The Georgetowner: February 12, 2020 Issue

KITTY KELLEY BOOK CLUB

‘The Age of Entitlement: America Since the Sixties’ SOLID WRITING AND RESEARCH ASIDE, THIS JEREMIAD ABOUT OUR CHANGING NATIONAL LANDSCAPE REVEALS THE AUTHOR’S BITTERNESS R EVIEWE D BY KIT T Y K E LLE Y In the 18th century, the Age of Enlightenment illuminated the world of ideas throughout Europe, stretching as far as America, where Thomas Jefferson adopted some of its ideals when writing the Declaration of Independence. Perhaps Christopher Caldwell aspired to achieve similar status by calling his book “The Age of Entitlement.”

In it, he explores the last five decades of a U.S. cultural upheaval, spurred, he claims, by the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and

the Voting Rights Act of 1965, legislation he sees as “a model for overthrowing every tradition of American life.”

Caldwell’s revolution starts with the assassination of John F. Kennedy in 1963, the event that propelled JFK’s successor, Lyndon B. Johnson, to initiate civil rights legislation. “[This] ideology, especially when it hardened into a body of legislation, became, most unexpectedly, the model for an entire new system of constantly churning political reform,” he writes.

With facile writing and impressive research, Caldwell examines his premise in detail, hitting the era’s hot-button issues: abortion, affirmative action, busing, Robert Bork, Gloria Steinem, women’s rights and gay marriage. He divides his book into seven sections: race, sex, war, debt, diversity, winners (African Americans, women and gays) and losers (white men).

Each of these sections contains bite-size subsections arguing aspects of Caldwell’s premise that “civil rights had been sold to the American public” under false pretenses, causing incalculable wreckage to society. He writes: “The new system for overthrowing the traditions that hindered black people became the model for overthrowing every tradition in American life, starting with the roles of men and women.”

As a conservative, white, male graduate of Harvard, Caldwell writes to the right, occasionally to the left and sometimes swerves center as he cites lawsuit after

lawsuit to make his points, one of which actually suggests that maybe Southern segregationists were correct all along.

His book, which relies on much of the conservative journalism he’s published in the Financial Times, the National Review and the Weekly Standard, reads like the lamentation of an anguished man who sees his world slowly crumbling beneath him.

Not all conservatives will applaud, particularly those who marched in the Reagan revolution. Caldwell lambasts Ronald Reagan on the issue of “mass immigration,” which, he maintains, “stands perhaps as [the president’s] emblematic failure. Reagan threw open the floodgates to international immigration while stirringly proclaiming a determination to slam them shut. Almost all of Reaganism was like that.”

What Caldwell grieves, progressives might celebrate, even the messiness of change and the discomfort of adjustment.

He rails against political correctness, considers it an affront to have to call black people African Americans and resents the federal holiday dedicated to Martin Luther King Jr. He lambasts his alma mater for ruling in 2016 that professors presiding over Harvard’s undergraduate houses be called “faculty deans” rather than “house masters,” sarcastically wondering if “kids would be unable to distinguish their house master from a slave-driving antebellum overseer.”

Strange that a skilled writer like Caldwell, who lives by the power of words, can’t acknowledge the degree of civility Harvard conferred with its small change.

The author becomes particularly overheated when he claims that, by embracing political correctness, Americans have “inadvertently voted themselves a second constitution,” and that this second

constitution, with its P.C. laws — “nurtured by elites in all walks of life” — is what currently prevails. He ridicules diversity as if it’s nothing more than a Mercedes-Benz, “a marker of money, class and power.”

He even chides CNN founder Ted Turner for ordering his company’s personnel to refer to things outside the U.S. as “international” rather than “foreign,” ignoring that “international” suggests a broader, more cosmopolitan embrace than “foreign,” which conjures all things strange, unfamiliar and alien. (That last sentence probably consigns me to the P.C. circle of hell.)

While much of this provocative book — with its conservative critique of the last 55 years in America — is interesting, it never rises above the author’s anger or overcomes his fury with the people of color, women and gays, who’ve challenged the system and won the changes that have rattled Caldwell’s world. He vents his spleen at a society that is not standing still, remaining soldered to tradition, but is instead, in his view, descending into chaos and leaving white men grasping the shreds of what once was.

More polemic than panacea, “The Age of Entitlement” is one man’s screed against change. As such, it offers no soothing balm to the gloom it delivers.

Georgetown resident Kitty Kelley has written several numberone New York Times best-sellers, including “The Family: The Real Story Behind the Bush Dynasty.” Her most recent books include “Capturing Camelot: Stanley Tretick’s Iconic Images of the Kennedys” and “Let Freedom Ring: Stanley Tretick’s Iconic Images of the March on Washington.”

GALA GUIDE FEBRUARY 26

MARCH 10

Carol and John Boochever and Olga and Scott Jaeckel are chairing the Leadership Changing Lives gala to support Teach For America leaders, whose efforts pave the way for educational equity for all children.

Ritz-Carlton. Email Cierra Hinton at cierra. hinton@teachforamerica.org.

The chairs of the gala are Hillary and Tom Baltimore and Erika and A. Scott Bolden. N Street Village is a nonprofit that empowers homeless and low-income women to claim their highest quality of life through shelter and a variety of programming. Marriott Marquis. Contact Stuart Allen at sallen@ nstreetvillage.org or 202-939-2085.

TEACH FOR AMERICA GALA

MARCH 7

CHILDREN’S NATIONAL’S A VINTAGE AFFAIR The Board of Visitors of Children’s National Health System will host this opportunity for wine lovers to taste fine wines and enjoy elegant cuisine while bidding on fine wines and experiences. Proceeds support the board’s annual grants and major gifts programs. Andrew W. Mellon Auditorium.

Contact Kathie Williams at kwilliams@ boardofvisitors.com or 202-660-1428.

N STREET VILLAGE GALA

MARCH 11

VITAL VOICES GLOBAL LEADERSHIP AWARDS The awards program honors women leaders standing on the frontlines of change, building and amplifying local solutions to global issues. Kennedy Center. Email mariadavis@ vitalvoices.org.

MARCH 12

LATINO STUDENT FUND GALA The evening begins with cocktails, Latin music and a silent auction, followed by

18 FEBRUARY 12, 2020

GMG, INC.

dinner and a live auction. LSF provides opportunities for underserved students of Hispanic descent in pre-K to 12th grade to get a strong academic foundation. Washington National Cathedral. Visit latinostudentfund. org.

MARCH 15

DAFFODILS & DIAMONDS LUNCHEON The 39th Daffodils & Diamonds event — a fashion show provided by Lord + Taylor and a luncheon emceed by WJLA-TV Anchor Alison Starling — supports the National Foundation for Cancer Research, focusing specifically on breast and ovarian cancers.

Columbia Country Club. Visit nfcr.org.

LEVINE’S GALA The evening begins with cocktails and includes a performance and a seated dinner.

Proceeds support Levine Music’s outreach program and scholarship fund, which last year provided more than $500,000 worth of music instruction to more than 650 children.

Arena Stage. Visit levinemusic.org.

MARCH 28

SIBLEY CELEBRATION OF HOPE AND PROGRESS Sibley Memorial Hospital relies on the support of the community to maintain a standard of excellence in public health services, including cancer research, maternal services and joint replacement care. Andrew W. Mellon Auditorium. Contact Kristen Pruski at kpruski@jhmi.edu or 202-6606814.

CYSTIC FIBROSIS BREWER’S BALL The event will benefit the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation, which funds research and drug development, promotes individualized treatments and ensures access to high-quality specialized care. National Building Museum.

Contact Chelsea Director at director@cff.org or 301-657-8444.