Founded 1876 daily since 1892 online since 1998
Monday November 27, 2017 vol. CXLI no. 107
{ www.dailyprincetonian.com }
Receive elite degrees, but at what cost? U . A F FA I R S
By Marcia Brown head news editor
Princeton’s German Department accepts only about eight students each year to join its new graduate student cohort. These students are among the finest minds in the country, and the very best graduate programs heavily compete for each scholar. In the graduate school at large, only 38 percent of admitted graduate students in the 2014-2015 academic year were women. From the outside, the German Department hardly seems the first place to look for gender discrimination. By the numbers, Director of Graduate Studies Professor Devin Fore wrote in an email, women constitute around half of the German department’s graduate students, above the percentage at the University as a whole. When they arrive on campus, however, many women find that the department is not quite so equal, according to interviews with 25 current and former students, professors, and administrators in the department. Several women left the program last year, citing what they perceived as rampant genderbased discrimination. Those interviewed cited a pervasive academic culture that favors men to succeed, but puts obstacles in front of women. Even a student, not in the department, who told of her initial excitement to take a class in the German department, found herself the center of “demor-
alizing,” “humiliating,” and “belittling” behavior from the professor – behavior that was overt enough that two other students in the class confirmed it in interviews. While it’s not clear that all such instances are gender-based, they indicate a culture that enables such behavior toward many students. Nearly all of the female students interviewed said the culture of the department had led them to seek therapy. “We used to joke that the women in our department all went to therapy to deal with the men in our department,” said one former graduate student who was in the department in the 2000s. Still, those in charge say the department is ultimately a positive environment for women. “At the University, our department is in some ways a haven [for women], but that doesn’t mean there aren’t residues of this,” explained Professor Michael Jennings of alleged gender-based discrimination in the German Department. As current acting department chair and a former 13-year chair, Jennings expressed a past and present desire for continuous improvement. Several current and former graduate students interviewed cried as they recounted their experiences and shared documents and recordings with the ‘Prince.’ Many were granted anonymity because they feared retaliation. “It was a boys’ world and women were just allowed in,”
BEYOND THE BUBBLE
MARCIA BROWN :: HEAD NEWS EDITOR
Many University language departments are housed in East Pyne Hall.
said former graduate student Susan Bernofsky GS ‘98. Other former graduate students said they knew women who previously left the department citing gender-based discrimination. Many current and former graduate students, some of whom came forward independently and others who were contacted by the ‘Prince,’ felt that their experiences were validated after the ‘Prince’ published an account of an allegedly discriminatory German Department. Others even posted Facebook statuses detailing their experiences. These students often cited asymmetrical power relationships between students and faculty as part of the foundation of alleged gender-based discrimination and abuse. While not every professor was accused of alleged discrimination in interviews, students alleged that a “culture of permissiveness” pervaded the department even among faculty who weren’t active perpetrators. “Historically and still, women don’t have the same amount of power in the [a graduate] de-
partment and even when they do they’re led to believe they don’t,” said K.A. Amienne, speaking broadly about graduate departments. Amienne serves as a consultant who helps academics with their research and writing, especially women recovering from bullying, conflict, and abuse in academia. Among faculty, women often struggle to reach the pinnacle of academic success: tenured full professorship. In this, the German department at the University is hardly unique, as professors from other schools confirm. ‘You’d never think it would happen here’ Princeton’s German Department is known for some of the most progressive graduate classes in media theory and philosophy at the University. Many of its graduate students identify as progressive, and a few are even Marxists. Its undergraduates are treated to individualized attention and department-sponsored trips to Europe. Even its list of readings for graduate general exams, called an erudition list, includes several liberal authors.
Students interviewed for this article often characterize the department as progressive from the outside, especially in its intellectual teachings. Faculty connections allow students opportunities throughout the academic world that can’t be quantified. Nearly every former graduate student acknowledged the department’s prestige; several said that the Princeton name was extremely instrumental in helping them get a job. Beyond reputation, the numbers speak for themselves: the department has the best job placement rate in the country for men and women, a distinction it’s had for nearly a decade. Acting chair Jennings said Princeton and a few other universities compete for the best graduate students in the country. To convince them to attend the University, he tells them four things: the department is progressive and keeps “on the edge of the scholarly wave,” it is more critical than others and produces “real intellectuals,” it is serious about professionalizSee GERMAN page 4
U . A F FA I R S
U. promotes campus diversity through veteran matriculation
NEHA CHAUHAN :: CONTRIBUTOR
Visitors to Diagon Alley attraction show off PotterVerse attire.
First annual Diagon Alley in Newton, NJ, attracts ‘magical’ crowds contributor
On Saturday, 25,000 Harry Potter enthusiasts flooded Spring Street in Newton, N.J. — just about an hour from Princeton — to witness its transformation into Diagon Alley for the afternoon. Following the Newton’s annual holiday parade, four shops known as the Spring Circle Merchants became magical storefronts from the famous fictional series. The small town holds several community events
In Opinion
throughout the year, such as its spring parade. This was its first Harry Potterthemed event. Ryan Stapel is the owner of ReCollectables, one of the four shops involved. He came up with the idea for this Diagon Alley event as a way to support the local businesses, many of which are located on Spring Street. The event also fell on national Small Business Day. Stapel’s inspiration was the proximity of the 20th anniversary of the first book in the Harry Potter See DIAGON page 3
The Editorial Board weighs in on sexual misconduct at Princeton, and columnist Lou Chen writes on Senator Bob Menendez’s corruption scandal. PAGE 4
COURTESY OF TYLER EDDY
Members of Princeton Student Veterans Alliance take a photo decked out in residential college gear.
By Victor Hua contributor
Compared to recent graduating years, the Class of 2021 contains a much higher number of students who are veterans — a number which will only increase in the following years, explained Tyler Eddy ’21, a former U.S. Marine and current first-year student. According to Eddy, the potentially tough transition
to student life often makes the decision to apply to an elite university difficult for veterans. However, because of diversity efforts pursued by President Eisgruber, the number of veterans has increased in recent years. Veteran alumnus requests to see a greater influx of veterans in future classes have also been an important driver, Eddy said.
Today on Campus 7 p.m.: James Lawer will discuss the known physiological research on trance, the benefits of it, and the curious origins of the re-emergence in 1976 of pre-agricultural Ecstatic Trance Postures. Frist Campus Center 114
“As a former helicopter and airplane mechanic for the Marines, stationed in California, I wanted to major in astrophysics,” said Eddy. “But applying to an Ivy League institution isn’t something that is always particularly encouraged among veterans.” Eddy noted that the University has increased outreach to veterans, persuading more of See VETERANS page 2
WEATHER
By Neha Chauhan
HIGH
51˚
LOW
29˚
Sunny chance of rain:
0 percent