Vanguard Markets | Monday, October 13, 2014 | Issue 014
SPOTLIGHT
Online shopping mall king ! page VM6 Sim Shagaya, founder, Konga
PETROLEUM MARKETING
Femi Otedola, the new don of downstream
Inside Sogal Art Auction’s launch is an indicator of confidence in Nigeria’s secondary art market.
! Page VM6
Market whispers are in overdrive that Femi Otedola-controlled Forte Oil may emerge the winner of Oando’s downstream business, which is being shopped. If these turn out to be true it would place the billionaire businessman, written off only a few years ago as a faded fluke, at the pinnacle of refined products distribution with an unprecedented market dominance in Africa’s largest economy. 2014 Deal of the Year? HERE ARE BARELY eight weeks to go to the end of the year. This probably explains the race against time to seal deals before Christmas. Companies want to share good news of closed transactions and booked income with investors in their year-end reports. On the advisor side, bonus-dependent M&A bankers and fee-reliant lawyers are excited to be working on what will in all likelihood rank as the most important deal of the year (DOTY) if consummated. This deal is none other than the acquisition of the downstream operations of Oando by Forte Oil, a company controlled by Femi Otedola, CON, the billionaire businessman. Until it released a denial, Aiteo, a company owned by press-shy Benedict Peters, was rumoured to be bidding too.
T
The other DOTY contenders If not in value, which unverified sources peg in the region of $350 million, a Forte Oil – Oando deal would change the competitive DNA of the downstream petroleum sector. Its significance in terms of altering the dynamics of a single industry would be more impactful than the six major runners-up for 2014 Deal of the Year. It’s a family affair. Femi Otedola, chairman of Forte Oil, relaxes with his daughter, Florence, aka DJ Cuppy, on his 80 ft. yacht, Nana, named after his wife
! Page VM2
FOREX RATES
$/N
164.289
166.3 165.6 164.9 164.2 163.5 Fr
Mo
Tu
£/N
We
Th
Fr
265.615
265.8 265.1 264.4 263.7 263.0 Fr
Mo
Tu
Euro/N
We
Th
Fr
209.135
209.8 209.1 208.4 207.7 207.0 Fr
Mo
Tu
CNY/N
We
Th
Fr
26.806
27.2 26.9 26.6 26.3 26.0 Fr
Mo
Tu
We
Th
Currency
Central Rate
SWISS FRANC
172.637
YEN
1.5224
CFA
0.3194
WAUA
229.4455
RIYAL
43.7995
DANISH KRONE
28.0973
SDR
230.2668
Fr
FIXED INCOME & FOREX
Source: FMDQ
VM2
BUSINESS
VM | Monday, October 13, 2014 | Issue 014
PETROLEUM MARKETING
Femi Otedola, the new don of downstream W Continued from Page VM1 These are the $503 million that Qatar National Bank spent on gobbling Ecobank Transnational Inc. shares, the $493 million that Nedbank of South Africa doled out to raise its stake in the same pan-African financial institution, the creation of Lafarge Africa through the combination of Lafarge Wapco, its Nigerian operations and the company’s South African business in a deal estimated to be worth $1.35 billion, the purchase of OML 24 by Pan Ocean from Shell Nigeria, the successful bid for Shell’s OML 29 by the Aiteo/Taleveras consortium for the widely bandied possibly inflated figure of $2.58 billion, and the deal that will win the record for longest gestation period to completion, Oando Energy Resources’ acquisition of ConocoPhillips’ Nigerian assets for $1.5 billion. Distant contenders would be Skye Bank’s acquisition of Mainstreet Bank for an amount in the range of N120 billion, and Heritage Bank’s takeover of Enterprise Bank for N56 billion.
Beautiful bride of downstream Oando’s Downstream Division is one of the jewels in the crown that looks set for the pawn shop to pay down the shuddering debt load its parent company took on to finance the purchase of ConocoPhillips’ assets in Nigeria.
Grapevine News Network (GNN) Since an announcement was made by Forte Oil close to a month ago the market has been abuzz about the formidable pricing leverage it would endow it with over buyers, as well as the bargaining power vis-à-vis suppliers it would confer on Femi Otedola, its non-executive chairman and biggest shareholder. The company’s 2013 annual report lists his direct and indirect shareholding in the company at 615,201,955 shares or 57 per cent of total shares outstanding. At this stage, it is not known if Forte Oil’s move is for the entire chain of Oando subsidiaries operating in the downstream sector, that is, Oando Marketing, Oando Supply & Trading, and Oando Terminals, or if it covers Oando Marketing only. It is probable that the sale would involve only Oando Marketing because its FY 2013 and H1 2014 investor presentation lists the divestment of up to 49 per cent of the subsidiary or potential listing as its target before the end of the year. It is also unclear if the sale would cover those assets outside Nigeria since Oando has significant operations in the sub-region. A terse statement from Forte Oil released to the Nigerian Stock Exchange gave little away. It read that ‘Forte Oil Plc has begun initial discussions with a downstream company with the intention to acquire the assets of the
To me, it is funny when people say I was down. It is like when a child is trying to walk, the child must fall down, but it doesn’t mean that the child will never walk again. There is no successful businessman today that has not gone through the ups and downs. That is what prepares you for a future of success
said company.’ A standard caveat that ‘the proposed transaction is still in its infancy’ was included to tick all boxes. On its part, Oando has kept sealed lips.
– Femi Otedola, recent newspaper interview
FORTE OIL 2013 BUSINESS SEGMENTS’ RESULTS N ’000
Fuels
Production Chemicals
Lubricants and Greases
Power generation
Group Total
Revenue
117,679,188
2,843,433
5,825,781
1,679,342
128,027,744
Cost of Sales
109,074,484
2,208,283
3,634,162
483,209
115,400,138
Gross Profit
8,604,704
635,150
2,191,619
1,196,133
12,627,606
OANDO DOWNSTREAM DIVISION 2013 BUSINESS SEGMENTS’ RESULTS N ’000
Marketing
Supply & Trading
Sales
N ’000
N ’000
Within Nigeria
233,977,828
46,936,053
Other West African Countries
11,435,536
31,611,325
245,413,364
328,411,983
Other countries
328,411,983
Total Sales
FORTE OIL MARKET RANKING Market Position
Market Share
Product
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
PMS
1
2
3
4
6
20%
15%
13%
11%
17%
AGO
1
2
3
4
6
17%
12%
10%
6%
14%
DPK
1
2
3
4
2
17%
12%
10%
12%
35%
ATK
1
2
3
5
5
17%
12%
10%
9%
11%
Lubes
1
2
3
4
4
20%
15%
13%
12%
15%
Data visualisation by Publican Media
For a long time, Wale Tinubu has explained that the low margins in the downstream business had shrunk its appeal despite being the being the country’s biggest distributor of refined petroleum products with a 27 per cent market share. In an industry with many fringe players Oando has maintained its leadership position through investments in forecourt upgrades, branding, and supply chain efficiency.
