“ “gair“rhydd Politics tackle 18 days of Egyptian protests
Morgan Stoddart talks broken bones
Sport page 33
LGBT+ history month Features special
Politics page 15
Features page 19
Monday February 21 2011 | freeword – Est. 1972 | Issue 943
228 Fixed Penalty Notices £22,280 in fines £1,000 late payment fee
A rubbish policy Miranda Atty News Editor Students have criticised Cardiff Council after they issued approximately £22,000 worth of fines to students for failing to comply with the Council’s waste regulations under Section 46 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. Two hundred and twenty eight Fixed Penalty Notices, of £100 each, have been issued to students in Cathays since the new measures were introduced at the start of 2011. If these Fixed Penalty Notices are paid, the Council will receive £22,280 in fines from students. gair rhydd first reported on the
new policy in November 2010 (issue 937). In December 2010 (issue 939) a follow up article confirmed the Council’s policy on waste, and included a statement from the Council, which stressed that the £100 fines would only be issued ‘after a process of visiting residents and offering advice and information on how to dispose of waste correctly.’ The statement continued: “If the problem persists after a formal letter of warning, a fine of £100 is imposed.” However, students have approached gair rhydd to complain that the Fixed Penalty Notices and resulting £100 fines were imposed
without a clear Section 46 notice that should have been issued as a warning. The Section 46 notices contain stipulations reminding tenants how waste should be presented for collection. Second-year Maths student Kathryn Wynne was issued with a £100 fine in January 2011. Kathryn and her housemates, who live on Harriet Street, were given a Fixed Penalty Notice after one of their three bins was found halfway down their street. Kathryn explained: “The bin in question was not outside our house following collection. “My housemates and I assumed
that the bin had been removed by council refuse collections operatives due to the fact that throughout our tenancy we had three black bins, which we felt was excessive for the number of tenants residing in our house. “At this time we did not contact Cardiff County Council to report the bin as missing, or to confirm its removal, as my housemates and I were currently undergoing examinations as part of our studies at Cardiff University. “This was an extremely stressful time as we have recently entered our second year of study and have seen a dramatic increase in workload and examination preparation.”
Kathryn visited the Advice and Representation Centre (ARC) after receiving no response to a letter she sent to the Council explaining her situwation. ARC is currently advising a number of students on their rights in relation to the issuing of both the Section 46 notices and the Fixed Penalty Notices. A spokesperson for ARC told gair rhydd: “We are currently aware that in excess of 200 student households in the Cathays area have been issued with Fixed Penalty Notices for £100.”
Continued on page 3