&/! 9+&! ;$--(.'&8! ! U&1!

2$)J$5)E&E!$)2&!D$+&!./!13&!'92G!$J!9!-39+&E!'9),59,&F!3&!29)!2$)%&/!'(11'&!&'-&!&L2&;1!

;'9,5&E!-('&)2&F!3(-!D$513!,9;(),!-15;(E'/8! !!

³6WD\ D ZKLOH ZRQ¶W \RX" -XVW D ELW LI \RX GRQ¶W PLQG ´!

!

P9+E'/! D$%(),! $)! 13&! 239(+F! 09+($)! +&923&-! 1$=9+E! 3(DF! 9)E! =(13! 9)! 9'D$-1!

()E&2&)1!9D$5)1!$J!;&+-(-1&)1!9JJ&21($)F!-3&!.&,()-!-1+$G(),!13&!G)52G'&-!9)E!J(),&+-!$J! 3(-!+(,31!39)E².92G!9)E!J$+13F!5;!9)E!E$=)²'(G&!9!.'()E!;&+-$)!)&&EJ5''/!29+&--(),!9)! ()E&1&+D()91&! $.M&218! ! Q51! H9D5&'! )&(13&+! +&-(-1-! $+! +&-;$)E-! 1$! 13&! D&+&! -G()! 9)E! .$)&! $J! 3&+! J+9,('&! 1$523F! 13&! D&1(25'$5-'/! 2$)-1+521&E! .$)&-! ;+&--(),! 5;$)! 3(-! J'&-38! !

H19)E(),!+LJLGO\ EHIRUH KHU LW¶V DV WKRXJK KH LV KHOG LQ D WUDQFH DQG DIWHU VKH ZLWKGUDZV 3&+! 39)EF! =9%(),! 3(D! 2'$-&+F! 3&! J&&'-! 1391! 13&+&! (-! )$! $13&+! 23$(2&! &L2&;1! 1$! .&)E! J$+=9+E8! ! <3&)! =3(-;&+(),! 91! 3(-! &9+F! 13&! =$+E-! '(G&! 9! E(-19)1! -$5)E! 29++(&E! $)! 13&! .+&&K&F!VKH KRDUVHO\ SURFODLPV LQ SHUIHFW 0DQGDULQ ³, ORYH \RX ´! !

<3&! -5+;+(-&! $J! 13(-! =(E&)-! H9D5&'S-! ,9K&F! 9-! E$&-! 3&+! D$513! =3&)! (1! -5EE&)'/!

;5-3&-! 9,9()-1! 3(-! ;9+1&E! '(;-F! E&'(%&+(),! 9! J'&&1(),! G(--! 1391! (-! J&'1! J9+! '$),&+! 139)! (1!

'9-1-8! ! X+$,,('/F!-3&!;91-!13&!-(E&!$J!3(-!J92&8! ! P&+!;5;('-!1=()G'&!()!13&!D(E-1!$J!-9,,(),!

H\HOLGV OLNH VWDJH DFWRUV WDNLQJ D ILQDO ERZ ZKLOH WKH FXUWDLQ GURSV ³'R \RX XQGHUVWDQG PH"´ KH ZKLVSHUV EDFN ZDWFKLQJ KHU QHVWOH LQWR WKH FKDLU WKH VPLOH UHWUDFWLQJ ³'R \RX NQRZ ZKDW ,¶P VD\LQJ"´ +LV TXHVWLRQV DUH DQVZHUHG RQO\ E\ D 3&9%/F!E&J()(1(%&!-(,38! ! 7)!1391!()-19)1F!9''!3&+!=9+D13!$J!J&&'(),!-&&D(),'/!&%9;$+91&-8! ! <3&)!3&+!3&9E!15+)-!J+$D!3(D²9!23&&G!-&11'(),!9,9()-1!13&!25-3($)F!3&+!.$E/!.&2$D(),!

'9L²9)EF!9-!;+&2(;(191&'/!9-!-3&!39E!9=9G&)&EF!09+($)!E+(J1-!$JJ!9,9()8! !

?$+! 9! =3('&! H9D5&'! '$(1&+-! 91! 13&! 239(+F! E5D.J$5)E&E8! ! N)2&! 9! J9()1! -)$+&!

O5(%&+-! $51! $J! 3&+F! 3(-! ,9K&! -3(J1-! &'-&=3&+&F! '$$G(),! 9+$5)E! 13&! +$$D8! ! N('! ;9()1(),-!

