Classics of moral and political theory 5th edition, (ebook pdf) - Own the ebook now with all fully d

Page 1


ClassicsofMoralandPoliticalTheory5th Edition,(EbookPDF)

https://ebookmass.com/product/classics-of-moral-andpolitical-theory-5th-edition-ebook-pdf/

Instant digital products (PDF, ePub, MOBI) ready for you

Download now and discover formats that fit your needs...

(eTextbook PDF) for Doing Ethics: Moral Reasoning, Theory, and Contemporary Issues 5th Edition

https://ebookmass.com/product/etextbook-pdf-for-doing-ethics-moralreasoning-theory-and-contemporary-issues-5th-edition/

ebookmass.com

Morality and Moral Controversies: Readings in Moral, Social and Political Philosophy 9th Edition – Ebook PDF Version

https://ebookmass.com/product/morality-and-moral-controversiesreadings-in-moral-social-and-political-philosophy-9th-edition-ebookpdf-version/

ebookmass.com

(eBook PDF) Disputed Moral Issues: A Reader 5th Edition

https://ebookmass.com/product/ebook-pdf-disputed-moral-issues-areader-5th-edition/

ebookmass.com

(eTextbook PDF) for The Canadian North: Issues and Challenges 5th

https://ebookmass.com/product/etextbook-pdf-for-the-canadian-northissues-and-challenges-5th/

ebookmass.com

Dirty Secret Love (Heartwood Lake Secret Billionaires Book 2) Claudia Burgoa

https://ebookmass.com/product/dirty-secret-love-heartwood-lake-secretbillionaires-book-2-claudia-burgoa/

ebookmass.com

The Dynamics of Natural Satellites of the Planets Nikolay Emelyanov

https://ebookmass.com/product/the-dynamics-of-natural-satellites-ofthe-planets-nikolay-emelyanov/

ebookmass.com

Computational Methods for Nonlinear Dynamical Systems: Theory and Applications in Aerospace Engineering Xuechuan Wang

https://ebookmass.com/product/computational-methods-for-nonlineardynamical-systems-theory-and-applications-in-aerospace-engineeringxuechuan-wang/ ebookmass.com

Loose Leaf for Cost Management: A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Paul Juras

https://ebookmass.com/product/loose-leaf-for-cost-management-astrategic-emphasis-8th-edition-paul-juras/

ebookmass.com

A Secret Baby for the Bratva: Forced Marriage Mafia Romance (Zolotov Bratva Book 2) Isla Brooks

https://ebookmass.com/product/a-secret-baby-for-the-bratva-forcedmarriage-mafia-romance-zolotov-bratva-book-2-isla-brooks/

ebookmass.com

and Ideology Mario Pomini

https://ebookmass.com/product/luigi-amoroso-the-building-of-economicsbetween-science-and-ideology-mario-pomini/

ebookmass.com

CLASSICS OF MORAL AND POLITICAL THEORY

FIFTH

INTRODUCTION

Wehavecalledthisanthology ClassicsofMoralandPoliticalTheory inordertosuggestbyitstitlesomeof thevolume’simportantfeatures.First,itcontainswritingswithacertaincontent.Someofthetextsareabout moralorethicaltheoryinthebroadsensethatincludesreflectiononthenatureofmoralityanddiscussion ofthecontentofthemorallife,itsprinciplesandideals,itscharacteristicvirtuesandvices.Otherworksdeal withpoliticalmatters,alsoinabroadway,oftentreatingtherelationshipsamongpolitical,legal,religious, philosophical,moral,andpsychologicalissues,discussingthenatureofpoliticalinstitutions,politicalpractice, andmuchelse.Someoftheseworks,then,areclassicmoraltexts;someareclassicpoliticaltexts;someare both.All,however,andthisismysecondpoint,areclassics.

Whatisaclassic?Surelythereisnoshortandsimpleanswertothisquestion.Butperhapsthismuchwill do:Aclassictextisonethatreverberateswithinoneormoretraditions.Itisatextthatarticulatespowerfully influentialviews,positions,orconceptions;thatexhibitsinaparadigmaticwaymodels,motifs,orarguments; andthatisrecalled,cited,andexhibitedinsubsequentdiscussion,inquiry,anddebate.Aclassic,inshort,is aworkthatmakesanimportantdifferenceoratleast,fromaparticularvantagepoint,isthoughttohavemade andtocontinuetomakesuchadifference.

Notalltextsofcourseareclassics.Butwhileothersmaybeinterestingorvaluableorhelpful,onlyclassic textsaresomehownecessary,bothforunderstandingatraditionandforparticipatinginoneaswellasfor callingatraditionintoquestionandseekingtodeconstructorsubvertit.Tosaysomethingsignificantand importantwithinoragainstatraditionofdiscourse,onemust,tosomedegreeorother,callupontheresources thatconstitutethattradition,andclassictextsarethechiefwrittenrepositoriesoftheseresources—ofthe tradition’sterms,itsalternativeviews,itsexamples,formulations,arguments,andindeedallthatmakeupits toolsfordiscussionanddebate.Inthissense,thewritingscollectedinthisanthologyareclassics,not the classics,tobesure—fortherearemanyothers,andtheverystatusofbeingaclassicchangesinthecourse ofhistory—but someoftheclassics oftheseveraltraditionsofreflectionaboutmoralandpoliticalmattersin theWest,fromGreekantiquitytothelatenineteenthcentury.

Theseclassics,moreover,areofalimitedkind.Theyareallworkswrittenbymen,largelyformen;their conceptionsofhumannature,thegoodlife,politicalvirtues,andsoonexhibitagenderbias.Furthermore, theyareWestern,Europeanclassicsthatarefeaturedincertaintraditionsofdiscussionanddebatebutshould becomparedandcontrastedwithothertypes—non-Westernclassics,classicsbynonwhites,bywomen,by NativeAmericans,bynon-Christianauthors,andmore.Formanyreasons,excludingsuchalternativeclassics isunfortunate,butithasbeenunavoidableandpurposeful.Whatthisvolumecontainsisnotasampleof everything;itis,rather,aselectionthatcanserveasacommonresourcebothforthosewhoseektounderstand andcontinuetheWesterntraditionsofdebateandforthosewhoseektoexaminethesetraditionscritically and,intheend,toopposethem.

Eachoneoftheseclassictexts,moreover,meansandhasmeantmanythings.Eachworkmeantsomething, surelymanythings,whenitwaswrittenandpublishedandinitiallyread.Eachcametomeanmuchelseas itwasreread,cited,recalled,andreinterpretedintheyearsanddecadesthereafter.Andeachtextnowmeans manythingstoitsmanycurrentreaders,usamongthem,asitisreadagainandinterpretedinthecontextof today’sdebates,issues,andevents.Differentreaderswillapproachtheseworksfordifferentreasonsandwith differentinterestsandpresuppositions.Inaway,then,eachofthesetextsisnotonetextbutmany,avastplurality.

Theseissueshaveguidedtheconstructionofthisanthology.Fromamuchlargerlistofclassictextsof moralandpoliticalthoughtwecarvedthecurrenttableofcontents,tryinginsofarasitwaspossibletoinclude manyofthemostinfluentialandsignificantclassicsthatarecurrentlytaughtandstudied.Moreover,where wecould,wechosetoincludeentireworksoratleastverysizeablechunks.Themoreweexcerpt,themore welimitthereader’sperspectiveandoptionsandhencethemorewecooptthereader’sroleasinterpreter andcritic.Wedidnotwanttodothateithertoyou,theteacher,ortoyou,thestudent.Finally,theintroductions toeachauthorarenotintendedasfull-scaleinterpretationsoftheworks;rathertheyaimtohelpthestudent bysituatingtheauthorandtheworkhistoricallyandbysayingsomegeneralthingsabouttheauthor’swork andthought.Intheend,thesestrategiesallserveasinglegoal:toprovideausefulandconvenientresource forthecriticalstudyofmoralandpoliticalthinkingintheWesternhistoricaltraditions.

Inmanywaysthisworkisanempiricalenterprise.Itdoesnothopetoshapeatraditionsomuchasto respondtoandexpressfeaturesofseveral.Forthisreason,asyearsgobyandasinterestschange,itmaybe advisable,ifnotnecessary,toalteritscontents—toadd,delete,andreplacetheseclassicswithothers.Your guidanceinthisprocesswillbeinvaluable,andweinviteit.Insuchaway,thisanthology,whichhasthus farbeenacooperativeenterprise,willcontinuetobeone,inacontinuallyusefulandsignificantway.

Preface to the Fifth Edition

The Fifth Edition of Classics of Moral and Political Theory offers four major new features. First, an augmentation of the unit on Aquinas—most significantly, by the inclusion of a selection from Aquinas’ Disputed Questions on Virtue from the splendid new translation by Jeffrey Hause and Claudia Eisen Murphy (Hackett, 2010). In addition, selections on law from the Summa Theologica, in Richard Regan’s translation, have been expanded. Together the selections from these two works offer a far better picture than have previous editions of Aquinas’ ethical and political theory, a body of work that has sparked renewed interest in recent years.

