Cultural Competency and Inclusion Training Resource Guide
Content Developed and Facilitated by: Dr. Miguel Angel Hernandez Associate Dean of Students University of California, Irvine MindsetsForSTEM.org
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Twitter: @FLC_LSRCE Š 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved.
Facebook: @FLCLSRCE
1
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Who We Are National Science Foundation and NSF INCLUDES National Network 1 of 6 Regional Centers of Excellence in Fall 2018 Regional Collaborative Partnerships Santa Fe College & University of the Virgin Islands Conduct STEM Intervention Research and Faculty Development Promote Student Success and Broadening Participation Strategies Broadly disseminate new knowledge acquired in STEM and Beyond
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Meet the Facilitator: Dr. Miguel Angel Hernandez Associate Dean of Students University of California, Irvine m.a.hernandez@uci.edu MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Overview of Training • Module 1: Cultural Competency in Higher Education: An Overview • Module 2: Cultural Competency in Administration & Leadership • Module 3: Cultural Competency in Training, Teaching & Assessment and Research • Theory to Action: Cultural Exposure Activity
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Introduction Reflection Activity: • Why did you choose to participate in this training? • What do you hope to gain from this training?
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
Module 1 Cultural Competency in Higher Education: An Overview
MindsetsForSTEM.org
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Twitter: @FLC_LSRCE © 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved.
Facebook: @FLCLSRCE
6
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Module 1 Overview
Readings
• Session Outcomes
•
“The Cycle of Socialization”
• Key Moments in History
•
“Race and Ethnicity in Higher Education” timeline for Activity
• Common Language • Awareness & Knowledge • Skills & Action MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
7
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Module 1 - Goal and Outcomes As a result of participating in this session, you will be able to… • Develop an understanding of key moments in history impacting higher education today, • Develop an understanding of self and others using the Cycle of Socialization, • Become empowered to look beyond the current context, demonstrate appropriate action within your sphere of influence by taking action and implementing change.. MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
8
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Activity:
Race & Ethnicity in American Higher Education 1.
Review the Key Moments in History Timeline.
2.
What events stood out to you and why?
3.
Reflect on at least one theme that emerged from your review of these select historical moments.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
9
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Key Moments… • 1790
Naturalization Act of 1790
• 1799
John Chavis is the first Black person on record to attend an American college or university. James McCune Smith is the first African American to earn a medical degree. First Black female medical student, Rebecca Lee Crumpler New England Female Medical College.
• 1837 • 1864
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
10
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Key Moments… • 1876 • 1881 • 1904
Edward Bouchet, first Black student to earn a Ph.D. in physics from Yale Spelman College, first historically Black college for Women, is founded in Georgia Daytona Literary and Industrial Training School for Negro Girls (renamed Bethune Cookman College in 1931) is established in Daytona Beach, Florida.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
11
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Key Moments… • 1927
U.S. Virgin Islands becomes an unincorporated U.S. Territory
• 1946
Mendez v. Westminster
• 1954
Brown v. Board of Education
• 1958
Mary Jackson becomes NASA’s first African American female engineer
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
12
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Key Moments… • 1972
Higher Education Amendments
• 1965
Santa Fe College is founded in Gainesville, Florida
• 1966
Tallahassee Community College is founded in Tallahassee, Florida.
• 1966
Samuel P. Massie Jr., a chemist, is the first ever Black professor at the US Naval Academy in Annapolis, Maryland
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
13
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Common Language Developing a shared meaning…
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
14
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Common Language "Culture” … pattern of human behavior of a social group (Cross et al, 1989)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
15
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Common Language "Competence” … capacity to function effectively (Cross et al, 1989)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
16
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Common Language "Cultural Competence” … work with others in meaningful, relevant, and productive ways (Pope, Reynolds, & Muller, 2004)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
17
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Awareness and Knowledge The Danger of a Single Story
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
18
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
The Danger of a Single Story Link to Video Link to Transcript
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
19
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Reflection Activity First thoughts…
What stood out to you from the TED Talk? • Take-a-ways • Notable quotes • A story/component that resonated with you MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
20
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Activity:
Think about‌ 1.
What single stories have been assigned to you?
2.
What single stories that you assign to others?
3.
How does this relate to developing cultural competence? MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
21
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Skill & Action Cycle of Socialization
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
22
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Cycle of Socialization
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
23
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Cycle of Socialization The The Beginning Beginning First Socialization
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
24
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Cycle of Socialization Institutional and Cultural Socialization
Enforcement
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
25
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Cycle of Socialization
Results
• Direction for •
Change Actions
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
26
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Activity 1.
Select at least one of your personal social identity.
2.
Write down at least 5 examples of what we learned about being / performing the selected identity.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
27
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Select References • • • • • •
Adams, M., Blumenfeld, W., Castaneda, C. Hackman, H. W., Peters, M. L., Zuniga, X. (2013). Readings for diversity and social justice. Routledge: New York, NY. Cross, T., Bazron, B., Dennis, K., & Isaacs, M., (1989). Towards A culturally competent system of care, Volume I. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Child Development Center, CASSP Technical Assistance Center. Cuyjet, M. J., Howard-Hamilton, M. F., & Cooper, D. L. (2011). Multiculturalism on campus – theories, models, and practices for understanding diversity and creating inclusion. Stylus. Sterling, VA. Harro, B. (2013). Cycle of socialization. In Adams, M., Blumenfeld, W. J., Castañeda, R., Hackman, H. W., Peters, M. L., & Zanita, X. (Eds.). Readings for diversity and social justice: An anthology on racism, antisemitism, sexism, heterosexism, ableism and classism (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge. Mueller, J. A., Pope, R. L. & Reynolds, A. L. (2004). Multicultural competence in student affairs. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco, CA. Mueller, J. A., Pope, R. L. & Reynolds, A. L. (2009). Looking back and forward: Future directions for diversity research in student affairs. Journal of College Student Development, 640-658.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
Module 2
Cultural Competency in Administration & Leadership
MindsetsForSTEM.org
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Twitter: @FLC_LSRCE © 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved.
Facebook: @FLCLSRCE
29
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Module 2 Overview
Readings
•
Outcomes
•
Faculty & Curriculum Reading
•
Administration & Leadership
•
Administrator Reading
•
Change Theory
•
Case Study 1
•
Case Study 2
•
Case Study
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
30
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Reflection Activity •
What stood out from the pre-reading?
•
Write and share thoughts, questions, and/or reactions to the material with a peer.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
31
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Module 2 - Goals and Outcomes •
Reflect on how culture and diversity influences our work,
•
Develop an understanding of cultural competency related to administration and leadership,
•
Explore strategies for developing these competencies.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
32
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
ADMINISTRATION & LEADERSHIP Framing the discussion…
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
33
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Administration and Leadership •
Competing cultures
•
Consider underline values
•
Assumptions and bias
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
34
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Administration and Leadership "promoting diversity and inclusion is no longer simply a question of answering our moral and social responsibility, but a matter of academic and institutional excellence.� (Williams, 2013)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
35
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE THEORY Individuals, groups, and institutions…
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
36
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Organizational Change Theory Multicultural Organization Development (MCOD) • Reflects & includes the members of diverse cultural and social groups as full participants • Acts & follows through on a commitment to eradicate social oppression (Pope, Reynolds, Muller 2004) MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
37
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Organizational Change Theory Figure 3: Continuum of Multicultural Organization Development
(Jackson and Hardiman, 1994) MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
38
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Organizational Change Theory 4 components - MCOD change process • • • •
Coalition building Readiness Assessment Change plan (Jackson, 2005) MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
39
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Organizational Change Theory
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
40
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Activity 1. Review your institutions’ or departmental mission statement. 2. Identify examples of 1st and 2nd order change you observe for one of the targets (individual, group, or institution)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
41
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Case Study Activity 1.
Select a case study to read.
2.
Discuss the case study and identify key issues.
3.
How would you assess each character within the theoretical models presented today?
4.
How might you intervene as a consultant in this situation? MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
42
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Select References • • • • • •
Adams, M., Blumenfeld, W., Castaneda, C. Hackman, H. W., Peters, M. L., Zuniga, X. (2013). Readings for diversity and social justice. Routledge: New York, NY. Cross, T., Bazron, B., Dennis, K., & Isaacs, M., (1989). Towards A culturally competent system of care, Volume I. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Child Development Center, CASSP Technical Assistance Center. Cuyjet, M. J., Howard-Hamilton, M. F., & Cooper, D. L. (2011). Multiculturalism on campus – theories, models, and practices for understanding diversity and creating inclusion. Stylus. Sterling, VA. Harro, B. (2013). Cycle of socialization. In Adams, M., Blumenfeld, W. J., Castañeda, R., Hackman, H. W., Peters, M. L., & Zanita, X. (Eds.). Readings for diversity and social justice: An anthology on racism, antisemitism, sexism, heterosexism, ableism and classism (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge. Mueller, J. A., Pope, R. L. & Reynolds, A. L. (2004). Multicultural competence in student affairs. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco, CA. Mueller, J. A., Pope, R. L. & Reynolds, A. L. (2009). Looking back and forward: Future directions for diversity research in student affairs. Journal of College Student Development, 640-658.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
Module 3 Cultural Competency in Training, Teaching & Assessment, Research
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
© 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved.
MindsetsForSTEM.org Twitter: @FLC_LSRCE 44 Facebook: @FLCLSRCE
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Module 3 Overview Readings •
Outcomes
•
The Cycle of Liberation
•
Training and teaching
•
•
Assessment and research
Towards a Theory of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy
•
Theory to Action Activity
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
45
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Module 3 - Goals and Outcomes •
Consider strategies for infusing cultural competency in training and teaching,
•
Expand our understanding of cultural competency related to assessment and research,
•
Reflect on highlights training and actionable develop next steps. MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
46
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Reflection •
What stood out from the readings?
•
Write and share thoughts, questions, and/or reactions to the material with a peer.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
47
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
FRAMING THE DISCUSSION
Training, teaching, assessment and research …
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
48
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Framing The Discussion “if all students believed it is important to contribute to the educational process, rather than merely accept and absorb the knowledge of others, then education has the potential to be a liberating force in their lives� (Pope et al., 2019) MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
49
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Framing The Discussion •
Listen and observe
•
Compare and contrast ideas
•
Engage in personal reflection
•
Explore personal identity
•
Empathize with others MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
(King, Perez, Shim, 2013) 50
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
TRAINING AND TEACHING
Creating positive conditions for learning
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
51
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Training and Teaching • Training: a way to improve performance of individuals or organizations. • Teaching: a process of exchanging information.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
52
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Training and teaching Methods for addressing diversity issues • • • • •
Recognize stereotypes or biases Respect students Change language that may offend Assess students’ comfort level with climate and tone Discuss diversity in departmental meetings MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
53
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Training and Teaching Reflection How have you addressed diversity issues in training and classroom settings?
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
54
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Dynamics of Diversity in Teaching-Learning Process • • • •
Knowing oneself Teaching methods Course content Knowing students
Multicultural Training Model • • • • •
Needs assessment Objectives Design Implementation Evaluation
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
55
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Key Factors for Multicultural Teaching • • • • •
Course content Student make-up Faculty make-up Intellectual tools Classroom dynamics
Multicultural Course Design Elements • Content (informed oriented)
• • • • •
Cognitive (worldview) Affective (emotions) Experiential (hands-on) Skills (development) Process (here and now)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
56
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Reflection •
Discuss the strategies provided.
•
How might you incorporate these into your training or teaching?
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
57
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
ASSESSMENT AND RESEARCH A culturally relevant design…
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
58
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Assessment and Research Assessment – evidence that describes effectiveness Research – uncovering new information Evaluation – determines merit, worth, or value
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
59
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Assessment and Research “… reframe the discussions by empirically demonstrating how diversity is essential to learning in higher education…” (Hurtado, 2005)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
60
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Assessment and Research Toward Cultural Awareness • • • •
Awareness of assumptions Defining population of interest Appropriateness of measurement Data collection (Pope et al., 2004)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
61
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Assessment and Research Cultural Variables
Aware of Assumptions • Own world view has implications for research process
• Collectivism v. Individualism • Communication style • Time orientation (Pope et al., 2004)
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
62
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Assessment and Research Time Orientation
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
63
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Theory to Action: Cultural Exposure Activity • • • • •
Select a marginalized group to engage Activity should take place on the focal group’s “turf” Activity should be a totally new experience Invest at least 5 hours Safely interact with people from the focal group
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
Florida-Caribbean Louis Stokes Regional Center of Excellence
Reflection Activity •
What is one highlight you have from this training series?
•
Set a goal a next steps goal related to something you learned from this training.
MindsetsForSTEM.org 2020 FL-C LSRCE All Rights Reserved
65
MindsetsForSTEM.org Twitter @FLC_LSRCE Facebook @FLCLSRCE
66