39),! $)! 13&! =9''-²9! 2(+25-! 2'$=)! M5,,'(),! .$='(),! ;()-F! W$)! g5(L$1&! 239+,(),! 9! =()ED(''F! 9! 2$=.$/! -O5911(),! )&9+! 2911'&8! ! ?+$D! 3(-! %9)19,&! ;$()1F! 3&! (-! 9.'&! 1$! -&&!

-$D&!$J!13&!G(123&)F!13&!D9)/!2$$G(&!M9+-!'()(),!13&!2$5)1&+1$;-8! ! ?()9''/!3(-!-19+&!J(L&-! $)!13&!1=$!J(,5+()&-F!G)$=(),!J5''!=&''!1391!3&!2$5'E!&9-('/!19G&!13&D!9)E!+5)F!D(--($)!

DFFRPSOLVKHG :LWK DOO WKH RWKHU REMHFWV OLWWHULQJ WKH DSDUWPHQW VKH SUREDEO\ ZRXOGQ¶W QRWLFH WKH\ ZHUH PLVVLQJ (YHQ VR KH FDQ¶W EULQJ KLPVHOI WR VWHDO IURP WKH ZRPDQ²)$1!

9J1&+! =391! -3&SE! -3$=)! 3(D! ()! 13&! ;3$1$! 9'.5DF! )$1! 9J1&+! -3&SE! .&&)! -$! G()E! 9)E! 39E! ,(%&)!3(D!29)E/8! !

<3$5,3!)$=!13&!19-1&!$J!;&;;&+D()1!39-!.&,5)!1$!J9E&F!9-!39-!13&!9J1&+)$$)!'(,31F!

9)E! ()! -;(1&! $J! 13&! .+&&K&F! 13&! -(2G'/! $E$+! (-! -1+$),&+! 139)! &9+'(&+F! %9,5&'/! ()-()591(),!

3&+!'$)&'()&--8! ! P&!29)!-D&''!(1!5;$)!3(D-&'JF!$)!3(-!J(),&+-F!3(-!'(;-F!&%&+/=3&+&8! ! H$$)!

(1!=(''!J$''$=!3(D!$51-(E&!J$+!9!1(D&F!E(D()(-3(),!E5+(),!13&!=9'G!3$D&!/&1!-1(''!(D.5(),!

3(-!5)+&-$'%&E!13$5,31-!9.$51!13&!=$D9)8! ! Q51!J(+-1!3&!,(%&-!3&+!9!J()9'!2$)1&D;'91(%&! ,'9)2&F!9!E&,+&&!$J!-9E)&--!-1(++(),!91!13&!-(,31!$J!-523!9)!$'EF!-$'(19+/!.$E/!2$)-5D&E! ./!-523!9!.(,!9)E!5,'/!239(+8! ! <3$-&!2+/-19'-!9+&!/$5+-F!3&!13()G-!=(13!9!+&-$'51&!)$E!$J! 3(-!3&9E8! ! U$5!E&-&+%&!13&D!D$+&!139)!098! ! <3&)!,+(;;(),!13&!-1+9;-!$J!3(-!.92G;92GF! H9DXHO GHSDUWV WKH DSDUWPHQW DV KH¶G HQWHUHG LW²O5(2G'/F!)(D.'/²D9G(),!9!2$)-2($5-!

23$(2&!1$!'$2G!3&+!J+$)1!E$$+!9)E!;5''!(1!-351!.&3()E!3(DF!'&-1!-$D&$)&!&'-&!1+/!1$!-)&9G! ()-(E&!=3('&!-3&!)9;-8! !

")E!=3&)!09+($)!+&%(%&-!'91&+!$)F!-3&!.'()G-!9=9G&!9D(E!13&!=9)(),!D()51&-!$J!

E5-G8! ! <3&!'$2G&E!J+$)1!E$$+!-&9'-!39'J!13&!9;9+1D&)1!()!E9+G)&--F!9)E!+(-(),!-39E$=-!

39%&! -;(''&E! '(G&! J'$$E=91&+! 13+$5,3! 13&! .9'2$)/! =()E$=! 1$! -=&''! .&)&913! 3&+! 23()[!

9'13$5,3! )$)&! $J! 13(-! J9-3($)-! 9)! (-$'91&EF! J$+-9G&)! 95+9! .&/$)E! 3&+8! ! #$1! &%&)!

6DPXHO¶V DEVHQFH HWFKHV D GHVRODWH TXHVWLRQ PDUN DFURVV KHU PLQG RU SUHYHQWV D E&'(,31&E!'$$G!J+$D!()%(,$+91(),!3&+!1(+&E!J92&8! ! ?$+!9-!(1!(-F!13&+&!9D$),!13&!2'(D.(),!

VKDGRZV DQG GHFUHDVLQJ VXQOLJKW VKH GRHVQ¶W ILQG KHUVHOI DORQH DW DOO ! !

³2K JRRGQHVV ´ VKH VD\V SHHULQJ GRZQ ZLWK DPD]HPHQW D IHHOLQJ RI LPPHGLDF\

J(''(),!3&+!&)1(+&!.$E/8! !

5HVWLQJ LGO\ EHWZHHQ WKH UHFOLQHU DQG WKH 79 LV D FUHDWXUH WKDW VKH KDVQ¶W

;+&%($5-'/! &)2$5)1&+&E²9! ;'5D;! 19../! 291! -1+&123&E! ()E(JJ&+&)1'/! $)! 13&! J'$$+! 9-! (J! (1! $=)&E!13&!;'92&F!(1-!J5++/!3&9E!;+$;;&E!9.$%&!13&!29+;&1!./!2+$--&E!;9=-8! ! ! !

³/RRN DW \RX QRZ 6DP $UHQ¶W \RX VRPHWKLQJ -XVW ORRN DW \RX ´!

!

$SSHDULQJ PLOGO\ DURXVHG WKH FDW¶V OR]HQJH>'(G&!&/&-!=9123!3&+!J+$D!.&'$=F!'9K('/!

/&1!E('(,&)1'/!D$)(1$+(),!&%&+/!D()$+!-3(J1!$J!09+($)S-!'(D.-8! ! <3&)!2$DD&)2(),!=(13!

ZKDW VKH¶G LQWHQGHG WR WDON DERXW EHIRUH GR]LQJ RII VKH WRR ORXQJHV LQ KHU YLVLWRU¶V ;+&-&)2&F! -19/(),! ;51! $)! 13&! +&2'()&+! =3('&! +&D()(-2(),8! ! H3&! +&29''-! 3$=²1391!

-;'&)E(EF! J91&J5'! V&E)&-E9/! 9J1&+)$$)²WKH\¶G PHW E\ FKDQFH DW WKH 8QLYHUVLW\ RI 6RXWKHUQ &DOLIRUQLD¶V OLEUDU\ +H ZDV IUHVK RXW RI WKH $LU )RUFH DIWHU WKUHH \HDUV LQ Z5+$;&F!+&>9EM5-1(),!1$!2(%('(9)!'(J&!9)E!5-(),!13&!X878!Q(''!J$+!-5DD&+!2'9--&-8! ! H3&!=9-!

J9-1!9;;+$923(),!13&!2$)2'5-($)!$J!3&+!J$+D9'!&E5291($)²13&!J(+-1!=$D9)!()!3&+!J9D('/!

1$!J()(-3!2$''&,&F!3&+!.+9()!$%&+)$5+(-3&E!./!0&E(&%9'!9+1!9)E!'(1&+915+&8! !

³<RX UHPHPEHU"´ VKH DVNV PRUH WKDQ RQFH VSHDNLQJ DV WKH VKDGRZV GHHSHQ

DURXQG WKHP ³<RX UHPHPEHU WKDW"´! !

V(13!3()E-(,31F!-3&!29)!9''$=!3&+-&'J!1$!2352G'&!91!13$-&!39+E-3(;-!13&/!39E!J92&E!

&9+'/!$)F!13$-&!;5.'(2!9)E!;+(%91&!()&O5(1(&-!1391!3(-1$+/!39-!-()2&!E&&D&E!5)M5-1:! ! 13&! +(E(25'$5-!9)1(>D(-2&,&)91($)!'9=-!J$+.(EE(),!9!/$5),!2$5;'&!'(G&!13&D!J+$D!D9++/(),! ()!13&!H191&!$J!49'(J$+)(9F!13&!K&9'$1-!&L;+&--(),!2$)1&D;1!5)E&+!13&(+!.+&913!$+!25+-(),!

9'$5E! =3&)! 29123(),! -(,31! $J! 9! =3(1&! =$D9)! 2'(),(),! 1$! 13&! 9+D! $J! 9! /&''$=>-G())&E! PDQ ³-DS VRQ RI D ELWFK´ DQG ³-DS ORYHU´ ZHUH WKH PRVW FRPPRQ LQVXOWV KXUOHG WRZDUG 13&DF!&-;&2(9''/!()!13&!D$)13-!J$''$=(),!13&!=9+8! ! <3&!.(11&+!D&D$+/!$J!(1!-39G&-!3&+!

