! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
"!#$%&'!()!*+$,+&--!./!0(123!45''()!6!*&1&+!78!439),:! 439;1&+-!<(,31&&)!6!#()&1&&)! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
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²13&!-$),!1+9)-;$+1&I!5;$)!13&! 2+92L-! 9)I! ;$;-! $F! -2+9123/! %()/'A! '(L&! 9! '5''(),! D&--9,&! .+$9I29-1! 13+$5,3! 1(D&²)$13(),! B$5'IA! ,(%&)! 9)! ()(1(9'! ,'9)2&! ;9-1! 13&! I$$+B9/A! D9+L! 13&! &-19.'(-3D&)1!9-!9)!()%(1(),!-;$1!()!B3(23!1$!&)1&+8! !
%XW VWLOO IHHOLQJ WKH SOHDVDQW EROVWHULQJ HIIHFWV IURP GULQNLQJ WKH VWUDQJHU¶V
.&&+A!G9D5&'!-35FF'&-!F$+B9+I!B(13!'(11'&!+&'5219)2&A!;+&-&)1'/!$.-&+%(),!9!L()I!$F! 1+$;(29'! $9-(-! 9D$),! 13&! $;92(1/8! ! N(,31! B3&+&! 13&! F$/&+! &)I-A! $)! 13&! '&F1! 9)I! L&;1!.&3()I!,'9--!'(L&! 9!D5-&5D!&O3(.(1A!(-! 9)!&)2'$-&I!,9+I&)!.913&I!-$F1'/!()! 9K59D9+()&²-D9''! ;$11&I! ;9'D! 1+&&-A! D9+9)19-A! 29'913&9-A! 9)I! I$E&)-! $F! 2$'$+F5'! 9)135+(5D-8! ! P&! 2+$--&-! ()1$! 9! '$),! 2$++(I$+A! )$1(2(),! &O$1(2! $+23(I-! 2$%&+(),! 13&! 2&('(),! +9F1&+-A! I+$$;(),! 3(,3! 9.$%&! 9! +&IC29+;&1&I! ;9138! ! Q()(),! &(13&+!-(I&!$F!13&!39''B9/!9+&!;+(%91&!.$$13-!1391!39%&!I$$+-!'(L&!13$-&!F$5)I!$)! ;5.'(2! 1$('&1! -19''-A! -$D&! $;&)! 9)I! 5)'(1A! -$D&! 2'$-&I! 9)I! F+9D&I! ./! +&I! '(,31!
F+$D! B(13()8! ! R$''$B(),! 13&! -1+&123(),! 29+;&1! 1$B9+I! 13&! D5-(2A! 3&! 3$'I-! 13&! VWUDQJHU¶V ER[ DW KLV FKHVW SDVVLQJ WKHPHG GLQLQJ VHFWLRQV²09'9/9)A!G$513!G&9-A! "F+(29)²/&1! -;(&-! )$! $)&! 5)1('! +&923(),! 13&! D5+L/A! &K59''/! 29%&C'(L&! 2$2L19('! '$5),&!91!13&!&)I!$F!13&!;9138! !
7)! 9! F9+! 2$+)&+! $F! 13&! '$5),&A! 9! G&&.5+,! J5L&.$O! ,'$B-! 9)I! ;5'-91&-! ./! 9!
B9''!$F!.9D.$$8! ! 09))(),!9!.9+!I&2$+91&I!B(13!D()(915+&!F(-3(),!.$91-A!29+%&I! B$$I&)!1+(.9'!D9-L-A!)91(%&!-;&9+-!9)I!-3(&'I-!(-!9!13()A!&'I&+'/!D9)!-;$+1(),!9! B(-;/! R5! 09)235! D5-1923&A! B&9+(),! 9)! 9)1(K591&I! 2$$'(&! 391! 9)I! B3(1&! I52L! -5(1A!9)I!B3$!-&&D-!'&--!'(L&!9!.9+1&)I&+!139)!9)!&O1+9!F+$D!9!23&9;'/!;+$I52&I! F('DS! 3(-! )(D.'&! F(),&+-! 9+&! 2$)-19)1'/! D$%(),²-192L(),! ,'9--&-A! B(;(),! 13&! 2$5)1&+1$;A!-1+9(,31&)(),!%9+($5-!'(K5$+!.$11'&-!-$!1391!13&!'9.&'-!-3$B²9'13$5,3! 3&!+&D9()-!()911&)1(%&!1$!13&!F&B!;91+$)-!2'$(-1&+&I!13&+&8! ! G&91&I!1$,&13&+!91!13&! .9+! 9+&! F$5+! /$5),A! I9+LC39(+&I! D&)! ()! D9123(),! 911(+&! 1391! +&-&D.'&-! 13&! 2'$13(),!$F!13&!-1+9),&+!9)I!3(-!1B$!2$D;9)($)-A!&923!)5+-(),!9!2$2L19('!.&1B&&)! 13$5,31F5'!2(,9+&11&!1$L&-A!19'L(),!'$B'/!9)I!'$$L(),!9-!(F!13&/!39I!+&2&)1'/!,$11&)! $FF!B$+L8! !
M3&)! ;5-3(),! 13+$5,3! -9'$$)! I$$+-! )&9+! 13&! .9+A! 9! 2$(FF&I!
B$D9)²-9)I9'-A! B3(1&! -$2L-A! 9! '$),! .'92L! +$.&! B(13! B(I&! -'&&%&-A! 9! ;()L! -9-3! 1(&I! 9.$51! 3&+! B9(-1²K5(2L'/! 35++(&-! ()! 13&! I(+&21($)! $F! 13&! 39''B9/A! 9! +$5)I! -&+%(),! 1+9/! .9'9)2&I! $)! 9! ;9'DA! .+&&E(),! ;9-1! 13&! /$5),! D&)! 9)I! -L(+1(),! G9D5&'! B(13$51! '$B&+(),! 3&+! ,9E&! 5;$)! 3(-! D(-;'92&I! ;+&-&)2&8! ! #$+A! F$+! 1391! D911&+A!I$&-!9)/$)&!&'-&!9'1&+!13&(+!-19+&!9.$%&!3(D8! ! #$1!9!$)&!$F!13&D²'$-1!()! K5(&1!2$)%&+-91($)A!.5-/!1(I/(),!5;!13&!.9+²15+)-!13&(+!3&9I!$+!29-1-!13&(+!&/&-! I$B)B9+I! 9-! 3&A! '(L&! 9)! $'I! 3$5-&3$'I! ;&1! 1391! 9D.'&-! D$-1'/! 5))$1(2&I! F+$D! +$$D!1$!+$$DA!2+&&;-!92+$--!13&!I(D!K59I+9)1!$F!13&!'$5),&8! ! G$$)!13&!J5L&.$O! 13+$.-!.&-(I&!3(DA!13&!5L5'&'&!D5-(2!&23$&I!()!(1-!F'9-3(),A!2$'$+F5'!I(-;'9/A!9)I! 3&!-19)I-!F92(),!9!I$$+'&--!;$+19'!1391!'&9I-!$)'/!1$!9)!$.'(K5&!F'(,31!$F!-19(+-8! ! ! ! !
T3('&! ;95-(),! 13&+&A! 9! -&)-&! $F! I&J9! %5! $%&+19L&-! G9D5&'A! D9L(),! 3(D!
-35II&+8! ! U&1! 3&! 9'-$! +&9'(E&-! 1391! 9'D$-1! &%&+/13(),! 3&! 39-! &)2$5)1&+&I²13&! F$/&+A! 13&! 39''B9/A! 13&! '$5),&²(-! 9-! 13&! -1+9),&+! 39I! 9'+&9I/! I&-2+(.&I! (1A! &%&)! WKH VWDLUZHOO OLJKW WKURZLQJ LWV IDLQW UHGGLVK KXH GRZQ WKH VWHSV ³$QG²91! 13&! 1$;!$F!13&!-19(+-²(-²(-!9!,+9/!D&19'!I$$+²DW WKH WRS ´ WKH VWUDQJHU WROG KLP DV
13&/!+$I&!()!13&!.92L-&91!$F!13&!V0TA!3(-!&/&-!39'F!$;&)!9)I!3(-!%$(2&!.&2$D(),! ()2+&9-(),'/! -'5,,(-3A! +&D$1&A! 9-! (F! 3&! B&+&! .$13! &O;&+(&)2(),! 9)I! FRPPXQLFDWLQJ D VLQJOH GUHDP ³$QG WKDW¶V %LJ )DW²)$²3(-!$FF(2&A!7!D&9)²)$! 5-&! L)$2L(),²VR GRQ¶W NQRFN²)$.$I/! (-! 9+$5)I²D9/.&! )$1! /&1²D9/.&²-1(''! 1$$! &9+'/²LW¶V HDUO\²,$! 5;! 13$-&! -19(+-²9)I! ,$! &)1&+²9)I! -&&! 9! I&-L²/$5! -&&! (1²9)I!1391W-!B3&+&!/$5!,$²9)I!-$!;51!13&!.$O²;51!91!13&!2&)1&+²91!13&!2&)1&+! $F! 13&! I&-L²9)I! 13&)! 1391W-! 9''²/$5! 29)! I$! 1391²9)I! ()! 29-&²(F! 13&/! 9-L! /$5²\RX¶UH²I&'(%&+(),!
13(-!
,(F1²1$!
H59)C/5²)$A!
)$²(I($1²1$!
V(,!
R91²/&-²V(,! R91²F+$D! H59)C/5²D&²1$! V(,! R91²DQG GRQ¶W VD\ QRWKLQJ &'-&²WKHUH¶V QRWKLQJ HOVH WR VD\²$L9/²$L9/²LWµV VWLOO HDUO\ \HW²\RXµOO GR ILQH²´! !
