The Justice, April 16, 2019

Page 1

the

Justice www.thejustice.org

The Independent Student Newspaper Volume LXXI, Number 24

of

B r a n d e is U n i v e r sit y S i n c e 1 9 4 9

Tuesday, April 16, 2019

KENNEDY ON ISRAEL

Waltham, Mass.

JUSTICE ANALYSIS

Dinlenc withdraws Hoot proposal ■ Senator Kent Dinlenc

'19 withdrew a proposal to decharter The Hoot after a wave of backlash. By EMILY BLUMENTHAL and CHAIEL SCHAFFEL JUSTICE EDITOR AND STAFF WRITER

Background

THU LE/the Justice

DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES: Congressman Joseph P. Kennedy III, who represents Massachusetts' 4th district, spoke to attendees about the implications of United States attitudes about Israel on democracy in the Middle East.

Congressman discusses U.S.-Israel relationship ■ Congressman Joe Kennedy

III spoke about Israel's democratic principles and their impacts on U.S. policy. By EMILY BLUMENTHAL JUSTICE EDITOR

Congressman Joseph P. Kennedy III spoke to Brandeis students about the complex relationship between the United States and Israel and discussed the countries’ shared governmental principles. The event, which took place Friday, was sponsored by the Brandeis Israel Public Affairs Committee and was moderated by Prof. Yehudah Mirsky (NEJS). BIPAC President Isaac Graber ’19 began the event by introducing the speakers. Mirsky, a graduate of Yale Law School, teaches at the Schusterman Center for Israeli Studies and previously served as a special advisor to the U.S. State Department’s Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor under the Clinton administration. Kennedy is the House Representative for Massachusetts’ 4th district. A graduate of Stanford University and Harvard Law, Kennedy served in the Peace Corps for two years before becoming a prosecutor. In 2012, after three years, he resigned from his prosecutorial job to run for political office. Mirsky first asked Kennedy how he reconciles the legacy of his family’s influence in politics with his

own role in office. “I am very proud of what my family has accomplished … and the contributions they have made to our country,” Kennedy replied, acknowledging that he attained his status “in no small part because of the work and contributions” of his predecessors in politics. He said that while his family is powerful, he “throw[s] everything that [he’s] got into this job.” Mirsky then moved to Kennedy’s support of Israel, stating that while Kennedy is “fundamentally supportive of the state of Israel,” he is also a “full-throated supporter of liberal and democratic values.” Mirsky viewed this as “striking,” asking how he came to bear his current foreign policy stances on the Middle East. In his response, Kennedy said he had originally kept himself informed by reading newspapers, but became more educated when he first traveled to Israel. The trip was especially meaningful to him because of his Catholic faith, and he emphasized the impact of seeing biblical sites in person. When he went to Israel, he felt “the sense of not only thousands of years of history, but the vulnerability, the reality … and the challenge of trying to implement democracy in a very tough neighborhood in the midst of extreme differences.” He said that from its founding, Israel has demonstrated “a commitment to those underlying fundamental principles” which constitute democracy and are important to the United States. The debate over Middle East geopolitics is one

Sustainability Committee Chair Kent Dinlenc ’19 rescinded his April 7 proposal to decharter The Brandeis Hoot on Thursday night. A petition opposing the proposal had gathered 518 individual and 65 club signatures over the course of the week. In a letter posted in the MyDeis Facebook groups, Dinlenc maintained that the Justice and The Hoot should be merged, but acknowledged the backlash his proposal had generated. Dinlenc had cited duality of purpose as the justification for removing The Hoot’s chartered club status. Duality of purpose, a concept that appears in Section 2 of Article VIII of the

Pushback

The Hoot editorial board began circulating a petition in response to the proposal on April 8. Addressing “members of the Brandeis Community,” the petition told all interested parties to sign their names, wear maroon or red on Friday, April 12, and attend the Senate meeting on April 14. The Hoot editorial board called the paper