Second and third are the additions of two milestones of Western political theory: Locke’s Letter Concerning Toleration and, from Ted Humphrey’s 2003 edition, Kant’s To Perpetual Peace

Fourth is the addition of Peter Preuss’ translation of Nietzsche’s On the Advantage and Disadvantage of History for Life, an early work that touches on many themes of Nietzsche’s work as a whole.

In addition, selections from Aristotle’s Politics have been expanded.

As in previous editions, unbracketed footnotes are an author’s own. Bracketed footnotes have been contributed by an editor or translator. Initialed bracketed footnotes signify the first in a series of notes by a given editor or translator.

PREFACETOTHE FIRSTEDITION

Inthefallof1990JayHullettapproachedmewithaproposalforamajoranthologyofclassictextsinthe Westerntraditionsofmoralandpoliticaltheory.Ateverystage,thishasbeenacollegialandcooperativeeffort. Jayhassupervisedourworkwithsensitivityandwisdom;BrianRakhasbeenathoughtfulandmeticulous editor.DanKirklinhasguidedtheproductionprocesswithtremendousattentiontodetail,constantencouragement,andagreatunderstandingofourgoals.

InmakingmyeditorialselectionsIwasaidedbyanumberoffriendsandcolleagues—JeffIsaac,Paul Eisenberg,MiltonFisk—butespeciallybyBrianRak,withhiskeensenseforwhatisusedandwhatisuseful intheteachingofethicsandpoliticaltheory.InpreparingtheintroductionsIbenefitedfromavastamount ofbiographical,historical,andphilosophicalwork.JimTullyreadalltheintroductionsandmadecopious recommendations,virtuallyallofwhichIacceptedandwhichdirectedmetoavoidinfelicitiesandinaccuracies. GillianParkerreadtextandproofsaswetriedtomaketheresultasaccurateaspossible,andMarkRooksof InteLexprovidedmanytextsondiskandscannedothers,inordertofacilitatethepublicationprocess.Audrey, Debbie,Sara,andourtwocats,BlazeandAmanda,enduredagooddeallessattentionthantheydeserved, sympathizingasIworriedaboutdeadlinesandprovidingencouragementanddistractionasneeded.

SOPHOCLES

Poetry,drama,andfictionexpressthemoralandpoliticaldimensionsofourlivesthatphilosophyattemptsto examineandanalyze.Indeed,giventhecharacterandcomplexityofmoralandpoliticallife,literatureoften isthebestavenuewehavetoitsdisclosure.Greektragedyisaclassiccaseofsuchdisclosure.Thereare featuresofGreekethicsandGreekthinkinginthefifthcentury b.c.e. thatareknowntousbestfromthe writingsofAeschylus,Sophocles,andEuripides.

Thefifthcenturywasatoweringperiod.TheGreekworldexperiencedthePersianWars,theriseofthe AthenianEmpire,thewarbetweenSpartaandAthens,theflourishingofPericleanAthensastheapexof democracyanditsculturalcenter,andthefallofAthensandtheemergenceofSpartaasthepreeminent Greek polis.ItexperiencedtoothedevelopmentofhistoricalwritingintheworkofHerodotusandThucydides, theriseoftheitinerantteacherscalledsophists,theepitomeofpre-Socraticnaturalphilosophy,andthebirth ofoldcomedy.AndthefifthcenturywasthecenturyofSocratesandofthetragedians,amongthemthe authorofthe Antigone,Sophocles.

Bornin496 b.c.e.,Sophoclesdiedin406,justpriortothefallofAthens.Hecomposedover120plays;it hasbeencalculatedthatabout96ofthemwonthefirstprizeatthefestivalofDionysuswheretragediesand satyrplayswereperformed.Hisfirstvictorywasin468;the Antigone wasfirstperformedin441.Ofthiscorpus, justsevenplayssurvive.

Sophocles’stragediesaremarkedbylarger-than-lifefigureswho,whenconfrontedwithmomentousdecisions andfacedwiththeforcesoffateand dike (justice),becomevictimsofthecomplexityofsuchforces.Inthe Antigone bothCreonandAntigonefacesuchasituation.Fromantiquitytoourownday,readershavepuzzled overwhothecentralplayerisandwhatSophoclesseekstoshowusabouthowhumanbeingsrespondtothe forcesoffateandjusticethatgoverntheuniverseandtheaffairsofhumankind.Readersfindwithinthe Antigone multipletensions—betweentheindividualandthestate,betweenfamilialobligationsanddutyto the polis,betweendivinecommandandpositivelaw,betweenyouthfulself-sacrificeandadultdomination, andmore.Whetherthedramadoesinfactdisplaypreciselytheseconflictsoroneslikethemthereadermust makeoutforherself.WhatisclearisthatAntigone’schoice,whenfacedwithherbrothers’deathsandthe edictofCreon,heruncle,setsinmotionachainofactionsthatultimatelyleaveCreondamagedandin despair.Fromoneperspective,whileitisAntigonewhofirstconfrontsthepulloffamilialdevotionandrespect undertheabidinglawsofthegods,ontheonehand,andtheprohibitionutteredbyCreonasking,onthe other,ultimatelyitisCreonwhoseconvictionsareshowntoparentconflictanddisaster.Thereisnoeasy waytosubordinatefamilyloyaltytotheallegianceandcommitmenttothestate.Thereisnoescapingfate, nowayofcultivatingwithoutfaultthemanymodesof philia (friendship,mutuality,loyalty).

ModerndiscussionofthedramafallsundertheheavyburdenofHegel’sfamousreading,inwhichsuch dichotomies,oppositions,anddialecticalreversalstakeprideofplace.Butsomeinterpreterssuggestthatthe playismoresubtlethanthat.Everyopposition,likethosebetweenthefamilyandthestate,youthandage, theindividualandsociety,isqualifiedinthecarefulspeechesthatSophoclescreates.Itisnotaseasyasone mightinitiallythinktoeulogizeAntigoneforherstrengthofcharacterandconvictionortodenigrateIsmene forherweakness,todemonizeCreonortoheroizeHaemon.Sophocles’portrayaloftheindividualismore complex;whatwecallmoralobligationsandpoliticalresponsibilitiesarelesseasytoseparatethanwetend tothink.ThelivesthatSocrates,Plato,andAristotlesubjecttoexaminationandanalysisrealizeinSophocles acomplexitythatweshouldkeepinmind.

RecommendedReadings

Benardete,Seth. SacredTransgressions:AReadingofSophocles’Antigone.SouthBend,Ind.:St.Augustine Press,1999.

Bowra,C.M. SophocleanTragedy.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,1944. Goldhill,Simon. ReadingGreekTragedy.Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,1986.

Kitto,H.D.G. GreekTragedy.London:MethuenandCompany,1970.

Knox,Bernard. TheHeroicTemper:StudiesinSophocleanTragedy.Berkeley:UniversityofCalifornian Press,1964.

Lloyd-Jones,H. TheJusticeofZeus.Berkeley:UniversityofCaliforniaPress,1971.

Reinhardt,K. Sophocles.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,1979.

Segal,C.P. TragedyandCivilization:AnInterpretationofSophocles. Cambridge:CambridgeUniversity Press,1981.

Steiner,George. Antigone.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,1984.

Winnington-Ingram,R.P. Sophocles:AnInterpretation.Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,1980.

[[link is on line number]]

ANTIGONE

CastofCharacters

Antigone:

Ismene,dearheart,mytruesister: YouandIareleftalivetopay

Antigone daughterandhalf-sisterof ThefinalpenaltytoZeusforOedipus. Oedipus I’veneverseensuchmiseryandmadness—

Ismene Antigone’ssister

5 It’smonstrous!Suchdeepshameanddishonor—

Chorus thecouncilofeldersinThebes Asthis,whichfallsuponthepairofus.

ChorusLeader haslinesinconversations Andnow,apublicannouncement!

Creon Antigone’suncleonher Theysaythegeneralhasplastereditaroundthe mother’sside city.

Watchman oneofthosesettoguardthe Haveyouheardthisterriblenewsornot? corpse

10 Ourenemiesareonthemarchtohurtour

Tiresias prophetofApollo friends.

Haemon Creon’sson,Antigone’sfiance ´

Ismene: Messenger aservantofCreon’s

No,Antigone,Ihavehadnonewsoffriends, Eurydice Creon’swife,Haemon’smother Nothingsweetorpainful,sincetheday Welostourbrothers,bothofus,ononeday,

NonspeakingRoles

Bothbrothersdeadbytheirtwohands.

15 LastnightthearmythatcamefromArgos

Attendants ofCreon Disappeared,andafterthatIdon’tknow Attendants ofAntigone(whenunderarrest) Anythingthatcouldbringmehappiness—or Servants ofEurydice despair.

Boy whoguidesTiresias

Antigone: Iknewit!That’sthewholereason Scene Ibroughtyououtside—tohearthenewsalone.

TheroyalhouseatThebes,frontingontoaraised

Ismene:

20 Tellme.You’reasclearasafogatsea. platformstage.Wingentrancesrightandleft allowforcharacterstobeseenbytheaudience Antigone: andthechoruslongbeforetheyareseenbythe It’stheburialofourtwobrothers.Creon maincharacters.Thegreatdoorsofthehouse Promotesoneofthemandshamestheother. standupstagecenter.

[5: LinenumbersrefertotheGreektext.] [EnterAntigoneleadingIsmenethroughthe [14–15: Thetwobrothers,Eteocle ˆ sandPolyneices,had greatdoorsthatleadfromthepalace.] plannedtotaketurnsrulingThebes;butEteocle ˆ srefused togivePolyneiceshistimeonthethrone.Anarmycame fromArgosinsupportofPolyneices’claimandwasde-

FromSophocles, Antigone, translatedbyPaulWoodruff (Indianapolis:HackettPublishingCompany,2001).featedatthesevengatesofthecity.Thetwobrotherskilled eachother.Argos,inthenortheastcornerofPelopon- Copyright  2001.Reprintedbypermissionofthe publisher. nesus,wasseenasanenemyofThebes.—P.W.]

Eteocle ˆ s—IheardCreoncoveredhimbeneath

Ismene: Ohno!Thinkcarefully,mysister. Theearthwithproperrites,aslawordains, 25 Sohehashonordownamongthedead.

50 Ourfatherdiedinhatredanddisgrace Aftergougingouthisowntwoeyes

ButPolyneices’miserablecorpse— TheysayCreonhasproclaimedtoeveryone:Forsinshe’dseeninhisownself. Next,hismotherandwife—shewasboth— “NoBurialofanykind.Nowailing,nopublic tears. Destroyedherselfinaknottedrope.

Givehimtothevultures,unwept,unburied, 30 TobeasweettreasurefortheirsharpeyesandKilledeachotherinaterriblecalamity, Whichtheyhadcreatedforeachother. beaks.”

55 And,third,ourtwobrothersononeday

That’swhattheysaythegoodCreonhas Nowthinkaboutthetwoofus.Wearealone. Howhorribleitwillbetodieoutsidethelaw, proclaimed Toyou.Andme.Heforbidsme,too.

60 Ifweviolateadictator’sdecree! No.Wehavetokeepthisfactinmind: Andnowhe’sstruttingheretomakeitplain Tothosewhohaven’theard—hetakes Wearewomenandwedonotfightwithmen. We’resubjecttothembecausethey’restronger,

35 Thisseriously—thatifanyonedoeswhathe forbids Andwemustobeythisorder,evenifithurtsus more. He’llhavehimpubliclystonedtodeath. There’syournews.Now,showyourcolors:

65 Asforme,Iwillsaytothosebeneaththeearth Thisprayer:“Forgiveme,Iamheldbackby Areyoutruetoyourbirth?Oracoward? force.”

Ismene: AndI’llobeythemenincharge.Mymind Youtakethingshard.Ifweareinthisnoose, Willneveraimtoohigh,toofar.

40 WhatcouldIdotoloosenorpulltighttheknot?

Antigone: Ifyousharetheworkandtrouble...

Antigone: Iwon’tpressyouanyfurther.Iwouldn’tevenlet

70 Youhelpmeifyouhadachangeofheart. Goonand be thewayyouchoosetobe.I

Ismene: Willburyhim.Iwillhaveanobledeath Inwhatdangerousadventure? Andliewithhim,adearsisterwithadear brother.

Antigone:

Callitacrimeofreverence,butImustbegood Ifyouhelpthishandraisethecorpse... tothose [Indicatingherownhand.]

Ismene:

75 Whoarebelow.Iwillbetherelongerthanwith you.

That’swhereIwilllie.You,keeptoyourchoice: Doyoumeantoburyhim?Againstthecity’s Gooninsultingwhatthegodsholddear. ordinance?

Ismene:

Antigone: Iamnotinsultinganyone.Bymyverynature

45 Butheismine.Andyours.Likeitornot,he’s Icannotpossiblytakearmsagainstthecity. ourbrother.

They’llnevercatchmebetrayinghim.

Antigone:

80 Goon,makeexcuses.Iamonmyway. Ismene: I’llheaptheearthuponmydearestbrother’s Howhorrible!WhenCreonforbidsit? grave.

Ismene:

Antigone: Hehasnorighttokeepmefrommyown. Ohno!Thisishorribleforyou.Iamsoworried!

Antigone: ShinegloryneverseenbeforeinThebes, OurCityofSevenGates. Don’tworryaboutme.Putyourownlifestraight. Obrighteyeofgoldenday!

Ismene:

105 YoucamestridingoverRiverDirke ˆ , Pleasedon’ttellasoulwhatyouaredoing. AndtheWhiteShieldofArgosranaway.

85 Keepithidden.I’lldothesame. Hehasfled,

Antigone: Manandweaponracingfromyourlight, Forgod’ssake,speakout.You’llbemoreenemy Onsharpenedspur. tome

Ifyouaresilent.Proclaimittotheworld!

110 Hewasrousedagainstourland

Ismene: ForafightthatPolyneices,haggling,picked. Yourheart’ssohottodothischillingthing! And,likeascreamingeagle, Hedroppedonourland:

Antigone: Theshadowofhiswhite-snowwing— Butitpleasesthosewhomattermost.

115 Amultitudeofarmoredmen, Ismene: Helmetscrestedwithhorsehair.

90 Yes,ifyouhadthepower.Butyoulovethe impossible.

Antigone:

[Antistrophe a]

Hestoopedoverourhomes, So?Whenmystrengthisgone,I’llstop. Mouthgapingwideforthekill, Ismene: HeengulfedourSevenGateswithspearsof Butit’sthehighestwrongtochaseafterwhat’s death; impossible.

120 Buthehasgone,

Antigone: Gonebeforeplunginghisbeakinourblood, Whenyousaythis,yousetyourselfagainstme. Gonebeforetorchingourcrownoftowers Yourbrotherwilltakeyoutohim—ashisenemy. WiththeflamesofHephaestus.

95 Soyoujustletmeandmy‘badjudgment’ Forbehindhisbacktherearosetooloud Gotohell.Nothingcouldhappentome

125 Theclamorofwar; Sobadthatitwouldcloudmynobledeath. Hisdragon-foewastoostrongforhim.

[ExitAntigonetowardtheplain,throughthe Zeushatesanarrogantboast, stageleftwing.] Withtoweringhatred.

Ismene: Hesawtheriverofmenattack, Thenfollowyourjudgment,go.You’velostyour

130 Theirgoldenarmorclashingincontempt, mind, Andsohestruckthemandownwithamissileof Butyouareholdingtotheloveofyourloved fire ones. Asheswoopedtowardhishighestgoal, [ExitIsmenethroughthegreatdoorsintothe Eagertoshout“Victory!” palace,asthechorusenterfromthecity,stage rightwing.]

[105: Dirke ˆ isoneoftheriversofThebes.]

Chorus:

[Strophe a]

[126: “Dragon-foe”— ThepeopleofThebesbelieved thattheyweredescendedfrommenwhogrewfromthe Parodos(Entry-song) teethofadragonslainbyCadmus.]

[131 – 40: Theselinesrefertotheattackerwhoboasts

100 LetuspraisetheSun: toomuch;accordingtothelegend,thiswasanArgive namedKapaneus.] Thesebrilliantbeams

[Strophe b]

ForLaius’powerwhenheheldthethrone, AndthesameagainforOedipus,whenhe Hecrashedtotheground rescuedThebes.

135 Likeaweightslungdowninanarcoffire, AfterhediedIknowyoustoodbytheirsons; Thismanwhohadswoopedlikeadancerin Youwerealwaystherewithgoodadvice. ecstasy,

170 Nowtheyaredead,bothononeday; Breathinghurricanesofhatred. Eachstabbedtheotherandwasstabbed. Buthisthreatscametonothing: Brotherstruckbrother,andtheblowswere Themightywargod,fightingbesideus, cursed. 140 Sweptthemaside.

Sevencaptainsatsevengates, aremine, Matchedwithsevendefenders, BecauseIamclosestkintothosewhodied. AlllefttrophiesforZeustheprotector (Theytookofftheirarmorandran).

SonowthethroneandallthepowerinThebes

145 Exceptforasavagepair,fullbrothers: Theirtwospearsstandupright,conquering, Incharacterorjudgment,tillherulesandmakes law; Eachintheother’sdeadbreast. Onlythencanhebetestedinthepubliceye. Ibelievethatifanyonetriestorunacity

175 Nomanhasamindthatcanbefullyknown,

[Antistrophe b] Onthebasisofbadpoliciesandholdshistongue NowVictoryisours,

180 Becausehe’safraidtosaywhatisright, Greatbehername!NowThebesrejoices. Thatmanisterrible.SoIhavealwaysthought.

150 Thereforeletusforgetourpain. Butit’sevenworsewhenheplaysfavorites, Thewarisover:letusdanceallnight, Putsfamilyorfriendsaheadoffatherland. Fillallthesacredprecinctswithjoy: Asforme—Icalltowitnessall-seeingZeus— WemustnowberuledbyBacchus, 185 IwillneverholdmytongueaboutwhatIsee Dance-masterofThebes. Whenruinisafootorthecityisnotsafe. Iwillnevercallamanmyfriend [EnterCreonthroughthegreatdoors.] Ifheishostiletothisland.Iknowthiswell: Thecityisourlifeboat:wehavenofriendsatall

Chorus:

155 Hereisthekingofourland

190 Unlesswekeephersailingrightsideup. Sucharemylaws.BythemI’llraisethiscity Creon,thesonofMenoeceus, Ournewrulergivenusbychanceandthegods.high. Whatplanhashebeenchurningoveronhis way?

AndIhavejustannouncedatwinsisterofthose Whyhashesummonedus— laws, 160 Thecouncilofelders— Toallthecitizens,concerningOedipus’sons: Bypublicannouncement? Eteocle ˆ sfoughtforthecity,andforithedied, 195 Aftereveryfeatofheroismwithhisspear.

Creon: Heshallbesanctifiedbyeveryburialrite Gentlemen,thecityissafeagain,wemaythank Thatisgiventothemostheroicdeadbelow. thegods: Afteragreatupheaval,theyhaverescuedThebes. YouareherebecauseIchoseyoufromthewholeAsforhisbloodbrother,Polyneicesbyname, Hebrokehisexile,hecamebackhungryforour crowd

165 Andsummonedyoubyescort.Youalwaysshowedblood,

200 Hewantedtoburnhisfatherlandandfamilygods respect

Downfromthetop.Hewantedtoleadhis

225 IhaltedmanytimesalongtheroadsoIcould think, people— Intoslavery.Thismanwillhavenograve:

AndIalmostturnedaroundandmarchedright back. Itisforbiddentoofferanyfuneralrites; NooneinThebesmayburyhimormournforMy mindkepttalkingtome.Itsaid, “Youpoorguy, Whyareyougoingthere?You’lljustgetyourass him.

205 Hemustbeleftunburied.Maybirdsanddogskicked.” Thenitsaid,“Areyoustoppingagain,youdamn Feedonhislimbs,aspectacleofuttershame. fool?

Suchisthecharacterofmymind:Never,whileI youhell.” rule, Well,Iturnedthisideaupanddownlikethat, Willacriminalbehonoredhigherthanamanof AndIhurriedalong,realslow.Madeashorttrip justice. long.

230 IfCreonhearsthisfromanotherman,he’llgive

Butgivemeatruefriendofthiscity

210 AndIwillpayhimfullhonor,indeathorlife. Itdoesn’tamounttomuch,butImightaswell

Whatgotmehereintheendwasthis:Myreport.

Chorus: giveit, Thatisyourdecision,sonofMenoeceus,

235 BecauseIwon’tletgothishandfulofhope Astotheonewhomeantourcitywell Thatthingswon’tbeanyworsethantheyhaveto Andtheonewhomeantitill.It’suptoyou: be. Makeanylawyouwant—forthedead,orforus

Creon: wholive. Whatisit,man—where’syourcourage?

Creon:

215 Now,lookaftermycommands.Iinsist.

Watchman:

First,IwanttotellyouwhereIstand:

Chorus: Ididn’tdothisthing,andIdon’tknowwhodid, Asksomeoneyoungertotakeupthetask.

240 Anditwouldn’tbefairifIgothurt.

Creon:

Creon: No,no.Ihavemenalreadywatchingthecorpse. Allright,yourdefenseperimeterisup. Now,let’shaveyourreport.

Chorus: Thenwhat’sleftforustodo?Whatareyour

Watchman: orders? It’sterriblenews.Ican’tcomerightoutwiththat.

Creon:

Creon: Thatyoudonotsidewithanyonewhodisobeys. Speakup!Andthengetlost.

Chorus:

Watchman: 220 Nooneisfoolishenoughtoaskfordeath. 245 OK,hereitis.Thebodyoutthere—someone buriedit

Creon: Justnowandwentaway.Theyspreadthirstydust Right.Thatwouldbetheirreward.Buthope— Allovertheskinanddidtheceremonyinfull. Andbribery—oftenhaveledmentodestruction.

Creon:

[EnterWatchmanfromthestageleftwing.] What?Nomanwoulddare!Whodidit?

Watchman:

Watchman: Sir,Iamhere.Ican’tsayIamoutofbreath.Idon’tknow.Thegroundwassohardanddry. 250 Itshowednomarks.Nospadescratches, Ihavenotexactlybeen“runningonlightfeet.”

Nopickaxeholes,notevenchariotruts.

It’stotallyunacceptable,whatyousaidaboutthe gods— Theperpetratorhadnotleftasingleclue.

Whenthefirstday-watchmanshowedittous,Thattheycouldhaveacaringthoughtforthis man’scorpse. Wewereallamazed.Itwasincredible:

255 Theguyhadvanished.Therewasnotomb,

Youthinktheyburiedhimforhisgooddeeds?

Onlyfinedustlyingoverthebody,enoughto take withfire

Togivehimhighesthonor?Theyknowhecame

Thecurseaway.Nosignofwildanimals, Nodogssniffingortuggingatthecorpse. land,

Toburndowntheirfine-columnedshrines,their

Theirstoreoftreasure—andtoblowtheirlaws away.

285

Weburstoutshoutingateachother;

260 Everyonewashurlingaccusations. gods?

Haveyoueverseenacriminalhonoredbythe

Wekeptcomingtoblows,noonetostopus. Notpossible. Anyoneofuscouldhavedonethething.

Butsome men herehavealwayschamped, Noonecaughtred-handed,everyonepled

290 Likesurf,againstmyorders,andobeyedme,ifat ignorance. all,

Wewereabouttotesteachotherwithred-hot

Withoutcheer.TheyshaketheirheadswhenI’m iron notlooking,

265 Orrunourhandsthroughfireandswearbyall

Pulloutoftheyokeofjustice,andarenot thegods: contentwithme.

“Ididn’tdoit,andIhadnopartinanyplot Theyaretheones,I’mabsolutelysure,whoused Todoit,notwithanyoneelse,notbyhandor bribes word.”

Toleadourwatchmenastray,intothiscrime. Well,weweren’tgettinganywhere,andinthe end

Someonetoldustodoathingwecouldn’tsee

Moneyisthenastiestweedevertosprout how Inhumansoil.Moneywillravageacity,

270 Torefuse or accept.Sowedroppedheads,stared Tearmenfromtheirhomesandsendtheminto attheground exile.

295

Infear.Therewasnowayitwouldturnoutgood Moneyteachesgoodmindstogobad; forus. Itisthesourceofeveryshamefulhumandeed. Wesimplyhadtobringwordtoyou, 300 Moneypointsthewaytowickedness, Becausewecouldnothideathinglikethis. Letspeopleknowthefullrangeofirreverence. Wevotedtodoit,andIamsodamnedunlucky Butthosewhocommittedthiscrimeforhire

275 Iwonthelotterytohavethislovelyjob. Havesetthemselvesapenalty,which,intime, Ididn’twanttocome.Andyousuredidn’twant they’llpay. toseeme:

Noonelovesthemanwhobringsbadnews.

Chorus: [ToCreon.]

[TotheWatchman.]

Youknow,sir,assoonasIheard,itcametome: Nowlistenhere.SolongasIamreverenttoZeus Somehowthegodsarebehindthispieceofwork.

Creon: [Tothechorusleader.]

305 Iamunderoath,andyoucanbeabsolutelysure Thatifyoudon’tfindthehandbehindthisburial

280 Stoprightthere,beforeI’mgorgedwithrage!AndbringhimsoIcanseehimwithmyown eyes, Youwanttoprovethatyou’reasstupidasyouare old? Deathalonewillnotbegoodenoughforyou—

NottillI’vestretchedyouwithropesandyou [Creonturnsandexitsthroughthegreatdoors tothepalace.] confess

310 Tothisoutrageouscrime.Thatwillteachyou

Watchman: Wheretolooktomakeaprofit.Andyouwill We’llfindhim.You’dbetterbelieveit. learn: Butifwedon’t—youknow,ifhegetslucky— Neveracceptmoneyfromjustanyonewhocomes Nowayyou’lleverseemecomingbacktoyou. along.

Watchman:

330 Asitis,thishasgonebetterthanIexpected— Thosewhotakefromasourcethatiswicked, I’mstillalive,thanksbetothegods. you’llsee, Areruinedfarmoreoftenthansaved. [ExitWatchmantowardtheplain,throughthe stageleftwing.]

315 Permissiontospeak,sir?Oraboutfaceandgo?

Creon:

Chorus: Don’tyouseehowbadlyyourreportannoyed me?

[Strophe a]

FirstStasimon

Watchman:

Manywonders,manyterrors, Sowhere’sitbitingyou?Onyourearsorinyour Butnonemorewonderfulthanthehumanrace mind? Ormoredangerous.

Creon:

335 Thiscreaturetravelsonawintergale What’sittoyou?Whyshouldyouanalyzemy Acrossthesilversea, pain? Shadowedbyhigh-surgingwaves, WhileonEarth,grandestofthegods,

Watchman: Hegrindsthedeathless,tirelesslandaway, Ifithurtsyourmind,blametheperpetrator.

340 Turningandturningtheplow Ifit’sonlyyourears,blameme. Fromyeartoyear,behinddrivenhorses.

Creon:

320 Damnit,man,willyouneverstopbabbling?

[Antistrophe a]

Light-headedbirdshecatches

Watchman: Andtakesthemawayinlegions.Wildbeasts Well,atleastIneverdidthething. Alsofallpreytohim.

Creon: Isthrashinginhiswovennets. Yes,youdid.Andformoney!Yougaveupyour ForheisMan,andheiscunning. life! Hehasinventedwaystotakecontrol

345 Andallthatisborntolivebeneaththesea

Watchman: Ofbeaststhatrangemountainmeadows: Ohno,no,no.

350 Takendowntheshaggy-neckedhorses, It’sterriblewhenfalsejudgmentguidesthejudge. Thetirelessmountainbulls, Andputthemundertheyoke.

Creon:

Allright,playwiththeword‘judgment.’But [Strophe b] you’dbettercatch

325 ThemanwhodidthisthingorI’llhaveproof:Languageandamindswiftasthewind

355 Formakingplans— Youmenruinedyourmiserablelivestomakea profit! Thesehehastaughthimself—

Andthecharactertoliveincitiesunderlaw. Creon: What’sallthis?LuckyIturnedupnow. He’slearnedtotakecoverfromafrost Andescapesharparrowsofsleet.

Watchman:

360 Hehasthemeanstohandleeveryneed, Sir,there’snopointswearingoathsifyou’rea Neverstepstowardthefuturewithoutthemeans. mortal. ExceptforDeath:He’sgothimselfnorelieffrom Secondthoughtsmakeanyplanlookbad. that,

390 IsworeI’dnevercometoyouagain Thoughheputseverymindtoseekingcures Becausethosethreatsofyoursgavemethe Forplaguesthatarehopeless. shakes. Butyouknow:“Joybeyondhope [Antistrophe b] Surpasseseveryotherpleasure.” I’vecome,thoughIsworeonoathIwouldn’t.

365 Hehascunningcontrivance,

395 AndI’vebroughtthisgirl,arrestedheratthe Skillsurpassinghope, grave Andsoheslithersintowickednesssometimes, Whenshewastidyingitup.Nolotterythistime. Othertimesintodoinggood. Thewindfall’smineandnooneelse’s. Ifhehonorsthelawoftheland Nowit’suptoyou.Takeher,questionher,

370 Andtheoath-boundjusticeofthegods, Makeyourjudgment.Asforme, Thenhiscityshallstandhigh.

400 Therightthingistoletmeoffscot-free. Butnocityforhimifheturnsshamelessoutof

Creon: daring. Circumstancesunderwhichyouarrestedher? Hewillbenoguestofmine, Location? Hewillneversharemythoughts,

Watchman: 375 Ifhegoeswrong. Shewasburyingthatman.Nowyouknowitall.

[EnterWatchmanleadingAntigonethroughthe Creon: stageleftwing.] Doyouhonestlyknowwhatyouaresaying?

Chorus:

Watchman: Monstrous!Whatdoesthismean? Well,Isawthisgirlburyingthedeadbody. Aregodsbehindit?Idon’tknowwhattothink: 405 Theoneyouputoff-limits.Clearenoughforyou? Isn’tthisAntigone?Ican’tdenyit.

Creon: Youmiserablechildofmisery, Howdidyouseethis?Caughtherintheact?

380 DaughterofOedipus, Whathaveyoudone?

Watchman: Isityoutheyarrested? Itwaslikethis.Wewentbacktothebody Areyousofoolish? Afterallyourterriblethreats, Sodisloyaltothelawsofkings? Andwebrushedoffthedustthatcoveredit,

Watchman: Thenwesettleddownonthehill, Yes,she’stheonethatdidtheburial. Upwind,sothestinkwouldn’thitus.

410 Soastomaketherottingcorpseproperlynaked.

385 Wecaughtherintheact.Hey,where’sCreon? Wekeptawakebyyellinginsults Ateachotherwhenaslackernoddedoff. [EnterCreonthroughthegreatdoors.]

415 Thatwentonforalongtime,tillthesun Stoodbrightinthecenterofthesky.

Chorus: Hereheis.Comingbackfromthepalace. Andwewerereallygettingcooked.Then,

Suddenly,atornadostruck.Itraiseddust

Antigone: Iknew.Icouldn’thelpknowing.Itwas Allovertheplain,grieftohighheaven.

420 Itthrashedthelow-lyingwoodswithterror everywhere. Andfilledthewholewidesky.Weshutoureyes

Creon: Andheldoutagainstthisplaguefromthegods. Andyetyoudaredtoviolatetheselaws?

Afteralongwhileitlifted,andthenwesawthe

Antigone: girl.

450 Whatlaws?IneverhearditwasZeus Shegaveashrillcrylikeabirdwhensheseesher Whomadethatannouncement. nest Anditwasn’tjustice,either.Thegodsbelow

425 Empty,andthebeddesertedwherehernestlings Didn’tlaydownthislawforhumanuse. hadlain. AndIneverthoughtyourannouncements Thatwashowshewaswhenshesawthecorpse

455 Couldgiveyou—amerehumanbeing— uncovered. Powertotramplethegods’unfailing, Shecriedoutinmourning,andshecalleddown Unwrittenlaws.Theselawsweren’tmadenow Cursesonwhoeverhaddonethisthing. Oryesterday.Theyliveforalltime, Rightawayshespreadthirstydustwithherhands, Andnooneknowswhentheycameintothe

430 Thenpouredthethreelibationsfromavesselof light. finebronze.

Andsoshecrownedthecorpsewithhonor.

Nomancouldfrightenmeintotakingon

460 Thegods’penaltyforbreakingsuchalaw. I’lldieinanycase,ofcourseIwill, Assoonaswespottedher,westartedtorun. Whetheryouannouncemyexecutionornot. Sheshowednofear;itwaseasytocatchher. ButifIdieyoung,allthebetter: Thenwequestionedheraboutherpastand Peoplewholiveinmiserylikemine presentactions.

465 Arebetterdead.Soifthat’stheway

435 Shedidnotdenyasinglething. Mylifewillend,thepainisnothing. Forme,thatwassweet,andagonizing,too. ButifIletthecorpse—mymother’sson— It’sagreatjoytobeoutoftrouble, Liedead,unburied,thatwouldbeagony. Butbringingtroubleonyourfriendsisagony. Thisway,noagonyforme.Butyou!Youthink StillIdon’tmindthatsomuch.It’snature’sway

440 Formetoputmyownsurvivalfirst.

470 I’vebeenafool?Ittakesafooltothinkthat.

Chorus:

Creon: Nowweseethegirl’saswildbybirthasher Youthere!Withyourheadbowedtothe father. ground— Shehasnoideahowtobowherheadtotrouble. Areyouguilty?Ordoyoudenythatyoudidthis thing?

Creon: [Tothechorus.]

Don’tforget:Themindthatismostrigid Antigone: Stumblessoonest;thehardestiron— Ofcoursenot.Ididit.Iwon’tdenyanything.

475 Temperedinfiretillitissuper-strong— Shatterseasilyandclattersintoshards. Creon: [TotheWatchman.]

You’redismissed.Takeyourselfwhereyouplease;Andyoucansurelybreakthewildesthorse Withatinybridle.Whenthemaster’swatching,

445 You’reafreeman,noseriouschargeagainstyou. Pridehasnoplaceinthelifeofaslave. [ToAntigone.]

480 Thisgirlwasacompleteexpertinarrogance Already,whenshebrokeestablishedlaw.

Asforyou,tellme—inbrief,notatlength— Didyouknowthatthishadbeenforbidden?Andnow,arrogantly,sheaddsinsulttoinjury:

She’sboastingandsneeringaboutwhatshe’s

Antigone: No.Theyallseeitthesame.You’vesilenced done!

Listen,ifshe’snotpunishedfortakingtheupperthem. hand,

485 ThenIamnotaman. She wouldbeaman!

Creon:

510 Aren’tyouashamedtohaveamindapartfrom Idon’tcareifsheismysister’schild— theirs? OrcloseryetatmyhouseholdshrineforZeus— Sheandhersistermustpaythefullprice

Antigone: Anddiefortheircrime. There’snoshameinhavingrespectforabrother.

Creon:

[Thechorusindicatetheirsurprisethatboth Wasn’theyourbrother,too,theonewhodiedon mustdie.] theotherside?

Yes,Isaytheyhaveequalguilt,

Antigone:

490 Conniving,onewiththeother,forthisburial. Yes,mybloodbrother—samemother,same father. Bringherout.Isawherinthereaminuteago;

Creon: Shewasravingmad,totallyoutofhermind. Whenyouhonortheone,youdisgracetheother.

Oftenit’sthefeelingsofathiefthatgivehim Whydoit? away Beforethecrimeshedidindarknesscometo

Antigone: light.

[TurningtoAntigone.]

515 Thedeadwillnevertestifyagainstaburial.

Creon:

495 ButhowIhateitwhenshe’scaughtintheact, Yes,iftheywereequal.Butoneofthemdeserves Andthecriminalstillgloriesinhercrime. disgrace.

Antigone:

Antigone: You’vecaughtme,youcankillme.Whatmore Hewasn’tanykindofslave.Hewashisbrother, doyouwant? whodied.

Creon:

Creon: Forme,that’severything.Iwantnomorethan Hewaskillingandplundering.Theotherone that. defendedourland.

Antigone:

Antigone: Thenwhatareyouwaitingfor?Moretalk? Evenso,Hadeslongstohavetheselawsobeyed.

500 Yourwordsdisgustme,Ihopetheyalwayswill. AndI’msureyouaredisgustedbywhatIsay. Creon: Butyet,speakingofglory,whatcouldbemore

520 Butsurelynotequaltreatmentforgoodandbad? Gloriousthangivingmytruebrotherhisburial?

Antigone: Allthesemenwouldtellyouthey’rerejoicing Whoknows?Downbelowthatmightbeblesse ´ d.

505 Overthat,ifyouhadn’tlockedtheirtongues Withfear.Butatyrantsaysanddoes Creon: Whathepleases.That’shisgreatjoy. Anenemyisalwaysanenemy,evenindeath.

Creon: Youaretheonlyone,inallThebes,whothinks [519: Hadesisthegodofdeath;hisnameisalsoused fortheunderworld,towhichthedeadbelong.] thatway.

Antigone:

Ismene: No,please!You’remysister:Don’tdespiseme! Icannotsidewithhatred.Mynaturesideswith love.

545 Letmediewithyouandsanctifyourdead.

Antigone:

Creon: No,youmaynotdiealongwithme.Don’tsay GotoHades,then,andifyouhavetolove,love youdidit! someonedead. Youwouldn’teventouchit.Nowleavemydeath

525 AslongasIlive,Iwillnotberuledbyawoman. alone! [EnterIsmeneunderguard,throughthegreat

Ismene: doors.) WhywouldIcaretolivewhenyouaregone?

Chorus:

Antigone: NowIsmenestandsbeforethedoors Creon’stheonetoask.He’stheoneyoucarefor. Andshedstearsofsister-love. Fromherbrows,ablood-darkcloud

Ismene: Castsafoulshadow

530 Andstainsherlovelyface.

550 Whyareyouscoldingme?Itwon’thelpyou.

Antigone:

Creon: Ofcoursenot.Ithurtsmewhenmymockery Nowyou.Hidinginmyhouselikeasnake, strikesyou. Acoiledbloodsuckerinthedark!AndInever

Ismene: realized ButIstillwanttohelpyou.WhatcanIdo? Iwasraisingapairofdeadly,crazed revolutionaries!

Antigone: Come,tellme:Howdoyouplead?Guiltyofthis Escape!Saveyourself!Idon’tbegrudgeyouthat. burial

535 Asanaccomplice?Ordoyouswearyouknew

Ismene: nothing? Omisery!WhyamIcutofffromyourfate?

Ismene:

Ididit,Iconfess.Thatis,ifwearepartners, anyway.

Antigone:

555 Becauseyouchoselife,andIchosedeath.

Ismene: Iamanaccomplice,andIbearresponsibility ButIgaveyoureasonsnottomakethatchoice. withher.

Antigone: [PointingtoCreonandthechorus.]

Antigone: Ohyes,youaresensible;thesemenagree. Iwillnotpermitthispenaltytofallonyou. [Pointingtotheground,speakingofthedead No.Ineverwantedtogiveyouashare. orthegodsbelow.]

540 Buttheseareyourtroubles!I’mnotashamed; I’llbeyourshipmateinsuffering.

Ismene: But they agreewithme.

Ismene: Yes,Iknow.Andnowthesinismineasmuchas

Antigone: yours. Ihavewitnesses:thegodsbelowsawwhodidthe work.

Iwon’tacceptafriendwho’sonlyfriendsin words.

Antigone: Bebrave.Youarealive.Alreadymysoulisdead.

560 Ithasgonetohelpthosewhodiedbeforeme.

Creon: [ServantstakeIsmeneandAntigonethroughthe greatdoors.] Whatapairofchildren!Oneofyoulosther mind

Momentsago;theotherwasbornwithouthers.

Ismene:

Chorus: Thatisright,sir.Wheneverwecommitacrime, Ourminds,whichgrewbynature,leaveus.

[Strophe a]

SecondStasimon

Creon:

Happyaretheythatnevertasteofcrime, 565 Yoursdid,whenyoudeliberatelyjoineda Butonceahouseisshakenbythegods, criminalincrime. Thenmadnessstalksthefamilywithoutfail, Ismene:

585 Disasterformanygenerations. Withouther,whyshouldIlive?I’dbealone. Itislikeagreatsaltwave KickedupbyfoulwindsfromThrace,

Creon: Itsurgesoverthehellishdepthsofthesea, Her?Don’tspeakofher.Sheisnomore. Roilsthebottom, Ismene:

590 Churnsupblacksand, Butwillyoureallykillthebrideofyourson? Andmakesthescreamingheadlandshowl Creon: Againstthegale. There’sothergroundforhimtoplow,youknow.

Ismene:

[Antistrophe a]

570 Butnooneissuitedtohimaswellassheis. IseegrieffallingfromolddaysonLabdacus’ family: Creon:

Newgriefheapedonthegriefofthosewhodied. Iloathebadwomen.She’snotformyson.

595 Andnothingredeemsthegenerationthatisto Antigone (orpossibly Ismene,orpossibly come: Chorus): Somegodisbatteringthemwithoutrelief. OHaemon,dearest,whatadisgraceyourfather NowIseeasavinglight doestoyou!

Risingfromthesoleremainingroots

Creon: OfthehouseofOedipus.Butthis,too,falls Shutup!Whatapainyouare,youandyour 600 Inabloodyharvest, marriage! Claimedbythedust OftheUnderworldgods,doomedbyfoolish Chorus (or Ismene,or Antigone): words Willyoureallytakeawayyourson’sbride? Andfrenziedwits.

Creon:

575 Notme.Deathwillputastoptothismarriage. [Strophe b]

Chorus (or Ismene):

OZeus!Whocouldevercurtailthypower? Soshewilldie.Hasitreallybeendecided?

605 Notaman,never— Nomatterhowfarheoverstepshisbounds— Creon: Yes.Byyouandme.Now,nomoredelays. Notsleep,thatweakenseveryone, Nottheuntiringmonthsofgods. Servants!Taketheminside.Theyarewomen, Andtheymustnotbefreetoroamabout. No,Zeus,youdonotgrowweakwithtime, 610 Youwhoholdpowerintheluminousglowof

580 EvenabravemanfleesfromDeath Whenheseeshislifeinimmediatedanger. Olympus.

Andthiswillbethelaw, It’ssotheboywillpunishhisfather’senemies Andrewardhisfriends—ashisfatherwould. Nowandfortimetocome,asitwasbefore: Madnessstalksmortalswhoaregreat,

[Antistrophe b]

645 Butsomemenbegetutterlyuselessoffspring: Theyhaveplantednothingbuttroublefor Leavesnoescapefromdisaster. themselves, Andthey’renothingbutajoketotheirenemies.

615 Bewareofhope!Far-reaching,beguiling,a

Nowthen,myboy,don’tletpleasurecloudyour pleasure— mind, Foralotofmen.

Notbecauseofawoman.Youknowverywell: Butalotarefooledbyalight-headedlove,

650 You’llhaveafrigidsqueezebetweenthesheets Anddeceptionstalksthosewhoknownothing Ifyoushackupwithahostilewoman.I’drather Untiltheysettheirfeetinfireandburn. have

620 Wisdomliesinthefamousproverb: Ableedingwoundthanacriminalinthefamily. “Thosewhojudgethatcrimeisgood, Sospitherout.Andbecausethegirl’sagainstus, Areinthehandsofadrivinggod SendherdowntomarrysomebodyinHades. Whoisleadingthemtomadness.”

655 YouknowIcaughtherinthesightofall, Timeisveryshortforthem, Aloneofallourpeople,inopenrevolt.

625 Leavesnoescapefromdisaster. AndIwillmakemywordgoodinThebes— Bykillingher.Whocaresifshesings“Zeus!” [EnterHaemonthroughthestagerightwing.] Andcallshimherprotector?Imustkeepmykin inline.

Chorus:

660 Otherwise,folksoutsidethefamilywillrunwild. Now,hereisHaemon,thelastofyourchildren. Thepublicknowsthatamanisjust IshegoadedherebyanguishforAntigone, Onlyifheisstraightwithhisrelatives. Whoshouldhavebeenhisbride?

Doeshefeelinjuredbeyondmeasure?

630 Cheatedoutofmarriage? Ortriestotellhismasterswhattodo,

So,ifsomeonegoestoofarandbreaksthelaw,

Creon: 665 Hewillhavenothingbutcontemptfromme.

We’llknowtheanswerrightaway,betterthan Butwhenthecitytakesaleader,youmustobey, prophets: Whetherhiscommandsaretrivial,orright,or Tellme,son,didyouhearthefinalverdict? wrong.

Againstyourfiance ´ e?Didyoucomeinangerat

AndIhavenodoubtthatsuchamanwillrule yourfather? well,

Orarewestillfriends,nomatterwhatIdo? And,later,hewillcheerfullyberuledby someoneelse.

Haemon:

635 Iamyours,Father.Yousetmestraight, Waitingfororders,agood,law-abidingsoldier. Givemegoodadvice,andIwillfollowit. Nomarriagewillweighmorewithme,

670 Inhardtimeshewillstandfirmwithhisspear

Butrejectonemanrulinganother,andthat’sthe Thanyourgoodopinion. worst.

Creon:

Anarchytearsupacity,dividesahome,

Splendid,myboy!Keepthatalwaysinyourheart,Defeatsanallianceofspears.

Butwhenpeoplestayinlineandobey,

640 Andstandbehindfatherlyadviceonallcounts. Whydoesamanpraythathe’llconceiveachild,Theirlivesandeverythingelsearesafe. Forthisreason,ordermustbemaintained, Keephimathome,andhavehimlistentowhat he’stold? Andtheremustbenosurrendertoawoman.

675

No!Ifwefall,betteramanshouldtakeusdown.Ifamanbelievesthathealonehasasound mind, 680 Neversaythatawomanbestedus!

Chorus: Unlessoldagehasstolenmywitsaway,

Andnooneelsecanspeakorthinkaswellashe does,

Then,whenpeoplestudyhim,they’llfindan emptybook. Yourspeechwasverywise.That’smybelief. 710

Haemon:

Butawisemancanlearnalotandneverbe ashamed;

Father,thegodsgivegoodsensetoeveryhumanHeknowshedoesnothavetoberigidandclosehauled. being,

Andthatisabsolutelythebestthingwehave.You’veseentreestossedbyatorrentinaflash flood:

685 Butifwhatyousaidisnotcorrect, IhavenoideahowIcouldmakethepoint. Iftheybend,they’resaved,andeverytwig survives, Still,maybesomeoneelsecouldworkitout.

Butiftheystiffenup,they’rewashedoutfromthe roots. Mynaturalduty’stolookoutforyou,spotany risk

It’sthesameinaboat:ifasailorkeepsthe footlinetaut, Thatsomeonemightfindfaultwithwhatyousay ordo.

Ifhedoesn’tgiveaninch,he’llcapsize,and then—

690 Thecommonman,yousee,livesinterrorofyour frown; He’llbesailinghomewithhisbenchesdownand hishulltothesky.

690a He’llneverdaretospeakupinbroaddaylight Andsayanythingyouwouldhatetolearn. Soeaseoff,relax,stopbeingangry,makea change. ButI’mtheonewhohearswhat’ssaidatnight— Howtheentirecityisgrievingoverthisgirl.IknowI’myounger,butImaystillhavegood ideas; Nowomanhaseverhadafatethat’ssounfair 695 (Theysay),whenwhatshediddeserveshonor

And I saythattheoldestidea,andthebest, Isforonemantobeborncomplete,knowing andfame. Shesavedherveryownbrotherafterhedied, everything. Otherwise—anditusuallydoesturnout Murderously,frombeingdevouredbyflesh-eating dogs otherwise— It’sgoodtolearnfromanyonewhospeakswell. Andpeckedapartbyvulturesashelayunburied. Forthis,hasn’tsheearnedglorybrightasgold?

715

720

Chorus: 700 Thissortoftalkmovesagainstyou,quietly,at Sir,youshouldlearnfromhim,ifheisonthe night. mark.Andyou, 725 Haemon,learnfromyourfather.Bothsidesspoke Andforme,Father,yourcontinuedgoodfortune well. IsthebestrewardthatIcouldeverhave. Nochildcouldwinagreaterprizethanhis Creon: [Tothechorus.] father’sfame, Doyoureallythink,atourage, Nofathercouldwantmorethanabundant Weshouldbetaughtbyaboylikehim? success— Fromhisson.

[715: Afootlineistheropethatrunsfromthefootof 705 Andnow,don’talwaysclingtothesameanger, thesail,equivalenttowhattoday’ssailorscallasheet. Don’tkeepsayingthatthis,andnothingelse,is Easingthesheetcansaveaboatfromcapsizingina suddengustofwind.] right.

Haemon:

No.NotifIaminthewrong.IadmitI’myoung; That’swhyyoushouldlookatwhatIdo,notmyleader? age.

Creon:

Creon: Isthatwrong,showingrespectformyjobas

Haemon:

745 Youhavenorespectatallifyoutrampleonthe

730 So“whatyoudo”isshowrespectforbreaking rightsofgods! ranks?

Creon:

Haemon: Whatasickmindyouhave:Yousubmittoa I’dneverurgeyoutoshowrespectforacriminal. woman!

Creon:

Haemon: Soyoudon’tthinkthisgirlhasbeeninfected No.You’llnevercatchmegivingintowhat’s withcrime? shameful.

Haemon: No.ThepeopleofThebesdenyit,allofthem.

Creon:

Soyouthinkthepeopleshouldtellmewhat

Haemon:

Creon: Buteverythingyousay,atleast,isonherside.

Haemon: orderstogive? Andonyourside!Andmine!Andthegods’ below!

735 Nowwho’stalkinglikehe’swetbehindtheears?

Creon:

Creon: SoIshouldrulethiscountryforsomeoneotherstillalive. thanmyself?

750 Thereisnowayyou’llmarryher,notwhileshe’s

Haemon:

Haemon: Thenshe’lldie,andherdeathwilldestroy Aplaceforonemanaloneisnotacity. SomeoneElse.

Creon:

Creon: Acitybelongstoitsmaster.Isn’tthattherule? Isthatathreat?Areyoubrashenoughtoattack me?

Haemon: Thengoberulerofadesert,allalone.You’ddo

Haemon: itwell. Whatthreat?AllI’msayingis,youhaven’t Creon: [Tothechorus.] thoughtthisthrough.

740 Itturnsoutthisboyisfightingforthewoman’s cause.

Creon: I’llmakeyouwishyou’dneverhadathoughtin

Haemon: youremptyhead! Onlyif you areawoman.AllIcareaboutisyou!

Haemon: Creon:

755 Ifyouweren’tmyfatherI’dsayyouwereoutof Thisisintolerable!Youareaccusingyourown yourmind. father.

Haemon:Creon: Don’tbeataroundthebush.You’reawoman’s BecauseIseeyougoingwrong.Becausejustice matters! toy,aslave.

Haemon: 775 I’llleaveheronlyasmuchfoodasreligiouslaw prescribes, Talk,talk,talk!Whydon’tyoueverwantto listen? Sothatthecitywillnotbecursedforhomicide.

Creon: LetherpraytoHadesdownthere;he’stheonly Really?Listen,youarenotgoingonlikethis.By god allthegods, Thatsherespects.Maybeshe’llarrangeforhimto Onemoreinsultfromyou,andthefunisover. saveherlife; Maybeshe’lllearn,atlast,thatshe’swastingher [Toattendants.] time

760 Bringoutthathatedthing.Iwanthertodieright

780 Showingrespectforwhatever’sinHades. here, [ExitCreonthroughthegreatdoors.] Rightnow,soherbridegroomcanwatchthe wholething.

Haemon:

Chorus: Notme.Never.Nomatterwhatyouthink. SheisnotgoingtodiewhileIamnearher.

Andyouwillnever,everseemyfaceagain.Go

ThirdStasimon

[Strophe]

InbattlethevictorygoestoLove; on, PrizesandpropertiesfalltoLove.

765 Becrazy!Perhapssomeofyourfriendswillstay Lovedalliesthenight byyou. Onagirl’ssoftcheeks, [ExitHaemonthroughthestageleftwing.]

785 Rangesacrossthesea, Lodgesinwildmeadows.

Chorus: OLove,noonecanhidefromyou: Sir,themanhasgone.Heisswifttoanger; Youtakegodswholiveforever, Painliesheavilyonayouthfulmind. Youtakehumanswhodieinaday,

Creon: 790 Andtheytakeyouandgomad. Lethimgo,himandhisloftyambitions!Good riddance!

[Antistrophe] Butthosetwogirlsshallnotescapetheirfate.

DestroyerLove,youseizeagoodmind,

Chorus: Andpervertittowickedness:

770 Areyoureallyplanningtokill both ofthem? Thisfightisyourdoing, Thisuproarinthefamily.

Creon:

795 Andthewinnerwillbedesire, Nottheonewhonevertouchedthecrime.You’re Shiningintheeyesofabride, right. Aninvitationtobed, Apowertosweepacrosstheboundsofwhatis

Chorus: Right. Bywhatmeanswillyouhavetheotherone Forweareonlytoysinyourhands, killed?

800 Divine,unbeatableAphrodite!

Creon:

I’lltakeheroffthebeatentrack,wherenoone’s Kommos around, AndI’llburyheraliveunderground,inagraveof [EnterAntigoneunderguardthroughthe greatdoors.] stone.

Chorus:

Chorus: Really!Niobewasagod;shehadagodfora NowI,too,amsweptaway, Outofbounds,whenIseethis. father.

835 Wearemortal,andourfatherspassaway. Icannotcontainthesurgeoftears: FornowIseeAntigone,soontogain Butyou—whenyoudie,youwillbegreat, Youwillbeequalinmemorytothegods,

805 Themarriagebedwhereeveryonemustsleep. Bythegloryofyourlifeanddeath.

Antigone: SeehowIwalkthelastroad,

Antigone: You’relaughingatme. Youwhobelongtomycity, HowIfillmyeyeswiththelast

840 Forthegods’sake,whynow? YoucouldhavewaitedtillI’mgone. Shiningofthesun.

810 There’snoreturn:Ifollowdeath,alive, Butnowyoumakeinsultstomyface, Yougrasping,richoldmen!Whatacityyouhave! TothebrinkofAcheron, WhereHegivesresttoall. IcallontherisingofriversinThebes

Nomarriagehymnsforme. Noonesounds Theriversandtheplainareonmyside,atleast. They’lltestifythatnofriendsweptforme, 815 Aweddingmarch: IwillbethebrideofAcheron. ThatthelawsofThebessentmetoprison Inarock-hollowedtomb.

Chorus:

845 Andonthegreatchariot-reachesoftheplain.

850 Theyseehowunusualandcruelthisis. Butwon’tyouhavehymnsofpraise? ButIhavenoplacewithhumanbeings, Somuchgloryattendsyou Livingordead.Nocityishometome. Asyoupassintothedeepplaceofthedead.

820 Foryouarenotwastedbydisease,notmaimedby

Chorus: You’vegonetoofar!Youareextreme,impetuous. asword. Buttruetoyourownlaws,youaretheonlyone,Mychild,youcaughtyourfootandfell

855 Whenyoutriedtoclimbagainsthighjustice. Ofmortals,who’llgodowntoHadeswhilestill alive. Thisisyourfather’slegacy—painandpunishment.

Antigone:

Antigone:

No.IhearNiobewaslostinutmostmisery—Nowyouraisetheagonythathurtsmymindthe most: DaughterofTantalus,visitorinThebes, 825 WastedonaPhrygianmountain. Griefformyfather, Likerawearthplowedthreetimes, Rocksprouteduparoundher,firm, Erectasshootsofivy, 860 Griefforthewholehugedisasterof us, Ourbrilliantfamily, Anditsubduedher.Somensay. Rainandsnowpeltedher Labdacus’descendants. Iweepfortheruininmymother’sbed, Withoutabreak,andshemeltedaway, 830 Drippingfromhermournfulbrows, Thesexualintercourseandtheincest 865 Myfatherhadwithourmother. Tearsstreamingdownherflanks. It’sthesameforme,exactly:

[816: Acheron—ariverintheunderworld.]

Ill-fatedparentsmakeamiserablechild. Iamgoingtothemnow, Somethingdivinelaysmetosleep. Unholyandunmarried,tolodgewiththem. Oh,mybrother,youweremarriedonce,

[821: “Buttruetoyourownlaws”— TheGreekis autonomos, renderedbysomescholarsas“ofyourownwill”;[869: “Youweremarriedonce”— Polyneicesmarriedthe daughterofthekingofArgos,andArgosprovidedthe butthewordmeansmorethanthatinancientGreek, andtherootword“law”(nomos)isclearlyheard.]armythatattackedThebes.]

870 Butwhatadisasteritwas:

900 Fromyou,dearheart,mybrother.Whenyou died, Yourdeathsnuffedoutmylife. Itookyouup,allthree,andlaidyouout,

Chorus: Andpouredlibationsatyourgraves. Youhaveonekindofreverence. And,Polyneices,look:Thisismyreward Butamanwhosejobitistorule Fortakingcareofyou.Iwasright,butwisdom Willneverletyoutrampleonhispower. knows 875 Youchoseanger,andangerdestroyedyou.

Iwouldnotdoitforachild,wereIamother, Notforahusbandeither.Letthemlie,putrefied, Antigone: dead; Notearsforme,nofriends,noweddinghymns. Iwouldnotdefythecityatsuchcostfortheir Theyaretakingmeaway sake. Inmisery,bytheroadbeforeme,

WhatlawcanIclaimonmysideforthischoice? Nowandforeverforbiddentosee Imayhaveanotherhusbandifthefirstshoulddie 880 Thisblessedeyeoflight. 910 AndgetanotherchildfromanewmanifI’ma Nofriendscryforme, widow. Nooneismourning.

Butmymotherandmyfatherlieinthelandof [EnterCreonwithhisattendantsthroughthe death, greatdoors.] Andthereisnogroundtogrowabrotherforme now.

Creon:

Singingandwailing?Theywouldneverend inhonor, Beforedeath,iftheymadeanydifference.

ThatisthelawIfollowedwhenImadeyoufirst

EventhoughCreonthoughtIdidaterriblething, 885 Takeherawayimmediately.Andwhenshe’s 915 Arashandsinfulcrime,dearheart,mybrother. lockedup, Nowhehastakenmebyforce,heisdrivingme Intheembraceofhercoveredtomb—exactlyasI down said—

Unmarried.I’vehadnoman,nowedding Leaveheralone,deserted.Letherdieifshe celebration, wants, Sharednothingwithahusband,neverraiseda Orelselivethereinhergrave,ifshefeelsat child. homethere.

Myfriendsandfamilyhaveabandonedmein Wewashourhandsofthisgirl.Buteitherway, misery, 890 Herpermittoresideabovetheearthiscanceled.

920 AndIamgoing—alive—tothescrapedhollowof thedead.

Antigone:

WhathaveIeverdoneagainstdivinejustice? Mytomb,mymarriage,myhollow,scrapedin HowcanIexpectagodtohelpmeinmy dirt, misery?

I’mcominghomeforever,tobeheldin

TowhomshouldIpraynow?Doyousee? Withmyownpeople,mostofthemdeadnow, Theyarecountingallmyreverencetobe AndgonewherePersephonewelcomesthem. 925 Irreverence.Ifthegodsreallyagreewiththis, 895 Iamthelastofthemthatwillgounder,andmy Thensufferingshouldteachmetorepentmysin. death— Butifthesinbelongstothosewhocondemnedme, Itistheworstbyfar—somuchbeforemytime. IhopetheysuffereverybitasIdonow.

AsIleave,evenso,Ifeedthisonestronghope: ThatIwillhavealovingwelcomefrommy

Chorus: Stillsheistossedbygustsofwind; father, Morelovefromyou,mymother,andthen,love 930 Theytearthroughhersoulasstronglyasbefore.

Creon:

[Antistrophe a] Listen,it’stheguardswhowillweep

Anothercase:Lycurguswaskeptdown, Iftheydon’tgetamoveonnow. AndhewasakinginThrace. Butbecauseofhisangryjeering, Antigone (or Chorus): [Withacryofpain.] Thatword— Dionysushadhimjailedinacellofrock, It’salmostdeathitself! Andtheretheterribleflood-force

955

960 Ofhismadnesstrickledaway,dropbydrop,until Creon: helearned, 935 Ihavenohopetogive. Atlast,thatitwasagodhehadstunginhis Thedeathsentencestands. madness

Antigone: Withthosejeeringinsults. Cityofmyfathers,Thebes! Forhetriedtoquenchtheholyfire, Godsofmypeople! Reinedinthegod-filledwomen, Theyaretakingmeagainstmywill.

965 Anddroveflute-lovingMusesintoarage. 940 Lookatme,OyoulordsofThebes: Iamthelastremnantofkings.

[Strophe b] Lookwhatthesewretchedmenaredoingto

AttheBlackWaters, me, WhereathrustoflanddividestheBosporusfrom Formypurereverence! theSea, LiesacityofThraceknownasSalmyde ´ ssus.

FourthStasimon

[955 – 65: Lycurgushadtriedtosuppresstheworship ofDionysus,whichinvolvedecstaticrituals.Insome

Chorus: [ToAntigone.] versionsofthestory,hewentmadandkilledhisson [Strophe a] beforebeingimprisoned.]

[958: DionysuswasbelievedbytheancientGreeksto Courage!Danae,too,endured havebroughthisworshiptoGreecefromAsia,along 945 Theexchangeofheavenlylight withthepracticeofmakingwine.] Forabronze-boltedprison.

[964: “God-filledwomen”— Thesewomen,variously Andthereshewaskeptdown calledMaenads,Bacchae,andbacchants,arewomen Secretlyinabedroomtomb. whoworshipDionysusthroughecstaticdanceandsong inthemountains,awayfromtheirhomes.“God-filled” Shewasofnoblebirth,too,mydaughter,Omy means“inspired.”] daughter,

950 AndZeustrustedhertomindhisgolden-rainfall [965: “Flute-lovingMuses”— The aulos,usuallytranslated“flute,”wasareedinstrument;itsmusicwasconsid- child. eredtobethemostexcitinginancientGreece.]

Fatehasaterriblepower

Thatnothingescapes,notwealth, hadtwosonsbyhisfirstwife,Cleopatra(norelationto Notwarfare,notafortresstower, thefamousqueenofEgypt).ThisCleopatrawasthe Notevenblackshipsbeatingagainstthe daughterofanAthenianprincesswhohadbeenstolen sea. byBoreas,theNorthWind,tobehisbride.Cleopatra’s sonswereblindedbytheirstepmotherafterPhineushad imprisonedtheirmotherandtakenanewwife.]

[966 – 87: Phineus,akinginThrace(northernGreece),

[944 – 50: Danae ¨ ’sfatherlockedherawayfrommenbecauseofanoraclewarninghimagainstanysonshe[966: “BlackWaters”— Themanuscriptsareunclear. ThephrasemayrefertotheBlackSeaorthetwoDark mightbear.ButZeusvisitedherinashowerofgold, andtheyconceivedachild,Perseus.] IslandsatthemouthoftheBosporus.]

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.