1RZ ZLWK WKH VWUDQJHU¶V %0: FLUFOLQJ WKH EORFN WKH UROOHU VNDWHV VLWWLQJ
XSULJKW RQ WKH FDU¶V IO$$+.$9+IA!9)I!9!35)I+&I!I$''9+!.(''!F$'I&I!9)I!-9F&,59+I&I! ./! 13&! B9(-1.9)I! $F! 3(-! 5)I&+B&9+A! G9D5&'! .&,()-! 2'(D.(),! 13&! -19(+-! 9-! ()-1+521&I²13&!.$O!2+9I'&I!1(,31'/A!13&!I$+D9)1!;9),-!()!3(-!29'%&-!F'9+(),²5)1('! 3&! D$5)1-! 13&! 1$;! -1$$;A! 9++(%(),! 91! 9! D&19'! -&25+(1/! I$$+! 1391! $FF&+-! )$! -(,).$9+I!$+!2'5&!F$+!B391!D(,31!&O(-1!J5-1!.&/$)I!(18! ! "F1&+!3&-(191(),!9!D$D&)1A! 3&! 29+&F5''/! B+(,,'&-! F(),&+-! 9+$5)I! 13&! -('%&+! L)$.A! 15,,(),! 13&! I$$+! $;&)! -&%&+9'! ()23&-8! ! P&! 13&)! 9),'&-! 3(-! .$I/! 9)I! 13&! .$O! 13+$5,3! 13&! -'(D! ,9;A! 13&! I$$+! )9++$B'/! D(--(),! 9! -3$5'I&+! B3&)! (1! 951$D91(29''/! -B(),-! -351! .&3()I! 3(D²13&!5L5'&'&!D5-(2!-('&)2&I8! !
%XW WKH IHHOLQJ RI GHMD YX GRHVQ¶W KDSSHQ WR DOVR VQHDN RYHU WKH WKUHVKROG
9)I! G9D5&'! F()I-! 3(D-&'F! ()! 9! B9+D'/! '(1! $FF(2&! 1391! 3&! 2$5'I! )&%&+! 39%&! &)%(-($)&I8! ! 71! (-! 9! B(I&! -;92&A! 1(I/! 9)I! 2'&9)! 9-! 9)/! +&-;&219.'&! '(.+9+/A! 2$D;'&1&! B(13! 3(,3! .$$L29-&-! 9)I! &O;&)-(%&! 9)1(K5&! F5+)(15+&A! 9''! .+$B)! 9)I! 1&9L! 9)I! .5+,5)I/8! ! M3&! &)1(+&! +$$D! 39-! 13&! $'ICB$+'I! 9''5+&! $F! 9! D9)$+! -15I/²%&+/! <5+$;&9)! ()! 19-1&A! 9)I! %&+/! $-1&)191($5-8! ! H+9)(1&! '($)-! $+! D9+.'&! )5I&-! 9+&! 9--(,)&I! 1$! %9+($5-! ;'92&-A! D$1($)'&--! $)! ;&I&-19'-! '(L&! -&)1+(&-8! ! X225;/(),!9!-(I&!19.'&!(-!9!-D9''!.+9--!29'I+$)!$F!.5..'(),!$('A!3&91&I!./!9!G1&+)$! 9)I!&D(11(),!9)!&O$1(2A!D5-L/!F+9,+9)2&!1391!F(''-!13&!$FF(2&8! !
³<HV²"´ DVNV D FXUW UDWKHU XQSOHDVDQW YRLFH !
!
³2K ZKR¶V WKLV NLG *RQJCPLQJ"´ VD\V DQRWKHU YRLFH LQ D KLJK
&O2&--(%&'/!I&'(291&!9)I!.+&913/!9FF&2191($)8!
!
7KH RIILFH LVQ¶1! &D;1/! '(L&! 13&! -1+9),&+! 39I! 2'9(D&IA! 9)IA! -5II&)'/A! 13&!
-(D;'&!19-L!$F!I&'(%&+(),!13&!.$O!-&&D-!9!F$+D(I9.'&!5)I&+19L(),S!F$+!)$B!13+&&! -&1-!$F!;+$.(),!&/&-!39%&!F(O&I!$)!G9D5&'A!13+&&!I(FF&+&)1!-19+&-²1B$!D&)!9)I!9! B$D9)²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¶V 'DYLG²I(-;+$;$+1($)91&'/!'9+,&!39)I-! F$'I&I! .&'$B! 9! .511$)&I! -;$+1-! J92L&1A! 9! -'(%&+! $F! ;()L! 1$),5&! B&I,&I! I5D.'/! .&1B&&)!3(-!'(;-!B3('&!3&!-K5()1-!B(13$51!&O;+&--($)²WKDW FDXVHV 6DPXHOµV JD]H 1$!)&+%$5-'/!I+$;8! ! ! !
³:KDW LV LW ER\"´ VQDUOV WKH EDOGLQJ PDQ DW WKH GHVN ³:KDW DUH \RX
GRLQJ KHUH" :KDW GR \RX ZDQW" :KDW LV LW"´ 7KH TXHVWLRQV DUH ILUHG OLNH .5''&1-8! !
³:KDW ZKDW ZKDW ´ VD\V WKH ZRPDQ VKDNLQJ KHU KHDG ³<RX DOZD\V DVN
WRR PDQ\ TXHVWLRQV ´! !
G19+(),!I$B)A!G9D5&'!-&&-!1391!3(-!-$2L-!9+&!+&-1(),!$)!9!+5..&+!I$$+D91A!
)&O1! 1$! B3(23! -(1! 9! ;9(+! $F! .+(,31! ,+&&)! -1('&11$! ;5D;-! 9)I! 9! ;9(+! $F! .'92L! I+&--! -3$&-8! ! M3&)! 9)! 5)&9-/! -&)-91($)! .&2$D&-! ;&+2&;1(.'&! ()-(I&! 3(-! -1$D923A! 9! F'5++/!$F!.511&+F'(&-!1+9;;&I!B(13()!;(123CI9+L!2$)F()&-A!F'511&+(),!3&';'&--'/!3&+&! 9)I!13&+&8! !
³+H¶V VK\ , WKLQN ´ WKH ZRPDQ VD\V LQ D FOR\LQJ ZD\ DV LI VKH ZHUH DQ
DGRULQJ \HW LQVLQFHUH DXQW\ ³7DON QLFHU <RX VKRXOGQ¶W EH VR PHDQ ´! !
"!%$'5D()$5-!-(,3!$F!(D;91(&)2&!.'$B-!F+$D!.&3()I!13&!I&-LA!.51!.&F$+&!
13&!.9'I(),!D9)!29)!,+$B'!9)/13(),!&'-&A!G9D5&'!'(F1-!.$13!3(-!&/&-!9)I!3(-!9+D-A! &O1&)I(),! 13&! .$O! $51B9+I8! ! M3&! B$D9)! ;+$;-! 3&+-&'F! 5;! $)! 9)! &'.$BA! &'$),91(),! 3&+! '&9)! )&2LA! 9)I! '$$L-! 1$B9+I! 13&! .$O! B(13! 25+($-(1/8! ! M3&! /$5),! D9)A!13$5,3A!+&D9()-!D$1($)'&--A!B9123F5'8! !
³$QG ZKDW¶V WKDW"´ WKH EDOGLQJ PDQ DVNV DVVXPLQJ D PRUH TXL]]LFDO
1$)&A!3(-!-9,,(),!23()!;+921(29''/!I+(;;(),!1$!13&!I&-L1$;8! ! ! !
³)RU %LJ )DW ´ 6DPXHO DQVZHUV ZHDNO\ !
!
"! D$1$+(E&I! )$(-&! .&,()-! B3(++(),! 5)I&+! 13&! I&-LA! 9)I! 13&! .9'I(),! D9)!
D$%&-! 9-! (F! F'$91(),! $)! 9(+A! ,'(I(),! .92LB9+I-! 9! 2$5;'&! $F! F&&18! ! P(-! 3&9I! 9)I! -3$5'I&+-! ;(%$1! -39+;'/A! 13&)! '(L&! 9! 1()! 19+,&1! 91! 9! 29+)(%9'! -3$$1(),! ,9''&+/A! 3(-! .'$91&I!;+$F('&!I+(F1-!I$B)!13&!'&),13!$F!13&!I&-L1$;!5)1('A!;(%$1(),!-39+;'/!9,9()! 1$!F92&!G9D5&'A!3&!-1$;-!9.+5;1'/!.&-(I&!13&!I&-L8! ! G&91&I!$)!9)!&'&21+(2C;$B&+&I! -2$$1&+A! B&9+(),! $)'/! 9! .'5&! I+&--! -3(+1A! 3&! -3(F1-! 3(-! 2&)1&+! $F! ,+9%(1/! F$+B9+IA! VD\LQJ ³,¶P %LJ )DW 6R ZKDW LV LW"´ 7KH PDQ¶V KHDG QHFN VKRXOGHUV DUPV 1$+-$²9''! 13$-&! .'5..&+/! ;9+1-! I$! 13&! )(2L)9D&! $F! V(,! R91! 92159'! J5-1(2&A! 3(-! -5;&+F'5$5-! F'&-3! ;+&11/! D523! 2$)-5D(),! 13&! -2$$1&+8! ! V51! 13&+&! (-! )$! B9(-1! .&'$B! 13&! D9--(%&! .&''/²)$! '&,-A! )$! F&&1²)$13(),! &O2&;1! 9! -2$$1&+! -&91! 1391! (-! $.-25+&I! .&)&913! 13&! 5)152L&I! I+&--! -3(+1! 9)I! -&&D-! -$D&3$B! F5-&I! ()1$! 3(-! ()2$D;'&1&!.$I/8! !
)RU D PRPHQW 6DPXHO FDQ¶W VSHDN WRQJXHC1(&I!9-!3&!(-!./!13&!39'%&I!F(,5+&!
)$B!F92(),!3(D!F+$D!92+$--!13&!+$$D8! ! G52L(),!3(-! .$11$D!'(;A!3&!+&-1+9()-!13&! .&B('I&+&I! '$$L! 1391! 13+&91&)-! 1$! 1+9)-F$+D! 3(-! F92&A! -$D&13(),! B3(23A! (F! &O;+&--&IA!B$5'I!.&1+9/!13&!9D9E&D&)1!$F!-&&(),!9!;&+-$)!B3$!(-!.$13!()2+&I(.'/! 35,&!9)I!1&++(.'/!-D9''8! ! P$B!I$&-!3&!,&1!13+$5,3!13&!$FF(2&!I$$+Y! ! 3&!B$)I&+-8! ! X+!5-&!13&!-19(+-²$+!13&!1$('&1Y! ! ! !
³0PP ZKDW KDYH \RX EURXJKW PH"´!
!
³$ JLIW ´ 6DPXHO ILQDOO\ PXWWHUV UDLVLQJ WKH ER[ KLJKHU VR WKDW LW EORFNV
3(-!%(&B!$F!V(,!R91!9'1$,&13&+8! !
³:KDW"´!
!
³+H VDLG D JLIW ´ WKH ZRPDQ FKLPHV LQ ³,WµV D JLIW *RQJCD(),8! ! U$5!
KDYH DQ DGPLUHU +RZ VZHHW ´! !
³$ JLIW" )URP ZKR"´!
!
G9D5&'! )$I-! (D;5'-(%&'/A! D5-1&+(),! B$+I-! 1391A! B3&)! -;$L&)A! 39%&! 13&!
UHKHDUVHG HVVHQFH RI VWDJH OLQHV ³)URP 0U *XDQC\X VLU WR 0U %LJ )DW ´ DQG 9-! 3&! -;&9L-! 13&! B$D9)! I9+1-! 3&+! ,9E&A! -5++&;1(1($5-'/! D$)(1$+(),! V(,! R91W-! +&921($)!B(13$51!15+)(),!3&+!3&9I8! !
³)URP *XDQC/5Y! ! H59)C\X LVQ¶W PDQ HQRXJK WR FRPH KLPVHOI"´ %LJ )DW V
%$(2&! (-! )$B! -3+(''S! 13&! -95-9,&C'(L&! F(),&+-! $F! 3(-! 39)I-! 9+&! -K5&&E(),! 13&! VFRRWHU¶V KDQGOHEDU ³7DNH RII \RXU VKRHV DQG EULQJ LW KHUH ´! !
³+H¶V QRW ZHDULQJ VKRHV ´ WKH ZRPDQ UHSRUWV 6KH UHWXUQV KHU VWDUH WR
13&!.$OA!13&!)$)239'9)2&!$F!3&+!I&D&9)$+!+&;'92&I!./!9!F(+D)&--!1391!2$)1+921-! 3&+!F92&!B(13!9!-$5+A!;&+15+.&I!'$$L8! !
³1R VKRHV" :K\ GRQ¶W \RX KDYH VKRHV" ,WµV ILOWK\ ZDONLQJ DURXQG
RXWVLGH OLNH WKDW ´ %LJ )DW OLIWV D KDQG ZDJJOLQJ LW DW WKH VNLQQ\ \RXQJ PDQ ³6HYHQ JR JHW LW IURP KLP ´! !
³'RQ¶W ERWKHU ,¶OO GR LW ´ VD\V WKH ZRPDQ VRXQGLQJ DQQR\HG 6KH
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
R'9-3(),! 9! ;&+F5)21$+/! -D('&A! 13&! B$D9)! 2'9(D-! 13&! .$OA! 3&+! 2+(D-$)!
F(),&+)9('-! ;+&--(),! 9,9()-1! 13&! -91()! B+9;;(),! 9-! G9D5&'! +&'&9-&-! 3(-! 3$'I8! ! 7)-1&9I! $F! (DD&I(91&'/! ,$(),A! 13$5,3A! -3&! ;95-&-! 9)I! -)(FF-! B(13! %(,$+$5-! QRVWULOV VXGGHQO\ UHFRLOLQJ ³7KH ER\ VWLQNV ´ VKH DQQRXQFHV SDVW D VKRXOGHU 13&!;+$J&21(RQ RI DQ $GDPµV DSSOH EREELQJ DW KHU WKURDW ! !
³+H ZKDW"´!
!
³6WLQNV +H VWLQNV ´!
!
³:KDW" +H VWLQNV" 0PP WKDW¶V QRW JRRG ´!
!
7KH ZRPDQ¶V VXSHUILFLDO VPLOH WKHQ UHVXPHV DV VZLIWO\ DV LW KDG
I(-9;;&9+&IA! 9)I! 3&+! +9%&)! &/&-! ,'&9D! I$B)! 5;$)! G9D5&'! '(L&! .5+)(-3&I! 2$9'A!
WKH FXUOHG H\HODVKHV EOLQNLQJ EHQHYROHQWO\ ³,¶P QRW WU\LQJ WR EH XQNLQG ´ VKH VD\V VRIWO\ ³EXW \RX UHDOO\ GR VWLQN )UHVK RII WKH ERDW DUH \RX"´! !
Z)-5+&! $F! 3$B! 1$! 9)-B&+A! G9D5&'! -39L&-! 3(-! 3&9I! %&+/! -'(,31'/8! ! U$5W+&!
5,'/A!3&!13()L-8! ! U$5¶UH XJOLHU WKDQ DQ\RQH ! !
G3&!-K5()1-!3&+!I$5.'&C'(II&I!&/&-A!,(%(),!3(D!13&!$)2&CRYHU ³7KLV LVQ¶W
V&(J(),8! ! U$5! )&B! 43()&-&! D5-1! '&9+)! .&11&+! 39.(1-8! ! *&+-$)9'! 3/,(&)&! (-! LPSRUWDQW ´! !
³,¶P 7DLZDQHVH ´! ! G9D5&'!D5D.'&-A!3(-!%$(2&!F9''(),!-3$+1!$F!(1-!()1&)I&I!
I&F(9)2&8! !
³, GRQ¶W FDUH (LWKHU ZD\ \RX VPHOO 7KDW¶V DOO , QHHG WR NQRZ DERXW
\RX ´ 6KH WRXFKHV KLP ZLWK DQ LQGH[ ILQJHU JHQWO\ SXVKLQJ WKH WLS RI KLV QRVH OLNH LW ZDV DQ HOHYDWRU EXWWRQ ³$)/B9/A! /$5! -19/! +(,31! 13&+&8! ! Q&1! D&! ,&1! /$5! -$D&13(),A!.51!L&&;!/$5+!I(+1/!-$2L-!$)!1391!D91²RU HOVH \RX ZRQ¶W JHW DQ\WKLQJ QLFH ´! !
G9D5&'!)$I-!9!'(11'&!.(1A!13&!35+1F5'!+&D9+L-!;+$D;1'/!'&--&)&I!./!13&!3$;&!
$F!9II(1($)9'!D$)&/8! ! M3&!B$D9)!)$I-!.92L!91!3(DA!B(;(),!13&!()I&O!F(),&+!$)! 3&+!D()(-L(+1!.&F$+&!9.$51CF92(),8! ! GB(%&'(),!3&+!3(;-A!-3&!,$&-!9B9/!F+$D!3(DA! ,+92&F5''/! 29++/(),! 13&! .$O! ()! 13&! ;9'D! $F! $)&! 39)I8! ! ")I! B9123(),! 3&+! -'()L! 1$B9+I! V(,! R91A! 3&! -&'F! 2$)-2($5-'/! F'&O&-! 3(-! )$-1+('-A! 2$%&+1'/! -)(FF(),! 13&! 9(+! B3('&! B$)I&+(),! B3&+&! (1! (-! &O921'/! 1391! 3(-! .$I/! -1()L-²3(-! 39(+A! 3(-! -L()A! 3(-! .$11$D²/&1! ()39'&-! )$13(),! ;$1&)1! $13&+! 139)! 13&! -1+$),A! F+9,+9)1! $I$+! $F! -2&)1&I!$('8! !
:KHQ WKH ZRPDQ VWRSV EHVLGH WKH VFRRWHU WKH \RXQJ PDQ¶V JD]H PRYHV
-(I&'RQJ REVHUYLQJ WKH ER[ EHLQJ GHOLYHUHG LQWR WKLFN KDQGV ³6R ER\ *XDQC/5! KDG \RX EULQJ PH WKLV JLIW ´ VD\V %LJ )DW ZLWK DQ H[SUHVVLRQ RI HDUQHVW K5&-1($)(),A!1&-1(),!13&!B&(,31!$F!13&!.$O!B3('&!&FF$+1'&--'/!.9'9)2(),!3(-!1$+-$!$)! WKH VFRRWHU VHDW ³0PP DQG ZKDW¶V RXU IULHQG *XDQC\X GRLQJ WRQLJKW"´! !
M3&!B$D9)!15+)-!3&+!3&9IA!)$B!I(-+&,9+I(),!13&!.$O8! ! P&+!-19+&!2+$--&-!
WKH RIILFH WR PHHW 6DPXHO¶V H\HV FRQFHUQHG DQG H[SHFWDQW %XW VRPHWKLQJ LQ KHU ()K5(+(),! '$$LA! 9-! 13$5,3! -3&! D(,31! 1+5'/! 29+&! 9.$51! 13&! -1+9),&+A! D9I&! 9)! XQVHHPO\ DQVZHU VSULQJ IRUWK ZLWKRXW D VHFRQG WKRXJKW ³+H¶V GHDG ´ 6DPXHO VD\V SODLQO\ VKUXJJLQJ ³+H¶V D JKRVW DOUHDG\ ´!
!
7KH \RXQJ PDQ¶V JD]H VKRRWV WR 6DPXHO WKH VOLYHU RI WRQJXH UHWUDFWLQJ DV
3(-!'(;-!;+&--!1$,&13&+!9)I!I+9B!9!-1+9(,31!'()&8! ! !
³'HDG"´ WKH ZRPDQ VD\V WDNHQ DEDFN D KDQG IXPEOLQJ XS KHU EORXVH
³*XDQC\X GHDG"³ 7KH VXUSULVH RYHUZKHOPLQJ KHU IDFH TXLFNO\ GUDLQV WKURXJK D ;5+-&I! D$513A! '&9%(),! 9! .'9)L! -'91&! .&3()I! 1391! &)I&9%$+-! 9! I(-;'9/! $F! K5(&1! 2$D;$-5+&8! !
V&D5-&D&)1!B+()L'&-!V(,!R91W-!.+$B8! ! P&!13$5,31F5''/!-15I(&-!13&!.$O!F$+!
D PRPHQW KLV ORZHU MDZ VODFN ³$QG KRZ LV WKDW KH V GHDG"´ KH VD\V JODQFLQJ 91!G9D5&'8! !
7)!;'92&!$F!9)!9)-B&+A!G9D5&'!-3+5,-!9,9()8!
!
³, VHH 0PP²´!
!
T(13!13&!-9D&!I&F1)&--!1391!L&&;-!3(-!B(I&!.$I/!;$-(1($)&I!$)!13&!-2$$1&+!
-&91A!V(,!R91!.9'9)2&-!13&!-1+9),&+W-!,(F1!()!9!39)I8! ! P&!I&'(291&'/!5)1(&-!13&!-91()! .$B!2$%&+(),!13&!.$O!1$;A!.+5-3(),!13&!.'92L!F9.+(2!9-(I&!1$!+&%&9'!9!.9'-9!B$$I! 2$)19()&+! ;9()1&I! ()! 13&! D()51&! 29''(,+9;3/! $F! L9)J(8! ! X)2&! 13&! '(I! (-! +&D$%&IA! 13&! 2$)1&)1-! $F! 13&! .$O! ,(%&)! 9! 25+-$+/! ()-;&21($)A! 9! ;'9/F5'! ,+()! +&-39;&-! V(,! )DW¶V VHYHUH H[SUHVVLRQ DQG IOHVK\ EDJV VZHOO EHORZ KLV DPXVHG H\HV OLNH WKH GRXJK RI VWHDPHG GXPSOLQJV ³/RRN =KXCVKHQJ ³ KH VD\V WKUXVW(),! 13&! .$O! XSZDUG DW WKH ZRPDQ ³6HH WKLV" 7KDW EDVWDUG ZDVQ¶W O\LQJ ZKHQ KH VDLG \RX WRRN KLV KHDUW ´! !
V51! F+$D! B3&+&! 3&! -19)I-A! G9D5&'! -&&-! 1391! 13&! B$D9)A! 5;$)! ;&&+(),!
LQVLGH WKH ER[ MXVW ORQJ HQRXJK IRU DYHUVLRQ WR UHJLVWHU GRHVQµW TXLWH VKDUH %LJ )DWµV SOHDVXUH HYHQ WKRXJK VKH PDQDJHV D IDLQW JULQ DIWHUZDUG XWWHULQJ IODWO\ ³1R KH FOHDUO\ ZDQWHG \RX WR KDYH LW GHDU ,W¶V QRW PLQH DQ\PRUH ´ +HU VNLQ 39-! %(-(.'/! '$-1! (1-! '5-1&+A! 9-! (F! 13&! ,+9I(&)1! %9'5&-! $F! 13&! ,9+(-3! D9L&5;! 39I! I&2+&9-&IA! 9)I! ZKHQ VKH VXGGHQO\ GHSDUWV %LJ )DW¶V VLGH WKH SUHYLRXV VZLYHOV VZD\V DQG VOLQNV DUH VXEVWLWXWHG E\ WKH GHOLEHUDWH KXUULHG JDLW RI D PDQ ³*LYH 13&! L(I! -$D&13(),A! H$),CPLQJ ´ VKH VD\V RIIKDQGHGO\ ³,W¶V WKH OHDVW \RX FDQ GR ´! !
³0PP ´ SXUUV %LJ )DW ;'92(),! 13&! .$OA! (1-! '(IA! 9)I! 13&! -91()! 2'$13! 91! 9!
2$+)&+!$F!13&!)&9+./!I&-LS!13&)!B3('&!13&!B$D9)!-;+&9I-!3&+-&'F!$)!13&!239(-&A!3&! +&'5219)1'/!;5''-!9!,$'IC;'91&I!2(,9+&11&!29-&!$51!$F!9!.+&9-1!;$2L&18! ! !
!
([FHSW 6DPXHO LVQ¶W ZDWFKLQJ %LJ )DW RU SD\LQJ D11&)1($)! 9-! F(),&+-! ;$;!
$;&)!13&!29-&!9)IA!+913&+!139)!+&D$%(),!9!2(,9+&11&A!&O1+921!B391!-&&D-!1$!.&!9! ZKLWH EXVLQHVV FDUG ,QVWHDG KH VFDQV WKH ZRPDQ¶V OHQJWKZLVH IRUP²3&+! 25+%(),! -;()&! )$B! 9(D&I! ()! 3(-! I(+&21($)A! 3&+! +&;$-&I! 3&9I! F92(),! 13&! $;;$-(1&! B9''²F+$B)(),! B(13! 13&! +&9'(E91($)! 1391! 13(-! D5-1! .&! 13&! .&951(F5'! ,(+'! 13&! -1+9),&+!39I!D&)1($)&IA!13&!$)&!+&-;$)-(.'&!F$+!39%(),!295-&I!3(-!)&BF$5)I!.(,! EURWKHU VR PXFK WURXEOH %XW \RXµUH ZURQJ KH WKLQNV 6KH LVQ¶W EHDXWLIXO DW DOO !! !
³+HUH \RX JR *HW \RXUVHOI GLQQHU ´!
!
G9D5&'!,'9)2&-!91!V(,!R91A!B3$!,&-15+&-!9-!(F!-(,)9'(),!9!B9(1&+A!D$1($)(),!
1B$!+9(-&I!F(),&+-!1391!3$'I!13&!B3(1&!29+I!9'$F18! ! X)!25&A!13&!/$5),!D9)!%9291&-! 3(-! ;$-1! ()! F+$)1! $F! 13&! [9%(I! -1915&A! B9'L-! 9! F&B! F&&1! 1$! 13&! -2$$1&+A! 9)IA! &O&251(),!9!;+921(2&I!.$BA!922&;1-!13&!29+I8! !
³/LVWHQ ER\ \RX ILUVW GHOLYHU *XDQC\X D PHVVDJH IURP PH ´ VD\V %LJ )DW
DEVHQWO\ ZDYLQJ WKH \RXQJ PDQ DZD\ ³<RX WHOO KLP , GRQ¶W EHOLHYH KLP 7HOO KLP %LJ )DW NQRZV KH¶V QHYHU KDG D KHDUW WR EHJLQ ZLWK 9)I!1&''!3(D!7!L)$B!13&! GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ D PDQ DQG D SLJ ´! !
1RW VXUH ZKDW WR PDNH RI %LJ )DW¶V VRPHZKDW VWUDQJH DQG FU\SWLF PHVVDJH
G9D5&'! )$I-! 9)/B9/8! ! P(-! +&-;$)-&A! 3$B&%&+A! (-! $.-25+&I! ./! 13&! 19''A! -L())/! F(,5+&! 2$D(),! F$+B9+I! ()! &O;9)-(%&! -1&;-A! 13&! \RXQJ PDQ¶V GUHVV VRFNV VWULGLQJ 5;$)! &O;&)-(%&! 13+$B! +5,-! 9)I! ;$'(-3&I! -'91-! $F! 39+IB$$I! F'$$+(),8! ! M3&)! I(-9;;$()1D&)1!15,-!91!3(-!F92&!B3&)!(1!.&2$D&-!$.%($5-!1391!D$)&/!(-)W1!.&(),! $FF&+&IA! 9)I! )$! -$$)&+! I$&-! 13&! 29+I! D&&1! 3(-! $51-1+&123&I! 39)I! 139)! 3&! 3&9+-! WKH ZRPDQ VD\ ³6HYHQ ZLOO \RX SOHDVH FDUU\ WKH NLG RXWVLGH +H V GLUW\ ´! !
³0PP \HV PDNH VXUH KLV IHHW RU KDQGV GRQ¶W WRXFK DQ\WKLQJ ´!
!
T(13! 1391A! 13&! &O;+&--($)'&--! /$5),! D9)! .&)I-A! -2$$;(),! 5;! 9! -19+1'&I!
G9D5&'!9+$5)I!13&!B9(-1A!35FF(),!9-!13$5,3!3&!B&+&!3$(-1(),!9!'9+,&!-92L!$F!+(2&! 9)I! J$-1'(),! (1! 9.$51! ()1$! 9! D$+&! D9)9,&9.'&! ;$-(1($):! ! 3$+(E$)19'A! B&(,31! I(-1+(.51&I!&%&)'/A!;'(9.'&!9)I!'(D;!91!3(-!-(I&A!-&25+&I!.&)&913!9)!()F'&O(.'&!9+D8! ! 09()19()(),!2$)1()59'!D$%&D&)1A!13&!/$5),!D9)!I(;-!13&!I+&--!-$2L-!()-(I&!13&! .'92L!I+&--!-3$&-!)&9+!13&!D91²13&!'&F1!F$$1A!13&!+(,31!F$$18! ! V51!-5-;&)I&I!13&+&! $FF! 13&! ,+$5)IA! 13&! 29+I! )$B! 2+5D;'&I! ()! 3(-! 25+'&I! F(),&+-A! G9D5&'! F&&'-! 9)! 9'D$-1! 3&';'&--! -&)-&! $F! $;;+&--($)S! 3(-! '&,-! J51! .&/$)I! 13&! /$5),! D9Q¶V FKHVW
3(-! 3&9I! 9)I! 9! -3$5'I&+! I9),'(),! 9.$%&! 9! F'91! +&9+! &)IA! 3(-! 2+$$L&I! ,9E&! UDQGRPO\ GLUHFWHG E\ EXVWOLQJ J\UDWLRQV WKDW DUHQµW KLV RZQ 6HFWLRQV RI FHLOLQJ -;()!$%&+3&9I8! ! M('1&I!F'9-3&-!$F!13&!B9''-A!13&!.$$L29-&-A!13&!-1915&-A!9)I!V(,!R91! F'/!;9-18! ! #$13(),!-19/-!-1(''8! !
M3&! ,+9/! I$$+! $;&)-! B(I&A! -;+9/(),! +&I! '(,31A! 9)I! 13&! /$5),! D9)! 9)I!
G9D5&'!.5D;!1$,&13&+!$)1$!13&!I(D!-1$$;!'(L&!D(-D9123&I!G(9D&-&!1B()-8! ! M3&! I$$+!951$D91(29''/!-;+(),-!-351A!B(13!$)'/!13&!'(),&+(),!-2&)1!$F!13&!$('!3()1(),!91! 13&!$;5'&)2&!2$)2&9'&I!.&3()I!(18! ! "!I(FF&+&)1!-2+9123/!-$),!;'9/-!$)!13&!'$5),&! J5L&.$O²-5+F! ,5(19+-A! F9-1! I+5D.&91-A! 13&! -;$+9I(2! 1+(.9'! 239)1! $F! B('I! %$(2&-²9)I! B3('&! 13&/! ;+$2&&I! I$B)! 13&! -19(+-A! 13&! /$5),! D9)! 35D-! 1$! 13&! D5-(2A!-&&D(),'/!F5''!$F!-1+&),13A!9-!(F!3(-!I9/-!B&+&!-;&)1!'&(-5+&'/!29+1(),!;&$;'&! F+$D! ;'92&! 1$! ;'92&8! ! M3(-! D5-1! .&! 3$B! 1391! V(,! R91! ,$&-! 3$D&A! 13&! 13$5,31! ERXQFHV LQ 6DPXHOµV ZREEOLQJ KHDG 7KLV LV KRZ WKDW JURVV PDQ LV FDUULHG MXVW '(L&!13(-8! !
<923! F'&&1(),! ,'(D;-&! (-! %(&B&I! 91! 9! -L&B&I! 9),'&A! %&+1(29'! 9)I! -&(-D(28! !
M3&!2$2L19('!'$5),&!9;;&9+-!29;-(E&IA!13&!;91+$)-!13+$B)!-(I&B9/-!$)!.9+!-1$$'-! 9)I! 2352L'(),8! ! Z;$)! 13&! +&IC29+;&1&I! ;913A! 13&! 13&D&I! I()(),! -&21($)-! ;9--! 6DPXHO¶V H\HV OLNH XSWXUQHG RDVHV 7KURXJK WKH KDOOZD\ RI! ;+(%91&! .$$13-A! 13&! -19''! I$$+-! D9L&! 9! '()&! $F! -'9)1&I! &)1+(&-A! 39),(),! 9J9+! 9)I! &O3(.(1(),! (D;&)&1+9.'&! -39I&8! ! T3&+&! 13&! 29%&+)$5-! F$/&+! .&,()-A! 9! 1+&D.'(),! %(-($)! $F! 13&! I&(1/! [ìEà QJ LV VSLHG IRU DQ LQVWDQW D VWRQH VWDWXH WKDW HDUOLHU KH KDGQ¶W )$1(2&I! -19)I(),! 13&+&8! ! M3&! (++&,5'9+C-39;&I! B9''-! 2'$-&! ()A! 13&! ;'9-1&+! +$2L! IRUPDWLRQV MROWLQJ DPLG WKH DGYDQFHV RI WKH \RXQJ PDQµV OHJV 3UHVHQWO\ 9)$13&+! I$$+! $;&)-! B(I&A! -3511(),! 9F1&+! 13&D! 9-! 13&! D5+L()&--! $F! 13&! F$/&+! EHFRPHV WKH HFOLSVH RI QLJKW DQG WKH \RXQJ PDQ¶V KXPPLQJ IDOOV VLOHQW ! !
"!D$D&)1!'91&+A!$)2&!13&/!39I!-1$;;&I!$51-(I&!.&'$B!9!-1+&&1'(,31A!G9D5&'!
F()I-! 3(-! .$I/! 9)I! ;&+-;&21(%&! .&(),! ;51! +(,318! ! Z-(),! .$13! 39)I-A! 13&! /$5),! D9)! -B(),-! 3(D! ;&+;&)I(25'9+A! ,(),&+'/! '$B&+(),! 3(-! F&&1! $)1$! 13&! -(I&B9'LA! VD\LQJ LQ DQ REOLJLQJ YRLFH ³7KHUH \RX JR ´ %XW KH GHVFHQGV ZLWK FRQVLGHUDEOH (++(191($)!91!39%(),!.&&)!1$1&I!9,9()-1!3(-!B(''A!9)!9))$/9)2&!1391!(-!&O92&+.91&I! B3&)!13&!/$5),!D9)!15--'&-!3(-!39(+A!13&!+5FF'(),!$F!B3(23!;+$I52&-!9!2+$--A!-5'L/! ORRN 'RQ¶W HYHU WRXFK PH DJDLQ KH IHHOV OLNH VKRXWLQJ²&O2&;1!13&!/$5),!D9)!(-!
9'+&9I/! '&9%(),! 3(DA! J$,,(),! .92L! 1$B9+I! 13&! F+$)1! &)1+9)2&! 9-! 13$5,3! '91&! F$+! -$D&13(),!(D;$+19)1A!13$-&!'$),!'&,-!2$%&+(),!13&!;9%&D&)1!B(13$51!D$+&!139)! F$5+!-1+(I&-:! ! >C\C]C,$)&8! !
#$B!2$D;'&1&'/!9'$)&!()!F+$)1!$F!13&!.5('I(),A!G9D5&'!15+)-!9)I!-35FF'&-!
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¶OO FRPH KH WULHV UHDVVXULQJ KLPVHOI <RX PDGH PH D SURPLVH ! !
6WUXJJOLQJ QRW WR GRXEW WKH VWUDQJHU¶V VLQFHULW\ 6DPXHO SXVKHV D WKXPE
9,9()-1! 13&! B9(-1.9)I! $F! 3(-! -B&91! ;9)1-A! ;+&--(),! 9'-$! 9,9()-1! 3(-! 5)I&+B&9+! 5)1('!13&!F$'I&I!.(''!+5.-!2$9+-&'/!91!9!3(;.$)&8! ! M3(-A!1$$A!(-!9)$13&+!+&9--5+9)2&A! D PRUH FRQYLQFLQJ RQH WKDQ DQ\WKLQJ KH FRXOG WU\ WHOOLQJ KLPVHOI ,I \RX¶UH I(-3$)&-1A!3&!13(QNV \RX ZRQ¶W JLYH PH \RXU PRQH\²/$5!L&&;!(1!9''!F$+!/$5+-&'FA! $F! 2$5+-&8! ! ")I! 9-! 13$5,3! 3(-! 135D.! 39I! -$$13&I! 9! L&&)! ;+&--5+&! ;$()1A! 3(-! 9)O(&1/!&9-&-!B(13!9!-B&''!$F!2&+19()1/A!3(-!.$11$D!'(;!+&'&9-&I8! !
X)'/! 13&)! I$&-! 3&! 2$)-(I&+! 13&! 29+I! -1(''! 3&'I! ()! 9! F(-1A! &)2'$-&I! ./!
B3(1&CL)52L'&I!F(),&+-8! ! P&!19L&-!9! -1&;!.92LB9+I-A!$;&)(),!3(-! .5)23&I! 39)I! 5)I&+)&913!13&!-1+&&1'(,318! ! M3&!F'(D-/!29+I!(-!2+5D;'&I!$)!3(-!;9'DA!'(L&!9!B9I! $F! 1(--5&A! 9)I! 3&! D5-1! -D$$13! 13&! ;9;&+! $51! 1$! F5''/! I&2(;3&+! (1-! .+(,31! ,+&&)! 239+921&+-:! !"#$%&'%()*+&,"--$.! /01&233&/&4567894&:7335;&<74=>9?5& *%& /&3455&?23;&@4ABCD&;59D&24&=23355& EA;>&3788&<74=>9?5&23&/&4567894&:7335;& (8>9F:49D&G2B;545H&#94CD&I&!9B&)9:4A58&82=9;A2B?&2B8H& & JAFA;&2B5&=27<2B&<54&=7?;2F54&
! !
R$+!9!B3('&!G9D5&'!-19)I-!13&+&A!-15I/(),!13&!29+IA!5)2&+19()!$F!(1-!92159'!
%9'5&8! ! [&-;(1&!13&!2$5;$)!F&&'(),!-$D&3$B!;&+-$)9''/!()-5'1(),²'(L&!13&!-$5)I! RI %LJ )DWµV YRLFH OLNH WKH ZRPDQµV UHPDUNV DERXW KLP²3&! B$)I&+-! (F! (1! D(,31! ;+$%&!5-&F5'!-$D&I9/A!;$--(.'/!-$D&13(),!3(-!D$13&+!B$5'I!9;;+&2(91&A!9)!9II&I! .$)5-!1$!13&!,$$I!F$+15)&!3&!B(''!-$$)!$FF&+!3&+8! ! P&!L)$B-A!3$B&%&+A!1391!-3&! 391&-! B9-1(),! D$)&/! $)! +&-195+9)1! F$$IA! 1391! -3&! 9'B9/-! ;+&F&+-! 3&+! $B)! 2$$L(),8! ! *'5-A! -3&! 9'+&9I/! 39-! 9! '$1! $F! 2$5;$)-A! 9! B3$'&! I+9B&+! -15FF&I! B(13! 13&D! ()! 13&! L(123&)A! -$D&! &O;(+&I! 9)I! D9)/! )&%&+! +&I&&D&I8! ! #$A! 3&! F()9''/! GHFLGHV LW¶V XVHOHVV²J5-1!1+9-3A!9-!B$+13'&--!9-!V(,!R91!9)I!1391!5,'/!B$D9)8! !
V51! .&F$+&! 13&! 2$5;$)! 29)! .&! I(-29+I&IA! .+(,31! 3&9I'(,31-! -'(2&! 13&!
I9+L)&--!1391!-3+$5I-!13&!I&29/(),!&I(F(2&-!9'$),!13&!-1+&&1A!.5+)(),!13&!2$+)&+-! RI 6DPXHO¶V H\HV 7KH FRXSRQ YDQLVKHV DJDLQ ZLWKLQ KLV ILVW DQG ZDYLQJ DQ DUP KH KXUULHV IRUZDUG DV WKH VWUDQJHU¶V %0: VSHHGV FORVHU ³+HUH ´ KH VD\V DORXG 3(-! 3&9+1! +92(), ³5LJKW KHUH ´ +LJK EHDPV IODVK WZLFH RQ WKH FDU¶V 9;;+$923²-15))(),! 3(-! -(,31A! .913(),! 3(D! ()! (1-! B&'2$D&I! +9I(9)2&²'(L&! -5)'(,31A! 91! '9-1A! &+9I(291(),! 13&! %9,9+(&-! $F! 9)! ()29'25'9.'&! )(,31! 1$! &%&)159''/! -3()&!13&!B9/!.92L!3$D&8! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =>^@! ! G1+&&1'(,31-! I+(F1! ./! $51-(I&A! .&/$)I! 13&! V0TA! 9-! F5EE/! $+.-8! ! R+$D! 13&! F+$)1! -&91A!B3&+&!_CM(;!I+(%&-!9)I!G39%&I!P&9I!+(I&-!-3$1,5)A!2(,9+&11&!-D$L&!F(''-!13&! ()1&+($+A!2+&91(),!9)!9II(1($)9'!'9/&+!$F!$.-25+(1/!9D$),!13&!.'92L!'&913&+!-&91-A! 13&!1()1&I!B()I$B-A!13&!-39I$B-!;$$'&I!$)!13&!F'$$+.$9+I8! !
")I!B3('&!13&!13$5,31!$F!-(11(),!)&O1!1$!13&!-1+9),&+!9,9()!13+(''-!G9D5&'A!
-$A! 1$$A! I$&-! 13&! (I&9! $F! 1+9%&'(),! $)2&! D$+&! ()-(I&! -523! 9! F9)19-1(2! 29+8! ! #$B! B(13! 13&! +9I($! 15)&I! 1$! 9! 2'9--(29'! -191($)A! ;'9/(),! '$B! 9)I! F$-1&+(),! 9)! 91D$-;3&+&!$F!+&F()&I!'5O5+/A!3&!F&&'-!9-!(F!3&!B&+&!F'/(),!3(,3!9.$%&!13&!2(1/A!13&! -D$L&!-B(+'(),!'(L&!2'$5I-!9+$5)I!3(D8! ! P(-!.$I/!39+I'/!-&)-&-!13&!F'521591(),! B3&&'-²13&! 239),(),! $F! '9)&-! $+! -1+&&1-A! 13&! -5II&)! -1$;-! 9)I! -19+1-²9)I! 13&! 29+W-! &),()&! .9+&'/! D9L&-! 9! -$5)I8! ! Z;! 5)1('! 1$)(,31A! 13$5,3A! 3&! 39I! )&%&+! .&F$+&!-91!()!9!%&3(2'&!1391!'$$L&I!13(-!)&BA!2'&9)A!9)I!&O;&)-(%&A!1391!-$D&3$B! -&&D&I!D$1($)'&--!9-!&%&+/13(),!&'-&!-'(I!;9-1!13&!B()I$B-S!)$+!39I!3&!&%&+!.&&)! 2395FF&5+&I! 3$D&A! $225;/(),! 13&! .92L! '(L&! 9! 2&'&.+(1/A! 13&! -1+9),&+! -'$523&I! K5(&1'/!)&9+./8! !
V51! -()2&! &)1&+(),! 13&! V0TA! -&11'(),! F9+! I$B)! $)! 13&! -&91! 9F1&+! -3511(),!
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
D$+&! D$)&/! B(''! &%&)159''/! I(-+5;1! 13&! &O2+52(91(),! -('&)2&8! ! P(-! &/&-! -K5()1A! '&--&)(),!13&!-1(),!$F!13&!-D$L&A!&O2&;1!)$!D911&+!3$B!'$),!3&!B9(1-!13&!-1+9),&+! 511&+-!)$13(),8! !
M3&)! +&D&D.&+(),! 13&! D&--9,&! 1391! V(,! R91! 39I! B9)1&I! I&'(%&+&IA! 3&!
9)O($5-'/! 15+)-A! ;&&+(),! 13+$5,3! 13&! -D$L&! 9-! (F! -;/(),! ()1$! 9! +$$D! 13+$5,3! 9! ZLQGRZ DQG IURZQV ZLWK GLVDSSRLQWPHQW DW ZKDW HPHUJHV 7KH VWUDQJHU¶V KHDG (-!-'5D;&I!1$B9+I!13&!$13&+!;9--&),&+!I$$+A!D$513!39),(),!$;&)A!13$-&!+922$$)! &/&-! -&9'&I! -351S! /&1! 13&! +&-1! $F! 3(D! -(1-! 5;+(,31A! 13&! 2&+%(29'! 2$''9+! L&&;(),! 3(-! QHFN VWUDLJKW ³0LVWHU ´ KH EOXUWV RXW ³, KDYH D PHVVDJH ´ ! !
_CM(;!-&)I-!9!B91&+/!,'9)2&!1$!13&!+&9+%(&B8! ! G39%&I!P&9I!'$$L-!F$+'$+)'/!
$%&+!9!-3$5'I&+8! ! V51!13&!-1+9),&+!(-!F(O&I!()!;'92&²13&!39E&!2$%&+(),!3(D!'(L&!9! 13()!'9/&+!$F!B3(1&!I5-1A!,(%(),!3(-!&I,&B(-&!F92&!9!,3$-1'/!;9''$+!1391!(-!I9+L&)&I! $)'/!./!13&!251-!9)I!.+5(-&-!$)!3(-!;9'&!-L()8! !
³0LVWHU WKDW %LJ )DW²KH VDLG VRPHWKLQJ \RX VKRXOG NQRZ ´!
!
G9D5&'!3&-(191&-!BKLOH H[SHFWLQJ WKH VWUDQJHU¶V EODFNHQHG H\HOLGV WR SDUW
WKH PDQ¶V KHDG WR VKLIW OD]LO\ DQG DOLJQ ZLWK KLV ERG\ :KHQ QRW HYHQ D VOLJKW D$%&D&)1!(-!13&)!$.-&+%&IA!3&!-2$$1-!9!'(11'&!2'$-&+A!'&9)-!F$+B9+IA!9)I!,9E&-!5;! 91!13&!-B$''&)A!I$+D9)1!F92&!)$II(),!9'D$-1!(D;&+2&;1(.'/!F+$D!13&!%(.+91($)-!$F! WKH URDG 7KRXJK VWDUH DV KH PLJKW WKH VWUDQJHU GRHVQ¶W EOLQN DZDNH UHPDLQLQJ '(F&'&--! 13&+&! '(L&! 13&! %(21(D! $F! 9! 1&++(.'&! 2+(D&A! .9I'/! .&91&)! 9)I! 5)+&-;$)-(%&8! ! 1R \RX DUHQ¶W DFWXDOO\ GHDG KH WKLQNV -XVW V'&&;(),!(-!9''8! !
P&! ;5''-! 3(-! F&&1! $FF!13&! F'$$+.$9+IA! F$'I-! 3(-! '&,-! .&)&913! 3(D-&'F! $)! 13&!
VHDW DQG ULVHV VR WKDW KH FDQ UHDFK WKH VWUDQJHUµV WLOWHG HDU ³7KH PHVVDJH LV WKLV ´ KH ZKLVSHUV FXSSLQJ D KDQG DW KLV PRXWK ³%LJ )DW GLGQ W EHOLHYH LQ \RX ! DQG SLJV DUH GLIIHUHQW WKDQ SHRSOH ´ +H SDXVHV VFUXQFKLQJ KLV EURZ WU\LQJ WR UHFDOO ZKDW HOVH %LJ )DW KDG WROG KLP ³2K ´ KH FRQWLQXHV KLV EURZ VPRRWKLQJ ³DQG \RX FDQ¶W KDYH D KHDUW EHFDXVH KH NQRZV LW 7KDWµV WKH PHVVDJH ´! !
%XW WKH VWUDQJHU¶V FRQVFLRXVQHVV LVQ¶W VWLUUHG E\ %LJ )DW¶V PHVVDJH DQG
B3('&!_C7LS¶V H\HV KDYH OHIW WKH UHDUYLHZ 6KDYHG +HDG VWLOO JD]HV RYHU D VKRXOGHU F$+!9!1(D&A!9!2(,9+&11&! -D$'I&+(),!()!3(-!'(;-8! ! G9D5&'!-(,3-A!F+$B)(),!9,9()S!3&! -15I(&-! 13&! -1+9),&+W-! 911+921(%&'/! -39;&I! &9+A! -D9''! B(13! 9! I&1923&I! '$.&A! 13&! .5D;/! F'&-3! -5++$5)I(),! (1-! I9+L&+! +&2&--&-! '(L&! 13&! &%&)1! 3$+(E$)! $F! 9! .'92L!
KROH $V LI FKDOOHQJLQJ WKH VPRNH¶V GRPLQDQFH WKH KDUVK RGRU RI DOFRKRO VHHSV IURP WKH VWUDQJHU¶V PRXWK²D VPHOO WKDW DOVR WDLQWV 6DPXHO¶-! .+&913! 1$! 9! D523! OHVVHU GHJUHH DOWKRXJK QRZ RWKHU WKDQ D KRW IHHOLQJ RQ KLV FKHHNV KH FDQ¶W UHFRJQL]H DQ\ OLQJHULQJ HIIHFWV RI WKH EHHU ³7KDW JLUO ´ KH WKHQ ZKLVSHUV GLVFUHHWO\ ³VKH¶V QRW YHU\ EHDXWLIXO OLNH \RX WKRXJKW 6KH¶V UHDOO\ DQ DZIXO ;&UVRQ ´! !
G39%&I!P&9I!15+)-!9B9/A!,'9)2(),!1$B9+I!13&!+$9I8! ! _CM(;!()2+&9-&-!13&!
UDGLR¶V YROXPH $QG WKHUH LQ WKH EDFN DV D &KRSLQ SLDQR FRQFHUWR JURZV D ELW '$5I&+A!G9D5&'!13()L-²J5-1!D9/.&²1391!3&!-&&-!9!-D(+L!F$+D(),!$)!13&!-1+9),&+A! ;5-3(),! -5.1'/! 91! 13&! 2$+)&+-! $F! 13&! ,9;(),! D$513A! ,'(D;-&I! B3&+&! %9+/(),! VKDGRZV DQG PXWHG OLJKW SOD\ XSRQ WKH PDQµV DQJOHG IDFH 'LVSOD\LQJ KLV RZQ -'/! ,+()A! 3&! '$B&+-! 3(D-&'F! .&-(I&! 13&! -1+9),&+A! -()L(),! ()1$! 13&! '&913&+! 5;3$'-1&+/A!9)I!+&2'()&-!9! -3$5'I&+!9,9()-1!13&!I+&--! 2$91!B(13!9'D$-1!13&!-9D&! ;3/-(29'! ;+$O(D(1/! 1391! 13&/! 39I! -39+&I! &9+'(&+8! ! <O2&;1! )$! 1&)I&+! 9+D! &)F$'I-! 3(DA! )$! F&&'(),! $F! 2$))&21($)! ;9--&-! .&1B&&)! 13&DA! )$! 9D(29.'&! B$+I-! $+! HQJDJLQJ FRPPHQWV DUH VSRNHQ +H FDQ¶W ZLWKRXW EHLQJ KHOG WLJKWO\ GLVFHU)!13&! VWUDQJHU¶V ULEFDJH H[SDQGLQJ FRQWUDFWLQJ WKH LQWLPDWH HEELQJ DQG IORZLQJ RI DQRWKHU¶V EUHDWK ! !
P(-! ,+()! F9I&-A! 9)I! 3(-! &/&-! '(F1! (D;91(&)1'/! 1$! 13&! -1+9),&+8! ! R+$D! 3(-!
%9)19,&! ;$()1A! 3&! %(&B-! $)'/! 9! 3&9I'&--! F(,5+&²9! .$I/A! 9! 2&+%(29'! 2$''9+A! -$D&! 39(+A!9!;$+1($)!$F!)&2L8! ! G$!3(-!-19+&!+&%&+-&-A!I&-2&)I(),!13&!'&),13!$F!13&!I+&--! 2$91!9)I!13&!'&F1!9+D!3&!;+&--&-!9,9()-1A!.+&923(),!13&!,'$$D!()!B3(23!13&/!9+&! ERWK VLWWLQJ 5HVWLQJ RQ WKH VHDW ULJKW E\ 6DPXHO¶V NQHH LV WKH VWUDQJHU¶V SDOH '&F1! 39)IA! 13&! F(),&+-! 39'F! 25+'&IA! 3$'I(),! -$D&13(),8! ! P&! .&)I-! F$+B9+I! F$+! 9! .&11&+! ()-;&21($)A! ;&&+(),! ;9-1! 13&! -D$L&A! 9)I! +&9'(E&-! 1391! 13&! '$$-&! F(-1! (-! 2'5123(),! D$)&/²9! -(),'&! .(''! 2+&9-&I! 9'$),! 13&! D(II'&A! &O921'/! $)&! 35)I+&I! I$''9+-8! !
