35 YEARS AND STILL GOING STRONG
by Stephen Longest
This issue marks the 35th Anniversary of the Greater Pine Island Real Estate Guide. Over it’s 35 years the guide has had 4 remarkably different owners who all had one thing in common: Their passion for Greater Pine Island and their urge to share their passion with as many people as possible.
Here’s a look back at our 35 years and 4 owners!
The Start: Tedd Lincoln 1990-2017
In January of 1990 Tedd Lincoln published the first Pine Island Real Estate Guide and continued to promote Pine Island by publishing 5 issues a year for nearly 30 years. For those that knew Tedd this was no surprise. A World War II Vet, Tedd made his mark improving every community he lived in.
When Tedd first started the real estate guide his concept was to only include local businesses directly related to the buying, selling, and rental of real estate properties. With dedication, quality, and consistency Tedd soon attracted other local businesses to advertise in his guide to provide visitors with accommodations, dining, and “recreational therapy” as they explored Pine Island.
“Buying and selling of real estate – like most other businesses is largely a numbers game. Exposure! Exposure! Exposure!” - Tedd Lincoln
New Life: Bonnie Mullee 2017-2019
In late 2017 Bonnie Mullee a well-known island Realtor, took on the responsibility of publishing the guide. Her first and most impactful change was to the name. Bonnie changed the name to The Greater Pine Island Real Estate Guide to reflect the growth of the magazine! Bonnie made some very influential changes that are still incorporated into each issue today.
“It certainly was one of the more fulfilling chapters in my career life. The changes made during my tenure I believe brought it into the 21st century.”– Bonnie Mullee
Showcasing our beautiful Island: Lisa and Jen Johnson 2019-2024
In 2019 Lisa and Jen began to publish the guide. Utilizing the great platform built by Tedd and Bonnie they were able to expand the guide into more than just a showcase of real estate. Lisa and Jen expanded the guide to showcase the many talented residents of the islands.
“We wanted to tap into our islands’ talent from artists to musicians. It is easy to find a beautiful house here, however discovering this community is what makes this our best decision.” Lisa & Jen
A Rebirth: Stephen Longest 2024-Current
In 2022 Greater Pine Island was wrecked by Hurricane Ian, but the spirit of the Island remained intact. The devastation put the Guide on hold for almost an entire year and a half. In July of 2024 normal printing of the Guide was resumed. Building on the legacy of it’s previous owners Stephen has worked to bring new life into the Guide.
The Greater Pine Island Real Estate Guide is now distributed all over Southwest Florida, mailed to over 15 states, and published digitally online! We hope you continue to enjoy our issues for years to come and support our advertisers. All 4 owners of our Guide have made it their mission to promote our islands and we hope you will join us in showing everyone the beauty of the landscape and the people of Greater Pine Island.
Thank you to Tedd, Bonnie, Lisa, Jen, Nancy, Jill and all of the advertisers that have made this Guide a beacon of Pine Island. #Pine Island Strong
621 RUM RD, UPPER CAPTIVA
Canal home, 80’ dock, elevator, new roof, 3bd/ den, screened pool, great views of preserve. $1,995,000
331 SPANISH GOLD, UPPER CAPTIVA
A spacious & luxurious home w/ 4 BR/4BA & den on a canal, two dock slips, pool, impact windows. Must see! $2,190,000
4551 BARTLETT , UPPER CAPTIVA
Walk to the beach in 5 min. from this 3 bd/ 2,5 bath on secluded lot. Lots of decks. $999,000
11194 MATLACHA AVE MATLACHA
The big & beautiful view across Matlacha Pass is stunning. Create your own special getaway here.
$550,000
11196 MATLACHA AVE., MATLACHA
Enjoy boating, fishing and fantastic sunrises over Matlacha Pass from this extraordinary homesite.
$475,000
4686 SANDPIPER DR., SAINT JAMES CITY
“Two Perfect” 2 BR, 2BA, 2 sheds, 2 carport spaces, Neat, Clean & Cute. Your own “Margaritaville.” $199,000
3252 EIGHTH AVE , SAINT JAMES CITY
Wide canal, quick access to open water. Short ride to Picnic Is., Ft. Myers Beach and Sanibel. $236,900
570 CORAL CIR, UPPER CAPTIVA
Build your dream home here and experience Spectacular Sunsets. Just a short walking distance to the beach. $175,000
4771 FLAMINGO DR. SAINT JAMES CITY
Very pretty furnished home move in ready. On a direct access canal leading to outer islands and beaches. $370,000
14112 SANDARAC DR., BOKEELIA
3 BD+Den/2 BA contemporary POOL home in the Alden Pines Golf Course community. 1839 sq.ft. overlooking a pond and golf course. Launch your boat at nearby Safe Harbor, Pineland Marina. $640,000
LOTS and DOCKS
BOAT SLIP J BARTLETT DR. UPPER CAPTIVA — Rare slip to fit a 28’ boat+/- $199,000
7160 ORANGE AVE. BOKEELIA — Drive your golf cart to Safe Harbor Marina for sunsets. $29,000
4809 SANDPIPER DR. ST. JAMES CITY — 80’x180’ Community boat ramp. $99,000
5131 SANDPIPER DR. ST. JAMES CITY — canal front with lift, fencing and electric. $174,900
13841 ROBERT ROAD BOKEELIA FL MAIN HOME 3 BEDS 2 BATHS RARE 3
$1,900,000
The Adams Mound Estate is composed of THREE RESIDENCES on 7+ acres in the ancient Calusa Indian mound area of Pineland. The main 2 story house was built in 1911 and is located on one of the highest Indian mounds in the area. It has 3 bedrooms and a beautiful brick patio area. The 2 other residences have complete kitchens, bathrooms and 1 or 2 bedrooms. The grounds are home to a large variety of tropical plants and fruit trees. The property also boasts a natural cypress slough, pond, artesian well, and is bordered by what was once the Calusa canal that crossed Pine Island hundreds of years ago. This property would make a great family compound or corporate retreat. Don't miss the opportunity to own this unique old Florida treasure.
Built in 1911 on top of a Calusa Mound
Stone Patio on 2 sides of home
Over 7 acres with fruit trees
3 bd/2 bth well-appointed, completely redone waterfront home. spacious master ensuite with generous walk-in shower. Main level: 2 bdrms, bath, ample storage.
or
3366 Stringfellow Road, Saint James City, Fl 33956
This stunning 3/2 is nestled into scenic SWFL. Perfect blend of modern sophistication and coastal charm.
Private, tranquil, bay waterfront 3/2 home with immediate Gulf Access. Highly desirable 8th ave property
Key west style home with direct access. Two docks! Remodeled Kitchen with stainless, granite and full backsplashes.
Located on the sought after Galt Island Ave this 3/2 home is made of CBS construction. Nature Preserve in your front yard!
Well maintained 3/2 pool home in desirable St. Jude Harbors. Lots of great upgrades. No flooding ever! Amazing Chef’s kitchen!
$299,900 $329,900 • $360,000 • $389,900
Beautifully remodeled 2/1 gulf access turnkey home. New roof, HVAC, plumbing, dock, and covered boat lift
Fisherman’s Wharf — 3 incredible gulf access condos available in this sought-after development. Community heated pool, boat slips, shuffleboard, and a secured boatyard.
$889,900
$995,900 $979,000 $899,900 $588,900 $835,900 $399,900
Modern gulf access canal pool home. Luxury living and investment potential all in one.
$519,900 Castaways Island Realty & Rentals can help you land your island dream, whether you’re looking to buy, sell, or rent, you’ve come to the right place!
Waterfront Oasis. This harmonious 3/2 offers comfort, style, and the ultimate island lifestyle.
8 QUESTIONS YOU SHOULD ASK WHEN INTERVIEWING A BUYER’S AGENT!
InIn 2024, the National Association of Realtors® made changes to the ways Buyers and Sellers negotiate commission and compensate their agent. These changes have also affected the process of buying a home. Before touring a home with an agent it’s important to be sure you are hiring the right agent. You may want to meet a few agents before committing to one and here are some questions you should ask them before signing a Buyer’s Agreement.
What Services do you offer?
A good agent will likely be able to provide you with an extensive list of the services they provide. How well do you know the local market?
To ensure you are getting the most accurate information and best pricing advice you should choose an agent familiar with the local market conditions. Do you have experience with similar buyers?
Depending on your situation you may want to find an agent that specializes in working with first-time buyers, or veterans, or buyers similar to your situation. What should I expect in the process of buying a home?
A good Realtor will be able to walk you through the process from the first home tour to the closing table.
Will you be able to recommend local professionals to assist me in purchasing and owning a home?
A good agent can often provide you with their contacts. (If they can’t just use the Greater Pine Island Real Estate Guide to find local professionals) What does the written buyer agreement include?
There are a few different types of Buyer’s agreements. You should agree with your agent on which type you are using. How long does the agreement last and how long will we work together?
A good agent will plan to support you well beyond the closing table! What do you charge and how is that paid?
Remember that agent compensatation is negiotable but a good agent should be able to convey thier value proposition and may be able to negioate on your behalf to be paid by the sellers!
Remembering Capt Codty Pierce
Captain Codty was a local, an avid Fisherman, and a passionate advocate for our SWFL waterways:
For anyone who ever met Codty Pierce it will be hard to forget his smile. Codty was an energetic and charismatic personality. Aside from owning Fort Myers Fishing Charters Codty also served as President of the Calusa Waterkeeper. Codty was the “heart and soul” of the organization and will forever be remembered for his unwavering commitment to protecting the waters of Southwest Florida.
“There was no one like Codty—his passion for the water, his tireless work, and the generosity with which he shared his knowledge and love of nature made him a beloved figure to all who crossed his path. He was often called “the watchdog of our waters” for his ability to speak hard truths, inspire action, and ignite hope for a healthier future for our ecosystems.
Codty was a rising environmental leader whose legacy will continue to inspire future generations of advocates, scientists, and citizens dedicated to safeguarding our precious natural resources. He had the rare gift of making everyone he encountered feel valued, understood, and empowered to make a difference.” – Calusa Waterkeeper
Whether you knew Codty or not you can be sure that you have benefited from the work Codty did to protect our waters. Our thoughts and prayers are with those near to him and those mourning his loss.
Calusa Waterkeeper will host a Celebration of Life on Monday February 3rd, 2025 at 2pm at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre.
99‘ 8:01 PM 0 60‘
1:25 AM 1 66‘ 9:21 AM 0 34‘ 3:04 PM 1 07‘ 8:46 PM 0 45‘
2:05 AM 1 55‘ 9:41 AM 0 19‘ 3:12 PM 1 18‘ 9:31 PM 0 31‘
2:45 AM 1 40‘ 10:00 AM 0 03‘ 3:24
1 30‘ 10:15
0 18‘
3:29 AM 1.24‘ 10:18 AM 0.15‘ 3:40 PM 1.42‘ 11:03 PM 0.07‘
4:18 AM 1.06‘ 10:36 AM 0.32‘ 4:01 PM 1.52‘ 11:55 PM 0.01‘
5:18 AM 0.89‘ 10:50 AM 0.49‘ 4:28 PM 1.59‘ 19 12:56 AM 0.06‘ 6:45 AM 0.73‘ 10:51 AM 0.63‘ 5:00 PM 1.62‘
waterfront fishing village with brightly colored art galleries, small island boutiques, and unique bars and restaurants. Own a piece of paradise whether to use as a rental property or for your own use, or both, this stylish tropical island waterfront home comes fully
THE EAGLES NEST RESTAURANT
1. Jug Creek Marina & Fish House
Carmen's Kayaks
2. Laz y Flamingo
Four Winds Marina
3. Safe Harbor Pineland
Tarpon Lodge & Restaurant
Calusa Heritage Trail
4. Fruitscapes & Pine island Tropicals
Koucky Studios & Potter's Guild Show
5. Patch of Paradise
Kuztum Designs
6. Sweeneys SOS
The Eagles Nest
7. Salty Girls Café
Spot’s Ice Cream
Island Bikeworks
8. Island Exchange Realty
Greater Pine Island Chamber of Commerce
Pine Island Pizza
John R. Wood Bokeelia
Greater Pine Island Alliance
Stearns Custom Builders
9. Dr. Watson’s Liquor Store
Material Green
eXp Realty
10. Century 21 Sunbelt Realty
Kickstands Pub & Grub
11. Pine Island Pest Control
Marine Body Guard
12. Ship Shape Laundr y Co.
13. Premier Island Realty
Premier Growers, Inc
14. Gault Preserve
15. Froggy's
16. Castaways Island Realty & Rentals
Monroe Canal Marina
Low Key Tiki
Phuzzy’s Boat Shack
John R. Wood St. James
Two Fish Inn
17.
Pine Island
Matlacha
3638 Pinetree Dr, St. James City
Exceptionally remodeled by a master craftsman this custom 3/3 home is a boaters dream with two 10,000 lbs. boat lifts.
6329 Monterey Dr, Bokeelia
Private rural residence on 1 acre lot. Vaulted ceilings with natural light. Fenced property with mature tress
2420 Cherimoya Ln, St. James City
Dream waterfront home. Fully remodeled 4/4 just minutes away from open waters. Must see!.
7767 Della Bitta Ln, Bokeelia
Highly sought after Captain’s Cove vacant lot. Community gulf access with private boat launch.
2758 Bruce St, Matlacha 3/2 home located in magical Matlacha. New roof, interior remediated and ready for you to place your finishing touches.
2839 Janet St, Matlacha
3262 Pinetree Dr., St. James City
Stunning custom home with direct sailboat access. This newer home was built in 2020. No flooding! Over 2100sft of absolute paradise.
11306 Matlacha Ave, Matlacha
This concrete block home has space for 2 beds and 2 baths. Sailboat Access canal. Needs full rehabs
Charming cottage with direct gulf access. Light and bright this home is in the heart of artsy Matlacha. .
4819 Pine Island Rd, Beautifully renovated home, impact windows, doors & metal roof.
ISLAND | $1,200,000 3864 Royal Palm Dr, expansive dock is composite plus workshop. Beautifully furnished. ST. JAMES CITY | $
2605 1st St, NEW custom Bahama shutters! NEW boat lift motors! Concrete block Gulf access cottage.
2771
ST. JAMES CITY $795,000
2654 Sanderling Ct, 2/2. Waterfront pool home, furnished turnkey.
4625 Berkshire Rd, 3/2. two acres that are beautifully landscaped ST JAMES CITY $650,000
13690 Waterfront Dr, 3+Den/2, overlooking Pine Island Sound. Sunset Views.
BOKEELIA $750,000
16310 Boyce Dr, 3/2. Direct Gulf access via a boat ramp directly across the street
3004 Trawler Ln, 3/2. Brand new construction. aterfront Phase III of Treasure Cove ST JAMES CITY $618,560
PINE ISLAND VACANT LAND
3892 Blueberry Ln. St. James City $290,000
4970 Sandpiper D., St. James City $229,000
4924 Gulfgate Ln. St. James City $147,000
7144 Ladyfish Dr St. James City $50,000
3486 Tangelo Dr. St. James City $45,000
7400 Cypress Dr, Bokeelia $29,000
6057 Calusa Ridge Trail, 4/3.5. Custom-built home, steps to lake.
3091 Trawler Ln, 3/2. Canal front home in the sought-after Treasure Cove
4931 Island Acres Ct, 3/3. On a peaceful pond, providing stunning views
ST. JAMES CITY $300,000
3757 Tropical Point Dr, 2/2. Gorgeously remodeled home is on a large lot
Teal Ct, 4/3.5, on a gorgeous interior bay with big views. Large dock.
ST. JAMES CITY $1,895,000
BOKEELIA $1,750,000
BOKEELIA $1,250,000
ST. JAMES CITY $699,000
ST. JAMES CITY $585,000
3247 Manatee Dr, 3/2. Custum built canal home w/ saltwater pool. ST. JAMES CITY $1,225,000
Clubhouse Dr, 4/3. Pool, 3 car garage, offered Turnkey
BOKEELIA $935,000
Beth Sweet Realtor®
Direct: 239-209-1424
bsweet@Johnrwood.om
Featured Properties
MATLACHA ISLES OFFERED FOR $1,049,000
MATLACHA ISLES OFFERED FOR $1,049,000
2304 Boat Shell Dr. Sold furnished turnkey, you can move right in to this beautiful 2 story, 3 bedroom 3 bathroom water front pool home,.
2304 Boat Shell Dr. Sold furnished turnkey, you can move right in to this beautiful 2 story, 3 bedroom 3 bathroom water front pool home,.
ST. JAMES CITY $2,699,000 4961 Galt Island Ave. This incredible 3 bedroom 3 bath waterfront pool home is located in a private gated community.
ST. JAMES CITY $548,800
5197 Anchorage Dr. 3+Den/3. Nearly 2100 sq ft, spacious living & dining area, high ceilings, granite kitchen.
ST. JAMES CITY $315,000
2717 N Ibis Ct. 2/2. Mobile home on the water. Opaen floor plan, new kitchen, a/c, water heater, flooring.
ST. JAMES CITY $249,000
3900 Royal Palm Dr. Waterfront lot with direct access. Sailboat access w/ 60 ft frontage.
ST. JAMES CITY $339,000
ST. JAMES CITY $548,800 5197 Anchorage Dr. 3+Den/3. Nearly 2100 sq ft, spacious living & dining area, high ceilings, granite kitchen.
3008 Sloop Ln. 2/2,partially furnished waterfront mobile home. Dock & boat life w/ new canvas cover.
ST. JAMES CITY $275,000
ST. JAMES CITY $315,000 2717 N Ibis Ct. 2/2. Mobile home on the water. Opaen floor plan, new kitchen, a/c, water heater, flooring.
3569 Gasparilla St. 2/2, Eat in kitchen, new granite counters,SS appliances, New flooring throughout.
2959 Oleander St. St. James City, FL. 33956
ST. JAMES CITY $249,000 3900 Royal Palm Dr. Waterfront lot with direct access. Sailboat access w/ 60 ft frontage.
ST. JAMES CITY $339,000 3008 Sloop Ln. 2/2,partially furnished waterfront mobile home. Dock & boat life w/ new canvas cover.
ST. JAMES CITY $550,000 4625 Berkshire Rd. This spacious 3 bedroom 2 bath home is situated on 2 acres of land. Enjoy the privacy and beauty of Pine Island
ST. JAMES CITY $485,000 2901 York Rd. New Model 2 Bedroom 2 Bath home on direct Gulf access canal. New 13,000# boat lift, whole home generator, fully furnished.
ST. JAMES CITY $275,000 3569 Gasparilla St. 2/2, Eat in kitchen, new granite counters,SS appliances, New flooring throughout.
ST. JAMES CITY $249,000 4700 Gulfgate Ln. Updated 2 bedrooms and 2 bath on an oversized lot. European sink, new flooring, Florida room, community pool and boat ramp.
ST. JAMES CITY $414,000 3892 Phoenix Dr. This turnkey 2 bedroom 2 bath home is perfect for moving into or renting. Renovated Kitchen, Quartz counters, new metal roof, 15,000# boat lift.
2959 Oleander St. St. James City, FL. 33956
BOKEELIA $265,000 7321 Pomegranate Dr. This peaceful 2 bedroom 3 bath home is close to Pineland Marina and everything Pine Island has to offer. Screened lani, room for a pool.
Stephen M Longest
2399 Sapodialla Ln., St. James City
Direct Gulf access pool home. Boat Lift, Impact windows, custom pool, completely remodeled, huge kitchen!
Priced at $850,000
2653 First St, Matlacha
Breathtaking views from this Matlacha home. Lot’s of bonus space downstairs to make your own. Gulf Access!
Priced at $1,0 00,000
5520 Phillips St, Bokeelia
Move In Ready!!!
2 beds and 2 baths, this great condo also has an attached garage. Inexpensive HOA!
Priced at $287,000
2685 Clyde St, Matlacha
Solid block construction, just a few repairs to be a great income producer! Impact windows and sliders!
Priced at $399,000
2605 First St, Matlacha
Heart o f Matlacha this great residence offers easy gulf access. With brand new Bahama Shutters!
Priced at $525,000
2566 Second St, Matlacha Gulf access, income producing duplex.
Priced at $475,000
4736 Pine Island Rd, Matlacha
Breathtaking Sunset views
Custom pool.
Priced at $499,000
LOCAL AS IT GETS
A look at a selection of Pine Island Farms
The soil on Pine Island is great for farming and we have the local farms to prove it. It’s always good to support local restaurants, and businesses, but don’t forget about our local farms! Here’s a look at just a few of our local farms!
Green Acres of Pine Island
Green Acres is a small 4 acre legacy orchard. The orchard has one of the most diverse offerings of tropical fruit here on Pine Island. They focus on growing things naturally without the use of commercial pesticides and herbicides. The owners, For Andrew and Bruce living a healthy life is paramount. They prioritize the health of their customers ensuring that the products they provide are as natural as possible.
Green Acres is open by appointment only. They offer Orchard tours as well as fresh fruit for sale in season. You can also find their fruits and other offerings at The Patch of Paradise stand.
Patch of Paradise Farm
Introducing Rich and Melissa Simonelli, the dedicated owners of Patch of Paradise. Their journey began with a simple goal: to adopt a healthier lifestyle. Acknowledging the difficulty in finding genuinely organic produce, Rich and Melissa took the plunge into cultivating our own fruits, vegetables, and trees naturally. Though they’ve faced their fair share of challenges, they believe that true success is born from overcoming obstacles.
As their passion flourished, so did the interest from their friends eager to purchase fresh, homegrown offerings. This excitement has fueled their journey and contributed to their love of Pine Island. They believe Pine Island is a beautiful place to nurture both inner wellbeing and outer health. Rich and Melissa love the vibrant sense of community and the array of unique businesses that enhance the island.
Pineshine Farms
Nestled in St. James City Pineshine Farms has provided the island with 100% grass fed beef and poultry since 2017. Since their inception they have grown their operation to include pasture raised heritage pork and provide access to local dairy! Their goal is to provide Greater Pine Island and it’s neighboring areas with tremendous value and superior customer service.
FruitScapes
FruitScapes was started by Stephen Cucura and Jesus Avalos in 2004. They primarily specialize in planting and landscaping fruit trees, which is how they got their name. In 2008, the pair
was able to purchase a quaint farm stand on Stringfellow to provide their trees and fruit to the local community. With time they have grown the farm to just over 10 acres here on Pine Island. Over the years the operation has grown to supply local farmers with trees and an opportunity to distribute their fruits and produce through the FruitScapes market. They distribute trees and produce from Homestead to Orlando!
The market sells fresh seasonal produce, local eggs, honey, jams, jellies, pickles, homemade bread, and ice cream made from surplus fruits and vegetables.
Their main attraction, however, is the huge selection of over 100 varieties of fruit trees and fruiting plants.
Support Island Events!
Upcoming Events
February 1 & 2 Art Fest Fort Myers Downtown Fort Myers
Saturday,10am - 5pm Sunday 10am - 4 pm
February 5, 12 and 19 Fishing Seminars @ 6pm-8pm Call 609-412-7328 to RSVP
February 8 Museum of the Islands 35th Anniversary @10am
February 15
• 60th Anniversary Party in the Park @2-5pm St. James City Civic Assoc.
• OTR @ The Eagles Nest Restaurant @8pm
• Two Fish Inn - Chili Cook Off @ 4-7pm
• The Mood Zombies @ Froggy’s @ 8pm
February 18 The Lonesome Rangers @ Jug Creek @5pm
March 2 Matlacha Hookers 13th annual Luau @ SJC Civic Center
March 7 Island Troy @ Tarpon @ 5pm
March 15
Snowbird Marathon@ Jug Creek Marina
On-Going Events
Second Saturday of each Month
October through April
Potters’ Guild Show featuring Island Artisans @ Koucky Studios
Last Saturday of each Month October through April
Island Market @Fishers of Men Lutheran Church
Saturdays & Sundays
Island Vibe Market @ The Eagles Nest
Second Saturdays
Big Breakfast @ SJCCA@ 8am
Every Friday VFW Market 9am-1pm
Check our
The Flo Smart Water Monitor and Shutoff is a gamechanging leak detection and water monitoring device that detects leaks anywhere in the home. This device can automatically turn off the water to the home if a leak or risk is detected, with the ability to start and stop water flow from your smartphone. It also provides real-time information on water usage in your home.
GREATER PINE ISLAND Market Report
Total 257)
BOKEELIA
PINELAND
$556,667 Average Sale (Dry Property)
$440,000 Average Sale (Gulf Access Property)
$1,132,500 Average Sale (Gulf Access Property)
$324,100 Average Sale (Dry Property)
$672,500 Average Sale (Gulf Access Property) N/A
$357,500 Average Sale (Gulf Access Property)
*Year to Date Data from Royal Palm Coast MLS as of January 2025
Bokeelia
5831 Samoa Dr $275,000
This 3/2 spacious split floor plan home offers vaulted ceiling’s, nice sized kitchen, a two-car garage, new roof 2023.
Flamingo Bay
4921 Sandpiper Drive $349,000
Recently updated, 1,120 sq’ waterfront 2/2 furnished home built in 2006 offers new granite countertops, soft close cabinets, pantry, new 7,000 lb boat lift and sits on a 80’ x 180’ lot. This home had no interior damage from the Hurricane.
Bokeelia
5781 / 5783 Marina Dr.
Updated deluxe duplex, each unit offers 2bds/2 bths, vaulted ceiling’s, kitchens with soft-close cabinets, quartz counter tops, pantry, breakfast nook, screened lanais and a one-car garage.
Flamingo Bay
5099 Flamingo Drive.
This water access home was damaged in Hurricane Ian and is in need of repair or start fresh with a new one
Bokeelia Off Water
3939 Areca Dr 5,097 sq' 12k boat lift $269,000
3884 Areca Dr 3,398 sq' Two boat lifts $220,000 SOLD
3913 Areca Dr 3,354 sq' $214,000
2375 York Rd
St James City Off Water
3
We have so many great restaurants on the islands. Here are a few of our favorite Menu Items!
Bacon Jam Scallops
This is one of the many amazing specials at the Blue Dog Bar & Grill. You won’t regret ordering these! and you can always start with a Stone Crab app!
Crab Crusted Grouper
A signature dish at The Waterfront Restaurant.
Enjoy the broiled local Grouper, topped with their special Crab stuffing.
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Stop into Kickstand’s Pub and Grub to add a kick to your day! Juicy chicken coated in an incredible sauce!
Award Winning Smash Burger
Chef Ried is flipping these great burgers non-stop at Street Eatz & Ale. These pair nicely with your favorite cold brew!
Island Burger
This huge 10oz Angus Burger is topped with grilled pineapple and fresh mango salsa. Get yours at The Eagles Nest Restaurant
Oysters on the Half Shell
Swing by Lazy Flamingo in Bokeelia to enjoy delicious gulf oysters and more local favorites. Go by car or by boat and enjoy the great views of Jug Creek.
REAL ESTATE
Brokerages
Islander Realty (p.9)
Castaways Island Realty (p.15)
RE/MAX Sunshine (p.27)
Island Exchange Realty (p.29)
Coldwell Banker Realty (p.37)
Sun Country Realty (p.53)
Home Inspectors
Professional Real Estate Inspectors (p.53)
Manufactured Home Retailers
LEECORP Homes (p.11)
Mortgage Lenders
Tonya Sample (p.13)
Realtors®
Sarah Chido (p.7)
Team Shevlin (p.12,58-59)
Michael Shevlin
Carlyn Herring
Tonya Player
Becky White (p.19,39)
Rob Stols (p.21)
Heidi Choiniere (p.33)
Char Seuffert (p.27)
Jay Johnson (p.29)
Christine Remler (p.29)
Julie Oberlin (p.31)
Pine Island Team (p.32-33)
Mike Faulkner
Christy Knight
Beth Sweet (p.34)
Paula Barwick (p.34)
Stephen M Longest (p.36-37)
Romana Gavrinev (p.37)
Shelby Bigler (p.41)
Business Directory
Kristi Dunfee (p.45)
Leslie Osborne (p.46)
Lori Caldwell (p.49)
Tammy Brown (p.51)
Marion Briggs (p.53)
Greg Lehman (p.53)
Brady Meier (p.54)
Michael Giusto (p.57)
Donna Gilles (p.60)
Phil Gilles (p.60)
Title Companies
Crossroads Title (p.22)
HOME SERVICES
Building Contractors
Stearns Custom Builders (p.2-3)
J. F. Smith (p.4-5,64)
Sun Country Homes (p.53)
Ross Jordan Homes (p.63)
Building Supplies
Shoreline Lumber (p.8)
Cleaning Services
A Way Out Cleaning Service
Licensed & Insured
239-339-3525
Let us be your way out of cleaning.
Docks & Boat Lifts
Island Time Canopy (p.20)
Dockshare (p.20)
Electricians
Gault Electric South 239-560-9974
Sound Electric 863-558-3939
Flooring
Josh Davis Flooring (p.16)
Garage Doors
The Door King (p.42)
Home Watch
Islander Home Watch (p.22)
Meier Home Service (p.55)
Landscaping
Meier Landscaping (p.55)
Larry’s Trimming Service
Trimming, weed spray, pest control, & rodent control 440-225-1695
Uni-Scape Landscape & Design Ponds, waterfalls, hard scrapes, pool renovation and landscaping. 239-283-7733
Pest Control
Pine Island Pest Control (p.48)
Plumbers
Nordic Plumbing (p.43)
Pool Builders
Artesian Pool Construction (p.44)
Roofers
Story Roofing (p.1,26)
Septic Services
Honc Inustries (p.48)
SHOP LOCAL
Artisans / Shops / Galleries
Island Bikeworks (p.10)
Koucky Studios (p.29
Sweeny’s SOS (p.30)
Onofrio D. Oro (p.35)
Leoma Lovegrove (p.40)
Matlacha Menagerie (p.47)
Dr. Watson’s Liquors (p.51)
Calusa Bug Spray (p.60)
CW Fudge & Ice Cream (p.62)
Traders Hitching Post (p.62)
Hair Stylists and Barbers
Angle’s Hair Design
239-283-5222
4673 Pine Island Rd NW
Matlacha, FL 33993
Adventures / Activities
Island Bikeworks (p.10)
Carmen’s Kayaks (p.28)
Calusa Land Trust (p.28)
Farms
Patch of Paradise (p.53)
FruitScapes
12870 Stringfellow Rd. Bokeelia FL
239-218-2848
Restaurants
Blue Dog Bar & Grill (p.8)
Spots Ice Cream (p.14)
The Waterfront Restaurant & Marina (p.14)
Tarpon Lodge (p.16)
The Eagles Nest (p.22)
Kickstands Pub & Grub (p.42)
The Yucatán Waterfront (p.47)
Paradise Deli & Grill (p.48)
Lodging
Tarpon Lodge (p.16)
Angler’s Inn (p.30)
RECREATIONAL VEHICLES
Boating
Shoreline Lumber (p.8)
Monroe Canal Marina (p.18)
Marine Body Guard (p.21)
Dockshare (p.22)
Island Time Canopy (p.20)
Golf Carts
Kuztum Designs (p.10)
2888 Oleander St #C3
Fully remodeled gulf access condo in highly desirable Fisherman’s Wharf. Everything has been updated!
Listed at $382,500
$580,000
3083 Sloop Ln
Cherry Estates. Partially furnished 2/2 home on 1 1/2 lots with a hobby room, open floor plan, hurricane windows, heated splash pool, screened porch.
$749,000
2643 Clyde St
Direct Gulf access! 2 bedroom, 2.5 bath home with pool, impact windows, dock & boat lift. Large workshop and under house parking.
$189,000
TEAM SHEVLIN —THE ISLAND EXPERTS—
$399,000
3790 Tangelo
Super nice 3 bedroom 2 bath home in Tropical Homesites with 2 screened porches, storage shed and a 2-car garage.
$449,500
4839 Flamingo Dr HOUSE NEVER FLOODED!! 2 /2 Gulf access home with a detached 2 car garage and tons of storage. With street to canal lot, composite dock and boat lift.
7744 Farrell Rd
Large 3/2 Mobile located in 55+ community with $45 per year HOA. Plenty of room for all your projects. Great investment/rental property!
$399,000
4754 Woodstock Rd
3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, on 1.25 acres zoned AG. Home was totally redone after Hurricane Ian. Also has large detached garage.
$749,000
2543 Sanibel Blvd
Impeccably maintained TURNKEY piling home on direct access canal in St James City. 3 bedroom, 2 bath, screened pool and concrete dock.
3057 Sloop Ln
This 3/2 +den home with large great room is turnkey, move-in ready. Perfect for all your living & entertaining needs. Boat lift and direct Gulf access!
$299,000
6253 Valeria Road
Very cool old Florida home with 2 bedrooms, 2 baths, two open decks on a beautiful lot (.37 acre) at the end of the road for great privacy.!
$60,000
9848 STRINGFELLOW RD
Well-established (1980) Beauty Salon on Pine Island located in the Winn Dixie Shopping Center just south of the center. EVERYTHING IS NEW! Salon is fully stocked and an ongoing business.
$425,000
$695,000
3342 Pinetree Dr
3/2 Waterfront pool home. Wraparound dock with 2 boat lifts, Carolina Skiff included! Super clean & neat, tile floors, no-mow landscaping
$699,500
2831 Janet St.
Elevated (9.5”) 2/2 with 2-porches, Dock/10,000lb lift and Beautiful Tropical Landscaping.
$1,400,000
$399,900
16276 Nautical Way
Captain’s Harbor Condominium, “IF YOU WANT THE BEST” Corner Unit 2/2-with 2 car garage and dock!
$460,000
16100 Tortuga
Super Cute WATERFRONT cottage, Steps away from Charlotte Harbor, Matlacha Pass, Pine Island Sound and Jug Creek Marina.
7759 Bocilla Lane
The Malu Lani Inn. Old Florida Charm! Two buildings, 5 units! Waterfront at the tip of Bocilla Island at the north end of Pine Island.
$425,000
5651 Marina Dr
Unique 3/2 with large porch and pool. Living area on top floor and huge garage on ground floor perfect for mechanic, hobbies, storage.
$1,599,000
5257 Western Dr.
3-Story home with 2400 sq ft garage overlooking 10+ acre property with pond and the shallow salt water bay perfect for birds-flamingos have been seen!
COMMERCIAL
$3,750,000
5110-5120 Pine Island Rd
5 Bay addition to Calusa Cay Publix. 2 bays are leased to Doc Watson’s Liquors. The other 3 are waiting for your finishing touches. Excellent investment opportunity. Stanley’s Mangos Business & Farms $23,500,000
$310,000
16111 Tortuga
Classic Florida fishermans’s cottage, Incredibly well maintained. Currently used as a very successful vacation rental.
$650,000
3544 Emerald Ave
Unique two-story house with open ground floor & fireplace, Top floor has large open space/ fireplace, bedroom, bath kitchen, and large wrap-around porch. 160’ of waterfront - 2 minutes to San Carlos Bay
$499,000
4195 PINE ISLAND RD
The property has parking and LAND available. There is a private bay that wraps around the property with miles of mangrove for privacy. Re-locate or rebuild the buildings closer to the waterfront for great views. Live and have a business at the same property
Acreage
• 43 Acres with approximately 3,000 mango trees $3,750,000 • 100 Acres Stringfellow frontage $45,000 per acre
Greater Pine Island Real Estate Guide
In 1990 Tedd Lincoln published the very first edition of the Pine Island Real Estate Guide. Over the years the Guide has been the go-to source for home buyers, home sellers, and visitors to Pine Island. We are now in year 36 of our publication and are excited to announce that, we have added a digital flip book! Sign up on our website or scan the QR code below to get the Greater Pine Island Real Estate Guide in your inbox.
pineislandfl.com
Geography
Greater Pine Island is a collection of places in unincorporated Lee County. These include Matlacha Isles, Matlacha, Little Pine Island, Pine Island Center, Bokeelia, Pineland and St. James City. North Captiva, Useppa, and Cayo Costa are often included as the most direct route to reach these islands is from Pine Island.
Pine Island is the longest island in Florida spanning just over 17 miles long. a large percentage of Greater Pine Island is protected mangrove estuaries giving the area a lot of natural beauty.
Population
The population of the area varies greatly depending on the time of year. According to the 2020 Census the island has about 9,000 permanent residents. The median age on the island is 62, and over 43% of the population is over the age of 65.
Local Government
The entirety of Great Pine Island is unincorporated and as such it’sgovornered by Lee county. The county courthouse is located in downtown Fort Myers.
Hospitals
The closest hospital is in Cape Coral, but there are a handful of Doctor’s offices and Urgent Care Offices within a short distance to the island.
Ambulance Services
Lee County provides emergency support services to all of Greater Pine Island.
Fire Protection
Greater Pine Island is serviced by the Matlacha-Pine Island Fire control District. The district has 4 fire houses, and is headquartered at Station 1 at Pine Island Center.
Police Protection
Greater Pine island is served by the Lee County Sheriff’s office. The 6th Precint office is located in St. James City.
Library
The Pine Island library building is located at Pine Island center on Russell Rd. It is open to all, and is a part of the Lee County system.
Swimming
Phillips Park at Pine Island Center opened the first public pool in Lee County in 1973 and in 1986 was the first heated public pool in the county. There is a nominal fee for entry.
Tennis
Phillips Park offers public tennis courts.
Hiking
There are multiple trails for hiking on Pine Island. Many are part of the Calusa Land Trust.
Kayaking
There are multiple places on the island to launch a kayak and paddle the Great Calusa Blueway. Two of the more popular launches are in the Matlacha Community Park and Pineland.
Get Involved on Pine Island
(Clubs and Community Organizations)
American Legion
Beacon Of Hope
Calusa Land Trust
F.I.S.H (Fellow Islanders Sending Help)
Friends of Cayo Costa State Park
Friends of Pine Island Library
Greater Pine Island Chamber of Commerce
Greater Pine Island Civic Association
Kiwanis Club of St.James City
Matlacha Civic Association
Matlacha Hookers
Museum of the Islands
Pine Island Art Association
Pine Island Garden Club
Pine Island Lions Club
Pine Island Loyal Order of Moose
St. James Civic Association
Veterans of Foreign Wars
We design, engineer and build on your lot on Pine Island and surrounding areas. All of our home plans are custom designed with Ross Jordan’s artistic, and versatile imagination, engineered, and prepared for permitting.
Our homes are built “Hurricane Strong”. The Concrete Tie-Beam Construction provides the ultimate security against tropical threats. Our Stilt Homes are built above the designated flood zone level. Helping you to get flood insurance and better rates.