Oando Marketing’s product range covers premium motor spirit (PMS), automotive gas oil (AGO, also known as diesel), dual purpose kerosene (DPK), aviation turbine kerosene(ATK), low pour fuel Oil (LPFO), lubricating oils and greases, insecticides, bitumen, and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) , also known as cooking gas) including the OGas brand. For 2014, its goal is to distribute up to 2 billion litres of products.
In recent years, Oando has increasingly turned its attention to its upstream business where it enjoys higher margins. It has declared that its ambition is to grow from 45,000 barrels of crude oil production per day as at August 2014 to 100,000 bpd by 2017. Oando’s upstream division has 6 oil mining licenses, operates 40 fields, and 146 wells in production. This is where it sees its future growth.
A Phoenix named Forte The suitor, Forte Oil, has come a long way since 2007. That was the year Femi Otedola’s Zenon Oil acquired a 28.7 per cent stake in African Petroleum, the predecessor company of Forte Oil, from the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) for $120 million. After a couple of turbulent years, including the loss of N200 billion from unhedged positions in oil imports, the Epe-born business man, who began his career as a printer, stabilised the business through a series of painful steps. Five years later his efforts started to yield fruit. In the process, he proved to critics that he is more than a subsidy payments arbitrageur and beneficiary of a favoured monopoly system instituted to enrich cronies under former president Olusegun Obasanjo. His survival of the trial by fire earned him the market’s respect. In 2010, African Petroleum was renamed as Forte Oil as a coded play on his F.O. initials. The company’s rebranding was launched two years later in 2012 by Brand Union, a South Africanbased brand design agency. At present, its distribution network covers over 500 petrol stations across Nigeria, storage depots in Lagos and Port Harcourt, and a 50,000 metric ton capacity lubricant blending plant capable of producing about 100 different grades of lubricating oil each year. Looking back at that difficult period, he says that he learned that ‘being a good entrepreneur doesn’t necessarily make you a good manager of a business.’ To cover up the managerial inadequacies he lacked, he invited experienced hands who ‘are hungry for success’ to join his team. Not satisfied, he surrendered control to an independent board that has instituted what he calls ‘one of the best if not the best corporate governance structures in Nigeria.’ Thus far, the results have won investors’ cheer. In May, MSCI, the global indexes creator, announced that it had added Forte Oil to its Frontier Market 100 index. At the start of July, the Nigerian Stock Exchange announced that it had added the company to its list of High Priced Stocks. According to the NSE’s criteria, ‘these are securities that have traded an average of N100 or more per share in four out of the last six months period.’ By a stroke of fate Akin Akinfemiwa, the group chief executive officer, spent 6 years
in his mid-career at Oando. From 2002 to 2003, he was the executive assistant to Mofe Boyo, the deputy managing director, and later, he became a products and derivatives trader at Oando Supply and Trading where he remained till 2009. Going by his background, if the deal does go through integrating Oando’s downstream interests into Forte Oil should be familiar territory for him.
The Conditionals There remain a number of hanging ifs over the deal. Some market watchers have conjectured that Femi Otedola may be going along for the ride for sinister purposes. Basically, they surmise that Forte Oil could have embarked on an intelligence gathering mission in the deal room. They also argue that Oando needs Forte Oil more than Forte Oil needs it. After all, how many players in this market have the credit to acquire a leviathan as vast as Oando’s business? Consider also that the rate at which Forte Oil is growing it does not need the boost from Oando’s downstream business to transform it. Organic growth seems to be working just fine. When all is said and done, a dispassionate observer could make a strong case that the Oando add-on is a good-to-have for Forte Oil, and not a need-to-have. This mindset will decide the price that Forte Oil will be willing to pay. And it is precisely on this last point that the deal would be determined. So far, no valuation details have been disclosed. There is also a governance ambiguity aspect involved if Oando is not selling majority control to Forte Oil. Finally, the overwhelming market dominance of the combined company could attract the attention of competition authorities who may demand proof that it will not stifle consumer choice and competitors. In the coming weeks, the markets will know for sure if these rumours are true. If the deal works to plan and Forte Oil emerges the winner, it will be a big garland for Femi Otedola, and an admission to the exclusive league of CEOs who have done multi-billion naira deals for Akin Akinfemiwa. If it does not work out, life should go on as normal for the company. For Oando, a successful sale to Forte Oil would deliver a needed fat cheque to keep its creditors happy. Conversely, a collapse of talks would deal a big blow at this time. The search for a new buyer would take time, and of this scarce commodity, Oando has precious little at its disposal. ;
MARKET DATA
VM | Monday, October 13, 2014 | Issue 014
VM3
TRADING UPDATE Declined Unchanged Advanced
SECTOR PRICE CHANGES – OCTOBER 2–10, 2014
MARKET REVIEW – OCTOBER 8–10, 2014 The market was closed for two days last week to celebrate of the Sallah festival. Over the 3 trading days, the All Share Index ↓1.6%, Banking Index ↓2.88%, Oil & Gas Index ↓2.27%, Insurance Index ↓1.79%, Insurance Index ↓0.56% all declined in value. The holidays impacted the trading tallies. Altogether, 9,861 deals ↓30.47% were done for 1,350,706,881 ↓47.81% shares, at N14,470,697,440.60 ↓41.88%. At the top of the gainer’s table were Ikeja Hotel ↑33.00%: ↑241.03%, Champion Breweries ↑27.37%: ↓6.98%, Conoil ↑10.23%: ↓23.72%, Learn Africa ↑9.09%: ↓26.90%, Cutix ↑5.00%: ↑6.18%, Livestock Feeds ↑3.01%: ↓28.37%, Fidson Healthcare ↑2.10%: ↑21.86%, Nigerian Breweries ↑1.89%: ↑7.21%, Eterna ↑1.60%: ↓15.74%, and Associated Bus Company ↑1.47%: ↓15.85. Featuring on the loser’s chart were A.G. Leventis ↓13.64%: ↓21.76%, UACN Property Development Co. ↓8.52%: ↓23.68%, Stanbic IBTC Holdings ↓8.49%: ↑50.02%, Zenith International Bank ↓6.17%: ↓16.79%, UBA Capital ↓5.96%: ↓28.65%, Oando ↓5.20%: ↑3.09%, Transnational Corporation ↓5.18%: ↑26.21%, International Energy Insurance Co. ↓5.08%: ↑3.70%, Premier Breweries ↓5.00%: ↑442.86%, and Mansard Insurance ↓4.83%: ↑12.65%, Legend: The figure before the colon ( : ) signifies the stock’s performance last week. The value behind the : symbol represents its year-to-date performance.
Agriculture Conglomerates Construction/Real Estate Consumer Goods Financial Services Healthcare ICT Industrial Goods Natural Resources Oil & Gas Services
3 1 3 8 19 4 1 2 0 4 6
2 4 6 15 35 4 9 15 5 4 9
0 0 0 8 3 2 1 4 0 3 3
DASHBOARD Friday Ticker
Change, Close % 7UP 162.86 0.00% ABCTRANS 0.69 0.00% ACCESS 8.77 -1.46% AGLEVENT 1.33 -5.00% AIICO 0.80 0.00% AIRSERVICE 1.91 0.00% ASHAKACEM 32.00 -0.06% BETAGLAS 19.01 0.00% CADBURY 54.52 0.04% CAP 39.00 0.36% CCNN 15.00 -0.13% CONOIL 52.00 0.35% CONTINSURE 1.00 0.00% COURTVILLE 0.53 1.92% CUSTODYINS 3.98 -0.50% CUTIX 1.98 4.76% DANGCEM 217.01 0.86% DANGFLOUR 6.23 -3.11% DANGSUGAR 8.10 -0.25% DIAMONDBNK 6.20 -0.80% ETERNA 3.80 -0.26% ETI 18.85 0.53% FBNH 12.91 -1.90% FCMB 4.30 -0.69% FIDELITYBK 2.02 0.50% FIDSON 3.33 0.00% FLOURMILL 62.16 0.26% FO 220.50 1.94% GLAXOSMITH 58.06 -4.03% GUARANTY 29.57 -0.64% GUINNESS 193.98 4.01% HONYFLOUR 3.83 -3.28% INTBREW 31.00 0.00% JBERGER 60.65 -5.00% LINKASSURE 0.50 0.00% MANSARD 2.76 0.00% MAYBAKER 1.83 5.17% MOBIL 174.00 -1.14% MRS 53.20 0.00% NAHCO 4.91 -1.80% NASCON 9.26 0.11% NB 180.00 -0.06% NEIMETH 1.05 0.00% NEM 0.77 -1.28% NESTLE 1,022.00 -0.78% NIGERINS 0.50 0.00% NNFM 22.90 OANDO 25.20 0.44% OKOMUOIL 33.00 0.00% PAINTCOM 1.68 PORTPAINT 5.23 0.00% PRESCO 35.36 -0.84% PRESTIGE 0.50 0.00% PZ 31.92 0.38% REDSTAREX 4.40 0.00% ROYALEX 0.57 0.00% RTBRISCOE 0.89 3.49% SEPLAT 610.00 -1.79% SKYEBANK 2.77 -2.81% SOVRENINS 0.50 0.00% STANBIC 32.02 -3.70% STERLNBANK 2.32 0.87% TOTAL 176.00 0.28% TRANSCORP 5.49 -3.68% UAC-PROP 14.50 -4.61% UACN 58.00 0.21% UBA 6.31 -3.22% UBCAP 2.05 -3.76% UBN 9.06 -0.33% UNILEVER 45.65 -1.62% UNITYBNK 0.50 0.00% VITAFOAM 4.27 -0.47% WAPCO 128.00 0.79% WAPIC 0.71 -2.74% WEMABANK 0.99 4.21% ZENITHBANK 22.80 -2.98%
5-day Volume 209 10,441 119,160 1,526 9,899 455 2,010 0 1,592 4,254 11,178 3,797 19,725 720 12,474 1,215 5,816 534 4,322 9,852 2,253 19,769 186,868 71,043 38,937 3,255 7,589 1,098 153 60,054 882 3,023 2,754 342 5 0 2,584 513 15 5,626 5,522 11,770 1,742 8,353 255 200 0 100,889 2,581 0 11 205 980 3,476 5,467 152 1,137 553 109,368 2 13,173 226,175 139 211,211 12,448 41,655 69,556 53,080 8,301 698 22,035 6,019 1,931 95,696 12,785 197,676
4-Week
Change, Change, Open Week Hi Week Lo Volume Open Volume % % 162.86 162.86 155.11 0.00% 1,971 147.73 10.24% 11,796 0.68 0.70 0.65 1.47% 68,079 0.70 -1.43% 199,624 9.01 9.24 8.70 -2.66% 517,704 9.59 -8.55% 2,276,227 1.40 1.47 1.33 -5.00% 2,351 1.45 -8.28% 34,181 0.80 0.81 0.80 0.00% 56,745 0.83 -3.61% 1,815,655 2.11 2.11 1.91 -9.48% 477 2.10 -9.05% 14,908 32.00 32.98 31.95 0.00% 14,468 32.14 -0.44% 129,147 20.00 20.00 19.01 -4.95% 157 18.85 0.85% 45,578 53.69 54.93 53.69 1.55% 6,232 52.41 4.03% 61,957 38.00 40.90 38.00 2.63% 5,676 39.95 -2.38% 35,511 15.73 15.87 14.82 -4.64% 23,446 14.50 3.45% 83,411 49.36 52.00 49.36 5.35% 6,568 55.00 -5.45% 24,826 1.00 1.02 0.97 0.00% 91,180 0.98 2.04% 224,094 0.54 0.54 0.51 -1.85% 5,970 0.53 0.00% 133,310 4.09 4.29 3.90 -2.69% 82,003 3.95 0.76% 166,537 1.90 1.98 1.75 4.21% 6,844 1.90 4.21% 59,435 218.98 220.80 215.00 -0.90% 14,240 215.00 0.93% 387,582 6.23 6.76 6.13 0.00% 1,785 6.80 -8.38% 21,292 8.16 8.49 8.10 -0.74% 35,412 8.50 -4.71% 340,678 6.25 6.27 6.19 -0.80% 325,408 6.30 -1.59% 4,443,562 3.74 3.89 3.65 1.60% 13,176 3.99 -4.76% 116,399 18.70 19.19 18.70 0.80% 286,548 19.32 -2.43% 21,491,450 13.48 13.52 12.74 -4.23% 433,315 14.52 -11.09% 3,706,710 4.51 4.64 4.12 -4.66% 168,238 4.15 3.61% 1,213,836 2.05 2.11 1.97 -1.46% 348,485 2.00 1.00% 1,364,392 3.35 3.52 3.33 -0.60% 16,665 3.50 -4.86% 127,178 61.98 64.45 61.23 0.29% 23,184 63.00 -1.33% 86,840 224.00 224.99 215.20 -1.56% 3,077 230.01 -4.13% 35,543 61.01 62.01 58.06 -4.84% 18,450 63.17 -8.09% 60,482 30.01 30.50 29.50 -1.47% 721,407 29.16 1.41% 3,356,332 188.98 195.70 185.20 2.65% 5,209 170.00 14.11% 78,853 4.00 4.10 3.83 -4.25% 17,085 4.06 -5.67% 166,368 31.05 31.47 30.00 -0.16% 11,432 28.90 7.27% 532,675 63.84 63.84 60.65 -5.00% 522 61.01 -0.59% 15,989 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00% 5 0.50 0.00% 1,821 2.89 3.04 2.76 -4.50% 3,140 2.50 10.40% 445,965 1.72 1.83 1.66 6.40% 18,631 1.38 32.61% 150,987 173.30 176.00 173.08 0.40% 2,346 180.10 -3.39% 10,261 53.20 53.20 53.20 0.00% 70 50.54 5.26% 1,114 4.98 5.20 4.91 -1.41% 11,446 5.11 -3.91% 186,783 9.00 9.74 9.00 2.89% 15,347 9.43 -1.80% 126,313 176.95 181.99 176.66 1.72% 55,881 177.19 1.59% 354,272 1.10 1.10 1.05 -4.55% 3,116 1.03 1.94% 63,182 0.79 0.80 0.77 -2.53% 23,503 0.76 1.32% 727,271 1,050.02 1,055.00 1,022.00 -2.67% 10,775 1,013.00 0.89% 35,239 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00% 205 0.50 0.00% 122,953 22.90 22.90 22.90 0.00% 4 20.91 9.52% 1,095 26.37 27.00 24.85 -4.44% 196,262 25.11 0.36% 1,316,830 33.01 34.00 33.00 -0.03% 4,606 33.50 -1.49% 49,710 1.68 1.68 1.68 0.00% 0 1.60 5.00% 1,253 5.23 5.23 5.23 0.00% 121 5.00 4.60% 24,783 38.50 38.50 35.36 -8.16% 4,353 37.00 -4.43% 20,042 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00% 1,110 0.50 0.00% 4,709 32.15 33.60 31.65 -0.72% 10,673 34.60 -7.75% 99,582 4.50 4.50 4.21 -2.22% 31,894 4.34 1.38% 166,845 0.59 0.59 0.57 -3.39% 913 0.58 -1.72% 41,502 0.85 0.89 0.84 4.71% 6,670 0.89 0.00% 35,317 639.99 640.00 610.00 -4.69% 2,178 655.26 -6.91% 84,150 2.88 3.16 2.73 -3.82% 730,648 2.87 -3.48% 6,502,964 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00% 7 0.50 0.00% 4,033 33.25 33.25 32.02 -3.70% 51,482 30.00 6.73% 189,679 2.26 2.35 2.20 2.65% 385,438 2.30 0.87% 1,218,167 183.97 183.97 173.05 -4.33% 1,574 180.10 -2.28% 7,591 5.79 5.81 5.43 -5.18% 1,153,224 6.05 -9.26% 4,893,388 15.81 16.64 14.44 -8.29% 15,517 15.18 -4.48% 42,996 58.00 58.00 57.00 0.00% 77,979 58.00 0.00% 220,524 6.66 6.84 6.31 -5.26% 382,694 7.19 -12.24% 2,340,946 2.18 2.20 2.05 -5.96% 113,191 2.02 1.49% 4,780,185 9.15 9.39 9.06 -0.98% 16,664 10.04 -9.76% 98,231 47.00 47.00 45.65 -2.87% 3,768 47.75 -4.40% 70,918 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00% 306,855 0.50 0.00% 1,085,090 4.11 4.29 4.10 3.89% 14,216 4.30 -0.70% 51,637 127.00 129.00 125.50 0.79% 5,123 119.70 6.93% 82,648 0.74 0.74 0.70 -4.05% 110,320 0.73 -2.74% 1,290,197 0.95 0.99 0.92 4.21% 66,824 0.91 8.79% 245,024 24.30 24.60 22.69 -6.17% 839,944 24.60 -7.32% 3,747,133
5-Week trading1
52-Week price range Low 68.00 0.65 7.22 1.25 0.74 1.91 13.87 11.85 49.90 35.96 8.00 30.24 0.93 0.50 1.62 1.59 185.00 6.13 8.00 5.86 2.48 12.40 11.50 3.01 1.85 1.91 58.10 50.40 58.06 22.67 162.00 2.80 19.94 59.18 0.50 1.96 1.33 111.01 32.63 4.56 8.85 140.00 0.79 0.55 950.00 0.50 18.00 10.40 32.15 1.33 4.00 34.00 0.50 30.08 4.01 0.50 0.84 590.00 2.57 0.50 19.00 2.09 146.26 1.62 12.80 42.58 6.31 1.24 8.00 42.50 0.50 3.87 95.01 0.66 0.85 19.50
Close ( )
High
YtD
162.86 128.00% 0.97 -11.74% 10.65 -8.65% 1.86 -18.40% 1.00 -13.04% 3.97 -42.99% 34.60 46.25% 22.10 31.74% 110.00 -43.90% 51.66 -18.72% 15.98 25.10% 79.80 -15.20% 1.29 -16.67% 0.89 -18.46% 4.30 82.57% 2.27 1.54% 250.02 0.39% 10.76 -39.10% 12.49 -28.32% 8.20 -17.33% 5.73 -19.66% 20.28 15.01% 17.29 -20.80% 4.64 11.98% 2.95 -25.19% 3.72 21.09% 83.64 -24.03% 259.94 137.43% 74.97 -17.06% 31.80 6.56% 262.00 -17.81% 4.50 -0.52% 31.50 9.46% 76.45 -3.84% 0.50 0.00% 3.15 10.40% 2.64 -28.24% 182.00 50.00% 70.00 2.86% 6.46 -22.68% 15.10 -37.64% 189.00 9.08% 2.08 -4.55% 0.97 -4.94% 1,250.01 -13.54% 0.54 0.00% 25.57 4.04% 36.89 -5.72% 45.99 -26.39% 2.23 -13.85% 6.25 -0.38% 49.00 -9.33% 0.81 -20.63% 41.46 -13.72% 5.35 3.53% 0.69 5.56% 1.49 -36.88% 735.00 0.86% 4.67 -38.58% 0.50 0.00% 35.00 43.33% 2.74 -7.20% 195.50 1.56% 7.08 26.50% 21.31 -5.70% 67.85 3.59% 9.60 -31.04% 3.04 -9.69% 10.89 -5.72% 64.00 -13.87% 0.69 0.00% 5.70 -11.23% 136.73 11.30% 1.48 -37.17% 1.40 -22.66% 27.40 -8.80%
PE
EPS
33.12
18.40
4.46 0.21 1.57 0.23 0.15 0.50 0.80 3.38 1.57 1.67 1.12 3.34 0.16 0.11 0.24 0.19 11.80
10.00 3.75 6.23 5.15 5.98 4.89 3.02 14.17 18.34 47.60 20.34 9.05 23.86 11.27 48.39 9.97 12.57 18.05 19.33 16.67 53.85 15.49 8.82 34.37
0.81 1.65 0.61 3.67 2.16 0.88 0.68 0.24 3.38 4.63 3.00 3.27 7.88 0.34 0.63 6.74 0.04 0.15 0.09 10.44 1.04 0.32 1.05 5.24
36.43 25.00
28.82 0.02
22.42 14.41 4.57 9.19 4.43 1.99 23.82 7.20 5.89
1.11 2.29 0.35 0.60 8.38 0.25 1.34 0.61 0.10
3.31 3.36 16.67 3.68 13.59 62.57 6.59 26.84 3.73 7.07 48.46 35.02 4.65 6.01
0.84 0.15 1.92 0.63 12.91 0.09 2.20 2.14 1.70 0.29 0.19 1.37 0.11 0.71
10.14
0.07
6.59
3.46
5.58 5.91 5.26 4.02 40.00 34.40 23.30 13.39 15.53 6.25 4.73 16.58
Liquidity Rating2
LEGEND 5-week trading bar: This bar shows the volume of the company’s shares traded during the 5 most recent weeks. Each alternate colour bar represents a consecutive week. The bar is to be read from left to right. The first bar on the left (light blue) represents the traded volume five weeks ago. The next bar (grey) represents the volume 4 weeks ago. The 5th and last bar (light blue) signifies the volume of shares exchanged last week. The purpose of the Weekly Trading bar is to give readers an instant view of trading volumes as they compare on a week-by-week basis. 1
Liquidity Rating: This indicates the level of demand for a company’s shares based on the number of deals rather than volume done over the past week. Stocks are graded according 5 categories. Blue spheres are used to represent liquidity. • Category 5: This is the highest liquidity rating shown by 5 blue spheres. Stocks that have traded more than 20 deals per day on at least 4 days in the past week are awarded this score • Category 4: This is shown by 4 blue spheres. It indicates that the stock has 2
traded between 12 to 19 deals per day on at least 4 days in the past week • Category 3: Shown with 3 spheres, this liquidity classification represents those stocks that have traded 8 to 11 deals per day on at least 4 days in the past week • Category 2: Shown with 2 spheres it identifies those stocks that traded 4 to 7 deals per day on at least 4 days in the past week • Category 1: This is shown by one blue sphere to represent stocks on which 3 deals and/or below were traded per day on at least 4 days in the week.
VM4
MARKET DATA
VM | Monday, October 13, 2014 | Issue 014
MARKET SNAPSHOT 3-MONTH PRICE TREND OF BELLWETHER STOCKS
ACCESS
8.77 0.24
7.22
PE 5.58
10.65 -0.83 -8.65%
YtD
3M
-1.03 -10.51%
-0.24 -2.66%
1W
02/10
July
August
CONTINSURE 0.93 YtD
September
T
-0.20 -16.67%
3M
PE 6.25 0.00 0.00%
1W
02/10
July
August
FCMB
September
T
0.46 11.98%
3M
0.15 3.61%
-0.21 -4.66%
1W
02/10
July
August
GUARANTY 22.67 YtD
September
T
1.82 6.56%
3M
PE 9.05 -0.44 -1.47%
1W
02/10
August
MANSARD
September
T
3M
0.17 6.56%
-0.13 -4.50%
1W
02/10
July
August
OANDO
September
T
-1.53 -5.72%
3M
-2.80 -10.00%
-1.17 -4.44%
1W
02/10
July
August
STANBIC
September
T
PE 16.67
35.00 9.68 43.33%
3M
4.97 18.37%
-1.23 -3.70%
1W
02/10
July
August
UBA
September
T
F
PE 3.74
9.60 -2.84 -31.04%
3M
-1.50 -19.21%
-0.35 -5.26%
1W
0.00 0.00%
02/10
July
August
DANGCEM
T
-11.42% 0.39%
3M
-27.99 -11.42%
-1.97 -0.90%
1W
02/10
July
August
FIDELITYBK 1.85 YtD
September
T
3M
PE 3.02 -0.03 -1.46%
1W
02/10
July
August
GUINNESS 162.00 YtD
September
T
3M
-6.02 -3.01%
5.00 2.65%
02/10
July
August
MOBIL
September
T
58.00 50.00%
3M
39.80 29.66%
0.70 0.40%
1W
02/10
July
August
OKOMUOIL 32.15 YtD
September
T
-11.83 -26.39%
3M
0.00 0.00%
-0.01 -0.03%
02/10
August
TOTAL
September
T
PE 13.59
195.50 2.70 1.56%
3M
1.02 0.58%
-7.97 -4.33%
1W
02/10
July
August
UNILEVER 42.50 YtD
F
September
T
-7.35 -13.87%
3M
F
45.65 1.35 PE 35.02
64.00 -5.85 -11.36%
-1.35 -2.87%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
DIAMONDBNK 5.86 YtD
T
-1.30 -17.33%
3M
PE 3.75 -0.05 -0.80%
1W
02/10
July
August
FLOURMILL 58.10 YtD
September
T
3M
-6.08 -8.90%
0.18 0.29%
02/10
July
August
HONYFLOUR 2.80 YtD
September
T
3M
-0.29 -7.04%
-0.17 -4.25%
02/10
July
August
NASCON
September
T
-5.59 -37.64%
3M
-2.24 -19.48%
0.26 2.89%
1W
02/10
July
August
PRESCO YtD
September
T
3M
-2.70 -7.09%
-3.14 -8.16%
1W
02/10
July
August
UACN
September
T
PE 26.84
67.85 2.01 3.59%
3M
-4.40 -7.05%
0.00 0.00%
1W
02/10
July
August
WAPCO
September
T
F
PE 0.00
136.73 13.00 11.30%
3M
16.99 15.30%
1.00 0.79%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
ETI 2.46 15.01%
1.35 7.71%
3M
0.15 0.80%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
FO
T
127.63 137.43%
0.00 0.00%
3M
-3.50 -1.56%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
INTBREW
T
2.68 9.46%
2.19 7.60%
3M
-0.05 -0.16%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
NB
T
14.99 9.08%
5.50 3.15%
3M
3.05 1.72%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
PZ
T
-5.08 -13.72%
-3.59 -10.11%
3M
-0.23 -0.72%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
T
PE 6.59
21.31 -2.80 -16.18%
3M
-1.31 -8.29%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
ZENITHBANK 19.50 YtD
T
3M
10/10
F W T
F
22.80 1.50 PE 6.59
27.40 -2.20 -8.80%
F
14.50 1.31
12.80 -0.88 -5.70%
10/10
F W T
August
September
FBNH YtD
02/10
September
T
10/10
F W T
F
02/10
July
August
September
T
10/10
F W T
F
02/10
July
August
September
T
-2.50 -9.88%
10/10
F W T
F
-1.50 -6.17%
1W
02/10
July
T
10/10
F W T
PE 5.98
17.29 -3.39 -20.80%
-3.23 -20.01%
3M
-0.57 -4.23%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
GLAXOSMITH
T
-8.44 -12.69%
3M
-2.95 -4.84%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
JBERGER
T
-7.25 -10.68%
3M
-3.19 -5.00%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
NESTLE
T
1250.01 -160.00 -13.54%
10/10
F W T
-108.00 -9.56%
3M
PE 36.43 -28.02 -2.67%
1W
02/10
July
August
September
SEPLAT
T
10/10
F W T
PE --
735.00 5.20 0.86%
-67.00 -9.90%
3M
-29.99 -4.69%
1W
02/10
July
F
610.00 29.99
590.00 YtD
F
1022.00 28.02
950.00 YtD
F
PE 9.97
76.45 -2.42 -3.84%
10/10
F W T
60.65 3.19
59.18 YtD
F
PE 20.34
74.97 -11.94 -17.06%
10/10
F W T
58.06 2.95
58.06 YtD
F
12.91 0.57
11.50
August
September
T
10/10
F W T
F
1. 52-week low price 2. Year low price 3. Current price 4. Year high price 5. 52-week high price 6. Current price 7. 5-day price change 8. PE ratio 9. 1-year price change 10. 3-months price change 11. 1-week price change 12. Daily price movement over 3 months. 13. 30-day moving average 14. Daily price movement over last week
1 2 TICKER
4
3
19.23 1YtD
5
25.23 0.018
August
September
T
10/10
F W T
F
PE 7.29
27.406 0.23 0.92%
3M
2.90 12.99%
7 0.01
1W
0.04%
10
12
August
-0.73 -4.64%
02/10
July
9
July
PE 13.39
1W
LEGEND
UAC-PROP YtD
F
PE 23.82
41.46
3.68 32.51%
3M
10/10
F W T
31.92 0.23
30.08 YtD
F
PE 34.37
189.00
3.01 25.10%
10/10
F W T
180.00 3.05
140.00 YtD
F
PE 48.39
31.50
YtD
15.98
10/10
F W T
31.00 0.05
19.94 YtD
F
PE 47.60
259.94
15.00 0.73
8.00
10/10
F W T
220.50 3.50
50.40 YtD
F
PE 5.15
20.28
CCNN
10/10
F W T
18.85 0.15
12.40 YtD
T
10/10
F W T
128.00 1.00
95.01 YtD
F
1.00 2.63%
1W
10/10
F W T
58.00 0.00
42.58 YtD
F
PE 4.43
49.00
-0.10 -0.26%
3M
10/10
F W T
35.36 3.14
34.00 -3.64 -9.33%
F
PE 8.82
15.10
-8.98 -18.72%
10/10
F W T
9.26 0.26
8.85 YtD
F
PE 11.27 1W
YtD
PE 23.30
51.66
10/10
F W T
3.83 0.17 4.50
-0.02 -0.52%
F
PE 18.34
1W
39.00 1.00
35.96
10/10
F W T
62.16 0.18 83.64
-19.66 -24.03%
F
6.20 0.05 -0.05 -0.80%
CAP
10/10
F W T
8.20
10/10
F W T
0.83 1.55%
1W
10/10
F W T
176.00 7.97
146.26 YtD
F
PE 14.42
1W
-17.63 -24.44%
3M
10/10
F W T
33.00 0.01 45.99
July
F
PE 16.67
182.00
-42.66 -43.90%
10/10
F W T
174.00 0.70
111.01 YtD
F
PE 23.86
1W
YtD
PE 34.40
110.00
10/10
F W T
193.98 5.00 262.00
-42.03 -17.81%
F
2.02 0.03 0.03 1.51%
54.52 0.83
49.90
10/10
F W T
2.95 -0.68 -25.19%
F
PE 18.40
250.02
CADBURY
10/10
F W T
217.01 1.97
185.00 YtD
September
10/10
F W T
6.31 0.35
6.31 YtD
F
PE 40.00
1W
10/10
F W T
32.02 1.23
19.00 YtD
F
PE 22.42
36.89
0.92 2.96%
10/10
F W T
25.20 1.17
10.40 YtD
F
PE 18.05
3.15
3M
10/10
F W T
2.76 0.13
1.96 0.26 10.40%
F
29.57 0.44 -0.43 -1.43%
10.12 46.25%
10/10
F W T
31.80
July
YtD
F
PE 4.89
4.64
YtD
32.00 0.00 34.60
10/10
F W T
4.30 0.21
3.01 YtD
F
1.00 0.00 -0.18 -15.25%
13.87
10/10
F W T
1.29
ASHAKACEM
11 14
13 May
21/07
June
July
25/07
M T W T
F
MARKET DATA
VM | Monday, October 13, 2014 | Issue 014
VM5
MARKET SNAPSHOT +140% SLIPPING +130%
LEADING
11 21
Bubble size = Market Cap
+120% +110% +100% +90% +80% YEAR-TO-DATE RETURN
+70%
# TICKER
WTD
YTD
1 DANGCEM
-0.90
0.39
2 NB
1.72
9.08
3 GUARANTY
-1.47
6.56
4 NESTLE
-2.67 -13.54
5 ZENITHBANK
-6.17 -8.80
6 FBNH
-4.23 -20.80
7 WAPCO
0.79 11.30
8 STANBIC
-3.70 43.33
9 ETI
0.80 15.01
+60%
10 GUINNESS
2.65 -17.81
+50%
11 FO
-1.56 137.43
12 OANDO
-4.44 -5.72
13 TRANSCORP
-5.18 26.50
14 UBA
-5.26 -31.04
15 ACCESS
-2.66 -8.65
16 UNILEVER
-2.87 -13.87
17 FLOURMILL
0.29 -24.03
18 UBN
-0.98 -5.72
19 PZ
-0.72 -13.72
20 UACN
0.00
21 7UP
0.00 128.00
22 CADBURY
1.55 -43.90
23 INTBREW
-0.16
24 DANGSUGAR
-0.74 -28.32
25 DIAMONDBNK
-0.80 -17.33
26 FCMB
-4.66 11.98
27 JBERGER
-5.00 -3.84
28 ASHAKACEM
0.00 46.25
288
8
+40% +30%
29
13
+20%
9
26
+10%
23
3 30
0%
27 36
-10%
1
40
12
5
-20%
33
25
6
-30%
2
18
15 16 4
32
7
20
31
19 38 37 17
24
14
35
10
39
34
-40%
22
-50% LAGGING -10%
Indices
-5%
YtD, %
ASI
-1.60% -0.32%
NSE30
-1.65% -0.52%
NSEBNK
-2.88% -1.55%
NSEINS
-1.79% -0.31%
NSECNSMRGDS
0.37% -0.02%
WtD, %
0% WEEK-TO-DATE RETURN TRADING BREAKDOWN BY SECTOR
DtD, %
Sector -2.14%
%
Financial Services
50 \ 73
Natural Resources
39 \ 8
Services
5\5
Others
6 \ 14
-3.28%
-7.12%
FGN Bond Index 3120
-4.66%
-7.37%
-2.27%
NSEOILGAS -0.03%
32.66%
-0.69%
NSELOTUSISLM 0.22%
-6.48%
-0.56%
NSEINDUSTR 0.70%
13.0
Market Value YTD Return
3090
12.5
3060
12.0
3030
11.5
6.96%
-8% -6% -4% -2% 0%
2%
4%
3000 11.0 20/10 08/10 10/10
7%
IMPROVING 10%
5%
GLOBAL INTEREST RATES & INFLATION TARGETS Central Last Date % Inflation Rate Bank Change Change Target China 6.00% 05.07.2012 -0.31 4.00% Japan 0-0.10% 05.10.2010 -0.20 2.00% UK 0.50% 05.03.2009 -0.50 2.00% USA 0-0.25% 16.12.2008 -0.1 2.00% Eurozone 0.05% 04.09.2014 -0.10 <2.00% Brazil 11.00% 02.04.201 +0.25 4.5% +/-2.0% Canada 1.00% 20.07.2010 +0.25 2.0% +/-1.0% Egypt -0.50 8.25% 05.12.2013 India 8.00% 28.01.2014 +0.25 Indonesia 7.50% 12.11.2013 +0.25 4.5% +/-1.0% Malaysia 3.25% 10.06.2014 +0.25 Mexico 3.00% 06.06.2014 -0.50 3.00% +/-1.0% Morocco 3.00% 28.03.2012 -0.25 Nigeria 12.00% 10.10.2011 +2.75 6.00% - 9.00% Qatar 4.50% 10.08.2011 -0.50 Russia 8.00% 28.07.2014 +0.50 5%* Thailand 2.00% 12.03.2014 -0.25 0.5% - 3.0% Turkey 8.75% 24.06.2014 -0.75 5.00% * +/- 1.5 pct point uncertainty band
Date
Deals
Turnover Volume
Turnover Value
Traded Stocks
Advanced Stocks
Declined Stocks
Unchanged Stocks
All Shares Index Value
1
08.10.14
4,567
408,897,218
5,717,087,626.40
105 \ 105
20 \ 24
26 \ 27
59 \ 54
40,995.02
2
09.10.14
4,894
698,841,661
6,068,835,834.99
110 \ 106
18 \ 30
35 \ 23
57 \ 53
40,572.25
3
10.10.14
4,967
242,968,002
2,684,773,979.21
112 \ 104
15 \ 29
30 \ 25
67 \ 50
40,444.39
0.40 50.00
30 TOTAL
-4.33
31 FIDELITYBK
-1.46 -25.19
32 GLAXOSMITH
-4.84 -17.06 2.65
34 SKYEBANK
-3.82 -38.58 5.35 -15.20
36 PRESCO
-8.16 -9.33
37 OKOMUOIL
-0.03 -26.39
38 CAP
2.63 -18.72
39 MAYBAKER
6.40 -28.24
40 NEIMETH
-4.55 -4.55
NSEASI
40,444.39
41,40 41,15 40,90 40,65 40,40 Th
Fr
S&P 500
Week Close
Change
WtD
MtD
QtD
YtD
1
All Shares Index
41,103.94
40,444.39
-659.55
-1.6
-1.86
-1.86
-2.14
2
NSE 30 Index
1,875.63
1,844.59
-31.04
-1.65
-2
-2
-3.28
3
NSE Banking Index
428.29
415.96
-12.33
-2.88
-2.16
-2.16
-7.12
4
NSE Insurance Index
148.40
145.75
-2.65
-1.79
-2.31
-2.31
-4.66
5
NSE Consumer Goods Index
1,015.47
1,019.20
3.73
0.37
-1.28
-1.28
-7.37
6
NSE Oil/Gas Index
461.33
450.87
-10.46
-2.27
-2.16
-2.16
32.66
7
NSE Lotus Islamic Index
2,696.03
2,677.45
-18.58
-0.69
-1.78
-1.78
-6.48
8
NSE Industrial Index
2,739.15
2,723.85
-15.3
-0.56
-0.47
-0.47
6.96
We
Th
Fr
1,906.13
1,980 1,960 1,940 1,920 1,900 Mo
Tu
FTSE 100 Week Opening
-7.20
35 CONOIL
Fr
Index
1.56
33 STERLNBANK
The \ arrow signifies week-on-week change in value. This week’s value is shown on the left of the \ sign, and last week’s value on the right.
INDEX PERFORMANCE
9.46
29 MOBIL
We
MARKET SNAPSHOT
3.59
We
Th
Fr
6,339.97
6,570 6,510 6,450 6,390 6,330 Fr
Mo
Tu
JSE FTSE
We
Th
Fr
47,092.24
49,20 48,65 48,10 47,55 47,00 Fr
Mo
Tu
We
Th
Fr
VM6
ARENA
VM | Monday, October 13, 2014 | Issue 014
ART AS AN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT
Sogal Art Auction berths in Lagos
Oliver Enwonwu is the director of leading Lagos gallery, Omenka and president of the Society of Nigerian Artists. oliver@omenkamagazine.com
HE STAGE IS SET for the entry of Sogal, the newest auction house in the growing secondary art market in Nigeria. On October 20, 2014, Sogal established by leading Lagos art dealer, Rahman Akar, proprietor of Signature Gallery, will premiere at the Porsche Centre in Lagos. Focusing on modern and contemporary art, the auction will feature 151 lots by 118 select artists from 11 countries across Africa, Europe, and Asia. Prominent
T
names include iconic Spanish surrealist, Salvador Dali, Senegalese Soly Cisse, and celebrated Ghanaians Ablade Glover, El Anatsui, Edmond Tetteh, Kofi Agorsor, and Amon Kotei, as well as major Nigerian artists, Justus Akeredolu, Bruce Onobrakpeya, Ben Osawe, Kolade Oshinowo, and Dele Jegede. Among the new entrants into the Lagos auction scene are Iraqi Salam Omar, Zimbabwean Berry Bickle, Ivorien Gensin, and Sabhan Adam from Syria. Others are Nigerian artists Bolaji Akingbade, G. Okojie, Akhile Ehitor, Osuchukwu Stephen, Chijoke Nwoga, and Jumoke Sanwo whose works, II Edition of 2, and A Thousand Brown Roofs are interestingly the only photographs in the auction. In a recent interview with Luciano Uzuegbu of Omenka magazine, Akar explains that Solgal is Lagos spelt in reverse and that he was inspired to establish an auction house because he was uncomfortable with the manner in which existing ones were run in Lagos particularly with regard to the
poor selection of artworks. Arguably, the history of organized auction sales began in Nigeria with, Before the Hammer Falls, held by Nimbus Gallery in December, 1999 at the MUSON Centre in Lagos, where N1.7 million ($10,600) was achieved for The Palm Wine Drinkards, a 1965 painting by Bruce Onobrakpeya. Since then, more auction houses have appeared on the Lagos scene, recording significant growth with impressive sales. Arthouse Contemporary founded in 2007 by Kavita Chellaram, holds the alltime record for artwork sold in Nigeria at N30.8 million ($192,500) for the smaller version of celebrated artist, Ben Enwonwu’s iconic Anyanwu. Chellaram asserts she started Arthouse Contemporary to establish reliable pricing mechanisms for Nigerian art. Founded by lawyer, Bolanle Austin-Peters in 2004, Terra Kulture is a private initiative established to promote the richness and diversity of Nigerian visual art and culture. It also boasts of a regular gal-
Salvador Dali, Elephant in Space, Bronze and plexi, glass, 94x46cm, est. between N12,900,000- 16,125,000 ($75,000 - $93,750)
lery, where artists are exhibited and their works consigned for sale. Terra Kulture successfully set-up its first auction in 2009 to commemorate the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting. A year later, it collaborated with Nimbus Gallery for an expectedly broader impact. After staging a first solo auction in 2011. Terra Kulture again partnered with Mydrim Gallery on an auction in Abuja. The auction recorded a princely sum of N27,605,000 ($172,134) in sales (from a selection of Nigerian and Ghanaian artists) representing a success rate of over 65%. A collaboration christened the Lagos Art Auction between these 2 galleries followed in April 2012, recording over 57% in sales. Nike Art Gallery and Tribes Art Gallery have also held auctions in Lagos. With an emphasis on quality, the entry of Sogal into the Lagos auction scene will no doubt contribute to the growth of the domestic secondary art market, and consequently an increased appreciation of Nigerian and indeed African art on the international art market. ;
SPOTLIGHT
Sim Shagaya, Founder at Konga, Serial entrepreneur
Sim Shagaya
IMDUL SHAGAYA, Sim for short, wears his military background with ease. The way he walks and talks gives the impression of a man used to exercising quiet authority from an early age. He is an ex-Boy, a venerable title jealously reserved for former students of the 60-year old Nigerian Military School, Zaria. After passing out, Sim spent two years doing ‘unit work’ as a noncommissioned officer in the Nigerian Army. Associates attribute his famed discipline, and obsessive attention to detail, necessary qualities to thrive in Nigeria’s start-up-unfriendly
S
environment, to his military precedents. Sim left Nigeria’s shores in the early nineties for his university education. He studied electrical engineering at the George Washington University, Washington D.C. After his bachelor’s program, he went straight on to earn a Master of Engineering Management (MEM) degree at Dartmouth College’s Thayer School of Engineering. He capped his academic sojourn in America with an MBA from Harvard Business School. Over a 16-year career, Sim has garnered a diversified portfolio of experience. Indeed, it reads like a Nigerian version of Forrest Gump, the unwitting character who manages to be at all the right places at the right time. The only difference is that Sim’s towering I.Q. leaves no one in doubt. At Rand Merchant Bank, he was part of the team that arranged financing worth several million dollars for V-Mobile (now Airtel), Conoil, and LCC Toll Road. In January, 2006 he moved on from there to serve as the local guide – Sherpa – to Google when the Internet and search
Published by
giant was making its foray into Africa. His restless energy and keen feel for the next bounce of the ball led him to start DealDey.com, an early online shopping and deal site. It was a short step from there to Konga. com, his current perch. Asked about his future career plans,
Sim has memorized three simple truths for survival: start lean, watch your expenses carefully, and prioritize wisely. he responds with three words: ‘Konga for life.’ It has not all been success along the way. Sim has had his fair share of hiccups too. Alarena, which has since been renamed Lovebase.com, a dating site he founded, is yet to turn cash flow positive. Another venture, JobClan, a job postings portal, did not catch fire with potential employers and job seekers either. One other attempt called Gbogbo, a classified ads site, did not go anywhere. A serial entrepreneur, Sim tried his hands at
EDITOR: MIDENO BAYAGBON GROUP BUSINESS EDITOR: OMOH GABRIEL
In Association With
content streaming with iNollywood. That too did not get much traction. This is not to discard his valid achievements. iNollywood was the first to get online licensing rights for the Nigerian Television Authority’s catalogue of classic soaps including New Masquerade, Vil-
CONTENT DIRECTION: OBIORA TABANSI ONYEASO DESIGN & ILLUSTRATION: PUBLICAN MEDIA
lage Headmaster, and Samanja. Through all of this Sim learned his lessons, cut his losses and moved on. He is not one to embark on quixotic missions. He knows when to call it a day in a struggling business. This could be due to his training in the military that has a place for orderly tactical retreats. He would live to fight another day. Varied as his career has been, there is a thread that runs through it linking up analytics, consulting, finance, engineering, and marketing to prepare him for his current position.
That common twine is called problem solving. Sim recognized the opportunity for online shopping sites in Nigeria years ago. A growing middle class, spreading internet usage, online payments system adoption, and other factors made the previously impossible comes within reach of the bold and daring. He took his chance. This time it clicked. The company’s record and outlook convinced investors to pump in $25 million in January. Last week, Techcabal.com reported that the company has raised a fresh round of capital estimated at between $40 million to 60 million. The money will be used to beef up its engineering team, improve its mobile applications and user interface experience, expand the retail inventory, and ramp up its logistics and fulfilment infrastructure. But challenges remain for the industry he plays in. Sim laments that the local tech start-up scene’s take-off has been stymied by a dearth of technical skill. It is hard to find good engineers conversant with the latest web technologies, and
Vanguard Markets features unbiased, in-depth coverage of corporate and market developments across a wide range of business sectors. Every week, Vanguard Markets delivers essential business analysis and commentary on Nigerian companies, regional economies, and global markets. Vanguard Markets is published by Vanguard Media Limited in association with Customs Street Advisors Limited, a specialist communications consultancy.
when they turn up the have a high rate of turnover quickly going in search of more attractive pay packets. Then there is the difficulty of convincing users to pay for services. Advertisers retain their focus on print as opposed to online advertising, draining valuable revenues from web entrepreneurs. For online shopping sites like his, the cost of logistics can push operators without deep and long-term capital out of business. Funding is a big obstacle for founders of these companies. There exists no structured funding channels to support these companies. They must rely on friends and family to support them stifling their growth. Along the roller coaster ride of building Konga to its enviable position, Sim has memorized three simple truths for survival: start lean, watch your expenses carefully, and prioritize wisely. He should have said ‘dream big, but watch the P&L’ if you want to build a successful company. Follow Sim’s simple steps to success and you stand a good chance of hitting it big. ;
Vanguard Media Limited, Vanguard Avenue, Kirikiri Canal, P.M.B.1007, Apapa. Website: www.vanguardngr.com ISSN 0794-652X