Preservation Plano 150 - Chapter 5: Potential Heritage Resources

CHAPTER 5: POTENTIAL HERITAGE RESOURCES

INTRODUCTION

Leading up to the 2018 Preservation Plan update, the City of Plano hired Austin-based HHM & Associates, Inc. (HHM) to complete a Potential Historic Assets Survey of structures built prior to 1960 and blocks or subdivisions developed between 1960-1969. The purpose of the survey work was to identify, research, and evaluate properties which may have historical, cultural, archaeological, or architectural importance, either as an individual property or as part of a larger district. As part of this process, an online Potential Historic Assets Map was also developed, which allowed citizens to identify the location of previously unidentified properties that could be potentially historic. The property owners of all surveyed properties were notified prior to HHM conducting the survey work. As a result of the 2018 Potential Historic Assets Survey, 15 individual properties, ten cemeteries, and three districts were identified as Potential Heritage Resources (PHR). PHRs are not officially designated historic, but have the potential to be with further research, rehabilitation, or property owner interest. The property owners of all recommended PHRs were notified again prior to the public workshops (see Appendix D). With this completed survey, it is important to keep in mind that:

A Listing as a Potential Heritage Resource is informational only and does not subject any property on the list to additional regulations, demolition restrictions, or architectural/design review by the Heritage Commission.

A Designation of an individual property requires an application by the property owner(s).

A Designation of districts requires an application signed by at least 60% of the property owner(s) within the proposed district.

In addition to the list of PHRs, a list of properties/districts that may be historic, but that need more research, was also compiled. Some of these properties may be eligible for designation as conservation districts. A conservation district typically regulates the form of new construction and large additions, but does not regulate exterior alterations to or demolition of heritage resources, as a heritage resource overlay district does. However, the city currently has no established criteria for creating a conservation district. The Preservation Plan recommends conservation district criteria be established before any further evaluation of these properties.

A As with the PHRs, this list is informational only and does not subject any property on the list to additional regulations, demolition restrictions, or design/architectural review by the Heritage Commission.

A Designation of an individual property requires an application by the property owner(s).

A Designation of districts requires an application signed by at least 60% of the property owner(s) within the proposed district.

For more detailed information about the properties included in the 2018 Potential Historic Assets Survey, refer to HHM’s Final Survey Report in Appendix B.

PHR - INDIVIDUAL PROPERTIES

1108 11th Street

Construction Date: 1928 Style: Folk Victorian

1306 14th Street

Construction Date: ca. 1930 Style: Tudor Revival

1412 14th Street

Construction Date: 1949 Style: Modern

1820 14th Street

Construction Date: 1963 Style: Ranch

1212 E 15th Street

Construction Date: ca. 1950 Style: Ranch

1300 E 15th Street

Construction Date: 1898, 1949 Style: Colonial & Greek Revival

1300 E 16th Street

Construction Date: ca. 1925 Style: Craftsman

808 19th Street

Construction Date: 1959 Style: Ranch & Craftsman

1601 Alma Drive

Construction Date: ca. 1925 Style: Prairie

1715 K Avenue

Construction Date: ca. 1920 Style: Colonial Revival & Craftsman

1800 K Avenue

Construction Date: 1962 Style: Modern

1513 M Avenue

Construction Date: ca. 1910 Style: National Folk

1512 N Avenue

Construction Date: 1927 Style: Tudor Revival

901 Springbrook Drive

Construction Date: 1961 Style: N/A

MORE RESEARCH REQUIRED

Collinwood House (relocated)

Construction Date: ca. 1861 Style: National Folk, Gothic Revival

The following properties are not official Potential Heritage Resources, but should be further studied to determine their eligibility pending right-of-entry or more intensive research:

1304 13th Street

Construction Date: 1932 Style: Industrial Warehouse

5845 McKamy Road

Construction Date: 1967 Style: Ranch

1439 Wind Cave Circle

Construction Date: 1973 Style: Ranch

5395 14th Street

Construction Date: ca. 1966 Style: Ranch

3740 E Parker Road

Construction Date: 1945 Style: Tudor Revival

Bishop Road (Barn)

Construction Date: unknown Style: Barn

7676 Robinson Road

Construction Date: 1940 Style: Barn

PHR - CEMETERIES

Cemeteries are important cultural landscapes that connect current residents with those of the past. These sites should be recognized for their contribution as places of burial, remembrance, and commemoration of the early Plano pioneers and those who followed. Caretakers of all Plano cemeteries are encouraged to join the Bowman Cemetery and L.A. Davis Cemetery and apply for designation as individually designated heritage resources.

Baccus Cemetery

Bishop Rd, N of Legacy Dr 1847 - Present

Bethany Cemetery

Custer Rd, N of Legacy Dr 1877 - Present

Collinsworth Cemetery

Vermillion Dr 1895 - 1920

Leach-Thomas Cemetery

Pensacola Dr, N of Destin Dr 1868-1920

Old City Cemetery I Avenue, S of 12th Street 1881 - Present

Felker Cemetery

S of Waycross Dr, W of Auburn Pl ca. 1890

Rowlett

Rowlett Cemetery Rd, S of 121 1862 - Present

Shepard Ranch Cemetery Park Blvd, W of Preston Rd ca. 1950

Plano Mutual Cemetery

Jupiter Rd & 18th Street 1852 - Present

Young Cemetery S of 121, E of Independence Pkwy 1847-1909

Creek Cemetery

PHR - DISTRICTS

Plano

Williams

Plano

Plano Mutual Cemetery

P Ave

Briarwood District

Construction Dates: 1962-1973 Style: Ranch, Contemporary

Clint Forman District

Construction Dates: 1898-2012 Style: Ranch, Queen Anne, Minimal Traditional, Colonial Revival, National Folk, Craftsman, Classic Revival, Prairie

North Forest Estates

Construction Dates: 1962-1963 Style: Ranch

Municipal Center

Meadows Elementary Haggard Park

The following districts meet two or more criteria for designation as a Heritage Resource Overlay District and are encouraged to apply for designation.

High School

Mutual Cemetery

MORE RESEARCH REQUIRED - DISTRICTS

Four districts are recommended to be re-evaluated in the future following the establishment of conservation district designation criteria. Two agricultural properties were also identified as requiring more research to determine if the larger agricultural complexes are eligible as heritage districts.

Haggard Addition

Construction Dates: 1952-1970

Type: Conservation District Styles: Ranch, Minimal Traditional Subdivisons: Haggard Addition, Olie Mathews Addition

Old Towne

Construction Dates: 1947-1970 Type: Conservation District Style: Ranch, Minimal Traditional Subdivisions: Belle View, French, Southwood

Belle View Estates

Construction Dates: 1958-1965

Type: Conservation District Style: Ranch Subdivision: Belle View Estates

First Presbyterian Church of Plano

Williams High School Plano Municipal Center

Bowman

Construction Dates: 1955

Type: Conservation District Style: Ranch Subdivision: Bowman J H Addition

Lavon Farms

Type: Agricultural Property Jupiter Rd, N of Parker Rd

Hall Property

Type: Agricultural Property Daniel Klepper Survey NW Corner of Park Rd and Alma Dr

Harrington Elementary School

Mendenhall Elementary School

Harrington Library Williams High School

MAP KEY

Individually Designated Heritage Resources 1 - Mitchell House 2 - S.B. Wyatt House

- Plano High School

- Aldridge House

- Will Schimelpfenig House 6 - Schimelpfenig-Dudley-O’Neal House

- Mathews House

- Lamm House

- R.A. Davis House

- Mary Schimelpfenig House

- Olney Davis House

- Hughston House

- Wall-Robbins House

- Forman House 15 - Little Carlisle House 16 - Merritt Building 17 - Bagwill-Sherrill Building 18 - Plano National Bank/IOOF Lodge

Rigsbee Dr Trailridge Dr

Briarwood

Kent eld Ln

Forestcrest Dr

Belle View Estates

Hillside Dr Meandering Way

Boedeker Dr Van Buren Dr Tilden Dr Ezekial Way Ballymonte Dr

19 - Interurban Station 20 - Moore House/Masonic Lodge 21 - Thornton House 22 - L.A. Davis Cemetery 23 - Carpenter House 24 - Schell House 25 - Hood House 26 - McCall-Skaggs House 27 - Carlisle House 28 - Roller House 29 - Arch Weatherford House 30 - Salmon House 31 - Wells Homestead 32 - Ammie Wilson House 33 - Bowman Cemetery

Heritage Resource Overlay Districts

Haggard Park HROD Downtown HROD

Brookview Dr

RockbrookDr

Natalie Dr Erwin Dr Briarwood Dr

18th St

Sharon Cir Greenbriar Ln Meadowcreek Dr GreenbriarLn BriarcreekLn

city-wide map

Dr Ridgeway Dr

Janet Way

Price Dr Meadows Dr

Rigsbee Dr De Sol Dr

Potential Heritage Resources (Individual)

1 - 808 19th Street

2 - 1715 K Avenue

3 - 1800 K Avenue

4 - 1513 M Avenue

5- 1300 E 16th Street

6 - 1512 N Avenue

7 - 1212 E 15th Street

8 - 1300 E 15th Street

9 - 1306 14th Street

10 - 1412 14th Street

11 - 1820 14th Street

12 - 1108 11th Street

13 - Collinwood House

14 - 1601 Alma Drive

15 - 901 Springbrook Drive

Potential Heritage Resources (Districts)

Clint Forman Addition North Forest Estates Briarwood

Potential Heritage Resources (Cemeteries)

1 - Plano Mutual Cemetery

2 - Old City Cemetery 3 - Baccus Cemetery 4 - Young Cemetery 5 - Rowlett Creek Cemetery 6 - Bethany Cemetery 7 - Leach-Thomas Cemetery 8 - Collinsworth Cemetery 9 - Old Shepard Cemetery 10 - Felker Cemetery

More Research Required (Individual)

1 - 1304 13th Street

2 - Bishop Rd 3 - 5845 McKamy Rd 4 - 7676 Robinson Rd

5 - 1439 Wind Cave Cir 6 - 3740 E Parker Road 7 - 5395 14th Street

More Research Required (Districts) Haggard Addition

Bowman J H Addition Old Towne Belle View Estates

5 - Hall Property 6 - Lavon Farms

DOUGLASS COMMUNITY MURAL