SINCE 1891
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2019
VOLUME CLIII, ISSUE 39
WWW.BROWNDAILYHERALD.COM
Zhou ’20 elected UCS president Stars, film industry leaders
to grace campus during IFF
Student body votes De Georgia ’20 as UFB chair, passes Brown Divest referendum
Olivia Wilde, Logan Lerman, André Leon Talley will speak during week of events, screenings
By KAYLA GUO SENIOR STAFF WRITER
William Zhou ’20 was elected president of the Undergraduate Council of Students and Julian De Georgia ’20 was chosen as chair of the Undergraduate Finance Board in this year’s elections, announced Elections Board Co-Chairs Katie Barry ’19 and Kathryn Stack ’19 Thursday night on the steps of the Stephen Robert ’62 Campus Center. Jason Carroll ’21 will serve as the next UCS vice president and Fatoumata Kabba ’22 will serve as the next UFB vice chair. All elected candidates will begin their terms in the fall. Student coalition Brown Divest’s referendum passed with around 69 percent of the vote. The referendum asked whether the University should “divest all stocks, funds, endowment and other monetary instruments from companies complicit in human rights abuses in Palestine” and also “establish a means of implementing financial
By ELISE RYAN ARTS AND CULTURE EDITOR
As Hollywood embraces social change through movements like Time’s Up, those same shifting tides will bring young, diverse and empowering stars to the University’s campus as part of the annual Ivy Film Festival Apr. 8-14. André Leon Talley GS ’72, the former editor-at-large of Vogue, will open the festival with a keynote address Apr. 8, accompanied by a screening of “The Gospel According to André.” The documentary chronicles Talley’s life and career, from his childhood in the segregated South to his unparalleled career at fashion giants W and Vogue. The address marks Talley’s first return to the University since he graduated with his master’s degree in French Literature in 1972, according to an IFF press release. “He’s bringing his life story in film
VICTORIA YIN / HERALD
William Zhou ’20 (right) was elected UCS president Thursday night with 50.1 percent of the vote. Zhou currently serves as UCS vice president. transparency and student oversight of the University’s investments.” Around 44 percent of the undergraduate student body voted in this year’s elections — 3,076 out of 7,043 students. This represents the highest voter turnout in three years. Turnout stood at approximately 36 percent in 2018, 20 percent in 2017 and 29 percent in 2016, according to numbers
provided by Barry and Stack. Brown Divest’s referendum passed with 1,939 of 2,810 votes. The University is not obligated to take any action based on the referendum outcome, The Herald previously reported. The University expects “to communicate with the campus community on » See ELECTIONS, BACK page
form to us,” said Misha Gehring ’19, co-executive director of IFF. Not only is Talley a fashion mogul, he also brings a unique perspective to the festival as the subject, rather than producer or director, of the documentary. “The thing that is so amazing about film is its multiplicity and the fact that it is more than cinematography. It is production design, it is costume, it is storytelling, it is documentary.” Official Selection blocks will be the core of the festival, which feature 22 undergraduate and graduate short films, “meticulously curated from over 330 submissions from 26 different countries,” according to the press release. For the first time in the festival’s history, the selection blocks are organized by themes: “Strength,” “Home” and “Selfhood.” “We always find it so interesting to see what student filmmakers want to turn their camera toward and what sorts of issues they want to capture,” said Kripa Venkatesh ’19, co-executive director of IFF. “They approach similar themes in such different, nuanced ways.” » See IFF, page 9
Community mourns BrownTogether reaches $2 billion milestone Christchurch victims BrownTogether Progress by Category (March 2019) BrownTogether has currently raised $2.06 billion of its $3.00 billion goal.
Students, faculty, community members gather in vigil on Main Green Thursday evening By EMILIJA SAGAITYTE SENIOR STAFF WRITER
Members of the Brown community gathered on the Main Green together under the night sky Thursday, candles lit in their hands, to mourn the Muslims who were killed during the New Zealand shooting last week. The vigil was organized by the Brown Muslim Students Association, Brown-RISD Muslim Chaplaincy and the Office of the Chaplains and Religious Life. Following the attacks in Christchurch, New Zealand — which took place at Al Noor Mosque and Linwood Mosque — members of the Brown community provided students and staff with opportunities and places to process the tragedy. Spaces to honor the victims over the past week have included organized attendance at Rhode Island’s statewide vigil at the Masjid
INSIDE
Al-Kareem mosque on Monday and time after the weekly Jumu’ah service last Friday, when around 80 people gathered for a reading of the translated Moroccan poem “The Prayer of the Oppressed.” On Thursday, the vigil began and ended with a reading of the opening verses of the Qur’an, which was followed by an array of speakers — from students to staff to other members of the community — who shared their thoughts and supportive words, in addition to offering moments of silence for the victims. Students Hamzah Shah ’22, Muram Ibrahim ’22 and Samy Amkieh ’21 read aloud the names of the 50 people who lost their lives, and then each elaborated on the life story of one victim. Associate University Chaplain for the Muslim Community Imam Adnan Adrian Wood-Smith remarked on the significance of the tragedy taking place during the weekly sacred day Jumu’ah. “The fact that this gathering for our brothers and sisters in New Zealand » See VIGIL, page 9
Annual Fund
236
Campus and Community Goal
495
Education and Research
717
Our People
537
0
164
255 83
513
200
400
600
Funds Raised (Millions)
800
1000
Funds to be Raised (Millions)
Source: Associate Vice President for Advancement Communications Joseph Zappala USHA BHALLA / HERALD
Two-thirds of $3 billion goal raised so far, campaign set for completion by 2022 By LI GOLDSTEIN SENIOR STAFF WRITER
The University’s BrownTogether fundraising campaign recently surpassed a $2 billion fundraising milestone in its
push to reach $3 billion by 2022. So far, over 56,000 people have donated to the campaign, which launched publicly in 2015, wrote Associate Vice President for Advancement Communications Joseph Zappala in an email to The Herald. “We are making great progress on the campaign. Being more than twothirds of the way in is exciting,” said President Christina Paxson P’19. “I’m very pleased with the momentum in the
campaign, and I’m also pleased with the number of things we’ve already been able to accomplish.” Paxson believes that BrownTogether is on track to meet its 2022 completion goal. “Right now, we’re actually tracking ahead of our goals, so now we’ve built in some flexibility in case there’s an economic downturn,” she said. After the BrownTogether campaign ends in 2022, Paxson hopes to make » See FUNDRAISE, page 2
WEATHER
FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2019
SPORTS Marchin '19 leads men's hockey team to victory over Quinnipiac, Bruno to go to semi-finals
NEWS Shake Shack opens to the public with much fanfare, Mayor Elorza participates in ribbon-cutting
NEWS President Trump signed an executive order to protect “free inquiry” on college campuses
PAGE 2
PAGE 11
PAGE 11
TODAY
TOMORROW
46 / 34
45/30
NEWS
PAGE 2 • FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2019
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
Marchin ’19 fuels Bears to victory over No. 5 Quinnipiac in Quarterfinals Senior scores two goals in comeback win Saturday, helps Bruno advance to ECAC semifinals By ALEXANDRA RUSSELL SPORTS EDITOR
For the first time since the 2012-13 season, the men’s hockey team advanced to the semifinals of the ECAC Tournament following a series sweep over No. 5 Quinnipiac University last weekend. Bruno upset the top-seeded Bobcats 2-1 in overtime Friday, before scoring four goals in the third period the following night to earn a 4-3 win and secure a spot in the final four in Lake Placid. The Bears’ offense was highlighted by a formidable performance from co-captain Tommy Marchin ’19, who notched a pair of goals — including the game-winner — to fuel the team to victory Saturday. Marchin has made a significant mark on the program since arriving at Brown in 2015. As a first-year, he was named to the ECAC Hockey AllRookie Team and was shortlisted as a finalist for ECAC Rookie of the Year. In his career with the Bears, Marchin has recorded a pair of hat-tricks, including one in a comeback overtime victory at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in the 2017-18 season. He currently leads the team with 26 points this year and recently earned Second Team All-Ivy honors for his efforts. For his outstanding performances against Quinnipiac and achievements with the Bears this season, Marchin has been named The Herald’s Athlete of the Week. Herald: Congratulations on sweeping Quinnipiac! How did it feel to get those wins and advance to the semifinals? Marchin: It’s been one of the goals for Brown hockey and myself since I got here my freshman year, getting to the final four of the ECAC finals. Just for getting there, we get a banner in the rink. It’s one of the small goals we’re working for to work our way up to (being) ECAC champions and then making it to the NCAA Tournament, so it’s just a huge accomplishment for Brown and we’re so fired up for it. When did you start playing
» FUNDRAISE, from page 1 sustainability goals an institutional priority and work toward providing need-blind financial aid for international applicants. “To my mind, one reason for doing a campaign is to energize the Brown community and to increase the ability of the University to raise funds,” she said. “We don’t want to let that fall back when the campaign is over.” Funds raised through the campaign are allocated into four categories: People, Education & Research, Campus & Community and the Annual Fund. Each category funds different projects and initiatives, though some projects draw funds from multiple categories. For example, funds raised for the Carney Institute for Brain Science — including a $100 million donation last April — fall into both the Education & Research and People categories.
COURTESY OF BROWN ATHLETICS
Co-captain Tommy Marchin ’19 leads the men’s hockey team with 26 points this season and was recently awarded Second Team All-Ivy honors. The Bears will take on Cornell in the ECAC semifinals this afternoon in Lake Placid at 4 p.m. hockey? I first started when I was three. I started rollerblading actually while my sister was at dance practice, and in the same building there was a (roller) hockey rink. To keep me busy when she was dancing, my parents put me in the rink and I had a coach or something, and I guess I just did that every time she went to practice. I got on ice skates the year after with my sister who then switched to hockey, so (she) and I have been playing together our whole lives. She played at Yale and I played here, so we kind of did it together.
Do you have a favorite game day breakfast or meal? I go to the Blue Room — I get a breakfast sandwich or two, depending on the day. … Then we go to the Ratty or Hope Street Pizza, and I get chicken and noodles and nothing else — no sauce, no anything. I get chicken noodles and a glass of Powerade. It’s kind of simple, but I like to keep it simple. This past month, I’ve been going to Andreas every Wednesday and then going to get Insomnia Cookies at some point in the week for good luck.
Do you have a favorite NHL team? Probably Detroit, I’m from there — I grew up going to the Detroit Red Wings games. I always actually liked the Anaheim Mighty Ducks, back when they were the Mighty Ducks when Disney owned them because I grew up watching the movies. … One of the reasons actually why I’m playing the sport is because I loved those movies so much.
Do you like to listen to music when you work out alone? What do you like to listen to? I do. … I love working out alone — it’s probably my favorite thing. It lets me clear my mind. Depending on my mood, I’ll probably go with either rap or like 80s or 90s rock that’s kind of not like screamo but more upbeat, faster — I like that. It’s what I listened to when I was driving to the rink as a kid because my dad always had the
Within the People category, many donations fund endowed professorships, which “let us recruit and retain amazing faculty,” Paxson said. So far, funds have been raised for 68 endowed chairs toward a goal of 123, and a little less than half of these “are currently filled with new or existing faculty who are doing great things for Brown.” Senior Vice President for Advancement Sergio Gonzalez said that a donation to support such endowed professorships is “an investment in the quality of teaching and research at Brown that will impact students certainly but also the institution overall.” Another central campaign priority is undergraduate financial aid, Paxson said. The BrownTogether campaign aims to raise $500 million for financial aid and $120 million for the Brown Promise, which eliminated student loans from undergraduate financial aid packages, The Herald previously
reported. So far, approximately $211 million has been raised toward that goal. Gonzalez derives his passion for fundraising, especially for financial aid, from personal experience. As a financial aid recipient through college and law school, “I would not have gotten the education I did” had it not been for the “generosity of donors that made financial aid possible for me,” he said. The fundraising campaign also provides support for the arts community on campus, said Managing Director of the Brown Arts Initiative Anne Bergeron. Along with funding the new Performing Arts Center, donations to the campaign support “programmatic development so that (the BAI) could expand what we’re doing on the academic side, curriculum-based side and public programming side.” The campaign’s priorities were conceived with the interest of the
radio control, so it just puts me back in that kind of mood. Has there been a most memorable experience in your Brown career so far? My freshman year, while I was getting recruited to Brown I was also getting recruited to Providence College, and then when I decided to come here I was excited to play them for the first time. It was over winter break, and they were number one in the country and we ended up winning in overtime, and I was lucky enough to get the goal. My two captains were on the ice, and one of them tipped (the puck) off the goalie’s pad and just gave me a wide open net that I could just tap it in, and that was just the coolest thing that could ever happen to me as a freshman, and I was really fired up about that. Do you have plans for what you would like to do after graduation? I’m hoping to play hockey somewhere professionally — it just kind of
University community in mind, Bergeron said. “The President and the leadership team really took the temperature of the campus community to understand where there was opportunity. … (Paxson) quickly realized that there was a tremendous amount of opportunity around arts and culture within the Brown universe because so many Brown students are interested in pursuing some kind of creative practice.” Funds from the campaign have also created more permanent faculty positions within the arts, including endowed professorships and positions for “professors of practice,” Bergeron said. Gonzalez attributed the pace in fundraising to “President Paxson’s leadership and the donors’ receptivity to the messages and importance of the campaign,” he said. “Our alums and our donors … are giving to us because they believe in the strategic vision.”
depends on who wants me and where the best fit is. I’m looking to put off working in an office as long as I can — I’m just having fun and mainly focusing on the end of the season and I’ll figure it out after that. It’s not a big worry of mine. What is the team’s mindset going into the semifinals in Lake Placid? Our mindset is all just positivity — it’s one-game elimination and we know that we’ve played Cornell before, and we know that we can score goals and play good teams when we need to. It’s just kind of exciting because we’ve never been in the position to be able to do this in my four years here. It’s all positive and encouraging, so I’m really excited for it. The Bears face off against Cornell in Lake Placid this afternoon. Puck drop is at 4 p.m. This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
In This Issue
Commitment Issues
Kahini Mehta 3
Blueno the Transfer Student
Hanna Rashidi 2 Moe Sattar 4
"Perfectly Innocent" Allie Cavallaro 5
BYOB: Build Your Own Booze Kia Caiting 5
Sing a Strong Song
postCover by Rémy Poisson
MAR 22
VOL 23 —
ISSUE 20
FEATURE
Blueno the Transfer Student Reflections on "Untitled (Lamp!/!Bear)" and the Transfer Student Experience By Hanna Rashidi Illustrated by Hanna Rashidi
A
s a result of my upbringing, I’m fairly fond of bears. Being a native Californian and a former UCLA Bruin, it’s almost part of the job description. My childhood was marked by the grizzly proudly flying on the California flag and speckled with several frightening encounters with the real thing at Yosemite. However, there is little today that could overshadow my affection for one particular bear. This bear happens to be 23 feet tall and an admittedly alarming shade of blue. I
speak, of course, of the sculpture officially known as "Untitled (Lamp/Bear)" but perhaps best known as Blueno. However, I must confess that Blueno hasn’t always occupied a warm place in my heart. I couldn’t understand why anyone would think it was a good idea to disrupt the tranquility of the surrounding colonial architecture with such a loud and assertive figure. It was only until I spent some time on this campus that I came to understand how Blueno’s journey, in some symbolic way, mirrors
my own as a mid-year transfer student at Brown. No previous affinity for bears could have prepared me for the sky blue monstrosity that confronted me the first time I stepped onto Brown’s campus this past summer. I applied to transfer to Brown without ever visiting the school in person, and although I had heard tales of the azure member of the Ursidae family currently residing on an otherwise well-composed campus, I was still thoroughly taken aback when faced with dear ol’
Spring Break Activities on Campus
Letter from the Editor Dear Readers, Wow. Okay. So this is my first editor's note for post- (I have publication anxiety). This started out as an uninspired editor’s note. I went through the whole process of looking through previous editor’s notes and reviewing this week's issue—the Feature is dedicated to Blueno, Narrative has a piece about my tragic commitment issues, and Arts & Culture has a piece about cocktails!—before I asked myself what I really wanted to say. And with spring break coming up and flowers in fresh bloom, I realized I wanted to acknowledge the importance of new beginnings. New beginnings, new projects, and new alliances—like the post-/Blog merge.
2!post–
I want to acknowledge the amazing work the post- staff does and how much they have helped the Bloggers make the transition from a group of four comedians with a penchant for puns to a large team of dedicated, inspired writers. So here’s to new beginnings—and to Bost. (They told me not to say that, but I can never resist a good pun.) I hope that you, our readers, are as excited about the changes coming your way as we are.
Yours,
Kahini
Lifestyle Managing Editor
1. Listen to the entire Spring Weekend discography 2. Procrastinate work due April 1st (or don’t turn it in and call it an April Fools’ joke) 3. Mess up your sleep schedule even more by sleeping for at least 15 hours 4. Stare longingly at the Ratty because you (rightfully) refused to pay for the spring break meal plan 5. Finally confront the emails that have been pressuring you to declare 6. Watch Spring Breakers on repeat until you feel even worse than you did before 7. Write an ode to the last patch of ice you see melting 8. Start planning your housing lottery strategy 9. Finally get a Shake Shack concrete while everyone else is out of town 10. Spend all week in the SciLi because your professors had the audacity to schedule exams after break
Blueno in person. The sun shone on the bright grass with a peaceful breeze winding its way through picturesque brick buildings, yet there stood this bizarre and disturbing colossus. The more I looked, the more his details unsettled me. From his blank expression to the lamp protruding through his spine hanging ominously over me, everything about Blueno was disconcerting. My shocked and confused frame of mind soon gave way to exasperation, which was quickly replaced by irritation. I found Blueno disruptive, distracting, and generally in poor taste. Blueno stood in contrast to the cohesion of the rest of the buildings, so different from their history and maturity. I remember standing in the stifling humidity of the Rhode Island summer, staring into those chipped unseeing black button eyes and thinking that this ridiculous sculpture belonged on Brown’s campus about as much as I did. My anxious mind conjured up all sorts of scenarios about how I would stick out in this prestigious place just as much as this nonsensical sculpture. Blueno has been dealing with these reactions since he came to campus and indeed since he was built. Constructed by the Swiss artist Urs Fischer in 2005 and installed on Brown’s campus in 2016, he experienced a mixed reception. Some students were bemused while others thoroughly disapproved of his rather conspicuous presence. A 2016 Blognonian poll found that students thought Blueno was uglier than the SciLi (and that’s really saying something). The debate over Blueno is not exclusive to the Brown University campus. Blueno is not the only one of his kind—he has several siblings installed around the world. These include one in the the Hamad International Airport in Qatar and one which simply sits next to an art collector's home overlooking the ocean. Blueno’s relatives are distinct from him only in their color, which is a bright yellow that’s perhaps even more perplexing to me than Blueno’s color first was. No matter where these bears are placed or what color they come in, the only unified reaction they seem to garner is opposition. Reportedly, children in the airport in Qatar refuse to go near Blueno’s canary yellow sibling due to its “creepiness,” according to Piran Cafe writer Bob Ramsak. Art collector Adam Lindemann, the owner of one of Blueno’s siblings, used the bear as retaliation against his neighbor who threatened to build a windmill shaped house. Lindemann expressed concern that the bear would be rejected by the community. According to him, the only reason this hasn’t occurred is because there isn't public access to the sculpture. In all these instances, I think it is safe to say that "Untitled (Lamp/Bear)" tends to be considered as somewhat of an outsider. Even if people aren’t directly put off by him, he never exactly blends in with his surroundings. He will always be, at his core, entirely out of place. This experience of dislocation is one I am sure many of my fellow transfer students have felt on campus. We are new and unfamiliar, and there are times when I feel as out of place and conspicuous as a 20-ton blue teddy bear. We aren’t like the Penone tree with its deceptively lifelike exterior (even
with its gravity-defying rock). Visitors on tour at Brown often have to be informed that the tree is a sculpture or else their eyes will simply glide past it. This is not the case for dear Blueno or the transfer students at Brown. We don’t meld seamlessly into our surroundings as if we were always meant to be here. We laugh at jokes we don’t understand and stumble our way through the lingo of the school. The first time I went to Andrews I froze when asked “Credit or points?” because I had no idea what a credit was. During transfer orientation, an advisor assured us that we wouldn’t be walking around like characters from The Scarlet Letter with bright red T’s identifying us. While we may not have scarlet letters on our jackets (or rather, our industrialstrength winter coats), there are days when we might as well be the same bright shade as Blueno as we walk around campus looking cluelessly at unfamiliar buildings, unwilling to ask directions and admit that we don’t have any idea where we’re going and that we’re going to be late to class. We spent our first few days at Brown trying to learn the five different names every entity here seems to have (our transfer advisors eventually sent a helpful pdf ) and the acronyms that go along with all of them. I still rely entirely on Google Maps to navigate around campus. My transfer class has been on campus for over a month now, reaching the point where we’ve learned not to call Jo’s “Josiah's.” However, there are still times when we are unmistakably “other.” This is not to say that other students react negatively to us—it is simply that it is too easy to feel as though we are imposters hidden among the real Brown students. I’ve heard many of my friends express confusion at how they’ve managed to “sneak past” the admissions office to get here. The first words out of my mouth when I saw my acceptance were “I’m not worthy.” Most of us seem to be in a drawn-out state of suspicion and disbelief. Some transfers choose not to introduce themselves as such while others, like me, still do so in order to prepare people for some of the faux pas that we will inevitably make—any “first-year” mistakes gaps in our knowledge. Who is Gail? What is Dear Blueno? Why is there a Beekeeping Society without any bees? It’s hard to feel deserving of this place, and sometimes I have to remind myself that I’m not just a visitor surrounded by infinitely more qualified people. I’ve come to realize, however, that this feeling is not at all unique to transfers but is rather an inevitable piece of growing up. Everyone has something that they feel makes them incongruous, whether it be their background, some physical feature, or just a bad case of imposter syndrome. The hope, of course, is that this is not a permanent state. At this point, Blueno has been thoroughly accepted into the Brown community. Bluenothemed Facebook pages seem to be everywhere, and students have even created Blueno Spring Weekend tank tops and laptop stickers. I think many (if not all) will be sad to see him go when he is moved in 2021—coincidentally, the same year I graduate. It is this acceptance that I, and I’m sure many others, hope to eventually feel at Brown. I hope that by
the end of my time here, I can say “I go to Brown” without hesitation or incredulity and that soon, when I talk about this community, I will be able to say “we” instead of “they.” When speaking on the overall philosophy of his work during a lecture on campus in October 2016, Fischer said that “Art is more of a question than an answer.” The time a student spends in college is the same. Coming to Brown wasn’t the answer to finding what we were supposed to do, it was just the place that would provide the environment for us to work on that answer. We might not ever find it, honestly, but that doesn’t mean that we’ve failed in any way. This is just another step in a very long process that will probably never end. We’re not supposed to feel like we know exactly what we’re doing or like we fit here seamlessly. Blueno certainly didn’t—and honestly I think he still doesn’t—but nevertheless he is part of this campus. He is exasperating, perplexing, and altogether ridiculous, but those are the very things that have made him part of campus culture. He’s strange and out of place, and so is every student when they arrive here. But if Blueno in all his bright blue glory can be welcomed so wholeheartedly, then I think our chances are pretty good.
Commitment Issues
The Other Side of Heartbreak by Kahini Mehta Illustrated by Rémy Poisson By the time I was 12, I’d been dubbed a late bloomer. And it was true: I was late to my birth, late to shedding 60 pounds of “puppy fat,” and certainly late to most events before 9 a.m. But in the age of Tinder, Bumble, and countless other apps, which all my friends had joined months ago, I was—and as a 20-year-old, still am—also late to experiencing love. I won’t say I’m “incapable of love.” I’m too young to make judgments like that. I do know, however, that I am bad at love. And, as a general rule, I don’t like doing things that I am bad at. I came to this realization when I first started dating. I’d met him when I was just 15. Our story was something out of a Disney movie: We met at a mutual friend’s New Year’s party, hit it off, became best friends, and then started dating. And I was excited to have my first boyfriend. Really. I saw him as a rite of passage, my path to womanhood. I could finally join my friends as they grumbled about their boyfriends through hangovers from the many drinks they’d downed to forget them. Only it didn’t work out that way. My boyfriend gave me little to grumble about. He was the type of boy who makes every other guy look bad. He wrote me songs. He held my hand. And when I told him Valentine’s Day made me nauseous and that I didn’t expect any gifts, he gave me a Friday the 13th present the night before. It was a maneuver so clever that I didn’t have the
"Eighty percent of Greek mythology started with someone being attracted to a cow." “Seating at Shiru is basically Game of Thrones.” march 22, 2019&3
NARRATIVE heart to decline the stuffed teddy bear he handed me. So yes, nothing to grumble about. Or so I thought. But around a month into the relationship—which lasted, astonishingly, an entire 15 months—I began to reconsider. Was he really what I wanted? Did I even like him?
These thoughts scared me. As a person who’d always been so certain of herself, it was terrifying to feel unsure about such a central aspect of my life. I mean, the boy was friends with all of my friends. If I broke up with him, he’d take most of my social circle with him, because if I was the one to break up with him, I'd be the bad guy. That was just the way high-school politics worked where I lived. So I swallowed my feelings for months, trying to ignore the growing pit in my stomach every time he leaned in. I’d grown up hearing unique truisms like “Love is a fart; if you force it, it’s probably going to be shit”—but I was stubborn (or stupid) enough to try anyway. Over time, though, I began to question exactly how much of our relationship had been fueled by peer pressure. I came to realize that the answer exceeded an acceptable amount. My mother had always told me I was one of those people who was born to be alone. This statement used to offend me. But the deeper into my relationship I got, the more the truth began to strike me. For me, my first boyfriend had been just that: my first boyfriend. A coming-of-age landmark, a social checkmark in my list of things to accomplish. More than anything, his love had felt like an obligation to me: a shop full of china so fragile it could hardly help crumbling under my bulls’ horns. While we were dating, no one of the opposite sex even seemed to exist to my boyfriend, but my eyes strayed frequently. Of course, I never acted on those impulses; the sheer principle of the matter forbade me from doing so. And when he wanted to hold my hand during movies, I could only focus on how clammy his felt. In fact, when he told me he loved me, I sometimes felt like crying. I spent months unable to look my reflection in the eye. “If you don’t like him, then stop leading him on,” my friends told me. If only it were that simple. They were in love with their boyfriends, despite their grumbling. They couldn’t possibly understand. I couldn’t just look my boyfriend in the eyes and utter the magic words that would set myself free. It took me 15 months to work up the courage I needed. And when I did, I was on the wrong side of the breakup—socially, at least. Emotionally, he was a wreck. And sure, my friends outright stopped inviting me to places, but at least I didn’t cry myself to bed like I did while I was dating him. “He deserved better,” my best friend told me before ending our friendship. And what could I do but shrug? She wasn’t wrong. When I saw him with another girl soon after, I wanted to feel jealousy, rage—anything in the spectrum of emotions 4!post–
that would be considered “normal” for a teenage girl in my shoes. Instead, I was happy for him: He deserved the world. More than anything, I struggled with my feelings of apathy. I didn’t want to feel apathetic. I wanted to feel pain, I wanted a love so consuming that it would set my soul on fire just like it did in those old Hollywood movies my parents liked to watch. I’d never thought the most painful part of my first relationship would be my guilt. That relationship weighed on me in so many ways. But none of his friends knew any of that. All they saw were the tear stains on his cheeks, and that was enough to earn me the title of “heartbreaker.” Looking at the experiences I’ve had since then, I’d say I’m pretty bad at love. And, like I said before, I don’t like doing things I’m bad at, so until I figure it out, love is pretty much off the table. It's just not a priority right now, and probably won't be for some time. Despite the social pressure to date that I face from my friends and family, I don’t think I need to date to be happy with myself. Until further notice, I'm fine with having "commitment issues."
"Perfectly Innocent"
A Woman's Experience on Public Transit By Moe Sattar Illustrated by Gaby Trevino I ran across the street, splashing through the cold slush of melting snow to catch the RIPTA before it left me waiting 20 minutes for the next one. Safely on the line, I pulled out my Brown ID and readied to swipe—hoping that I was holding the card correctly to avoid fumbling and causing an awkward holdup. The possibility of slightly inconveniencing anyone, as well as my incessant need for validation, leads me to live day-to-day constantly worrying about being in the way. I heard the beep of a successful swipe and let out a little sigh of relief. Putting my card back in my jacket pocket as the bus started to roll forward, I scanned the seating area to find it mostly empty—not usually the case. I stumbled toward the middle, sat down, and put my earbuds in. Opening up Spotify, I decided that this was a King Princess kind of day and settled into the ease of just listening to my music, taking care to not
make awkward eye contact with the two other people on the bus. I didn't notice the middle-aged man who boarded at the next stop until he took the seat directly next to mine. Even though the bus was virtually empty. Slightly uncomfortable, to say the least, I made a point of pretending to be busy reading emails on my phone. I crossed my legs, angling away from him, but somehow this was misconstrued as a signal for him to move in and take up the room I had left. I tried ignoring his general existence, but King Princess had faded and was replaced by an internal argument in my head. You’re just reading into this too much, like you do with everything else. But why didn’t he take one of the seats closer to the front of the bus? Why sit directly next to me? Don’t be a narcissist; this is probably perfectly innocent. But also don’t turn your head to the right or make eye contact. Can you move any closer to the window? The world doesn’t revolve around you. I’m so uncomfortable. You grew up taking the subway; this is nothing. But was it “nothing”? I realize taking public transportation means having to forgo certain luxuries, including personal space. I’ve been part of the sardine pack during morning rush hour on the E train many a time. But these experiences didn't make me any less uncomfortable on the RIPTA. In fact, I felt even more of an invasion of privacy and space on this empty bus. As a young woman, I have certain safety concerns that the average male doesn’t typically need to think about—concerns I have been conditioned to know how to protect myself from. Harassment of women on public transport is a common occurrence that often goes under-reported; it’s something women fear is possible anytime they decide to take a public bus or train. Unfortunately, it just as often feels as though nothing can be done. Was it really an “accident”? Who would you tell? How could you stop it from happening again, to yourself or to someone else? Of course, harassment on public transport isn’t limited to women—this feeling of vulnerability spans across all genders and ages. However, over time, this has become an issue that women have had to deal with so frequently that we’ve just come to expect it as the status quo. And yet, I still often find myself wondering what defines harassment, what I should brush off, and what I can allow myself to mull over without feeling guilty of “overreacting.” The #MeToo era has brought to light the idea that
ARTS&CULTURE women should not simply have to accept invasions of their personal space. We now have a movement that expressly recognizes the daily occurrences women must deal with, or be aware of, in order to manufacture a safer environment for themselves. People are finally recognizing how unfair it is that women have always had to carry this burden. My first thought is that living during such a time of increased awareness is a privilege—but really, it is a right. As soon as I saw my stop approaching, I excused myself and darted off the bus, saying a quick thank you to the driver and making a mental note to move on. It was just another day, and odds were I would never see this man again. But there will inevitably be another man; perhaps again on the RIPTA, perhaps on the MTA. It will happen to me, to others. Although we are becoming a culture that increasingly brings these issues to light and tries to remedy them, harassment is so widespread that it’s difficult to find a solution that creates a safer environment for everyone. This can lead to a defeatist attitude in which the easiest, safest, and sometimes only choice we have is, seemingly, to just move on. But “moving on” normalizes and perpetuates the problem, so maybe this time I actually will—and should—keep thinking about it.
BYOB: Build Your Own Booze A Handy Guide to Cocktail Craftsmanship By Allie Cavallaro Illustrated by Caroline Hu
to mask the taste of bathtub gin, cheap alcohol from plastic bottles (we in the business call it “swill”) will go unnoticed. To this day, most cocktails rely on the same intertwined flavors as these original creations: sour and sweet. The sour portion usually comes from lemons or limes, and while I always prefer fresh-squeezed, many find hand-juicing both emotionally and physically taxing. If you have to use the presqueezed stuff, the little plastic lime-y and lemon-y boys in the fruit section of the supermarket (not those radioactive green ones you see in the juice
bougie, or making a f*ck-ton of cocktails for friends
aisle) make a good substitute.
who you want to impress, go to Eastside Mini Mart
If you want something citrus-y other than lemon
and buy a bag of ice for two dollars. While you’re
or lime, grapefruit juice pairs nicely with tequila.
there, throw in some limes so you can hit the five-
Add a bit of simple syrup, a tiny bit of lime juice, and
dollar card minimum—and have some sour on hand
top it off with sparkling water—you have a Paloma.
for later, when you realize I’m right about gimlets.
Now, you’re super classy, sipping something Ernest
Once your shaker is full of ice, add the
Hemingway probably nursed while writing The Sun
ingredients carefully: one cocktail at a time. Don’t
Also Rises, all because you swiped some grapefruits
get overzealous and spill sticky stuff on your desk,
from the V-Dub.
leaving your MacBook syrupy for months. Shake
The best way to achieve sweetness, the other
carefully. Alternative shakers can sometimes be
essential cocktail component, is by adding a liqueur
surprising and tricky bastards. After shaking for
(like triple sec and peach schnapps) or syrup. Triple
long enough that you start feeling cool, pour the
sec, a cheap orange liqueur, sweetens up a mixed
Good Stuff into your red solo cup and hold back the
drink while still adding more booze. It goes well with
ice (chill your cup in an ice bath if you want to make
most juices and liquors, so play around with it. If you
me laugh). Wow, you did it, you made a daiquiri!
don’t want to pay money for things—or you want to
And there you have it. Just like that, you’re
pay less—simple syrup makes another great add-on.
ready to be a bartender at your next frat party…
All you have to do is pour some white sugar into a
and all the dummies who didn’t read this will think
mason jar, add an equal amount of heated water
you’re an absolute god for making something that’s
from your kettle (aka: Jo’s microwave), put on the
not straight Svedka.
lid and shake it like a polaroid picture. Huzzah! You made a thing. It’s called simple syrup and lasts in the fridge for about four days. You can add this to pretty much anything you want to make sweeter. I put a bit
My darling friends, there are so many more ways
of simple syrup in my gimlets (gin, lime juice, simple
to get plastered than by drinking vodka straight
syrup, shake with ice, pour into a coupe so you feel
out of plastic bottles. I, as an alcohol expert having
like Jay Gatsby), but you can also use it in margaritas
served as professional bartender making four dollars
instead of triple sec (two parts tequila, one part
an hour at a bowling alley, am here to tell you to class
triple sec or simple syrup, one part lime). What’s a
up your game. Believe me, I get it: Parties are gross,
part? That takes us to...
so gross I can understand why you’d think you have to drink gross alcohol to tolerate them. But did you know that you can also power through the hours with something straight-up tasty? And that you can make it yourself?
“Allie, help me! How do I measure in ounces?! Where can I find a jigger?!” Hold your horses, friendos. Let's start with
How?
chilling in their rooms, but if you have a shot glass,
Without further ado, let’s talk cocktails:
that’s a good estimate. If you’re a oddball, and you
My friends think I’m some sort of magician for
have tablespoons, a mason jar, or one of those little
being able to mix drinks. Although my bowling alley
plastic measuring cups you get with liquid cough
bartender experience may intimidate you, the truth
syrup, a shot is 1.5 oz or about 45 ml. This translates
is, I was a terrible bowling alley bartender who made
to about three tablespoons.
cocktails up because she didn’t actually know how
Let’s break down a simple cocktail together:
to make them. And they were terrible cocktails. Why
the daiquiri—a favorite of your favorite writer/
am I so skilled now? Well, I discovered the secret to
alcoholic, Hemingway (not me, I’m more of a gimlet
the great cocktail, and it is: the internet.
gal). Perhaps this is surprising; most are familiar
The internet is full of these things called
with the drink as it has been redefined by Chili’s bars
“recipes.” A recipe is a thing that you ask Google
nationwide—trashy garbage. But the classic daiquiri
about, and then Google tells you how to make things
is actually classy, dead simple, and delicious.
that aren’t sh*t. What are the parts of a recipe?
The drink consists of 2 oz light rum, ¾ oz
Generally, ingredients, quantity, and instructions. So,
fresh lime, and ¾ oz of that simple syrup we just
what’s first?
talked about. You have all the stuff. You know the Ingredients
because “Oh my god, WTF is orgeat syrup?” First, dial down your ambitions; there’s no need to start off making mai tais. Classic, fundamental cocktails
Fighting Patriarchy in Words & Music
By Kia Caiting illustrated by Rémy Poisson
Quantities
the basics. It’s true, most people don’t have jiggers
Starting out, cocktails can be intimidating
Sing a Strong Song
measurements. So, how do you make it? That brings us to our final section. Instructions “Add all the ingredients into a shaker with ice, shake until well-chilled, strain into a chilled glass.”
never require gathering obscure ingredients. There’s
That may sound scary, but it’s not. “ALLIE, I
no reason to think you need a full bar in your dorm
DON’T HAVE A SHAKER!” I know you don’t. Do you
room to make a decent cocktail.
have a jam jar? A mason jar? A travel coffee mug?
I’ve found that prohibition-era cocktails are
Yes? You do? Then you have a f*cking shaker. Take
a great place to start. They are very simple, tasty,
your shaker or shaker alternative, and stuff some ice
and often have cute names—like gimlets, and Bee’s
you stole from Jo’s in it. Don’t. Skip. The. Ice! Every
Knees. Moreover, because the flavors were invented
cocktail tastes better served cold. If you’re feeling
If I told you 'bout my sex life, you'd call me a slut When boys be talkin' about their bitches, no one's makin' a fuss (Lily Allen, "Hard Out Here") It’s no secret: The patriarchy exists to screw women over. From the workforce to the schoolyard, systems ingrained with sexism lie in wait, ready to steal our agency and put us down. But what’s horrific about institutionalized sexism—its true paradox— is how alone it makes us feel. I’ve been ignored and shamed, told to be quiet, that I’m too big or too small, that my feelings are irrational. Some days, I feel like I’m the only girl in the world, and I might always, if it were not for Spotify. Female artists like Jorja Smith, The Spice Girls, Miss Lauryn Hill, Demi Lovato, and Aretha Franklin make me feel less alone; I know from their songs that they have endured everything I have. In a world that has taught us to hate ourselves, they have instead dared to love themselves (and other women) and celebrate their vulnerabilities, sexualities, and frustrations. With their music, they have created a sonic space for anger alongside love, a space to undermine the very messages that have shaped their lives. These women are just a small sample of the artists I’ve included in my carefully vetted “f*ckthepatriarchy” playlist on Spotify. It is six hours and 20 minutes of strength and vulnerability; sex and frustration; life-loving, ass-shaking exuberance; profound, dignified suffering. There’s `90s R&B, `60s Soul, and even a Dixie Chicks song for good measure (let’s all be honest, “Wide Open Spaces” is kind of a march 22, 2019&5
ARTS&CULTURE bop). No matter their personal takes on feminism, no song or artist on this playlist can be called apolitical; they are women taking up space and refusing to apologize for doing so. Some artists relish in resisting the patriarchy through their music, while others go about it in a more understated way (and might not even claim to be doing so). Aretha Franklin demands respect, Maggie Rogers celebrates her independence, and the members of Salt-N-Pepa just want us to know that they are getting it and will not apologize. It is my most musically incoherent playlist, and yet all its different sounds are tied together in my mind by three words with which I have a complicated relationship: “I hate men.” Of course, I don’t actually hate all men, nor do these artists—nor should anyone. But a pop song isn’t real life; it’s a space for exaggerated emotions, melodramatic narratives, and screaming to the sky. When I put this music on, each new song reinforcing the last, it feels okay to let my emotions get a little carried away as well; it seems okay to hate men. I see how such a playlist (and the incredible amount of time I spend listening to it) might come off as kind of problematic—and full disclosure, there is, indeed, a song entitled “I Hate Men (I Hate All Men).” In my defense, it happens to be a certifiable banger, and you should check it out. Besides, what do I need to defend? Frankly, I have done enough of that in my life and am tired of it. The truth is the playlist allows me, if only for a short time, to be man-hatey, and its creation was prompted by the realization that I needed to allow myself the space to feel all the pain, anger, and disappointment that comes with being female. What better way to do this than by celebrating the women who have dedicated their professional lives to documenting emotional truths? The playlist has been the soundtrack for my own personal feminist awakening as I’ve grappled with its central question: Is there value in symbolically hating men? Mama said, you're a pretty girl What's in your head, it doesn't matter (Beyonce, "Pretty Hurts") Indeed, the idea of hating anything makes me uncomfortable. Growing up, I was programmed to believe that anger was not a part of my emotional toolkit. Sure, boys would be boys—wild, impulsive, and brash—but girls? Girls could be maternal, nurturing, and collaborative, not to mention catty, calculating, and backstabbing. What girls could never be was angry… at least according to TV shows, commercials, movies, and the gender dynamics I internalized on the playground. Anger was for boys. Lacking any means of expressing anger, however, left me and many other girls with few options when we were excluded from playing with the boys at recess, when we began hearing snide comments having to
do with the contours of our pubescent bodies, when we heard older men call us “sweetie” and “honey” on street corners, and when we realized that we couldn’t safely attend parties without deploying the age-old buddy system because there could be drugs in our drinks. Instead of getting mad, many of us internalized sexism and accepted it as part of our everyday existence. Hating men (or, rather, the roles and behaviors into which men are generally pigeonholed), the natural response to these woes wasn’t a possibility. Or so I thought. Even if it makes others uncomfortable I wanna love who I am Even if it makes others uncomfortable I will love who I am (Janelle Monae, "Q.U.E.E.N.") My discovery of these songs, these women, changed that. What began as an effort to diversify my playlist (i.e. stop listening solely to white-boy indie) transformed into a discovery of a sonic space in which it was okay to scream, to yell, to cry, and to blame men—condemn them, even. It was not a space dominated by reason or moderation, but by unadulterated, unabashed, exaggerated emotions that were beautiful for the very reason that they were at the same time real and larger than life. Christina Aguilera has a son, whom she presumably loves very much. She also has an incredible song entitled “I Hate Boys.” When I got sick of male friends not even trying to understand my daily fears and frustrations, I was empowered by Lily Allen agreeing that it is “hard out here for a b*tch.” None of them apologized, ever, and so maybe I didn’t have to either. Without judgment, I could love men, hate them, and say I hated them
“Renell’s work reminds us that if we want to consume art in Berlin from a smorgasbord of international artists, we need to understand the way that events like Berlin Art Week erase the continual harm done to communities across the globe.” Tal Frieden, “Cyborgs, Not Goddesses” 3.23.18
“Giant Robot and Same Difference evoke truths that are often erased by the model minority myth: a defiant and disobedient Asian America.” Pia Ceres, “Asian American Slacker” 3.23.17
6!post–
whenever my feelings told me it was true. But when I’d try the words out, there was still one more roadblock: How could I say I hated men when not all men are bad, and, hell, some of them are even pretty great? And, because I so genuinely cared about the well-being of the men and boys in my life, how could I say I hated them in such general terms? That’s just plain ol’ reverse sexism, right? But I quickly realized that wasn’t the point. The phrase was intentionally hyperbolic; it had nothing to do with individual people or qualities. Rather, it was a symbolic tool, a tiny verbal Band Aid to heal a festering wound of subordination and inequality, as old as written history. Few things are quite as satisfying as staring into the eyes of a beloved female friend, knowingly nodding your head, and saying those oh-so-familiar words: “I hate men.” Sometimes, when the mood is light and sardonic, we’ll say the words jokingly, and other times they’ll come out when we are genuinely ready to punch a wall. The phrase is multivalent and full of hermeneutic possibility; it is at once a moment of catharsis, a declaration of war, a sob, a celebration, and an acknowledgement of the bullsh*t we all put up with. Fair? Maybe not. The epitome of rational discourse we love to venerate? Definitely not. But isn’t that the genius of music? It is a vehicle to express all that is raw, irrational, and complex. We all need a space just to be human, and this phrase and its playlist are mine. The world is still imperfect, but when I speak those words, and jam out to “Truth Hurts” by Lizzo, I suddenly feel as though I’m sticking it to every boy and every man who ever made me feel less-than, and that is a powerful thing.
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Anita Sheih a FEATURE Managing Editor Sydney Lo Section Editors Kathy Luo Sara Shapiro Staff Writers Sarah Lettes Caroline Ribet
NARRATIVE Managing Editor Celina Sun Section Editors Liza Edwards-Levin Jasmine Ngai Staff Writers Danielle Emerson Abbie Hui Naomi Kim Anneliese Mair Kahini Mehta
SOCIAL MEDIA Caleigh Aviv Camila Pavon
ARTS & CULTURE Managing Editor Julian Towers Section Editors Griffin Plaag Emily Teng Staff Writers Rob Capron Kaela Hines Pia Mileaf-Patel
Want to be involved? Email: post@browndailyherald.com!
HEAD ILLUSTRATOR Rémy Poisson BUSINESS LIAISON Saanya Jain
CO-LAYOUT CHIEFS Jacob Lee Nina Yuchi COPY CHIEF Layout Designers Amanda Ngo Amy Choi Assistant Copy Editors Steve Ju Sonya Bui Nicole Fegan WEB MASTER Mohima Sattar Jeff Demanche
NEWS
FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2019 • PAGE 9
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
»VIGIL, from page 1
COURTESY OF IVY FILM FESTIVAL
» IFF, from page 1 Beyond the Official Selection, these themes extend into the advanced screenings, speakers and projects presented throughout the festival, Venkatesh said. “Selfhood … is so integral to young film in the sense that comingof-age stories (are) kind of the nature of films being made at this age,” Gehring said. Included in this category is a screening of “Booksmart,” the directorial debut of actress Olivia Wilde on Wednesday, Apr. 10. The film follows two girls, played by Beanie Feldstein and Kaitlyn Dever, after they decide to “let loose on their last night of high school,” according to the press release. Wilde, known for her role in “House” and a number of feature films will join Feldstein, who starred in “Lady Bird,” and Dever, who recently acted as Lauren in “Beautiful Boy,” in a question-and-answer segment after the film. The film debuted in Austin last week to rave reviews — Vulture critic Emily Yoshida wrote that Feldstein and Dever have “chemistry that sings,” and that the film “manages to be inclusive and progressive, without being precious about anything or sacrificing an ounce of humor.” The film “aligns with our vision as a festival to be young and fresh and kind of unapologetically female,” Venkatesh said. Seventy-seven percent of Ivy Film Festival’s leadership is female, according to the press release, as are three out of the four directors of this year’s festival. Continuing this theme, “Mickey and the Bear,” written and directed by Annabelle Attanasio, will screen Saturday, Apr. 13. The film follows a teenage girl as she cares for her father who struggles with addiction and she grapples with the choice between family and personal fulfillment, the press release said. 25-year-old Attanasio began working on the film as her thesis project at NYU, Venkatesh said. “She’s gone through this whole process and now we’re seeing her at the other end of it as an industry professional.” Attanasio and her producing partner Lizzie
Shapiro will answer questions following the screening. Saturday’s “Rising Stars” panel will feature Logan Lerman, Danielle Macdonald and Callum Woodhouse. Lerman, known for his starring role in the Percy Jackson series and “The Perks of Being a Wallflower,” has appeared more recently in independent films, which he also sometimes executiveproduces. Macdonald recently appeared in the Netflix film “Dumplin” alongside Jennifer Aniston and was featured in the streaming service’s hit horror film “Bird Box.” Throughout the week, students will be able to attend numerous advanced screenings of feature films, including “The Farewell,” “Teen Spirit,” “Science Fair” and “Luce.” Workshops will feature producer Mike Medavoy, producer and writer Jonathan Schwartz and costume designer Beatrice Bulgari, among others. “We always try to … bridge the gap between being students and entering the industry, so we’re so excited to have … industry professionals come and run intimate workshops on different aspects of the industry.” These workshops allow for meaningful “tangible experience,” Gehring added. “I ultimately hope that students are able to see that film is not this kind of abstract … impossible industry to get involved with,” Gehring said. Today, the industry has become “about selfinitiative and independent film, young film, just taking initiative and making it happen.” Ivy Film Festival will release tickets for all events, which are free and open to the public, on Apr. 1. The official Selection Blocks will be screened throughout the week of events. “Strength,” which is presented in partnership with Bumble, will play at 7 p.m. Thursday, Apr. 11 and will feature films by female-identifying filmmakers. “Home” will play Friday, Apr. 12 at 7 p.m. and “Selfhood” Saturday, Apr. 13 at 3 p.m. in the Granoff Center for the Creative Arts Martinos Auditorium.
was so much not about peace cuts right at the heart of many of us,” Wood-Smith said, adding that though the shooting took place “halfway across the world … the likeness of the spiritual community is the likeness of a body.” Wood-Smith then invited the community to gather in an “act of communal defiance, in terms of standing together against hate, against white supremacy, against everything that pits us against each other.” Amara Majeed ’19 spoke about the harmful effects of Islamophobia on Muslim communities, referencing destabilization of Muslim communities, cases of abuse and violations of human rights throughout the world. “For our allies that took the time out of their day to show us your love, your solidarity and your support, we would like to express our sincerest gratitude … but we ask that if you stand for our murdered brothers and sisters in New Zealand, that you stand for” Muslims in China, Jerusalem, Palestine, Sudan
and elsewhere. Chaplain of the University Janet Cooper Nelson also spoke at the event, articulating her grief and hope for a better future. “I speak to you as someone who identifies as white. I speak to you as someone who identifies as Christian, and the person who did the shootings said both of those things about himself,” Cooper Nelson said, adding that “I have to take responsibility that … someone in my community has taken these actions, and for that I express my extreme sorrow, and I even go as far as to ask for forgiveness.” “I also pledge to you, that in the name of my tradition, we will strive to do better,” she said. During the open mic portion of the vigil, individuals shared their thoughts and experiences in response to the attack in Christchurch. Luqmaan Bokhary ’21 stressed the emotional impact on children in Providence, who are increasingly aware of Islamophobia in their community and beyond.
“I just hate that this (has) essentially become normalized in even children of today,” Bokhary said. Abdullah Shihipar GS reminded community members that it is possible to write letters to those in Christchurch as a way to show their support. Following the event, Amkieh expressed appreciation for the Brown community during this dark time. “Seeing this many people really made me happy to see that there were so many people that came and showed support and solidarity,” Amkieh said. “The Brown community showed itself to be like caring and welcoming, and I really love that.” The Muslim Chaplain and the Office of the Chaplains and Religious Life are available to provide support for any students in need of help at this time in light of the tragedy. “We offer pastoral care, and work in conjunction with CAPS, Student Support Services, identity centers and other offices to support the full wellbeing of students,” Wood-Smith wrote.
Want daily headlines or weekly Brown Bites in your inbox? linktr.ee/browndailyherald
COMMENTARY PAGE 10 • FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2019
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
Students should use guide to Hay library To the Editor: The concluding paragraph of Thursday’s article “Hay library houses vast collection,” noted “Fields of Hay,” the recentlylaunched undergraduate guide to the John Hay Library. As a Special Collections Assistant at the Hay, I created the guide to offer students entry points to the perhaps daunting building (the marble busts of dead guys in the Willis Reading Room are not the friendliest, I admit) and its seemingly overwhelming mass of materials. I invite students to visit the website to learn about the Hay’s standing collections, find materials pertinent to their studies and interests, request materials, read about their peers’ work and connect with other special collections on Brown’s campus. I emphasize that the Hay is home to teaching collections: The materials here are meant to be used and enjoyed by students, faculty members and community members alike. We invite anyone — including those without ties to Brown — to register online and request materials that they find enriching. The Hay’s collections, though often derived from private collectors and gifts, transform from things coveted for prestige or self-interest upon entering the library. In how these materials are used (in classes, for personal research, on display) and in what they contain (marginalia, inscriptions, correspondence), they foster connection, collaboration and community. The Hay has something for
everyone: papyrus scraps from the Book of the Dead; early editions of Galileo’s “Starry Messenger” signed by his assistant Vicenzo Viviani; George Orwell’s original manuscript of 1984; “Color Standards and Color nomenclature,” an early 20th-century, handmade book of pantone color blocks. In the stacks sit Damon’s Collection of Occult and the Smith Collection of Conjuring and Magicana, two masses of mystical and magical literature; the Pingree Collection of Indic scientific texts and Sanskrit texts on astronomy, math and medicine; the Alcohol and Addiction Studies Collections, which feature archival material from early temperance movements to the beginnings of Alcoholics Anonymous, research on addiction treatment and material from anti-drug campaigns; and, of course, the University Archives, which document the ins and outs of Brown’s history, including information on the tunnels and the Cold War bunker on Brown’s campus. (It’s underneath Wriston. No, I have not been granted access. Yes, I have asked.) The materials in the Hay breathe life into the subjects we study at Brown, and they bring us much closer to the many pasts that have shaped our present. Whether in their first or last semester on campus, I encourage students to seek out and connect with these pasts, and I wholeheartedly, though biasedly, recommend Fields of Hay as a launching point for that inquiry. Shira Buchsbaum ’19
Find us online! facebook.com/browndailyherald
browndailyherald.com
@the_herald
Location: 195 Angell St., Providence, R.I. www.browndailyherald.com
@browndailyherald
youtube.com/browndailyherald
Editorial Leadership
Sections
Multimedia & Production
Business
Editor-in-Chief Emily Davies
Arts & Culture Editors Elise Ryan Annabelle Woodward
Design Editors Bilal Ismail Ahmed Dylan Tian Julie Wang
General Managers Ravi Betzig Nicholas Masiakowski
Metro Editors Colleen Cronin Sophie Culpepper Celia Hack
Head Photo Editors Tiffany Ding Benjamin Turuño
Office Manager Diane Silvia
Managing Editors Anna Kramer Priyanka Podugu Senior Editors Anita Sheih Sarah Wang Editorial Page Editors Grace Layer Krista Stapleford
News Editors Katherine Bennett Jacob Lockwood Melanie Pincus Allie Reed
post- magazine Editor-in-Chief Anita Sheih
Science & Research Editors Cate Ryan Chris Schutte Sports Editors Alexandra Russell Alex Smolar COMMENTARY Opinions Editors Rebecca Aman Emily Miller Derek Simshauser
Copy Desk Chief Kelley Tackett Illustrations Editor Daphne Zhao
Directors Sales: Bersabel Yifru Finance: Rudra Srivastava, Reynaldo Blandon Strategy: Edwin Farley
Editorial contact: 401-351-3372 herald@browndailyherald.com
Advertising contact: 401-351-3372 advertising@browndailyherald.com
Submissions: The Brown Daily Herald publishes submissions in the form of op-eds and letters to the editor. Op-eds are typically between 750 and 1000 words, though we will consider submissions between 500 and 1200 words. Letters to the editor should be around 250 words. While letters to the editor respond to an article or column that has appeared in The Herald, op-eds usually prompt new discussions on campus or frame new arguments about current discourse. All submissions to The Herald cannot have been previously published elsewhere (in print or online — including personal blogs and social media), and they must be exclusive to The Herald. Submissions must include no more than two individual authors. If there are more than two original authors, The Herald can acknowledge the authors in a statement at the end of the letter or op-ed, but the byline can only include up to two names. The Herald will not publish submissions authored by groups. The Herald does not publish anonymous submissions. If you feel your circumstances prevent you from submitting an op-ed or letter with your name, please email herald@browndailyherald.com to explain your situation. You can submit op-eds to opinions@browndailyherald.com and letters to letters@browndailyherald.com. When you email your submission, please include (1) your full name, (2) an evening or mobile phone number in case your submission is chosen for publication and (3) any affiliation with Brown University or any institution or organization relevant to the content of your submission. Please send in submissions at least 24 hours in advance of your desired publication date. The Herald only publishes submissions while it is in print. The Herald reserves the right to edit all submissions. If your piece is considered for publication, an editor will contact you to discuss potential changes to your submission. Commentary: The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.
Video Editor Victoria Caruso Max Dekle
Corrections: The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication.
Graphics Editors Sarah Martinez
Advertising: The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion. The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. is a financially independent, nonprofit media organization bringing you The Brown Daily Herald, BlogDailyHerald and Post- Magazine. The Brown Daily Herald has served the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement and once during Orientation by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each member of the community. Subscription prices: $200 one year daily, $100 one semester daily. Copyright 2019 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Postmaster: Please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906.
NEWS
FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2019 • PAGE 11
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
Shake Shack shakes up Thayer Trump issues executive order
to protect campus free speech
Opening day for the national burger chain brings long lines, eager students, tasty treats
12 executive agencies tasked with using grants to ensure colleges follow existing free speech laws
By JORDAN KEI-RAHN STAFF WRITER
By ALEX SMOLAR SPORTS EDITOR
Shake Shack finally opened its doors to the public Wednesday morning following a ribbon cutting ceremony attended by Providence Mayor Jorge Elorza, Shake Shack team members and the owners of 249 Thayer St. The ceremony took place in front of an ever-growing line of customers waiting for their first taste of Shake Shack’s Rhode Island offerings. Individuals waiting in line were serenaded by the local Extraordinary Rendition Band. “Looking at the line of about 50 to 80 people right now, it is going to be a busy day for us for sure,” said Dave Yearwood, Shake Shack’s area director of Connecticut and now Rhode Island. Customers started arriving even before some of the staff. “Our first guest here, it’s her birthday today and she wanted to be a part of the Shake Shack opening, so she has been waiting here since 8 o’ clock in the morning, potentially earlier.” Bryan Huang ’22 arrived at around 9 a.m. only to find a line already forming. Huang was drawn to Shake Shake by a “need for something meaty and delicious,” he said. “A consistently delicious burger is hard to find in Providence.” Another student in line, Rebecca Herman ’22, headed straight to Shake Shack after her class ended at 9:50 a.m. “I’m a native New Yorker, so Shake Shack runs in my blood,” Herman said. “I’ve been planning on coming for opening day for a while.” An advocate for the classic ShackBurger, Herman also looked forward to trying the new “Chocolate Thayer Cake” custard made with PVDonuts. Ben Myers ’21 already tried the flavor on Tuesday, calling it Shake Shack’s “real kicker … an extravagant but pretty simple treat.” But for Caleb Trotz ’22, the main culinary attraction remained
JORDAN KEI-RAHN / HERALD
The Shake Shack on Thayer Street is the first in the state. The occasion was attended by Providence Mayor Jorge Elorza. Shake Shack’s special sauce. “It’s just really good,” says Trotz. “They won’t tell me what’s in it. I’ve asked, and they just won’t tell me.” Students’ praise for the restaurant extended past the food. Myers was struck by the attention staff paid to customers and said that “everyone is highly professional and courteous, and will get you whatever you need.” Part of the restaurant’s warm ambiance seems to stem from the mural that greets customers as they enter. The work of Rhode Island School of Design alum Jing Wei — who also attended the grand opening — represents Shake Shack’s first contribution to local art, which is one of their philanthropic goals, The Herald previously reported. Wei gained inspiration from “her college days, which were particularly community-oriented,” adding that she drew from “memories of hanging out and lounging on the RISD beach and also the Brown lawns.” Shake Shack also featured her designs on tote bags and notebooks given to the first
100 patrons of the restaurant, a giveaway that drew even more students, including Trotz. The lines continued throughout most of the day, reaching peak volume during the dinner rush. “It’s been a lot at once, and in-progress, but (with) all the anticipation and excitement, we’re just kind of ready to make some burgers, make some Shakes, and bring some of that Shackiness to Thayer,” Yearwood said.
President Donald Trump signed an executive order Thursday afternoon designed to protect “free inquiry” on college campuses, which supporters have called a victory for free speech and opponents have criticized for government overreach. The order, titled “Improving Free Inquiry, Transparency, and Accountability at Colleges and Universities,” asks 12 executive agencies to use federal grants to guarantee that colleges and universities comply with existing free speech laws by threatening to withhold funds. It does not affect federally-funded financial aid and tuition programs. The University, through a working group led by Provost Richard Locke P ’18, will spend the next few days reviewing the order before sharing next steps with the Brown community. “Freedom of expression is an essential component of academic freedom, which protects our ability to fulfill our core mission of advancing knowledge,” wrote President Christina Paxson P’19 in an email to The Herald. Earlier this month, after President Trump suggested the executive order in a speech to the Conservative Political Action Conference, Locke expressed
his opposition during a faculty meeting. Locke referred to an executive order on free speech as “a tremendous government overreach into the affairs of universities, both public and private.” Since the University is already committed to free speech, an executive order of this nature is “unnecessary,” he added. President Trump said that by signing the executive order, he is “taking historic action to defend American students and American values that have been under siege,” the Washington Post reported. According to the order, the executive agencies tasked with enforcing free speech on college campuses are the Departments of Defense, the Interior, Agriculture, Commerce, Labor, Health and Human Services, Transportation, Energy and Education; the Environmental Protection Agency; the National Science Foundation and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. The order does not create a new agency tasked with policing or defining free speech on campus, nor is there a clear implementation strategy for withholding federal funds to universities. Executive action on free speech has been a priority for conservative activists, who allege that conservative viewpoints are suppressed on college campuses throughout the country. Founder and Executive Director of Turning Point USA Charlie Kirk was one of the leading activists urging Trump to sign the executive order, according to Business Insider.
STAY UP-TO-DATE. FOLLOW US ON FACEBOOK. FACEBOOK.COM/BROWNDAILYHERALD
NEWS THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2019
» ELECTIONS, from page 1 Friday after carefully considering the results of the referendum,” wrote Director of News and Editorial Development Brian Clark in email to The Herald. Shortly after results were announced, Brown Divest and Brown Students for Israel posted responses to the referendum outcome on their Facebook pages. “Today is a historic day for Brown as we take an emboldened and clear stand against the University’s complicity in human rights abuses in Palestine and in similar systems of oppression across the world,” Brown Divest wrote. “We will continue this momentum and come together as a community to hold the administration accountable.” BSI called the referendum outcome “a defeat for all students who believe there is a better way to pursue peace between Israelis and Palestinians, who seek intellectually honest discourse about Israel and the conflict and who prioritize a safe and inclusive community at Brown.” They pledged to “continue to share our beliefs with Brown’s administration and encourage them to reject divestment.” Zhou, who is currently UCS vice president, received 50.1 percent of the vote to defeat current UCS Chair of Campus Life Melissa Lee ’20 and UCS Secretary Vanessa Garcia ’20.5.
VICTORIA YIN / HERALD
Julian De Georgia ’20 (center) was elected UFB chair with 51.9 percent of the vote. De Georgia, who currently serves as UFB vice chair, defeated UFB At-Large Member Alesandro Walker ’20. Lee earned 28.8 percent and Garcia UFB and UCS representatives, and to to overtake UFB At-Large Member Alereceived 14.1 percent of the vote. The make some change and hopefully make sandro Walker ’20 in the race for chair. remaining seven percent of the vote Brown a better place for all students.” “I think that there’s a lot that we went to write-in candidates. Zhou’s election marks the first time can do to improve,” De Georgia told “I’m very excited, very honored to since 2015 that a UCS president-elect The Herald. “I’m excited about the opbe given an opportunity to represent has served on the Council at the time portunity.” our incredible student body,” Zhou of their election, The Herald previously Carroll, who is UCS Appointments told The Herald after results were an- reported. chair, defeated UCS Chair of Student nounced. “I’m really looking forward De Georgia, who is currently UFB Activities Alex Song ’20 with 72 percent to working with the newly-elected vice chair, won 51.9 percent of the vote of the vote. Song received 25.8 percent
of the vote and write-in candidates receiving the remaining votes. “I’m super passionate about UCS and that won’t change,” Song told The Herald. “There are plenty of other places you can do amazing stuff on UCS, and Jason will do an awesome job.” Kabba, who is currently a UFB member at-large, won 51.9 percent of the vote to defeat At-Large Members Phillip Champagne ’21 and Peter Deegan ’21, who received 28.7 and 19.5 percent of the vote, respectively. The races for chairs of Academic Affairs, Student Activities, Campus Life and Student Wellness were all uncontested. Two candidates without prior UCS experience — Livingstone Harriott Jr. ’20 and Chima Amushie ’21 — will assume the roles of chair of Academic Affairs and Student Activities, respectively. Zanagee Artis ’22, a member of the Council’s Academic Affairs and Campus Life committees,will be chair of Campus Life, and Shivani Nishar ’20 was re-elected chair of Student Wellness. All the unsuccessful candidates for UFB chair and vice chair were elected to serve as UFB at-large representatives. Current members Gianna DeVincenzo ’22, Nimo Ismail ’21 and Jeewon Shin ’21 and newcomers Okezie Okoro ’22 and Akilesh Raman ’22 were also chosen as at-large representatives.
CORRECTION A previous version of the March 21 article titled “New businesses move into space formerly occupied by Café Paragon” incorrectly named Jack Wrenn’s degree as MA’18 GS. In fact, he is Jack Wrenn ScM’18 GS.
B R OW N U N I V E R S I T Y ON CAMPUS and ONLINE
JUNE 24 AUGUST 9
PRE-REGISTRATION OPENS APRIL 1
brown.edu/summersession