MB(-1(),! 3(-! )&2LA! G9D5&'! ,(%&-! 13&! -1+9),&+! 9)! 9B+/! '$$LA! ,9E(),! 91! 13&!
3&9I'&--!.$I/A!;&+;'&O&I!9)I!()1&)1A!9-!(F!2$)1&D;'91(),!9!2+$$L&I!;(215+&!F+9D&8! ! M3&! D$)&/A! 3&! -5-;&21-A! D5-1! .&! F$+! 3(D²13&! -&2$)I! ;9+1! $F! 13&(+! I&9'A! 13&! ;9/D&)1!1391!-3$5'I!39%&!;+&2&I&I!13&!I+(%&!3$D&8! ! M3$5,3!5)'&--!13&!-1+9),&+! -9/-!-$A!3&!39-!)$!B9/!$F!.&(),!2&+19()!9.$51!(18! ! T(13!3(-!&O;+&--($)!5)239),&IA!
KH UHJDUGV WKH PRQH\ RQFH PRUH FDXWLRXVO\ SODFLQJ ILQJHUWLSV RQ WKH VWUDQJHU¶V '5L&B9+D!B+(-1A!9)!()I&O!F(),&+!F'(2L(),!9!1$;!&I,&!$F!13&!.(''A!5;!9)I!I$B)A!'(L&!(1! B9-!9!'(,31!-B(1238! ! U$5!;+$D(-&I!D&A!3&!13()L-8! ! U&1!1$!-(D;'/!19L&!13&!D$)&/A! 1$!&O1+921!(1!F+$D!13&!-'92L!39)IA!-&&D-!9!I95)1(),!;+$-;&21²9!;$--(.'&!13&F1!1391! PLJKW XOWLPDWHO\ WHUPLQDWH WKH VWUDQJHU¶V EURWKHUO\ LGHD RI KLP ! !
³$WODQWLF"´ KH KHDUV 4CM(;!9-L!()!9!39+I!%$(2&8!
!
&OHDULQJ KLV WKURDW 6KDYHG +HDG DQVZHUV KRDUVHO\ ³<HDK $WODQWLF
3XOO LQ DQ\ZKHUH ,W GRHVQµW PDWWHU ´! !
5HDOL]LQJ WKHUH LVQ¶W PXFK WLPH OHIW 6DPXHO LPSXOVLYHO\ WXJV WKH ELOO IUHH
"! ;+$D(-&! (-! 9! ;+$D(-& KH UHDVRQV DQG WKH VWUDQJHU VKRXOGQµW KDWH KLP IRU 2'9(D(),!3(-!+&B9+I8! ! #$)&13&'&--A!9!I&,+&&! $F!,5('1!-5+F92&-!$)2&! 13&!D$)&/!(-! -5++&;1(1($5-'/! F$'I&I! B(13()! 13&! -39I$B-! 9)I! 152L&I! .&3()I! 3(-! B9(-1.9)IA! 9! -D9''!-&)-&!$F!39%(),!-$D&3$B!.&1+9/&I!13&(+!F+(&)I-3(;8! ! G52L(),!91!3(-!.$11$D! '(;A!9!39)I!.5)23(),!13&!F9.+(2!$F!3(-!-B&91!;9)1-A!3&!.+(&F'/!2$)-(I&+-!+&15+)(),! WKH RQH KXQGUHG GROODUV WR WKH VWUDQJHU %XW LQVWHDG LW LV %LJ )DW¶V FUXPSOHG 2$5;$)!1391!D(,+91&-!F+$D!3(-!$13&+!39)I²29+&F5''/!&)1&+(),!13&!%$(I!&)2(+2'&I! E\ WKRVH OD[ ILQJHUV GHSRVLWHG ZKHUH WKH ELOO KDG EHHQ KHOG QHDU KLV NQHH ,WµV ;+$.9.'/!-$D&13(),!13&!-1+9),&+!B(''!9;;+&2(91&A!3&!1&''-!3(D-&'F²-$D&13(),!13&! D9)!29)!-5+&'/!5-&!B3&)!-1(++(),!9B9L&8! !
7KHQ DV WKH %0:¶V DFFHOHUDWLRQ GHFUHDVHV 6DPXHO¶V JXLOW DOVR ZDQHV WKH
;('F&+&I!D$)&/!)$B!;+$I52(),!9!-5+,&!$F!)&+%$5-!&O2(1&D&)1A!$F!B9)1$)!-522&--8! ! M3&! +$9D(),! -1+&&1'(,31-! '$-&! D$D&)15D8! ! T(13! 13&! 15+)! .'()L&+! 2'(2L(),! +3/13D(29''/A! 13&! 29+! +$''-! 1$! 9! -D$$13! -19)I-1(''A! '(L&! 9)! 9(+;'9)&! -1$;;(),! 91! 9! 1&+D()9'! ,91&8! ! M3&! +9I($! ,$&-! -('&)18! ! R()I(),! 3(D! ()! 13&! +&9+%(&BA! _CM(;! DEUXSWO\ VD\V ³*HW RXW ´ DQG WKH KDUVKQHVV RI WKH WRQH KDV DQ LQVWDQWDQHRXV +&-5'18! !
4+9B'(),!$%&+!13&!-&91!1$!&-29;&!.&F$+&!13&/!+&9'(E&!13&!D$)&/!(-!D(--(),A!
G9D5&'! F5D.'&-! 91! 13&! I$$+A! ,+9-;(),! .'()I'/! 5)1('! 3&! -&(E&-! (1-! 39)I'&8! ! M3&! ()1&+($+! '9D;! -5II&)'/! .+(,31&)-! 13&! 39E&8! ! M3&! I$$+! -B(),-! B(I&A! +&%&9'(),! 9! -B913!$F!-1$+&F+$)1!;9%&D&)1A!,+&&)!9B)(),-A!9)I!9!)&9+./!2$FF&&3$5-&!1391²(F! QRW IRU WKH QHRQ VLJQ KDQJLQJ DERYH WKH VKRS¶V HQWUDQFH WKH QDPH DQG VWUHHW 9II+&--!-3$B(),!()!43()&-&²2$5'I!.&!9)/B3&+&8! ! G2$$1(),!3(-!'&,-!9)I!.$11$D!
$)! 13&! '&913&+A! 3&! 9(D-! 3(-! F&&1! 1$B9+I! 13&! -(I&B9'L! .&'$BA! K5(2L'/! -'(;;(),! 3(D-&'F!$51-(I&8! ! ³<RXU VNDWHV ´ 6KDYHG +HDG FDOOV ! !
2K WKDW¶V ULJKW 6DPXHO WKLQNV 0\ VNDWHV +H WXUQV DQG EHQGV
-1+&123(),! 1$! ,+9.! 13&! +$''&+! -L91&-! $FF! 13&! F'$$+.$9+I8! ! M3&)! ()! 13&! 39-1&! B3('&! -1$$;(),! 13&+&A! 3&! 13+$B-! 9! F5+1(%&! ,'9)2&! 91! 13&! -1+9),&+A! -1(''! &O;&21(),! -$D&! ()I(291($)! $F! '(F&A! ;$--(.'/! 9! ;9+1(),! +&D9+L! $+! ,&-15+&8! ! U&1! &%&)! B(13! 13&! LQWHULRU OLJKW VKLQLQJ WKH PDQ¶V IDFH LV VOXPSHG EH\RQG YLHZ 2GGO\ HQRXJK WKRXJK WKH VWUDQJHU¶V GDUN FORWKLQJ DQG WKH OH913&+! 5;3$'-1&+/! )$B! 9;;&9+! 9-! 9'D$-1!$)&A!13&!(''5-($)!&)39)2&I!./!13&!I&)-&!2(,9+&11&!%9;$+-A!9)I!13&!2&+%(29'! 2$''9+!9)I!13&!;9'&!'&F1!39)I!'$$L!I&1923&IA!-5-;&)I&IA!9-!(F!F'$91(),!()!-;92&8! !
³+XUU\ XS ´ 4C7LS EDUNV ³DQG FORVH WKH GRRU ´!
!
G9D5&'!-25++(&-!F+$D!13&!29+A!13&!-L91&-!2+9I'&I!.&)&913!9)!9+D8! ! T3&)!
3&! ;5-3&-! 13&! I$$+! -351A! B(-;-! $F! -D$L&! -1&9'! ()1$! 13&! )(,31A! &%9;$+91(),! '(L&! -1&9D8! ! V51! 3&! I$&-)W1! B9123! 9-! 13&! V0T! -$$)! &9-&-! F+$D! 13&! 25+.²,+9I59''/! J$()(),! 13&! &D&+,&)1! 1+9FF(2A! 9! D$D&)1! '91&+! I(-9;;&9+(),! 9D$),! 9! -1+&9D! $F! 19(''(,31-²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²9)!()-(,)(F(29)1!,+()A! 91! F(+-1A! 1391! F'$B&+-! .+$9I'/! 9-! (F! )$5+(-3&I! ./! -;&&I! 9)I! 13&! D9,)&1(2! ;5''! 1$B9+I!3$D&8! !
M3&!39+I/!+$$1-!$F!3(-!-D('&!B+(13&!I&&;&+!()-(I&!3(D!B(13!13&!9;;+$923!$F!
&923!+&2$,)(E9.'&!'9)ID9+LS!-3$;-A!+&-195+9)1-A!9)I!;9+L(),!'$1-!B3(E!;9-1A!9)IA! ;+&-&)1'/A! 9! 3$1&'A! 9! N9';3-! ,+$2&+/! -1$+&A! 9! '$),! +$B! $F! (I&)1(29'! ;+$D$1($)9'! ;$-1&+-! 9FF(O&I! 1$! ;'/B$$I! .9++(&+-! 9+$5)I! 9! 2$)-1+521($)! -(1&²-(,);$-1-! 9)I! ;'92&-!-&&)!-$!$F1&)!1391!3&!L)$B-!B391!13&/!9+&!B(13$51!'$$L(),!91!13&D8! ! #$B! -9F&'/!.92L!B3&+&!3&!.&'$),-A!13&!;9)(2L&IA!9,$)(E(),!13$5,31-!1391!,$%&+)&I!3(-! I9/! 9+&! 1+5D;&I! 2$D;'&1&'/! ./! -$D&13(),! &'-&A! 9! -1(''! %9,5&! /&1! .5II(),! (D;+&--($)A! .$13! ;9+9I$O(29'! 9)I! '(.&+91(),! ()! (1-! +5D.'(),-:! ! 9! B+$),! 15+)! $+!
K5&-1($)9.'&!23$(2&!D(,31!9'-$!;+$%(I&!,+&91&+!+&B9+I-!139)!9)/13(),!F$5)I!$)! WKH DFFHSWHG SDWK ,I KH KDGQ¶W JRWWHQ ORVW WKLV DIWHUQRRQ WKHQ WKHUH ZRXOG )&%&+! .&! 9! D93J$),! ;9+'$+! $FF&+(),! F+&&! F$$I! 9)I! I+()L-A! $+! 9! ,&)&+$5-! .(,! .+$13&+!1$!'&9)!2$DF$+19.'/!9,9()-1A!$+!13&!+(23&-!3(II&)!.&3()I!3(-!B9(-1.9)I!()! WKH VKDSH RI WZR IROGHG ELOOV ,I WKH YLROLQ SHUIRUPDQFH KDGQ¶W EHHQ PLVVHG KH 9)I!3(-!D$13&+!B$5'IA!()!F921A!39%&!)$13(),!.51!-;9+&!239),&!1$!2$5)1!91!13&!&)I! $F! 13&! )(,318! ! <%&+/13(),A! (1! -5II&)'/! -&&D-! 1$! 3(DA! D5-1! 39;;&)! F$+! 13&! +(,31! +&9-$)²HYHQ LI LW GLGQ¶W DOZD\V IHHO WKDW ZD\ ! !
M3(-! ;'&9-&I! -&)-&! $F! 9119()D&)1! +&F'&21&I! 5;$)! G9D5&'W-! .&9D(),!
2$5)1&)9)2&A! -3$B(),! 2'&9+'/! 9-! 3(-! .$I/! F'9-3&-! 5)I&+! -1+&HWOLJKWV GRHVQ¶W JR 5))$1(2&I8! ! P&!(-!,'9)2&I!91!25+($5-'/!./!13$-&!B3$!&)2$5)1&+!3(D!9)IA!.+(&F'/A! 29123! 13&! B()I! $F! 3(-! 3&9I'$),A! D9)&5%&+(),! F'(,318! ! ")IA! 1$$A! 3&! (-! ,'(D;-&I! F+$D! 9! 3(,3&+! %9)19,&! ;$()1A! -;$11&I! 13+$5,3! 9! -D5I,&I! 1+9)-(1! .5-! B()I$B²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
M3&)!(1!B$5'I!+&K5(+&!13&!;9--(),!$F!-&%&+9'!D()51&-!9)I!13+&&!2(1/!.'$2L-!
.&F$+&! G9D5&'! $.-&+%&-! 3(-! D$13&+! B9(1(),! )&9+! 9)! &D;1/! .5-! -1$;8! ! Q(L&! 9)! (DD$%9.'&! $.J&21 VKH VWDQGV ULJLGO\ RQ WKH VLGHZDON EHQHDWK D VWUHHWOLJKWµV I(FF5-&I! ,'$BA! 9+D-! 2+$--&I! 9)I! F92(),! 3(D8! ! R$+! -$D&! +&9-$)A! 13$5,3A! 13&! XQIRUHVHHQ VLJKW RI /RXLVD LVQ¶W VXUSULVLQJ GHVSLWH KLP KDYLQJ H[SHFWHG KHU WR -1(''!.&!91!B$+L8! ! V51!()!13&!D&+&!-&2$)I-!.&1B&&)!-&&(),!3&+!9)I!+&923(),!3&+A! WKH LQHYLWDEOH FRQVHTXHQFHV DUHQ¶W JLYHQ PXFK FRQVLGHUDWLRQ²)$1! B3&)! &%&+/13(),! &'-&! -3$5'I! .&! &2'(;-&I! ./! 13&! D$)&/! -3&! B(''! +&2&(%&A! )$1! B3&)! -3&! B(''!-$$)!5)I&+-19)I!1391!3&!29)!19L&!29+&!$F!3(D-&'FA!9)I!3&+A!'(L&! 9!D9)8! ! M3&! .$'I)&--! (D;&''(),! 3(D! (-! 9-1$5)I(),A! 9)I! 295-&! 9)I! &FF&21! 9+&! '(11'&! D$+&! 139)! 9)! 9.-1+921($)8! ! "-! -523A! 13&! ;9B)-3$;! -L91&-! .+(),(),! 3(D! F$+13A! 13&! &%&)(),!
UHFLWDO KH GLGQ¶W DWWHQG WKH KXPLOLDWLRQ DQG ZRUU\ KH KDV FUHDWHG²)$)&!$F!(1!/&1A! 9-!3&!I+9B-!2'$-&+A!I$B)-3(F1-!3(-!D()I!()1$!B$&F5'!+&,+&1!$+!-1(F'&-!13&!.5$/9)1! -D('&!25+%(),!3(-!'(;-8! !
³0D ´ 6DPXHO VD\V H[FLWHGO\ EUHDNLQJ LQ IURQW RI /RXLVD¶V SLHUFLQJ VWDWLF
,9E&²WKH H[DFW H[SUHVVLRQ VKH¶G ZRUQ GXULQJ WKRVH VWUHVVIXO QLJKWV ZKHQ KHU! 35-.9)I! 39I! 9++(%&I! 3$D&! '91&8! ! ")I! )$B! (1! (-! 435)CWH¶V WKRXJKWOHVV IDFH VKH -&&-!$)!3&+!-$)A!13&!-9D&!)$)239'9)2&!9)I!9++$,9)2&8! ! 4(,9+&11&!$I$+-!F5D&!$FF! KLV FORWKLQJ SHUPHDWLQJ WKH DLU DURXQG WKHP ³/RRN 0D ´ KH VD\V WXJJLQJ WKH F$'I&I!.(''-!F+$D!KLV ZDLVWEDQG ZKLOH KHU DUPV XQIXUO ³&DQ \RX EHOLHYH LW"´! !
P(-! F92&! (-! F'5-3&I! .+(,31! +&IA! 3(-! .+&913! F'9%$+&I! B(13! .&&+A! 3(-! 39(+!
D5--&I!9)I!$('/8! ! #$!-$$)&+!I$&-!13&!D$)&/!9;;&9+!139)!-3&!-;+(),-!91!3(D!'(L&! 9!-;(I&+!&)-)9+(),!;+&/8! ! M3&!F(+-1!-'9;!2$D&-!-$!F9-1!1391!3&!.9+&'/!F&&'-!(1-!-1(),A! 9)I! F$+! 9! D$D&)1! 3&! 2$)1()5&-! -D('(),! B(13$51! 92159''/! +&9'(E(),! B391! 39-! 39;;&)&I8! !
³0D²´!
!
M3&! -&2$)I! -'9;A! 3$B&%&+A! +&,(-1&+-! 39+I! 9)I! ;9()F5'A! $.'(1&+91(),! 3(-!
-D('&A! D9L(),! 3(D! 2+(),&8! ! P&+! -'&)I&+! $;&)! 39)I-! 13&)! -1+(L&! 3(-! 23&&L-! 9)I! &9+-!9)I!)&2L!()!+9;(I!-522&--($)A!13&!F$+2&!$F!B3(23!+$''-!13&!-L91&-!.92LB9+I-! 9-!-3&!F'9('-!9F1&+!3(D8! ! 71!(-!13&!F(+-1!1(D&!-3&!39-!&%&+!5-&I!.$13!39)I-!9,9()-1! 3(DA! .51! J5-1! B3&)! (1! -&&D-! '(L&! 13&! 91192L! D(,31! )&%&+! &)IA! Q$5(-9! -5II&)'/! ZLWKGUDZV KHU DUPV DQG GURSV WKHP OLPSO\ ³6WXSLG ´ VKH \HOOV KHU YRLFH ,9-;(),8! !
6DPXHO¶V VNLQ EXUQV WHUULEO\ ZKHUH VKH KLW KLP DQG KLV UHSHDWHGO\
-D92L&I! &9+-! +(),! B(13! 9! ,95E&CF(''&I! -&)-91($)8! ! M3+$5,3! B&''(),! &/&-! 3&! D9)9,&-!1$!;&&+!5;!91!13&!&O395-1&I!F(,5+&!$F!3(-!D$13&+!,'9+(),!I$B)!$)!3(D8! ! Q$$D(),!9.$%&!3(-!2$B&+(),A!I&F&91&I!.$I/!(-!3&+!F92&²;9)1(),A!F5+($5-²15+)&I! -9%9,&! 9)I! I+9()&I! $F! 2$'$+8! ! M3&! D$)&/! F9''-! F+$D! 3(-! F(),&+-! '(L&! I(-29+I&I! 29)I/! B+9;;&+-A! 9)I! 3&! .&,()-! 2+/(),A! B9('(),! ;(1(F5''/8! ! G1(''! 3$'I(),! 3&+! ,'9+&! $)!3(DA!-3&!)$B!9)-B&+-!3(-!'9D&)1A!-;(11(),!9!.9++9,&!$F!9),+/!K5&-1($)-!1391!3&! 29)! 39+I'/! 2$D;+&3&)I²I(D()(-3&I! 9-! 13&/! 9+&! ./! 13&! +(),(),! ()-(I&! 3(-! &9+-A! 9)I! 13$-&! B+&123&I! -$.-! 2$)%5'-(),! ;9-1! 3(-! 2'&)23&I! 1&&13A! +&I52(),! 3(D! $)2&! 9,9()!1$!)$13(),!.51!3&+!F&2L'&--!23('I8!
! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
"#$%&'!%&!()&*)+,-! .!/01234!5467801!29:27!;19:!<96=73! .!³6KXQJ>\R \RXU IDWKHU LV ZDLWLQJ +XUU\ ´! .!?@35A7!3@B!4644=@C!D=7=9@7!9;!.>7B@54K9;?& ! .!EF0!G378!F36@87!8F0!26=4B=@C!38!HIJK!?80D0@7 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !