Skip to main content

Cambridge IGCSE® English as a Second Language Teacher Guide Preview

Page 1

Chapter 16

Answering long writing questions

Assessment objectives W1 Communicate information/ideas/opinions clearly, accurately and effectively W2 Organise ideas into coherent paragraphs using a range of appropriate linking devices W3 Use a range of grammatical structures and vocabulary accurately and effectively W4 Show control of punctuation and spelling W5 Use appropriate register and style/format for the given purpose and audience

Question types • Long writing questions

Differentiated learning outcomes

Resources

•

•

• •

Lower: All students should present some straightforward information and opinions; they should use simple structures in their writing, display a basic range of vocabulary and punctuation, and tend to use the same tone and style regardless of reader and purpose. Mid: Most students should present information and opinions clearly; they should use some different structures to give variety to their writing, display a fair range of vocabulary and punctuation with some accuracy, and sometimes adapt tone and style to reader or purpose.

• •

Student Book: Chapter 16, pp. 268–81 Chapter 19, pp. 307–8 Worksheet: 16.1–16.4 Workbook: Section 2, pp. 34–64 Section 3, pp. 65–89

High: Some students should present detailed information effectively and write persuasive arguments; they should use a wide variety of structures and vocabulary to good effect, use punctuation accurately and to clarify meaning, and effectively adapt tone and style to reader and purpose.

Exploring the questions Clarify for the class that both Core-level and Extended-level students will write about the same topics. They are marked differently, with up to 12 marks available to Corelevel students, and up to 16 marks for Extended-level students. This is because Grades A and B (marks 13 to 16) are not available to Core-level students. This will be clearer when they come to look at the marking guidance later on. The other difference is that the Core-level students have a recommended length of 100 to 150 words; Extended-level students are expected to write slightly more, i.e. 150 to 200 words. If students have practice in writing these essays in a timed situation, this will help them to learn how to pace themselves. Point out that writing much more than the recommended amount could be counter-productive. There may not be enough time to write even the minimum amount for the next question. Also, as the piece is be marked for the quality of the writing, a much longer piece could create a sense of long-windedness. Remind the students that they must leave at least five minutes at the end for checking their work.

To help explain what is involved in a writing question, and to assist students in deciding on a plan of action. Chapter 16 takes two sample writing tasks as examples and explores them thoroughly, step by step.

© HarperCollinsPublishers 2017

141

Chapter 16

Explain that usually the first task is less formal and requires the student to explain or describe something or to give an account of an event. The second task is often more formal in nature and requires the student to argue points for and against a topic, or to argue persuasively in favour of or against a viewpoint.

Long writing questions

Explain that the two different types of writing questions, one to explain or describe, the other including opinion or argument, have different forms, purposes and readers. For example, if one writing question is an informal letter to a younger friend, the other may be a formal report for an adult newspaper reader.


A long writing question to explain or describe Step 1:

Students will need to revise the terms ‘form’, ‘reader’ and ‘purpose’ and what they mean in this context. The level of formality required for the writing will be decided by these three aspects. The top grade descriptors will focus on the ability of the student to adapt the style of writing according to form, reader and purpose.

Step 2:

This type of question makes use of pictures as a stimulus for writing. Emphasise that these pictures are to help give ideas. Students do not have to use them – in fact, the sense of an individual voice with independent thinking is often the hallmark of a student who will do well. On the other hand, students should not be afraid of using one of the suggestions – they have been designed to be valid ideas, and able students should be well able to demonstrate some independence of thought through the treatment of the topic.

Step 3:

As well as the pictures, the question will usually provide three bullet points: the ‘prompts’. These prompts must be followed. The Student Book suggests using the prompts as a way to structure the writing, using them as a framework for collecting and organising ideas. The exercises in the Student Book will take more time than the student will actually have in the examination. Make it clear that the practice work is to help the student understand how to make use of the prompts. In the practice questions at the end of the chapter the student should aim for greater speed.

Step 4:

This step explains how ideas can be developed at proper length.

Step 5:

This step focuses on the use of connectives within and between paragraphs. It includes some suggestions on how punctuation and pronouns can also help cohesion.

A long writing question including opinion or argument Explain that this type of question involves a discussion of a topic on a more sophisticated level in the format of an article, a report or a review. Usually there is clear guidance as to whether students are expected to ‘offer your views on this topic’, i.e. give an opinion on what the pros and cons are, or whether they are expected to take a stance and argue for or against the topic. If it is not made clear, then students can choose whether or not to approach the question in a dispassionate, objective way, or whether to argue very forcibly for one side of the case. Draw attention to the fact that there are no compulsory prompts here. Instead, there are the speech bubbles to provide ideas that could be incorporated or simply used as inspiration. It is most important that students understand they must never copy out the prompts. The ideas should be referred to in some way, however. As with the first writing question, this section question is also presented as five steps, based on a sample question (Student Book pp. 274–277). The teacher may decide to ask the students to do the two sample questions (Student Book pp. 278–280) on another day.

Using the practice questions Chapter 16

Long writing questions

You may choose to have the students complete all of the practice questions in one sitting, perhaps as a last-minute revision exercise. Alternatively, you may choose to have them do each question separately and focus on it. Whichever route you decide on, a study of the marking guidance shown will provide great help for students in understanding more clearly what they should be aiming to do when they write the exam. After completing the two different types of writing question, the students can discuss their responses in pairs, with some or all of these prompts:

142

•

Compare how you felt after writing to explain or describe with how you felt after writing to include opinion or argument.

•

Look again at the practice questions and compare which words you underlined to show the form, the reader and the purpose of each task. Decide together how formal you thought each piece of writing should be. © HarperCollinsPublishers 2017


•

What use did each of you make of the pictures when writing to describe or explain and the speech bubbles when writing to include opinion or argument?

•

Did you both make brief outline plans before you started writing? Compare your approaches and ask yourself: Did I use the best way to prepare? Should I make any changes to how I prepare for the writing exercise?

•

Did you work to the best of your abilities and keep to the word limits? It's very important that you don't write too little, and if you write too much then you can waste valuable time.

•

In these two questions you are marked on how accurate your grammar, your spelling and your punctuation are. Did you leave time to check through your work? You can make changes by clearly drawing a line through the wrong word, and writing the correct version above it.

•

Read through each other’s work. Tell one another about the best things about each piece, and also about any parts where the writing was less clear and easy to read.

If there are both Core-level and Extended-level students in the class, for ease of classroom management, you could ask all students to work together on the Extended section of ‘The student as marker’ section that follows. Finally, the Core-level students can be shown the different marking guidance used for the Core. A class of Core-level students does not need to work through both sections – the Core section alone will be sufficient for them, and the more complex Extended version could confuse or demotivate. A class of Extended-level students needs only to work through the Extended section.

The student as marker To help students become familiar with how these questions are marked, give them a copy of the relevant marking guidance from pp. 145–146 of this Teacher Guide (also available on the CD-ROM), which they can use to mark the sample answer to the practice questions:

•

For Core-level students – An additional sample answer is provided on worksheet 16.1, along with a marked-up version of it on worksheet 16.2. Ask students to mark this sample and then compare the marked-up version with their own.

•

For Extended-level students – An additional sample answer is provided on worksheet 16.3, along with a marked-up version on worksheet 16.4. Again, students can mark this sample and then compare the marked-up version with their own.

Students can then mark their own responses or one another’s work, using the appropriate marking guidance (Core or Extended). Alternatively, as teacher, you may decide to use the marking guidance to support and enhance your own marking, perhaps referring to it closely when returning students’ work to them.

Using the sample answers in Chapter 19

It is worth pointing out to students that these questions carry the most marks. This is especially important for Extended-level students, as 16 marks are allocated to each writing question – if a student spends too much time on the first question, they run the risk of losing a high proportion of marks if they do not have time to make a reasonable attempt at the second. If they should run low on time for the two writing © HarperCollinsPublishers 2017

143

Chapter 16

Student 1 is a Core-level student, and Student 2 is Extended-level. As before, you may choose to focus on one level or the other to avoid confusing students with two different marking guidances.

Long writing questions

In Chapter 19 (pp. 307–308), there are two more sample answers to long writing questions. Your students can practise marking these and so increase their familiarity with the marking guidance. See the Introduction to this Teacher Guide (p. 5) for more guidance on using the sample answers and marking guidance.


questions, they would be well advised to divide the remaining time by two, aiming to produce two shorter, but accurate, compositions. The importance of time management cannot be stressed enough. One of the annotated responses in Chapter 19 could be presented as a model; you can then ask students to annotate the other example response before comparing theirs with the marker’s version. Stress to the students that there is no ‘right’ or definitive way to annotate these. In fact, it will be interesting to compare the different features that different students identify. This will allow you to explain the subtleties of assessing compositions – it will be a matter of weighing up strengths and weaknesses. The same technique can be used when students assess one another’s written responses to other writing questions on past papers. Photocopy the students’ work, then ask partners to swap essays, mark and annotate them, and then hand them back. Highlighting pens may be used. Suggest that students identify three good features and three areas requiring improvement. The students then try to improve the work before handing it in to the teacher for final grading. To vary the activity, choose two or three good examples of responses from the class. Photocopy them but on a larger scale – say as A3-sized posters – and pin them on the wall. Give students a green and a red sticky note each, and invite them to identify a good feature (green) and a feature requiring improvement (red) in one of the essays. Then students stick them on the relevant poster with a line from the sticky note pointing to the feature.

Handy tips As a final task, ask students to draw up a list of ‘Handy tips’ to help them when they next do a long writing exercise like this. This can be done as a class, brainstorming ideas together, as a group, pair or individual activity. It may also be a useful lastminute revision activity: Handy tips for long writing questions (Exercises 5 and 6)

•

Read the question carefully and underline words that tell you form, reader and purpose.

Chapter 16

Long writing questions

144

© HarperCollinsPublishers 2017


Marking guidance – Core* The same instructions and the same marking guidance apply to both Question 5 and 6 You have to award each answer a mark for Content and a mark for Language.

• • •

Content – out of 6 marks Language – out of 6 marks Total – 12 marks.

Content means:

• •

Relevance (how far the piece fulfils the task; awareness of purpose/reader) Development of ideas (details/examples given and how enjoyable it is to read).

Language means:

• •

Style (choice of words; sentence structures) Accuracy (grammar; spelling; punctuation; paragraphs).

Notes:

•

If the writing is a lot shorter than 100 words, it should be put into the middle mark band or lower for Content.

•

If the writing has nothing to do with the question, it should be given 0 marks for both Content and Language – even if it is good to read!

145

Chapter 16

Long writing questions

© HarperCollinsPublishers 2017


Marking guidance – Extended* The same instructions and the same marking guidance apply to both Question 5 and 6 You have to award each answer a mark for Content and a mark for Language.

• • •

Content – out of 8 marks Language – out of 8 marks Total – 16 marks.

Content means:

• •

Relevance (how far the piece fulfils the task; awareness of purpose/reader) Development of ideas (details/examples given and how enjoyable it is to read).

Language means:

• •

Style (choice of words; sentence structures) Accuracy (grammar; spelling; punctuation; paragraphs).

Notes:

•

If the writing is a lot shorter than 150 words, it should be put into Band 4 or lower for Content.

•

If the writing has nothing to do with the question, it should be given 0 marks for both Content and Language – even if it is good to read!

Marking guidance: Long writing questions (Exercises 5 and 6) – Extended Band

Marks

Content

(out of 10)

Marks

Language

(out of 9)

7, 8

• Fulfils the task very well • Excellent sense of purpose and audience • Develops ideas well and uses own ideas in a convincing way • Interests the reader successfully

7, 8

• Uses a variety of sentence structures successfully • Uses a good range of vocabulary and idioms precisely and accurately • No or very few mistakes in accuracy • Well-constructed paragraphs, with good links inside and between them

Band 2

5, 6

• Fulfils the task well • Good sense of purpose and reader • Develops ideas well with details/examples • Interests the reader in places

5, 6

• Tries to use a variety of sentence structures • Uses words precisely and may try to use idioms • A few small errors in accuracy • Uses paragraphs correctly and may try to link ideas inside and between them

Band 3

3, 4

• Fulfils the task • Some sense of purpose and reader • Uses a few details/examples to develop ideas

3, 4

• Simple sentence structures mostly correct and tries to use some complex sentences • Choice of words generally satisfactory • Meaning is clear despite some errors in accuracy • Uses paragraphs to organise ideas

Band 4

1, 2

• Some of the writing fulfils the task • Very little awareness of the reader or purpose • Gives very few if any details/ examples to develop ideas tries to do the set task 1 mark

1, 2

• Uses simple sentence structures but makes mistakes • Meaning is not always clear • Paragraphs not used properly if at all Very hard to understand because of all the mistakes 1 mark

Band 5

0

Top Band 1 [Extended only]

Chapter 16

Long writing questions

• No attempt – 0 marks

0

• Impossible to understand – 0 marks

Bottom

*The questions, sample answers and marks/comments that appear in this book were written by the author. In the examination, the way marks would be awarded to answers like these may be different. 146

© HarperCollinsPublishers 2017


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Cambridge IGCSE® English as a Second Language Teacher Guide Preview by Collins - Issuu