CYAN
MAGENTA
YELLOW BLACK
PAGE XX
★ Service Office Successes / Page 3 ★ At Home and Away / Page 6 ★ A Final Farewell / Page 8 ★
★ Service Office Successes / Page 3 ★ At Home and Away / Page 6 ★ A Final Farewell / Page 8 ★
MAY/JUNE 2005
MAY/JUNE 2005 87th Annual State Convention
Future Depends on Delegates’ Decisions When delegates to the 87th Annual State Convention convene in Indianapolis July 7-10 they will confront a variety of issues with long-lasting implications for the future of the Department of Indiana. Foremost among the decisions to be made will be the election of a new commander and state level officers, the swearing in of new district commanders, disposition of several program and constitutional resolutions, and, of course, a final decision on the proposed per capita increase. None of the issues have excited as much interest and controversy as the dues increase. Since the Department Finance Committee first
proposed, and the Executive Committee first recommended, a $10 annual per capita increase in January, opponents and proponents have squared off over the amount of the increase, the propriety of the original resolution, and the root causes of the financial strains now facing the Department. Per Capita Increase In an interview earlier this year, the Chairman of the Department Finance Committee, Webber LaGrange described the effect of declining membership, increasing program costs, and rising fixed expenses as underlying the proposal. “Four years ago we ended
the year with a $310,000 deficit. Three years ago the deficit was $201,000. With a lot of work, we were able to turn that around in 2003, ending the year with a $27,000 surplus, and one year ago, the surplus was $28,000. Unfortunately, for 2005, we are projecting a $118,000 deficit, and by the end of 2006, the deficit may well be $230,000,” he said. Department Finance Officer Tony Riley has crisscrossed the Department since March, offering a detailed briefing on the proposal. Among concerns frequently voiced was the authority of the Finance Committee to propose such a resolution and the role of the DEC in approving it.
“This resolution is, in fact, a recommendation by this body (the DEC) that the Department Convention approve a $10 increase in the per capita. That is because only the convention can approve such a change,” Riley has told his audiences. “Resolutions can originate in a number of ways. This particular resolution came from the Finance Committee, and despite what many of you may have heard, committees may propose resolutions and they can be considered by the DEC as long as they are presented by a member with full privileges,” he says. “The per capita increase resolution was so presented.
It also was reviewed by the Resolutions Assignment Committee and forwarded with the committee’s recommendation. Here is an important distinction. Our vote was a vote to forward the resolution to the Department Convention with a ‘Do Pass’ recommendation. It is not our decision to increase dues. That power rests solely with the Convention Delegates. It is important that our members understand that the DEC did not raise dues, and can not raise dues.” 2005-2006 Officers The delegates soon will exercise their power, not only in deciding the per capita issue,
Continued on page 2
Legion to Fight Effort to Trim Fee Remission Governor Slips Provision To Bar Some Rated Vets From Popular Benefit Into State’s Budget
Honors In Waiting
As ceremonies honoring the men and women of the Indiana Veterans Home staff unfolded, members of the Honor Guard from West Lafayette Post 492 stood by, awaiting their cue. Later, the unit fired a 21-gun salute in honor of America’s veterans and those who lived and died at the facility. The ceremonies were part of 2005 Legion Day at the Home, which coincided with Close of Books activities there June 12.
Past Commanders Challenge NEC
Grass-Roots Effort Necessary To Save VA Health Care Budget By Steve Brooks The Dispatch Through 15,000 posts all over the world, The American Legion has for 86 years been able to shape legislation affecting veterans’ health care and public policy. That kind of grass-roots effort helped bring the GI Bill into existence and turned the Department of Veterans Affairs into a cabinet-level department. And that kind of effort is needed to ensure adequate VA health care can be provided now and in the future for veterans. That was the dominant theme during the Legion’s 2005 Spring Meetings in Indianapolis. National Commander Thomas P. Cadmus and Past
National Commanders John Geiger and Ron Conley called on Legionnaires to make their fellow veterans and elected representatives alike aware of the problems facing VA health care this budget year. “The White House has proposed a VA budget that is woefully inadequate,” Cadmus said. “The new House Veterans Affairs Chairman wants to re-define the meaning of the word ‘veteran.’ He wants to provide VA health-care access only to those veterans he calls the ‘core constituency.’ In addition, Congress is considering a tiered scale of fees for Priority Groups 7 and 8 -- ranging from $230 to $500, depending on income -- to use the health-care system
that was designed for them. If the budget that is proposed passes, the result will be hundreds of thousands of veterans denied access to quality health care. “It is extremely crucial that we Legionnaires again do what we are good at: activate every member, every Auxiliary member, every Son, every family member and every citizen in every community in a massive grass-roots campaign to get mandatory funding passed by this Congress.” One way of doing this, Conley said, is to replicate a program he started in April in the Department of Pennsylvania. Working with Pennsylvania’s Alliance of Veterans Services -- made up of organizations
such as the Legion, AMVETs, Disabled American Veterans and Veterans of Foreign Wars -- Conley conducted Veterans Service Day events in McKeesport and Washington, two communities near Pittsburgh. Trained service officers from among the seven veterans’ service organizations that make up the alliance were on hand to provide free assistance and information to veterans. Attendees also received firsthand updates on issues of importance to veterans under consideration in the 109th Congress from U.S. Reps. Mike Doyle, D-Pa., and Tim Murphy, R-Pa., who spoke at
Continued on page 3
The American Legion has drawn a line in the sand over eligibility for one of the few state-sponsored benefits available to military veterans. In reaction to the budget proposed by Indiana Governor Mitch Daniels making some disability rated veterans ineligible for fee remissions at state colleges and universities, The Department of Indiana recently convened a meeting of Veterans Service Organization representatives to address the proposed change. After the meeting, Department Commander Bill Firkins said “We were shocked to learn of this change in the remission of fees program. The change is another example of the Daniels Administration’s unwillingness to consult with or get the opinion of the respective veterans’ service organizations on matters involving veterans.” The provision, which would make veterans with 0 percent disability ratings (those disabled but not eligible for VA compensation payments) was included in the budget proposal “under the cloak of night, with no discussion, no references to the statute itself, with one sentence on page 85 of a 250- page budget,” Firkins said. “Since the 1930s this provision has been a reward Indiana provided to veterans for their service and sacrifice, but with a flick of the pen the Administration has revoked this 70-year old statutory benefit.” According to Department Adjutant Steve Short, the Vet-
erans Service Organizations were advised of the change after publication of the budget, and then only as a “done deal in a memorandum to the VSOs from (Indiana Department of Veterans Affairs) Director Applegate. “We believe it is doubtful that most legislators even knew this provision was included in the budget statute, and we plan to fight this change,” Short said. According to Short, the Department of Indiana has consulted legal and government authorities, and are considering both legislative and public relations actions. “The Indiana Department of Veterans Affairs and the Governor can expect to be engaged on this issue,” he said. Indiana does not staff a veterans’ claims office to help veterans win appeals for federal veterans’ benefits, nor does Indiana help finance County Veterans Service Offices. The state does provide other veterans benefits, one of the best and most appreciated of which is the Remission of Fees Program for Children of Wartime Era disabled veterans. Although Indiana does not help finance college education of its returning active duty veterans, except for National Guard members, Indiana does provide free college tuition benefits up to 124 credit hours to the children of those veterans who served on active duty during a wartime era, performed duty equally hazardous that was recognized by the award of a campaign medal of the United States, or received the Purple Heart award. Also eligible for the fee re-
Continued on page 2
Legion Baseball Agrees: Wooden Bats Not ‘Safer’ Following a nine-month review, the American Legion’s National Baseball Subcommittee has concluded that there is no substantial evidence in scientific research to support the claim that baseball bats made from wood are “safer” than bats manufactured from metal or composite materials. The issue has been examined for years. Statistics compiled from numerous studies by the National Collegiate Athletic Association, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission and the National Institute for Sports Science and Safety, were among the
several studies considered by The American Legion in reaching their conclusion. The subject was brought to the national level by Legionnaires in Florida and Montana, where in 2003 an American Legion baseball pitcher died as a result of a head injury from a baseball hit with a metal bat. “We were concerned then and we are concerned now for the safety of the game and the safety of the young athletes who participate in it,” said Larry Price, Chairman of the subcommittee. “With deference to the family of the young
man we have given the matter our fullest attention over the last nine months. We have collected, compiled and distributed for the committee’s study a great deal of technical information, scientific analysis and expert opinion. We have heard from both camps -- wood and non-wood -- and we have found no clear evidence of unreasonable risk of injury or death with the use of non-wood bats in the game of baseball.” In a twenty-year study by the National Center for Catastrophic Sports Injury Research (1982-2002), seven
deaths of high school-aged baseball players were recorded. In that same period, there were six deaths in soccer, 20 deaths in track, and 92 deaths associated with football. Price offered that the game of baseball is one of the safest sports played today in high school and at the college level, noting that, “Injuries and, tragically, deaths occur in nearly every sport. By comparison, death on a baseball diamond is extremely rare.” Meeting at Indianapolis in their semi-annual gathering, the eight-member subcommittee heard from David
Cook, president of Hoosier Bat Company and Jim Darby, vice-president for Easton Bat Company. Both are experts in the manufacture and use of wood and non-wood bats, respectively. “Nearly every amateur baseball organization, from the NCAA to Little League has closely monitored and studied the use and safety of bats. These organizations, about 19 in number, permit teams to use both wood and non-wood bats,” said Price. Price noted that another three-year independent study on bat safety is being orga-
nized. The study is being directed by Dr. Fred Mueller, a member of the USA Baseball Medical and Safety Committee and Director of the National Center for Catastrophic Sports Injury Research. “We look eagerly toward its results,” said Price. “For now, finding no substantial evidence in scientific research on which to base a decision to ban non-wood bats from the field of play, The American Legion will maintain the current rule, which leaves the option for wood bats to the teams that play American Legion ball.”