See HOOT, 6 ☛

CAMPUS EVENT

which involves “passionate opinions across the spectrum,” but also “a willingness to hear people out,” he said, noting that people can come at the issue in legitimate ways from progressive and conservative standpoints. Mirsky moved the discussion to the recent Israeli election, which saw incumbent Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu win a fifth term over opponent Benny Gantz. He asked how Netanyahu’s victory could shift U.S.-Israeli relations, given that the United States is ruled by “an administration that loves the Jewish state and despises most liberal American Jews.” Kennedy re-emphasized that the fundamental values of Israel are the same as the United States’, adding that the two are committed to empowering the individual. Though he believes that a strong U.S.-Israel relationship is very important, he does not believe that “that means I can shy away from criticizing policies from any government, including Israel.” He said he believes that he can still criticize politicians while “staying true to the underlying principles” that are the foundation of the countries’ relationship. In an interview with the Justice, Kennedy discussed the current stance of the Democratic Party on the Israel-Palestine conflict. “I don’t think supporting Palestinian rights … should … come at the cost of the right to exist for the state of Israel. I don’t think those two things are antithetical,” he said, stating that he is a “strong supporter of a two-state

See KENNEDY, 6 ☛

Students march to ‘take back the night’ ■ Students marched from

the Rabb Steps to the Light of Reason in a show of solidarity with survivors of sexual assault. By NATALIA WIATER JUSTICE EDITOR

Members of the Brandeis community gathered at the bottom of the Rabb Steps on Thursday to raise awareness of sexual violence on campus in the annual Take Back the Night march. Over 60 members of the Brandeis community marched through the center of campus to the Light of Reason as organizers called out statistics from the 2015 Campus Climate Survey on Sexual Misconduct. “The work of dismantling rape culture and ending sexual violence is fundamentally tied to the dismantling of racism, transphobia, homophobia, ableism, and all systems of oppression,” Becky Schwartz ’20, one of the event’s organizers, told the march’s participants at the introduction of the event. All quotes attributed to those who spoke at the march are from a copy of the remarks that organizers provided to the Justice. The march was held “to critically reflect on sexual violence, empower one another, and show solidarity with, or as, survivors,” Schwartz said. Before the march started, TBTN organizer Chila Haber ’19 announced that the press would not

photograph or record the event, and asked participants to refrain from photographing and recording the event themselves without explicit permission from the participants themselves to respect the identities of the people who attended. Take Back the Night originated in the 1960s when women across the globe protested sexual violence as part of the feminist movement. The event has provided survivors a “powerful space … to share their stories and reclaim areas on campus where they experienced harm,” Haber said. Like last year, the organizers marched through the center of campus but did not stop at individual dorms, respecting the students who did not want to participate. “As we gather and march tonight, we walk in solidarity with survivors and, for many of us, as survivors,” Haber told the crowd. They finished their march at the Light of Reason, where participants chanted, “Shatter the silence, stop the violence. Ignite the light, take back the night.” There, Schwartz repeated a quote from former University President Frederick Lawrence, who said, “We’re not here to protect you, we’re here to prepare you for the real world” to a group of students who protested sexual violence on campus five years ago. Schwartz said Lawrence failed to recognize “that sexual violence does not HAVE to happen everywhere,” and that this kind of rhetoric “actively

Waltham Wonders

Bacchae

Re-imagining New Indias

 Exploring the town is easy via BranVan and by foot.

 The department of Theater Arts presents its interpretation of Greek mythology.

By ELLA RUSSELL

By SAMMY PARK

By NIA LYN SAMMY PARK/the Justice

Union Bylaws, stipulates that a proposed club must not “duplicate the purpose or goals of an existing club,” and must not have a “substantively” similar “impact and student appeal” as an existing club. But Dinlenc said his real motivation was sustainability. Per the proposal, Dinlenc believes having two newspapers is “unnecessary and unsustainable,” adding that “we are essentially the 0.1% who can afford to waste resources.” In the proposal, Dinlenc also claimed The Hoot is a waste of Allocations Board funding, noting that their funding has remained steady as the Justice’s decreased steadily since 2014.

FEATURES 8 For tips or info email editor@thejustice.org

NOAH ZEITLIN/the Justice

Make your voice heard! Submit letters to the editor to letters@thejustice.org

See TBTN, 6 ☛

NEWS 3

Campus smoking rules are in need of an update By MADDOX KAY

FORUM 12

Brandeis Quidditch competes at national competition

ARTS 24

By MEGAN GELLER

COPYRIGHT 2019 FREE AT BRANDEIS.

SPORTS 16


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.