KHDG EXW VKH VPLOHV QRQHWKHOHVV /LNH ZDWHU RII D GXFNµV EDFN VKH WHOOV KHU ODWH KXVEDQG 7KH YLFWRU\ ZDV XOWLPDWHO\ WKHLUV WR HQMR\ DQ\ZD\ ,W GLGQµW PDWWHU WKDW WKH =$+'E! ZDU KH¶G IRXJKW LQ ZDV ORQJ ZRQ E\ WKH WLPH WKH\ FRXOG OHJDOO\ ZHG ,W GLGQµW D911&+!1391!9)$13&+!E&29E&!&)E&E!5;!;9--(),!5)1('!3&+!;9+&)1-!92G)$='&E,&E!3&+!9,9()! $+!.&,+5E,(),'/!922&;1&E!13&!,$$E>)915+&E!/$8-%2%-#=3$-&!'9-1!)9D&!39E!.&2$D&!3&+! $=)8! ! 71!GLGQ¶W PDWWHU QRW D OLFN EHFDXVH WKH\ DOZD\V KDG HDFK RWKHU ! !

³<RX UHPHPEHU 6DP"´ VKH DVNV WKH RYHUIORZLQJ VKDGRZV XQDEOH QRZ WR VHH

WKH FDW RQ WKH IORRU RU WKH SKRWR DOEXP SUHVVLQJ DW KHU ODS ³'R \RX"´ 6KH H[WHQGV D 39)E!()1$!13&!)(,318! ! P&+!J(),&+1(;-!.'()E'/!,+9K&!13&!9(+!=3&+&!3&+!35-.9)E!39E!-1$$E! DV D ER\ JUDVSLQJ IRU KLV ERG\ KLV DUP VRPH XQVHHQ WUDFH ³$UH \RX VWLOO KHUH GHDU"´! !

ZL2&;1! 09+($)! 9'+&9E/! G)$=-! 3&! 39-! +&2&E&E! J+$D! 3&+[! 3&! 9'=9/-! E$&-F!

&%&)159''/F!9-!-5+&'/!9-!13&!-5)!%9)(-3&-!J+$D!13&!-G/8! ! Q51F!-3&!+&D()E-!3&+-&'J!=3('&! '$=&+(),! 3&+! 39)EF! 3&! 9'=9/-! 2$D&-! .92G! =3&)! E9/'(,31! .+(,31&)-! 13&! =$+'E! $51-(E&F! $J1&)! 15+)(),! 5;! ()! 13&! '&9-1! $.%($5-! $J! =9/-:! ! 9! E(-29+E&E! 5D.+&''9! '&J1! .&-(E&! 9!

E5D;-1&+F!9!.'9)G!;(&2&!$J!;9;&+!'(11&+(),!13&!;9%&D&)1F!9!=3(1&!J&913&+!J'$91(),!;9-1!3&+! .&E+$$D! =()E$=F! %9+(91($)-! $J! 3(-! J92&! ,'(D;-&E! 9'$),! 2+$=E&E! -(E&=9'G-! 9)E! 91! .5-!

-1$;-F! 9! 235../! .$/F! 9! J91! 291²35)E+&E-! $J! E(JJ&+&)1! 13(),-! 13+$5,3$51! 13&! /&9+-F! .(,!

9)E! '(11'&²9''! $J! =3(23! 39%&! )&%&+! J9('&E! 1$! -5+;+(-&! 3&+8! ! <3&+&J$+&F! 13&! E9+G)&--! &)%&'$;(),!3&+²$D)(;+&-&)1!9)E!'92G(),!-5.-19)2&F!9)!(DD91&+(9'!+&9'(1/²=$)S1!.+(),!

3(D!1$!3&+F!)$+!=(''!(1!2$DJ$+1!3&+!9-!9!-$'(E!2$D;9)($)F!'(G&!9!'$%&+8! ! V(13$51!+&D$+-&F! VKH¶V XQGHUVWRRG IRU WKH ORQJHVW WLD&!1391!&%&+/13(),!.&951(J5'!-3&!39-!1+5'/!'$%&E!(-!)$=! $51! $J! +&923! 9)E! J9+! 9=9/8! ! Z%&)! (J! -3&! 2$5'E! -&(K&! 13(-! .'92G! '9/&+! 1391! D(,31! /&1!

2$)2&9'!3(-!;+&-&)2&F!,+(;;(),!(1!29+&J5''/!9)E!-1$=(),!(1!5;$)!9!.&E+$$D!-3&'JF!(1!=$)S1! .&! 13&+&! ()! 13&! D$+)(),! 1$! D&&1! 3&+! &/&-F! 9)-=&+! 3&+! %$(2&F! $+! .+5-3! 3&+! 23&&G! 9-! 9!

E&%$1&E!35-.9)E!=$5'E!E$!J$+!3(-!911&)1(%&!=(J&8! !

³6DP"´ VKH ZKLVSHUV DW WKH QLJKW ³6DP²"´!

!

")E! -&%&+9'! .'$2G-! J+$D! 3&+! 9;9+1D&)1F! 9'-$! (DD&+-&E! =(13()! 13&! %&+/! -9D&!

E9+G)&--F! H9D5&'! &)%(-($)-! 09+($)! 9'D$-1! 9-! -3&! (-! 91! 3(-! D$D&)1:! ! 3&9E! +&-1(),!

9,9()-1!13&!+&2'()&+F!;9'D-!J'91!91$;!13&!;3$1$!9'.5DS-!2$%&+8! ! H(11(),!$)!13&!'(%(),!+$$D! 2$523F! 3&! J&&'-! 3(-! =+(-1F! 3(-! G)52G'&-F! 3(-! '(;-²13$-&! ;9+1-! $J! 3(D! =3&+&! 3&+! 1$523! '(),&+-! '(G&! ()%(-(.'&! -29+-! (++(191(),! 3(-! -G()8! ! <3&! $'E! ;3$1$,+9;3-F! 1$$F! (123! 91! 3(-!

13$5,31-! 9-! (J! 1$! 195)1! 3(D! =(13! 13&! $13&+! H35),>/$²13&! .$/! 9)E! 13&)! 13&! D9)²9)! &)1(+&!'(J&1(D&!D9E&!;'9()!.51!5)G)$=9.'&8! ! V391S-!(1!D&9)T! ! 3&!13()G-F!9)E!3&9+-!13&! =$D9)S-!+9-;/F!2+/;1(2!%$(2&!+&-;$)E(),!()!3(-!D()EF!-9/(),!-$D&13(),!1391F!)$!D911&+!

3$=!=&''!3&+!'9),59,&!(-!D9-1&+&E!-$D&E9/F!3&!=$)S1!&%&+!.&!9.'&!1$!2$D;+&3&)E8! !

"!1(D&+!2'(2G-!)&9+!13&!J+$)1!&)1+/=9/F!921(%91(),!13&!J'5$+&-2&)1!2&('(),!'(,31[!(1-!

15.&!.5KK&-!=(13!;$=&+F!J'(2G&+()J RYHUKHDG DQG LOOXPLQDWLQJ KLV PRWKHU¶V SRVVHVVLRQV 9+$5)E! 3(D²13&! ;'9-1(2>2$%&+&E! 2$523! $)! =3(23! 3&! -(1-F! 13&! 5);92G&E! .$L&-F! 13&! <RF! 13&! E(-;'9/! 29.()&1! 2$)19()(),! 13&! J(,5+()&-²OLNH D ORDWKVRPH UHPLQGHU RI /RXLVD¶V (DD()&)1!9++(%9'!3$D&8! ! P(-!-1$D923!(DD&E(91&'/!-()G-F!9)E!&L;&''&E!J+$D!13&!E9+G!3&!

-O5()1-! 9-! D$+&! 1+$5.'(),! 2$)-(E&+91($)-! -19+1! 15,,(),! 91! 3(DF! 2$)M5+(),! 5;! 13&!

5)9%$(E9.'&!()1&++$,91($)!1391!=(''!)$!E$5.1!19G&!;'92&8! !

³6KXQJ>\R GLG \RX JR WR WKH DSDUWPHQW OLNH , WROG \RX"´!

!

³0P ´!

!

³:DV WKDW ZRPDQ WKHUH"´!

!

³0P ´!

!

³:KHUH DUH P\ FU\VWDOV" 'LG VKH JLYH WKHP"´!

!

³1R ´!

!

³:KDW GR \RX PHDQ -1"´!

!

Q51!)$13(),!H9D5&'!2$5'E!&L;'9()!9.$51!13(-!9J1&+)$$)!=$5'E!.&!.&'(&%&EF!J$+!3&!

EDUHO\ EHOLHYHV LW KLPVHOI $OO WKH VDPH KH GRHVQ¶W UHJUHW!'&9%(),!13&!J(,5+()&-!.&3()EF! 9)/D$+&!139)!3&!(D9,()&-!1391!3(-!D$13&+!+&,+&1-!E(-;$-(),!$J!13&!-G91&-8! ! ?9(+!(-!J9(+F! 3&!+&9-$)-F!9'13$5,3!13&!2$)-&O5&)2&-!9+&!3(-!1$!-5JJ&+8! ! ")E!.&9+(),!1391!()!D()EF!3&!

29)! 13()G! $J! '(11'&! &'-&! 1$! E$! )$=! &L2&;1! ,$! ;+921(2&! 13&! %($'()! 5)1('! -3&! +&15+)-²13&!

9;;&9'(),!-$5)E!$J!=3(23F!9'$),!=(13!3(-!E('(,&)2&F!D(,31!91!'&9-1!;'&9-&!3&+!=3&)!-3&! &)1&+-!13&!3$5-&8!

!

6RRQ WKH VWUDLQV RI 0HQGHOVVRKQ¶V @8158-# /1-7".)1# 8-# ?# 48-1.!J(''!3(-!.&E+$$DF!

-&&;(),!;9-1!13&!2'$-&E!E$$+!9)E!$51!()1$!13&!39''=9/8! ! NJ!9''!13&!;(&2&-!3&!G)$=-!13(-!(-!

KLV PRWKHU¶V IDYRULWH VR LW LV WKH RQO\ SLHFH KH FKRRVHV WR SOD\ <HW EHIRUH WKH ILUVW PRYHPHQW FRQFOXGHV /RXLVD¶V YRLFH VXGGHQO\ HUXSWV IURP WKH OLYLQJ URRP ORXG WKHQ -('&)1F!13&)!'$5E!9,9()8! ! P(-!.+&913!-1$;-F!9)E!3(-!.$E/!1&)-&-8! ! P$=!'$),!39-!-3&!.&&)!

3$D&T! ! ?+$K&)! ()! J+$)1! $J! 13&! D5-(2! -19)EF! 3&! O5(1-! ;'9/(),F! )&+%$5-'/! '(-1&)(),! J$+! 9!

PRPHQW :KHQ LW EHFRPHV FOHDU WKDW VKH LVQµW DGGUHVVLQJ KLP EXW UDWKHU LV DUJXLQJ RQ 13&! 1&'&;3$)&! =(13! -$D&$)&F! ;+$.9.'/! 3(-! J913&+F! 3&! '&1-! 3(-! .+&913! +&-5D&! 9)E! 2$)1()5&-! 1$! ;'9/8! ! Q/! 13&! D(EE'&! $J! 13&! -&2$)E! D$%&D&)1! 13&! 3&91&E! ;3$)&!

2$)%&+-91($)! (-! E$)&F! 13&! 3$5-&! J9''(),! O5(&1! -9%&! J$+! 13&! %($'()F! 9)E! =3('&! 13&! 13(+E! D$%&D&)1! ;+$2&&E-! =(13$51! ()1&++5;1($)F! 13&! =9+D! -D&''! $J! 3&+! 2$$G(),! ,+9E59''/! ()J5-&-!13&!9(+!()-(E&!3(-!+$$D8! !

2QFH WKH SLHFH LV FRPSOHWHG WKRXJK /RXLVD GRHVQ¶W ZDVWH D VHFRQG LQ EHFNRQLQJ

KLP 6KH VWRPSV KDOIZD\ WR KLV GRRU DV LI RQ FXH VKRXWLQJ ³6KXQJ>\R GLQQHU ´ +H 3&9+-! 3&+! O5(2G'/! 15+)! 9+$5)EF! J'$$+.$9+E-! 2+&9G(),! .&)&913! 29+;&1F! 3&+! J$$1-1&;-! ;$5)E(),! .92G! 1$=9+E! 13&! G(123&)8! ! ?+$=)(),F! 3&! ;51-! 3(-! ()-1+5D&)1! 9)E! .$=! 9=9/F! 9=9+&! )$=! $J! &923! )$(-&! -3&! 2+&91&-8! ! "! ;$1! 2'911&+-! 9,9()-1! 13&! -1$%&1$;8! ! *'91&-! 9+&! +&D$%&E!J+$D!9!29.()&1!-3&'JF!2'()G(),8! ! ")E!2951($5-'/!-1&;;(),!J+$D!3(-!.&E+$$DF!3&! ,$&-!E$=)!13&!39''F!;95-(),!&%&+/!1=$!$+!13+&&!-1&;-F!39D;&+&E!./!13&!J&9+!$J!=391!D9/!

39;;&)!)&L18! !

<3&)! -&91&E! ()! 3(-! 5-59'! -;$1! 91! 13&! E()(),! 19.'&F! 13&! -&2$)E! D/-1(J/(),!

$225++&)2&! $J! 13&! E9/! -'$='/! +&%&9'-! (1-&'J! 1$! 3(D²9! +&D9+G9.'&! $512$D&! 1391! (-! 9-!

SHUSOH[LQJ DQG XQH[SHFWHG DV DQ\WKLQJ HOVH KHµG H[SHULHQFHG RYHU WKH ODVW IHZ KRXUV ?+$D!13&!.&,())(),!$J!13&(+!E())&+!1$,&13&+!5)1('!(1-!&)EF!E5+(),!9;;+&3&)-(%&!.(1&-!9)E! 1(,31>'(;;HG FKHZLQJ WKH LVVXH RI KLV PRWKHU¶V WZR DEGXFWHG ILJXULQHV LV QHYHU EURXJKW XS QRU GRHV VKH DVN LI KH¶G YLVLWHG WKH $PHULFDQ ZRPDQ¶V DSDUWPHQW DIWHU VFKRRO ,Q J921F!I$5(-9!E$&-)S1!511&+!9!-(),'&!=$+E!13+$5,3$51!13&!D&9'²)$!.$13&+-$D&!O5&-1($)-F! )$!.9E,&+(),!$+E&+-F!)$!()-(-1(),!1391!3&!-2$$;!9!'(11'&!&L1+9!25++(&E!295'(J'$=&+!$+!.(11&+!

D&'$)! -$5;! ()1$! 3(-! .$='8! ! 7)-1&9E! -3&! +&D9()-! 5)2$DD5)(291(%&! $)! 3&+! -(E&! $J! 13&!

19.'&F!,'$$D/!9)E!+&D$1&F!-&&D(),'/!9'$)&8! ! Q51!=3&)!3&!J()(-3&-!&91(),F!&9-(),!$JJ!13&!

239(+! '(G&! -$D&$)&! E(-2+&&1'/! '&9%(),! 9! D$%(&! 13&91&+! -&91F! 3&+! E9+G! &/&-! J()9''/! '(J1! 1$! +&,9+E!3(D!=(13!9!-39+;!-19+&8!

!

³<RX JR VWXG\ ´ VKH VD\V WKH WRQH PRUH WLUHG WKDQ VWHUQ ³1R 79 IRU \RX

WRQLJKW ´ ! !

P&+! %$(2&! -1$;-! 3(D! ()! 3(-! 1+92G-8! ! P&! '$=&+-! 3(-! 3&9EF! )$EE(),! =3('&! J$25-(),!

$)!13&!J'$$+8! !

³*R GR OHVVRQV DQG JR WR EHG ´!

!

"--5D(),! 1391! 13&! =$+-1! 39-! M5-1! .&,5)F! H9D5&'! G&&;-! )$EE(),! D$D&)19+('/!

.&J$+&!+&9'(K(),!3(-!;+&&D;1(%&!+&-;$)-&!(-!2$)2&E(),!1$!)$13(),!$13&+!139)!3&+!-('&)2&8! !

P(-! 3&9E! -1$;-! D$%(),F! 9)E! 3&! ;&&G-! +&'5219)1'/! 91! 3&+! =(13$51! +9(-(),! 3(-! 23()F! E+&9E(),! 13$-&! ;(&+2(),! &/&-! 1391! 29)! .5+)! E&&;! ()-(E&! 3(D8! ! <$! 3(-! -5+;+(-&F! 13$5,3F! I$5(-9! (-! )$! '$),&+! -19+(),! 3(-! =9/8! ! W5''/! ;5-3(),! J$$E! 9+$5)E! 3&+! .$='! =(13!

23$;-1(2G-F! -3&! 1$$! 39),-! 3&+! 3&9E! '$=F! -(J1(),! 13+$5,3! 3&+! D&9'! ()! 9)! 9;913&1(2!

D9))&+8! ! ")E! ./! 13&! 1(D&! 9! ;(&2&! $J! 295'(J'$=&+! J'$91-! 5;=9+E! 9)E! E(-9;;&9+-! 91! 3&+! '(;-F! 3&! 39-! 9'+&9E/! -&(K&E! 13&! $;;$+15)(1/! 1$! -'()G! O5(&1'/! J+$D! 13&! +$$D²19G(),! 13&!

-3$+1251!92+$--!13&!G(123&)F!;'$EE(),!E$=)!13&!39''=9/²,$(),!=3&+&!13&!-$J1!-2+9;(),-! $J!3(-!D$5-&!9+&F!J$+!$)2&F!9!+&9--5+(),!-$5)E8! !

#$=!13&!+(EE'&-!$J!13&!E9/!D&'E!'(G&!9D9--(),!2'$5E-F!9)E!-(11(),!13$5,31J5''/!$)!

13&! &E,&! $J! 3(-! .&EF! H9D5&'! (-! 5)2&+19()! $J! 3(D-&'J! 9)E! 13&! =$+'E! 3&! ()39.(1-8! ! P$=!

2$5'E!3&!&)E!5;!()!;3$1$,+9;3-!1391!=&+&!)&%&+!19G&)!$J!3(DT! ! ")E!3$=!2$5'E!3&!,+$=!

ROG DQG VLFNO\ ZKHQ KH KDVQ¶W HYHQ ILQLVKHG PLGGOH VFKRRO" $QG ZK\ GLGQ¶W KLV PRWKHU 9-G! 9.$51! 13&! J(,5+()&-F! $+! O5&-1($)! 3(D! 9.$51! 13&! J9('5+&! $J! 3(-! 9J1&+)$$)! D(--($)T! !

V3/F!3&!=$)E&+-F!E$&-!&%&+/13(),!'$$G!13&!-9D&!9-!(1!E(E!13(-!D$+)(),²-D&''!9)E!19-1&!

9)E! +$5,3'/! J&&'! 13&! -9D&²H[FHSW DOVR IHHO VRPHKRZ DOWHUHG ,W¶V DV WKRXJK VLQFH SDVVLQJ WKH DSDUWPHQW¶V GLP WKUHVKROG D SDUDOOHO UHDOLW\ KDG HQFRPSDV-&E! 3(DF! +&19()(),!13&!J9D('(9+! J929E&-!=3('&! 239),(),!13&!()1+()-(2!)915+&!$J!=391&%&+!(-!%&('&E! .&3()E!13&D8! !

P&! J9''-! .92G! $)1$! 13&! D911+&--F! E+$;;(),! 3(-! 3&9E! 9,9()-1! 13&! ;(''$=8! ! 45+($5-!

-39;&-!&D&+,&!'(G&!;39)1$D-!$)!13&!=3(1&!2&('(),!9.$%&!3(D²13&+&!J$+!9!-&2$)EF!,$)&!

13&! )&L1²D(++$+(),! 13&! &..! 9)E! J'$=! $J! 3(-! ,+9;;'(),! 13$5,31-8! ! Q51! 9D$),! 13&! &L395-1(),F! ()9+1(25'91&!+5D.'(),-!$J!3(-!.+9()F!3&!5)2$)-2($5-'/!-&)-&-!1391!3(-!'(J&!(-! '(G&!9!.(J5+291(),!.+9)23!5;$)!9!%&)&+9.'&!1+&&F!-;+$51(),!9'$),-(E&!35)E+&E-!$J!-(D('9+! .+9)23&-²-$D&! E&9EF! -$D&! 13+(%(),F! -$D&! .&,())(),! 9)&=²9''! 2$))&21&E! /&1! 9),'(),! $51=9+E! ()! 13&(+! $=)! 5)(O5&! E(+&21($)-8! ! <3&)! (1! E9=)-! $)! 3(D! 1391F! ()! $)&! J$+D! $+!

DQRWKHU KH PXVW KDYH EHHQ KHUH IRU D YHU\ ORQJ WLPH +H PXVW¶YH EHHQ 9'(%&!.&J$+&!3(-!

RZQ ELUWK DQG PLUDFXORXVO\ DIWHU KLV RZQ GHDWK $QG WRR KH¶OO VXUHO\ EH KHUH IRU D %&+/! '$),! 1(D&! 1$! 2$D&F! ;&+39;-! J$+&%&+8! ! <391! (-! 13&! 2$)2'5-($)! 3&! (-! '&J1! =(13! 9-! 3(-! &/&'(E-! -'$='/! 2'$-&F! 13&! $)'/! 9)-=&+! =$+13! .&'(&%(),! =3&)&%&+! 3&! -3$5'E! +&%(-(1! 13(-! ;9+1(25'9+! <5&-E9/²()&JJ9.'&! ()! (1-! D&9)(),F! .$13! 3&9+1&)(),! 9)E! E(-O5(&1(),²39%(),!

9++(%&E! 1$! 3(D! 1$)(,31F! '(G&! -$! D523! &'-&! 13&-&! +&2&)1! E9/-F! J+$D! =391! -&&D-! 13&! %925$5-!E&;13-!$J!)$=3&+&8! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

,1 )(%58$5<¶6 ,668( ! "!#$%!&'()*!!"#$!+,)!!"$"! "!-(+,./*!0+1%*!+!2+33! ³,W¶V WRR EDG WKH VXQ GLGQ¶W VKLQH WKLV PRUQLQJ ´! "!4/5$0%%,!6%+(*!2('7!0$/*!8%(6!%8%,/,5! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !