1
Speckle Park Breed Feature Pages 35-39
Vol 23 No 18 | May 12, 2025
View online at farmersweekly.co.nz
$4.95 Incl GST
Dairy slant to PM’s council vexes science NEWS
S
Research
CIENTISTS have raised concerns about the appointment of Dr John Roche as the prime minister’s chief science adviser, pointing to issues over Overseer transparency and Roche’s influence on earlier freshwater policy settings. They have also flagged the heavy focus on dairying in the PM’s newly formed Science and Technology Advisory Council, where Roche is also deputy chair.
I remain extremely concerned about the government’s commitment to true public-good ... science. Dr Lucy Stewart NZ Association of Scientists Other council members include Sir Peter Gluckman, John Key’s previous science adviser; Craig Piggott, the founder of Halter; Professor Merryn Tawhai from the University of Auckland; Fonterra’s chief innovation and brand officer Komal Mistry-Mehta; and Malcolm Johns, the CEO of Genesis Energy. As chief science adviser, Roche takes up a role that has been empty for almost a year, moving from his current position as the Ministry for Primary Industries’
chief science adviser. Before this he was DairyNZ’s principal animal scientist. New Zealand Association of Scientists co-president Troy Baisden said Roche was an excellent choice, given the government’s focus on reforms to achieve efficiency. “He has played intimate roles in a ministry with both significant internal science capability and funding of external science and innovation.” But he also raised concerns about Roche’s effectiveness on environmental issues. “He took on his MPI role just as a report from the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment and a follow-up report from an MPI advisory group raised deep concerns about the need for improved transparency or replacement of Overseer, the model most used to link farming practice to environmental outcomes. “The Overseer controversy has been effectively buried rather than solved.” He also questioned Roche’s role in helping develop freshwater policy. Baisden said this had become more regulation focused than protection focused, to the frustration of councils, farmers and environmentalists alike. Dr Lucy Stewart, also copresident of the NZ Association Continued page 3
Council ‘plug’ blamed for flooding Canterbury farmer Tom Power was left frustrated and critical of a lack of council action after parts of his property were underwater following a significant recent rain event. He had to launch a jet boat to check on the welfare of the farm’s sheep and cattle. Photo: Supplied
NEWS 7
Ag life can be a barrel of fun
S FOECT CU OR S
Richard Rennie
Tyla Toheriri is just as at home riding barrels at rodeos as she is on the drafting gate as a stock representative.
SHEEP & BEEF 18-21 The urban-rural gap may be Aussie election result set to all in the mind. sink live exports.
Family farms produce a nation, writes John Foley.
NEWS 3
OPINION 17
NEWS 4
Building Healthy Cows Help prevent milk fever, ketosis, and mastitis while setting your cows up for peak production for as little as $14 per cow with TranzSol™
www.sollus.co.nz | 0800 765 587
More info: