SUBSCRIPTION COPY
OCTOBER 2017
H INDIA’S BEST CAR BUYER’S GUIDE
| Volume 12 No. 3
October 2017 | Rs 80
SKODA KODIAQ
Hugely accomplished luxury SUV that ticks all the right boxes z 150hp diesel z Rs 36 lakh z On sale now
FI
DRRST IVE
SKODA KODIAQ RENAULT CAPTUR COMPARISON NEW HYUNDAI VERNA AUTO vs SKODA RAPID
Driven
RENAULT CAPTUR
Attractive blend of rugged mechanicals and cutting-edge design
Compared
New Octavia RS vs Polo GTI
Sports sedan or hot hatch? We help you decide
New Verna auto vs Rapid
Can the Korean ‘Czech’mate the Skoda Rapid?
PLUS INDIA’S BEST CARS We pick the best car in every segment p69
India’s best car buyer’s guide
ContaCt us Editorial tel: 022-23787500/022-23787400 e-mail: edit.whatcar@haymarketsac.com Editor-in-chief Shapur Kotwal Senior Correspondent Saumil Shah Correspondents Jay Patil Production editor aswathi Nair Sub editor Sanket chaukiyal Art editor ellared D’Souza Assistant art editor Pralhad Kusuma Senior designers Mohan Ghag, rajesh rathod, Jagdish bari, Sukhdeep Singh bhamra Image editor Yogesh Padte Head - Photography Paul Dewars Chief photographer ardeshir ashley baxter Photographers Priyank chhapwale, Kuldeep chaudhari Senior editorial executive John Fernandes (Mumbai) Editorial executive GK Singh (Delhi) Ad sales, marketing & distribution tel: 022-23787500/022-23787400 e-mail: ad.whatcar@haymarketsac.com Group head - Ad Sales harvinder Pal Singh Regional heads - Ad Sales amit Jha (west), Jaidev wadhwa (North) Senior managers - Ad Sales Jagmohan Singh (Delhi), amlan Mukherjee (Mumbai), raghavendra S (bangalore) Managers - Ad Sales Unnati Joseph, Prashant Mishra (Mumbai), Nackeeran M (chennai), Karun Dube (North) Assistant managers - Ad Sales Vipin arora (Delhi) Coordinator - Ad Sales Sonal Jain General manager – Circulation Gilbert D’Souza Head – Circulation P Vijaykumar (South), Satish Kumar Manager – Circulation ashok More (west), Saravana D (South), Vimal Sharma (North) Manager – Subscription Mahesh Malusare Production manager Prasad Gangurde Manager – Finance amol Mahadik Contact us Mumbai: raheja Xion, 4th/5th Floor, opp Nirmal Park, Dr b ambedkar Marg, byculla east, Mumbai 400 027 tel: 022-23787500/022-23787400 e-mail: whatcar@haymarketsac.com New Delhi: a 2/9, Lower Ground Floor, Safdarjung enclave, Main africa avenue road, New Delhi 110029 tel: 011-46020600, 32444090, 32969125 Fax: 011-46020633 Chennai: F3, 1st Floor, 8/27, Govindu Street, t Nagar, chennai 600 017 tel: 044-4212 3230 Bengaluru: No. 811, ‘a’ wing,8th Floor, Mittal towers, M.G. road, bengaluru - 560001 tel: 080-2559 3775 Hyderabad: c/o a M News agency, h. No. 11-4-138, central bank, back Side, bazaarghat, Lakdikapool, hyderabad 500 004 News-stand price rs 80 Subscription enquiries: e-mail: subscribe.whatcar@haymarketsac.com the publisher makes every effort to ensure that the magazine’s contents are correct. however, he can accept no responsibility for any effects from errors or omissions. Unsolicited material — including photographs and transparencies — is used in whatcar?, but it is submitted entirely at the owner’s risk and the publisher accepts no responsibility for its loss or damage. all material published in whatcar? is copyright and unauthorised reproduction is forbidden. Printed and published by hormazd Sorabjee on behalf of haymarket Sac Publishing (India) Pvt Ltd, raheja Xion, 4th/5th Floor, opp Nirmal Park, Dr b ambedkar Marg, byculla east, Mumbai 400 027. Printed at Kala Jyothi Process Pvt Ltd, Kondapur Unit, Survey No 185, Kondapur Village, Serilingampally Municipality rr District - 500 133, telangana. Published at haymarket Sac Publishing (India) Pvt Ltd, raheja Xion, 4th/5th Floor, opp Nirmal Park, Dr b ambedkar Marg, byculla east, Mumbai 400 027. cIN: U22120Mh1998Ptc116780 editor: hormazd Sorabjee ‘what car?’ is under licence from haymarket Magazines Ltd. this magazine contains 116 pages, including both covers.
What our ratings mean OUTSTANDING VERY GOOD GOOD REASONABLE POOR
october 2017
In this issue of What Car?
Skoda knowS how to deliver 'Skoda has value for money. no, its cars aren’t given the ultra-affordable, but what the kodiaq all Czech company manages to do, that it needs almost better than anybody else, is blend high levels of technology, to nail plenty of space and a genuine luxury car vibe; all at success.' the right price. Cars like the octavia and the Superb are living proof of this. Skoda doesn’t always get it right: far from it. The quirky but robust Yeti didn’t get the price-to-size ratio right, and there are others as well. But with the new kodiaq, Skoda has taken the game way ahead; this car just has everything it needs to nail success. Space, comfort, technology, SUV appeal, it has it all. It is, in fact, so good, Skoda may even risk making it a bit pricey, at around Rs 36 lakh (ex showroom). Is that too much of a stretch or does it have enough in the tank to deliver the value you'd expect for that kind of money? Turn to our in-depth story on page 6. also in this issue is another attractive-looking SUV that seems to offer the best of both worlds. Renault, smartly, has kept the best bits of the duster and changed everything else. But will the Captur, with its crossover-like looks, resonate with our more traditional SUV-loving buyers? and how good is the car? we also get a taste of the updated Maruti S-cross, the fully loaded but nicely priced Verna diesel takes on the Skoda Rapid automatic, and the Vw Polo GTI takes on Skoda’s new octavia RS in the battle of fast and fun performance cars. Shapur Kotwal, editor-in-chief edit.whatcar@haymarketsac.com whatcar? october 2017 | 3
India’s best car buyer’s guide
October 2017
This month’s contents BMW 530i
First drive It gets a 252hp, turbo-petrol engine. We take the new 5 for a spin p18
Performance battle
oN THe CoVeR 6
Skoda Kodiaq The first big luxury SUV from Skoda
Two-car comparison New Skoda Octavia RS takes on VW's GTI hot hatchback p42
60 Reader rescue Our reader confused between Verna and City
20 Maruti S-cross Maruti's most expensive car gets a facelift
66 Buying used All you need to look out for in a used Maruti S-cross
24 Renault Captur Stylish crossover to be positioned above Duster
114 Trading up From a Renault Kwid to a Hyundai Grand i10
32 News l Tata Nexon launched l Impact of GST cess on vehicles l BR-V finally gets a touchscreen
Plus
37 New launches The latest models in our market 38 Feature How to maximise the life of your car's brakes 56 Hot deals All the best deals for the month of October
Diesel automatic sedans
Buyer’s guide and A to Z
Two-car comparison New Hyundai Verna and Skoda Rapid go head to head p46
All you need to know before buying your new car p69
India's Best Cars Class by class, the
ed and rated best buys review
‘We've got the best cars in every price bracket’
New Cars
A to Z
WHAT CAR TEAM
Contents
Contents
Premium, Mid-size 71 Hatchbacks Sedans Hatchbacks, Hatchbacks Mid-size, Sedans Executive, Luxury 70 Hatchbacks Entry, 73 Sedans Luxury Sedans Premium ury, Sedans Sub-4-metre Luxury Sedans Mid-size, Soft-roaders, SUVs Hatchbacks Import/Lux Sedans Compact, SUVs Entry-level 74 Luxury , SUVs Mid-size, MPVs 76 SUVs Entry, SUVs Premium Mid-size, Luxury 75 SUV Sub-4-metre next car Small, Luxury SUVs to purchase your 77 Luxury SUVs and tips on how Plus Read our advice WHATCAR?
69 OCTOBER 2017 |
9/29/2017
Buyers Guide Best
Buys_New_3.indd
69
86 Hatchback Premium Hatchback Mid-size Mid-size 83 Hatchbacks 84 re 90 Sedan Entry Compact 82 Hatchback Entry xury 89 Sedan Sub-4-met 94 Luxury Sedan 87 Hatchback Import/Lu , Luxury Sedan Entry Premium 93 Sedan Executive Sedan re 91 Sedan Mid-size Mid-size 96 Luxury 100 SUV Sub-4-met ers) 95 Luxury Sedan Cars 99 Supercars 106 SUV (Soft-road 98 Performance MPV 105 SUV Entry 97 Luxury Touring Utility Vehicles 104 Small 109 Luxury SUV Mid-size 103 Mid-size 102 SUV 108 Luxury SUV 107 SUV, Lifestyle Premium 110 Luxury SUV 12:37:15 PM right car, you buy just the and prices to help together. Plus all the facts cars g with competin | 79 | 79 2017 2017 OCTOBER OCTOBER WHATCAR? WHATCAR?
PM 9/29/2017 2:33:24
WHATCAR? PB | OCTOBER 2017
WC_New Car Buyer's
Guide (cover & Intro)_Changes
Final.indd 79
Hyundai Verna
Reader test team Our readers give their opinions on the latest Hyundai sedan p58 whatcar? october 2017 | 5
Star car
Skoda kodiaq
Photography Paul Dewars
What is it? Skoda's first big luxury SUV gets an upmarket interior, loads of features and seven seats. Price Rs 36 lakh (estimated, ex-showroom, Delhi) On sale This month Verdict Accomplished luxury SUV at an executive car price.
6 | OCTOBER 2017 whaTCaR?
It has the presence and the style, but not the girth of other SUVs. What is it? Skoda knows how to play the value game. This is one of the reasons it has enjoyed a fair amount of success in India, and we're not merely talking good old-fashioned price-driven value here. With cars like the Superb and even the Octavia, it has provided exceptional value and loads of luxury as well. Now, with the Kodiaq, the carmaker wants to take that formula for success and apply it to its new flagship SUV; a car that will sit just above the Superb in the line-up. It has the requisite size for sure, and the high bonnet line gives it that all-important presence. But what makes this design stand out are the sharp details that are crystallike in form. The sharp ‘Czech crystal’ headlamps with their split fog lights work very well and Superb like tail-lamps
'It's only Skoda's first big SUV, but the company has done an outstanding job.'
look great. The 18-inch wheels do look a bit small, especially when you consider the bulk of the car, and the Kodiaq doesn't quite have the girth of other SUVs either. But what it lacks in outright size compared to, say a Fortuner or Endeavour, it makes up for in flair and modern styling. What’s it like to drive? The Kodiaq offers a good balance between ride and handling. Yes, there’s a bit of underlying firmness at low speeds and sharp bumps, and big holes do result in the occasional muted thud, thud, but regular bumps and broken patches are swallowed so easily, comfort levels are pretty good. Up the pace and that bit of firmness pays dividends; you can now just fly over any and all surfaces, with almost no up and down movement at all as the Kodiaq absorbs all kinds of irregularities. Driving the SUV through narrow streets needs some amount of adjustment. It's not that it is a chore to drive, quite the contrary, but the steering is so light and quick, and visibility is so good, you sometimes forget how bulky it really is. Maybe a bit more connection and feel between the steering and wheels would have helped. Steering aside, handling at higher speeds is nothing less than impressive. Now, most cars with a long wheelbase whaTCaR? OCTOBER 2017 | 7
Star car
Drive it in a relaxed manner and performance is more than adequate.
with all rows up there's enough boot space for a few soft bags. (the gap between the front and rear wheels) tend to forsake agility for stability, and so they need to be dragged 'by the nose' into corners. But Skoda has tuned the suspension so beautifully, the Kodiaq even rewards drivers who enjoy carrying a fair amount of speed in and even out of corners. Yes, the body rolls a fraction and there is a bit of momentum from all that weight being transferred in the back, but, otherwise, the Kodiaq drives so neatly and 8 | OCTOBER 2017 whaTCaR?
with so much compactness, it encourages you to drive faster. And you comply because it is so easy to up the pace and is quite enjoyable. Being an AWD, it also has some genuine off-road skills. It doesn't quite have the clearance of a Ford Endeavour and the suspension is more car-like rather than off-roader like, but the on-demand four-wheel system can be configured for low-traction surfaces and that helps make the part-time system quite effective. The Kodiaq is quite
Third row has decent legroom but you're sat in a knees-up position.
'It gets several features that you'd expect in a premium car.'
capable through slush and soft mud, and that comes as something of a surprise. Look at the spec sheet and Skoda seems to have underspecified the Kodiaq with what appears to be a low-powered engine; it gets just 150hp and a seven-speed automatic (DSG) gearbox. But this is only partially true. The diesel motor is extremely refined at low speeds to begin with, and it even has a fair amount of oomph at low and medium speeds. It feels very responsive when you take off, and there's
Cabin quality is top-notch; there are several practical bits like a twin glovebox.
Large touchscreen is great to use, the interface is good and the display is crisp.
Leather seats are extremely comfy; these can recline and slide too. a very healthy slug of power in the mid-range; keep the engine spinning there and the pace is actually quite good. In fact, drive it in a disciplined manner and it feels quite quick. Skoda's 0-100kph claimed time is 10.1sec. However, try and extract maximum performance from this car and it will disappoint. Yes, the engine revs nicely to around 5,000rpm, but power tails off so sharply after 4,000rpm, you only get more engine noise and almost no extra progress. You do miss
having some extra power out on the highway, where frequent overtaking is a must and that 4,000rpm 'wall' in the power delivery means you need to shift manually to the next gear. And that gets a bit irksome, especially because after the manual intervention, you have to put the car back into 'D'. So yes, a bit more power would have been nice and would have made it a tad more effortless to drive. What’s it like inside? Step into the Kodiaq and you
This SUV is properly loaded with premium kit, expected out of a car of this price.
Several bits are carried over from other Skodas like dials, steering, switches; not nice.
Large, comfy front seats get electric adjustment and memory. are greeted by an upright dashboard that has a thick horizontal slab of trim running across it. This looks good and the fact that it gets two gloveboxes resonates well. The vertically aligned vents are tastefully executed, the big touchscreen looks great and works well, and you get Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. But for a completely fresh design, such as this one, it's odd to see so many carryover bits scattered around the cabin – you get the standard Skoda dials, steering wheel,
stalks, window switches and air con controls. Still, quality levels are excellent and the cabin is full of practical touches like a big elbow box and massive door pockets. Comfort levels, however, are extremely high. The front seats are large, shoulder, leg and headroom are excellent, and the view over the bonnet is good; important when you have a big, bulky SUV. In addition, what adds to the comfort factor is that the 'leather' seats are superbly put together and nicely contoured, whaTCaR? OCTOBER 2017 | 9
Star car KODIAQ vs RIVALS
*estimated
Skoda Kodiaq Possibly the most luxurious and comfortable 7-seater in its segment. Price from Rs 36 lakh* Engine 2.0-litre diesel Power 150hp L/W/H 4697/1882/1665mm Ford Endeavour Great mix of toughness and luxury; it's feature-loaded and easy to drive. Price from Rs 25.09-31.40 lakh Engine 2.2/3.2 diesel Power 160/200hp L/W/H 4893/1862/1837mm
Massive panoramic sunroof enhances the cabin's premium quotient.
Toyota Fortuner An SUV that's high on style, dependability and resale value. Price from Rs 25.71-31.48 lakh Engine 2.7 petrol/2.8 diesel Power 166/177hp L/W/H 4795/1855/1835mm Isuzu MU-X A robust, basic but good SUV that offers good value for money. Price from Rs 23.58-25.55 lakh Engine 3.0-litre diesel Power 177hp L/W/H 4825/1860/1840mm
5 driving modes, including an individual setting; three-zone climate control.
Volkswagen Tiguan 5-seater SUV with a high-quality cabin and premium features. Price from Rs 27.49-30.88 lakh Engine 2.0-litre diesel Power 143hp L/W/H 4486/1839/1672mm
Premium, wireless charging function; semi-automatic parking feature. and Skoda has chosen to keep the cushioning a bit stiff. Yes, they may appear to be a bit hard initially, especially in comparison to seats from other carmakers, but they are also super comfy when you spend a longer time in the cabin. The second row is arguably the best place to be sat. Legroom is huge, there's a fantastic feeling of space and those seated at the rear get a third climate zone. Even the seat itself is seriously impressive; thigh support is excellent, the backrest can be reclined to your liking, and even back support is first rate. You can even slide it 180mm forward, fold the split 10 | OCTOBER 2017 whaTCaR?
seats and access the third row. But getting onto the seats here isn't as easy as you would imagine. You have to crouch a bit and slip in between the narrow gap between the seat and door. Once you are in the back, and because the thirdrow seat is placed extremely low, you sit with your knees up. And then visibility forward is quite poor. You can add a bit of extra legroom, however, by sliding the second-row seats forward, and the smart thing is that it can be done for one seat and not the other; pretty clever. Though, with all rows up, the boot is only hatchbacksized. Fold the third row and you get 630 litres, and
'A bit more power and performance would have gone down well.'
with the second row down, it expands to a massive 2,005 litres. But for those of you with steamer trunks and American XXL-sized bags, remember, the boot floor is high, so loading them can be quite a chore. And you only get a space-saver instead of a full-sized spare wheel, which limits how far off the beaten path you can go. In India, we will get only one edition for now, and it is very well-equipped. The 8.0-inch touchscreen is the same one in the new Octavia, there’s a 10-colour ambient lighting system, a nicesounding 12-speaker Canton stereo and the drives modes adjust throttle responses,
The Kodiaq, being a Skoda, is replete with clever little touches; a little dustbin in the door pockets, a magnetised flashlight you can stick on the car while you change a tyre and unique plastic ‘bumpers’ that pop out when you open the doors, to protect the edges, and retract when you close them! Should I buy one? Like all Skodas, the handsome Kodiaq will deliver a huge amount of car for the money. It will be a bit expensive, at an expected ex-showroom price of Rs 36 lakh, and that, for a Skoda, may seem like a lot. But the Kodiaq is so accomplished, it all but
delivers the full-size luxury SUV experience at just over half the price. The size and design of the Kodiaq are what grab your attention first. You get a genuine luxury car vibe on the inside; it has a long equipment list, plush interiors, plenty of space for passengers and luggage, and even decent ride comfort. And if that wasn’t enough, it has sufficient power and is surprisingly enjoyable to drive. Yes, a bit more power from the engine would have worked wonders, third-row comfort should have been a bit better and Skoda's aftersales service, though much improved now,
still isn't at the level it should be. But all things considered, the Kodiaq still makes for a beguiling and tempting choice, one that car buyers should definitely explore with the company's new extended warranty and comprehensive service packs in hand. Shapur Kotwal Buyer’S file Engine size Price L/W/H Power Torque Gearbox Torque
2.0 (D) Rs 36 lakh* 4697/1882/1665mm 150hp at 3500-4000rpm 340Nm at 1750-3000rpm 7-speed auto 151Nm at 4850rpm
whaTCaR? OCTOBER 2017 | 11
*Estimated, ex-showroom, Delhi
gearbox programming and steering weight. Adjustable dampers aren't available in India, but the Kodiaq gets an off-road mode that tailors throttle responses and drive system intervention for optimum traction. And then the there's other stuff, like the truly humongous panoramic sunroof that stretches way back, both front seats are powered and you even get hands-free parking assist. Skoda has also done an outstanding job when it comes to safety: you get nine airbags, so safety levels should be on par with the European car, and right up there with some of the big luxury SUVs.
Audi Q7 40 TFSi
First drive
Popular luxury SUV now gets a 2.0-litre turbo petrol heart. Verdict It's relaxed and refined but is a lot more thirstier than the diesel.
Pretty much all the luxury SuVs in India are powered by diesel engines. Still, there’s a small section of people today who prefer petrol vehicles, and with this new Q7 40 tFSI, audi aims to cater to these buyers. Powering this SuV is a 1,984cc, four-cylinder turbopetrol engine that makes 252hp – 3hp more than the 3.0-litre diesel. Despite being nearly 90kg lighter, this Q7 accelerates to 100kph in 7.65sec, which is 0.7sec slower than the diesel. this petrolpowered SuV has merely 370Nm of torque to haul its 2.2-tonne kerb weight, and so performance isn’t as effortless as the diesel which boasts 600Nm of torque. at low revs, this engine feels quite lazy, and the only way to move quickly would be to shift down. Only when this motor is spun faster does the performance improve, and then it’s quite enjoyable. this Q7 uses the same eightspeed auto transmission as the diesel. It shifts seamlessly
apart from a '40 tFSI' badge, there's no differentiating this car from diesel.
and rapidly at most times, but under hard acceleration, it upshifts in a jerky and rather aggressive manner that can be quite uncomfortable. Downshifts, however, aren’t as quick, with the unit taking almost a second to recognise the need to select a lower gear in auto. there are paddle shifters for manual gearshifts. the strength of this engine is its refinement. It’s very quiet at idle and at cruising speeds, there is zero clatter or vibrations. this car’s excellent
insulation masks the actual speed of the vehicle. the Q7’s ride is plush and absorbent like the diesel, thanks to the adaptive air suspension. It gets four-wheel drive too but doesn’t feel as sharp or as sure-footed as the diesel around corners due to its lighter front end. the steering, however, is light and easy in the city, with sufficient heft at speeds. With prices between rs 67.76-74.43 lakh, the audi Q7 petrol is approximately
'The engine is lazy at low revs, but wakes up at higher revs.' Buyer’S File Engine size Price Power Torque Gearbox 0-100kph Tyre size
rs 2.3-3.4 lakh cheaper than the diesel, and this small price difference isn’t likely to sway buyers in the petrol’s favour. yes, it’s a bit more refined, but refinement is even a strength of the diesel. even in terms of performance, the diesel is a lot more effortless and efficient. also, the value of petrol luxury cars depreciates quickly. So, while the petrol Q7 might appeal to those who don’t clock too many kilometres and to those looking for a relaxed, chauffeur-driven SuV, its appeal isn’t likely to extend to the general carbuying public. So, that makes the diesel the better choice here. It’s as simple as that. Saumil Shah
rivAlS 2.0 (P) rs 67.76 - 74.43 lakh* 252hp at 5000-6000rpm 370Nm at 1600-4500rpm 8-speed auto 7.65sec 255/55 r19
Mercedes GLS Price 79.86 lakh* the GLS 400 is powered by a 333hp, 3.0-litre V6 petrol engine and is great in terms of road presence and comfort.
*Ex-showroom, Delhi
Photography Paul Dewars
this engine's silent and vibration-free character stands out.
whatcar? OctOBEr 2017 | 13
First drive
Hyundai Verna petrol AT
Photography ashley baxter
New six-speed auto gearbox replaces the older four-speed unit. Verdict It's a great point A to B car with a very relaxed driving experience. A good portion of midsize sedan buyers look at buying petrol automatics. today, every single car in this segment – be it the Honda City or the Maruti Ciaz, the Volkswagen Vento or the Skoda rapid – gets a petrol automatic option. Hyundai has just launched the new-generation Verna, and while it retains the 1.6-litre petrol engine, the old four-speed unit is replaced with a new six-speed automatic transmission. the 1,591cc petrol engine makes 123hp and is marginally down on torque. But, like before, it’s extremely silent at idle with zero vibrations. once on the move, this motor feels effortless 14 | october 2017 whatcar?
to amble around in the city, with the gearbox shifting to a higher gear below 2,000rpm in a seamless manner. it’s only when you push it more that it holds onto a lower gear and pulls harder; then shifts
'The auto shifts seamlessly, and will even drop gears at the earliest opportunity.'
between 3,000 and 4,000rpm. it is here that the Verna’s engine turns from silent to noisy and is prominently audible. this makes the car feel out of its comfort zone when trying to overtake in
slow-moving traffic or while driving around in a bit of a hurry. performance in the mid-range is adequate at best and, under hard acceleration, this engine spins all the way until 6,500rpm
7-inch touchscreen is easy to use and loaded with tech.
Gearbox misses out on 'Sport' but gets manual mode.
Steering is light and weights up well. It's wrapped in leather.
480-litre boot is now larger than before; at the rear, space is at a premium; front seats are snug. reduced; there’s none of the bobbing movement that plagued the fluidic Verna. Compared to the diesel though, the handling doesn’t inspire as much confidence. Still, it turns in sharply, and the steering is light and weights up consistently. However, there's no real feel to it. Buyer’s file Engine size Price Power Torque Gearbox Fuel Tank L/W/H Boot space Tyres (f-r)
Hyundai is offering the Verna petrol automatic in two variants – EX and the rangetopping SX (o), which gets cooled front seats, sunroof, projector fog lights, 7.0-inch touchscreen with six speakers, Android Auto, Apple Carplay, navigation and more. For someone who wants a sedan to travel from point
A to B in comfort, with the convenience of an automatic, the Verna petrol auto is the one to go for. it might not be as comfortable and spacious as the Ciaz or the City, but with its premium features and baby-Elantra looks, the Verna petrol automatic is a practical buy. Saumil Shah
riVAls 1.6 (P) rs 10.49 – 12.49 lakh* 123hp at 6400rpm 151Nm at 4850rpm 6-speed automatic 45 litres 4440/1729/1475mm 480 litres 195/55 r16
Honda City Price rs 11.59 - 13.57 lakh* the city has grown in terms of premium feel. It's nice to drive and comfy to be chauffeurdriven in. It gets several features but is priced at a premium.
*ex-showroom, Delhi
before upshifting. At higher revs, it gets even boomier and feels strained. Even performance isn’t effortless at those engine speeds and power delivery is weak. in terms of numbers, the petrol automatic’s performance is near identical to the outgoing car, and 0-100kph comes up in 12.49sec. Unlike its competitors, the Verna’s auto 'box doesn’t have a ‘Sport’ or Low mode. What it has, though, is a tiptronic mode to change gears manually. there’s, however, a noticeable improvement in the Verna’s suspension tuning. the ride at low speeds is still comfy and absorbent and, at high speeds, body movement has significantly
whatcar? october 2017 | 15
First drive
Skoda Octavia RS
Photography Omkar Dhas
A performance-focused version of the Octavia that delivers a lot more driving pleasure. Verdict Fast, exciting and practical, the Octavia RS is also stunningly capable. When Skoda introduced the ‘rS’ version of the octavia with the first-generation model, it found a niche audience and plenty of admirers in india. a practical yet fast, performance-oriented car for a relatively affordable price was no mean feat. no wonder then that soon after the octavia facelift, Skoda has brought the rS version with a 230hp, 2.0-litre turbo-petrol engine, sporty suspension, sport seats, bigger wheels, an electronic differential and a throaty exhaust note, good enough to pass off as a full-blown sports sedan. But that’s all on paper. does it live up to expectations? Visually, the enhancements are quite subtle. the rS gets a sporty body kit, which includes a rear spoiler, dual exhausts and new design for the 17-inch alloy wheels. on the inside, it's all black. the all-black leather and black upholstery, with carbon-fibre accents on the dashboard and centre console, add to the aggressive and 16 | OCTOBER 2017 whaTCaR?
sporty appeal. also, the sport seats with firmer cushioning get alcantara upholstery with contrast red stitching. equipment-wise, the rS is as loaded as the top-end octavia, which means you get the long list of features including electric seats, touchscreen infotainment, navigation and auto parking. the same goes for the safety gizmos as well. Powering the rS is a 2.0-litre turbo-petrol engine making 230hp, which is 50hp over the standard car; an advantage you feel at the first dab of the accelerator as
the rS lunges forward. Put the shifter in ‘S’ for Sport and you can do the 0-100kph dash in just 6.6sec. But more than the number, it is the way it gets there that baffles you; the acceleration is so swift, you almost confuse the speedometer for the rev counter, which hauls the needle until almost 7,000rpm. there is no doubt that the rS can achieve its admirable top speed of 250kph, and what adds to the feeling of power is that the six-speed dual-clutch automatic gearbox works in perfect tandem
with the engine. You don't experience any delay during shifting, at either highways or city speeds. to add to the full experience, you also get paddle shifters, which work wonderfully with the dualclutch automatic gearbox. the rS features stiffer and lower suspension compared to the standard car and that keeps it composed in corners. however, the highlight is the addition of an electronic differential. this assures confidence in tight corners and helps keep the car in line to a great extent by manipulating
'You know it's a powerful car the second you hit the accelerator.' apart from being sporty, this car is practical and usable daily.
Touchscreen is responsive and easy; sound quality is great.
Flat-bottom steering wheel gets paddle shifters.
Sunroof brightens the cabin.
Rear spoiler adds sportiness.
Rear seat is very comfortable.
2-litre turbo-petrol engine makes 230hp and is very refined. well, with an almost 600-litre boot and spacious rear seats. While the fuel efficiency of 7.22kpl in the city and 13.10kpl on the highway is expectedly down on other petrol cars, it's
quite commendable for what it is. to sign off then, the rS is as close as it can get to the ideal balance between performance, practicality and, most importantly, price. however,
BuyeR’S file Engine size Price Power Torque Gearbox Tyres 0-100kph
Gets semi-auto parking feature too. with the rS launched at a price of rs 25.48 lakh, it is also only rs 3.86 lakh more than the fully loaded 1.8 tSi, and that’s a lot of car for the money. Jay Patil
RivalS 2.0 (P) Rs 25.49 lakh 230hp at 5500-6200rpm 350Nm at 1500-4500rpm 6-speed automatic 225/45 R17 6.65 sec
VW Polo GTI Price Rs. 20.69 lakh Offers an explosive performance and all the hot hatch thrills. Practicality is limited due to its two-door design.
*Ex-showroom, Delhi
power to either of the front wheels depending upon the situation. also, the sporty flatbottomed steering weighs up well at speeds and has got the right weight and accuracy for enjoyable cornering. coming to the ride, the suspension has been tuned with performance and indian road conditions in mind. the rS is 15mm lower than the standard car (as compared to the 300mm of the european car), but does admirably well on most bumpy roads. So, while you can properly enjoy a winding road, you don’t necessarily need to cringe when you drive over broken pieces of tarmac. however, it is stiffer than the standard car and will not favour the chauffeur-driven. at low speeds, even the relatively smaller bumps and potholes are registered into the cabin. and although it is better controlled than the standard car, there is a bit of pitching and bobbing at speed. the rS scores high on practicality as
Excellent, sporty front seats are in alcantara and leather.
whaTCaR? OCTOBER 2017 | 17
First drive
BMW 530i
Photography ashley baxter
This 5-series gets a 252hp turbo-petrol engine and an attractive price tag. Verdict A refined, luxurious sedan that delivers a sporty performance.
The BMW 5-series is a huge step forward from its earlier generation. The new car has impressed us with its refinement, ride quality, new features and opulent quality. We sampled the diesel engines earlier, and now finally, we drive the petrol 5-series, dubbed '530i', to see whether its as good as the similarly priced 520d. Don’t let the 530i’s moniker misguide you. This 5-series isn't powered by a 3.0-litre engine but a 1,998cc, fourcylinder turbo-petrol engine that makes 252hp, as on the 330i GT. What’s truly incredible is how refined this motor is. sound insulation 18 | october 2017 whatcar?
is so good, and even at crawling speeds there’s an eerie silence on the inside. On the move, there’s barely any sound filtering into the cabin. Performance is consistent and enjoyable all throughout. And the best bit is that, at mid
and high revs, there’s a linear pull from this turbo-petrol motor and power delivery is relentless. What’s really nice is that the claimed 0-100kph acceleration timing of this car is 6.2sec, merely 0.5sec slower than the much more
powerful and expensive 530d’s claimed time. And this engine emits a snarl at higher revs, making the entire experience really sporty. speaking of sporty, the eight-speed gearbox is incredibly quick and surprisingly clever. it knows
'With the petrol, you get the refinement and the performance.' twin exhausts, 18-inch wheels add to the sporty look of the 5.
Interior quality is top-notch. Dakota leather feels nice too.
10.3-inch touchscreen is crisp and offers gesture control too.
Dials change style based on the current driving mode.
Seats lack lumbar adjustment.
Key misses remote parking.
Drive modes stiffen suspension.
ride quality is excellent and sharp bumps are rounded off nicely. agility is surprisingly good for its size. the 530i at rs 52 lakh which is on par with the 520d that produces more torque and is more fuel efficient. Then, the diesel is available in two variants. so, then, why would
one buy this petrol 530i over its diesel counterpart? The simple answer is that if you really enjoy driving, this petrol variant will put a smile on your face, and if fuel
Buyer’s file Engine size Price Power Torque Gearbox Tyres (f-r) 0-100kph Top speed
bills aren’t something you’re worried about, the 530i is a refined sedan with a stellar performance that’s worth a serious consideration. Saumil Shah
rivals 2.0L (P) rs 52 lakh* 252hp at 5200rpm 350Nm at 1450-4800rpm 8-speed auto 245/45 r18 6.2 sec# 250kph#
Jaguar XF 25t Price rs 56.35 lakh* Strong performance, opulent cabin and sporty handling make the XF a serious contender. It blows away the bMw in terms of equipment too.
*ex-showroom, Delhi, #claimed
exactly in which gear you’d want it to be and obliges. To change gears manually, there are paddle shifters too – these respond well to aggressive downshifts and are a joy to use while driving this car swiftly on a winding section of road. BMW has equipped this car with ‘dynamic damper control’ that stiffens the suspension based on the driving mode selected. Between the various driving modes, it’s only when you really get moving that the difference in terms of suspension stiffness becomes a lot more evident. There’s also an ‘Adaptive’ mode that automatically adjusts this, and the engine, gearbox and steering response based on the driving style. This car feels quite agile to dart into corners despite its 4.9m length, and a lot of credit also goes to that fantastic steering, which, although electronic power assisted, feels very direct and infuses confidence in the driver. it doesn’t lose out on ride comfort either, and takes on bad roads very nicely and even rounds off sharper bumps. This sportLine trim of the 530i is well-equipped. While the interior design remains identical to the higher variants, this car misses out on quite a lot of kit including a 360-degree camera, fourzone climate control, remote control parking, harman Kardon 600W sound system, heads-up display or even a rear-seat entertainment package. What this car gets instead are auto LeD headlights, electric sunroof, 18-inch alloy wheels, 10.3-inch touchscreen infotainment system and navigation, and a multifunction display which changes the style of the dials based on the driving mode. The front seats, however, lack lumbar adjustment and memory function, and are basic in terms of comfort. The rear seat, on the other hand, is reasonably comfy with decent legroom and easy access. Firstly, BMW has priced
whatcar? october 2017 | 19
First drive
Maruti S-cross
The range-topping S-cross gets a facelift and a mild-hybrid system Verdict A striking new face, but a familiar experience
Photography omkar Dhas
Launched in 2015, the S-cross was the first Maruti to be sold out of the upmarket nexa retail network, and that premium position still holds true. it still serves as Maruti’s most premium model in the line-up, so, despite having sold a humble (by Maruti’s standards) 53,000 units in the past two years, the company is not giving up on it. The S-cross is now back, with a fresh face, a host of tweaks, and, for the first time, a mildhybrid system (ShVS). What is it? The biggest change is to the face in a bid to address the S-cross’ biggest weakness – its hatchback-like looks. it now gets a muscular new bonnet, with strong character lines that are visible even from the driver’s viewpoint. What really 20 | october 2017 whatcar?
catches your attention are the new headlamps and the large, SuV-like toothy grille with strong chrome accents. But it’s only the top alpha model that gets Led projector lights and Led daytime running lamps, while the lower three variants make do with halogens. new machine-polished 16-inch wheels look quite fetching, while the rear gets a new Led tail-lamp design.
variants, the dashboard uses a new, high-gloss piano-black treatment and also gets some satin-polished chrome trim. if you opt for the top alpha variant, you'll get leather upholstery as well. The rear remains quite spacious and comfortable, but there are no ac vents. The 375-litre boot is spacious and the seats can be reclined or folded flat in a 60:40 split.
What's it like on the inside? The interiors are quite familiar and largely carried over, and, though there are more softtouch materials, the overall cabin feels quite plasticky and lacks the luxury quotient of some cars in this price bracket. The touchscreen display is the same, but now supports both apple carPlay and android auto. On the top two
New alloys and tail-lamps freshen up the rear three-quarters.
The S-cross is well-equipped and includes auto headlamps, rain-sensing wipers, cruise control and more. however, the switchgear is shared with most Maruti products and you don't get the lovely full-colour, instrument panel multi-information display from the Baleno. Buyers at this price point would have liked the option of a sunroof too. happily, the S-cross now
'Ride quality is comfortable and highspeed highway stability is excellent.' offers dual airbags, aBS and rear isofix mounts as standard on all variants and the vehicle is compliant with the upcoming safety regulations. Soft-feel material for the dashboard is new.
top two models get new piano black and satin chrome trim.
Dials are similar but feature a light for the hybrid system.
New JK tyres are wider, better.
Mild-hybrid boosts efficiency.
rear air-con vents are missed.
handle broken roads without stress. high-speed behaviour is excellent too, and the car feels planted at triple-digit speeds through flowing corners. The new wider, more grippy tyres are partly to thank for this. We didn't get to test the outright fun factor on tight mountain roads, but the S-cross impresses with how it balances comfort and dynamics.
launched soon and pricing should be similar to the outgoing version, perhaps with some marginal increments. We expect the four variants to be priced between Rs 8.2 and Rs 11 lakh (ex-showroom, delhi). Maruti was unable to broaden its appeal with the introduction of petrol or automatic variants in this facelift. however, the S-cross continues to be just the right size to be a practical family car, while remaining compact enough to deal with
the urban crawl. its striking new face certainly gives it more road presence, but it still lacks the appeal of an SuV and doesn’t quite have the emotional clout of its rivals either. instead, the S-cross plays to Maruti’s strengths and it should cost an estimated Rs 1 lakh less than the creta 1.4. The S-cross is worth considering if you’re looking for a practical, nononsense family car at an attractive price. Rishaad Mody
Should i buy it? The updated S-cross will be Buyer’S file Engine size Price Power Torque Gearbox Boot space Tyres (f-r)
rivalS 1248cc turbo-diesel rs 8.2-11 lakh (estimated) 90hp at 4000rpm 200Nm at 1700-4500rpm 5-speed manual 375 litres 215/60 r17
Hyundai Creta 1.4 Price rs 9.77-11.98 lakh* More premium and SUVlike, but the good features are on the creta 1.6.
*ex-showroom, Delhi
What is it like to drive? The S-cross now comes with just one engine option, as Maruti has dropped the previous 1.6-litre diesel from the line-up, leaving just the 1.3-litre diesel. it's a loud motor, but the nVh levels are the best we've seen from the current Marutis, and it stays relatively quiet in the cabin until you rev the engine above 3,000rpm. With 90hp and 200nm of torque, the engine is adequate for the S-cross for normal driving, but it feels a bit underpowered under spirited driving, and there is quite a delay when you put your foot down. This means you have to use the slick fivespeed gearbox quite a bit. This hybrid system offers a mild torque-assist function that mainly aids fuel efficiency. it also features a start-stop system and brake energy regeneration. The system works seamlessly and the difference to the driving feel is negligible, but Maruti quotes a 7 percent increase in efficiency and a reduction in carbon dioxide outputs from around 115g/km to 105.5g/km. The S-cross has a welljudged suspension setup. Ride comfort is good, with a supple and planted feel that absorbs all but the nastiest potholes in the road. Factor in the generous ground clearance, and the S-cross can
whatcar? october 2017 | 21
First drive
Photography Kuldeep Chaudhari
Renault captuR
24 | OCTOBER 2017 whaTCaR?
An upmarket and stylish SUV from Renault for those who want a bit more panache from their car. Verdict Good blend of chic design and rugged mechanical bits.
whaTCaR? OCTOBER 2017 | 25
First drive
What is it? The latest addition to the SUV brigade in our country is the very stylish Renault Captur. A five-seater SUV with enough bling and dazzle, Renault says the SUV will sit between the Hyundai Creta and the Jeep Compass. The Captur definitely has the presence and the style to stand out from the crowd. The front looks futuristic, with the contoured bonnet and sleek headlights, and the big Renault logo dominates the grille, which features subtle chrome accents. Also stylish are the ‘C’-shaped fog lights with daytime running
'The cabin design and insulation are very impressive, befitting a car of this price.'
LED headlamps with dynamic indicators.
lamps and the silver faux metal skid plate at the front. The profile is fairly low slung with cladding, a chrome strip, a rising beltline and an attractive two-tone paint scheme. This top-of-theline ‘Platine’ variant also gets sharp-looking alloy wheels, typically Renault wrap-around tail-lights and splashes of tastefully executed chrome. This means the outside has been taken care of quite well. What about the inside though? What’s it like on the inside? The dashboard layout is completely different from
Funky 'c'-shaped fog lamps with DrLs.
the Duster's, apart from a few new bits such as the vents and the attractivelooking instrument binnacle. But there are also a lot of carried-over Duster bits like the touchscreen and steering wheel. Also, some of the plastics are hard and feel low-rent, depriving you of the plush feel you would expect from a car in this segment. Also, even at its lowest setting, the seating position feels too high, which, if you factor in the sloping windshield, makes it quite uncomfortable for taller drivers. Also, there is no space in the footwell to rest
210mm ground clearance improves stance. whatcar? OctOBEr 2017 | 27
Front seats are set high, so while visibility is good, tall drivers struggle for headroom.
7-inch touchscreen is identical to the Kwid's. however, the interface is different.
Golden inserts look nice and add a bit of a premium feel to the otherwise vanilla interiors.
Instrument panel design both attractive and practical. Gets a digital speedometer too.
your left foot, and the centre armrest is intrusive and fouls your elbow. However, the seats are rather good. The cushioning is nice and firm, which means long drives won’t be a problem, and the seat upholstery feels upmarket with the dual-tone theme. Cabin refinement is much better than that of the Duster and most of the ambient noise is taken
care of. You get navigation, Bluetooth telephony, but no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. However, it isn’t as responsive or as vibrant as the competition and makes for an overall dull experience. The new butterfly-shaped instrument cluster, on the other hand, looks modern, sharp and comes with a digital speedometer. Apart from that, Renault will offer
customisation bits like colour options for the centre console. Moving to the rear, the seats are nice and supportive, and you have enough legroom and headroom. However, it isn't as wide as the Creta and fitting three large-frame adults will be difficult. Also, the middle passenger is likely to struggle for legroom as the Captur gets rear AC that which protrude out. The
rising beltline also limits visibility out for the rear passengers. And at 392 litres, the boot space is less than the Duster's; it can be expanded to a substantial 1,352 litres by flipping the rear backrest. Safety has been taken care of diligently as well, with the Captur getting six airbags, ABS with ESP, hill hold control and Isofix points in the rear for a child seat.
392-litre boot not as large as Duster's.
white-black leatherette seats look nice.
Front seats are very supportive and comfy. whatcar? OctOBEr 2017 | 29
First drive
What’s it like to drive? The Captur will come with two engine options – a 106hp, 1.5-litre petrol engine and a 110hp, 1.5-litre diesel engine that powers the Duster as well. We got a chance to sample the diesel engine that's mated to a six-speed manual transmission. At startup, the diesel clatter is evident but the motor smoothens out as soon as you spin it faster. Performance is adequate, but you do feel that the Captur could have 30 | OctOBEr 2017 whatcar?
'The Dusterbased suspension can take whatever the road throws at it.'
done with a bit more power. So, while on highways, it's not exciting, but it does the job fairly well if you stay in the mid-range, and punch and acceleration are sufficient. The gearing too is well-sorted, and the Captur feels fairly tractable as long as you keep the rev counter above the 2,000rpm mark. It's a neat handler at high speeds, the SUV stays well in control and there is no nervousness even when you go over big undulations. Bends and
corners are handled with ease, and apart from some slight body roll, the Captur stays well in line. And the steering, too, is full of feel. One of the Captur’s strongest points is its ride quality. Like the Duster, the Captur is absolutely unfazed by bumps and potholes, and it stays flat and composed over broken roads as well. Now, even though Renault hasn’t announced the addition of the AWD Captur, you will be impressed with this front-
Engines are shared with the Duster; plastics on the dash are not soft-touch.
Glovebox is too small for storage; floating centre console looks good.
Gets auto headlamps and wipers; smart key not practical like smaller key fobs.
Should I buy one? Renault is looking to price the Captur aggressively at an estimated Rs 12-18 lakh, which means it will
be cheaper than the Jeep Compass, and will target the Hyundai Creta. The car does have a lot of appeal. The European styling, the rugged chassis and suspension, and
the tried and tested diesel engine, the Captur has it all. Add to that the multiple customisation options for the exterior and interior, along with premium features like
Buyer’s file
rivals
Engine size Price L/W/H Power
Hyundai Creta rs 9.30-14.55 lakh*
Torque
1.5 (P)/1.5 (D) rs 12-18 lakh (est.)* 4329/1813/1619mm 106hp at 5600rpm/ 110hp at 4000rpm 142Nm at 4000rpm/ 240Nm at 1750rpm
auto headlights, swiping indicators, and rain sensing wipers to name a few. This is a car that definitely deserves to be on your shortlist. Saumil Shah
*Ex-showroom, Delhi
wheel drive variant as it's quite capable too. The 210mm ground clearance certainly helps its case and it also features hill start assist and traction control. Efficiency can also be expected to be impressive as the 1.5-litre K9K engine has shown us it's frugal nature time and again.
the creta comes with nice engines and sophisticated interiors. It's easy to drive and overall quality is great. whatcar? OctOBEr 2017 | 31
News
Aggressive pricing for Tata's Nexon compact SUV
Feature-rich, stylish SUV undercuts EcoSport massively; priced lower than Brezza too. The past few models from Tata Motors' stable have made everyone sit up and take notice of the brand, and this is thanks to the attractive packaging and greater value proposition. The carmaker succeeded in doing this yet again with the muchawaited stylish Nexon compact SUV that was launched at a price of Rs 5.85 lakh for the petrol and Rs 6.85 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) for the diesel. There are two new engines to choose from – a 1.2 turbo petrol and a 1.5 turbo diesel, both making 110hp, paired with a six-speed manual gearbox. Interestingly, the carmaker expects the diesel variant to account for 80 percent of overall Nexon sales.
The compact SUV packs in plenty of kit and offers standard features such as dual front airbags, ABS with EBD, reach and rake steering adjust and multiple drive modes
(Eco, City, Sport). In fact, the Nexon is the only model in the segment to offer multiple drive modes for both engine options. In addition to the standard features, higher variants
get an eight-speaker, 6.5inch touchscreen, Harman infotainment system with Android Auto, automatic climate control, projector headlamps with daytime running lamps, 16-inch alloys, rear parking camera, driver’s seat height adjust, a smart key with push-button start and a dual-tone roof. The fully loaded Nexon diesel undercuts its key rivals, the EcoSport by Rs 1.37 lakh and the Brezza by Rs 46,000. Tata Motors is looking to ride the SUV wave in the automotive market and is pitching the Nexon as an attractive buy for customers looking for a feature-rich compact SUV that stands out from the crowd.
VW Passat to launch with diesel engine only Production of Volkswagen's new Passat sedan has commenced at its Aurangabad facility, with launch slated for October 10, 2017. The carmaker, however, has announced that the premium sedan will be sold in India with only a diesel engine, at least initially. The engine will be a 177hp, 2.0-litre TDI unit paired with a six-speed DSG automatic gearbox. VW had formerly hinted at
launching the Passat in plug-in hybrid GTE form and even displayed the car at the 2016 Auto Expo. However, it is not clear whether this will become a reality as hybrids have been sidelined by the government in its push for full electrics, and now under GST, it also attracts a higher tax. This launch will mark Passat's return after the previous-gen model was discontinued in 2014.
The Passat will count Superb, Camry and accord as key rivals. 32 | OCTOBER 2017 whaTCaR?
Jeep Compass aces European crash test The Jeep Compass has scored a full 5-star rating in the European New Car Assessment Programme (Euro NCAP). The Compass achieved a high 90 percent in adult occupant protection and 83 percent in child safety. Dummy readings indicated good protection of the knees and thighs of both the driver and passenger. The test car was equipped
with six airbags and autonomous braking system, safety features standard on the European-spec car. While the results speak volumes about the Compass’ body shell’s crashworthiness, the safety ratings are not exactly reflective of the India model. The Indian Compass gets two airbags as standard and doesn’t come with autonomous braking.
GST impact: Mid-size, luxury cars and SUVs get dearer due to hike in cess If you are in the market looking for a mid-size, luxury car or SUV, be prepared to shell out more as the Goods and Services Tax (GST) council recently decided to hike cess on these categories of vehicles. The additional cess on midsize vehicles has been raised by 2 percent to 17 percent, on large vehicles by 5 percent to 20 percent and on SUVs by 7 percent to 22 percent. This makes for a total tax incidence on each of the above categories at 45, 48 and 50 percent, respectively. The council has refrained from hiking the cess on small cars – under four metres in length, and with engine capacity less than 1,200cc (petrol) and 1,500cc (diesel) – on vehicles with 13 seats and on hybrid vehicles. Many carmakers, including
Honda, Hyundai, Jeep and Toyota, were among the first to announce price hikes and others are expected to follow soon.
GST: A SHORT-LIVED BOON FOR CAR BUYERS Category Small petrol cars (length <4m) Swift, Kwid, Grand i10, i20, Dzire, etc. Small diesel cars (length <4m) Swift, i20, Dzire, etc. Mid-size cars (length >4m and engine <1500cc) City, Vento, etc. Big cars (length >4m and engine >1500cc) E-class, 3-series, etc. SUVs (length>4m; engine > 1500cc; ground clearance >170mm) Creta, Compass, Fortuner hybrids (Camry hybrid, Prius)
Honda BR-V finally gets touchscreen, rear camera
When Honda launched the BR-V in India, the absence of a touchscreen infotainment system – a common feature in most cars these days – was a deal breaker for many potential customers. Moreover, another key feature which was sorely missed (considering the car's size) was a rear parking camera and sensors. Now, in a welcome move, the Japanese carmaker recently introduced a touchscreen infotainment
Honda increased prices of the City and BR-V by as much as Rs 18,500. Hyundai hiked prices for its new Verna sedan within days of the car’s
launch by up to Rs 29,090, while certain variants of the Creta have become pricier by as much as Rs 55,375. Toyota also announced price increases of Rs 78,000 for the Innova Crysta and Rs 1.6 lakh for the Fortuner. Jeep’s Compass is also costlier now by Rs 21,000 to Rs 72,000, depending on the variant. Korean carmaker Hyundai criticised the GST council’s move saying it would hurt demand ahead of the festive season.
system, a rear parking camera and sensor in the SUV. The touchscreen and rear camera is available on the top-spec VX trim, while the rear parking sensor is available on the 'S' and higher trims. The AVN unit with Digipad is the one used on the City, with MirrorLink support for smartphones, voice command, Bluetooth, MP3, two USB slots and an HDMI-in port. Prices start at Rs 12.27 lakh (petrol) and Rs 13.22 lakh (diesel) (ex-showroom, Delhi).
Before GST 31.40% 33.40% 46.60% 51.80% 55.30%
Post GST 29% 31% 43% 43% 43%
Revised GST 29% 31% 45% 48% 50%
30.30%
43%
43%
Maruti WagonR hits two million sales milestone Maruti Suzuki recently announced that its WagonR hatchback crossed a sales milestone of two million units. First introduced in 1999, the WagonR is one of the bestselling vehicles in India and has always featured on the monthly list of top 10 cars by sales. The hatch sold 14,571 units in August 2017 compared to 13,907 during August last year. These sales figures have been helped in part by its potential as a taxi and fleet vehicle, and because
Maruti has continuously upgraded the model with features such as dual airbags, multiple fuel options, ABS and an AMT gearbox. Maruti claims that nearly 45 percent of WagonR customers are first-time buyers. It said that the automated manual version accounted for 16 percent of total sales. With this, the WagonR becomes the third model in the country after the Maruti 800 and Alto, to cross two million in cumulative sales.
Nearly 45 percent of wagonR customers are first-time buyers. whaTCaR? OCTOBER 2017 | 33
News Tata introduces specialedition Tiago Wizz Most carmakers get into a frenzy to introduce specialedition models or feature additions to their vehicles ahead of the festive season to boost sales. Not one to miss out, Tata Motors launched the Tiago Wizz, a special-edition version on the mid-spec Tiago. Priced at Rs 4.52 lakh for the petrol and Rs 5.30 lakh for the diesel variant (both prices ex-showroom, Delhi), the special-edition Tiago
comes with a contrast black roof, and red highlights on the grille, wheel caps and interiors. It also gets roof rails as standard. And, since it is based on the mid-spec XM trim, the Tiago Wizz doesn't get alloy wheels. Mechanically, the Tiago Wizz variant comes with the same 1.0-litre diesel and a 1.2-litre petrol engine as the standard model.
Toyota restores 17-inch wheels on Innova Crysta and is a common feature in Mahindra's micro-hybrid technology. Interestingly, this feature has been added to the automatic trims of the Fortuner as well as a part of a minor update. Coming back to the Crysta, the base GX trim (only eightseater) gets more features like rear-seat centre armrest, driver-seat height adjuster and rear air conditioning. The door ajar warning function for each door is now standard across the range. Notably, Toyota has also equipped the V trim with GPS navigation.
The Innova Crysta is once again available with larger 17-inch wheels, with tyres that have been beefed up with stiffer sidewalls. Following instances of tyre damage under heavy load on Innova Crystas equipped with 17-inch rims earlier, Toyota had replaced them with smaller 16-inchers last year. The upgrade, however, is effective only on top-spec Crysta Z trim and the Innova Touring Sport. Furthermore, the Crysta sees the addition of engine start-stop function, which enhances fuel economy
New fully loaded TUV300 variant launched Toyota expands Fortuner and an upgraded 7.0-inch Mahindra has launched a line-up with TRD Sportivo infotainment system equipped range-topping variant of its TUV300 SUV with additional equipment to spur the car buyer's interest. Dubbed 'T10', the top-spec model gets alloys wheels, a rear spoiler and black chrome inserts on the front fog lamps and grille. Mahindra has also introduced a new white paint shade for the butchlooking SUV. Additions to the cabin include faux leather upholstery
with maps from MapmyIndia, navigation and the Mahindra Blue Sense app. The SUV is priced at Rs 9.75 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) and Rs 9.66 lakh (exshowroom, Mumbai). The T10 is available with the option of both manual and AMT gearboxes and the choice of a dual-tone paint scheme. It is powered by the same 1.5-litre engine that makes 100hp and 240Nm, found in other variants.
The Fortuner has been a hugely popular choice among buyers looking for a premium, capable SUV. In an effort to expand its lineup, Toyota has introduced a special-edition TRD Sportivo variant of the burly SUV at a price of Rs 31.01 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) The 2017 Fortuner TRD Sportivo is available only in
a pearl white exterior paint shade, and gets unique front and rear bumper extensions, a 'TRD'-badged radiator grille, and special 18-inch alloy wheels. On the inside, it gets red stitching on the seats and other interior bits, and 'TRD Sportivo' badging. The SUV is powered by a 177hp, 2.8-litre diesel engine mated to an automatic transmission.
additional features include bumper extensions, 18-inch alloys. whatcar? OctOBEr 2017 | 35
Trusted even at 5,374 ft. MAKINO ‘NOW’ in Passenger Vehicles
Mak/BT/08/17
Actual Coordinates: 33.32 N 75.77 E, Kishtwar, Jammu & Kashmir
DISC BRAKE PADS & BRAKE SHOES FOR 4 WHEELERS.
www.makino.in
TM
TM
TM
TM
T: +91-11-28753965 E: sales@makino.in
News launches and Inconel exhaust, new 20-inch forged alloy wheels and a carbon-fibre rear wing.
Audi Q7 40 TFSI
Audi Q7 40 TFSi Price: Rs 67.76 – 74.43 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) The 252hp, 2.0-litre turbopetrol version of the Q7 flagship SUV has been launched with two trim levels – Premium Plus and Technology. Both trims get the same level of equipment as their respective diesel counterparts, featuring Audi's 'Parking System Plus' with 360-degree surroundview camera, automatically adjusting LED headlamps, electronically controlled air suspension with variable damping, Audi’s Virtual Cockpit, a 12.3-inch touchscreen display and a panoramic sunroof. TATA Tigor XM Price: Rs 4.99 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) The Tigor’s new mid-spec XM variant slots between the base XE and the higher-spec XT. It retains the mechanical setup of its siblings. The Tigor XM gets manual central locking with key, all four power windows, speedsensitive auto door locks, follow-me-home lamps, an LED fuel gauge, full fabric seats, interior lamp with theater-dimming function and full wheel covers.
Force gurkhA Price: Rs 8.45 – 11.48 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) The new Gurkha has the same 2.6-litre diesel mill, putting out 85hp and 230Nm, mated to a five-speed manual; though it is now BS-IV compliant. Sold in two trim levels, the Xplorer is available as a hardtop and a soft-top, three-door or five-door, with capacity to seat five or seven people and permanent four-wheel drive. The Xpedition is a five-door model that can seat up to nine but only gets rear-wheel drive. renAulT duSTer SAndSTorM ediTion Price: Rs 10.40 – 11.70 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) Available in both 85hp and 110hp versions of the K9K diesel engine, the Duster Sandstorm Edition gets unique
exterior paint shade options with body graphics and body-coloured door handles, a bumper extension up front, round fog lamps and new 16-inch alloys. On the inside, it gets special dual-tone seat covers. It is also equipped with a touchscreen infotainment system and gets safety features like ABS and dual front airbags. JAguAr F-Type SVr Price: Rs 2.63 crore (ex-showroom, Delhi) Jaguar has introduced the range-topping F-Type SVR in India. It gets the 5.0-litre supercharged V8 motor tuned to produce 575hp and 700Nm, mated to an eightspeed automatic that sends power to all four wheels. It also gets some weight-saving equipment like the titanium
Renault Duster Sandstorm Edition
niSSAn MicrA FAShion ediTion Price: Rs 6.09 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) A limited-run model, the Micra Fashion Edition, developed in collaboration with United Colors of Benetton, is only available with the 64hp, 1.2-litre petrol engine mated to a CVT gearbox. It gets two new exterior colours – Fashion Black and Fashion Orange – sporty decals on the sides and an off-centre bold stripe. An updated 6.2-inch infotainment system, orange-coloured interiors with piano black finish and designer floor mats and headrests with the UCB logo are the changes. ToyoTA eTioS croSS X ediTion Price: Rs 6.64 – 8.09 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) A special edition for the festive season, the Etios Cross X Edition is powered by the same 80hp, 1.2-litre petrol, 90hp, 1.5-litre petrol and 68hp 1.4-litre diesel engines mated to a five-speed manual transmission. However, it gets a bevy of cosmetic changes on the outside and inside, along with dual-front airbags, ABS with EBD and Isofix child seat mounts. dATSun redigo gold 1.0 Price: Rs 3.69 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) The Redigo Gold 1.0 is a special-edition model for the festive season. Based on the higher-spec T (O) trim, it is equipped with central locking, keyless entry, a lock/unlock button on the central console, front power windows and a driver-side airbag. The special edition adds an audio system with Bluetooth connectivity and a reverse parking sensor. Mechanically, the Redigo Gold 1.0 is unchanged. whatcar? OctOBEr 2017 | 37
Buying & owning
How to get the best out of your brakes Braking is one of the most critical performance parameters of a car. Here are some driving and maintenance tips to keep your brakes in tip-top condition. Story Mark Narakaden
After the horn, it’s probably the brakes that are the Indian motorist’s favourite component in a car. on any given day, a driver faces myriad situations – signals, potholes, unmarked speed breakers, unruly road users – that have them stepping on the brakes frequently. Depressing the brake pedal results in the brake pads rubbing against the brake disc which slows down the wheels and the vehicle. over time, the braking material on the pads degenerates due to heat generated by the friction. So, it is important to realise that brakes are consumables. You can surely maintain the effectiveness over longer periods of time by braking correctly and with some basic care. So, here's how you can get the best out of your car's brakes. 38 | october 2017 whatcar?
Intuitive driving reading the road ahead correctly avoids the need to slam the brakes. observation is key in developing a strong on-road intuition. for example, when you see a red signal on in the distance, it is always better to coast up to it rather than drive up fast, then hit the brakes and wait for the light to turn green. With practice, you’ll be able to develop this driving intuition to better negotiate successive signals, avoid bunched up traffic, adjust speeds for turns, etc. however, always be mindful of elements like the road, weather and the condition of your vehicle, which are critical factors that can have an impact on your braking reaction time.
Do not follow traffic too closely. It increases the probability of using the brakes. Progressive braking When slowing down, apply the brakes gently. Locking the wheels wears out the brake components. Braking should be
Typical STopping DiSTanceS 32kph 6m 48kph 9m 64kph 12m 80kph 15m 96kph 18m
well-maintained brakes along with systems like abS helps reduce stopping distances considerably. here are some typical braking distances and the reaction times in metres.
6m = 12m 14m
= 23m
24m
reactIoN tIMe
braKING DIStaNce
= 36m 38m
= 53m = 73m
55m
112kph 21m
75m
= 96m
ServIce check
Progressive braking preserves the brakes and makes for a smooth drive experience. friction there is. for example, stopping from 110kph, rather than 90, causes the brakes to dissipate almost a third more of energy, and in the process, a lot more braking material gets used up. therefore, you must keep a constant pace and not overspeed unnecessarily.
progressive – start with light pressure on the pedal, increase it as necessary, and release the pedal in a smooth manner as well when done with braking. By following this, the entire process will be smooth even for the vehicle’s occupants, as there won't be any uncomfortable jolts. this technique will also help reduce wear and tear on the braking components, tyres and suspension. Additionally, motorists behind you will also get valuable milliseconds to react to your braking manoeuvre. If you drive a car without ABS, this is even more important. keeping moderate speeds Coming to a quick stop from a higher speed is really bad for brakes as they wear out due to friction. And higher the speed the more
Overheated brakes nothing damages your brakes more than overheating. In cases where you have to use the brakes continuously – like when driving downhill for prolonged periods – the chances for overheating are high. And after a while, their effectiveness also reduces drastically. to prevent this, use the gears when you are descending to bring the car to a halt and allow the brakes to cool down. But it is important to not keep the pedal depressed when doing this as the heat from the pads could get transferred to the disc rotor and result in the disc getting warped.
'After hard braking, do not hold the car on the brakes at a traffic signal.'
Brakes are critical for driving safely and therefore it is vital to keep them in tip-top shape at all times. In case you notice anything amiss, do not hesitate to get it checked. A routine brake check-up usually involves the following. n Measurement of front and rear brake pad wear: If worn out beyond permissible limits, installation of new brake pads (disc brake) or shoes (drum brake) is in order. n Measurement of disc or drum wear: resurface or replace brake rotors or drums if required. n Brake fluid check: Check for brake fluid level. If brakes are spongy, brake-bleeding is necessary. n Vacuum hose inspection: Get the vacuum hose from the inlet manifold to the servo checked for cracks and leaks. replace the hose at the earliest, if you spot any damage.
carrying a small bottle of brake fluid is always handy. easy to top up if required.
says… It goes without saying that good brakes are a lifeline while driving. And with some simple measures, correct driving techniques and regular maintenance, you can keep them effective for a longer period of time. whatcar? october 2017 | 39
advertorial
the hills are calling Barot: Anglersâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; Paradise
Little mountain villages greeted us as we drove from Mandi to Barot.
No exploratioN of hidden travel gems can be complete without an expedition into the mountains. they, after all, are a treasure trove of hidden gems, of little picturesque villages tucked into the fold of imposing mountains clad in green, brown and white. Hyundai had sent over the tucson for our latest journey, and we packed it up and set off for a tiny village called Barot hidden in the hills of Himachal pradesh.
Cardiogram roads
We began our drive from Chandigarh, quickly covering ground as we drove through its wide boulevards and onto a wide, well-paved highway. a couple of hours later, however, the straights almost completely disappeared, replaced by curving and bending and snaking mountain roads. the road to Barot took us through the crowded and bustling town of Mandi. post Mandi, it transformed into a picturesque route flanked by wooded mountain faces on one side and steep, heart-stopping falls on the other. as i flicked the tucson from one corner into another, i was struck by its lack of body roll and the absence of that top-heavy feeling so commonly felt in SUVs. Towering mountains and heart-stopping drops awed and intimidated us.
anglers’ Paradise
Barot was founded in the 1920s for the Shanan Hydel project. Built on the banks of the river Uhl, the Uhl barrage and reservoir are the defining features of the village’s geography. its claim to fame, at least from a travel perspective, is the abundance of trout in its river water. anglers will absolutely love the fishing experience in Barot: sitting on a rock overlooking the flowing river while surrounded by high mountains on either side is quite an idyllic scene. Barot is best enjoyed by those looking to cut off from their regular lives and just take a few days’ breather. there isn’t much to do here except go for long walks in the hills, drive around the neighbouring mountains, spend hours trying to catch some trout and generally enjoy the crispness and cleanness of the mountain air.
Chasing stars
if you’re into stargazing or just want to spend some time lying under a brilliantly twinkling sky, the hills around Barot offer you ample opportunity to do so. around 15km out of Barot, we found the perfect spot to do a bit of stargazing: the sky was lit up by hundreds of thousands of twinkling stars, and amidst all of
them lay the Milky Way, a long stretch of pale white against the black sky.
Breaking the sPell
the few days we spent in Barot felt surreal. Barot is big enough to be stocked with basic amenities like a market and electricity as well as some frivolities like packaged ice-cream, but at the same time, it is small enough to feel like an escapade, a refuge. every morning in Barot is invigorating, every evening soothing. i must admit, getting to Barot is not an easy task – the drive is quite arduous – but if you have a nimble and comfortable car like we did, it’s actually quite a pleasure. By the end of it, i was loath to leave, afraid that leaving Barot would feel like breaking the spell.
Comparison
Family feud
The Volkswagen Polo GTI, until now, was king of the hills but the stakes just got higher with the entry of the all-new third-gen Skoda Octavia RS. So, which one is better?
Skoda Octavia RS List price rs 25.48 lakh Performance-oriented version of the octavia which looks as fast as it drive. 42 | october 2017 whatcar?
Volkswagen Polo GTI List price rs 20.69 lakh Vw’s two-door hot hatch with a firecracker of an engine powering it.
All prices ex-showroom, Delhi
Photography ashley baxter
The conTenders
Performance, until now, wasn’t really a priority for car buyers and the rising fuel prices haven’t helped either. But there is still a class of buyers who demand more performance from their cars. However, performance cars are still at its infancy. Yes, we have the Volkswagen Polo Gti that gives buyers a taste of performance, but now, Skoda has launched the hot octavia rS and it costs
almost rs 6 lakh more than the VW. Both use powerful turbo-petrol engines, both get focused and stiffer suspensions and both have a raspy exhaust note that turns heads everywhere. While the octavia rS is more powerful, the Gti scores higher in terms of being lighter and more nimble. the biggest similarity by far, however, is the 0-100kph time that is just 0.1sec apart.
Skoda Octavia RS vs Volkswagen Polo GTI
'The dash to 100kph is only 0.10 second apart, with the VW being slower.' Suspension masks speeds, feels at home in high-speed corners.
What are they like to drive? first impressions in the octavia rS are very positive. the 230hp turbo-petrol engine catapults the rS swiftly, and the pace is searing. in normal ‘D’ or drive more, the rS feels just as exciting, but it is the more focused ‘S’ or Sport mode that really brings out its character. engage this, and you have a more responsive engine, faster gearshifts from the six-speed DSG gearbox,
which hold the gears right up to the 6,800rpm redline and, of course, that raw and raspy exhaust note that crackles and pops between shifts. the engine has a wide powerband which means you can overtake with minimal hesitance. the paddle shifters too, are well calibrated and shifts are instant after every flex of the fingers. Handling is excellent. the stiffer suspension, lower ride height and the superb grip from the michelin Pilot Sport tyres help its case; it also has a lot to do with the electronic differential which keeps the rS from understeering. all combined, the result is flat and composed cornering with loads of grip from both the front and rear. You do feel the length no doubt, but as you go faster, it shrinks around you. Downsides? Well, the ride does get jarring after a long stint over broken roads, and it feels a bit skittish on mid-corner bumps, but that’s about it. the VW Gti may not have the show, but it too has a burly exhaust note, and if you mash the throttle you could easily get a similar heart rate. the Gti has a 190hp, 1.8-litre engine mated to a seven-speed DSG gearbox. Yes, it is a bit down on power, but with almost a 150kg advantage, the acceleration is just as exciting. in the sprint from 0-100kph, the octavia rS crosses the line at 6.65sec and the Gti at 6.75sec. that said, gearshifts do feel jerky and you get quite a bit of that ‘head nod’ every time it upshifts. the Gti may not have the outright grip
All-black colour theme overall design is identical to octavia but are all-black here.
Flat-bottomed steering red stitching adds sportiness and suede trip looks great.
The Polo GTI has huge grip and it just darts into tight corners.
Design Interiors are identical to Polo Gt, which costs half as much.
Short on features a lot of kit missing; thankfully paddle shifters aren’t. whatcar? october 2017 | 43
Comparison SkOda OcTaVIa RS
electric sunroof is nice to have; gets several practical features like air con vents and twin mobile charging ports at the rear.
Skoda octavia rS
Rs 20,68,895 Rs 89,564 Rs 2,13,190 Rs 24,02,551 NA
1st year 31%
1st year 29%
2nd year 21%
2nd year 21%
3rd year 19%
3rd year 18%
Aftersales & service ll
ll ll
ll
Average
ll
lllllll lll ll ll ll l
lllll llll lll ll ll
lllll llll lll ll ll
Good
touchscreen is slick to use and doubles as camera display.
llllllll lllll lll lll ll ll ll ll ll
ll
ll
lllllll lll ll ll ll l
ll
ll
ll
Poor
ll
ll
Average
ll
ll
llllllll lllll lll lll ll ll ll ll ll
Economy
Economy Tank Range
14.45 kpl* 50 litres 722 km
Good
Poor
Screen is nice to use, but misses apple and android connectivity.
Size 1798cc, 4 cyls Peak power 192hp at 5400-6200rpm Peak torque 250Nm at 1250-5300rpm
top speed
0-100kph
16.35 kpl* 45 litres 736 km
Engine and performance
Size 1984cc, 4 cyls Peak power 230hp at 5500-6200rpm Peak torque 350Nm at 1500-4500rpm
top speed
0-100kph
250 kph
6.65 sec
depreciation each year
ll
Economy
Engine and performance
Prices (delhi)
ll
Volkswagen Polo GtI List Price rs 20.69 lakh
Economy Tank Range
Volkswagen Polo GtI
Rs 25,48,644 Rs 1,00,327 Rs 3,05,408 Rs 29,59,326 NA
Skoda octavia rS List Price rs 25.48 lakh
6.75 sec
233 kph
Test Figures
Test Figures
Acceleration 50-80kph through the gears
Acceleration 50-80kph through the gears
1.98 sec 20-80kph in kickdown 4.07 sec 40-100kph in kickdown 4.73 sec Braking 80-0kph 22.73m
2.02 sec 20-80kph in kickdown 4.18 sec 40-100kph in kickdown 4.46 sec Braking 80-0kph NA
Buying details
Buying details
http://www.skoda-auto.co.in
http://www.volkswagen.co.in
relaxed and this allows you to do long hours comfortably.
of the rS but it still attacks corners like a terrier. the combination of the compact dimensions, stiffened suspension, sharp steering and electronic differential setup is so good, you almost forget the lack of rigidity from the Polo body shell. What’s surprising is that, even at cruising speeds, the Gti feels
What are they like inside? ‘racy’ seems like a safe word to describe the rS’ interiors. all black with a hint of red in the stitching with carbon-fibre accents on the centre console. You also have the superb sport seats covered in alcantara,
equipment 3 Standard 7 Not available
Skoda Octavia RS Volkswagen Polo GTI 44 | october 2017 whatcar?
Climate control
Touchscreen Infotainment
Reverse camera
Cruise control
LED headlamps
Electric folding mirrors
Paddle shifters
Airbags
3 3
3 3
3 7
3 7
auto 3
3 7
3 3
8 6
*Claimed
stats, specs and ratings
What it will cost you
Ex-showroom price Insurance Registration (& taxes) On-road price Deals
Sporty seats draped in alcantara (suede) are very supportive; space and comfort-wise, it’s as good as the regular octavia.
Skoda Octavia RS vs Volkswagen Polo GTI
VOlkSWaGen POlO GTI
two-door looks sporty but hampers practicality on a daily basis; gets some smart bits like underseat storage tray. with the ‘rS’ logo on the headrests. the seats are very comfortable and supportive as well; the cushioning is a tad firm but you need that with all the performance on offer. apart from that, everything else is lifted straight from the top-end octavia, which means you get the good build, plush materials, and buttons and switches that work superbly. in the rear, the seat is set a tad low and could have done with a bit more underthigh support. that said, there is ample legroom and headroom even for large-frame adults. the Gti, however, is on the back foot in comparison. the dashboard is strikingly similar to the Polo. the build quality is undoubtedly good and there is tartan fabric on the seats, which is interesting, but the feel-good factor isn’t a high as on the rS. also, the front seats have extra side bolstering to support you. Distinguishing features on the Gti are the flat-bottomed steering wheel, sporty instrument cluster and a precise rotary adjuster for the seat backrest. also, being a two-door, access to the rear seats is slightly difficult, and once seated, it is alarmingly cramped for adults; a far cry from the spacious cabin of the rS. equipment and safety the rS comes with a lengthy equipment list. taking centre stage on the dashboard is an 8.0-inch touchscreen featuring apple carPlay, android auto and mirrorlink. You get navigation, Bluetooth telephony, automatic parking with front and rear parking sensors. You also get electrically adjustable
front seats, rear ac vents, a sunroof and cruise control. the highlight, however, is the front electronic differential which helps the rS corner with more confidence, and is a boon in terms of safety as well. Speaking of safety, you get eight airbags, aBS with eBD, ESC and Isofix points for child seats as well. the Gti is falls way behind on the equipment front. While it does get a touchscreen, it’s a more basic one. there isn’t apple or android connectivity, and it even misses out on rear parking camera. What you do get is Bluetooth telephony, paddle shifters, full leD headlights with Drls and cruise control. Safety, however, is diligently looked after. You get six airbags, aBS with EBD, and Isofix points in the rear. Buying and owning Both these performance cars are available in just a single trim. the Gti is a full cBu and what you see is what you get. there are no options and no add-ons, and it’s the same for the octavia rS. So, the Rs 5 lakh deficit is all there is separating these two. the octavia rS launched at rs 25.48 lakh is on the higher side, but with it, you also get Skoda’s impressive, 4 year/1,00,000km warranty. the VW Gti has a huge advantage with an ex-showroom price of just rs 20.69 lakh, along with a 2 years/unlimited kilometre warranty. You can further extend this for 1 year/80,000km or 2 years/1,00,000km, which is advisable as its parts will be pricey.
Sporty front seats are very supportive while driving fast; space at the rear is very poor and getting into the back is a bit challenging.
OUR VeRdIcT BotH tHe octaVia rS and VW Gti give those who love driving that requisite dose of performance and sportiness. While the Gti is rs 11.5 lakh pricier than a Polo Gt tSi, the rS is only rs 3.5 lakh more expensive than a petrol octavia, so relatively, the rS is better value. that said, the Gti’s compact dimensions will be loved by hot hatchbacks fans. its two-door design and subtle exteriors enhancements do very little to distinguish it from the regular Polo, not good when someone is spending rs 20 lakh. missing features, cramped cabin and limited practicality only weaken its case. and that’s why the octavia rS wins. With a punchy 230hp engine and sharp handling, this car is even better to drive. its looks have been properly enhanced and you get all the features and practicality of the octavia. So, the rS is a comfy, spacious sedan that’s also capable of satisfying your need for speed, and clearly the one to go for.
1
Skoda Octavia rS
For Punchy performance, practical, feature loaded Against Stiff ride, could be more agile Verdict Strikes a great balance between performance and practicality.
2
Volkswagen Polo GtI
For Staggering performance, sharp handling Against Looks too similar to regular Polo, price Verdict Plenty of hot-hatch thrills but it’s too expensive. whatcar? october 2017 | 45
Comparison
An automatic choice
Photography omkar Dhas
The last time we compared these two diesel automatic sedans, it was the Rapid that emerged the winner. Now, the Verna is back in a new avatar.
46 | october 2017 whatcar?
Hyundai Verna vs Skoda Rapid
automatic. And now we have the new-generation Hyundai Verna that is better equipped. What’s more, Hyundai has replaced the old four-speed automatic transmission with a new six-speed unit. the Verna’s price is also really attractive, undercutting both its rivals. Because the Vento and rapid are mechanically near-identical, it's the rapid and the Verna that are going up against each other. What are they like to drive? Not only is the Verna’s engine
the larger one of the two at 1,582cc, but at 128hp, it’s significantly more powerful. this helps it reach 100kph 1.5sec faster than the Skoda. What’s also impressive is how responsive the engine is right from the word go. Cruising at mid revs is very comfortable and overtaking feels effortless, with ample punch under your right foot. this motor is eager to rev, and even under hard acceleration, the gearbox upshifts at around 4,000rpm, so performance is strong. the six-speed automatic unit
shifts smoothly and does a good job of being in the right gear almost all the time; but compared to the rapid, it’s a lot slower. there’s no Sport mode either. that said, the engine’s performance makes up for the gearbox’s sluggishness, and 20-80kph and 40-100kph acceleration timings in kickdown are identical to the rapid's. there, however, is a prominent diesel engine rattle that filters into the cabin, and compared to the outgoing car, this one feels louder. Still, by
The conTenders
Hyundai Verna 1.6 AT SX+ List price rs 12.62 lakh Feature-loaded diesel sedan that now has baby-elantra looks and a new six-speed automatic.
Skoda Rapid 1.5 AT Style List price rs 13.06 lakh a competent diesel auto sedan that's nice to drive and be driven in.
All prices ex-showroom, Delhi
A mAjority of buyers prefer to drive their mid-size sedans themselves and for these buyers, automatics bring in a lot of convenience. Also, for those who drive a lot each month, fuel costs play a key role; hence, diesel is the preferred choice of fuel. Not many cars in this segment offer the convenience of an automatic along with the efficiency of a diesel engine. there’s the Volkswagen Vento and the Skoda rapid, both of which share the same 1.5-litre diesel engine and dual-clutch
whatcar? october 2017 | 47
Hyundai Verna vs Skoda Rapid
segment standards, noise and vibration levels are really good and our sound test also revealed that the Verna is significantly quieter than the Rapid. Hyundai has also redone the car’s suspension. It’s still soft, so the ride at low speeds is quite absorbent and comfy, and at highway speeds, the Verna is now well-behaved and the bobbing characteristic of the older version has been completely eliminated. It also feels a lot more planted at highway speeds and isn’t shy to tackle corners either. However, the steering still feels vague, the rear feels nervous at speeds and it doesn’t inspire confidence like the Rapid does. Brake
'Rapid has the quickershifting gearbox, but it's the more sluggish of the two.' feel isn’t good, but, in spite of missing rear disc brakes (like the previous generation), the car comes to a halt from 80kph in an impressive 2.7m shorter distance than the Rapid. The Skoda Rapid is powered by a 110hp 1,498cc diesel engine, mated to a seven-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission. Almost immediately, it sounds extremely loud and clattery, and that only amplifies as the engine is wound harder. In stop and go traffic, the Rapid is very eager to shift to second gear, hence the engine feels a bit slow to respond at times. Also, compared to the Verna, there’s a noticeable delay before the turbo boost comes in. Get moving, however, and this car really shows its strengths with strong performance across all engine speeds. It pulls all
Comparison
Hyundai VeRna
New Verna rides nicely in the city; there's no excessive pitching.
Front seats are snug, rear ones are angled and room at the back is very limited.
Skoda Rapid
Rapid has the stiffer suspension and the heavy front end bobs too. the way until its 5,100rpm redline, and the gearbox shifts ratios very quickly. There’s a Sport as well as a Manual mode that makes driving this car a lot of fun. The suspension of the Rapid has a firmer edge than the Verna but it feels front-heavy due to the diesel’s weight. So the car has a lot of vertical movement in the front, with its nose bobbing. Its steering weighs up consistently and feels sharper What are they like inside? There’s an air of familiarity in the Verna. The dashboard
design, layout and the beigeblack colour theme is all very Hyundai, which means it is pleasing to the eye. Some buttons, like those for the climate control and startstop, feel low-grade but that aside, quality, on the whole, is good. The cloth front seats are snug and not as comfy as the Rapid’s. The rear seats, however, are a lot more supportive in comparison to the front and its angle is nicer. But the sloping roofline and limited knee and legroom really limit this car’s appeal for those who prefer sitting at the back. While the seats miss out on
Seats are comfier than the Verna's; rear seat is wider and more spacious as well. adjustable rear neck restraints, passengers here do get air-con vents and a sunshade on the rear windscreen. The Rapid’s dashboard is minimalistic yet premium. However, it feels a bit dated in comparison to the Verna. The interiors are well-built no doubt, but even in terms of quality, the Hyundai feels better put together. What are nice though are the Rapid’s artificial leather seats that are broad and fairly supportive. The beige interiors make the cabin feel bright and airy. Its rear bench feels wider and flatter, and although the whatcar? october 2017 | 49
New Arrivals
2012 LAMBORGHINI AVENTADOR LP700-4
2014 PORSCHE 911 TURBO S
2011 FERRARI CALIFORNIA
2016 BMW I8
2016 MASERATI QUATTROPORTE
Comparison
Hyundai Verna vs Skoda Rapid
Hyundai VeRna
auto headlamp function adds a lot of convenience.
Quality Interiors are well put together and quality is good.
Touchscreen has a very good resolution and functionality is slick.
Design colour theme and layout is functional yet good looking.
electric sunroof is a big draw for buyers in this segment.
Skoda Rapid
Misses out on auto headlamps but gets rain-sensing wipers.
Design Minimalistic design feels dated in comparison.
Quality Plastics are hard but robust and their quality is nice.
Fog windscreen tends to fog up quite easily.
one-touch up/down power windows for all four doors.
backrest is a bit upright, its rear seat is more supportive and more spacious compared to the Verna’s. So, it’s the better of the two if you want to be chauffeured around. Even in terms of practicality, the Verna has a bit of an edge over the Rapid. While both cars have ample well-thoughtout storage areas, the Verna
gets a rubberised base adding just that much of a special feel and preventing loose metallic objects from rattling on the go. The Rapid’s 460-litre boot is large and well-shaped but once again the Verna’s is 20 litres larger.
are loaded with equipment like projector headlamps with LED daytime running lamps, 16-inch alloy wheels, remote key entry, tilt steering adjustment, climate control, auto-dimming mirror, cruise control, reversing camera and parking sensors. Features like telescopic steering adjustment, rain-
sensing wipers, leatherette seats, 6.5-inch touchscreen infotainment system, onetouch up/down power windows and adjustable rear neck restraints are unique to the Rapid. On the other hand, the Verna gets auto headlamps with cornering function, a 7.0-inch touchscreen with Android Auto and Apple
equipment and safety Being top variants, both cars
Equipment 3 Standard 7 Not available
Hyundai Verna SX+ Skoda Rapid Style
Projector headlamps
Steering adjustment
Cruise control
Reversing camera
Auto wipers
Electric sunroof
Isofix mounts
Hill-hold function
ESP
auto 3
tilt tilt+telescopic
7 3
3 3
7 3
3 7
3 7
7 3
7 3
whatcar? october 2017 | 51
Comparison Stats, specs and ratings Hyundai Verna 1.6-litre at SX+ List price 12.62 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi)
What it will cost you Skoda Rapid 1.5-litre at Style List price rs 13.06 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi)
Measurements Figures in bold are best in test. Dimensions in cm
175 93
90 68-90
147
Space 480 litres
75 172
Depreciation each year
Space 460 litres
70
Rs 13,06,425 Rs 51,486 Rs 1,68,268 Rs 15,54,242 Rs 75,000
170
ll
ll
ll
ll
ll ll
ll
ll ll
lll
ll
lll
lll
lllll
lllllllllllll
Average
lll
lll
ll
ll
ll
ll
lll llll
Good
llll
Poor
llllll
Good
ll
lll
Poor
ll
lll
lll
llll
lll
llllllll
ll ll
ll
lllllllllllll
Average
l ll
ll
lllll
ll
lll
lll
185 kph
Test figures
Acceleration 50-80kph through the gears
Acceleration 50-80kph through the gears
3.86 sec 20-80kph in kickdown 6.55 sec 40-100kph in kickdown 8.47 sec Braking 80-0kph 25.86m
4.00 sec 20-80kph in kickdown 6.84 sec 40-100kph in kickdown 8.40 sec Braking 80-0kph 28.56m
Buying details
Buying details
http://www.hyundai.com/in
http://www.skoda-auto.co.in
Infotainment
Infotainment
52 | october 2017 whatcar?
lll
top speed
Test figures
7-inch touchscreen is very easy to use; gets android auto, apple carPlay; gets 6 speakers.
ll
llll
0-100kph
12.31 sec
ll
llllll
Size 1498cc, 4 cyls Peak power 110hp at 4000rpm Peak torque 250Nm at 1500-2500rpm
ll
llll
Engine and performance
ll
ll
21.72 kpl* 55 litres 1194 km
lll
182 kph
Economy Tank Range
lll
top speed
3rd year 19%
l ll
Size 1582cc, 4 cyls Peak power 128hp at 4000rpm Peak torque 260Nm at 1500-3000rpm
3rd year 18%
ll
Engine and performance
2nd year 21%
Aftersales & service
Economy 21.02 kpl* 45 litres 946 km
2nd year 19% 136
ll
Economy Tank Range
137
1st year 31%
lll
Economy
Turning Turning circle Turning circle circle 10.6m
1st year 24%
llll
137
llllllll
140
circle
*Claimed
Turning Turning circle Turning
circle 10.4m
0-100kph
100 103
60
Rs 12,62,244 Rs 48,722 Rs 1,64,494 Rs 14,78,460 NA
Ex-showroom price Insurance Registration (& taxes) On-road price Deals
441
110
10.89 sec
Prices (Delhi)
64-89
148 94
Skoda rapid 1.5-litre at Style
103
89
94 60-85
63-87
444
58
Hyundai Verna 1.6-litre at SX+
171
94
6.5-inch screen's touch sensitivity is great; it only gets MirrorLink but no satnav.
480-litre boot Spacious boot is a bit larger and is well-shaped.
460-litre boot It's a bit easier to load heavier items because of lower lip.
CarPlay, six speakers, rear manual sunshade and an electric sunroof. In terms of safety, both cars get ABS, EBD and dual airbags. The Rapid also gets electronic stability program (ESP) and hill-hold assist, whereas the Verna gets Isofix child-seat mounts on the rear seat.
two years, expandable up to the fifth year or 1,00,000km for Rs 26,790. Even the Rapid is available in two variants â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Ambition and Style. The Style variant we tested is priced at Rs 13.29 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi). Skoda is offering an extended warranty up to the fourth year or 1,00,000km, and an attractive maintenance package that includes routine servicing costs until four years or the 60,000km service for Rs 29,999. Both extended warranties are options we strongly recommend.
Buying and owning Hyundai offers the Verna diesel automatic in two variants â&#x20AC;&#x201C; EX and SX+. As tested, the SX+ is priced at Rs 12.88 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi). It carries a standard warranty of
Hyundai Verna vs Skoda Rapid
ouR VeRdiCT
1
Hyundai Verna 1.6-litre at SX+
For ride, refinement, effortless performance Against backseat space, vague steering Verdict refined, featureloaded sedan with strong performance.
2
Skoda Rapid 1.5-litre at Style
See how other mid-size sedans compare in our Buyer's Guide on p79 For airy cabin, slick gearbox Against engine refinement, dated interiors Verdict Despite being a bit more spacious, it's well past its prime in many areas. In THE PAST, the Rapid had been our pick for someone looking for a diesel automatic sedan in this segment. The 1.5-litre diesel offers a fair amount of punch and its dual-clutch automatic gearbox is fast to respond. Then, it still remains the nicer of the two cars to drive around corners and even has the more comfortable rear seat. So, if you are buying a
'The Verna is the more effortless to drive of the two.'
car to be chauffeur-driven around during the week and self-driven on weekends, we suggest you take a good look at the Skoda. The Hyundai Verna isnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t as comfortable to sit in the back and the automatic gearbox isnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t as quick on the draw, but it is the better car here because it scores well in other important areas. To begin with, it has the nicer engine.
Performance is stronger and it feels the more refined and effortless of the two. It even has a nicer-looking and better-built interior. Equipment levels too are much better and, reliabilitywise, it is likely to be the more dependable and problem-free of the two. They come close in the final analysis, but in the end, itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s the Verna that wins. whatcar? october 2017 | 53
Hot deals
The best deals available this month
deal of the month
Save rs 7.5 lakh MercedeS S-cLaSS Save up to rs 7.5 lakh List price from rs 1.34 crore The flagship Mercedes sedan is due for a mid-cycle facelift soon. A direct rival to the BMW 7-series and the Audi A8, the S-class in India is available with a choice of a petrol as well as a diesel engine. It’s a great mix of tech and tradition, and the interiors are a class apart. Discounts and benefits of up to Rs 7.5 lakh are on offer at some dealerships, depending on stock available.
Hatchbacks Fiat abarth Punto
Save rs 75,000
Mahindra kuV100 Save up to rs 65,000 List price from rs 5.04 lakh Mahindra’s smallest model, the KUV100, comes with a long list of variants and features. However, it’s a slow seller due to its awkward proportions. It comes with a spacious cabin and a choice of a petrol and a diesel engine. Discounts to the tune of Rs 65,000 are on offer at most locations. Bargain hard for more, as a refreshed KUV is just around the corner.
hyundai grand i10 Save up to rs 50,000 List price from rs 4.55 lakh Hyundai's Grand i10 recently received a major facelift along with an even longer feature list. A direct rival to the Swift and the Etios, it now gets a touchscreen infotainment system in the higher trims. Available in both petrol (MT/AT) and diesel (MT only) options, discounts and benefits of up to Rs 50,000 are on offer at most Hyundai outlets.
Mahindra kuV100
Fiat abarth Punto Save up to rs 75,000 List price from rs 9.67 lakh Fiat’s stylish hatchback is rather long in the tooth now. The performance-oriented Abarth Punto comes with a 1.4-litre turbo motor with 147hp on tap. It takes on the likes of the Polo GT TSI. Fiat is offering discounts in the range of around Rs 75,000 on the Abarth Punto at most dealerships. 56 | october 2017 whatcar?
VoLkSwagen PoLo Save up to rs 65,000 List price from rs 5.41 lakh The Volkswagen Polo takes on the Swift, Grand i10 and the Etios. The carmaker has recently added more feature-laden variants as part of its initiative to push for sales this festive season. Standard Polos (non-GT) are being offered with benefits and discounts of up to Rs 65,000.
Save rs 65,000
new car bargains
SUVs/MPVs bMw X3 Save up to rs 3.5 lakh List price from rs 49.1 lakh The BMW X3 is a direct rival to the Mercedes GLC and the Audi Q5. Soon to be replaced by an all-new model, the mid-size SUV from BMW comes with a 3.0-litre diesel engine. Discounts of about Rs 3.5 lakh are on offer to push sales.
Save rs 4 lakh MercedeS gLc Save up to rs 4 lakh List price from rs 46.49 lakh The GLC is Mercedes’ rival to the Audi Q5 and the BMW X3,
and is the newest SUV of the lot. The stylish GLC is currently available with benefits amounting to Rs 4 lakh at most dealerships.
Mahindra nuVoSPort Save up to rs 85,000 List price from rs 7.6 lakh The NuvoSport is Mahindra’s answer to the Vitara Brezza and the Ford EcoSport. Essentially a facelifted Quanto, the SUV comes with a 1.5-litre, three-cylinder
diesel engine, along with choice of a manual as well as an AMT gearbox. Discounts of up to Rs 85,000 are on offer in an attempt to drive sales. renauLt duSter Save up to rs 65,000 List price from rs 8.43 lakh Renault recently introduced a special-edition model to the popular Duster line-up as part of its festive sales initiative. The Duster takes on the likes of the Terrano, Creta and the Mahindra Scorpio, to name a few. Renault is, currently, offering attractive discounts and benefits in the range of Rs 65,000 on standard models as well.
Sedans MercedeS c-cLaSS
toyota coroLLa aLtiS
Save rs 3.5 lakh MercedeS c-cLaSS Save up to rs 3.5 lakh List price from rs 38.48 lakh The C-class sedan gets plush interiors as well as stylish S-class-like exteriors. Also known as a baby S-class, the C-class makes you feel special and gives a proper luxury experience. Discounts and benefits of around Rs 3.5 lakh are on offer at most locations. bMw 3-SerieS dieSeL Save up to rs 2.5 lakh List price from rs 37.8 lakh The BMW 3-series now comes with a stronger diesel engine and also gets the option of a petrol powerplant. The cabin is spacious but it doesn’t feel as special as a Mercedes C-class'. Discounts and benefits of around Rs 2.5 lakh
are on offer on the dieselpowered models of the 3-series standard sedan in India. honda aMaze PetroL Save up to rs 1 lakh List price from rs 5.50 lakh The Honda Amaze is a direct rival to the Swift Dzire and the Hyundai Xcent. Available with a 1.2-litre petrol and a 1.5-litre diesel, the Amaze sedan
Save rs 45,000 recently received a facelift and there are talks of a full-model change in the near future. Discounts and benefits to the tune of Rs 1 lakh are on offer at most dealerships. hyundai Xcent Save up to rs 55,000 List price from rs 5.33 lakh Hyundai’s answer to the Dzire and the Amaze, the Xcent,
bMw 3-SerieS dieSeL
Save rs 2.5 lakh
recently got a mid-cycle refresh. Sales, however, have been slow, thanks to the shift towards compact SUVs. The Xcent is currently available with benefits of around Rs 55,000 as part of Hyundai’s festive offers. toyota coroLLa aLtiS Save up to rs 45,000 List price from rs 15.43 lakh The Altis takes on the Elantra and the Octavia. The segment has been severely hit and sales are dwindling due to an increasing number of people looking at crossovers and SUVs at the same price point. In order to push sales, dealers are offering discounts and benefits in the range of Rs 45,000 on most variants. whatcar? october 2017 | 57
Discounts vary from city to city. Please check and bargain with your dealer for exact discounts, which may not match the figures quoted in this issue. All prices ex-showroom, Delhi
MercedeS gLc
Reader test team
Hyundai Verna
Photography Kuldeep chaudhari
What is it? An effortless, comfortable sedan with premium features and baby-Elantra looks. On sale Now Price Rs 8-12.88 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) The fluidic Verna that launched in 2011 was loved by buyers because of its laundry list of features and wide engine and transmission options. With this newgeneration version, hyundai is sticking to the recipe, equipping this car with loads of features and a 1.6-litre petrol and diesel engine with six-speed manual and new six-speed automatic transmissions. The new Verna has grown in dimensions, sharpened in terms of looks and with features close to the rs 20-lakh elantra, it's back to compete in a segment that it once dominated. 58 | october 2017 whatcar?
Parth Chaturvedi Occupation banking associate Age 27 Drives hyundai creta Uses car to transport the family Parth said, "this car looks quite attractive inside and out. I'm really happy to see a sunroof with the car. this just completes the Verna. For really long I actually delayed my purchase for this car. the space inside though is just not comparable to my creta. the space at the back is average and even the front seats don't feel as comfy as my creta. the
Parth liked the Verna's list of features, and thought that it's value for money. petrol is very smooth and the engine feels almost the same in my car. this SX (o) variant has just so many features that my car lacks, and I could have actually picked up this top SX (o) automatic variant for a
bit more than the price of my manual creta. at least in terms of value, this car ranks really high. however, I wish hyundai could have done something about cabin space." RAting
Madhurima Shekhar Occupation Junior analyst Age 22 Drives toyota corolla altis Uses car to commute to work Madhurima said, "It's so quiet, I could barely tell that this engine is running. this car is just so easy to drive and its steering is very light. the size of this car is just right and squeezing it into a tight parking spot will be pretty easy because of the camera and sensors. this touchscreen is easy on the eyes too and it's very simple to use. what's nice is that it has android auto
Madhurima liked this car's easy to drive nature and its premium quality. and navigation, and the six speakers sound quite nice. also, the quality of the interiors and design looks a lot better than my toyota that's a lot more expensive than this. even in terms of
design, I really like the way this car looks. You get the impression of an expensive car and the silhouette is very sleek. this front grill looks a bit odd though." RAting
Harmanjot Singh Occupation banker Age 23 Drives hyundai i20 Uses car to go for long drives Harmanjot, "the power definitely feels nice. out on the highway, this will feel so much better than my i20. on long drives, these cooled seats will make the journey a lot more comfortable. there's a very familiar feeling sitting inside this car. while the quality is good, its design didn't impress me much as it's too generic and not radical, like my car. I'm a tall guy and
Cooled seats, auto headlamps, cruise control will make Harmanjot's drives comfy. usually headroom is an issue for me, and in this car, the story isn't any different. what's worse is that I cannot fit at the back without bending my neck uncomfortably, so my tall
family members will refuse to get in this backseat. Must say that although six airbags are great, I'd have loved if it had nice leather seat covers." RAting
Paarshva Shah Occupation analyst Age 27 Drives hyundai Xcent Uses car to be chauffeured around town Paarshva said, "this back seat doesn't feel like a big step up compared to my car, honestly. I was considering this as an upgrade, but seeing the lack of space, I'm in two minds. I just checked out the city and ciaz recently, and space at the back is huge. this car's suspension is pretty nice and potholes don't toss you
Fancy joining the Reader Test Team?
Paarshva found the headroom and legroom at the back to be a bit cramped. around like in my car. what I really loved is the fact that this car has cooled front seats and for a guy like me who sweats a lot, this feature is a boon when I have to drive myself. Its boot
is pretty big and will easily gobble up my occassional airport luggage. that handsfree boot function is a pretty cool party trick." RAting
Hereâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s your chance to join an exclusive car preview. If you want to be a part of the Reader Test Team or have a question about a specific car, write to us with your details. Contact: rtt.whatcar@haymarketsac.com 022-23787500 whatcar? october 2017 | 59
Reader Rescue
Wants a sedan to replace a Fiesta
Nishant Raut wants a replacement for his Ford Fiesta. It has to be reliable, ideal for use over short distances within Mumbai city, and above all, an automatic. Need help? E-mail rr.whatcar@ haymarketsac.com with details of your budget and what you need from your next car.
Shortlist
Photography omkar Dhas Words Saumil Shah
Hyundai Verna SX (o) Honda city VX at
60 | october 2017 whatcar?
Name Nishant Raut Age 28 City Mumbai, Maharashtra Current car Ford Fiesta, Mercedes-Benz E-class Mileage 6,000km per year Will use car for intra-city runs Other needs This car will have to be easy to drive, trouble-free and more importantly, should be an automatic.
"I love my Fiesta a lot, but the ever-increasing traffic is really forcing me to let go of this fun car and look for a new automatic sedan," says the 28-yearold marketing manager of a reputed digital agency. He isn't a car enthusiast but his requirements were clearly laid down, "It has to be an automatic sedan and it has to be reliable. My schedule doesn't permit me to spend time getting small niggles and anomalies fixed regularly, so I want something that's largely trouble-free to begin with."
Nishant will use this car to visit the gymkhana and for outings with family and friends. Keeping his requirements in mind, and the fact that his other car is a mercedes e-class, we shortlisted two cars for him - the all-new Verna and the Honda City. While the Verna is a top-spec SX (o) variant, the City is the VX variant, one level below top. Both these cars are priced at par, are really wellloaded with a premium feel and equipment, and are very comfortable to drive and be driven in. He examines these and comes to a conclusion.
Personal shopper We help a reader examine two cars and decide which one suits their requirements best.
List price rs 14.40 lakh Reader rating
Cooled front seats impressed Nishant; the Verna gets 6 airbags while similar-priced City has only 2.
"It looks just like the elantra" said Nishant, "although the front grille and oversized headlights look a bit weird". he gets inside and the high-quality interiors impress him. "there's a very expensive feel in here", he says. "even this touchscreen is so nice and easy to use. and these cooled seats, I'd buy this car just for these!" he exclaims. "It's a nice car with many cool features and good quality, but it hasn't really blown me over."
Honda City 1.5 VX Petrol automatic List price rs 14.99 lakh Reader rating
Touch controls for the air con feel premium; back seat comfort is much superior despite fixed head rests.
Nishant says, "Personally, I think the city looks sportier in comparison." he continues, "even on the inside, I like the city's dashboard design â&#x20AC;&#x201C; it's minimalistic and classy." while fidgeting with the paddle shifters behind the steering he says, "these give the feeling of a race car." on the back seat he comments, "this seat is so nice. It feels as comfy as my cousin's toyota altis that's much more expensive."
Nishant's best new alternative
Maruti Ciaz 1.4 Alpha Rs 12.48 lakh the ciaz is substantially cheaper than its rivals and offers the most bang for buck in its segment. It has a spacious cabin, a comfy ride and is fairly well-kitted too. what lets it down, though, is its average build, and it isn't very engaging to drive either.
Nishant's best used alternative
Toyota Corolla Altis Rs 14 lakh the altis has been known for its reliability world over. this car is ideal for someone looking at a dependable mode of transport, that'll seldom require mechanical attention. It's larger than the city and a bit more comfortable too. Lightly used examples are aplenty. PrIceS oN-roaD, MuMbaI
Hyundai Verna 1.6 SX (O) Petrol automatic
Our reader's choice Honda City 1.5 VX petrol automatic almost from the start, Nishant seemed more inclined towards the honda city. "a lot of my family and friends own different versions of the city and they all love it", says Nishant being convinced with his choice. "this car feels posh, is more comfortable at the back and those super-cool LeD headlights add a lot of bling to this car". he concludes by saying, "although the Verna is half a lakh cheaper than the city and has more airbags and cooled seats, it just doesn't feel as appealing as the city". with that, Nishant says goodbye to his Fiesta and welcomes the city to his garage. whatcar? october 2017 | 61
Buying & owning - Q&A
Ask us anything Got a car-related problem you can’t resolve? Get in touch and we will help. Question of the month
Need our help? E-mail us your problem: whatcar@ haymarketsac.com or Write to What Car? Questions, Raheja Xion, 4th/5th floor, Opp Nirmal Park, Dr B Ambedkar Marg, Byculla East, Mumbai 400 027
Overall winner
the Skoda Rapid is a solid sedan that’s spacious and easy to drive.
Consider a sedan
I am looking for an automatic diesel car (preferably an SUV) in the range of Rs 10-15 lakh. I would like to know which the best car to buy. Or, should I should wait the new launches later this year? Aly Furniturewala, Mumbai There is not much choice when it comes to automatic diesel SUVs. The only good option is the Hyundai Creta diesel auto, but this may just be beyond your budget. The Renault Duster auto fits your budget but the AMT gearbox it comes with isn’t very smooth. If you don’t mind considering a sedan, then we suggest you look at the Skoda Rapid diesel auto which got a facelift recently. It is solid, spacious and quite easy to drive too.
Worth the stretch
I am confused about which car to choose – the Maruti 64 | octoBER 2017 whatcaR?
Ciaz or the Honda City. My requirement is a petrol automatic sedan as my average monthly running is 1,500km within Mumbai. I was waiting for the new Verna but it did not impress me. Neither am I impressed with the German cars. Currently, I am using a 2010 Hyundai i10 (1.2L), which is very impressive when comes to power. Maruti is offering a good deal on the Ciaz, with an exchange bonus and other dealer offers, making the Zeta automatic cost below Rs 8.5 lakh (on road), which is within my budget. However, at 93.27hp, power doesn’t seem impressive compared to the City, which has a top-insegment output of 120.6hp. But its V CVT variant is very expensive at Rs 13.5 lakh. The ownership cost is also high and there are no exchange offers either.
I want to buy a hatchback and my maximum budget is Rs 6.5 lakh. I have shortlisted the Maruti Ignis Zeta petrol and the Tata Tiago XZ petrol but am very confused between the two. I want to but this car for my father who has used a Maruti 800 for last 17-18 years and also a Mahindra Scorpio for some time. He wants the car for daily use. Feature-wise, the Ignis is good and so is the Tiago XZ but it feels a little less spacious than the Maruti. I have also heard that the sales figures for the Ignis aren’t so good when compared to the Tiago. Omkar Savant, Mumbai Both, the Ignis and the Tiago, are good cars. But for your elderly father, we would recommend the Ignis as it’s easier to drive. The controls are light and easy to operate, and the high seating position gives a good view out. Also, the Ignis is more compact than the Tiago, which makes it easier to park and manoeuvre. Lastly, after owning a Maruti for the last 17-18 years, he will be used to a certain level of service and reliability, which the Ignis will be able to offer. The Tiago is a solid, well-built car but it’s better suited for family and outstation trips.
However, I haven’t taken a test drive of either car yet. And I think power output is the only issue that is making me apprehensive about going for the Ciaz. Also, I heard a facelift is expected in early 2018. Shailesh Bandekar, Navi Mumbai
The Ciaz is worth considering because of its price. As you said, you can get some tempting offers for a Ciaz but, unfortunately, the petrol automatic feels lethargic and doesn’t offer any real driving pleasure. Overall, the City is a better car thanks to its fantastic
1.5-litre engine, comfortable seats and a level of plushness that the Ciaz doesn’t have. All this comes at a price, but we feel it’s worth it stretching out for the City.
Fun factor
I want to gift a new car to my father this December. It will also be the first car that I buy. My budget is around Rs 18 lakh and I want a car that is fun to drive, and has reasonable power and acceleration. I would prefer a sedan with good functionality and tech. Also, mileage is not
adds to the fun factor. You could also look at the Honda City petrol, whose 1.5-litre petrol engine is an absolute jewel and loves to be revved hard. You will, however, need to upgrade the tyres as the stock rubber is too skinny and doesn’t offer great grip.
Jazzy ride
I have a 2014 Mercedes C220 and a 2006 Toyota Corolla. Due to the Toyota’s age, it has repairs coming up. So, I have, instead, decided to sell it and get a new car; I wanted to buy an automatic
the Discovery Sport is a practical SUV with great off-road skills. between the GLC, the Land Rover Discovery Sport and the XC60. With the Discovery, I get the advantage of seven seats, making it quite useful, and buying a Volvo would mean adding of the same brand to my garage. What about the BMW X3? My requirements are highway cursing and a comfortable ride. Please suggest the right SUV for me. Arulmurugan, Coimbatore
Good ride and handling makes the Vento a car that’s fun to drive. a concern and both, diesel and petrol, engines are okay with me. But since everyone in the family is tall, space is important. Could you please suggest the three best cars that fit my requirement, along with the reasons for picking them? Aditya, Mumbai There aren’t too many options of fun-to-drive cars in your budget. The Skoda Octavia is a brilliant driver’s car but costs upward of Rs 22 lakh on road and may be beyond your budget. However, if you can stretch your budget, this is the one we would recommend, no question about it. But, if you can’t spend that much then an alternative is the Volkswagen Vento TSI. Its turbo-petrol engine is mated to a sevenspeed twin-clutch gearbox and offers a great driving experience. The Vento also has good ride and handling, which
for city driving. Which one would you recommend between the Honda Jazz, the Volkswagen Ameo and the Maruti Baleno? Or do you have any other suggestions? Subramani, Mumbai If you clock a lot of mileage then you might want the cost benefit of a diesel. In this case, the Ameo diesel, with its sevenspeed twin-clutch automatic, is a good option. But if your running is less than 30-35km a day, then we would recommend the Honda Jazz, which has a CVT automatic transmission that’s better than the Baleno’s. It is also a car that’s better, overall.
The current Volvo XC60 is due to be replaced, and the new model won’t be here until the end of the year. We feel it makes sense for you to go in for the Land Rover Discovery Sport, which is a practical and well-priced SUV. It is a solid highway cruiser, apart from having great off-road capabilities. The new X3 won’t be here until March 2018, so that will be quite a wait as well.
Bumper to bumper
I’m considering buying a mid-level sedan and thinking of the 2017 Verna and City (both petrol variants). My requirement is of a car for driving in Mumbai city, and, hence, I would like to go for an automatic. Which one would you suggest between the two? My budget is Rs 12-15 lakh on road. Raghvesh Bhagat, Mumbai The new Verna has some interesting features like the cooled front seats that are great to have in the summer. However, we would suggest that you go in for the Honda City, which in automatic form is nicer to drive than the Verna. The Honda’s 1.5-litre petrol and CVT transmission are responsive and smooth in bumper-to bumper-traffic.
Sport a Discovery
Currently, I own a Volvo S60, a S80 and the Renault Koleos and would like to buy a luxury SUV in the price range of Rs 65 lakh. I am a bit confused
the city is spacious, comfortable and has a smooth petrol engine. whatcaR? octoBER 2017 | 65
Buying used
Maruti S-cross Photography ashley Baxter
Maruti’s urban crossover is practical and frugal. A perfect car for the Indian family. Production run 2015–2017. What’s it like? Launched in 2015, the S-cross marked Maruti’s entry into the crossover segment. Sold through Maruti’s premium Nexa dealerships, the model was launched with two diesel engines, a 1.3-litre and a 1.6-litre unit that are mated to a five-speed manual and six-speed manual gearbox, respectively. Power and torque figures are equally impressive, as the smaller engine gets 90hp and 200Nm, while the bigger engine boasts 120hp and a healthy 320Nm of pulling 66 | octoBER 2017 whatcaR?
power. Now, given that the car is just two-years old, there wasn't been any major update. So, cars in the used car market command a price of about Rs 7.7-8.3 lakh, depending on the variant. However, expect prices to drop soon as the facelift is launched, with the S-cross receiving mild hybrid technology on the 1.3-litre engine and the 1.6 being discontinued altogether. The drive The 1.6-litre engine which developed 120hp and 320Nm
What’s it like inside?
at the rear there's ample leg and headroom at the rear; leather seats also recline.
Up front Large seats, and driver can get comfy thanks to adjustable seat and steering.
What to look out for
steering control there have been several reports of malfunctioning steering- mounted controls.
hatchback-like looks don't go down well but it is very accomplished.
sUspension wear check for suspension sounds or rattling; some owners tend to abuse their crossovers.
fUel inJectors Loss of power could be due to worn-out fuel injectors as a result of poor fuel quality. of torque is easily the more fun and the better performer of the two. There is a hint of lag under 1,800rpm, which is followed by a jolt of power that lunges you ahead. The engine is quiet too, by Maruti standards, but is still no match against the Hyundais. The lag is a by-product of the tall gearing which means a lot of work in city traffic, but it also means you can sit at 100kph at about 2,000rpm with the gear slotted in 6th. Long highway drives then, are its comfort zone. What to look out for? Being a Maruti, you would expect the S-cross to have fewer problems than competitors, but it has its share of hiccups. In 2016, Maruti recalled over 20,000 units of the crossover
'Strikes a fine balance between practicality and performance.'
manufactured between August 2015 and February 2016 to replace a faulty brake part. Make sure the used example was part of this recall. Also, many models have reportedly faced premature wear of the clutch, especially the 1.6-litre S-cross. Check if
dashboard Quality of plastics feel premium. Design is pleasant.
the buttons and steeringmounted controls work fine and that there's no lag in the infotainment system. Also, if you’re looking at a car that was used in remote areas, watch out for power loss as it could be fuel injector wear due to poor quality of fuel used. It is also advisable to look for cars with extended warranty. Unless it’s the top Alpha trim, pay no more than Rs 8-8.25 lakh. living with it Yes, the S-cross 1.6-litre can be entertaining to drive, but under stop-go conditions the sudden power delivery can be a bit uncomfortable. Also, the clutch is heavy. What's nice is this car's ability to cruise effortlessly on the highway with the added sixth gear. Jay patil
infotainment system touchscreen is easy to use but a bit slow to respond.
Buyer’S file price when new Rs 12.07 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) engine (d) 120hp, 320Nm fuel economy 14.9kpl 0-100kph 11.5sec annual insurance Rs 18,015 one to go for alpha
priceS We found 2015
Rs 7.7 lakh
2016
Rs 8.3 lakh
says… the S-cross didn’t really set the sales charts on fire due to its stance that didn’t impress Indian buyers. however, it is a very capable car and should you find one that's kept in good nick, it could be plenty of fun without compromising on practicality. whatcaR? octoBER 2017 | 67
*External Microphone
XAV-W651BT MRP Rs. 18,990/Remote Supplied
6.2(15.7cm) WVGA Touch Panel AV Receiver with Bluetooth® Connectivity BUILT FOR POWERFUL SOUND, GEARED FOR BASS PERFORMANCE
68 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
India's Best Cars Class by class, the best buys reviewed and rated
‘We've got the best cars in every price bracket’ WHAT CAR TEAM
Contents 70 Hatchbacks Entry, Hatchbacks, Hatchbacks Mid-size 71 Hatchbacks Premium, Hatchbacks Import/Luxury, Sedans Sub-4-metre 73 Sedans Mid-size, Sedans Executive, Luxury Sedans Entry-level 74 Luxury Sedans Compact, Luxury Sedans Mid-size, Luxury Sedans Premium 75 SUV Sub-4-metre, SUVs Mid-size, MPVs 76 SUVs Entry, SUVs Soft-roaders, SUVs 77 Luxury SUVs Small, Luxury SUVs Mid-size, Luxury SUVs Premium Plus Read our advice and tips on how to purchase your next car WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 69
Hatchbacks Entry | Rs 2.52 - 4.98 lakh
More on page 82 Maruti Alto K10 Price range Rs 3.70-4.51L Our pick 1.0P VXi (O) AMT List price Rs 4.51L Kpl 24.07 For Peppy and efficient engine, easy to drive. Against Cabin space, rear legroom, small boot, dated design. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
Price range Rs 3.21-4.98L Our pick 1.0P RxT (O) AMT List price Rs 4.98L Kpl 25.17 For Spacious interiors, large 300-litre boot, touchscreen with navigation, ride quality. Against Turning radius, quality of plastics WhatCar? says
Hyundai Eon Price range Rs 3.64-4.96L Our pick 1.0P Magna Opt (O) List price Rs 4.96L Kpl 20.3 For Stylish exteriors, good interior quality. Against Expensive to buy, dull to drive, not as fuel efficient as others in the segment. WhatCar? says
Hatchbacks | Rs 3.56 - 7.53 lakh
More on page 83
Renault Kwid
The Renault Kwid, with its unique SUV-like styling, is a breath of fresh air in this segment. Its 1.0L engine is a big improvement over the 0.8L engine, but it's a segment leader in space, boot capacity, equipment and ride quality.
Maruti Celerio Price range Rs 4.53-5.71L Our pick 1.0P ZXI (O) AMT List price Rs 5.59L Kpl 23.1 For Spacious cabin, peppy engine, easy to drive. Against Unsupportive seats, dull interiors, short equipment list. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
Honda Brio Price range Rs 5.11-7.53L Our pick 1.2P VX List price Rs 6.42L Kpl 18.5 For Easy to drive, engine likes to rev, nice interiors. Against Firm ride at low speeds, missing equipment and small 175-litre boot. WhatCar? says
Tata Tiago
The Tiago offers the best value proposition in this segment â&#x20AC;&#x201C; it boasts a long list of equipment, and the cabin design and build better than rivals. The ride and handling are great too; the engines, while not the segment best, are certainly not bad.
Hatchbacks Mid-size | Rs 5.06 - 9.00 lakh
Best Buy Maruti Swift
Itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s been around for a while but the Swift is a good mid-size hatchback. The petrol engine is free revving, the slightly gruff diesel motor is quite punchy too and it has comfy seats. What rounds off the experience is that it is one of the most fun70 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
to-drive hatchbacks in India. Price range Rs 5.26-8.65L Our pick 1.2P VXI (O) List price Rs 6.40L Kpl 20.4 For Fun to drive, decent ride, a pair of good engines. Against Rear-seat space, no automatic option. WhatCar? says
Price range Rs 3.56-6.41L Our pick 1.2P XT List price Rs 4.94L Kpl 23.8 For Great cabin build quality and long equipment list, ride and handling. Against Dull engines, engine refinement. WhatCar? says
More on page 84 Ford Figo Price range Rs 5.20-8.37L Our pick 1.5D Sport Edition List price Rs 8.37L Kpl 24.3 For Powerful diesel motor, spacious cabin, ride quality. Against Dated interiors, unimpressive 1.2-litre petrol engine, missing features. WhatCar? says Hyundai Grand i10 Price range Rs 5.01-8.25L Our pick 1.2P Sportz (O) List price Rs 6.47L Kpl 18.9 For Easy-to-drive, good equipment levels, quality interior. Against Not engaging to drive, narrow cabin. WhatCar? says
Hatchbacks Premium | Rs 5.46 - 10.89 lakh
Hyundai Elite i20 Price range Rs 5.82-10.89L Our pick 1.4D Sportz List price Rs 8.63L Kpl 21.7 For Well-built cabin, great interior quality, feature rich, refined engines. Against Unexciting to drive, petrol needs more power. WhatCar? says
Best Buy Maruti Baleno
The Baleno provides a great value proposition â&#x20AC;&#x201C; it is spacious and well-equipped, the cabin is well-finished and the petrol engine is extremely peppy and refined. It ticks all the right boxes and gives the max bang for the buck.
More on page 86
Honda Jazz Price range Rs 6.41-10.36L Our pick 1.2P V List price Rs 8.14L Kpl 18.2 For Rev-happy petrol engine, space and practicality. Against Some essential equipment missing, noisy diesel engine. WhatCar? says
Price range Rs 5.89-9.71L Our pick 1.2P Zeta List price Rs 7.51L Kpl 21.4 For Ride and handling, cabin space, long equipment list. Against Interior quality is average, diesel is a bit rough, inconsistent steering. WhatCar? says
Hatchbacks Import/Luxury | Rs 30.06 - 53.13 lakh Mercedes-Benz A-Class Price range Rs 31.89-33.73L Our pick 200 d Sport List price Rs 33.73L Kpl NA For Stylish exteriors, sporty interiors, competent engines. Against Poor rearward visibility, low rear seat, missing equipment. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
BMW 1-series Price range Rs 37.32L Our pick 118d Sport Line List price Rs 37.32L Kpl NA For Responsive diesel engine, quick gearbox, engaging to drive. Against Expensive to buy, no petrol engine. WhatCar? says
Volvo V40
The V40 is loaded with safety and other equipment, it boasts of a spacious cabin and a generous boot, is powered by a punchy diesel engine and the agile handling makes it quite thrilling to drive.
Sedans Sub-4-metre | Rs 5.19 - 11.48 lakh
Best Buy Maruti Dzire
Bigger, more spacious and more practical. This new Dzire is bound to impress with its more proportionate looks, cabin space and improved refinement levels. It's more fuel efficient too. It now gets auto options with both engines.
More on page 87
Price range Rs 6.07-10.81L Our pick 1.2P ZXi List price Rs 8.00L Kpl 22.0 For Interior space, equipment list, ride and handling balance. Against Expensive top variants, vague steering feel, slow diesel auto. WhatCar? says
Price range Rs 32.40-37.60L Our pick 2.0D R-Design List price Rs 36.55L Kpl NA For Punchy engine, neat handling, safety kit, equipment. Against Space in the rear, slow gearbox, limited sales and service outlets. WhatCar? says
More on page 89 Hyundai Xcent Price range Rs 5.84-9.47L Our pick 1.2P SX (O) List price Rs 8.31L Kpl 20.14 For Refined engines, cabin quality, pleasant ride. Against Not very engaging to drive, diesel engine performance, narrow cabin. WhatCar? says Ford Figo Aspire Price range Rs 6.09-9.19L Our pick 1.5D Titanium List price Rs 8.40L Kpl 25.8 For Powerful diesel engine, comfy ride quality, fun to drive, safety kit. Against Dated interiors, missing features. WhatCar? says WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 71
Sedans Mid-size | Rs 7.27 - 15.93 lakh
More on page 91
Maruti Ciaz Price range Rs 8.77-12.20L Our pick 1.3D Zeta SHVS List price Rs 10.30L Kpl 28.0 For Cabin space, ride quality, equipment list, good value for money. Against Not a great drive, needs more power. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
Hyundai Verna Price range Rs 8.75-14.78L Our pick 1.6D SX (O) List price Rs 14.78 Kpl 24.75 For Smooth and refined engines; interior quality, list of premium features. Against Rear seat experience, still not fun to drive WhatCar? says
*ex-showroom, Delhi
Honda City
The Honda City is very popular already for good reason â&#x20AC;&#x201C; its petrol engine is fantastic, and it's enjoyable to drive. The backseat is very comfortable and spacious; and the car comes with a long equipment list.
Price range Rs 9.40-15.72L Our pick 1.5P V MT List price Rs 11.01L Kpl 17.4 For Comfortable rear-seat, strong petrol, efficient diesel. Against Cabin insulation, rear headroom, pricier than the competition. WhatCar? says
Sedans Executive | Rs 14.35 - 29.59 lakh
Skoda Octavia Price range Rs 18.72-29.59L Our pick RS List price Rs 29.59L Kpl 14.7 For All engines offer good performance, well equipped, nice to drive. Against Expensive to buy, sales and service network. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
Hyundai Elantra
The latest Elantra is a big step forward for the last. The cabin is well built, spacious and comfortable too. The petrol motor is powerful and feels good to drive yourself. Price range Rs 14.35-21.57L Our pick 2.0P SX (O)
More on page 93
Toyota Corolla Altis Price range Rs 17.35-21.71L Our pick 1.8P GL List price Rs 19.97L Kpl NA For Backseat comfort, equipment, automatic gearbox. Against Inconsistent interior quality, dull to drive, expensive to buy. WhatCar? says
List price Rs 18.36L Kpl 14.59 For Petrol car is fun to drive, good ride and handling balance, loaded with kit. Against Fully loaded car is expensive, lower-spec variants miss out on some essential kit, diesel engine lacks punch. WhatCar? says
Luxury Sedans Entry-level | Rs 28.00 - 43.10 lakh Toyota Camry Hybrid Price range Rs 33.28-43.10L Our pick Hybrid List price Rs 43.10L Kpl 19 For Low running costs for hybrid, smooth drive, comfy back seat. Against Unexciting performance, dull interiors. WhatCar? says Honda Accord Hybrid Price range Rs 42.76L Our pick Hybrid List price Rs 42.76L Kpl 23.1 For Plush and comfy ride quality, fuel-efficient hybrid motor. Against Expensive to purchase, soggy handling. WhatCar? says
More on page 93
Best Buy Skoda Superb
The Superbâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s highlights are the class-leading rear legroom, the comfortable seats, smooth and powerful engines, long equipment list, involving driving experience and contemporary interior and exterior design.
Price range Rs 28.00-36.63L Our pick 1.8P Style DSG List price Rs 29.84L Kpl 14.6 For Comfort and rear legroom, boot space, strong engines, long equipment list. Against After sales and service network. WhatCar? says WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 73
Luxury Sedans Compact | Rs 36.36 - 56.73 lakh
Audi A4 Price range Rs 45.19-51.09L Our pick 35 TDI Technology List price Rs 51.09L Kpl 18.25 For Equipment list, comfortable ride, well-built interiors. Against Not engaging to drive, petrol lacks performance. WhatCar? says
Best Buy BMW 3-series
The 3-series has evolved from being the best driverâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s car to a more rounded package, combining strong performance with a quiet and comfortable back seat experience, good ride quality and a strong feature list.
More on page 94
Mercedes-Benz C-class Price range Rs 47.31-52.94L Our pick C250 d Avantgarde List price Rs 52.94L Kpl NA For Luxurious cabin, quality of materials, nice to drive. Against Firm at low speeds, and the diesel engine gets noisy. WhatCar? says
Price range Rs 44.85-56.30L Our pick 320d Luxury Line List price Rs 50.83L Kpl NA For Strong performance, ride and handling, quick shifting gearbox, comfy back seat Against Low seating, lacks some essential equipment. WhatCar? says
Luxury Sedans Mid-size | Rs 59.64 - 81.57 lakh
More on page 95
BMW 5-series Price range Rs 59.64-75.46L Our pick 530d M Sport List price Rs 75.46L Kpl NA For Punchy engines, cabin quality, fun to drive, equipment list. AgainstRear seat is a bit upright, limited variants. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
Volvo S90 Price range Rs 65.25L Our pick 2.0D D4 Inscription List price Rs 65.25L Kpl NA For Luxurious cabin, generous equipment list, creamy engine. Against Not engaging to drive, scanty support network, no 6-cylinder engine option. WhatCar? says
Mercedes-Benz E-Class
This long wheelbase E-Class belongs to a segment of its own with superb levels of comfort, especially at the back. The quality of interiors is top notch and the air-suspension offers a very comfy ride. Of course, it all comes with a heavy price tag.
Price range Rs 63.91-81.57L Our pick E220d LWB List price Rs 66.75L Kpl NA For Interior quality, rear legroom, powerful 6-cylinder diesel engine. Against Price tag for the 350d, spare wheel in the boot. WhatCar? says
Luxury Sedans Premium | Rs 95.35 lakh - Rs 6.25* crore
More on page 96
BMW 7-series Price range Rs 136.85-267.70L Our pick 730Ld M Sport List price Rs 144.81L Kpl NA For Sporty drive, packed with technology, extremely luxurious, interior quality. Against Poor engine refinement. WhatCar? says
*ex-showroom, Delhi
Best Buy
Mercedes-Benz S-class
The S-class does what a luxury limousine is supposed to do best â&#x20AC;&#x201C; it provides best-in-class seat comfort, ride comfort and noise insulation, making it an ideal chauffeur-driven vehicle. It is not thrilling to drive, but it is most comfortable 74 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
to be driven in for sure. Price range Rs 136.18-303.88L Our pick S350 d List price Rs 136.18L Kpl NA For Supple ride, well-insulated, luxurious cabin, refined engine. Against Not exciting to drive, petrol is expensive. WhatCar? says
Audi A8 L Price range Rs 137.46-143.74L Our pick 50 TDI Premium List price Rs 137.46L Kpl NA For Rear seat comfort, topnotch interior quality, loaded with technology. Against Dated design, lacks the presence of its rivals. WhatCar? says
SUVs Sub-4-metre | Rs 5.11 - 12.26 lakh Maruti Vitara Brezza Price range Rs 8.38-11.16L Our pick 1.3D VDI (O) List price Rs 9.13L Kpl 24.3 For Spacious cabin, handling, comfortable, SUV looks. Against Dull interiors, engine needs more performance, no petrol engine option. WhatCar? says
Tata Nexon
It's surprisingly nice to drive and the ride is very comfortable. Cabin quality and design is very appealing and it's fairly well loaded the concept car-like styling are a big draw for the car. As a package, it's is a great buy.
SUVs Mid-size | Rs 9.29 - 16.30 lakh
Honda BR-V Price range Rs 9.92-15.28L Our pick 1.5D S List price Rs 13.11L Kpl 21.9 For Seven seater option, fuel-efficient diesel engine. Against Missing equipment, and it looks alot like the Mobilio MPV. WhatCar? says
Price range Rs 10.02-16.30L Our pick 1.6D SX+ MT List price Rs 15.13L Kpl 19.6 For Easy-to-drive, smooth and powerful engines, interior quality. Against Some variants are expensive, dull to drive. WhatCar? says
MPVs | Rs 4.39 - 24.86 lakh
More on page 104
Maruti Suzuki Ertiga Price range Rs 7.05-12.41L Our pick 1.3D VDI SHVS List price Rs 10.77L Kpl 24.5 For Easy to drive, well equipped, good value. Against Cramped cabin, high-speed ride, unexciting petrol engine. WhatCar? says Renault Lodgy Stepway Price range Rs 8.96-13.47L Our pick 1.5D RxZ 110 PS List price Rs 13.14 Kpl 21.04 For Strong 110hp engine, good ride quality and spacious cabin. Against Heavy clutch, slow to respond engine and dull interiors. WhatCar? says
More on page 102 Renault Duster Price range Rs 9.46-16.22L Our pick 1.5D RxL 110 PS List price Rs 13.39L Kpl 19.7 For Great ride quality, tough build, punchy 110hp engine. Against Interiors feel old and utilitarian, refinement, missing equipment WhatCar? says
Best Buy The Cretaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s 1.6-litre diesel is powerful and refined, its gearbox is crisp, the cabin is spacious and sophisticated, the equipment list is long and the ride is soft and comfortable, making it a great all-round SUV.
Price range Rs 5.85-9.45L* Our pick 1.5D XM List price Rs 7.40L* Kpl 21.5 For Concept car-like styling, driving manners, ride. Against Lacklustre engine performance, inconsisten fit and finish. WhatCar? says
*ex-showroom, Delhi
Best Buy
Ford EcoSport Price range Rs 8.13-11.48L Our pick 1.5D Trend+ List price Rs 10.30L Kpl 22.7 For Smooth engines, ride and handling, safety features. Against Cabin feels cramped, plastic quality is poor in places, dated interior design. WhatCar? says
Hyundai Creta
More on page 100
Best Buy Toyota Innova Crysta
The Crysta is a combination of great space, powerful engines, excellent ride quality, comfortable seats and a strong equipment list. It might be expensive, but few others can transport people the way it does.
Price range Rs 15.60-24.86L Our pick 2.4D VX List price Rs 20.46L Kpl 15.1 For Large and roomy cabin, good ride comfort, interior quality, tough build. Against The premium pricing, heavy steering, not agile. WhatCar? says WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 75
SUVs Entry | Rs 7.80 - 20.56 lakh
More on page 105 Mahindra XUV500 Price range Rs 14.80-20.56L Our pick 2.2D W8 4x2 AT List price Rs 19.55L Kpl 15.1 For Well-equipped, very car-like to drive. Against Interior quality, cabin insulation, manual gearbox. WhatCar? says
Best Buy Tata Hexa
It's a huge step up in terms of quality, equipment and desirability. The car is spacious, interiors are airy and the ride quality is great. Its also got a really nice engine and automatic gearbox. Price range Rs 13.15-19.40L
Mahindra Scorpio Price range Rs 11.03-17.34L Our pick 2.2D S8 List price Rs 15.27L Kpl 16.01 For Engine drivability, visibility all around. Against Low speed ride, high speed manners, dated interiors. WhatCar? says
Our pick 2.2D XTA 4x2 List price Rs 19.27L Kpl NA For Premium-feel interiors, cabin space, comfy ride, usable third row. Against Ponderous to drive, notchy manual gearbox, fit and finish is inconsistent. WhatCar? says
SUVs Soft-roaders | Rs 17.35 - 36.08 lakh Hyundai Tucson Price range Rs 20.73-27.81L Our pick 2.0D GLS AT List price Rs 27.81L Kpl NA For Powerful and refined engines, cabin space, wide engine-gearbox options. Against Not engaging to drive, no all-wheel drive option. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
VW Tiguan Price range Rs 31.07-34.87L Our pick 2.0D Comfortline List price Rs 31.07L Kpl 17.6 For Solid build, equipment, diesel engine performance. Against Only available as an automatic, no petrol option, expensive to buy. WhatCar? says
Jeep Compass
With baby Grand Cherokee looks and Jeep's tough-asnails, go-anywhere ability, the Compass is really well packaged. This car has competent engine and transmissions, as well as twoand four-wheel drive options.
SUVs | Rs 23.23 - 35.58 lakh
The Endeavour is a great mix of capable engines, a wellequipped and upmarket cabin, light electric steering, laudable ride quality and fantastic handling. The smaller and cheaper 2.2-litre variant is also very capable. 76 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
Price range Rs 17.35-24.50L Our pick 2.0D Longitude (O) List price Rs 20.51L Kpl 17.1 For Abuse-friendly, solid build, interior quality, ride and handling, punchy engines. Against Some missing equipment, rear seat comfort. WhatCar? says
More on page 107
Best Buy Ford Endeavour
More on page 106
Price range Rs 28.64-35.33L Our pick 2.2D Titanium List price Rs 32.22L Kpl 9.95 For Rugged, plush interior quality, long equipment list, punchy engine. Against Gearbox response, cramped last row space. WhatCar? says
Toyota Fortuner Price range Rs 28.26-35.58L Our pick 2.8D 4x4 MT List price Rs 33.60L Kpl NA For Strong engine, off-road, abuse-friendly construction, good ride over broken surfaces. Against Premium pricing, no sunroof. WhatCar? says Isuzu MU-X Price range Rs 23.99-25.99L* Our pick 3.0D 4x4 AT List price Rs 25.99L* Kpl NA For Spacious, value for money, off-road ability, tough build Against Missing equipment, interior quality, refinement and heavy steering at low speeds. WhatCar? says
Luxury SUVs Small | Rs 37.14 - 50.65 lakh
More on page 108
Audi Q3 Price range Rs 38.99-48.16L Our pick 30 TDI Premium List price Rs 43.11L Kpl 15.7 For Smooth engines, comfy interiors, cabin finish Against Lifeless steering, rear-seats are small, not engaging to drive. WhatCar? says
Best Buy
Mercedes-Benz GLA Price range Rs 37.14-44.49L Our pick 220 d 4Matic List price Rs 44.49L Kpl 17.9 For Cabin quality, high ground clearance. Against Ride is crashy, engine is noisy, cabin feels claustrophobic. WhatCar? says
BMW X1
The new X1 offers fantastic rear seat space, an attractively designed dashboard, good build quality, it is engaging to drive, the refined powertrain and a long list of equipment. The xDrive variant with all-wheeldrive is worth the extra price.
Price range Rs 42.26-50.65L Our pick sDrive 2.0D xLine List price Rs 43.36L Kpl 18.5 For Strong engine, spacious cabin, well-designed and well-insulated. Against Plastics quaity, the front seats feel relatively small. WhatCar? says
Luxury SUVs Mid-size | Rs 56.15 lakh - Rs 1.41 crore
Land Rover Discovery Sport Price range Rs 65.65-76.87L Our pick 2.0P HSE 5+2 List price Rs 66.85L Kpl 10.68 For Petrol is punchy, spacious, capable off-road, third row option. Against Diesel refinement, bit expensive to buy. WhatCar? says
Best Buy Mercedes-Benz GLC
The GLC is an all-round performer â&#x20AC;&#x201C; the interior looks and feels great, it is loaded with equipment, refinement is excellent, it is very comfortable to sit in, the engine pulls well and is quite good to drive too.
BMW X3 Price range Rs 57.96-63.36L Our pick 2.0D xLine List price Rs 62.63L Kpl 18.5 For Great to drive, comfy cabin, sporty performance Against Interiors feel a bit long in the tooth. WhatCar? says
Price range Rs 56.19-60.33L Our pick 220 d Sport List price Rs 60.33L Kpl NA For Capable and refined engines, comfy seats, equipment, car-like to drive. Against Not planted at higher speeds. WhatCar? says
Luxury SUVs Premium | Rs 72.42 lakh - Rs 4.61 crore Volvo XC90 Price range Rs 98.87-148.48L Our pick 2.0D Inscription List price Rs 98.87L Kpl NA For Unique styling, interior quality, smooth diesel. Against Harsh ride, engine performance, gearbox is a bit slow. WhatCar? says Mercedes-Benz GLS Price range Rs 93.26-207.78L Our pick 350 d List price Rs 93.16L Kpl NA For Large 7-seater SUV, strong diesel motor, smooth gearbox. Against Feels its size from behind the wheel, plenty of body roll. WhatCar? says
More on page 109
More on page 110
Best Buy
Audi Q7
The new Q7 takes the luxury SUV game further with a raft of features, strong performance, well-executed cabin. It then sets a new benchmark in its segment and is currently the one to go for.
Price range Rs 77.79-93.20L Our pick 45 TDI Technology List price Rs 93.20L Kpl NA For Strong and refined engine, quick gearbox, cabin quality Against Odd spare-wheel positioning, floaty ride at low speed. WhatCar? says WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 77
New Cars
A to Z Contents
82 Hatchback Entry 83 Hatchbacks 84 Hatchback Mid-size 86 Hatchback Premium 87 Hatchback Import/Luxury 89 Sedan Sub-4-metre 90 Sedan Entry Mid-size 91 Sedan Mid-size 93 Sedan Executive, Luxury Sedan Entry 94 Luxury Sedan Compact 95 Luxury Sedan Mid-size 96 Luxury Sedan Premium 97 Luxury Touring 98 Performance Cars 99 Supercars 100 SUV Sub-4-metre 102 SUV Mid-size 103 Utility Vehicles 104 MPV 105 SUV Entry 106 SUV (Soft-roaders) 107 SUV, Lifestyle 108 Luxury SUV Small 109 Luxury SUV Mid-size 110 Luxury SUV Premium Plus all the facts and prices to help you buy just the right car, with competing cars together.
WHATCAR? WHATCAR? OCTOBER OCTOBER 2017 2017 | 79 | 79
YOU R GU I D E TO . . .
Buying from start to finish. 1 DO YOUR HOMEWORK Research your chosen car thoroughly before going to the dealership. You can gather all the essential information using What Car? Consider several parameters such as the size of the car, the purpose you will use it for, how many people you intend to carry, the luggage space you will need, the rear legroom, whether it will fit into your parking lot, what safety equipment comes as standard, etc.
4 TEST DRIVE Taking a test drive is important to get a feel of the car. Drive a route you know well, so you can concentrate on the car rather than where you’re going. Pick a wide variety of roads and drive for at least half an hour. If you frequently travel on the highway, do just that. If you spend most of your time in town, test the car in traffic. The question you want to answer is: Is this a car you want to use every day?
2 SET YOUR BUDGET The most important thing to remember is that the bills don’t stop once you’ve bought your car – don’t forget every day running costs, such as fuel, insurance, servicing and road tax. It’s the same story with the single biggest cost in car ownership: depreciation. So remember that.
5 HAGGLE Negotiation is a crucial part of any deal. You should look as if you want to do a deal. Be insistent on the price you are willing to pay. If the salesman can’t agree to that, then he will lose your business. 6 CLOSE THE DEAL Eventually you should reach a point where you can think about shaking hands and putting pen to paper. Remember, though, that this is the point of no return. Once you sign, you have entered into a contract; pull out after this and the seller is entitled to compensation. The only exception is if you buy on finance, because the contract becomes binding only once the finance firm has also agreed. Always check the small print of any contract, particularly regarding delivery times.
3 EXCHANGE BONUS Selling your old car to the dealer you’re buying your new one from can make sense. If your car is a popular make and model in reasonable condition and with a service history and a chunk of its insurance remaining, most dealers will offer a fair price for it. If not, try selling privately.
The WhatCar? insider's guide to. . .
T
. . . G E T T I NG T H E B E ST D E A L he sticker price of a car is just a starting point for negotiations. Haggling brings some car buyers out in a cold sweat, but don’t be intimidated. Remember, sales people want your business as much as you want that new car.
undervalue your exchanged car. Equally, if a dealer thinks you’re more interested in a good price for your old car, they might overvalue the new car. It’s the cost to change — the difference between the new car’s price and your trade-in — that you pay. Keep it down.
DO YOUR HOMEWORK
DISCOUNT ON FINANCE
Before zeroing in on a dealer, hunt around and check out prices of the car of your choice at several dealers. Take the best quotes you can find with you. If the dealer knows you can buy the same car for a lesser amount somewhere else, he or she will be more likely to cut you a deal. And don't forget to check out our deals pages, where we tell you of the best discounts on offer.
Don’t be taken in by mouth-watering discounts offered on the financed amount of the deal. Remember the bigger the financed amount, the more you pay in terms of interest. So your short-term gain may actually be a long-term loss.
DON’T BE INTIMIDATED Sales staff cut deals for their living and have a number of tactics to sell at a price that suits them. Know the games before you set foot in the showroom and you’ll be a step ahead. Ever heard the ‘I can give you a special price, but only today’ line? Don’t believe it. Tomorrow’s deal is usually even better.
KEEP AN EYE ON YOUR COST TO EXCHANGE Some dealers give what appears to be a big discount only to
8080| OCTOBER | OCTOBER2017 2017 WHATCAR? WHATCAR?
DON’T GIVE UP A DISCOUNT FOR A SPECIAL OFFER
My total bu
dget
What I need Cars I want
from my ca
r
to test drive
Dealers I ne
ed to call
Test drive no
tes
Deals on of
fer
My choice
of car
Finance ra
te to aim fo
Best deal I
can get
r
Finance or insurance deals often tempt buyers into the showroom. Some dealers then use such offers to resist discounting, saying the special deal has eaten into their margin for negotiation. This might sound like a valid reason, but these offers are mostly paid for by car manufacturers.
TAKE TIME TO SHOP AROUND If the salesman doesn’t deliver the saving you want, don’t panic. Don’t ever think your local dealer is your only option.
H OW TO U S E T H E B U Y E R’S GU I D E
Your new car buyer’s guide H OW TO F I N D YOU R WAY A ROU N D I N D I A’S B I G G E ST A N D B E ST CA R B U Y E R’S GU I D E
1
idea as to just how efficient your car can be in the real world.
Verdict and prices
WHATCAR? VERDICT Our road test reviews are the standard by which the car industry judges new cars. Our ratings are: HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Good HHHHH Average HHHHH Below par HHHHH Poor ON THE ROAD PRICE This is the price set by the carmakers as well as local registration taxes and insurance charges, listed in Rupees/Lakhs.
2
Fuel Economy
3
top speed and power output (hp)/pulling power (nm). The figures were recorded by our road test team using sophisticated industry-standard timing equipment.
Performance
4
AVERAGE KILOMETRE PER LITRE (KPL) Based on official tests carried out by our sister magazine Autocar India, the average figure is a weighted average of two test runs — city and highway. Please note the official fuel consumption figures are published as a guide only — you may not match them in day-to-day driving.
Equipment
Find out if a particular model has the necessary features you want. The list includes all models with every variant on sale.
KEY AC/climate control Electric windows (R/F) Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele) Central/remote locking Leather seats Alloy wheels Traction control MP3-compatible Split/folding seats Rear wash wipe Electronic Stability Program Parking sensors
E/F e L/M O/P p D Y
TANK RANGE Based on the average kilometres per litre and the car’s fuel tank size, this is the maximum distance you’re able to travel after filling up the tank.
q/
AT WHATCAR? We undertake
exhaustive fuel efficiency tests in the real world. This is so that you can get a fair
PERFORMANCE FIGURES Our performance figures reflect acceleration (0-100kph) and
s! P
s
BUYER'S GUIDE Select a few favourites The most noteworthy model from the manufacturer
3
2
See what we have to say All new model additions and pricing are updated
MODEL DE
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Split/folding seats
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
MP3 player
Seats Height Adjust
Traction control
Airbags
E/F c/a N O/P p
Alloy wheels
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Highway
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
City
PERFORMANCE
Annual Insurance (Rs)
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Mumbai
1
Identify your budget Name and contact details of the dealership
MODE
MODEL DETAILS
Delhi
How to use this guide
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SUV MID-SIZE TO LUXURY SUV PREMIUM
P
s
MERCEDES
AUDI Q5 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4629mm Width 2089mm Height 1653mm Ground Clearance 201mm Boot 540/1560 Tank 75 litres Kerb Weight 1865kg 30TDI Premium (Diesel) 30TDI Premium Plus (Diesel) 30TDI Technology (Diesel)
58.04 61.64 66.16
62.70 66.59 71.49
Doors 5 Seats 7 Length 5162mm Ground Clearan Boot 680/2300 Kerb Weight 24
You’ll like Performance, build quality. You won’t Uninvolving driving experience, excessive road and wind noise. We say Much improved and now a much better-rounded product. Buy Premium Plus 58.10 61.62 66.05
60.87 64.69 69.49
58.42 68.78 65.10
— — —
— — —
— — —
14.1 14.1 14.1
172 11.21 172 11.21 172 11.21
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4648mm Width 1881mm Height 1661mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 550/1600 Tank 67 litres Kerb Weight 1715kg 57.96 62.63 63.36
Doors 5 Seats 4 Length 5140mm Ground Cleara Boot 590 Tank Kerb Weight 24
You’ll like Great to drive, comfortable cabin, intuitive iDrive system. You won’t Dated interior styling. We say There is no denying that the new X3 is a clever piece of engineering. Buy xLine 58.28 63.01 64.35
52.78 57.13 59.36
57.75 62.48 64.90
60.49 65.40 67.92
— — —
— — —
— — —
18.56 190 9.28 18.56 190 9.28 13.77 245 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
6.0 W12 5-Door
s
PORSCHE C
s
VOLVO XC60 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4644mm Width 1891mm Height 1713mm Ground Clearance 230mm Boot 495 Tank 70 litres Kerb Weight 1854-1912kg D4 Kinetic (Diesel) D4 Momentum (Diesel) D5 Inscription (Diesel)
53.06 57.05 61.14
You’ll like Superb seats, absorbent ride. You won’t Not as spacious as rivals. We say Grown up just a bit more. Buy D5 65.91 72.00 77.09
53.09 56.70 60.90
55.62 63.28 69.08
59.19 63.30 67.09
— — —
— — — — 9.0 12.2
— — —
183 — 183 — 218 9.90
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
s
LUXURY SUV PREMIUM LEXUS LX HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5080mm Width 1980mm Height 1865mm Ground Clearance 225 Boot NA Tank 93 litres Kerb Weight 2660-2840kg LX450d (Diesel)
GLS 400 (Petrol GLS 350d (Diese GLS 63 AMG
BENTLEY B
BMW X3 HHHH
xDrive20d Expedition (Diesel) xDrive20d xLine (Diesel) xDrive25i xLine (Petrol)
KEY TO VERD
HHHHH Outst HHHHH Very HHHHH Good HHHHH Reaso HHHHH Poor
275.00
NA
WHATCAR? WHATCAR? OCTOBER OCTOBER 2017 2017 | 81| 81
You’ll like Road presence, technology, reliability You won’t Price, rear seat comfort, 5-seater only. We say Posh and more luxurious version of the Toyota LC200.. Buy LX450d. NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
254
—
F c/a L
P
p 10 D/P D Y
q Yes Ex
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s
Doors 5 Seats 5 Length 4846mm Ground Cleara Boot 540/1770 T Kerb Weight 21
Cayenne (Petro Cayenne (Diese Cayenne S (Petr Cayenne S (Dies Cayenne GTS (P Cayenne Turbo Cayenne Turbo
LAND ROV
Doors 5 Seats 7 Length 4988m Ground Cleara Boot NA Tank 89/85 litre
MODEL BY MODEL HATCHBACK ENTRY
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
HATCHBACK ENTRY DATSUN REDIGO HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3429 mm Width 1560 mm Height 1541 mm Ground Clearance 185 mm Boot 222 Tank 28 Litres Kerb Weight 645 kg D (Petrol) A (Petrol) T (Petrol) T (O) (Petrol) S (Petrol) Sport 1.0 T (O) 1.0 S
2.82 3.48 3.71 4.07 4.23 4.13 4.07 4.23
3.05 3.74 3.99 4.10 4.27 3.63** 4.10 4.27
You’ll like Easy to manoeuvre, best-in-class legroom. You won’t Noisy engine, stiff suspension. We say Uniquely styled hatchback is good value but has a lot of visible cost-cutting. Buy S 2.85 3.31 3.60 3.72 3.89 3.63** 3.57** 3.72**
2.94 3.44 3.75 3.88 4.05 3.63** 3.98 4.53
2.90 3.63 3.88 4.27 4.45 4.34 4.27 4.45
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
25.17 25.17 25.17 25.17 25.17 25.17 22.7 22.7
54 54 54 54 54 54 68 68
17.21 17.21 17.21 17.21 17.21 17.21 NA NA
— E0 E E E E E E
— — — a a a a a
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — 1 1 1 1
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — —
— — — — — —
—
No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In
No No No No No No No No
— — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No
Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
Ex Ex Ex Ex In In In In In In
No No No No No No No No No No
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In
No No No No No No No No No No
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In In
No No No No No No No No No No No
— — — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No No
Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No —
— — —
MARUTI ALTO 800 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3430mm Width 1490mm Height 1475mm Ground Clearance 160mm Boot 177 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 695-812kg Std (Petrol) Std (O) (Petrol) LX (Petrol) LX (O)(Petrol) LXi (Petrol) LXi (O) (Petrol) VXi (Petrol) VXi (O) (Petrol) LXi (CNG) LXi (O) (CNG)
2.82 2.87 3.20 3.24 3.48 3.53 3.69 3.73 4.15 4.20
You’ll like Peppy and responsive engine, slick gearbox. You won’t Cabin space and legroom, firm ride. We say Gets the basics right. Buy LXI (O) 3.11 3.18 3.52 3.59 3.70 3.77 3.92 3.99 4.25 4.31
2.99 3.05 3.38 3.44 3.67 3.74 3.88 3.95 NA NA
3.08 3.15 3.47 3.54 3.77 3.84 3.99 4.06 4.37 4.50
3.20 3.27 3.60 3.67 3.91 3.98 4.14 4.21 4.56 4.63
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
24.70 24.70 24.70 24.70 24.70 24.70 24.70 24.70 — —
48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 41 41
18.34 18.34 18.34 18.34 18.34 18.34 18.34 18.34 — —
— — E E E E E E E E
— — — — a a a a a a
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — P P — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — a a a a
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — O O O P
— — — — — — — — — —
— 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — P P — — P P P
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — 1 — — — 1 1
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
— —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— —
MARUTI ALTO K10 HHH Doors 5 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3545mm Width 1295mm Height 1475mm Ground Clearance 160mm Boot 177 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 740-835kg LX (Petrol) LX (O) (Petrol) LXi (Petrol) LXi (O) (Petrol) LXi (P/CNG) LXi (O) (P/CNG) VXi (Petrol) VXi (O) (Petrol) VXi A/T (Petrol) VXi (O) A/T (Petrol)
3.70 3.77 3.88 3.95 4.58 4.66 4.06 4.24 4.47 4.11**
You’ll like Peppy engine, easy to drive. You won’t Narrow cabin, skinny tyres. We say A big upgrade over the old K10. Buy VXi (O) 3.94 4.01 4.13 4.20 4.84 4.75 4.32 4.55 4.86 4.92
3.96 4.02 4.13 4.19 4.28** 4.34** 4.31 4.52 4.79 4.85
4.01 4.08 4.20 4.27 4.14 4.52 4.39 4.61 4.86 4.97
4.07 3.49** 4.35 4.43 5.03 4.30** 4.55 4.79 5.09 5.18
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
24.07 24.07 24.07 24.07 — — 24.07 24.07 24.07 24.07
68 — E 68 — E 68 — E 68 — E 59 — E 59 — E 68 — E 68 — E 68 15.49 E 68 15.49 E
RENAULT KWID HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3679mm Width 1579mm Height 1478mm Ground Clearance 180mm Boot 300 Tank 28 litres Kerb Weight 669-699kg STD (Petrol) RXE (Petrol) RXE (O) (Petrol) RXL (Petrol) RXT (Petrol) RXT (O) (Petrol) 1.0 RXL (Petrol) 1.0 RXL A/T (Petrol 1.0 RXT (Petrol) 1.0 RXT(O) (Petrol) 1.0 RXT(O) A/T (Petrol)
3.21 3.66 3.47 3.92 4.29 4.42 4.16 4.47 4.52 4.66 4.98
You’ll like Spacious cabin, large boot, ride quality. You won’t Unrefined 800cc engine, small fuel tank. We say Unique budget car that breaks the mould not your pocket. Buy RXT (O) 3.62 4.10 4.22 4.38 4.74 4.88 4.63 4.97 4.99 5.14 5.48
3.52 3.95 3.85 4.21 4.54 4.65 4.57 4.87 4.93 5.06 5.37
3.30 3.78 3.80 4.07 4.44 4.58 4.32 4.66 4.69 4.83 5.17
3.37 3.86 3.97 4.15 4.53 4.68 4.41 4.75 4.79 4.90 5.28
HYUNDAI EON HHH
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3495mm Width 1550mm Height 1500mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 215 Tank 32 litres Kerb Weight 715-795kg
D-Lite (Petrol) D-Lite+ (Petrol) D-Lite+ (O) (Petrol)
82 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
3.64 3.91 4.01
3.91 4.21 4.31
— — — — — — — — — — —
15.3 15.3 15.3 15.3 15.3 15.3 — — — — —
21.5 21.5 21.5 21.5 21.5 21.5 — — — — —
25.17 25.17 25.17 25.17 25.17 25.17 23.01 — 23.01 23.01 —
54 54 54 54 54 54 68 68 68 68 68
16.93 16.93 16.93 16.93 16.93 16.93 — — — — —
— E E E E E E E E E E
— — — — a a — — a a a
—
You’ll like Styling, interior quality. You won’t Mediocre engine, dull to drive. We say Stylish, affordable runabout that feels a class higher. Now also in LPG. Buy Magna (O) 3.69 3.97 4.08
3.74 4.03 4.14
3.93 4.23 4.34
8299 13.7 17.2 9047 13.7 17.2 9047 13.7 17.2
21 21 21
56 17.60 56 17.60 56 17.60
— E E
— — —
No In No In No In
MODEL BY MODEL HATCHBACK ENTRY TO HATCHBACKS
— — — — O O O P P P
— — — — — — — — — —
— 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — —
In In In In In In In In In In
No No No No No No No No No No
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No In/No In/No In/No In/No Ex/No Ex/No
— —
— — —
— — O
— — —
— — O
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — — — —
— — — P P
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
L L L L L L L L L L L L
O O P P P P P O O P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — 2 2 2 — — — — 2
— — — — D D D — — — — D
— — — — D D D — — — — D
— — — —
P P P
O
Electric stability prog
No No No No No No No No No No
q
D/P D Y
— — — — L L L L — —
s!
Parking sensor
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
ABS
a a a a a a a a a a
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
E E E E E E E E E E
Rear wash wipe
E/F c/a N O/P p
Alloy wheels
17.60 17.60 — — 17.60 17.60 — 17.60 — —
Traction control
56 56 56 56 56 56 56 56 69 69
Seats Height Adjust
21 21 — — 21 21 — 21 — —
Rear defogger
17.2 17.2 — — 17.2 17.2 — 17.2 — —
Rear AC vents
13.7 13.7 — — 13.7 13.7 — 13.7 — —
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Average kpl
Airbags
9418 9418 11467 11467 10214 10214 12365 10956 — —
Leather Seats
4.39 4.51 4.63 4.92 4.77 4.88 5.14 5.10 5.26 5.37
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
4.18 4.30 4.24 4.15 4.55 4.66 4.57 4.87 5.13 5.23
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
4.13 4.10 4.42 4.54 4.48 4.59 4.77 4.80 5.05 NA
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
4.36 4.48 4.54 4.49 4.73 4.84 4.76 5.06 5.23 5.33
AC/climate control
Kolkata
Era+ (Petrol) Era+ (O) (Petrol) Era+ (Petrol/LPG) Era+(O) (Petrol/LPG) Magna+ (Petrol) Magna+ (O) (Petrol) Magna+ (Petrol/LPG) Sportz (Petrol) Magna (O) 1.0 litre Kappa (Petrol) Magna (O) opt 1.0 litre Kappa (Petrol)
Power hp
Mumbai
4.05 4.16 4.34 4.47 4.41 4.51 4.62 4.70 4.86 04.96
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
No In No In No In
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No —
— — —
— — —
No No No No No
— — — — —
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — — No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No —
—
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — —
No No No No No No No No No No No No
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
No No No No Yes Yes Yes No No No No Yes
— — — —
— — —
— — 2 2
— — — D — — D D — D D —
—
No No No No
In In In In
No Yes Yes Yes
— — — —
— — —
— — 2
— — —
— — —
— — —
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
DATSUN GO HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3785mm Width 1635mm Height 1485mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 265 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 788kg D (Petrol) A (Petrol) T (Petrol)
You’ll like Practicality, easy to drive. You won’t Evidence of cost cutting, sales and service network not robust as yet. We say Well priced, practical and easy to drive, but feels built to a cost. Buy T
3.78 4.37 4.61
4.49 4.69 4.92
3.96 4.43 4.81
3.95 4.55 4.78
4.03 4.59 4.83
— — —
12.8 17.9 20.6 12.8 17.9 20.6 12.8 17.9 20.6
68 14.54 68 14.54 68 14.54
— E E
— — a
TATA NANO HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Rear/Rear Length 3099mm Width 1495mm Height 1652mm Ground Clearance 180mm Boot 80/500 Tank 15 litres Kerb Weight 695-765kg XE (Petrol) XM (Petrol) XMA (Petrol) XT Twist (Petrol) XTA (Petrol)
2.52 2.89 3.33 3.10 3.53
You’ll like Easy maneuverability, cabin space, fuel efficiency. You won’t Ride quality, boot space. We say Barring a few flaws, the Nano is a great city car with superb value. Buy XTA
2.90 3.30 3.77 3.52 3.98
2.96 3.32 3.53 3.75 3.94
2.78 3.15 3.59 3.36 3.79
2.85 3.23 3.68 3.44 3.88
6952 7740 — — —
14.6 20.3 25.4 14.6 20.3 25.4 — — 21.9 14.6 20.3 25.4 — — 21.9
38 38 38 38 38
27.78 27.78 37.86 27.78 37.86
— E E E E
— — — a a
— — —
HATCHBACKS TATA TIAGO HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3748mm Width 1647mm Height 1535mm Ground Clearance 165-170mm Boot 242 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 930-1080kg 1.2 Revotron XB (Petrol) 1.2 Revotron XE (Petrol) 1.2 Revotron XM (Petrol) 1.2 Revotron XT (Petrol) 1.2 Revotron XZ (Petrol) 1.2 Revotron XTA A/T (Petrol) 1.2 Revotron XZA A/T (Petrol) 1.05 Revotorq XB (Diesel) 1.05 Revotorq XE (Diesel) 1.05 Revotorq XM (Diesel) 1.05 Revotorq XT (Diesel) 1.05 Revotorq XZ (Diesel)
3.61 4.26 4.61 4.94 5.54 5.33 5.95 4.48 5.04 5.48 5.81 6.41
You’ll like Value for money, cabin design and quality. You won’t Engine vibrations. We say The lacklustre engines take away from an otherwise well-rounded car. Buy 1.2 XT 3.97 4.61 4.96 5.31 5.94 5.80 6.34 4.84 5.44 5.92 6.28 6.91
3.97 4.54 4.87 5.19 5.78 4.94** 5.67** 4.73 5.26 5.71 6.04 6.63
3.92 4.53 4.83 5.17 5.82 5.53 5.52** 4.80 5.35 5.76 6.11 6.74
3.94 4.59 4.94 5.30 6.01 4.87** 6.51 4.75 5.35 5.82 6.24 6.88
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
84 84 84 84 84 84 84 69 69 69 69 69
— — — — — — — — — — — —
E E E E E E E E E E E E
— — c//a c//a c//a c//a c//a — — c//a c//a c//a
— — —
— — — —
No No No No Yes Yes Yes No No No No Yes
In/No In/No In/No El/No El/No El/No El/No In/No In/No In/No El/No El/No
No No Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes
— — — —
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
— — — — s!
s
s
s
s
— — — P P
s
s
HONDA BRIO HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3610mm Width 1680mm Height 1500mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 920-970kg 1.2 i-VTEC E (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC S (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC VX (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC VX A/T (Petrol)
5.11 5.64 6.42 7.53
5.50 6.10 6.94 7.92
You’ll like Clever packaging, fun to drive. You won’t Small boot. We say The facelift Brio is updated inside-out. Still offers big-car feel for small-car money. Buy VX M/T 5.18 5.72 6.51 7.42
5.43 6.00 6.83 7.77
5.59 6.21 7.13 8.11
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
18.5 18.5 18.5 16.5
89 89 89 89
— — — —
E a E c//a E c//a E c/a
L L L L
O P P P
— — — —
— — — —
No In No In No In
No — No In/No — No — No In/No — No — Yes ln/No —
— — —
No In
No — No In/No —
—
NISSAN MICRA ACTIVE HHH You’ll like Manoeuverability, quality interiors, equipment. You won’t Throttle response, seats not generous. We say Big car at a low cost. Buy XV
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3600mm Width 1600mm Height 1560mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 235 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 810-900kg XL (Petrol) XV (Petrol) XV S (Petrol)
5.23 5.61 6.20
5.60 5.99 6.60
5.25 5.63 6.21
5.44 5.83 6.44
5.50 5.91 6.63
— — —
11.8 17.5 11.8 17.5 11.8 17.5
19 19 19
68 15.50 68 15.50 68 15.50
E a L E c/a L E c/a L
HYUNDAI i10 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3565mm Width 1595mm Height 1550mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 225 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 860-952kg 1.1 Era (Petrol)
4.78
You’ll like Easy drivability, rev-happy engine. You won’t Narrow cabin, bouncy ride, dated interiors. We say Competent small car., now showing its age Buy 1.1 Sportz 5.17
4.89
5.06
5.20
12231 12.0 16.3
17.8
69 15.55
E
a
—
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 83
MODEL BY MODEL HATCHBACKS TO HATCHBACK MID-SIZE
c/a c//a c/a c/a
— — — —
— — — —
— — P
— — —
— — —
— — — — — — — D —
— —
— No In — No In q No In
No — No In/No — No — No In/No — No — No In/No —
— — —
Electric stability prog
No — No In/No — No — No In/No — Yes No El/No — Yes No El/No —
q
s!
Parking sensor
In In In In
ABS
No No No No
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
— —
Rear wash wipe
— — — —
D/P D Y — — — —
Rear defogger
— — — —
Split/folding seats
— — — —
MP3 player
— — — —
Alloy wheels
Rear AC vents
E E E E
Traction control
O O O O
E/F c/a N O/P p
Seats Height Adjust
69 15.55 69 — 69 15.55 69 —
Airbags
17.8 — 17.8 —
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Average kpl
12635 12.0 16.3 — — — 13970 12.0 16.3 — — —
Leather Seats
5.49 6.34 5.84 6.25
Central locking/ Remote locking
5.33 5.38 5.67 5.76
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
5.15 4.46** 5.48 5.81
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
5.45 5.79 5.80 5.78
AC/climate control
Kolkata
5.04 6.05 5.35 5.62
0-100 kph
Mumbai
1.1 Magna (Petrol) 1.1 Magna LPG (Petrol) 1.1 Sportz (Petrol) 1.1 Sportz LPG (Petrol)
Power hp
Delhi
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
TATA INDICA HH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3690mm Width 1665mm Height 1485mm Ground Clearance 165-170mm Boot 220 Tank 37 litres/30.7 litres (LPG) Kerb Weight 995-1080kg GLS (P/CNG) emax eV2 LS (Diesel) eV2 LX (Diesel)
4.82 5.55 6.06
5.02 6.10 6.66
You’ll like Affordable motoring, space and comfort. You won’t Fit and finish. We say Hanging in there as a value-for-money car. Buy LX NA 5.79 6.31
NA 6.13 6.68
5.81 5.91 6.55
— — — 14371 15.3 19.3 15284 15.3 19.3
— 25 25
50 — 70 15.93 70 15.9
E E E
— — a
— — —
MARUTI WAGON R HHH You’ll like Lively performance, feels effortless to drive, class-leading cabin space. You won’t Lacks refinement of rivals, not meant for highway driving (AMT). We say A user-friendly city car. Buy VXi
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3599mm Width 1475mm Height 1670mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 180 Tank 35 litres/LPG 28 litres Kerb Weight 860-925kg LXi (Petrol) LXi (CNG) LXi (O) (Petrol) VXi (Petrol) VXi ABS (Petrol) VXi A/T (Petrol) VXi (O) (Petrol) VXi (O) A/T(Petrol) VXi + (Petrol) VXi+ A/T (Petrol) VXi+ (O) (Petrol) VXi + (O) A/T (Petrol)
4.64 5.24 5.00 4.93 5.11 4.84 5.28 5.35 5.24 6.05 5.41 5.32**
4.84 5.18 5.21 5.14 5.48 5.68 5.51 6.05 5.46 6.22 5.88 6.45
4.84 4.51** 5.20 5.12 5.30 5.61 5.49 5.98 5.45 5.97 5.65 5.57**
4.96 4.45** 5.34 5.21 5.44 5.75 5.59 6.13 5.54 6.08 5.80 6.35
5.02 5.66 5.51 5.35 5.47 5.80 5.78 6.43 5.66 6.24 6.01 6.59
12114 14410 — 12857 13775 — — — — — — —
12.4 — 12.4 12.4 12.4 — 12.4 — 12.4 — 12.4 —
17.0 — 17.0 17.0 17.0 — 17.0 — 17.0 — 17.0 —
18.9 — 18.9 18.9 18.9 — 18.9 — 18.9 — 18.9 —
68 59 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68
16.9 — 16.9 16.9 16.9 — 16.9 — 16.9 — 16.9 —
E E E E E E E E E E E E
a a a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
— — — L L L L L L L L L
O O O P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — 2 2 — — 2 2 1 1 2 2
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — —
q q q q q q q q q q q q
No No No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In In In
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — No — Yes Ex/No — Yes No El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes No El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes No El/No — Yes No El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— 2 — 2 — 2 — 2 — 2 1 1 2 2
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — D D — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — q q q q q q q q q q
No No No No No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In In In In In
No No No No No No No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— — — — — D D — — D — — D
— — — D D D D — — D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— q q q q q q q q q q q q
No No No No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In In In In
No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
— Yes In/No — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/No — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/No — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes —
— — —
1
—
—
—
—
MARUTI CELERIO HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3600mm Width 1600mm Height 1560mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 235 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 810-900kg LXi (Petrol) LXi (O) (Petrol) LXi A/T (Petrol) LXi (O) A/T (Petrol) VXi (Petrol) VXi (O) (Petrol) VXi A/T (Petrol) VXi (O) A/T (Petrol) VXi (CNG) VXi (O) (CNG) ZXi (Petrol) ZXi A/T (Petrol) ZXi (O) (Petrol) ZXi (O) A/T (Petrol)
4.53 4.75 4.46 4.91 4.86 5.08 4.76 5.54 5.58 5.71 5.19 5.02 5.69 5.59
4.71 4.94 5.23 5.46 5.06 5.29 5.60 5.83 5.61 5.74 5.41 5.94 5.94 6.09
You’ll like Spacious cabin, peppy engine, easy to drive. You won’t Unsupportive seats, dull and unexciting interiors. We say The Celerio ticks all the small car must-have boxes, diesel is frugal. Buy ZXI (O) AMT 4.71 4.92 5.22 5.45 5.03 5.26 5.56 5.78 5.13 5.26 5.37 5.89 5.89 6.04
4.81 5.03 5.33 5.56 5.11 5.33 5.64 5.87 5.01 5.13 5.45 5.98 5.98 6.13
4.96 5.20 5.50 5.80 5.31 5.55 5.87 6.16 6.07 6.21 5.67 6.28 6.28 6.44
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
23.1 23.1 23.1 23.1 23.1 23.1 23.1 23.1 31/kg 31/kg 23.1 23.1 23.1 23.1
68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 58 58 68 68 68 68
14.42 14.42 15.41 15.41 14.42 14.42 15.41 15.41 — — 14.42 15.41 14.42 15.41
E E E E E E E E E E E E E E
— — — — c/a c//a c/a c//a c//a c//a c//a c/a c/a c/a
— — — — — — — — — — L L L L
— — — — O O O O O O P P P P
No Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes No No No No Yes Yes
Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No El/No El/No El/No El/No
HATCHBACK MID-SIZE MARUTI IGNIS HHHH You’ll like Good engines, loaded with equipment. You won’t Doesn't offer the most bang for the buck. We say Stylish and funky, the Ignis is a competitive car. Buy Zeta petrol auto
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3700mm Width 1690mm Height 1595mm Ground Clearance 180mm Boot 260 Tank 32 litres Kerb Weight 825-960kg 1.2 K12 Sigma (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Delta (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Delta A/T (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Zeta (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Zeta A/T (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Alpha (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Alpha A/T (Petrol) 1.3 DDiS Delta (Diesel) 1.3 DDiS Delta A/T (Diesel) 1.3 DDiS Zeta (Diesel) 1.3 DDiS Zeta A/T (Diesel) 1.3 DDiS Alpha (Diesel) 1.3 DDiS Alpha A/T (Diesel)
5.15 5.80 6.55 6.41 7.19 7.63 7.01** 7.40 8.03 7.99 8.62 9.00 8.08**
5.33 6.04 6.68 6.58 7.21 7.55 6.99** 7.46 8.11 8.02 8.67 8.95 8.09**
5.38 6.05 6.67 6.68 7.30 7.74 7.10** 7.40 8.01 7.98 8.60 8.98 8.18**
5.44 6.14 6.76 6.67 7.29 7.63 8.08 7.42 8.05 7.95 8.58 9.13 9.31
5.48 6.26 6.91 6.81 7.45 7.80 8.53 7.60 8.25 8.16 8.80 9.09 9.84
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
20.89 20.89 20.89 20.89 20.89 20.89 20.89 26.80 26.80 26.80 26.80 26.80 26.80
83 83 83 83 83 83 83 75 75 75 75 75 75
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
E E E E E F F E E F E E F
a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L L L
— P P P P P P P P P P P P
P P P P
s
s
s
s
— — P P P P
s
s
s
s
FORD FIGO HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3886mm Width 1695mm Height 1525mm Ground Clearance 174mm Boot 257 Tank 40-42 litres Kerb Weight 1037-1041kg Base (Petrol)
84 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
5.20
5.69
You’ll like Powerful diesel motor, spacious cabin, ride quality. You won’t Lacklustre interiors, unimpressive 1.2 petrol, automatic gearbox is slow to shift. We say The new Figo fits the bill as a great all-rounder. Buy 1.5 Sports Edition 5.44
5.54
5.79
—
—
—
18.16
88 13.64
E
—
L
O
—
No In
No — No In/No —
—
MODEL BY MODEL HATCHBACK MID-SIZE
a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a — c c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L L
— — — — Y — — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In In In
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
— No In/No — No El/No Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes — No In/No — No In/No — No El/No Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
— P P P — P P P P P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— D D D — D D D D D D D
— — — D — — — D — D — D
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— —
No No No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In In In
No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— Yes In/No — Yes In/No Yes El/No Yes El/Yes — Yes In/No — Yes In/No Yes El/No Yes El/Yes — Yes In/No Yes In/No — Yes In/No Yes In/No
— — — — — — — —
— — 2 2 — — 2 2
D — — D — — D — — D D — D — — D — — D — — D D —
—
No In q No In q No In q No In No In q No In q No In q No In
No No No Yes No No No Yes
— No In/No — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/No — Yes El/No — — No In/No — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/No — Yes El/No —
— — — — — — — —
— — —
— — 1
— — — — — — — D —
— —
— — —
No Ex No Ex No Ex
No — No Ex/No — No — No In/No — Yes — Yes El/No —
— — —
1 1 1 2 2 2 2 1 1 2 2 2
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — D — D D — — — — — — — — — — — — — D D —
— — —
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Re Re Re Ex Ex Ex Re Re
No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes
— — —
1 1
— —
No In No In
Yes Yes
q
Electric stability prog
— — D D D D — — — D D D
D/P D Y
Parking sensor
— — D D D D — — — D D D
ABS
2 2 2 2 2 6 1 2 2 2 2 6
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
— — — — — — — — — — — —
Split/folding seats
Rear wash wipe
E E F F F F E E E F F F
MP3 player
O P P P P P O O P P P P
E/F c/a N O/P p
Alloy wheels
13.64 13.64 13.64 11.11 13.64 13.64 10.55 10.55 10.55 10.55 10.55 10.55
Traction control
88 88 88 112 88 88 100 100 100 100 100 100
Seats Height Adjust
18.16 18.16 18.16 — — 18.16 25.83 25.83 25.83 25.83 24.3 25.83
Rear defogger
— — — — — — — — — — — —
Rear AC vents
— — — — — — — — — — — —
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Average kpl
Airbags
— — — — — — — — — — — —
Leather Seats
6.19 6.79 7.21 9.40 7.81 7.75 7.00 7.45 7.98 8.31 8.91 8.84
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
5.86 6.44 6.85 8.91 7.41 7.34 6.64 7.06 7.57 7.89 8.45 8.38
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
5.75 6.31 6.70 8.69 7.25 7.18 6.50 6.91 7.40 7.70 8.25 8.18
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
6.50 7.00 7.45 9.75 8.07 7.91 6.94 7.93 8.41 8.73 9.36 9.15
AC/climate control
Kolkata
5.51 6.13 6.51 8.69 7.24 6.82 6.39 6.70 7.50 7.81 8.37 8.35
Power hp
Mumbai
Ambiente (Petrol) Trend (Petrol) Titanium (Petrol) Titanium 1.5 A/T (Petrol) Sports Edition (Petrol) Titanium+ (Petrol) Base (Diesel) Ambiente (Diesel) Trend (Diesel) Titanium (Diesel) Sports Edition (Diesel) Titanium+ (Diesel)
KEY TO VERDICT
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
— — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
s!
— — — — — — — —
s
TOYOTA ETIOS LIVA HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3775mm Width 1695mm Height 1510mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 251 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight NA G (Petrol) GX (Petrol) V (Petrol) VX (Petrol) D-4D GD (Diesel) D-4D GXD (Diesel) D-4D VD (Diesel) D-4D VXD (Diesel) Cross G (Petrol) Cross V (Petrol) Cross D-4D GD (Diesel) Cross D-4D VD (Diesel)
5.81 6.06 6.31 7.04 7.50 7.77 7.96 8.42 7.25 8.80 8.66 8.99
You’ll like Space, easy to drive, responsive engines. You won’t Not exciting to drive, hard plastics. We say Practical big hatch but not terribly exciting. Buy V 6.43 6.81 6.98 7.60 8.13 8.52 8.61 9.10 7.92 9.68 9.43 9.78
5.45** 6.35 6.52 7.10 6.81** 7.95 8.05 7.55 6.49 8.30 7.87 8.32
6.48 6.86 7.03 7.67 8.02 8.43 8.69 9.12 7.96 9.68 9.31 9.66
NA 6.79 6.96 7.60 NA 8.42 8.52 9.02 7.93 9.60 9.34 9.69
TATA BOLT HHH
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3825mm Width 1695mm Height 1562mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 210 Tank 44 litres Kerb Weight 1095-1160kg
XE Revotron (Petrol) XM Revotron (Petrol) XMS Revotron (Petrol) XT Revotron (Petrol) XE Quadrajet (Diesel) XM Quadrajet (Diesel) XMS Quadrajet (Diesel) XT Quadrajet (Diesel)
5.11 5.84 6.09 6.90 6.32 7.04 7.44 8.18
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — 18.16 — — 18.16 — — 18.16 — — 18.16 — — 23.59 — — 23.59 — — 23.59 — — 23.59 12.1 16.7 18.3 — — 16.7 14.5 19.3 23.5 14.5 19.3 23.5
80 80 80 80 68 68 68 68 80 90 68 68
— — — — — — — — 15.93 11.88 15.86 15.86
E E E E E E E E E E E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L L
— —
— —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — P
s
— — — P
s
— — — —
You’ll like Superb ride, spacious cabin, well equipped. You won’t Small boot, petrol engine needs more fine-tuning. We say Offers almost all that’s expected from a big hatch. Buy XMS 5.71 6.51 6.78 7.55 7.09 7.81 8.05 8.86
5.36 6.11 6.36 7.07 6.56 7.21 7.44 8.17
5.35 6.13 6.39 7.13 6.62 7.29 7.53 8.29
5.47 6.33 6.61 7.37 6.82 7.54 7.78 8.57
— — — — — — — —
11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 — — — —
16.1 16.1 16.1 16.1 — — — —
— — — — — — — —
90 90 90 90 75 75 75 75
15.81 15.81 15.81 15.81 16.58 16.58 16.58 16.58
E E E F E E E F
— c/a c/a c/a — c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L
— P P P — P P P
—
MAHINDRA VERITO VIBE HH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3991mm Width 1740mm Height 1540mm Ground Clearance 172mm Boot 330 Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight 1155kg D2 (Diesel) D4 (Diesel) D6 (Diesel)
7.21 7.53 8.26
You’ll like Spacious and comfortable, predictable handling. You won’t Quirky styling, fixed rear glass. We say A sensible choice for anyone buying a comfortable compact car. Buy D4 7.94 8.28 9.05
6.34 6.62 7.26
7.61 7.94 8.70
7.56 7.88 8.62
— — —
13.7 19.3 20.8 13.7 19.3 20.8 13.7 19.3 20.8
64 16.07 64 16.07 64 16.07
E — — E c/a — E c/a —
— O P
HYUNDAI GRAND i10 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3765mm Width 1660mm Height 1520mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 256 Tank 43 litres Kerb Weight 1093kg 1.2 Kappa Era (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa Magna (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa Magna A/T (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa Sportz (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa Sportz (O) (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa Sportz (O) A/T (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa Asta (Petrol) 1.2 U2 CRDi Era (Diesel) 1.2 U2 CRDi Magna (Diesel) 1.2 U2 CRDi Sportz (Diesel) 1.2 U2 CRDi Sportz (O) (Diesel) 1.2 U2 CRDi Asta (Diesel)
5.01 5.70 6.49 6.15 6.47 7.58 7.11 6.22 6.97 7.45 7.78 8.25
5.41 6.16 7.03 6.65 7.00 7.99 7.49 6.83 7.40 7.90 8.26 8.76
You’ll like Easy-to-drive, good equipment levels, ergonomics. You won’t Stiff ride, small cabin, diesel needs more power. We say Efficient and user-friendly city car that’s good value too. Buy 1.2P Sportz 5.25 5.97 6.83 6.45 6.80 7.77 7.28 6.51 7.05 7.53 7.87 8.36
5.24 5.97 6.82 6.46 6.80 7.77 7.29 6.48 7.03 7.52 7.86 8.35
5.55 6.38 7.28 6.89 7.26 8.29 7.77 6.95 7.53 8.05 8.41 8.93
— — — — — — — — — — — —
11.7 11.7 — 11.7 11.7 — 11.7 — — — — —
16.3 16.3 — 16.3 16.3 — 16.3 — — — — —
18.9 18.9 — 18.9 18.9 — 18.9 — — — — —
83 83 83 83 83 83 83 75 75 75 75 75
— — — — — — — — — — — —
E E E E E E F E E E E F
a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a
— — — L L L L — — L L L
— P P P P P P — P P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— —
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No Yes No No No No Yes
In/No El/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — —
P P P P
s
s
s
s
— — P P P
s
s
s
RENAULT PULSE HHHH You’ll like Decent ride quality and friendly handling manners. You won’t Low rear seat, dull cabin. We say Comes with a dash of French flair but there are better options in the market. Buy 1.5 D RxZ.
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 3805mm Width 1665mm Height 1530mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 251 Tank 41 litres Kerb Weight 1070kg 1.2 RXL (Petrol) 1.5 dCi RXL ABS (Diesel)
5.68 7.05
6.29 7.85
6.29 7.63
6.03 8.21
5.99 7.36
— —
— —
— —
— —
76 64
— —
F c/a L F c/a L
P P
— —
— —
— —
— —
No El/Yes — Yes El/Yes —
— —
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 85
MODEL BY MODEL HATCHBACK MID-SIZE TO HATCHBACK PREMIUM
Average kpl
—
—
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
—
Traction control
64
Seats Height Adjust
—
Airbags
—
Leather Seats
8.20
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
8.02
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
8.11
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
8.13
AC/climate control
Kolkata
1.5 dCi RXZ (Diesel)
0-100 kph
Mumbai
7.76
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Power hp
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
Highway
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
P
—
2
D D —
P P P P
— — — —
1 2 1 1
— — — D D — — — — — — —
—
L L L L L L L L L L
— P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — — — — — —
— 2 — 2 2 — 2 — 2 2
— — — — — — — — — — — — D D — — — — — — — — — — — — — D D —
— —
L L
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
No In No In
No — No In/No — No — No In/No —
— —
P P P
— — —
— — —
— — — — — — — D —
—
No In No In No In
No — No In/No — No — No In/No — No — No In/No —
— — —
No No No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In In In
No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes —
— — — — —
In In In In In
No Yes Yes Yes Yes
F c/a L
No In
Yes
Yes El/Yes —
—
No No No No
Ex Ex Ex Ex
No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — No — No In/No — No — Yes ln/No —
— — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In EI In In In In EI
No No No No Yes No No No No Yes
— — — —
NISSAN MICRA HHH You’ll like Easy to drive, improved interiors. You won’t Delayed throttle responses (CVT), rear seat still lacks thigh support. We say Much improved but quite dull to drive. Buy XL diesel
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3825mm Width 1665mm Height 1525-1530mm Ground Clearance 150-154mm Boot 251 Tank 41 litres Kerb Weight NA XL CVT (Petrol) XV CVT (Petrol) XL (Diesel) XL (O) (Diesel)
6.70 7.98 7.77 8.53
7.16 8.33 8.04 8.83
6.72 7.83 7.42 8.16
7.00 8.16 7.73 8.50
7.21 8.41 8.05 8.85
— — — —
— — — — 14.6 19.5 14.6 19.5
19.3 19.3 23 23
77 77 64 64
17.88 17.88 15.98 15.98
E F E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L
—
MARUTI SWIFT HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3850mm Width 1695mm Height 1530mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 204 Tank 42 litres Kerb Weight 960-1080kg LXi (Petrol) LXi (O) (Petrol) VXi (Petrol) VXi (O) (Petrol) ZXi (Petrol) LDi (Diesel) LDi (O) (Diesel) VDi (Diesel) VDi (O) (Diesel) ZDi (Diesel)
5.26 5.39 6.23 6.40 7.29 6.76 7.21 7.59 7.67 8.65
You’ll like Fun to drive, ride and handling, good engines. You won’t Rear-seat space, no automatic option. We say Still one of the sportiest hatchbacks on sale. Buy VXi (O) / VDi (O)
5.49 5.82 6.40 6.57 7.39 7.16 7.35 7.86 7.95 8.78
5.57 5.80 6.37 6.55 7.36 6.98 7.16 7.66 7.75 8.55
5.71 5.94 6.52 6.70 7.52 7.12 7.19 7.88 7.97 8.79
5.85 5.90 6.80 6.99 7.85 7.41 7.60 8.17 8.26 9.16
— — — — — — — — — —
12.6 12.6 12.6 12.6 12.6 14.6 14.6 14.6 14.6 14.6
17 17 17 17 17 19.5 19.5 19.5 19.5 19.5
20.4 20.4 20.4 20.4 20.4 25.2 25.2 25.2 25.2 25.2
84 84 84 84 84 75 75 75 75 75
14.24 14.24 14.24 14.24 14.24 13.65 13.65 13.65 13.65 13.65
E E E E F E E E E F
— a c/a c/a c/a a a c/a c/a c/a
— — — —
q q q q q q q q q q
— — — — — — — —
No Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No In/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No In/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
P
s
— — — — P
s
FIAT PUNTO PURE HH You’ll like Feels tough, ride quality. You won’t Dull engines,small dealer network. We say Doesn’t cost much and does a good job of the basics. Buy 1.3 Diesel
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3987mm Width 1687mm Height 1495mm Ground Clearance 185-195mm Boot NA Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight NA 1.2 Fire (Petrol) 1.3 Multijet (Diesel)
5.06 6.30
5.69 7.10
4.80** 5.89**
5.95 6.90
4.65** 5.73**
— —
— —
— —
— —
68 68
— —
F F
a a
— —
HATCHBACK PREMIUM MAHINDRA e2o PLUS HHH You’ll like Spacious and comfortable rear seating. You won’t Build quality, handling. We say An eco-friendly hatchback that carrys four in comfort. Buy P8
Doors 4 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3590mm Width 1575mm Height 1585mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 135 Kerb Weight 932-990kg P4 (Electric) P6 (Electric) P8 (Electric)
5.46** 5.95** 8.46**
7.87 8.28 10.97
6.96** 7.33** 9.67**
8.31 9.14 12.64
7.90 8.68 11.79
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
26 26 41
— — —
E c/a — E c/a — E c/a —
MARUTI BALENO HHHH You’ll like Ride and handling, cabin space, equipment list. You won’t Interiors lack upmarket feel, rough diesel engine, edgy and nervous steering. We say Ticks all the right boxes and gives the best bang for the buck.Buy 1.2 Zeta
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1745mm Height 1500mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 339 Tank 37 litres Kerb Weight 890-985kg 1.2 K12 Sigma (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Delta (Petrol) 1.2 Delta A/T (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Zeta (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Zeta A/T (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Alpha (Petrol) 1.2 K12 Alpha A/T (Petrol) 1.0 Boosterjet RS (Petrol) DDiS 190 Sigma (Diesel) DDiS 190 Delta (Diesel) DDiS 190 Zeta (Diesel) DDiS 190 Alpha (Diesel)
5.89 6.66 8.02 7.51 8.70 8.30 8.34** 9.85 7.47 8.21 8.91 9.71
6.19 7.03 8.23 7.73 8.94 8.54 9.64 9.78 7.70 8.50 9.23 10.07
6.20 6.99 8.18 7.67 8.86 8.46 8.49** 10.00 7.51 8.25 8.93 9.73
6.33 7.15 8.34 7.85 9.04 8.65 8.49** 9.88 7.69 8.47 9.17 9.99
6.46 7.31 8.55 8.03 9.27 8.87 10.24 10.13 7.87 8.68 9.41 10.26
— — — — — — — — — — — —
13.4 13.4 13 13.4 13.4 13.4 — — 14.9 14.9 14.9 14.9
18.1 18.1 16.9 18.1 18.1 18.1 — — 21.42 21.42 21.42 21.42
21.4 21.4 21.4 21.4 21.4 21.4 — — 18.1 18.1 18.1 18.1
84 84 84 84 84 84 84 102 75 75 75 75
12.60 12.60 13.20 12.60 12.60 12.60 — — 12.92 12.92 12.92 12.92
E F F F F F F F E F F F
a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a
L L L N N N N N L L N N
O P P P P P P P O P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— — — D D D D D — — D D
— — — D D D D D — — D D
— — — — — — — — — — — —
—
— — — — —
2 2 2 2 2
— — D — D — D — D D
— — — — —
—
—
— q q q q q q q — q q q
— P P P P
P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
— P P P
s
s
s
HONDA JAZZ HHHH You’ll like Free-revving petrol engine, space and practicality. You won’t Noisy diesel engine, missing equipment. We say Well-rounded hatchback that puts practicality above all else. Buy 1.2 V MT
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3955mm Width 1694mm Height 1544mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 354 Tank 40 litres Kerb Weight 1007-1155kg 1.2 i-VTEC E (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC S (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC S A/T (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC SV (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC V (Petrol)
86 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
6.41 7.28 8.47 7.76 8.14
6.88 7.61 8.86 8.12 8.52
6.53 7.22 8.37 7.68 8.08
6.81 7.53 8.74 8.02 8.43
7.08 7.84 9.11 8.35 8.78
— — — — —
12.3 12.3 — 12.3 12.3
16.9 16.9 — 16.9 16.9
18.2 18.2 19 18.2 18.2
90 90 89 90 90
14.20 14.20 14.89 14.20 14.20
E E E E F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L
— P P P P
— — — —
No No Yes Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/No El/No El/Yes
— — — — —
— — — — —
MODEL BY MODEL HATCHBACK PREMIUM TO HATCHBACK IMPORT/LUXURY
E/F c/a N O/P p F F E E E F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L
P P — P P P P
— — —
— —
No No No q Yes q Yes
In In In In In
No — Yes In/No — No — No In/No — No — Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No —
—
No No No No No No No No No No
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/No s Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2
D D — D D D D
D D — — — D D
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 6 2 2 6 2 2 2 2 2 6 2 2 6
— — — D D D D — D D — — D D D D — D D
— — — — — D D D D D — — — — D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
—
— — — — —
— — — 2 2
— — — — — — D — — D D — D D —
— — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
D D D D D D D D D D
q —
q
Electric stability prog
No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes
q
D/P D Y
— — — — — — —
s!
Parking sensor
In In In In In In In In In In In In In In In In In In In
ABS
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
— — — — — — —
Rear wash wipe
Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — No — Yes In/No — Yes — Yes El/No — Yes — Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes —
Rear defogger
In In In In In In In
Split/folding seats
— — — — — — —
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Rear AC vents
— — 19 89 14.89 12.3 16.9 18.2 90 14.20 — — 27.3 100 12.11 — — 27.3 100 12.11 — — 27.3 100 12.11 — — 27.3 100 12.33 — — 27.3 100 12.33
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Average kpl
Airbags
— — — — — — —
Leather Seats
10.02 9.35 8.69 9.50 9.97 10.53 11.02
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
9.61 8.97 8.35 9.12 9.57 10.10 10.57
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
9.20 8.59 7.98 8.72 9.15 9.65 10.10
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
9.73 9.08 8.58 9.37 9.85 10.38 10.87
AC/climate control
Kolkata
9.30 8.68 8.19 8.94 9.39 9.89 10.36
Power hp
Mumbai
1.2 i-VTEC V A/T (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC VX (Petrol) 1.5 i-DTEC E (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC S (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC SV (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC V (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC VX (Diesel)
KEY TO VERDICT
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
HYUNDAI i20 ELITE HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3985-3995mm Width 1734-1760mm Height 1505-1555mm Ground Clearance 170-190mm Boot NA Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1080-1200kg 1.2 Kappa VTVT Era (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa VTVT Magna Exec (Petrol) 1.4 Dual VTVT Magna A/T (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa VTVT Sportz (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa VTVT Asta (Petrol) 1.2 Kappa VTVT Asta Dual tone (P) 1.2 Kappa VTVT Asta (O) (Petrol) i20 Active Kappa VTVT (Petrol) i20 Active Kappa VTVT S (P) i20 Active Kappa VTVT SX (P) 1.4 U2 CRDi Era (Diesel) 1.4 U2 CRDi Magna Exec (Diesel) 1.4 U2 CRDi Sportz (Diesel) 1.4 U2 CRDi Asta (Diesel) 1.4 U2 CRDi Asta Dual Tone (Diesel) 1.4 U2 CRDi Asta (O) (Diesel) i20 Active CRDi (Diesel) i20 Active CRDi S (Diesel) i20 Active CRDi SX (Diesel)
5.82 6.49 9.99 7.17 7.75 8.01 8.64 7.48 8.26 9.25 7.51 8.12 8.63 9.27 9.54 10.15 9.10 9.90 10.89
6.30 7.04 10.49 7.57 8.18 8.46 9.12 7.92 8.74 9.77 8.00 8.64 9.19 9.86 10.15 10.80 9.70 10.55 11.61
6.14 6.86 10.34 7.38 7.98 8.26 8.90 7.63 8.48 9.49 7.63 8.26 8.78 9.43 9.71 10.33 9.19 10.01 10.80
You’ll like Brilliant cabin, refined and punchy diesel motor. You won’t Unexciting to drive, petrol feels underpowered. We say Not very engaging to drive but feels every bit a premium hatchback. Buy 1.4 Sportz 6.10 6.82 10.21 7.35 7.94 8.22 8.88 7.68 8.49 9.51 7.59 8.21 8.74 9.40 9.68 10.30 9.22 10.05 11.07
6.53 7.29 10.88 7.85 8.48 8.77 9.47 8.13 9.10 10.06 8.14 8.80 9.36 10.05 10.35 11.01 9.87 10.85 11.82
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
11.5 11.5 — 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 — — — — — — — — — — — —
15.2 15.2 — 15.2 15.2 15.2 15.2 — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
83 83 100 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90
15.71 15.71 — 15.71 15.71 15.71 15.71 — — — 12.85 12.85 12.85 12.85 — 12.85 — — —
E E E E F F F E E F E E F F F F E E F
a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
— — — — N N N — — N — — N N N N — — N
O O P P P P P P P P O O P P P P P P P
q
q —
q
q
— — — — —
— — — — — —
— —
No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
P P P P
s
s
s
s
— P P
s
s
— — P P P P
s
s
s
s
— P P
s
s
FIAT PUNTO EVO HHH You’ll like Fantastic ride and handling, supremely stylish. You won’t Petrol engine lacks punch, awkward driving position. We say Oozes style both inside and out, but let down by its sales network. Buy 1.3 Dynamic
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3987-3989mm Width 1687mm Height 1495-1505mm Ground Clearance 155-195mm Boot 280 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1090-1144kg 1.2 Fire Pure (Petrol) 1.3 Multijet Active (Diesel) 1.3 Multijet Dynamic (Diesel) 1.3 Multijet Emotion (Diesel) 1.4 T-jet Abarth (Petrol)
5.46 7.29 7.98 8.59 10.80
5.77 7.62 8.34 8.99 11.30
5.76** 7.66 8.34 8.96 11.25
5.69 7.39 8.08 8.71 11.14
5.68 7.48 8.26 8.91 11.55
— — — — —
9.7 — — — —
15 — — — —
15.8 — — — —
68 18.16 93 — 93 — 93 — 147 9.54
E a L E a L E c/a L F c/a L F a L
— O P P P
— — — — —
VOLKSWAGEN POLO HHH You’ll like Smooth torquey diesel,fantastic build quality. You won’t Rear legroom is tight. We say With its new engine and updates, the Polo is back in business. Buy 1.5 Comfortline
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3971-3987mm Width 1682-1698mm Height 1469-1474mm Ground Clearance 168mm Boot 294 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1030-1125kg 1.2 MPI Trendline (Petrol) 1.2 MPI Comfortline (Petrol) 1.2 MPI Highline (Petrol) 1.5 TDI Trendline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Comfortline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Highline (Diesel) 1.2 GT TSI A/T (Petrol) GT TDI (Diesel) Cross Polo (Petrol) Cross Polo (Diesel)
6.00 6.93 7.94 7.96 8.98 9.79 10.35 10.67 8.12 9.98
6.55 7.35 8.40 8.49 9.57 10.41 10.95 11.33 9.17 11.09
6.05 6.80 7.80 7.70 8.70 9.48 10.18 10.33 8.58 10.17
6.28 7.07 8.10 8.00 9.04 9.85 10.58 10.74 8.84 10.48
6.50 7.32 8.40 8.29 9.38 10.23 11.00 11.17 9.08 10.64
— — — — — — — — — —
10.9 10.9 10.9 14 14 14 10.5 — 10.9 14
15.5 15.5 15.5 18.9 18.9 18.9 15.9 — 15.5 18.9
16.47 16.47 16.47 20.14 20.14 20.14 17.21 — 16.47 20.14
75 75 75 90 90 90 105 110 75 90
16.50 16.50 16.50 13.08 13.08 13.08 11.02 — 16.50 13.08
E E F E E F F F F F
a c/a c/a c c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N N N
O P P O P P P P P P
— — D — — D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — —
—
!
— — P
s
— — P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
HATCHBACK IMPORT/LUXURY VOLKSWAGEN GTI HHHH Doors 3 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3976mm Width 1682mm Height 1452mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1273kg GTI (Petrol)
30.06
30.10
You’ll like Punchy performance, superb engine and gearbox You won’t Looks too similar to the Polo hatchback, expensive We say Drives very well but is let down by its price Buy GTI NA
24.18
24.74
—
—
—
—
192
—
F c/a N P
p
6 D/P D Y
q No Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
7 D/P D Y
—
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s
TOYOTA PRIUS HHH You’ll like Comfy to drive, spacious rear seat, efficiency. You won’t Expensive to buy, . We say Very expensive to buy but is surprisingly nice to drive and be driven in. Buy Z8.
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4540mm Width 1760mm Height 1490mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 43 litres Kerb Weight NA Z8 A/T (Hybrid)
53.13
56.63
43.04**
51.58
57.49
—
—
—
—
122
—
F c/a N P
No Re
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 87
MODEL BY MODEL HATCHBACK IMPORT/LUXURY
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s!
P
s
MINI CLUBMAN HHH You’ll like Practical Mini, punchy engine, driving dynamics. You won’t Expensive to buy, confused character.. We say A well-equpped, practical car with a great engine with extensive customizable options. Buy Cooper S.
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4253mm Width 1800mm Height 1441mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 360 Tank NA Kerb Weight NA Cooper S Clubman (Petrol)
37.90**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
13.8
192
—
F c/a N P
p
2 D/P D Y
q No Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
p p p p
6 6 8 8
q q q q
No No No No
Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
VOLVO V40 HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4369mm Width 1783mm Height 1420mm Ground Clearance 133-145mm Boot 324 Tank 62 litres Kerb Weight 1485-1582kg D3 Kinetic (Diesel) D3 R-Design (Diesel) Cross Country D3 Inscription (D) Cross Country T4 Inscription (P)
32.40 36.55 37.60 33.90
39.03 41.49 47.67 38.87
You’ll like Punchy engine, handling, equipment and safety. You won’t Rear seat space, limited sales and service outlets. We say The full compact luxury experience, but at a price. Buy D3 R-Design 30.11 34.10 35.15 33.32
32.36 36.00 41.04 34.23
35.30 40.77 41.76 37.34
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
152 8.68 152 8.68 152 8.68 180 —
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
Yes El/No —
P
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s
s
s
s
FIAT ABARTH HHH Doors 3 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 3657mm Width 1627mm Height 1485mm Ground Clearance 105mm Boot NA Tank NA Kerb Weight 1155kg 595 Competizione (Petrol)
34.58
You’ll like Zesty, agile handling, capable track-day performance. You won’t Rock-hard ride, limited rear space., AMT We say There’s something about the Competizione’s enthusiasm that’s hard to dislike. Buy 595 Competizione
39.06
NA
NA
38.11
—
—
—
—
160 10.58 E
P
p
2
— D —
q Yes In
Yes
a N P
p
6 D/P D —
q No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
— —
7 D/P D Y 7 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p
7 D/P D — 7 D/P D —
q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
F c/a N P
—
6 D/P D Y
q Yes Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
F a F a F c/a F c/a
P P P P
p p p p
6 6 6 6
q q q q
No No No No
Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
F c/a N P
p
6 D/P D Y
q No Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
a
L
s
VOLKSWAGEN BEETLE HHHH Doors 3 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4278mm Width 1808mm Height 1486mm Ground Clearance 136mm Boot NA Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight NA 1.4 TSI (Petrol)
34.63
38.17
You’ll like Retro looks, powertrain, ride quality. You won’t Price. We say No longer just fashionable, but a capable all-rounder as well. Buy 1.4 TSI 34.13
33.39
33.56
—
—
—
—
150 9.22
F
s
MERCEDES A-CLASS HHHH Doors 5 .Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4299mm Width 1780mm Height 1433mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 341 Tank 56 litres Kerb Weight NA A180 Sport (Petrol) A200 d Sport (Diesel)
31.89 33.73
37.64 38.97
You’ll like Stylish, sporty, luxurious. You won’t Poor rearward visibility, low rear-seat, missing equipment. We say Beautifully built, stunning looks and dynamically competent. Buy 200 d Sport 30.98 34.13
34.24 35.47
35.63 36.91
— —
— —
— —
— —
124 9.76 136 8.71
E c/a N P E c/a N P
s
s
MERCEDES B-CLASS HHHH You’ll like Spacious, versatile cabin, impeccable fit. You won’t Unusual design, expensive. We say Spacious, comfortable and versatile Merc hatch. Buy 200 CDI Sport
Doors 5 .Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4393mm Width 1786mm Height 1557mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 486/1545 Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight 1425-1577kg B180 Sport (Petrol) B200 CDI Sport (Diesel)
34.15 36.05
40.29 41.62
34.22 36.40
37.11 38.35
38.19 39.47
99607 9.5 14.2 — — —
— —
123 10.2 136 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
BMW 1-SERIES HHH You’ll like Responsive engine, lightning quick gearbox. You won’t Does not feel very luxurious as you would expect, nervous steering. We say The most affordable BMW is rewarding to drive, but not great value. Buy 118d Sport Line
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4324mm Width 1765mm Height 1421mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 360/1200 Tank 52 litres Kerb Weight 1310-1345kg 118d Sport Line (Diesel)
37.32
37.76
33.92
37.29
38.14
—
—
—
—
150
—
s
MINI COOPER HHHH You’ll like Brilliant dynamics, cabin. You won’t Price, expensive options. We say Mini’s evergreen hatchback is back with a diesel. Buy Cooper S
Doors 3/5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3850mm Width 1727mm Height 1415mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 211 Tank 44 litres Kerb Weight 1150-1295kg Mini Cooper S 3-Door (Petrol) Mini Cooper D 3-Door (Diesel) Mini Cooper D 5-Door (Diesel) Mini Cooper S Convertible (P)
34.65** 28.60** 31.94** 34.90**
NA 31.85** 35.20** 36.47**
NA NA NA NA
NA 39.55 44.27 NA
NA 40.93 45.19 NA
— — — —
— 11 11 —
— 16.8 16.8 —
— — — —
192 6.44 116 9.94 116 9.94 192 —
N N N N
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
s
s
s
s
MINI COOPER COUNTRYMAN HHH You’ll like Peppy performance, funky interiors. You won’t Firm ride, cabin ergonomics. We say The most practical Mini ever, but still not that practical. Buy Diesel
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4110mm Width 1996mm Height 1561mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 350-1170 Tank 47 litres Kerb Weight 1335-1410kg Mini D Countryman (Diesel)
25.60**
88 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
32.41
NA
NA
NA
—
10.5 14.7
—
112 11.87
s
MODEL BY MODEL SEDAN SUB-4-METRE
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
SEDAN SUB-4-METRE TATA TIGORHHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3992mm Width 1677mm Height 1537mm Ground Clearance 165-170mm Boot 419 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 1035-1130kg Revotron XE (Petrol) Revotron XM (Petrol) Revotron XT (Petrol) Revotron XZ (Petrol) Revotron XZ(O) (Petrol) Revotorq XE (Diesel) Revotorq XM (Diesel) Revotorq XT (Diesel) Revotorq XZ (Diesel) Revotorq XZ(O) (Diesel)
5.19 5.56 5.94 6.45 6.81 6.00 6.50 6.99 7.53 7.85
You’ll like Value for money, cabin quality, features, large boot, ride quality You won’t Mediocre engines, interior space We say Great value proposition that rides well and is loaded with equipment but let down by dull engine options. Buy 1.2P XZ (O)
5.48 4.99** 6.31 6.86 7.18 6.54 5.82** 7.38 7.95 8.28
5.31 5.22** 6.09 6.61 6.92 6.21 6.04** 6.99 7.51 7.82
5.45 6.02 6.29 6.83 7.15 6.40 6.97 7.24 7.78 8.11
5.55 5.09** 6.46 7.03 7.36 6.58 5.91** 7.44 8.02 8.35
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
85 85 85 85 85 70 70 70 70 70
— — — — — — — — — —
— P P P P — P P P P
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — 2 2 — — — 2 2
— — D D D — — D D D
— — — D D — — — D D
— — — — — — — — — —
—
P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — — p — — — — — p
2 2 2 2 6 7 2 2 2 2 6
— — D D D D — — D D D
— — D D D D — — D D D
— — — — — — — — — — —
—
— — L L L L — — L L L — —
— O P P P P — O P P P P —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— — — — D D — — — D D — —
— — — — D D — — — D D — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
—
— — — E c/a — E c/a —
O O O
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — 2 2 — — 2
— — — — — — D — — D D — — — — — — — D — —
E E E E F E E E E F
— c/a c/a c/a c/a — c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L
—
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
In In In Re Re In In In Re Re
No No No Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
No No Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes
In/No In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes In/No In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No No
El El El El El El El El El El El
No No No No No No No No No No No
— — — — — — — — — — —
No Yes Yes Yes No Yes No Yes Yes Yes No
In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — —
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No No
In In In In Re Re In In In Re Re In In
No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes No No
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
No No No No Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes No No
In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No In/No
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — P P P
s
s
s
— — P P P
s
s
s
FORD FIGO ASPIRE HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1695mm Height 1525mm Ground Clearance 174mm Boot 359 Tank 42 litres Kerb Weight 995-1048kg 1.2 Ambiente (Petrol) 1.2 Trend (Petrol) 1.2 Titanium (Petrol) 1.2 Sports Edition (Petrol) 1.2 Titanium+ (Petrol) 1.5 Titanium A/T (Petrol) 1.5 Ambiente (Diesel) 1.5 Trend (Diesel) 1.5 Titanium (Diesel) 1.5 Sports Edition (Diesel) 1.5 Titanium+ (Diesel)
6.09 6.57 6.64 7.42 7.82 9.29 7.60 8.10 8.40 8.78 9.19
You’ll like Smooth and powerful engine, ride quality, generous safety kit. You won’t Drab interiors, tight knee room at the rear. We say Delivers almost everything you’d want from a compact sedan. Buy 1.5D Titanium
7.00 7.55 7.89 8.31 8.55 10.42 8.52 9.08 9.42 9.85 10.05
6.27 6.76 7.05 7.42 7.83 9.29 7.49 7.98 8.27 8.64 9.05
6.40 6.91 7.21 7.60 8.02 9.53 7.66 8.17 8.47 8.86 9.28
6.75 7.28 7.60 8.01 8.45 10.05 8.08 8.61 8.93 9.34 9.79
— — — — — — — — — — —
18.16 18.16 18.16 18.16 18.16 — 25.83 25.83 25.83 25.83 25.83
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
88 88 88 88 88 112 100 100 100 100 100
16.63 16.63 16.63 16.63 16.63 — 11.03 11.03 11.03 11.03 11.03
E E F F F F E E F F F
a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L
—
— — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
HYUNDAI XCENTHHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1660mm Height 1520mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 407 Tank 43 litres Kerb Weight 1018-1108kg E 1.2 Kappa (Petrol) E+ 1.2 Kappa (Petrol) S 1.2 Kappa (Petrol) S 1.2 Kappa A/T (Petrol) SX 1.2 Kappa (Petrol) SX(O) 1.2 Kappa (Petrol) E 1.2 U2 CRDi (Diesel E+ 1.2 U2 CRDi (Diesel) S 1.2 U2 CRDi (Diesel) SX 1.2 U2 CRDi (Diesel) SX (O) 1.2 U2 CRDi (Diesel) Prime CNG T Prime CNG T+
5.84 6.43 6.99 7.87 7.47 8.31 7.11 7.73 8.12 8.61 9.47 5.85 6.06
6.33 6.97 7.37 8.31 7.88 8.77 7.54 8.20 8.61 9.13 10.04 NA NA
You’ll like Refined and responsive petrol engine, boot space, feature loaded. You won’t Firm ride, cramped cabin. We say A smartly packaged sedan that ticks all the important boxes. Buy 1.2 SX MT 6.16 6.77 7.18 8.08 7.68 8.55 8.87 7.83 8.24 8.74 9.61 NA NA
6.12 6.75 7.15 8.06 7.65 8.52 7.16 7.80 8.19 8.70 9.57 NA NA
6.55 7.21 7.63 8.60 8.16 9.08 7.67 8.35 8.77 9.30 10.22 NA NA
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
83 83 83 83 83 83 75 75 75 75 75 75 75
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
E E E E E F E E E E F E E
a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a — —
—
— —
— — P P P P
s
s
s
s
— — P P P P
s
s
s
s
—
TATA INDIGO eCS HH You’ll like Fuel economy, price. You won’t Interior ergonomics, notchy gearbox. We say A sedan strictly for the value conscious. Buy LX
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3988mm Width 1620mm Height 1540mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 380 Tank 42 litres Kerb Weight 1065-1110kg GLS (Petrol) LS (Diesel) LX (Diesel)
5.46 6.59 7.01
5.84 7.18 7.39
6.11 6.89 7.08
7.09 7.29 7.50
7.09 7.09 7.43
— — — 16672 15.3 19.6 17316 15.3 19.6
15.6 23 23
65 — 70 16.15 70 16.15
No In No In No In
No — No In/No — No — No In/No — No — No El/No —
— — —
No No No No No No No
No No No Yes No No No
— — —
TATA ZESTHHH You’ll like Superb ride-handling balance, AMT-diesel combo works well, refinement. You won’t Oddly shaped small boot, drive modes dont feel as different as they should. We say Right up there with the best. Buy XT Quadrajet
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1706mm Height 1570mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 360 Tank 44 litres Kerb Weight 1115-1170kg XE Revotron (Petrol) XM Revotron (Petrol) XMS Revotron (Petrol) XT Revotron (Petrol) XE Quadrajet 75PS (Diesel) XM Quadrajet 75PS (Diesel) XMS Quadrajet 75PS (Diesel)
5.68 6.39 6.58 7.39 6.97 7.79 8.09
6.36 7.10 7.32 8.00 7.74 8.44 8.74
5.99 6.68 6.88 7.51 7.17 7.80 8.08
6.06 6.77 6.99 7.64 7.30 7.96 8.26
6.12 6.95 7.17 7.84 7.48 8.17 8.48
— — — — — — —
11.2 11.2 11.2 11.2 — — —
16.1 16.1 16.1 16.1 — — —
17.6 17.6 17.6 17.6 23 23 23
90 90 90 90 75 75 75
13.74 13.74 13.74 13.74 — — —
E E E F E E E
a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L
O P P P O P P
—
—
In In In In In In In
— — — — — — —
No No Yes Yes No No Yes
In/No El/No El/No El/No In/No El/No El/No
— — — — — — —
P
s
— — —
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 89
MODEL BY MODEL SEDAN SUB-4-METRE TO SEDAN ENTRY MID-SIZE
Average kpl
— — —
— — —
E/F c/a N O/P p E c/a L F c/a L F c/a L
P P P
— — —
— — — D D — D D —
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
q
D/P D Y — 2 2
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
90 — 90 14.78 90 —
Seats Height Adjust
23 23 23
Airbags
— — —
Leather Seats
9.15 9.19 10.16
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
8.94 8.98 9.90
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
8.74 8.78 9.66
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
9.46 9.50 10.45
AC/climate control
Kolkata
XMA Quadrajet 90PS (Diesel) XT Quadrajet 90PS (Diesel) XTA Quadrajet 90PS (Diesel)
0-100 kph
Mumbai
8.72 8.75 9.66
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Power hp
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
Highway
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
No In No In No In
No — Yes El/No — Yes — Yes El/No — Yes — Yes El/No —
—
— — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No
In In In In In In In In In In
No No No Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
ln/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes ln/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In Re Re Re Re Re Re In Re Re Re Re Re Re
No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — —
No No Yes No No No Yes Yes
In In In In In In In In
No No Yes No No No Yes Yes
— — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/Yes In/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In
No No Yes Yes
— — — —
No No Yes Yes
In/No In/No In/No In/No
— — — —
No No No No No No
Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/Yes In/No El/No El/Yes
— — — — — —
P P
s
s
HONDA AMAZE HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3990mm Width 1680mm Height 1505mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 400 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 940-1075kg 1.2 i-VTEC E (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC S (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC S CVT (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC SX (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC VX (Petrol) 1.2 i-VTEC VX CVT (Petrol) 1.5 i-DTEC E (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC S (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC SX (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC VX (Diesel)
6.00 6.42 8.21 7.78 8.21 9.28 7.54 8.50 9.07 9.49
6.51 7.73 8.66 8.22 8.66 9.78 8.06 9.19 9.54 9.95
You’ll like Smooth petrol engine, accurate steering, ample rear passenger space.You won’t Ride, dull to drive, missing features. We say The effective CVT gearbox and new dash makes a good car even better. Buy 1.2 SX MT 6.19 7.07 8.17 7.76 8.17 9.21 7.53 8.36 8.90 9.32
6.30 7.22 8.37 7.95 8.37 9.46 7.70 8.57 9.14 9.58
6.60 7.56 8.78 8.34 8.78 9.92 8.06 8.99 9.60 10.05
— — — — — — — — — —
12.5 12.5 — 12.5 12.5 — 15.2 15.2 15.2 15.2
17 17 — 17 17 — 20.8 20.8 20.8 20.8
18 18 — 18 18 — 25.8 25.8 25.8 25.8
88 88 90 88 88 90 100 100 100 100
13.27 13.27 — 13.27 13.27 — 12.97 12.97 12.97 12.97
E E E F F F E E F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L
O P P P P P O P P P
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — 2 2 2 — — 2 2
— — — D — — D — — D — — D D — D D — — — — D — — D — — D D —
—
— P P P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— D D D D D D — D D D D D D
—
— — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— — — D — — D D — — — — D — — D — — D D — D D —
—
—
MARUTI DZIRE HHHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1735mm Height 1515mm Ground Clearance 163mm Boot 378 Tank 42 litres Kerb Weight 860-990kg LXi (Petrol) VXi (Petrol) VXi A/T (Petrol) ZXi (Petrol) ZXi A/T (Petrol) ZXi + (Petrol) ZXi + A/T(Petrol) LDi (Diesel) VDi (Diesel) VDi A/T (Diesel) ZDi (Diesel) ZDi A/T (Diesel) ZDi+ (Diesel) ZDi+ A/T (Diesel)
6.07 7.16 7.70 8.00 8.55 8.99 9.54 7.47 8.42 8.96 9.28 9.82 10.28 10.81
You’ll like Ride, refined engines, cabin space., more proportionate looks You won’t Higher variants are pricey, diesel AMT. We say Larger, much better and more Dzirable. Buy ZXi 6.27 7.27 8.11 8.03 8.90 9.04 9.96 8.07 9.04 9.37 9.34 10.25 10.37 11.32
5.63** 6.92 7.04** 8.01 7.75** 8.19** 8.67** 7.56 8.10 9.20 8.31** 9.76 9.23** 9.71**
6.25 7.28 7.81 8.06 8.59 9.08 9.60 7.93 8.38 8.91 9.24 9.78 10.26 10.79
6.56 7.66 8.22 8.46 9.02 9.52 10.08 8.33 8.82 9.38 9.71 10.27 10.79 11.33
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
22 22 22 22 22 22 22 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4
84 84 84 84 84 84 84 75 75 75 75 75 75 75
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
E E E F F F F E E E F F F F
— c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L L L L
— — — D D D D — — — D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
—
P P P P
s
s
s
s
— — — P P P P
s
s
s
s
VOLKSWAGEN AMEO HHHH You’ll like Equipment, price, premium feel. You won’t Boot space, cramped back seat. We say An unexpected value proposition from VW but falls a bit short on practicality. Buy 1.5 TDI Comfortline M/T
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1682mm Height 1483mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 330 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1044-1069kg 1.2 MPI Trendline (Petrol) 1.2 MPI Comfortline (Petrol) 1.2 MPI Highline (Petrol) 1.5 TDI Trendline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Comfortline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Comfortline A/T (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Highline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Highline A/T (Diesel)
6.23 7.32 8.44 7.68 9.11 10.57 10.02 11.48
6.55 7.52 8.69 7.86 9.35 10.89 10.31 11.85
6.14 7.06 8.16 7.25 8.63 10.06 9.52 10.94
6.38 7.34 8.48 7.53 8.97 10.45 9.89 11.38
6.60 7.60 8.80 7.80 9.31 10.87 10.28 11.83
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — 21.66 21.66 21.73 21.66 21.73
75 75 75 110 110 110 110 110
15.80 15.80 15.80 15.80 15.80 15.80 15.80 15.80
E E F E E E F F
a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N
O P P O P P P P
—
s!
— — P
s
— — —
—
P
s!
P
s
s
SEDAN ENTRY MID-SIZE FIAT LINEA CLASSIC HH You’ll like Big-car feel, great combination of ride and handling. You won’t Below par performance, equipment. We say Great car to be driven in but lacks equipment. Buy Classic + Multijet
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4560mm Width 1730mm Height 1487mm Ground Clearance 185mm Boot 500 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1180-1230kg Classic FIRE (Petrol) Classic Multijet (Diesel) Classic + Multijet (Diesel) Classic + Premium Multijet (Diesel)
7.27 8.55 9.36 11.18
7.51 8.85 9.52 NA
7.68 8.89 9.54 NA
7.61 8.82 9.49 7.62
7.91 9.25 9.98 NA
— — — —
9.4 12.9 12.9 12.9
13.4 14.6 17.5 20.4 17.5 20.4 17.5 20.4
89 76 76 76
15.14 18.92 18.92 18.92
E E E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L
— — O O
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— —
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L
P P P P P P
— — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2
D — — D — — D D — D — — D — — D D —
—
— — — —
TOYOTA ETIOS HHH You’ll like Comfortable seats, easy to drive. You won’t Bland as white. We say An ideal A to B family car for India. Buy V
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4369mm Width 1695mm Height 1510mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 592 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight NA GX (Petrol) V (Petrol) VX (Petrol) GXD (Diesel) VD (Diesel) VXD (Diesel)
7.59 7.88 8.56 8.92 9.22 9.91
90 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
8.32 8.71 9.35 9.76 10.15 10.81
7.95 8.29 8.96 9.18 8.59 10.19
8.27 8.65 9.30 9.57 9.96 10.60
8.20 8.59 9.26 9.51 9.91 10.57
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
16.78 16.78 16.78 23.59 23.59 23.59
90 90 90 68 68 68
— — — — — —
E E E E E E
—
— — — — — —
— — P
s
— — P
s
MODEL BY MODEL SEDAN ENTRY MID-SIZE TO SEDAN MID-SIZE
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
— — — —
— — — —
s
MAHINDRA VERITO HH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4277mm Width 1740mm Height 1540mm Ground Clearance 172mm Boot 510 Tank 40 litres Kerb Weight 1080-1140 kg D2 (Diesel) D4 (Diesel) D6 (Diesel) D6 Executive (Diesel)
8.17 8.44 9.25 9.02
8.99 9.28 10.14 10.61
You’ll like Great ride quality, space and practicality. You won’t Still looks boxy, lacks upmarket feel. We say Very practical, great value but still not very desirable. Buy D6 7.05 7.29 7.96 8.68
8.62 8.91 9.76 8.36
8.52 8.81 9.67 10.28
23532 24316 26703 —
13.6 13.6 13.6 13.6
19.3 19.3 19.3 19.3
20.7 20.7 20.7 20.7
66 66 66 66
17.15 17.15 17.15 17.15
E — — E c/a — E c/a — E c/a —
— O P P
— — — — — 1 p 1
— — — — — — — D — — D —
— —
— — — —
No No No No
In In In In
No No Yes Yes
— — — —
No No Yes Yes
No/No In/No EI/No EI/No
— — —
— — — — D — — D —
—
— — —
No In No In No In
Yes — No In/No — Yes — No El/No — Yes — No El/No —
— — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In Re Re Re In In Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No EI/Yes EI/Yes EI/Yes EI/Yes EI/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes EI/Yes EI/Yes EI/Yes EI/Yes EI/Yes
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El El El El El El El El El El
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/No El/No
MAHINDRA eVERITO HH You’ll like Low running costs, eco-friendly, ride quality and space. You won’t Boxy looks, lacks power and range. We say An alternative to a regular car, if you have to go electric. BUY D6
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4247mm Width 1740mm Height 1540mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 510 Battery 72V Lithium-ion Kerb Weight NA D2 (Electric) D4 (Electric) D6 (Electric)
9.50** 9.80** 10.00**
12.15 12.17 12.45
NA NA NA
NA NA NA
10.97 11.23 11.49
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
41 41 41
— — —
E c/a — E c/a — E c/a —
— P P
— — —
SEDAN MID-SIZE HONDA CITY HHHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4440mm Width 1695mm Height 1495mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 510 Tank 40 litres Kerb Weight 1029-1165kg 1.5 i-VTEC S (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC SV (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC V (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC V CVT (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC VX (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC VX CVT (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC ZX CVT (Petrol) 1.5 i-DTEC SV (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC V (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC VX (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC ZX (Diesel)
9.40 10.52 11.01 13.12 13.24 14.57 15.33 12.54 13.44 14.99 15.72
9.94 11.11 12.23 13.47 13.61 14.99 15.76 12.84 13.78 15.30 16.11
You’ll like Rear seat comfort, strong performance, fuel economy. You won’t Tight rear headroom, premium, price. We say Not as revolutionary as previous City’s, but the best all-rounder in the segment. Buy 1.5 V MT 9.44 10.53 11.59 12.74 12.87 14.17 14.89 11.96 12.83 14.23 14.97
9.85 11.01 11.33 13.91 14.08 15.47 16.26 13.03 13.99 15.52 16.33
10.26 11.47 11.81 14.28 14.48 15.92 16.73 13.40 14.38 15.96 16.79
— — — — — — — — — — —
11 11 11 — 11 — 11 14.2 14.2 14.2 14.2
17 17 17 — 17 — 17 19.5 19.5 19.5 19.5
17.4 17.4 17.4 18 17.4 18 17.4 25.1 25.1 25.1 25.1
119 119 119 119 119 119 119 100 100 100 100
10.13 10.13 10.13 11.84 10.13 11.84 10.13 14.75 14.75 14.75 14.75
E F F F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — — p p p — — p p
2 2 2 2 2 2 6 2 2 2 6
— D D D D D D D D D D
— — D D D D D — D D D
— — — — — — — — — — —
N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — p p — — — p p p p p p
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— D D D D — D D D D D D D D
— D D D D — D D D D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
L L L L L L L L L L
P P P P P P P P P P
— — — p p p p p — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— D D D D D D D — D
— — — D D D D D — —
— — — — — — — — — —
L L L L L N N L L N N
SKODA RAPID HHHH You’ll like Strong engines, mature ride, good build quality. You won’t Premium price tag. We say With the face-lift, Skoda has pumped in new life into its aging mid-size sedan. Buy 1.5 D Ambition.
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4413mm Width 1699mm Height 1466mm Ground Clearance 163mm Boot 460 Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1111-1228kg 1.6 MPI M/T Active (Petrol) 1.6 MPI M/T Ambition (Petrol) 1.6 MPI A/T Ambition (Petrol) 1.6 MPI M/T Style (Petrol) 1.6 MPI A/T Style (Petrol) 1.5 TDI M/T Active (Diesel) 1.5 TDI M/T Ambition (Diesel) 1.5 TDI A/T Ambition (Diesel) 1.5 TDI M/T Style (Diesel) 1.5 TDI A/T Style (Diesel) 1.6 MPI M/T Monte Carlo (Petrol) 1.6 MPI A/T Monte Carlo (Petrol) 1.5 TDI M/T Monte Carlo (Diesel) 1.5 TDI A/T Monte Carlo (Diesel)
9.37 10.35 12.21 12.03 13.44 11.00 12.52 13.95 13.89 15.20 12.62 14.03 14.83 16.14
9.55 10.56 12.24 12.06 13.47 11.23 12.49 13.92 14.19 15.50 10.75** 11.97** 12.46** 13.57**
9.23 10.20 11.63 11.46 12.80 10.66 11.65 12.99 12.93 14.15 10.75** 11.97** 12.46** 13.57**
9.64 10.66 12.76 12.58 14.04 11.13 12.80 14.26 14.20 15.53 12.99 14.45 14.95 15.67
10.01 11.07 13.08 12.89 14.40 11.58 13.11 14.63 14.56 15.94 13.45 14.97 15.50 16.88
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
105 105 105 105 105 110 110 110 110 110 105 105 110 110
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
E F F F F E F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
—
—
— P P P P
s
s
s
s
— P
s!
P
—
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
MARUTI CIAZ HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4490mm Width 1730mm Height 1485mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 510 Tank 43 litres Kerb Weight 1010-1105kg Sigma (Petrol) Delta (Petrol) Delta A/T (Petrol) Zeta (Petrol) Zeta A/T (Petrol) Alpha (Petrol) S (Petrol) Alpha A/T (Petrol) Sigma SHVS (Diesel) Delta SHVS (Diesel)
8.77 9.23 10.53 9.96 11.26 10.59 10.65 12.20 9.09 9.55
9.12 9.62 10.93 10.32 11.23 11.05 9.70** 12.48 11.37 12.20
You’ll like Value for money, ample space, ride quality, equipment list. You won’t Not a great drive, underpowered. We say SHVS tech gives marginal improvement in fuel economy. Buy Zeta 9.08 9.54 10.84 10.27 11.58 10.90 9.70** 12.21 9.89 10.38
10.80 9.45 11.22 10.53 11.44 11.15 11.15 13.10 11.32 12.52
9.48 10.00 11.34 10.77 11.81 11.41 9.72** 13.22 11.60 12.67
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
20.7 20.7 19.1 20.7 19.1 20.7 20.7 20.7 28.0 28.0
92.2 92.2 92.2 92.2 92.2 92.2 92.2 92.2 90 90
12.02 12.02 — 12.02 — 12.02 12.02 12.02 15.54 15.54
E F F F F F F F E F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
— — — — — — — — — —
— P P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
— P
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 91
MODEL BY MODEL SEDAN MID-SIZE
Average kpl
— — —
— — —
E/F c/a N O/P p F c/a L F c/a L F c/a L
P P P
— p p
D — — D D — D D —
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
q
D/P D Y 2 2 2
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
90 — 90 15.54 90 15.54
Seats Height Adjust
28.0 28.0 28.0
Airbags
— — —
Leather Seats
11.87** 13.54 14.49
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
14.31 13.19 14.32
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
11.86** 11.17 11.90
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
11.77** 12.73 14.13
AC/climate control
Kolkata
S (Diesel) Zeta SHVS (Diesel) Alpha SHVS (Diesel)
0-100 kph
Mumbai
13.70 10.30 10.99
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Power hp
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
Highway
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
— Yes El — Yes El — Yes El
Yes — Yes El/No — Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes — Yes El/Yes —
P
— — — — — — —
No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
P P
s
s
s
s
NISSAN SUNNY HHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4455mm Width 1695mm Height 1515mm Ground Clearance 161mm Boot 490 Tank 41 litres Kerb Weight 998-1097kg XE (Petrol) XL (Petrol) XL Auto (Petrol) XE (Diesel) XL (Diesel) XV (Diesel) XV Premium Safety (Diesel)
8.02 8.68 10.31 8.71 9.26 10.47 13.13
You’ll like Comfortable and spacious cabin, ride quality. You won’t Feedback from the steering, handling under brisk driving. We say Nicer looking, more premium feeling and just as practical as ever before, the updated Sunny is a far more complete sedan now. Buy XL 8.31 8.98 10.64 9.03 9.60 10.82 13.89
7.82 8.47 10.05 8.36 8.90 10.05 12.09
8.08 8.74 10.39 8.64 9.19 10.39 13.00
8.33 9.03 10.82 8.92 9.51 10.82 13.62
— — — — — — —
11.5 11.5 — 13.6 13.6 13.6 13.6
16.4 16.9 16.4 16.9 — 17.9 18.7 21.6 18.7 21.6 18.7 21.6 18.7 21.6
99 99 101 86 86 86 86
12.58 12.58 — 12.89 12.89 12.89 12.89
E F F E F F F
a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L
O P P O P P P
— — — — — — —
1 1 1 1 1 2 4
— — — D — — D — — — — — D — — D D — D D —
P P P
— — —
2 2 2
D D — D D — D D —
—
—
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In Re Re In Re Re Re
— — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/No In/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — —
— P P
s
s
— P
s
— P
s
RENAULT SCALA HHH You’ll like Comfortable ride, space and practicality. You won’t Low seating, dull cabin, poor resale value. We say Practical but unexciting vehicle. Buy RXZ
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4425mm Width 1695mm Height 1505mm Ground Clearance 161mm Boot 490 Tank 41 litres Kerb Weight 1080kg RxL (Petrol) RxL (Diesel) RxZ (Diesel)
9.01 10.79 10.78
9.91 10.76 11.86
9.71 10.50 10.54
9.35 10.57 11.04
9.16 10.37 10.84
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
99 99 86
— — —
F c/a L F c/a L F c/a L
— Yes In — Yes In — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/No — Yes — Yes El/No — Yes — Yes El/Yes —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — —
VOLKSWAGEN VENTO HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4390mm Width 1699mm Height 1467mm Ground Clearance 163mm Boot 494 litres Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1121-1233kg 1.6 MPI Trendline (Petrol) 1.6 MPI Comfortline (Petrol) 1.2 TSI Comfortline A/T (Petrol) 1.6 MPI Highline (Petrol) 1.2 TSI Highline A/T (Petrol) 1.6 MPI Highline Plus (Petrol) 1.2 TSI Highline Plus A/T (Petrol) 1.5 TDI Trendline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Comfortline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Comfortline A/T (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Highline (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Highline A/T (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Highline Plus (Diesel) 1.5 TDI Highline Plus A/T (Diesel)
9.16 10.22 12.06 11.22 13.11 12.69 14.27 10.87 12.41 13.91 13.54 14.99 14.50 15.93
9.73 10.84 12.68 11.89 13.43 13.20 14.65 11.57 12.87 14.40 14.02 15.50 15.11 16.59
You’ll like Punchy turbo engines, build quality, upmarket cabin. You won’t Jerky automatic gearbox at city speeds, fuel efficiency, dated interior design. We say Versatile and dependable sedan. Buy 1.2 TSI Comfortline 9.00 10.05 11.69 11.54 12.71 13.84 13.80 10.53 11.74 13.16 12.81 14.18 13.82 15.32
9.35 10.44 12.64 11.47 13.74 13.30 13.74 10.95 12.73 14.28 13.89 15.38 14.99 16.48
9.71 10.85 12.95 11.93 14.16 13.49 14.09 11.38 13.05 14.65 14.25 15.79 15.38 16.91
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
9.2 9.2 — 9.2 — 9.2 — — — — — — — —
15.3 15.3 — 15.3 — 15.3 — — — — — — — —
15.04 15.04 16.93 15.04 16.93 15.04 16.93 — — — — — — —
105 105 105 105 105 105 105 110 110 110 110 110 110 110
12.18 12.18 11.24 12.18 11.24 12.18 11.24 11.90 11.90 12.25 11.90 12.25 11.90 12.25
E F F F F F F E F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
O P P P P P P O P P P P P P
— — — p p p p — — — p p p p
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
D D D D D D D D D D D D D D
— — — D D D D — — — D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
P P P P P
— — p 2 — — — 2 p 2
— D — D D
D D — D D
O P P P P P O P P P P P
— — — — p p — — — — p p
— D D D D D — D D D D D
— — D D D D — — D D D D
—
— —
P
s!
P
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In Re Re Re Re Re Re In Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes In/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In In
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — —
No Yes No Yes Yes
El/No El/No El/No El/No El/No
— — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In In In In In In In In In
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/No El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — —
—
P
—
P
s!
P
—
P
s!
P
— —
P
s!
P
P
—
P
s!
P
—
P
s!
P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
FIAT LINEA HHH You’ll like Ride and handling, turbo petrol engine. You won’t Rear seat space, ergonomics. We say More exciting to drive than its rivals. Buy T-jet Emotion
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4596mm Width 1730mm Height 1487/1494mm Ground Clearance 185/190mm Boot 500 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1258-1268kg Active FIRE (Petrol) T-jet Emotion (Petrol) Active Multijet (Diesel) Dynamic Multijet (Diesel) Emotion Multijet (Diesel)
8.06 10.99 9.67 10.42 11.06
8.24 11.46 10.08 10.89 11.58
8.81 11.26 10.24 11.04 11.26
8.17 11.33 9.81 10.60 11.26
8.39 11.74 10.14 10.97 11.59
— — — — —
9.4 — 12.9 12.9 12.9
13.4 14.6 — — 17.5 20.4 17.5 20.4 17.5 20.4
89 125 93 93 93
15.14 10.84 17.81 17.81 17.81
E F E F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L
— P
s
— P P
s
s
HYUNDAI VERNA HHH You’ll like Cabin quality, overall refinement. You won’t Still not a driver’s car, rear seat is too low. We say Well-rounded as before and now a lot better to drive. Buy SX (O)
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4440mm Width 1729mm Height 1475mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 480 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight NA 1.6 E MT (Petrol) 1.6 EX MT (Petrol) 1.6 EX A/T (Petrol) 1.6 SX MT (Petrol) 1.6 SX (O) MT (Petrol) 1.6 SX (O) A/T (Petrol) 1.6 E MT (Diesel) 1.6 EX (Diesel) 1.6 EX AT (Diesel) 1.6 SX MT (Diesel) 1.6 SX+ AT (Diesel) 1.6 SX (O) MT (Diesel)
8.75 9.88 10.79 10.64 11.81 12.07 10.26 11.35 12.68 12.51 13.89 14.78
92 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
9.29 10.52 12.05 11.01 13.06 14.40 10.85 11.79 13.65 13.32 15.10 14.84
7.99** 9.06** 10.22** 9.49** 11.08** 12.23** 9.19** 9.99** 11.39** 11.11** 12.61** 12.39**
9.21 10.42 12.36 10.91 14.77 NA 10.57 11.58 13.76 13.42 15.22 14.96
9.82 11.11 12.95 11.62 14.01 15.45 11.30 12.26 14.45 14.09 15.97 15.68
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
123 123 123 123 123 123 126 126 126 126 126 126
— — — — — — — — — — — —
E F F F F F E F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L N N L L L L N N
2 2 2 2 4 4 2 2 2 2 4 4
— P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
— P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
MODEL BY MODEL SEDAN EXECUTIVE TO LUXURY SEDAN ENTRY
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
SEDAN EXECUTIVE HYUNDAI ELANTRA HHHH You’ll like Ride quality, smooth petrol and refined diesel engine. You won’t Missing equipment on lower variants, low set rear seat. We say It's well equipped and priced competitively too making it an attractive proposition. Buy SX (O)
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4570mm Width 1800mm Height 1465mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot 458 Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight NA Nu 2.0 S (Petrol) Nu 2.0 SX (Petrol) Nu 2.0 SX AT (Petrol) Nu 2.0 SX(O) (Petrol) Nu 2.0 SX(O) AT (Petrol) U2 1.6 S (Diesel) U2 1.6 SX (Diesel) U2 1.6 SX(O) (Diesel) U2 1.6 SX(O) AT (Diesel)
14.35 16.42 17.60 18.36 19.86 16.74 18.49 19.92 21.57
14.96 17.12 18.37 19.15 20.73 17.49 19.32 20.81 22.55
16.91 18.39 19.64 17.04** 18.48** 17.45 18.34 19.87 21.32
15.05 17.26 18.53 19.34 20.94 17.30 19.14 20.64 22.37
15.78 18.08 19.40 20.23 21.91 18.19 20.10 21.66 23.48
— — — — — — — — —
8.1 8.1 8.7 8.1 8.7 14.1 14.1 14.1 11.1
11.8 11.8 12.5 11.8 12.5 17.7 17.7 17.7 15.1
14.59 14.59 14.62 14.59 14.62 22.54 22.54 22.54 18.23
152 152 152 152 152 128 128 128 128
9.32 9.32 10.46 9.32 10.46 10.94 10.94 10.94 11.37
E F F F F E F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L N N N N L N N N
P P P P P P P P P
— — — p p — — p p
2 2 2 2 6 2 2 2 6
D D D D D D D D D
D D D D D D D D D
— — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re El El Re Re El El
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — p p — —
5 5 5 7 3 3
D D D D D D
D D D D D D
— — — — — —
q q q q q q
No No No No No No
In In Re Re In In
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — —
6 6 6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In In In
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — —
— — —
— P P
s!
P
s!
P
— —
s
s
s
s
— P
s!
P
s!
P
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — —
P
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/Yes El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
s
s
TOYOTA COROLLA ALTIS HHHH You’ll like Comfy backseat, better equipped than before. You won’t Lacklustre diesel engine, plastic quality We say Comfortable car that offers good performance, backed by Toyota Buy 1.8 GL
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4620mm Width 1775mm Height 1475mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 470 Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1220-1310kg 1.8 G (Petrol) 1.8 G A/T (Petrol) 1.8 GL (Petrol) 1.8 VL A/T (Petrol) D-4D G (Diesel) D-4D GL (Diesel)
17.35 19.13 19.97 21.71 19.71 21.61
19.07 20.97 21.87 22.89 21.07 23.05
18.20 20.02 20.88 22.65 19.75 21.61
19.94 21.92 22.85 24.78 21.67 23.69
18.97 20.91 21.83 23.72 21.10 23.13
— — — — — —
— — — — 12.1 12.1
— — — — 17.1 17.1
— — — — — —
140 140 140 140 88 88
10.08 11.54 10.08 11.54 14.05 14.05
F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N
P P P P P P
P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
VOLKSWAGEN JETTA HHHH You’ll like Punchy diesel engine, ride quality, solid build. You won’t Dated interiors, engine refinement. We say Smart, understated executive sedan. Buy 2.0 Highline A/T
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4644mm Width 1778mm Height 1453mm Ground Clearance 159mm Boot 510 Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1445-1460kg 1.4 TSI Trendline (Petrol) 1.4 TSI Comfortline (Petrol) 2.0 TDI Trendline (Diesel) 2.0 TDI Comfortline (Diesel) 2.0 TDI Highline (Diesel) 2.0 TDI Highline A/T (Diesel)
16.89 18.65 18.71 20.97 23.22 24.44
17.29 19.11 19.06 21.37 23.89 25.16
16.76 18.52 18.16 20.36 22.56 23.76
18.61 20.50 20.11 22.48 24.84 26.13
18.39 20.46 19.99 22.39 25.02 26.34
— — — — — —
— — 11.7 11.7 11.7 11.8
— — 16.7 16.7 16.7 16.8
14.69 14.69 19.33 19.33 19.33 16.96
122 122 140 140 140 140
10.56 10.56 10.92 10.92 10.92 10.02
E E E E E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N
P P P P P P
s! s!
— P
s
—
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
El/No — El/Yes s El/Yes s El/No — El/Yes s El/Yes s El/Yes s El/Yes s
P
s
s
s
SKODA OCTAVIA HHHH You’ll like Strong engines, comfort, ride and handling, loaded with kit. You won’t Interiors don’t feel very solid, sales and service network. We say Latest Octavia sets a new benchmark in the executive car segment. Buy 1.8 Style Plus A/T
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4670mm Width 1814mm Height 1476mm Ground Clearance 155mm Boot 590/1580 Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight 1260-1395kg 1.4 TSI Ambition M/T (Petrol) 1.8 TSI Style A/T (Petrol) 1.8 TSI Style Plus A/T (Petrol) 2.0 TDI Ambition M/T (Diesel) 2.0 TDI Style M/T (Diesel) 2.0 TDI Style A/T (Diesel) 2.0 TDI Style Plus A/T (Diesel) RS 230
18.15 21.71 24.36 20.19 22.60 24.41 27.23 29.59
18.22 21.88 24.76 20.27 22.68 24.70 27.55 25.48**
17.18 20.65 23.17 18.80 21.05 22.73 25.36 NA
20.58 23.97 26.09 22.98 19.67** 23.75 28.93 30.21
19.48 23.40 26.34 21.30 23.85 25.98 28.83 NA
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— 15.1 15.1 — — — — —
140 180 180 143 143 143 143 230
— — — — — — — —
F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P
— p p — p p p p
4 4 8 4 4 4 8 8
D D/P D/P D D/P D/P D/P D/P
p
8 D/P D —
— Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes —
P
p p
7 D/P D — 9 D/P D —
— Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
D D D D D D D D
— — — — — — — —
!
P
!
P P
!
P
!
P
!
P
!
P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
LUXURY SEDAN ENTRY HONDA ACCORD HYBRID HHHH You’ll like Plush cabin, comfortable ride and efficient hybrid motor. You won’t Expensive to buy, not fun or exciting to drive. We say Chauffeur driven, eco friendly folk will love this one. Buy Hybrid.
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4933mm Width 1849mm Height 1464mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1620kg 2.0 i-VTEC (Hybrid)
42.76
52.92
40.99**
48.87
51.25
—
—
—
23.1
215
—
F c/a N P
s
TOYOTA CAMRY HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4850mm Width 1825mm Height 1480mm Ground Clearance 160mm Boot 484 Tank 65-70 litres Kerb Weight 1490-1635kg 2.5 A/T (Petrol) Hybrid (Petrol)
33.28 43.10
37.02 45.19
You’ll like Low running costs, smooth drive, fuel economy. You won’t Unexciting performance, dull interiors, lifeless steering. We say Relaxing with a capital R. Buy Hybrid 28.19 32.35
37.76 39.90
36.24 47.06
— —
8.2 —
12 —
— 19
181 9.23 160 9.20
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 93
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SEDAN ENTRY TO LUXURY SEDAN COMPACT
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
SKODA SUPERB HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4861mm Width 1864mm Height 1483mm Ground Clearance 149-164mm Boot 625/1760 Tank 66 litres Kerb Weight 1494-1565kg 1.8 TSI Style (Petrol) 1.8 TSI Style A/T (Petrol) 1.8 TSI L&K A/T (Petrol) 2.0 TDI Style A/T (Diesel) 2.0 TDI L&K A/T (Diesel)
28.00 29.84 33.18 33.21 36.63
28.77 30.66 34.10 33.98 37.48
You’ll like Rear legroom, large boot, smooth engines, equipment list. You won’t Skoda’s poor after sales service. We say New model carries forward the Superb legacy with elan. Buy 1.8 Style A/T 26.64 28.40 31.58 30.94 34.13
29.22 31.14 34.63 33.93 37.42
30.77 32.77 36.69 35.67 39.60
— — — — —
8.9 8.5 8.5 10.1 10.1
14.2 12.7 12.7 14.6 14.6
— — — — —
180 180 180 177 177
8.42 8.52 8.52 7.83 7.83
F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N
p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
P P P P P P
p p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8 8
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In In In
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
P P P P P
p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — —
P
P P P P
p p p p
6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
q q q —
No No No No
Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p
6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6 8 7
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q — q —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— — —
No Re No Re No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
LUXURY SEDAN COMPACT JAGUAR XE HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4795mm Width 1850mm Height 1416mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank NA Kerb Weight 1547kg 2.0 Pure (Petrol) 2.0 Prestige (Petrol) 2.0 Portfolio (Petrol) 2.0 Pure (Diesel) 2.0 Prestige (Diesel) 2.0 Portfolio (Diesel)
41.66 46.02 50.60 43.38 47.81 52.52
You’ll like Ride and handling, interior. You won’t Lesser rear legroom than its rivals, boot space. We say A car capable of taking on established players at their own game. Buy 2.0 Portfolio
41.73 46.21 50.92 43.31 47.85 52.66
46.79 52.70 54.34 39.31** 43.19** 47.61**
49.67 54.34 59.64 49.63 54.29 59.59
44.16 48.98 54.04 45.08 49.87 54.96
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
199 — 199 — 240 6.43 180 — 180 — 180 —
F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N
s
s
s
s
s
s
AUDI A3 HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4456mm Width 1796mm Height 1416mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 425 litres Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight 1295-1340kg 35TFSI Premium Plus (Petrol) 35TFSI Technology (Petrol) 35TDI Premium Plus (Diesel) 35TDI Technology (Diesel) 35TFSI Cabriolet (P)
36.36 40.64 38.39 42.38 56.73
38.42 42.89 40.35 44.50 63.33
You’ll like Smooth motor, comfy ride, light steering. You won’t Rear seat space. We say Capable compact luxury sedan that sets the bar high for the segment. Buy 35 TDI Premium Plus 37.31 41.13 36.11 40.30 55.56
34.38 37.09 41.53 44.93 37.90
39.52 44.29 40.89 45.24 61.37
— — — — —
— — — 150 — — — — 150 — 12.3 17.5 20.3 143 8.97 12.3 17.5 20.3 143 8.97 — — — 150 —
F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a a
N N N N N
P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
MERCEDES CLA-CLASS HHH Doors 4 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4630-4691mm Width 1777mm Height 1416-1432mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 470 Tank NA Kerb Weight 1510-1650kg CLA 200 Sport (Petrol) CLA 200 CDI Style (Diesel) CLA 200 CDI Sport (Diesel) CLA 45 AMG (Petrol)
38.84 36.15 41.04 83.03
41.80 39.70 43.71 91.79
39.38 41.27 36.74 81.51
You’ll like Stunning looks, quality interiors. You won’t Understated performance, rear headroom. We say A very competent luxury car, but style is still its strongest point. Buy 200 Sport 40.33 37.63 41.51 90.90
42.61 39.16 43.82 91.02
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
183 136 136 381
— — — —
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
s
s
s
s
AUDI A4 HHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4726mm Width 1842mm Height 1427mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 480 Tank 54 litres Kerb Weight 1450kg 30TFSI Premium Plus (Petrol) 30TFSI Technology (Petrol) 35TDI Premium Plus (Diesel) 35TDI Technology (Diesel)
45.19 48.73 47.55 51.09
47.58 51.28 49.83 53.51
You’ll like Loaded with equipment, comfortable ride, welll built. You won’t Petrol engine lacks punch, floaty diesel ride We say A feature-loaded sedan with excellent refinement. Buy 35TDI Technology 44.80 48.27 46.14 49.53
46.89 50.66 49.61 50.70
49.17 53.12 50.70 NA
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
17.84 17.84 18.25 18.25
150 150 190 190
— — — —
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
P P P P
s
s
s
s
MERCEDES C-CLASS HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4686-4756mm Width 1810-1839mm Height 1426-1442mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 480 Tank 66 litres Kerb Weight 1545-1690kg C200 Avantgarde (Petrol) C220 CDI Style (Diesel) C220 CDI Avantgarde (Diesel) C250d Avantgarde (Diesel) C300 Cabriolet (Petrol) C 43 AMG (Petrol) C 63 S AMG (Petrol)
47.31 46.54 49.72 52.94 69.73 85.78 154.71
51.64 50.02 53.70 57.90 77.15 94.82 168.55
You’ll like Luxurious cabin, exceptional interior quality. You won’t Firm ride at low speeds, noisy engines. We say Feels like a junior S-class. Buy C250 Avantgarde
48.36 49.58 46.05 47.30 50.02 50.75 52.43 54.92 ** 60.40 60.87** 75.30** 75.09** 155.00** 134.09**
51.60 49.23 52.83 57.16 77.66 99.11 169.67
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
14.74 19.27 19.27 — — — —
184 170 170 204 245 367 510
8.11 8.49 8.49 — — — 4.26
F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
VOLVO S60 HHH You’ll like Great on power to price ratio, attractive styling. You won’t Not involving to drive, plain interiors, lacks drama. We say The safest car for the money. Buy D4
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4635mm Width 1899mm Height 1484mm Ground Clearance 136mm Boot 380 Tank 67.5 litres Kerb Weight 1652-1680kg D4 Kinetic (Diesel) D4 Momentum (Diesel) D5 Inscription (Diesel)
38.06 43.34 50.53
94 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
49.01 53.44 55.93
37.33 41.99 46.55
41.18 47.78 52.81
42.65 48.88 54.40
— — —
— — 9.5
— — 13.4
— — —
183 — 183 — 218 8.19
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
s
s
s
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SEDAN COMPACT TO LUXURY SEDAN MID-SIZE
Average kpl
— —
— —
E/F c/a N O/P p F c/a N P F c/a N P
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
— —
Traction control
193 367
Seats Height Adjust
— —
Airbags
— —
Leather Seats
54.93 68.68
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
51.85 53.10**
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
46.26 53.10**
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
57.46 53.10**
AC/climate control
Kolkata
Cross Country Inscription (Diesel) Polestar (Petrol)
Power hp
Mumbai
48.86 62.27
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— —
No Re No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p p p p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 7 7
— — — — — — — q q q — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
BMW 3 SERIES HHHH You’ll like Strong performance, ride, engaging handling. You won’t Low seating position. We say New diesel engine and tweaks to the suspension help bring the 3-series back into the limelight. Buy 320d Luxury Line
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4633-4824mm Width 1811-1877mm Height 1484mm Ground Clearance 157mm Boot 480-500 Tank 57-60 litres Kerb Weight 1420-1630kg 330i Sport Line(Petrol) 330i M Sport Edition (Petrol) 320d Prestige (Diesel) 320d Edition Sport (Diesel) 320d Sport Line (Diesel) 320d Luxury Line (Diesel) 320d M Sport (Diesel) 320d GT Sport Line (Diesel) 320d GT Luxury Line (Diesel) 330i GT Luxury Line (Petrol) M3 Sedan (Petrol) M4 Coupe (Petrol)
49.19 51.98 44.85 45.50 50.83 50.83 54.54 52.35 56.30 55.92 142.20 145.35
49.87 52.73 45.01 47.80 51.07 51.07 54.83 52.61 56.62 56.76 131.85** 134.10**
45.82 48.49 40.58 NA 46.15 46.15 49.60 47.57 51.26 52.26 135.20 138.21
50.20 53.10 44.52 47.30 50.56 51.17 54.31 52.10 56.10 57.19 147.69 150.96
52.44 55.46 46.55 NA 52.82 53.45 56.71 54.60 58.76 59.90 153.60 157.01
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — 21.76 21.76 15.34 — —
252 252 190 190 190 190 190 190 190 252 431 431
— — 7.58 7.58 7.58 7.58 7.58 — — — 4.73 4.73
F F F F F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a a
N N N N N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
— — — — — — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
q Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
q Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
— Yes Re — Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
LUXURY SEDAN MID-SIZE LEXUS ES300H HHH You’ll like Comfortable backseat, silent and efficient hybrid engine. You won’t Bland styling, price tag. We say A posh and premium alternative to the Toyota Camry Hybrid. Buy Hybrid
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4915mm Width 1820mm Height 1450mm Ground Clearance 151mm Boot 425 litres Tank 65 litres Kerb Weight 1705kg ES300h (Hybrid)
55.27**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
160
—
F c/a N P
p 10 D/P D Y
s
VOLVO S90 HHHH You’ll like Ultimate in cabin luxury, creamy diesel engine. You won’t Isn't engaging to drive. We say Possibly one of the best executive luxury sedan available today but is let down by the scanty sales and service network. Buy D4 Inscription.
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4963mm Width 2019mm Height 1433mm Ground Clearance 152mm Boot NA Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1717kg D4 Inscription (Diesel)
65.25
75.65
54.50**
71.58
71.72
—
—
—
—
190
—
F c/a N P
p
7 D/P D Y
p p p p
8 D 8 D 8 D 6 D/P
s
AUDI A6 HHHH You’ll like Ride comfort, equipment list. You won’t Dull to drive, limited engine options. We say Sharper-looking A6 is a little better value now. Buy 35TDI Matrix
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4933-4979mm Width 1874-1936mm Height 1455-1461mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 530/1680 Tank 65-75 litres Kerb Weight 1610-2240kg 35TFSI Premium (Petrol) 35TFSI Matrix (Petrol) 35TDI Matrix (Diesel) RS6 Avant (Petrol)
60.78 60.68 63.11 161.83
61.23 63.57 65.81 179.53
57.49 60.01 61.10 157.63
60.39 60.04 64.96 138.00**
61.76 66.29 67.53 179.24
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
190 — 190 — 191 8.58 560 3.75
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
P P P P
D D D D
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Y Y Y Y
Re Re Re Re
— — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
s
s
s
MERCEDES E-CLASS HHHHH You’ll like Backseat comfort, equipment, robust build. You won’t Expensive to buy. We say The most comfortable iteration of the E-Class till date. Buy E200.
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 5063mm Width 1860mm Height 1494mm Ground Clearance 120-135mm Boot 540 Tank 66 litres Kerb Weight 1920kg E 200 (Petrol) E 220d (Diesel) E 350d (Diesel)
63.91 66.75 81.57
69.56 71.92 86.93
65.06 55.52** 80.33
66.80 67.96 82.49
69.44 70.65 83.75
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
184 194 258
— — —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
s
s
s
BMW 5 SERIES HHHH You’ll like Fun to drive, great engines, spacious cabin, interior quality. You won’t Rear seat a bit upright. We say Very accomplished and capable. Buy 530d M-Sport
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4936mm Width 1868mm Height 1466mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 530 Tank NA Kerb Weight NA 520d Luxury Line (Diesel) 520d M Sport (Diesel) 530d M Sport (Diesel)
65.63 49.90** 75.46
66.11 61.41 75.47
59.92 55.79 68.51
65.57 66.87 74.90
80.01 70.73 NA
— — —
— — —
— — —
22.5 190 22.5 190 18.6 265
7.5 7.5 5.7
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6
— — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
JAGUAR XF HHHH You’ll like Strong performance, opulent cabin. You won’t Rear-seat comfort could be better, some plastic in cabin feel inexpensive. We say New XF looks and feels better than ever. Buy Prestige
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 5065mm Width 2091mm Height 1457mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 505 Tank 66 litres Kerb Weight 1685kg 2.0 Prestige (Petrol) 2.0 Portfolio (Petrol) 2.0 Pure (Diesel) 2.0 Prestige (Diesel) 2.0 Portfolio (Diesel
67.60 73.56 55.07 60.71 69.48
59.36 67.21 54.67 60.45 69.43
NA NA NA NA NA
70.18 76.71 61.50 70.49 77.01
63.21 71.65 57.19 63.28 72.77
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
240 240 180 180 180
— — — — —
F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N
P P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In In
— — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s
s
s
s
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 95
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SEDAN PREMIUM
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
AC/climate control
Electric windows R/F
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
LUXURY SEDAN PREMIUM PORSCHE PANAMERA HHHH You’ll like Supercar-like performance, cabin space You won’t Price, no diesel option available We say Better-looking, more power and more space than before Buy Turbo Executive
Doors 4 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5049-5119mm Width 1937mm Height 1432mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 500 Tank 90 litres Kerb Weight 1195-2100kg Turbo (Petrol) Turbo Executive (Petrol)
NA NA
193.00** 206.00**
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
— —
— —
— —
— —
550 550
— —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re
No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re
No — Yes El/Yes No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
— — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
AUDI A8 HHHH You’ll like Space, comfort, quality interior, technology. You won’t Too old, characterless. We say Quite a step forward for the A8 but can’t match newer rivals. Buy 50 TDI Premium Plus
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5265mm Width 1949mm Height 1471mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 510 Tank 82 litres Kerb Weight 2010-2050kg 50TDI Premium (Diesel) 50TDI Premium Plus (Diesel)
137.46 143.74
146.23 153.10
130.11 136.18
142.61 143.75
145.50 152.40
— —
— —
— —
6.0 6.0
250 6.61 250 6.61
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
MERCEDES CLS-CLASS HHH You’ll like Design, now with a diesel engine. You won’t Rear headroom, no petrol option. We say Luxury sedan with star appeal. Buy 250 CDI
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4937mm Width 1881mm Height 1418mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 530 Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 1850kg CLS 250 CDI (Diesel)
95.35
98.52
87.87**
94.14
98.86
—
—
—
—
207
—
F c/a N P
s
MASERATI GHIBLI HHHH You’ll like Standout appearance, cabin ambience. You won’t Stiff ride, heavier than it should be. We say It still charms, it’s the most rounded Maserati ever created. Buy Diesel
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4971mm Width 1945mm Height 1461mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 500 Tank 70 litres Kerb Weight 1835kg Ghibli Diesel (Diesel)
110.00**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
275
—
F c/a N P
s
MASERATI QUATTROPORTE HHHH You’ll like Plenty of rear room, styling. You won’t Lack of strong service network, lacks certain finesse. We say The GTS could sway you into the showroom. Buy GTS
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5262mm Width 1948mm Height 1481mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 535 Tank 70-80 litres Kerb Weight 1885-1900kg Quattroporte Diesel (Diesel) Quattroporte GTS (Petrol)
150.00** 220.00**
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
— —
— —
— —
— —
275 530
— —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
MERCEDES S-CLASS HHHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 5027-5246mm Width 1899mm Height 1411-1496mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 400-530 Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 2113-2132kg S 350 (Diesel) S 400 (Petrol) Maybach S 500 (Petrol) Maybach S 600 (Petrol) S 500 Coupe (Petrol) S 500 Cabriolet (Petrol) S 63 AMG Coupe (Petrol)
136.18 146.01 204.25 303.88 232.84 257.41 309.31
You’ll like Supple ride, well-insulated and luxurious cabin, refined engine. You won’t Not exciting to drive. We say Expensive, but then again, it’s the best S-class ever built. Buy S350 145.95 156.92 219.67 340.02 263.76 271.02 336.55
139.53 152.55 213.16 179.90** 234.93 208.00** 299.72
142.72 155.90 218.64 315.88 252.32 208.00** 300.38
145.58 159.28 228.10 347.94 264.96 263.96 319.25
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
258 333 459 530 455 442 585
— — — — — — —
P P P P P P P
p p p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8 8 8
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— Yes El — Yes El — Yes El
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8 8
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
— — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
JAGUAR XJ HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5255mm Width 2105mm Height 1460mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank NA Kerb Weight 1775kg 2.0 Portfolio (Petrol) 3.0 Premium Luxury (Diesel) 3.0 Portfolio (Diesel)
115.14 116.58 125.90
You’ll like Still looks good, performance, price. You won’t Lacks refinement of rivals, showing its age. We say Still not best in class but one we’d highly recommend nonetheless. Buy 3.0 Portfolio 115.36 113.96 122.68
101.40** 100.20** 107.82**
122.95 123.87 133.39
123.45 121.95 131.33
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
240 300 300
— — —
s
s
s
BMW 7 SERIES HHHH You’ll like Drives like a sports saloon, packed with tech, luxurious and comfortable. You won’t Refinement. We say Now feels special enough to justify its positioning. It’s pricey though. Buy 730Ld M Sport
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 5212-5328mm Width 2134-2169mm Height 1479mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank NA Kerb Weight 1990kg 730Ld Pure Design Ex. (Diesel) 730Ld M Sport (Diesel) 730Ld Pure Design Ex. (CBU) (D) 740Li Pure Design Ex (Petrol) 750Li Pure Design Ex. (CBU) (Petrol) 750Li M Sport (CBU) (Petrol)
136.85 144.81 147.59 145.86 182.34 189.79
96 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
140.25 147.25 149.69 148.67 184.85 191.57
125.14 132.51 157.49 138.19 173.10 180.24
136.78 150.94 171.88 150.94 188.83 196.57
142.26 150.57 178.80 157.00 196.44 204.51
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
265 265 265 326 450 450
— — — — — —
F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N
P P P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s
s
s
s
s
s
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SEDAN PREMIUM TO LUXURY TOURING
Average kpl
— —
— —
E/F c/a N O/P p F c/a N P F c/a N P
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
— —
Traction control
610 610
Seats Height Adjust
— —
Airbags
— —
Leather Seats
289.31 NA
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
278.02 278.02
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
255.30 255.30
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
262.28 262.28
AC/climate control
Kolkata
M760Li xDrive (Petrol) M760Li xDrive V12 Excellence (Petrol)
Power hp
Mumbai
267.70 267.70
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
—
No El
No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p p p p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
— — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s
s
s
BENTLEY FLYING SPUR HHH You’ll like Driving pleasure, build quality, performance. You won’t Some cheap bits in the cabin, price. We say Supremely powerful and luxurious but at a very hefty price. Buy V8
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5295mm Width 1976mm Height 1488mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 100 litres Kerb Weight 2475kg Flying Spur V8 (Petrol) Flying Spur W12 (Petrol)
285.00** 330.00**
398.24 393.49
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
— —
— —
— —
— —
507 625
— —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
BENTLEY MULSANNE HHHH You’ll like Road manners, performance. You won’t Price. We say Mulsanne has a formal yet sporty air about it. Buy Mulsanne
Doors 4 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5575mm Width 1926mm Height 1521mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 90 litres Kerb Weight NA Mulsanne (Petrol) Mulsanne Speed (Petrol)
553.53** 553.53** NA 690.00**
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
— —
— —
— —
— —
512 537
5.3 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
ROLLS-ROYCE GHOST HHHH You’ll like Comfortable ride, waftability like no other. You won’t Exorbitant price. We say The baby of the family, but every bit a Rolls-Royce. Buy Ghost SWB
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 5399mm Width 1978mm Height 1550mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 80-100 litres Kerb Weight 2940kg Ghost SWB (Petrol) Ghost EWB (Petrol)
430.00** 450.00** 490.00** 493.00**
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
— —
— —
— —
— —
570 4.7 570 5.0
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
ASTON MARTIN RAPIDE S HHHH You’ll like Eccentric charm, delectable performance and refinement blend. You won’t Second-row practicality. We say Brilliantly accomplished four-door GT. Buy Rapide S
Doors 4 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5020mm Width 1929mm Height 1360mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 90.5 litres Kerb Weight 1990kg Rapide S (Petrol)
350.00** 435.00**
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
552
—
F c/a N P
s
LUXURY TOURING ROLLS-ROYCE DAWN HHHH You’ll like Power, grace. You won’t Price. We say A car to have when the sky is the limit, literally. Buy Dawn
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 5282mm Width 1947mm Height 1502mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank NA Kerb Weight 2560kg Dawn (Petrol)
625.00** 625.00**
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
632
—
F
/a N P
s
MASERATI GRANTURISMO HHHH You’ll like Interior space, agile handling. You won’t Seating position, underwhelming brakes. We say For the first time in a long time, you no longer need to make excuses to buy and run a Maserati. Buy GranTurismo
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4881mm Width 2051mm Height 1353mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 173 Tank 75 litres Kerb Weight 1955kg GranTurismo (Petrol)
180.00**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
411
—
F
a N P
s
BENTLEY CONTINENTAL HHHH Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4806mm Width 1943mm Height 1404mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 90 litres Kerb Weight 2320kg GT (Petrol) GT V8 (Petrol) GT Speed (Petrol) GT V8 S (Petrol) GTC (Petrol) GTC V8 (Petrol) GTC Speed (Petrol) GTC V8 S (Petrol)
309.99** 289.88** 346.39** 308.62** 339.67** 317.54** 379.71** 338.16**
You’ll like Performance, fantastic seats. You won’t Few cheap bits in the cabin, poor ride. We say Quite the honest brute. Buy GT V8
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
575 507 625 528 575 507 625 528
— — — — — — — —
F F F F F F F F
a a a a a a a a
N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
— — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
ROLLS-ROYCE WRAITH HHHH You’ll like Interiors, visibility. You won’t Slight body movement over uneven patches. We say The new Rolls-Royce Wraith is exactly what a Rolls coupe should be - smooth, swift and refined. Buy Wraith
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5269mm Width 1947mm Height 1507mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 470 Tank 83 litres Kerb Weight 2435kg Wraith (Petrol)
460.00** 470.00**
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
632
—
F c/a N P
— Yes Re
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 97
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY TOURING TO PERFORMANCE CARS
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
ASTON MARTIN VANQUISH HHHH Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4380mm Width 1865mm Height 1241mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 1680kg Vanquish (Petrol)
NA
You’ll like Feels special, still easy to drive. You won’t Expensive. We say The Vanquish is a match for some much more track-focused cars. Buy Vanquish
550.00**
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
577
—
F
a N P
—
No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
—
No El
No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
6 D/P D Y
—
No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
6 D/P D Y
—
No Re
—
— Yes El/Yes
s!
P
6 D/P D Y
—
No Re
—
— Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
—
No Re
—
— Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p p p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6 6 6
— — — — — — —
No No No No No No No
— — — — — — —
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
s
MASERATI GRANCABRIO HHHH Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4881mm Width 1915mm Height 1380mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 173 Tank 75 litres Kerb Weight 2350kg GranCabrio (Petrol)
You’ll like Elegant styling, useable rear seats, charismatic V8. You won’t Compromised dynamics, small boot. We say The GranCabrio is elegant, exciting if dynamically flawed. Buy GranCabrio
200.00**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
439
—
F
a N P
p
6 D/P D Y
s
BMW 6 SERIES GRAN COUPE HHH You’ll like Head-turning styling, powerful engines, great touring abilities. You won’t Quite heavy, so not particularly agile. We say 5 series too common and a Bentley too expensive? This could be for you. Buy Eminence
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4894-5011mm Width 1894-1899mm Height 1369-1393mm Ground Clearance 123mm Boot 450 Tank 70 litres Kerb Weight 1845-2015kg 640d Eminence (Diesel) 640d Pure Design Exp (Diesel) M6 (Petrol)
140.41 152.12 208.85
144.90 121.90** 221.54
128.92 139.74 198.40
140.89 152.62 216.27
146.86 155.75 224.99
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
313 6.07 313 6.07 560 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
s
s
s
PERFORMANCE CARS MERCEDES SLC-CLASS HHHH You’ll like Effortless performance, pricing. You won’t Unintuitive infotainment system, lacks AMG growl. We say Offers similar performance to the car it replaces at a much cheaper price. Buy 43 AMG
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4142mm Width 1817mm Height 1304mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 335 Tank 70 litres Kerb Weight 1615kg SLC 43 AMG (Petrol)
90.67
100.19
79.42**
79.42**
79.42**
—
—
—
—
367
—
F
a N P
p
s
FORD MUSTANG HHHH You’ll like V8 engine, equipment. You won’t Few cheap plastics, not enough of a growl from the engine. We say The iconic American muscle car is finally here and will appeal to your wild side. Buy Mustang
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4784mm Width 2080mm Height 1391mm Ground Clearance 137mm Boot 383 Tank 60.9 litres Kerb Weight 1770kg Mustang GT Fastback (Petrol)
77.33
90.64
78.13
81.50
88.04
—
—
—
—
401
—
F
/a N P
p
s
PORSCHE 718 BOXSTER HHHH You’ll like Enjoyable to drive. You won’t New 4-cyl motors lack emotion. We say A fun driving experience, but the four-cylinder engines will take some getting used to. Buy Boxster S
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Rear/Rear Length 4379mm Width 1801mm Height 1280-1281mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 150 Tank 54-64 litres Kerb Weight 1365-1385 kg Boxster (Petrol)
85.53**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
300
—
F
/a N P
p
s
PORSCHE 718 CAYMAN HHHH You’ll like Handling, grip, performance. You won’t Four cylinder engines don’t sound special enough. We say One of the best handling sports cars around. Buy Cayman S
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Rear/Rear Length 4379mm Width 1801mm Height 1295mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 150 Tank 54-64 litres Kerb Weight 1365-1385 kg Cayman (Petrol)
81.63**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
300
—
F
/a N P
s
JAGUAR F-TYPE HHHHH You’ll like Beautifully crafted, pliant ride, spacious cabin. You won’t Expensive. We say A sportscar that has the right blend of attributes for Indian conditions. Buy S Coupe
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4470mm Width 1923mm Height 1308-1319mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 72 litres Kerb Weight 1614-1665kg Coupe (Petrol) S Coupe (Petrol) R Coupe (Petrol) V6 S Convertible (Petrol) V8 S Convertible (Petrol) V8 AWD Coupe SVR (Petrol) V8 AWD Convertible SVR (Petrol)
146.44 168.61 238.32 184.76 197.29** 257.52** 272.09**
163.21 223.97 244.05 202.26 223.97 NA NA
140.55 155.02 210.11 171.36 201.54 NA NA
148.44 148.44 231.00 181.10 212.86 NA NA
157.67 182.15 263.06 200.01 259.21 NA NA
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
340 379 550 379 495 575 575
— — — — — — —
F F F F F F F
a a a a a a a
N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
AUDI RS7 HHHH You’ll like - Looks, performance, tech-laden interiors. You won’t Steering feel, lackluster drive. We say Glamorous alternative to a German sports sedan. Buy RS7
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5012mm Width 1911mm Height 1419mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 535 Tank 75 litres Kerb Weight 1920 kg RS-7 Sportback (Petrol)
170.78
98 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
186.16
171.19
NA
202.08
—
—
—
—
560 3.93
F c/a N P
— Yes Re
s
MODEL BY MODEL PERFORMANCE CARS TO SUPERCARS
Average kpl
—
—
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
—
Airbags
605
Leather Seats
—
Central locking/ Remote locking
—
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
NA
Electric windows R/F
Bengaluru
NA
AC/climate control
Chennai
NA
Delhi
RS 7 Sportback Performance (Petrol) 160.00**
Power hp
Kolkata
NA
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Mumbai
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
— Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
—
No Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
4 D/P D Y
—
No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— —
No Re No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
F
/a N P
p
6 D/P D Y
— Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
a a a a a a a a
p p p p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
— — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
—
No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
F c/a N P
s
s
AUDI S5 HHH You’ll like Smooth, punch V6, ride quality. You won’t Looks too similar to an A4, numb steering. We say Great mix of comfort, performance, practicality, style at a good price, but it’s a bit soulless. Buy S5 Sportback
Doors 4 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4718mm Width 1854mm Height 1382mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 480 Tank 61 litres Kerb Weight 1820kg S5 Sportback (Petrol)
77.22
84.37
74.53
71.89
83.53
—
—
—
—
333
—
F
a N P
s
AUDI TT HHHH You’ll like User-friendly, supple ride, cabin quality. You won’t Steering feels numb, significantly pricier. We say Nicer to drive, performance is usable in our conditions. Buy TT
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4177mm Width 1832mm Height 1353mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1410kg TT (Petrol)
73.54
81.69
72.00
NA
80.84
—
—
—
—
230 5.81
F
a N P
s
BMW Z4 HHH You’ll like Blistering performance, hard-top practicality. You won’t Price, cabin is small. We say Open-top thrills. Buy sDrive35i Design Pure
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4239mm Width 1790mm Height 1291mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1525kg sDrive35i Prestige (Petrol) sDrive35i Design Pure (Petrol)
92.59 93.75
80.90** 82.00**
87.22 88.83
96.17 97.38
99.95 101.21
— —
— —
— —
— —
306 6.18 306 6.18
s
s
SUPERCARS NISSAN GT-R HHHH Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4710mm Width 1895mm Height 1370mm Ground Clearance 105mm Boot 315 Tank 74 litres Kerb Weight 1752kg GT-R (Petrol)
199.00**
You’ll like Performance, handling. You won’t Interior feels a bit cheap. We say Earth-shattering performance, now in a slightly better package. Buy GT-R. NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
570
—
s
PORSCHE 911 HHHHH You’ll like Dynamics, ride comfort, usability. You won’t Expensive. We say A sports car you can use everyday. Buy Carrera S
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Rear/Rear Length 4499-4501mm Width 1808-1880mm Height 1289-1297mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 115-145 Tank 64-68 litres Kerb Weight 1450-1670kg Carrera (Petrol) Carrera S (Petrol) Carrera Cabriolet (Petrol) Carrera S Cabriolet (Petrol) 911 Turbo (Petrol) 911 Turbo S (Petrol) 911 Turbo Cabriolet (Petrol) 911 Turbo S Cabriolet (Petrol)
142.33** 139.71** 163.49** 160.48** 155.75** 152.88** 176.39** 173.14** 225.92** 221.76** 266.17** 261.27** 239.34** 234.93** 281.64** 276.46**
146.23** 167.96** 160.01** 181.21** 232.10** 273.45** 245.88** 289.35**
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
144.86** 166.39** 158.52** 179.52** 229.94** 270.90** 243.59** 286.65**
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
370 420 370 420 540 580 540 580
— — — — — — — —
F F F F F F F F
N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D D
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
— — — — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
AUDI R8 HHHHH You’ll like Mind-blowing performance, everyday usability. You won’t Stiff ride, numb steering. We say A no-nonsense supercar that is quite usable. Buy V10 Plus Coupe
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4426mm Width 1940mm Height 1240mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 73 litres Kerb Weight 1630kg R8 V10 Plus Coupe (Petrol)
292.49
321.43
285.95
NA
321.93
—
—
—
—
610 3.50
F
a N P
s
ASTON MARTIN VANTAGE HHHH You’ll like Characterful engine, handling, interior quality. You won’t Patchy ride, numb steering. We say The Vantage really scores with its look and classy aura. Buy V8 Roadster
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4380mm Width 1865mm Height 1255mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 1630kg Vantage V8 (Petrol) Vantage V8 S (Petrol) Vantage V12 S Coupe (Petrol)
NA NA NA
280.00** 320.00** 385.00**
NA NA NA
NA NA NA
NA NA NA
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
426 436 573
— — —
F F F
a N P a N P a N P
p p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— — —
No Re No Re No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
a N P
p
8 D/P D Y
—
No Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
6 D/P D Y
—
No In
No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s
s
s
ASTON MARTIN DB11 HHHH You’ll like Handling manners. You won’t Cramped rear seating. We say If you desire a different supercar. Buy DB11.
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4739mm Width 1940mm Height 1279mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 78 litres Kerb Weight 1770kg DB11 (Petrol)
427.00**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
608
—
F
s
LAMBORGHINI AVENTADOR S HHHHH You’ll like Massive grunt, visual drama. You won’t Jerky gearbox, unforgiving ride. We say The most extreme car you can buy in India right now. Buy S Coupe
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Mid/Four Length 4797mm Width 2030mm Height 1136mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 90 litres Kerb Weight 1575kg S Coupe (Petrol)
501.00**
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
740
—
F
a N P
p
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 99
MODEL BY MODEL SUPERCARS TO SUV SUB-4-METRE
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
FERRARI 488 GTB HHHHH Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Mid/Four Length 4568mm Width 1952mm Height 1213mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 230 Tank 78 litres Kerb Weight 1475kg 488 GTB (Petrol)
You’ll like Extremely communicative steering. You won’t Just a wee bit less exciting than the earlier one. We say The most docile handling mid-engined cars driven. Buy 488 GTB
388.00** 405.00**
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
669
—
F
a N P
p
6 D/P D Y
—
No In
No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
—
No In
No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
—
No In
No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
— —
No In No In
No — Yes El/Yes No — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6
— — — — —
No No No No No
In In In In In
No No No No No
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
p p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
— Yes Re — Yes Re — Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p
6 D/P D Y
—
No Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
— — — —
2 2 2 2
D — — D D — D — — D D —
No No No No
Ex Ex Ex Ex
Yes — Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes — Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes —
— — — —
— — — —
— — 2 2
— D D D
No No q No q No
Ex Ex Re Re
No — No In/No — No — Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No —
— — — —
s
FERRARI CALIFORNIA T HHHH You’ll like Makes for a fine grand tourer. You won’t Fairly quiet engine, noticeable lag. We say Ultimately the California T can hold its own against anything that’s meant to do a similar job. Buy California T
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4569mm Width 1910mm Height 1320mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 78 litres Kerb Weight 1729kg California T (Petrol)
NA
330.00**
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
560
—
F
a N P
s
FERRARI F12 BERLINETTA HHHHH You’ll like Titanic engine and performance. You won’t Overly sharp steering. We say Thrilling in every way that a front engined V12 Ferrari should be. Buy F12 berlinetta
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4618mm Width 1942mm Height 1273mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 92 litres Kerb Weight 1630kg F12 Berlinetta (Petrol)
NA
472.00**
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
741
—
F
a N P
s
FERRARI GTC4LUSSO HHH You’ll like Clever all-wheel drive system, boot space. You won’t Different Ferrari vibe, gearbox hesitance at low speed. We say This Ferrari could be a compelling purchase of a lifetime. Buy GTC4lLusso
Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4907mm Width 1953mm Height 1379mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 450 Tank 91 litres Kerb Weight 1880kg GTC4Lusso V12 (Petrol) GTC4Lusso T V8 (Petrol)
520.00** 420.00**
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
— —
— —
— —
— —
680 610
— —
F F
a N P a N P
s
s
LAMBORGHINI HURACAN HHHH You’ll like Monumental performance, surprisingly useable. You won’t Handling could be better. We say Thoroughly modern supercar that’s brutally quick. Buy AWD
Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Mid/Four Length 4459mm Width 2236mm Height 1165mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 1389kg Huracan AWD Coupe (Petrol) Huracan AWD Spyder (Petrol) Huracan RWD Coupe (Petrol) Huracan RWD Spyder (Petrol) Huracan AWD Performante (Petrol)
343.00** NA 389.00** NA ** 299.00 299.00** ** 345.00 NA 397.00** NA
NA NA NA NA NA
NA NA NA NA NA
NA NA NA NA NA
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
610 3.2** 610 — 581 — 581 — 640 —
F F F F F
a a a a a
N N N N N
P P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y
— — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s! s! s! s!
— — — — —
MERCEDES AMG GT HHHH Doors 2 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4546mm Width 1939mm Height 1288mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 245/350 Tank 75 litres Kerb Weight 1645kg GT S (Petrol) GT R (Petrol) Roadster (Petrol)
You’ll like Strong, wide powerband, styling, engine note. You won’t Firm ride, cabin ergonomics. We say A great mix of looks, thrills and serious capabilities. Buy GT S
281.81 320.00 208.54** 208.54** 263.52 223.00** 223.00** 223.00** 267.85 223.00** 219.00** 219.00** 219.00** 263.05 273.96
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
510 3.82 585 — 469 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
s
BMW i8 HHHH Doors 2 Seats 2 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4689mm Width 1942mm Height 1298mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 42 litres Kerb Weight 1485kg i8 (Hybrid)
308.42
263.80
You’ll like Style, near-silent drive, comfortable. You won’t Doesn’t respond well to being driven hard. We say The BMW i8 doesn’t quite feel as exciting as it does fast. Buy i8 295.66
322.31
333.99
—
—
—
47.45 362
—
F
a N P
s
SUV SUB-4-METRE HONDA WR-V HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3999mm Width 1734mm Height 1601mm Ground Clearance 188 Boot 363 Tank 40 Kerb Weight 1087-1204kg S (Petrol) VX (Petrol) S (Diesel) VX (Diesel)
8.53 9.87 9.84 11.17
You’ll like Spacious interior, large boot, equipment You won’t Petrol lacks punch, expensive to buy We say Practical car with great space, large boot and higher ground clearance but comes at a premium price Buy 1.5D VX. 8.90 10.30 10.29 11.67
8.55 9.88 9.70 11.11
8.84 10.21 10.02 11.35
9.21 10.64 10.45 11.84
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— 90 — 90 25.5 100 25.5 100
— — — —
E F E F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
P P P P
FIAT URBAN CROSS HHH You’ll like Ground clearance, good ride quality. You won’t Limited dealer support. We say A more practical alternative to the Avventura. Buy 1.4 T-Jet Abarth Emotion.
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3989mm Width 1706mm Height 1542mm Ground Clearance 151-156mm Boot NA Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1210-1215kg 1.3 Multijet Active (Diesel) 1.3 Multijet Dynamic (Diesel) 1.3 Multijet Emotion (Diesel) 1.4 T-Jet Abarth Emotion (Petrol)
7.81 8.50 9.29 10.84
100 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
8.17 8.89 9.73 11.33
8.23 8.92 8.53** 11.14
7.92 8.62 9.42 11.18
8.04 8.77 9.62 11.44
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
93 93 93 142
— — — —
E a L E c/a L F c/a L F c/a L
O O P P
D D D D
— — — —
MODEL BY MODEL SUV SUB-4-METRE
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
MARUTI VITARA BREZZA HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1790mm Height 1640mm Ground Clearance 198mm Boot 328 Tank 48 litres Kerb Weight 1170-1195kg DDiS 200 LDi (Diesel) DDiS 200 LDi (O) (Diesel) DDiS 200 VDi (Diesel) DDiS 200 VDi (O) (Diesel) DDiS 200 ZDi (Diesel) DDiS 200 ZDi (O) (Diesel)
8.38 8.53 8.98 9.13 10.03 11.16
8.56 8.71 9.33 9.48 10.23 11.37
You’ll like Spacious cabin, stable ride, value for money. You won’t Dull interiors, underpowered engine. We say Not revolutionary in any way but ticks the boxes that matter. Buy VDi (O) 8.40 8.55 9.13 9.28 10.00 11.11
8.58 8.73 9.35 9.49 10.23 11.47
8.74 8.89 9.57 9.72 10.52 11.68
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
24.3 24.3 24.3 24.3 24.3 24.3
90 90 90 90 90 90
12.96 12.96 12.96 12.96 12.96 12.96
E E E E F F
a a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L
O O P P P P
— — — — — —
1 2 1 2 2 2
— — — — — — — — — — — — D D — D D —
No No No No q No q No
Ex Ex El El El El
No No No No Yes Yes
O O P P P P
— — — — — 2 — 2 p 2 p 2
— — — — — — — — — — — — D D — D D —
— —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— 2 — 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— — — — — D D D D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— 2 — 2 — 2 2 — 2 — 2 — 2 2
— — — — — — — — — — — — D — — D — — D D — — — — — — — — — — — — — D — — D — — D D —
— — — —
No Yes No Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/No El/No El/No El/No El/Yes
— — — — — —
— —
q q q q q q
No No No No No No
Ex Ex El El El El
No — No In/No — No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No —
— —
— — — — —
No No No No No No No No No No No No No
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No — No In/No — No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes In/No — Yes Yes In/No — Yes Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — —
— —
— — — —
— —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
El El El El El El El El El El El El El El
No No No No Yes Yes Yes No No No No Yes Yes Yes
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
No No No No No
El El El El El
No — No El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No s
— — —
P P P P
s
s
s
s
MAHINDRA NUVOSPORT HH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3985mm Width 1850mm Height 1870mm Ground Clearance 176mm Boot 412-850 Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1670-1698kg N4 (Diesel) N4+ (Diesel) N6 (Diesel) N6 A/T (Diesel) N8 (Diesel) N8 A/T (Diesel)
8.97 9.41 10.20 10.95 11.09 12.26
9.18 9.58 10.43 11.20 11.35 12.19
You’ll like Low-end torque, practicality, tough build. You won’t Interior design, bouncy ride. We say Lacks sophistication of rivals and seems unnecessary after TUV300. Buy N6 9.00 9.39 10.16 10.86 11.01 11.79
9.03 9.44 10.25 10.98 11.14 12.45
9.25 9.67 10.51 11.28 11.45 12.62
— — — — — —
11 15 11 15 11 15 10.7 13.6 11 15 10.7 13.6
— — — — — —
101 101 101 101 101 101
17.22 17.22 17.22 21.09 17.22 21.09
E E E E E E
— — c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L
— — — — P P
s
s
MAHINDRA TUV300 HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1835mm Height 1839mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 384 Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1626-1654kg T4 (Diesel) T4+ (Diesel) T6 (Diesel) T6+ (Diesel) T6+ A/T (Diesel) T8 (Diesel) T8 A/T (Diesel) T8 mHawk 100 (Diesel) T8 A/T mHawk 100 (Diesel) T10 (Diesel) T10 A/T (Diesel) T10 Dual-Tone (Diesel) T10 A/T Dual-Tone (Diesel)
8.97 9.38 9.72 10.02 10.85 10.71 11.54 10.80 11.59 11.31 12.66 11.48 12.83
You’ll like Space, practicality, tough build. You won’t Bouncy ride, AMT auto far from sorted. We say Tough, spacious, practical but lacks sophistication. Buy T8
9.27 9.69 10.05 10.36 11.22 11.19 12.05 12.05 NA 11.72 12.81 11.90 12.99
8.69 9.08 9.42 9.70 10.49 10.30 11.27 10.46 11.35 9.92 10.67 10.07 10.82
8.84 9.25 9.61 9.90 10.65 10.80 12.26 10.70 11.54 9.78 10.46 9.93 10.61
9.09 9.51 9.89 10.19 11.11 10.98 11.85 11.03 12.24 9.74 10.49 9.89 10.64
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 — 11.4 — — — — — — —
15.5 15.5 15.5 15.5 — 15.5 — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
85 85 85 85 82 85 82 100 100 100 100 100 100
19.52 19.52 19.52 19.52 22.63 19.52 22.63 — — — — — —
E E E E E E E E E E E E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L L L
O O P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — D D D D D D D D
MAHINDRA KUV100 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5/6 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3675mm Width 1715mm Height 1635-1655mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 243-473 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 1095-1140kg 1.2 mFALCON G80 K2 (Petrol) 1.2 mFALCON G80 K2+ (Petrol) 1.2 mFALCON G80 K4 (Petrol) 1.2 mFALCON G80 K4+ (Petrol) 1.2 mFALCON G80 K6 (Petrol) 1.2 mFALCON G80 K6+ (Petrol) 1.2 mFALCON G80 K8 (Petrol) 1.2 mFALCON D75 K2 (Diesel) 1.2 mFALCON D75 K2+ (Diesel) 1.2 mFALCON D75 K4 (Diesel) 1.2 mFALCON D75 K4+ (Diesel) 1.2 mFALCON D75 K6 (Diesel) 1.2 mFALCON D75 K6+ (Diesel) 1.2 mFALCON D75 K8 (Diesel)
5.24 5.67 5.80 6.04 6.44 6.68 7.23 6.45 6.69 6.82 7.30 7.78 8.04 8.41
5.72 6.07 6.13 6.39 6.87 7.13 7.48 6.89 7.16 7.31 7.57 8.10 8.36 8.59
You’ll like Value, clever bits in the cabin. You won’t Oddball proportions, unexciting engines. We say A hatchback that’s different but falls short of class-best. Buy K6 5.45 5.87 6.05 6.29 6.77 6.94 7.32 6.60 6.84 7.05 7.30 7.75 8.03 8.38
5.40 5.84 5.96 6.21 6.69 6.94 7.35 6.57 6.83 6.98 7.24 7.74 8.00 8.42
5.38 5.89 6.09 6.35 6.83 7.12 7.49 6.66 6.92 7.15 7.42 7.95 8.22 8.61
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
82 82 82 82 82 82 82 77 77 77 77 77 77 77
15.13 15.13 15.13 15.13 15.13 15.13 15.13 14.85 14.85 14.85 14.85 14.85 14.85 14.85
E E E E E E E E E E E E E E
— — c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a — — c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L L L L
— — O O P P P — — O O P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — —
— — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No In/No In/No In/No El/No El/No El/No In/No In/No In/No In/No El/No El/No El/No
FORD ECOSPORT HHHH You’ll like Competent engines, ride and handling, well-equipped. You won’t Cramped cabin, inconsistent plastic quality. We say The only SUV in its segment offered with a petrol engine and DCT gearbox. Buy 1.5 Trend+
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3999mm Width 1765mm Height 1708mm Ground Clearance 200mm Boot 362 Tank 52 litres Kerb Weight 1259-1290kg 1.5 Ambiente (Petrol) 1.5 Trend (Petrol) 1.0 Trend+ Ecoboost (Petrol) 1.5 Titanium (Petrol) 1.5 Titanium A/T (Petrol)
8.13 8.94 9.72 10.19 11.16
8.45 9.30 10.12 10.61 11.63
8.17 8.98 9.77 10.21 11.18
8.33 9.17 9.97 10.45 11.45
8.75 9.62 10.47 10.97 12.02
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
15.8 15.8 15.8 15.8 15.6
112 112 125 112 112
14.01 14.01 12.54 14.01 14.01
E E F F F
a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N
P P P P P
— — — — —
— — 2 2 6
— — — — D — — — D — — — D D — D D Y
q q q q
!
P P
s
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 101
MODEL BY MODEL SUV SUB-4-METRE TO SUV MID-SIZE
Average kpl
11.8 11.8 13.3 13.3 13.3 13.3 13.3 13.3
17 17 18.6 18.6 18.6 18.6 18.6 18.6
E/F c/a N O/P p P P P P P P P P
p 6 p 6 — — — — — 2 — 2 p 6 p 6
D D — D D D D D
E a L E c/a L F c/a L F c/a L
O P P P
— — — —
— — 2 2
— — — D — — D D — D D —
O P O P
— — — —
— — — —
— — — — D — — — — — D —
c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
D D — — — D D D
— — — — — — — —
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
q
D/P D Y
N N N N N N N N
F F E E F F F F
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
12.54 12.54 13.67 13.67 13.67 13.67 13.67 13.67
Traction control
125 125 100 100 100 100 100 100
Seats Height Adjust
18.9 18.9 22.7 22.7 22.7 22.7 22.7 22.7
Airbags
— — — — — — — —
Leather Seats
12.04 13.15 9.62 10.45 10.92 11.82 12.94 13.55
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
11.46 12.71 9.17 9.95 10.40 11.26 12.52 13.10
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
11.26 12.00 8.97 9.73 10.17 11.04 11.77 12.37
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
11.64 12.83 9.46 10.28 10.74 11.63 12.50 13.46
AC/climate control
Kolkata
1.0 Titanium+ Ecoboost (Petrol) 1.0 Platinum Edition (Petrol) 1.5 Ambiente (Diesel) 1.5 Trend (Diesel) 1.5 Trend+ (Diesel) 1.5 Titanium (Diesel) 1.5 Titanium+ (Diesel) 1.5 Platinum Edition (Diesel)
0-100 kph
Mumbai
11.17 12.41 9.08 9.86 10.30 11.14 11.48 12.82
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Power hp
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
Highway
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
q No El q No El No El q No El q No El q No El q No El q No El
Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — No — No El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No —
P
—
No No q Yes q Yes
In In In El
No — No In/No — No — No El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/No —
— — — —
—
q q q q
No No No No
Ext Ext Ext Ext
Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — — —
No No Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes
Ext Re Re Re Re Ext Re Re Re Re
Yes No No Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
— Yes In/No — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — — Yes In/No — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes q Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— Yes In/No — Yes El/No Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes El/No — Yes El/No — Yes El/No — Yes El/No Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
— — —
P
s
s
s
— — — P P P
s
s
s
FIAT AVVENTURA HHH You’ll like Great ride quality, ground clearance, strong engine (Abarth). You won’t Odd driving position. We say Great mix of performance and design. Buy Multijet Active
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3989mm Width 1706mm Height 1542mm Ground Clearance 205mm Boot NA Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1090-1255kg 1.3 Multijet Active (Diesel) 1.3 Multijet Dynamic (Diesel) 1.3 Multijet Emotion (Diesel) 1.4 T-jet Abarth (Petrol)
8.20 9.13 10.03 11.04
8.57 9.56 10.51 11.40
8.72 9.63 10.48 11.67
8.30 9.26 10.17 11.14
8.49 9.49 10.40 11.65
— — — —
12.8 18.7 20.5 12.8 18.7 20.5 12.8 18.7 20.5 — — —
93 93 93 145
15.10 15.10 15.10 9.19
PREMIER RIO H You’ll like Low speed ride, city-friendly size. You won’t Poor dynamics, inferior build quality. We say The latest version is the best Rio yet, but there’s still a long way to go. Buy LX
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 3970mm Width 1570mm Height 1730mm Ground Clearance 200mm Boot 454 Tank 46 litres Kerb Weight 1080-1145kg GX (Petrol) GLX (Petrol) DX (Diesel) LX (Diesel)
5.11 6.42 6.94 7.36
5.91 6.41 6.98 7.40
4.98** 5.44** NA NA
7.52 7.85 8.25 8.69
NA NA NA NA
— — — —
— — 13.8 13.8
— — 17 17
— — — —
76 76 72 72
19.39 19.39 20.26 20.26
E E E E
a a a a
— — — —
—
No Yes No Yes
El/No El/No El/No El/No
— — — —
TATA NEXON HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3994mm Width 1811mm Height 1607mm Ground Clearance 209mm Boot 350 Tank 44 litres Kerb Weight 1237-1305kg Revotron XE (Petrol) Revotron XM (Petrol) Revotron XT (Petrol) Revotron XZ+ (Petrol) Revotron XZ+ Dual-Tone roof (Petrol) Revotorq XE (Diesel) Revotorq XM (Diesel) Revotorq XT (Diesel) Revotorq XZ+ (Diesel) Revotorq XZ+ Dual-Tone roof (Diesel)
5.85** 6.49** 7.29** 8.45** 8.59** 6.85** 7.40** 8.15** 9.30** 9.45**
You’ll like Concept car-like styling, driving manners, ride. You won’t Lacklustre engine performance, inconsisten fit and finish. We say Very well rounded compact SUV with good ride and features.. Buy 1.5D XM. 6.86 7.61 8.62 9.84 10.01 8.15 8.79 9.66 11.00 11.18
5.99** 6.69** 7.46** 8.62** 8.77** 6.99** 7.66** 8.32** 9.47** 9.62**
6.98 7.72 8.63 9.94 10.11 8.13 8.83 9.61 10.92 11.09
5.94** 6.59** 7.39** 8.54** 8.69** 6.94** 7.56** 8.24** 9.39** 9.54**
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
110 110 110 110 110 110 110 110 110 110
— — — — — — — — — —
O P P P P O P P P P
— — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— — — D D — — — D D
— — — D D — — — D D
— — — — — — — — — —
—
P P P P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — — — p
— — 2 2 2 — — 2 2 2 2 2 2 6
— — D D D — D D D D D D D D
— — D D D — — D D D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
—
E c/a L P E c/a N P
— —
2 2
— —
— —
— —
—
E E F F F E E F F F
a c/a c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N N N
q q
q q
— P P P P
s
s
s
s
— P P P P
s
s
s
s
SUV MID-SIZE HYUNDAI CRETA HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4270mm Width 1780mm Height 1630mm Ground Clearance 190mm Boot 405 Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1265-1350kg 1.6 E (Petrol) 1.6 E+ (Petrol) 1.6 SX+ (Petrol) 1.6 SX+ A/T (Petrol) 1.6 SX+ Dual Tone (Petrol) 1.4 CRDi E+ (Diesel) 1.4 CRDi S (Diesel) 1.4 CRDi S+ (Diesel) 1.6 CRDi VGT S+ A/T (Diesel) 1.6 CRDi VGT SX (Diesel) 1.6 CRDi VGT SX+ (Diesel) 1.6 CRDi VGT SX+ A/T (Diesel) 1.6 CRDi VGT SX+ Dual Tone (Diesel) 1.6 CRDi VGT SX (O) (Diesel)
10.02 10.74 13.21 14.31 13.62 11.79 12.94 13.97 15.37 14.03 15.13 16.38 15.55 16.30
10.63 11.41 13.88 15.04 14.30 12.78 13.60 14.67 16.14 14.73 15.89 17.20 16.32 17.11
You’ll like Easy drivability, smooth, powerful engine, premium interiors. You won’t Body roll, premium pricing. We say The Creta is the “go to” SUV in the segment. Buy 1.6 SX+ MT 10.04 11.18 13.86 15.03 14.29 11.18 13.10 14.13 15.88 14.51 16.07 16.94 16.07 16.85
10.17 10.99 13.82 14.98 14.25 12.31 13.29 14.37 15.81 14.42 15.58 16.88 16.01 16.80
10.88 11.75 14.51 15.73 14.96 12.61 13.98 15.09 16.61 15.15 16.35 17.72 16.80 17.63
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — —
15.2 15.2 15.2 15.2 15.2 21.3 21.3 21.3 17 19.6 19.6 17 19.6 19.6
123 — 123 — 123 — 123 — 123 — 90 — 90 — 90 — 128 — 128 11.37 128 — 128 — 128 11.37 128 11.37
E E F F F E E E E F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L N L L L N N L L
— — — — — — — — — — — — — s!
— — P P P
s
s
s
— — P P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
MARUTI S-CROSS HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4300mm Width 1765mm Height 1590mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 353 Tank 48 litres Kerb Weight 1180-1275kg 1.3 DDiS 200 Sigma (Diesel) 1.3 DDiS 200 Delta (Diesel)
9.29 10.10
102 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
9.59 10.49
You’ll like Spacious cabin, interior quality, ride and handling, punchy engine. You won’t Unappealing looks, lacks an SUV feel. We say Very capable premium crossover that does everything you ask, but nothing more. Buy 1.6 Alpha 9.49 10.29
9.64 10.52
9.84 10.75
— —
— —
— —
23.65 90 13.72 23.65 90 13.72
q No El q No El
No — Yes El/No — No — Yes El/No —
— P
s
MODEL BY MODEL SUV MID-SIZE TO UTILITY VEHICLES
Average kpl
— — —
— — —
23.65 90 13.72 23.65 90 13.72 22.70 120 11.50
E/F c/a N O/P p 2 2 2
D D — D D — D D —
q No El q No El q No El
O O P P P O O P P
— — — — p — — — p
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
— D D D D — D D D
— — D D D — — D D
— — — — — — — — —
—
P P P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— 1 1 — — 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2
— — — — — — — — — D D D D
— — D — — — — — D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
—
P P P P P
— — — p p
1 1 1 2 2
D — — D — — D — — D D — D D —
— — — P P — P P
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— —
— —
— —
Yes Yes Yes
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
q
D/P D Y
— p p
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
— — —
Leather Seats
11.57 13.41 14.85
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
11.27 13.29 14.70
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
10.97 12.36 14.00
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
11.17 12.88 14.31
AC/climate control
Kolkata
1.3 DDiS 200 Zeta (Diesel) 1.3 DDiS 200 Alpha (Diesel) 1.6 DDiS 320 Alpha (Diesel)
Power hp
Mumbai
11.39 12.60 14.31
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes —
P P P
s
s
s
s
HONDA BR-V HHHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4453-4456mm Width 1735mm Height 1666mm Ground Clearance 210mm Boot 223-691 Tank 42 litres Kerb Weight 1199-1306kg 1.5 i-VTEC E (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC S (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC V (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC V CVT (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC VX (Petrol) 1.5 i-DTEC E (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC S (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC V (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC VX (Diesel)
9.92 11.09 12.73 13.94 13.77 11.64 13.11 14.09 15.28
10.31 11.71 12.88 14.10 13.94 11.88 13.21 14.20 15.40
You’ll like Flexibility of seven seats, easy to drive. You won’t Lacks the rugged appeal of an SUV, missing key equipment. We sayAn ideal option for large families. Buy S 9.85 11.22 12.30 13.43 13.28 11.14 12.37 13.31 14.42
10.23 11.35 13.33 14.57 14.40 11.28 13.42 14.43 15.64
10.59 11.76 13.63 14.91 14.73 11.76 13.72 14.76 16.02
— — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — —
15.4 15.4 15.4 16 21.9 21.9 21.9 21.9 21.9
119 119 119 119 100 100 100 100 100
— — — — — — — — —
E F F F F E F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L
—
q q q q q q q q q
No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No — No In/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes —
— — — — — — — — —
No No No No No No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — No — — In/No — No — Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes s Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes s Yes Yes El/Yes s
— — — — — — —
No No No Yes Yes
In Re Re Re Re
Yes No Yes Yes Yes
No No No No No No No No
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No No No No No No No No
RENAULT DUSTER HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4315mm Width 1822mm Height 1695mm Ground Clearance 205-210mm Boot 410/475 Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight 1770-1889kg 106 PS RxE (Petrol) 106 PS RxL (Petrol) 106 PS RxS A/T (Petrol) Standard 85 PS 2WD (Diesel) RxE 85 PS 2WD (Diesel) RxL 85 PS 2WD (Diesel) RxL 110 PS 2WD (Diesel) RxL 110 PS 2WD A/T (Diesel) RxS 85 PS 2WD (Diesel) RxZ 85 PS 2WD (Diesel) RxZ 110 PS 2WD (Diesel) RxZ 110 PS 2WD A/T (Diesel) RxZ 110 AWD (Diesel)
9.46 10.32 11.61 10.64 10.86 12.62 13.39 14.10 12.55 13.59 14.56 15.25 16.22
You’ll like Great ride, build quality, peppy engine. You won’t Dated interiors, low refinement levels. We say Small upgrades and an automatic option make it a more rounded SUV. Buy RxL 110 PS 10.54 11.45 12.71 11.74 11.93 13.85 14.72 15.48 13.33 14.39 15.38 16.08 16.88
10.15 11.04 12.18 11.13 11.35 12.76 13.64 14.40 12.55 13.56 14.50 15.17 15.93
9.86 10.75 12.56 10.92 11.17 13.03 14.00 14.73 13.04 14.12 15.13 15.85 16.60
10.14 11.06 12.11 11.23 11.46 13.17 14.22 14.97 13.10 14.26 15.27 15.98 16.82
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — —
106 — 106 — 106 — 85 — 85 — 85 — 110 — 110 14.01 85 — 85 — 110 — 110 14.01 110 —
E E E E E E E E E F F F F
c/a c/a c/a a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L L L L
— —
!
P
s
— — —
!
P
!
P
s
s
NISSAN TERRANO HHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4331mm Width 1822mm Height 1671mm Ground Clearance 205mm Boot 475 Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight 1755-1787kg (Gross) XL (Petrol) XE 85 (Diesel) XL 85 (Diesel) XV Premium 110 (Diesel) XV Premium 110 A/T (Diesel)
10.87 11.46 14.27 16.21 16.90
You’ll like Build and ride quality. You won’t Poor ergonomics. We say The Terrano steers and drives with the precision of a sedan or a hatchback. Buy XV Premium 11.28 11.77 13.89 16.20 16.99
10.66 11.03 13.29 15.09 15.75
11.10 11.49 13.74 16.36 17.07
11.43 11.88 15.29 16.80 17.55
— — — — —
— — — 11.8 —
— — — 17 —
13 20 20 19 —
104 — 85 — 85 — 110 11.88 110 —
E E E E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L
—
Yes No Yes Yes Yes
El/No ln/No El/No El/No El/No
— — — — —
— — —
No No No No No — No — No No
Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
No — No In/No — No — No In/No —
— —
P P
s
s
UTILITY VEHICLES MAHINDRA BOLERO HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4107mm Width 1745mm Height 1880mm Ground Clearance 180mm Boot NA Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight NA Plus Non AC (Diesel) Plus AC (Diesel) SLE (Diesel) SLX (Diesel) ZLX (Diesel) 1.5 Power+ SLE (Diesel) 1.5 Power+ SLX (Diesel) 1.5 Power+ ZLX (Diesel)
6.43** 6.80** 9.11 9.73 10.01 8.07 8.79 9.18
8.87 9.37 9.13 9.73 10.01 8.37 9.13 9.54
You’ll like Engine is torque-y, abuse-friendly vehicle. You won’t Poor refinement levels, lack of equipment, cramped interiors. We say Marginally improved but still feels crude. Buy Power+ ZLX 8.62 9.05 9.07 9.67 9.95 8.12 8.82 9.20
8.68 9.55 9.47 10.10 10.39 8.28 9.03 9.42
9.11 9.57 8.32 9.95 10.23 8.53 9.31 9.72
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
15.9 15.9 15.9 15.9 15.9 — — —
63 — 63 — 63 25.61 63 25.61 63 25.61 71 — 71 — 71 —
— E E E E E E E
— — — c/a c/a — c/a c/a
— — — — — — — —
— — —
—
q q q q q q q q
— — — —
TATA MOVUS HH Doors 5 Seats 7/8/9 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4421mm Width 1780-1853mm Height 1940mm Ground Clearance 180mm Boot 150/500 Tank 65 litres Kerb Weight 1940kg CX (Diesel) LX (Diesel)
9.09 9.41
9.73 10.07
You’ll like Flexible seat-layout options, comfortable seats, cabin space. You won’t Cheap plastics, rubbery gearbox, sparse equipment list. We say Credible rival to the Xylo. Buy LX 7.23** 7.51**
9.29 9.72
7.06** 7.34**
— —
— —
— —
13.5 13.5
120 17.04 120 17.04
— E
— —
L L
— —
— —
— —
— —
q No Ex q No Ex
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 103
MODEL BY MODEL UTILITY VEHICLES TO MPV
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
— — — — —
— — — — —
— —
s
MARUTI EECO HHH Doors 5 Seats 5/7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 3675mm Width 1475mm Height 1800mm Ground Clearance 160mm Boot NA Tank 40 litres Kerb Weight 908-928kg Std 5-seater (Petrol) AC 5-seater (Petrol) Std 5-seater (CNG) AC 5-seater (CNG) Std 7-seater (Petrol)
3.63 3.99 4.43 4.81 3.85
You’ll like Ample space for people and luggage, low running costs. You won’t Low equipment levels, basic interiors. We say Excellent value and sensible upgrade from the Omni. Buy 5-seater AC
3.94 4.30 4.61 4.95 4.16
4.03 4.39 3.91** 4.27** 4.24
4.18 4.56 3.92** 4.28** 4.41
4.27 4.64 5.04 5.42 4.48
10557 11504 — 14297 11095
— — — — —
— — — — —
15.7 15.7 — — 15.7
73 73 73 73 73
— — — — —
— E — E —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
No No No No No
Ex In Ex Ex Ex
No Yes No No No
— — — — —
No No No No No
Ex/No In/No Ex/No Ex/No Ex/No
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
No Ex No Ex
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No —
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
q q q q q q q q q q
No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In In In In In In In
No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
MARUTI OMNI HH Doors 5 Seats 5/8 Engine/Drive Mid/Rear Length 3370mm Width 1410mm Height 1640mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot NA Tank 36 litres Kerb Weight 785 - 800kg 5-seater (Petrol) 8-seater (Petrol)
2.98 2.99
You’ll like Price, utility. You won’t Crash safety is appalling. We say A van trying hard to be a car. Buy 5-seater version – it’s the cheapest yet 3.26 3.28
3.28 3.29
3.46 3.48
3.50 3.52
8144 8195
— —
— —
16.8 16.8
35 35
— —
— —
MPV TOYOTA INNOVA CRYSTA HHHH Doors 5 Seats 7/8 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4735mm Width 1830mm Height 1795mm Ground Clearance 167mm Boot 758/1128 Tank 55 - 65 litres Kerb Weight 1805-2450kg 2.7 GX 7-seater (Petrol) 2.7 GX 8-seater (Petrol) 2.7 GX 7-seater A/T (Petrol) 2.7 GX 8-seater A/T (Petrol) 2.7 VX 7-seater (Petrol) 2.7 ZX 7-seater A/T (Petrol) 2.7 Touring Sport 7-seater (Petrol) 2.7 Touring Sport 7-str A/T (Petrol) 2.4 G 7-Seater (Diesel) 2.4 G 8-Seater (Diesel) 2.4 GX 7-Seater (Diesel) 2.4 GX 8-Seater (Diesel) 2.8 GX 7-Seater A/T (Diesel) 2.8 GX 8-Seater A/T (Diesel) 2.4 VX 7-Seater (Diesel) 2.4 VX 8-Seater (Diesel) 2.4 ZX 7-Seater (Diesel) 2.8 ZX 7-Seater A/T (Diesel) 2.4 Touring Sport 7-seater (Diesel) 2.8 Touring Sport 7-str A/T (Diesel)
15.60 15.69 16.80 16.90 18.79 21.91 19.79 22.93 16.26 16.31 17.25 17.30 18.70 18.75 20.41 20.46 22.58 24.03 21.25 24.86
17.23 17.33 18.51 18.61 20.64 24.14 21.70 25.27 17.89 17.16 18.84 18.94 20.37 20.47 22.31 22.37 24.57 26.44 24.47 27.76
You’ll like Space, seat comfort, ride quality, tough build. You won’t Premium pricing, heavy steering, ponderous to drive. We say Bigger, bolder and even better; easily the new MPV benchmark. Buy 2.4 VX
14.04** 14.08** 15.15** 15.19** 16.94** 20.00** 18.13** 21.18** 14.24** 14.29** 15.91 15.96 17.26 17.31 18.93 18.98 20.95 22.30 19.25** 22.49**
17.28 17.34 18.61 18.66 20.67 24.31 21.52 25.17 17.56 17.61 18.62 19.21 22.01 22.06 22.56 22.73 24.38 25.88 22.86 26.73
17.12 17.22 18.54 18.33 20.66 24.26 21.75 25.42 17.24 17.29 18.44 18.55 20.02 20.13 21.99 22.04 24.27 26.05 24.11 27.46
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — 15.1 15.1 15.1 15.1 14.2 14.2 15.1 15.1 15.1 14.2 15.1 14.2
166 166 166 166 166 166 166 166 150 150 150 150 174 174 150 150 150 174 150 174
— — — — — — — — 13.11 13.11 13.11 13.11 11.46 11.46 13.11 13.11 13.11 11.46 13.11 11.46
E E E E F F F F E E E E E E F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — p p p — — — — — — — — p p p p
3 3 3 3 3 7 7 7 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 7 7 7 7
— — — — D D D D — — — — — — D D D D D D
D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — —
— — 2 2 — — 2 2 2 2
— D D D — D D D D D
— — D D — — D D D D
— — — — — — — — — —
—
— — — — — —
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/No El/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/No El/No El/No El/No El/No El/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — —
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
— — — — — — — —
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
P P P P
P P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
HONDA MOBILIO HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4386-4398mm Width 1683mm Height 1603mm Ground Clearance 189mm Boot 223 Tank 42 litres Kerb Weight 1131-1246kg 1.5 i-VTEC E (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC S (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC V (Petrol) 1.5 i-VTEC V (O) (Petrol) 1.5 i-DTEC E (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC S (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC V (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC V (O) (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC RS (Diesel) 1.5 i-DTEC RS (O) (Diesel)
7.94 9.13 10.55 11.72 9.72 10.57 12.40 13.20 13.72 14.52
8.82 10.11 11.76 12.44 10.79 11.81 13.27 13.96 14.65 15.34
You’ll like Spacious, flexible cabin, easy to drive. You won’t Dashboard is a bit basic, rear seat set too low. We say A stylish, easy to drive and versatile MPV from Honda. Buy S 8.20 9.38 10.79 11.18 9.88 10.72 12.18 12.45 12.93 13.71
8.64 9.87 11.32 12.56 10.43 11.29 13.31 13.99 14.80 15.47
9.14 10.43 12.35 13.02 11.25 12.32 13.81 14.51 15.24 15.94
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — 13.8 13.8 13.8 13.8 13.8 13.8
— — — — 18.2 18.2 18.2 18.2 18.2 18.2
17.3 17.3 17.3 17.3 24.2 24.2 24.2 24.2 24.2 24.2
119 119 119 119 100 100 100 100 100 100
11.07 11.07 11.07 11.07 14.88 14.88 14.88 14.88 14.88 14.88
E E E E E E E E E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L
O P P P O P P P P P
— — — — — — — — — —
—
— No In/No — No El/No Yes El/No Yes El/No — Yes ln/No — Yes El/No Yes El/No Yes El/No Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
TATA ARIA HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4780mm Width 1895mm Height 1780mm Ground Clearance 200mm Boot NA Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1990kg Pure LX 4x2 (Diesel) Pleasure 4x2 (Diesel) Pride 4x4 (Diesel)
12.50 15.01 18.34
15.13 17.96 21.73
You’ll like Comfortable second row, handles the rough stuff with ease. You won’t Gearbox feels unpolished, cramped third row. We say Hardly a facelift, but subtle tweaks improve overall package. Buy Pleasure 14.02 14.28 17.48
15.03 17.88 21.60
14.00 16.69 20.10
41381 — — — 150 — 53904 — — — 150 — 66600 9.8 13.8 15.05 150 14.79
E c/a L E c/a L F c/a L
P P P
— — — 2 p 6
— — — — D — — D D Y
q Yes In q Yes In q Yes In
Yes Yes Yes
No El/No — Yes El/No — Yes El/Yes s
— —
— —
q No In q No In
No — No In/No — No — Yes In/No —
!
— P P
s
s
MARUTI ERTIGA HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4265mm Width 1695mm Height 1685mm Ground Clearance 185mm Boot 185-735 Tank 45 litres Kerb Weight 1135-1265kg K14 LXi (Petrol) K14 LXi (O) (Petrol)
7.05 7.48
104 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
7.46 7.86
You’ll like Easy to drive, well-equipped, value for money. You won’t Cramped cabin, slow to respond engine. We say The ideal Indian family car. Buy VDi 7.51 7.92
7.76 8.17
8.04 8.47
— —
10.2 14.8 10.2 14.8
16 16
92 13.56 92 13.56
E E
— —
L L
— —
1 2
— —
— —
— —
— —
MODEL BY MODEL MPV TO SUV ENTRY
E E E E E E E E E E
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a — — c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L
— — — — — — — — — —
2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 2
— — — D D — — — D D
— — — D D — — — D D
— — — — — — — — — —
— Yes El/No — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/No — Yes El/No — Yes El/No — — Yes In/No — — Yes El/No — — Yes El/No — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes —
P
— P P P P P P P P P
— — — — — — — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 2 — 2 p 2
— — — — — — — D D D
— — — D D — — D D D
— — — — — — — — — —
— — —
— — O O O P
— — — — — —
— — — — — 2
— — — — — — — — — — D D
— — — — — —
— — — — —
— — O
— — —
— — O
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — — — — —
2 2 2 6 6 6
D — — D — — D — — D D Y D D — D D Y
— — — — — — — —
— — 2 2 2 2 2 2
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — D — D D — D D —
— —
q q q q q q q q q q
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In In In In In In In
No No No No No No No No No No
— — — — —
q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No — No In/No — No — No In/No — No No In/No — No No In/No — No Yes In/No — Yes Yes El/No —
No In No In No In
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No —
q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
q q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Electric stability prog
No No No Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes
q
D/P D Y
P P P P P — — P P P
Parking sensor
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex In Ex Ex Ex
ABS
P
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
s!
q q q q q q q q q q
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Rear wash wipe
E/F c/a N O/P p
Alloy wheels
13.56 — 13.56 13.56 13.56 — — — — —
Traction control
92 — 92 92 92 90 90 90 90 90
Seats Height Adjust
16 — 16 16 16 24.5 24.5 24.5 24.5 24.5
Rear defogger
14.8 — 14.8 14.8 14.8 — — — — —
Rear AC vents
10.2 — 10.2 10.2 10.2 — — — — —
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Average kpl
Airbags
— — — — — — — — — —
Leather Seats
9.37 10.08 10.58 10.10 10.78 10.76 10.85 11.69 12.88 13.47
Central locking/ Remote locking
Annual Insurance (Rs)
9.03 9.56 10.18 9.72 10.38 10.35 10.44 11.24 12.47 13.04
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Bengaluru
8.78 8.56** 9.94 9.48 10.13 8.98 9.06 9.77 10.40 10.88
Electric windows R/F
Chennai
8.73 9.10 9.88 9.38 10.03 10.23 10.32 11.15 12.03 12.54
AC/climate control
Kolkata
K14 VXi (Petrol) K14 VXi CNG (Petrol) K14 VXi A/T(Petrol) K14 ZXi (Petrol) K14 ZXi+ (Petrol) DDiS LDi SHVS (Diesel) DDiS LDi SHVS (O) (Diesel) DDiS VDi SHVS (Diesel) DDiS ZDi SHVS (Diesel) DDiS ZDi+ SHVS (Diesel)
Power hp
Mumbai
8.50 9.18 9.62 9.17 9.81 9.89 9.97 10.77 11.45 12.41
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Delhi
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
Indian Driving Cycle*
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
City
MODEL DETAILS
P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
— — — P P
s
s
RENAULT LODGY HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4498mm Width 1751mm Height 1697mm Ground Clearance 174mm Boot 207/1861 Tank 50 litres Kerb Weight 1299-1368kg Standard 85 PS (8 seater) (Diesel) RxE 85 PS (7 seater) (Diesel) RxE 85 PS (8 seater) (Diesel) World Edition 85 PS (8 seater) (D) World Edition 110 PS (8 seater) (D) RxL 85 PS Stepway (8 seater) (D) RxL 110 PS Stepway (8 seater) (D) RxZ 85 PS Stepway (8 seater) (D) RxZ 110 PS Stepway (8 seater) (D) RxZ 110 PS Stepway (7 seater) (D)
8.96 10.02 10.02 10.96 12.17 10.96 12.16 12.34 13.14 13.47
10.05 11.17 11.17 12.17 13.05 12.17 13.02 13.11 14.02 14.36
You’ll like Performance, good ride, spacious cabin. You won’t Heavy clutch, lazy engine, dull interiors. We say A great product which appeals to the head. Buy RxZ 85 PS 9.49 10.56 10.56 11.51 12.25 11.51 12.24 12.32 13.19 13.52
9.55 10.64 10.66 11.61 12.98 11.61 13.01 13.06 13.99 14.38
9.67 10.81 10.81 11.65 13.02 11.65 13.01 13.11 14.04 14.40
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
21.04 21.04 21.04 21.04 19.98 21.04 19.98 21.04 19.98 19.98
85 85 85 85 110 85 110 85 110 110
— — — — — — — — — —
E E E E E E E E E E
— c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
MAHINDRA XYLO HHH Doors 5 Seats 7/8 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4520mm Width 1850mm Height 1895mm Ground Clearance 186mm Boot NA Tank 55 litres Kerb Weight 1830kg D2 MAXX (Diesel) D2 (Diesel) D4 (Diesel) H4 (Diesel) H4 ABS Airbag (Diesel) H8 ABS Airbag (Diesel)
10.02 10.24 10.74 11.00 11.43 13.62
10.27 10.50 11.01 11.28 11.72 13.63
You’ll like Wallet-friendly price, unbeatable space, comfort, strong m-Hawk engine. You won’t Interior fit and finish, sloppy handling. We say Long in the tooth now, replacement expected soon Buy H8 9.76 9.97 10.44 11.21 10.77 12.92
9.64 10.23 10.72 10.87 11.15 13.65
10.72 10.97 11.50 11.78 12.68 14.52
30113 — — 14.88 30113 — — 14.88 31607 — — 14.88 32894 10.1 14.4 14.0 34829 10.1 14.4 14.0 38012 10.1 14.4 14.0
92 — 92 — 92 — 122 12.97 122 12.97 122 12.97
E E E E E E
— — c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L
— — — — — P
s
DATSUN GO+ HH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 3995mm Width 1635mm Height 1490mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 48/347 Tank 35 litres Kerb Weight 788kg D (Petrol) A (Petrol) T (Petrol)
4.39 5.18 5.44
5.15 5.52 5.80
You’ll like Engine response, price, easy to drive. You won’t Minimal thigh support, rear luggage space. We say Could very well turn out to be a practical and popular five-seater. Buy T 4.56 5.19 5.45
4.58 5.38 5.65
4.59 5.45 5.74
— — —
— — —
— — —
20.6 20.6 20.6
68 13.96 68 13.96 68 13.96
— E E
— — a
— — —
— — —
— — —
SUV ENTRY TATA HEXA HHHH Doors 5 Seats 6/7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4788mm Width 1903mm Height 1791mm Ground Clearance 200mm Boot NA Tank NA Kerb Weight NA XE 7-seater (Diesel) XM 7-seater (Diesel) XMA A/T 7-seater (Diesel) XT 6/7-seater (Diesel) XTA A/T 6/7-seater (Diesel) XT 4X4 6/7-seater (Diesel)
13.15 15.34 16.64 17.98 19.27 19.40
13.63 15.65 16.98 18.48 19.80 19.93
You’ll like High quality interiors, ability to seat seven. You won’t Some missing equipment, ponderous to drive. We say An able people mover with decent off-road ability. Buy XTA 13.28 15.16 16.39 17.79 19.01 19.13
13.49 15.50 16.80 18.29 19.59 19.72
13.70 15.76 17.09 18.64 19.96 20.10
— — — — — —
— — — — — — 10.1 13.1 — — 10.1 13.1
— — — — — —
150 156 156 156 156 156
— — — — — —
E E E F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L
P P P P P P
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/No El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
In/No In/No In/No In/No In/No El/No El/No El/No
— — —
— P P
s!
P
—
P
s!
P
s
s
s
s
s
MAHINDRA SCORPIO HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5/7/8/9 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4456mm Width 1820mm Height 1195mm Ground Clearance 165-180mm Boot 820 Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1750/2610kg(2WD/4WD) S2 (Diesel) 4x2 S4 (Diesel) 4x4 S4 + (Diesel) 4x2 S4 + (Diesel) 4x4 S6 + (Diesel) 4x2 S8 (Diesel) 4x2 S10 (Diesel) 4x2 S10 (Diesel) 4x4
11.03 12.45 12.91 14.33 14.08 15.27 16.03 17.34
11.43 12.70 13.21 14.58 14.50 15.65 16.47 17.88
You’ll like Punchy engine, pleasing interiors. You won’t Nervous at high speeds, poor cabin ergonomics. We say More comfortable, better equipped and much nicer to drive. Buy S8 10.90 11.77 12.25 11.50 13.48 14.56 15.34 16.69
11.20 13.25 13.77 15.19 14.92 16.29 17.13 18.59
11.60 13.71 14.26 15.77 15.65 16.95 17.85 19.40
— — — — — — — —
11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 —
14 14 14 14 14 14 14 —
16.01 16.01 16.01 16.01 16.01 16.01 16.01 16.01
122 111 122 122 122 122 122 122
13.44 13.44 13.44 13.44 13.44 13.44 13.44 13.44
E E E E E E F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L
O O O O P P P P
— — — —
— — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — P P P
s
s
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 105
MODEL BY MODEL SUV ENTRY TO SUV (SOFT-ROADERS)
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
TATA SAFARI HHHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 4650-4655mm Width 1918-1965mm Height 1922-1925mm Ground Clearance 200-205mmBoot NA Tank 63-65 litres Kerb Weight 1920-2665kg Storme 2.2 LX (4x2) (Diesel) Storme 2.2 EX (4x2) (Diesel) Storme 2.2 VX Varicor 400 (4x2) (D) Storme 2.2 VX Varicor 400 (4x4) (D)
11.30 13.87 15.60 17.31
12.11 13.98 15.91 17.64
10.90 12.90 14.60 16.15
You’ll like Spacious, comfortable ride, smooth engine. You won’t Decade old styling, dated interiors, not well equipped. We say Improved in many ways but fundamentally an SUV that’s well past its time. Buy VX 4x2 11.27 13.99 15.87 17.60
11.60 14.22 16.16 17.94
— — — —
10.1 13.2 10.1 13.2 — — — —
— — — —
140 14.06 E c/a 140 14.06 E c/a 156 — E c/a 156 — E c/a
L L L L
— — — —
— — 2 2
— — — D — — D D — D D —
P P P P P P P P P P
— — — p p p p p p p
2 2 2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6
D D D D D D D D D D
— — — D D D D D D D
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — P
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
2 6 2 6 6
D D D D D
D D D D D
— — — — —
6 6 6 6
— D D D
D D D D
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D D D D
P P P P
—
q q q q
No Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex
Yes — No El/No — Yes Yes El/No — Yes Yes El/Yes — Yes Yes El/Yes —
q q q q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El El El El El El El El El El
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— No — No — No — Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — No — No In/No — Yes No In/No —
q q q q q
No Yes No Yes Yes
Re Re El Re El
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — —
q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes
In In In In
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex Ex
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
— — P P
s
s
MAHINDRA XUV500 HHHH You’ll like Improved cabin, long list of features. You won’t Steering kickback, average ride (A/T). We say Superb value but a little rough around the edges. Buy W10
Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Front/Four Length 4585mm Width 1890mm Height 1785mm Ground Clearance 200mm Boot 93 Tank 70 litres Kerb Weight 1785kg W4 4x2 (Diesel) W6 4x2 (Diesel) W6 4x2 A/T (Diesel) W8 4x2 (Diesel) W8 4x2 A/T (Diesel) W8 AWD (Diesel) W10 4x2 (Diesel) W10 4x2 A/T (Diesel) W10 AWD (Diesel) W10 AWD A/T (Diesel)
14.80 16.23 17.33 18.32 19.55 18.18 19.36 20.52 19.41 20.56
14.97 16.52 17.54 18.54 19.79 19.56 19.60 20.78 20.86 22.04
14.18 15.61 16.55 17.48 18.62 19.32 18.49 19.55 19.62 20.71
14.95 16.51 17.54 18.54 19.79 19.56 19.60 20.79 20.86 22.09
15.69 17.35 18.44 19.51 20.43 20.60 20.64 21.91 21.98 23.25
— 45034 — 50193 — 52884 — — — —
10.2 10.2 — 10.2 — — 10.2 — — —
14.3 14.3 — 14.3 — — 14.3 — — —
15.1 15.1 — 15.1 — — 15.1 — — —
140 140 140 140 140 140 140 140 140 140
12.34 12.34 — 12.34 — — 12.34 — — —
E F F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L N N N N N N N
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No — El/No — El/No — El/Yes s El/Yes s El/Yes s El/Yes s El/Yes s El/Yes s El/Yes s
— P P
!
P
!
P
!
P
!
P
!
P
!
P
!
P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
TATA SUMO GOLD HHH Doors 5 Seats 7/9 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4258mm Width 1700mm Height 1925mm Ground Clearance 190mm Boot NA Tank 65 litres Kerb Weight NA 3.0 CR4 CX (Diesel) 3.0 CR4 CX PS (Diesel) 3.0 CR4 EX (Diesel) 3.0 CR4 GX (Diesel)
7.80 7.98 8.57 9.31
8.24 8.44 8.95 9.73
You’ll like Spacious cabin, supple ride. You won’t Interiors are basic, heavy clutch. We say Very basic but has more space than a Bolero. Buy CX PS 7.82 6.60** 8.50 9.18
8.72 8.94 9.54 10.35
8.05 8.25 8.82 9.57
25878 — 28134 30665
9.1 9.1 9.1 9.1
12.06 12.06 12.06 12.06
15.3 15.3 15.3 15.3
85 85 85 85
25.87 — — 25.87 — — 25.87 E — 25.87 E c/a
— — — —
— — —
— — — —
SUV (SOFT-ROADERS) HYUNDAI TUCSON HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front Length 4475mm Width 1850mm Height 1660mm Ground Clearance 172mm Boot 513 Tank 62 litres Kerb Weight NA Nu 2.0 M/T (Petrol) Nu 2.0 A/T GL (Petrol) R 2.0 M/T (Diesel) R 2.0 A/T GL (Diesel) R 2.0 A/T GLS (Diesel)
20.73 23.86 24.05 26.20 27.81
21.72 25.23 25.42 27.70 29.40
You’ll like Equipment list, cabin room, refined engines. You won’t Doesn't handle well as competitors, no AWD option. We say With a good ride quality and upmarket interiors, Hyundai's all-new Tuscon is a great urban SUV. Buy 2.0 D GLS. 21.79 25.04 24.87 27.04 28.71
21.85 25.18 24.89 27.13 28.81
22.73 26.43 26.18 28.55 30.31
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
155 155 185 185 185
— — — — —
E F E F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N
P P P P P
— p — p p
— — — —
P
s!
P
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — — — — — — — —
P
P P P
s
s
s
s
s
HONDA CR-V HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front/Four Length 4545mm Width 1820mm Height 1685mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot 589 Tank 58 litres Kerb Weight 1470-1600kg 2.0 2WD (Petrol) 2.0 2WD A/T (Petrol) 2.4 AWD A/T (Petrol) 2.4 AWD A/T AVN (Petrol)
25.31 27.38 30.01 27.92
27.69 30.20 30.28 30.45
You’ll like Powerful engines, comfortable ride, well-appointed cabin. You won’t Poor fuel efficiency, lack of a diesel option. We say Improved and better value, but not a huge leap forward. Buy 2.4 24.17 26.04 28.50 28.27
25.92 28.02 28.24 30.08
27.37 29.51 32.28 32.20
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
13.7 13.7 12 12
156 10.52 156 — 190 11.13 190 11.13
E F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
L N N N
P P P P
p p p p
s
s
s
s
JEEP COMPASS HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four/Four Length 4395mm Width 1818mm Height 1640mm Ground Clearance 170mm Boot NA Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1537-1641 kg 1.4 Sport 4x2 (Petrol) 1.4 Limited A/T 4x2 (Petrol) 1.4 Limited A/T 4x2 Option (Petrol) 2.0 Sport 4x2 (Diesel) 2.0 Longitude 4x2 (Diesel) 2.0 Longitude 4x2 Option (Diesel) 2.0 Limited 4x2 (Diesel) 2.0 Limited 4x2 Option (Diesel) 2.0 Limited 4x4 (Diesel) 2.0 Limited 4x4 Option (Diesel)
17.35 21.65 22.45 18.40 19.57 20.51 21.45 22.27 23.68 24.50
106 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
17.88 22.32 23.15 19.26 20.50 21.48 22.47 23.34 25.02 25.89
You’ll like Solid build quality, abuse-friendly, ride and handling. You won’t Missing features, rear seat comfort. We say Baby Grand Cherokee looks and high quality interiors, in a compact package carrying Jeep's DNA. Buy 2.0 Longitude 4x2 Option 14.99** 18.74** 19.44** 15.49** 16.49** 17.29** 18.09** 18.79** 19.99** 20.69**
18.17 22.66 23.50 18.86 20.06 21.01 21.97 22.72 24.25 25.09
18.57 23.25 24.11 19.30 20.54 21.53 22.52 23.39 24.87 25.97
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
162 162 162 173 173 173 173 173 173 173
NA NA NA 17.1 17.1 17.1 17.1 17.1 17.1 16.3
F F F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
L L L L L L L L L L
P P P P P P P P P P
p p p p p p p p p p
P P P P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
MODEL BY MODEL SUV TO LIFESTYLE
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
VOLKSWAGEN TIGUAN HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4486mm Width 1839mm Height 1672mm Ground Clearance 149mm Boot 615-1655 Tank 71 litres Kerb Weight 1720kg 2.0 TDI Comfortline A/T (Diesel) 2.0 TDI Highline A/T (Diesel)
31.07 34.87
32.80 36.69
You’ll like Build quality, equipment list, interior fit and finish You won’t Exorbitant price tag, 5-seater only. We say Impressive package but pricey for what it is. Buy Comfortline. 29.54 33.15
32.05 35.97
33.35 37.44
— —
— —
— —
— —
113 143
— —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p
6 6
D D Y D D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes
Yes El/No Yes El/No
s!
P
s!
P
p p
2 2
D D Y D D Y
q Yes Ex q Yes Ex
Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p p
2 6 7
D D Y D D Y D D Y
q Yes El q Yes El q Yes El
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s
s
SUV ISUZU MU-X HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 4955mm Width 1800mm Height 1805mm Ground Clearance 210mm Boot NA Tank 76 litres Kerb Weight 1945kg 3.0 2WD A/T (Diesel) 3.0 4WD A/T (Diesel)
23.99** 25.99**
30.58 33.09
You’ll like Strong engine, acres of room inside. You won’t Expensive, tiny dealer network. We say No-nonsense SUV, but expensive for what you get. Buy 4x2 M/T 24.63** 26.68**
24.34** 26.37**
28.16 30.49
— —
— —
— —
— —
177 177
— —
E c/a L E c/a L
P P
s
s
FORD ENDEAVOUR HHHHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 4892mm Width 1860mm Height 1837mm Ground Clearance 225mm Boot NA Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 2338-2394kg 2.2L 4x2 Trend A/T (Diesel) 2.2L 4x2 Titanium A/T (Diesel) 3.2L 4x4 Titanium A/T (Diesel)
28.64 32.22 35.33
31.13 35.02 38.78
You’ll like Refined engines, plush cabin, ride and handling. You won’t Slow gearbox, third row is difficult to access. We say A long time coming but well worth the wait. Buy 3.2 Titanium 27.05 30.43 33.68
28.96 32.59 36.10
30.44 34.26 37.95
— — —
8.1 8.1 7
11.8 11.8 10.3
— — —
160 12.68 160 12.68 200 11.22
F c/a L F c/a L F c/a L
P P P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
— — — —
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
TOYOTA FORTUNER HHHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 4795mm Width 1855mm Height 1835mm Ground Clearance 225mm Boot NA Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 1900-2145kg 2.7 4X2 M/T (Petrol) 2.7 4X2 A/T (Petrol) 2.8 4X2 M/T (Diesel) 2.8 4X2 A/T (Diesel) 2.8 4X4 M/T (Diesel) 2.8 4X4 A/T (Diesel) 2.8 4x2 A/T TRD Sportivo (Diesel)
28.26 30.03 30.86 33.40 33.60 35.58 31.01**
31.85 33.80 34.27 37.01 37.23 39.36 31.43**
You’ll like Improved ride and handling, list of features. You won’t Weighty steering feel at parking speeds, no sunroof. We say Fortuner handles bad roads with applomb and has genuineability to carry seven persons comfortably. Buy 2.8 D 4x4 MT. 26.70** 28.39** 28.30** 29.92** 30.83** 31.90** 31.57**
32.34 34.36 34.25 36.18 37.27 38.55 31.31**
31.55 33.53 33.42 36.14 36.37 38.62 31.78**
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
166 166 177 177 177 177 177
— — — — — — —
F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P
p p p p p p p
7 7 7 7 7 7 7
D D D D D D D
D D D D D D D
— — — — Y Y Y
q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El El El El El El El
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
L L L L
P P P P
p p p p
2 2 2 2
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ex Ex Ex Ex
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
— — — —
P
q Yes In q Yes In q Yes In
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes s Yes El/Yes s
P
q No Ex q No Ex q No Ex
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No —
— — —
q No Ex q No Ex
No No
s!
— —
P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
MITSUBISHI PAJERO SPORT HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 4695mm Width 1815mm Height 1840mm Ground Clearance 215mm Boot NA Tank 70 litres Kerb Weight 1935kg 4x2 A/T (Diesel) 4x4 (Diesel) Select Plus 4x2 A/T (Diesel) Select Plus 4x4 (Diesel)
31.75 32.22 31.70 32.20
27.12** 27.52** NA NA
You’ll like Strong engine, ride quality. You won’t Poor after-sales support, body roll. We say A good old-school SUV. Buy 4x2 27.45** 27.86** NA NA
32.40 32.87 NA NA
27.45** 27.86** NA NA
— — 64818 9.5 64818 9.5 64818 9.5
— 13 13 13
— — — —
178 178 178 178
11.40 12.45 12.45 12.45
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
P P P
s
s
s
s
MAHINDRA SSANGYONG REXTON HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4755mm Width 1900mm Height 1785-1840 mm Ground Clearance 252mm Boot NA Tank 78 litres Kerb Weight 1986-2000kg RX5 (Diesel) RX6 (Diesel) RX7 A/T AWD (Diesel)
23.23 26.92 28.49
26.34 27.10 28.68
You’ll like Fantastic cabin quality, Auto is loaded with features, tough build. You won’t Noisy engine, slow auto box, dull to drive. We say First SsangYong for India offers Mahindra-typical good value. Buy RX7 20.75 22.58 23.06
22.24 28.33 30.00
23.53 27.91 29.64
69776 — 77653
— — —
— — —
12.4 164 — 12.4 164 — 11.18 187 10.92
F c/a L F c/a L F c/a L
P P P
— p p
2 6 6
D D — D D Y D D Y
— — —
— — —
— D — — D — — D —
p p
2 2
D D Y D D Y
!
P
!
P
s
s
s
LIFESTYLE FORCE GURKHA HH Doors 3-5Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four/Rear Length 3992-4342mm Width 1790mm Height 2055mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 63 litres Kerb Weight NA XPlorer 3-door (Diesel) XPlorer 5-door (Diesel) Xpedition 5-door (Diesel)
9.88** 9.35** 8.19**
9.56** 9.13** 7.95**
You’ll like Off-road ability, tough character. You won’t Missing equipment, crude interiors. We say Capable off-roader let down by its crude interiors. Buy XPlorer 5-door 10.27** 11.90** 8.94**
9.71** 10.79 9.50
9.71** 10.30 8.98
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
85 85 85
— — —
E E E
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
JEEP WRANGLER UNLIMITED HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4583mm Width 1877mm Height 1829-1860mm Ground Clearance 238mm Boot 884-1980 Tank NA Kerb Weight 2119kg 2.8 4x4 (Diesel) 2.6 V6 4x4 (Petrol)
77.65 65.60
94.06 NA
You’ll like Sheer off-road ability, timeless looks. You won’t Gearbox, back seat, price. We say Extremely capable off the road but very expensive. Buy 4x4 NA NA
82.06 87.78
70.23 80.78
— —
— —
— —
— —
200 284
— —
F c/a L F c/a L
P P
Yes El/No Yes El/No
s!
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 107
MODEL BY MODEL LIFESTYLE TO LUXURY SUV SMALL
E/F c/a N O/P p
q
D/P D Y
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
MARUTI GYPSY HHH You’ll like Peppy engine, light weight, capable off the road. You won’t Unstable at speeds, lacks creature comforts. We say Only for serious mud-pluggers. Buy King
Doors 3 Seats 5/8 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4010mm Width 1540mm Height 1845-1875mm Ground Clearance 210mm Boot NA Tank 40 litres Kerb Weight 965-1000kg King ST (Petrol) King HT (Petrol)
7.00 7.16
7.60 7.77
7.02 7.18
7.22 7.39
7.69 7.86
18443 19032
— —
— —
11.3 11.3
83 16.39 83 16.39
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
No Ex No Ex
No — No Ex/No — No — No Ex/No —
— —
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
No Ex
No — No Ex/No —
—
P
—
2
D D
—
— q No Ex
Yes — Yes El/Yes —
—
E c/a L E c/a L
P P
— —
— —
— —
— —
— —
q Yes Ex q Yes Ex
No — No In/No — No — No In/No —
— —
E c/a L E c/a L
P P
— —
— —
— D — — D —
— —
No Re No Re
Yes — Yes El/No — Yes — Yes El/No —
— —
P P P P
p p p p
6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p
6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
q q q q
No No No No
Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
— — — — p
7 7 7 7 7
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D
Y — Y Y Y
q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
MAHINDRA THAR HHHH Doors 3 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 3920mm Width 1726mm Height 1930mm Ground Clearance 200mm Boot NA Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1750kg 4x4 CRDe (Diesel)
10.07
10.33
You’ll like Rugged appeal, off-roading ability, locking rear differential. You won’t Ergonomics, uncomfortable rear seats. We say Only for serious mud-pluggers. Buy 4X4 10.32
10.09
10.84
—
—
—
—
105 17.45
E
—
—
ISUZU D-MAX V-CROSS HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 5295mm Width 1860mm Height 1840mm Ground Clearance 225mm Boot NA Tank NA Kerb Weight 1905kg 4X4 M/T
13.30**
15.41
You’ll like Capable off-road, on road manners, comfy ride, torque-y engine. You won’t Ponderous in traffic, basic interior. We say As pick-ups in India go, it is the best value proposition. Buy 4X4 13.65**
13.50**
15.84
—
—
—
—
136
—
F c/a L
MAHINDRA GETAWAY HHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 5098mm Width 1770mm Height 1874mm Ground Clearance 210mm Boot 1540 x 780mm (Load width x load height) Tank 80 litres Kerb Weight 2050kg Getaway 2WD (Diesel) Getaway 4WD (Diesel)
8.61** 9.60**
11.09 11.33
You’ll like Off-road ability, robust build. You won’t Looks like a Scorpio, handling. We say A no-nonsense pick-up with genuine off-road ability. Buy 4x4
8.12** 9.12**
8.03** 9.02**
11.17 12.78
— —
9.1 9.1
11.4 11.4
— —
117 18.17 117 18.17
— —
TATA XENON XT HHH You’ll like Styling, rugged appeal. You won’t Rear seats, shallow bed. We say If you need the utility and like to do things in style. Buy 4x4
Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear/Four Length 5125mm Width 1860mm Height 1833mm Ground Clearance 200mm Boot NA Tank 65 litres Kerb Weight 1860-1990kg EX 4X2 (Diesel) EX 4X4 (Diesel)
11.37 12.95
12.12 13.36
11.49 12.65
12.36 13.61
11.41 12.69
30719 9.2 12.9 34175 9.2 12.9
— —
140 14.82 140 14.82
LUXURY SUV SMALL AUDI Q3 HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Front/Four Length 4388mm Width 1831mm Height 1608mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 460 Tank 64 litres Kerb Weight 1565-1630kg 30TFSI Premium (Petrol) 30TDI Premium (Diesel) 35TDI Premium Plus (Diesel) 35TDI Technology (Diesel)
38.99 43.11 44.62 48.16
40.56 42.67 46.23 50.97
You’ll like Smooth engines, equipment, SUV-like seating position. You won’t Not engaging to drive. pricey top variants We say Well-packaged SUV that's compact in size. Buy35 Premium Plus 38.25 39.63 42.91 47.28
40.62 42.22 42.22 50.38
41.68 43.25 46.98 51.96
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
150 150 184 184
— — — —
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
s
s
s
s
BMW X1 HHHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4439mm Width 1821mm Height 1612mm Ground Clearance 165mm Boot NA Tank 51 litres Kerb Weight 1550kg sDrive20i xLine (Petrol) sDrive20d Expedition (Diesel) sDrive20d xLine (Diesel) xDrive20d M Sport (Diesel)
42.26 38.81 43.36 50.65
You’ll like Strong engine, spacious cabin, well-designed, well-insulated. You won’t Hard plastics in the cabin, small front seats. We say Very different from the original but better in most ways. Buy xLine 42.72 38.82 43.43 50.83
39.13 34.89 39.13 45.93
44.05 38.25 42.94 50.32
41.45 40.28 45.07 52.73
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— 18.56 18.56 18.56
191 — 190 8.61 190 8.61 184 8.61
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
P P P P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
MERCEDES GLA-CLASS HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Rear Length 4417mm Width 1804mm Height 1494mm Ground Clearance 183mm Boot NA Tank 100 litres Kerb Weight 1525-1720kg GLA 200 Sport (Petrol) GLA 200 CDI Style (Diesel) GLA 200 CDI Sport (Diesel) GLA 220d 4Matic (Diesel) GLA 45 AMG (Petrol)
37.14 37.26 41.05 44.49 85.92
108 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
41.52 39.72 43.74 47.37 94.97
You’ll like Cabin quality, high ground clearance. You won’t Crashy ride, noisy engines, claustrophobic cabin. We say More practical than sporty, GLA diesel is a very likeable package. Buy 220d 4Matic 41.99 38.13 40.69 45.07 84.35
39.52 37.64 41.52 45.04 90.35
45.61 42.98 46.98 50.82 96.18
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— 17.9 17.9 — —
187 — 136 9.51 136 9.51 170 — 360 5.13
F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N
P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SUV MID-SIZE
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog s!
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
P
s
LUXURY SUV MID-SIZE LEXUS RX450HHHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4890mm Width 1895mm Height 1685mm Ground Clearance 195mm Boot NA Tank 65 litres Kerb Weight 2100-2210kg Luxury (Hybrid) F-Sport
107.29** 109.61**
You’ll like Stylish design, silent and efficient hybrid engine. You won’t Quality of interiors doesn't justify the price tag, limited cabin room. We say Stylish SUV that stands out in the crowd. Buy F-Sport NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
NA NA
— —
— —
— —
— —
262 262
— —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
p 10 D/P D Y p 10 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes — Yes El/Yes Yes — Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
p p p p
7 7 7 7
Y Y Y Y
q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
s
s
JAGUAR F-PACE HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4731mm Width 2175mm Height 1651mm Ground Clearance 213mm Boot 650 Tank 60-66 litres Kerb Weight 1775kg 2.0 Pure (Diesel) 2.0 Prestige (Diesel) 3.0 R-Sport (Diesel)
82.12 92.82 141.01
You’ll like Good road manners. You won’t Expensive to buy. We say First SUV from Jaguar looks and drives like one. Buy 2.0 Prestige 92.93 105.43 160.38
NA NA NA
84.97 96.54 147.28
85.59 93.01 127.53
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
180 180 300
— — —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
PORSCHE MACAN HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4699mm Width 1923mm Height 1624mm Ground Clearance 230mm Boot 500 Tank 60 litres Kerb Weight 1925kg Macan S Diesel Macan 2.0 Petrol Macan Turbo Petrol
108.61** NA 111.00**
106.62** 76.84** 108.98**
You’ll like Deft handling, quality interiors, ballistic petrol engine, all-terrain ability. You won’t Price. We say Incredible driver’s SUV. Buy Turbo petrol 111.59** NA 114.03**
NA NA NA
122.64 NA 136.13
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
244 6.70 252 — 400 4.6
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
s
MERCEDES GLC-CLASS HHHH You’ll like Capable and refined engines, comfortable seats, equipment list. You won’t Unsettled at high speeds. We say A good looking well-rounded SUV with great appeal. Buy 220d Sport
Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4656-4728mm Width 1890-2096mm Height 1587-1639mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 550 Tank 100 litres Kerb Weight 1855-1954kg GLC 220d Style (Diesel) GLC 220d Sport (Diesel) GLC 300 Sport (Petrol) GLC 43 Coupe (Petrol)
56.19 60.33 59.22 85.90
59.63 61.37 63.43 NA
63.98 63.98 64.21 NA
56.93 61.17 61.64 NA
59.25 63.66 64.15 NA
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
170 170 245 367
8.56 8.56 7.49 4.9
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
s
LAND ROVER DISCOVERY SPORT HHH You’ll like Refined engine, spacious cabin, 4WD is super. You won’t Outright performance is disappointing, cramped third row seats for adults. We say Capable SUV with a personality very distinct from its rivals. Buy SD4 HSE
Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4600mm Width 1894-2069mm Height 1724mm Ground Clearance 212mm Boot 65 Tank 64 litres Kerb Weight 2000kg TD4 S (Diesel) TD4 SE (Diesel) TD4 SE 5+2 (Diesel) TD4 HSE (Diesel) TD4 HSE 5+2 (Diesel) SD4 HSE Luxury (Diesel) SD4 HSE Luxury 5+2 (Diesel) Si4 HSE (Petrol)
55.91 56.71 63.68 66.20 66.65 64.66 76.87 65.62
60.96 68.45 67.33 68.60 73.07 77.55 79.71 74.56
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
59.14 65.50 67.37 68.64 70.51 77.86 79.73 77.86
62.09 68.70 70.71 71.84 73.84 81.75 85.74 NA
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — —
150 150 150 150 150 191 191 240
11.56 11.56 11.56 11.56 11.56 — — —
E F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P
— p p p p p p p
8 — D Y 8 — D Y 8 — D Y 8 — D Y 8 — D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/No El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
N N N N N N
P P P P P P
— p p p p p
7 7 7 7 7 7
q q q q q q
No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re
p
7 D/P D Y
s! s!
— — —
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
Yes — Yes Re/Yes Yes Yes Re/Yes Yes Yes El/Yes Yes Yes El/Yes Yes Yes El/Yes Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
Yes
s!
P
s
s
s
s
s
RANGE ROVER EVOQUE HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4656mm Width 1900mm Height 1635mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 575 Tank 57 litres Kerb Weight NA 2.0 Pure A/T (Diesel) 2.0 SE A/T (Diesel) 2.0 SE Dynamic A/T (Diesel) 2.0 HSE A/T (Diesel) 2.0 HSE Dynamic A/T (Diesel) 2.0 SE A/T (Petrol)
56.15 61.91 64.29 67.61 73.72 59.54
59.49 65.74 68.32 71.92 78.55 66.27
You’ll like Stylish looks, go-anywhere ability. You won’t A bit expensive to buy. We say In the market for a stylish SUV from the Range Rover family? Look no further. Buy HSE NA 62.67 NA 68.10 74.31 NA
60.39 67.72 NA 74.30 81.42 NA
NA 68.92 NA 75.02 82.02 NA
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
179 179 179 179 179 241
— — — — — —
F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y
s
s
s
s
s
s
TOYOTA LAND CRUISER PRADO HHH Doors 5 Seats 8 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4760mm Width 1880mm Height 1880mm Ground Clearance 220mm Boot 620 Tank 87 litres Kerb Weight 2140kg Prado (Diesel)
101.18
115.01
You’ll like Go anywhere ability, torquey engine. You won’t Dull driving experience. We say Right image backed-up by a diesel powered engine. Buy Prado 87.36**
114.60
110.32 224543 —
—
—
172
—
F c/a N P
q Yes Ex
Yes El/Yes
s
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 109
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SUV MID-SIZE TO LUXURY SUV PREMIUM
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Average kpl
Power hp
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Indian Driving Cycle*
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Highway
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
AUDI Q5 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4629mm Width 2089mm Height 1653mm Ground Clearance 201mm Boot 540/1560 Tank 75 litres Kerb Weight 1865kg 30TDI Premium (Diesel) 30TDI Premium Plus (Diesel) 30TDI Technology (Diesel)
58.04 61.64 66.16
62.70 66.59 71.49
You’ll like Performance, build quality. You won’t Uninvolving driving experience, excessive road and wind noise. We say Much improved and now a much better-rounded product. Buy Premium Plus 58.10 61.62 66.05
60.87 64.69 69.49
58.42 68.78 65.10
— — —
— — —
— — —
14.1 14.1 14.1
172 11.21 172 11.21 172 11.21
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
BMW X3 HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4648mm Width 1881mm Height 1661mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 550/1600 Tank 67 litres Kerb Weight 1715kg xDrive20d Expedition (Diesel) xDrive20d xLine (Diesel) xDrive25i xLine (Petrol)
57.96 62.63 63.36
You’ll like Great to drive, comfortable cabin, intuitive iDrive system. You won’t Dated interior styling. We say There is no denying that the new X3 is a clever piece of engineering. Buy xLine 58.28 63.01 64.35
52.78 57.13 59.36
57.75 62.48 64.90
60.49 65.40 67.92
— — —
— — —
— — —
18.56 190 9.28 18.56 190 9.28 13.77 245 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p 10 D/P D Y
q Yes Ex
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
6 D/P D Y
q Yes Ex
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6 8
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
VOLVO XC60 HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4644mm Width 1891mm Height 1713mm Ground Clearance 230mm Boot 495 Tank 70 litres Kerb Weight 1854-1912kg D4 Kinetic (Diesel) D4 Momentum (Diesel) D5 Inscription (Diesel)
53.06 57.05 61.14
You’ll like Superb seats, absorbent ride. You won’t Not as spacious as rivals. We say Grown up just a bit more. Buy D5 65.91 72.00 77.09
53.09 56.70 60.90
55.62 63.28 69.08
59.19 63.30 67.09
— — —
— — — — 9.0 12.2
— — —
183 — 183 — 218 9.90
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
s
LUXURY SUV PREMIUM LEXUS LX HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5080mm Width 1980mm Height 1865mm Ground Clearance 225 Boot NA Tank 93 litres Kerb Weight 2660-2840kg LX450d (Diesel)
275.00
You’ll like Road presence, technology, reliability You won’t Price, rear seat comfort, 5-seater only. We say Posh and more luxurious version of the Toyota LC200.. Buy LX450d.
NA
NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
254
—
F c/a L
P
s
MITSUBISHI MONTERO HHHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4900mm Width 1875mm Height 1900mm Ground Clearance 235mm Boot NA Tank 88 litres Kerb Weight 2335kg GLS 4X4 A/T (Diesel)
79.41
67.88**
You’ll like Abuse friendly construction, spacious cabin. You won’t Exorbitant price tag, quality of interiors. We say It gets a robust build quality, a longer equipment list, but it is just too expensive to purchase. Buy 4x4 GLS. 68.48**
81.54
86.36
—
—
—
—
192
—
F c/a L
P
p
s
JEEP GRAND CHEROKEE HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4828-4846mm Width 1943-1954mm Height 1749-1802mm Ground Clearance 206-210mm Boot 1025-1945 Tank NA Kerb Weight 2432-2458kg 4X4 Limited (Diesel) 4X4 Summit (Diesel) SRT (Petrol)
90.43 102.37 125.41
122.94 135.71 147.07
NA NA NA
You’ll like Performance, sturdy build, off-road ability. You won’t Fit and finish, price. We say A plush and rugged luxury SUV that can go anywhere. Buy SRT NA NA NA
NA 120.21 130.26
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
240 240 475
— — —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
s
s
s
AUDI Q7 HHHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5052mm Width 1968mm Height 1741mm Ground Clearance 215-245mm Boot 295/2075 Tank 72 litres Kerb Weight 2060kg 40TFSI Premium Plus (Petrol) 40TFSI Technology (Petrol) 45TDI Premium Plus (Diesel) 45TDI Premium Plus Nav (Diesel) 45TDI Technology (Diesel)
77.79 85.37 84.17 87.34 93.20
67.76** 74.43** 86.69 NA 96.01
You’ll like Performance, refinement, cabin quality, tech-loaded. You won’t Odd spare wheel positioning, rear styling, floaty ride. We say High-tech SUV that feels two generations ahead of the older Q7. Buy Technology NA NA 80.78 87.56 89.36
NA NA 90.46 93.04 98.70
90.74 99.56 89.70 NA 99.46
— — — — —
— — — — 8.3 12.5 8.3 12.5 8.3 12.5
— — — — —
252 — 252 — 245 6.95 245 6.95 245 6.95
F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N
P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
BMW X5 HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4880mm Width 1938-1985mm Height 1754-1762mm Ground Clearance 195-209mm Boot 570/1450 Tank 85 litres Kerb Weight 2350kg xDrive30d Expedition (Diesel) xDrive30d Design Pure (D) xDrive35i Design Pure (Petrol) xDrive30d Design Pure 5+2 (D) xDrive30d M Sport (D) X5 M (Petrol)
80.88 83.90 84.38 90.21 92.99 191.12
110 | OCTOBER 2017 WHATCAR?
86.37 86.75 85.79 90.16 92.95 162.00**
77.26 78.40 78.85 81.53 84.21 182.03
You’ll like Performance and handling, overall ride quality. You won’t Rear-seat thigh support. We say Fun and practicality put together. Buy 30d Design Pure 84.15 86.05 86.54 89.44 92.35 198.50
85.76 88.45 88.95 91.95 94.82 206.49
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
— — — — — —
15.3 259 7.05 15.3 259 7.05 — 306 — 15.3 259 7.05 15.3 259 7.05 — 575 4.22
F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N
P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SUV PREMIUM
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
MERCEDES GLS-CLASS HHHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5162mm Width 1982mm Height 1850mm Ground Clearance 307mm Boot 680/2300 Tank 100 litres Kerb Weight 2495kg GLS 400 (Petrol) GLS 350d (Diesel) GLS 63 AMG
93.26 95.75 207.78
100.60 102.28 183.03**
You’ll like Sheer road presence, very comfy third row, strong engine. You won’t Feels its size from behind the wheel. We say A proper seven seat luxury SUV. Buy 350 d 95.09 95.04 160.59**
97.41 97.41 250.52
101.61 101.61 225.85
— — —
— — —
— — —
— — —
333 — 258 8.21 585 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
p p p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
p p p p p p p p p p
6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
Yes Yes Yes Yes —
Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
s
s
s
BENTLEY BENTAYGA HHHH Doors 5 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 5140mm Width 2224mm Height 1742mm Ground Clearance 245mm Boot 590 Tank 85 litres Kerb Weight 2440kg 6.0 W12 5-Door A/T (Petrol)
385.00** 402.32**
You’ll like Performance, oppulance, ride quality. You won’t Price, design may divide opinion. We say Everything you’d expect a Bentley SUV to be. Buy W12 NA
NA
NA
—
—
—
—
600 4.1
F c/a N P
s
PORSCHE CAYENNE HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4846mm Width 2155mm Height 1705mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 540/1770 Tank 85-100 litres Kerb Weight 2100-2355kg Cayenne (Petrol) Cayenne (Diesel) Cayenne S (Petrol) Cayenne S (Diesel) Cayenne GTS (Petrol) Cayenne Turbo (Petrol) Cayenne Turbo S (Petrol)
NA 101.18** 123.84** 125.75** NA 185.89** NA
NA 99.32** 121.56** 123.44** NA 182.47** NA
You’ll like Goes like no other 4x4. You won’t Rear seats not as comfy as they should be. We say The fastest go-anywhere vehicle. Buy Turbo V8 for top performance, Cayenne V6 for value NA 103.95** 127.23** 129.19** NA 190.97** NA
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
NA 102.98** 126.04** 127.99** NA 189.19** NA
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
— — — — — — —
300 — 245 7.40 420 — 385 — 440 — 520 — 570 —
F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P
s! s! s! s! s! s!
— — — — — — —
LAND ROVER DISCOVERY HHH Doors 5 Seats 7 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4988mm Width 2220mm Height 1888mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 89/85 litres Kerb Weight 2718kg S (Diesel) SE (Diesel) HSE (Diesel) HSE Luxury (Diesel) First Edition (Diesel) S (Petrol) SE (Petrol) HSE (Petrol) HSE Luxury (Petrol) First Edition (Petrol)
78.37** 85.30** 85.30** 95.47** 103.00** 68.05** 71.15** 74.23** 78.91** 84.83**
100.91 109.66 115.01 123.44 131.26 87.87 91.79 95.67 101.59 108.55
You’ll like Go-anywhere ability, flexible seating for seven. You won’t Boxy styling, massive kerb weight, V6 diesel a little unenthusiastic. We say Great blend of comfort and off-road ability. Buy 3.0 V6 HSE NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
94.26 103.00 108.00 115.00 124.00 81.89 85.60 89.29 94.90 102.00
98.15 107.05 112.35 119.75 128.98 85.27 89.14 92.98 98.83 105.98
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — —
258 258 258 258 258 340 340 340 340 340
— — — — — — — — — —
F F F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
MERCEDES G-CLASS HHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4662mm Width 2007mm Height 1931mm Ground Clearance NA Boot NA Tank 96 litres Kerb Weight 2550kg G63 AMG (Petrol) G63 AMG Edition 463 (petrol)
236.59 250.88
244.90 221.19**
You’ll like Staggering performance, off-road ability, exclusivity. You won’t Stratospheric price, dated underpinnings. We say Sportscar performance coupled with great off-road capability. Buy G63 AMG
220.30 NA
242.86 250.05
259.13 263.52
— —
— —
— —
— —
572 5.42 572 5.42
F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p
6 D/P D Y 6 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re
p p p p
6 6 6 6
q q q q
s
s
MERCEDES GLE-CLASS HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4819-4891mm Width 1935-2003mm Height 1719-1796mm Ground Clearance NA Boot 651-2010 Tank 93 litres Kerb Weight 2150-2220kg GLE 400 (Petrol) GLE 250d (Diesel) GLE 350d (Diesel) GLE 450 AMG Coupe (Petrol)
84.26 74.46 86.12 104.73
90.95 79.72 92.05 86.40**
83.58 73.87 85.49 NA
You’ll like Overall refinement, comfortable ride. You won’t No seven seater option, not as sporty as rivals. We say New styling and more kit add much to the already well-rounded SUV. Buy GLE 250d
87.95 75.62 87.55 10.6.00
91.77 78.94 91.35 114.72
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
— — — —
333 — 207 — 258 7.64 367 5.71
F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N
P P P P
D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D
Y Y Y Y
Yes Yes Yes YES
Re Re Re RE
s
s
s
s
TOYOTA LAND CRUISER HHH Doors 5 Seats 8 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4950mm Width 1980mm Height 1910mm Ground Clearance 225mm Boot NA Tank 93 litres Kerb Weight 2720kg 200 Premium (Diesel)
151.74
164.34
You’ll like Road presence, off-road ability, luxury. You won’t Pricey, doesn’t have the sheer quality of its rivals. We say It’s a legend. Enough said. Buy 200 Premium
120.00
164.00
168.56
—
5.3
8.5
9.65 265 13.10
F c/a N P
p 10 D/P D Y
q Yes Ex
—
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 111
MODEL BY MODEL LUXURY SUV PREMIUM
E/F c/a N O/P p
D/P D Y
q
Electric stability prog
Parking sensor
ABS
Door mirror (Adjust/Electric retract)
Rear wash wipe
Rear defogger
Rear AC vents
Boot release Remote/ Electric/External/Internal
Split/folding seats
MP3 player
Alloy wheels
Traction control
Seats Height Adjust
Airbags
Leather Seats
Central locking/ Remote locking
Steering adjust (Tilt/Tele)
Electric windows R/F
AC/climate control
Power hp
Average kpl
EQUIPMENT cost options in blue
0-100 kph
Bengaluru
Chennai
Kolkata
Delhi
Mumbai
KEY TO VERDICT HHHHH Outstanding HHHHH Very good HHHHH Good HHHHH Reasonable HHHHH Poor
Highway
** indicates Ex-showroom price O indicates Optional * Indian Driving Cycle figures as per ARAI standards
Indian Driving Cycle*
PERFORMANCE
City
PRICE (ON-ROAD)
Annual Insurance (Rs)
MODEL DETAILS
s!
P
s
LAND ROVER RANGE ROVER SPORT HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4856mm Width 2073mm Height 1780mm Ground Clearance 227mm Boot 280/2558 Tank NA Kerb Weight 2335-2675kg 3.0 V6 S (Diesel) 3.0 V6 SE (Diesel) 3.0 V6 HSE (Diesel) 5.0 V8 SC Autobiography (Petrol) 5.0 V8 SC SVR (Petrol)
109.57 126.98 143.26 183.22 208.13
You’ll like Superb build, comfortable seats. You won’t Initial hesitation when you floor the throttle (3.0L). We say The new Range Rover Sport is an impressive car with a broad range of abilities. Buy 3.0 V6 SE
155.30 176.66 202.84 230.72 268.57
130.23 147.43 95.68 195.68 NA
146.43 166.35 190.99 220.24 256.35
166.22 199.11 NA 245.59 235.00**
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
— — — — —
292 — 292 — 292 — 510 — 551 5.23
F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N
P P P P P
p p p p p
8 8 8 8 8
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
p p p p p p p p p p p p
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P D/P
D D D D D D D D D D D D
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
q q q q q q q q q q q q
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re Re
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s!
P
s
s
s
s
s
LAND ROVER RANGE ROVER HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4999-5199mm Width 2034-2220mm Height 1835-1840mm Ground Clearance 225-296mm Boot 535 Tank NA Kerb Weight 2687-2717kg 3.0 TDV6 HSE (Diesel) 3.0 TDV6 Vogue (Diesel) 4.4 SDV8 Vogue SE (Diesel) 4.4 SDV8 Autobiography (Diesel) 5.0 V8 SV Autobiography (Petrol) 5.0 V8 Autobiography (Petrol) 3.0 TDV6 LWB Vogue (Diesel) 4.4 SDV8 LWB Vogue SE (Diesel) 4.4 SDV8 LWB Autobiography (D) 5.0 V8 LWB Autobiography (P) 4.4 SDV8 LWB Autobio. Black (D) 5.0 V8 LWB Autobio. Black (P)
210.55 201.83 240.49 302.45 325.07 250.85 207.80 252.07 258.58 324.77 456.92 461.72
226.92 277.06 265.23 316.47 NA 288.53 292.90 343.50 357.84 368.08 494.30 508.32
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
You’ll like Waftability, exceptional fit and finish, on- and off-road ability. You won’t Price. We say Everything a Range Rover stands for, only better. Buy 4.4 SDV8 Vogue SE 220.92 251.16 238.26 308.05 NA 317.33 240.22 311.64 299.65 304.93 311.64 320.51
NA NA NA NA NA NA 295.16 363.14 354.71 371.99 NA NA
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
— — — — — — — — — — — —
247 247 339 339 510 510 247 339 339 510 339 510
7.90 7.90 8.20 8.20 8.20 — 7.90 8.20 8.20 — 8.20 —
F F F F F F F F F F F F
c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a c/a
N N N N N N N N N N N N
P P P P P P P P P P P P
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
VOLVO XC90 HHHH Doors 5 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4950mm Width 1923mm Height 1776mm Ground Clearance 227-267mm Boot NA Tank 368/1868 litres Kerb Weight 2011kg D5 Momentum (Diesel) D5 Inscription (Diesel) T8 Excellence (Hybrid)
87.42 98.87 148.48
You’ll like Fresh design, quality interiors, smooth diesel. You won’t Slow witted gearbox, thumpy ride, no six-cylinder option. We say Fresh, modern and very alluring take on the luxury SUV. Buy Inscription
103.82 121.34 130.00**
82.79 96.60 127.50**
91.82 112.86 127.50**
93.96 108.44 173.88
— — —
9.1 9.1 —
13.1 13.1 —
— — —
228 9.14 228 9.14 407 —
F c/a N P F c/a N P F c/a N P
p p p
7 D/P D Y 7 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes — Yes El/Yes s
P
!
P
p p
8 D/P D Y 8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re q Yes Re
Yes Yes
Yes El/Yes Yes El/Yes
s!
P
s!
P
p
8 D/P D Y
q Yes Re
Yes
Yes El/Yes
s!
P
P
s
s
s
BMW X6 HHHH Doors 4 Seats 5 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4909mm Width 1989mm Height 1689-1702mm Ground Clearance 195-212mm Boot 580 Tank NA Kerb Weight 2180-2340kg xDrive40d M Sport (Diesel) X6 M (Petrol)
144.97 196.84
You’ll like Sports car handling and performance. You won’t Price, fuel economy, limited range. We say If you’re looking for a sports car and an SUV, then here’s both. Buy xDrive40d
120.00** 207.32
132.67 187.19
144.96 204.12
149.00 212.36
— —
— —
— —
— —
313 577
— —
F c/a N P F c/a N P
s
s
VOLVO V90 CROSS COUNTRY HHHH Doors 4 Seats 4 Engine/Drive Front/Four Length 4939mm Width 1879mm Height 1543mm Ground Clearance 210mm Boot 560 Tank 60 Kerb Weight 2440kg D5 Inscription
71.76
You’ll like Interior quality, diesel refinement, equipment. You won’t Stiff ride, station-wagon-styling. We say Practical, luxurious and an able off-road too. Buy Inscription
71.54
NA
72.01
75.50
SEPTEMBER 2017
AUGUST 2017
H INDIA’S BEST CAR BUYE
60
R’S GUIDE
H IND IA’S
| Volume 12 No. 1
August 2017 | Rs 100
NEW CARSFIRST
BES T CA R
JEEP RENEGADE
Annivers
I VERNA JAGUAR
NEW CAR SPECIAL BMW
XE DIESEL
NEW BMW X3
AUDI Q2
COMPARISON
Elantra bac
k to take on
2017 | Rs 80
the City
NEW MITSUBISHI PAJERO SPORT
Compared
TATA NEXON PETROL VS
530d COMPARISON
COMPARISON SPECIAL
Which compact luxury
BREZZA
Maruti Brezza e? Tata Nexon vs of style and substanc
FORD ECOSPOR T 1.5
TATA NEXON vs MARUTI
vs Audi Q3 New Mercedes GLASUV is better?
Who wins in the battle
| Volume 12 No. 2
September
NDAI
NEW HYUNDA
NEW MARUTI SWIFT
HONDA HR-V
IDE
V E R NA
z 123hpary petrol, 126hp issue diesel z From Rs 8–12 lakh z On sale now
SKODA KODIAQ
BU YE R’S GU
N EW H Y U
DRIVE your dealer won’t talk about. what’s Our complete guide to Fea coming and when 11 th ture-rich baby
Tata Nexon
—
—
—
—
235
—
F c/a N P
s
BUYING A CAR? TRUST INDIA'S BEST CAR BUYER'S GUIDE
Datsun Redig o 1.0 vs Rena Affordable hatchb ult Kwid acks go head
to head
petrol vs Ford EcoSport 1.5 new
Tata’s stylish
SUV takes on Jaguar XE the Ford PLUS INDIA’S E 220d The Audi A4 diesel vs Audi A4 BES BMW 520d vs Mercedes fights to keep fight for top honours T CARS We German luxury sedans pick the best its crown car in every segment p69 WC Sept 2017
Cover_2.ind
d 1
01-08-2017 04:40:53
WC August 2017 Cover
(gatefold)_NS_8.indd
1 8/31/2017
1:00:05 AM
WHATCAR? OCTOBER 2017 | 113
Trading up
A grand plan
Photography ashley baxter Words Siddhant Ghalla
The trade in 2015 Renault Kwid (12,000km) The trade up 2014 Hyundai Grand i10 (26,000km) The numbers The Kwid is valued at Rs 3 lakh and a further Rs 1.2 lakh was added to match the price of the Grand i10.
'The Grand i10 is more spacious and better equipped.'
What’s being traded in? The Kwid is Renault’s entrylevel hatchback that offers first-time buyers everything they want from a first car. It is light, easy to drive, spacious despite its compact dimensions and armed with a roomy boot, pliant ride and a segment-first touchscreen infotainment system. The Kwid shown here is a 2015, single-owner car in the top-spec RXT trim (with a driver-side airbag) that has covered approximately 12,000km. It has been maintained properly and only been serviced at authorised service stations. It is powered by a 799cc, three-cylinder petrol engine. At current market rates, this Kwid will fetch approximately Rs 3 lakh in the used car market.
spacious for passengers and luggage, its steering is easy and light, its SUV looks find appeal with many people and it has a great infotainment system. Plus, Renault has done a great job with the suspension set-up; it deals with our potholed roads with aplomb. However, the quality of its plastics is not premium and the driving experience is lacklustre: the 799cc engine, while adequate for city runs, feels out of its depth on longer drives.
Why the trade up? The Kwid is a great entry-level car in many respects. It is
What’s the best upgrade on offer? The Hyundai Grand i10 is a
114 | october 2017 whatcar?
small hatchback, two segments above the Kwid. Powered by a 1.2-litre petrol engine, the Grand i10 is peppy, a lot more refined, more spacious, especially in the rear, and gets more premium cabin materials. Its equipment list is also longer and gets alloy wheels, a rear wiper and electrically foldable outside mirrors. Moreover, it gets dual front airbags and ABS. The Grand i10 shown here is a 2014 model in the top-spec Asta trim. It is a single-owner model that has clocked about 26,000km. Like the Kwid, the Grand i10 too has been serviced at authorised service stations only. We were able to push down its asking price to Rs 4.2 lakh; that's a premium of just Rs 1.2 lakh over the Kwid. What do you need to look out for in a used Grand i10? When buying a used Grand i10, one must check the steering
Not ready to buy a new car? How about trading up to a used one?
rack, AC and electricals. A rattling noise while driving over bad roads is a sign of excess wear and tear in the steering rack assembly. A humming noise from the AC when the fan is at its lowest setting could indicate a faulty compressor. Finally, one should check if all power window switches, and light and indicator stalks work properly; several owners have reported problems with these.
says… trading up from a Kwid to a Grand i10 is a great idea for someone looking to move up from an entry-level car. the Grand i10 is a more premium car, characterised by better space, drivability, materials and equipment. with the price difference at about rs 1.2 lakh, this makes for a worthy trade-up indeed.
RNI No. MAHENG/2006/18641