THE BROWN DAILY HERALD FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2006
Volume CXLI, No. 13 WANDERING BARDS Four seniors, known as the Peripatetic Playwrights, have a new take on the old SciLi challenge ARTS & CULTURE 3
www.browndailyherald.com
An independent newspaper serving the Brown community since 1891 ‘ROID RANT Hugh Murphy ’06 writes that Rafael Palmeiro could get away with humping a badger in the Vatican SPORTS 12
THE HERALD POLL
THE SIXTH WOMAN Athlete of the Week Jaclyn Vocell ’06 shares the inspiration for her clutch performance on the w. hoops team SPORTS 12
TODAY
TOMORROW
mostly sunny 34 / 24
mostly cloudy 36 / 28
Queer Alliance on probation amid SPG fallout
A HOT AND STEAMY SITUATION
Responses highlight student disapproval of plus/minus
BY ERIC BECK NEWS EDITOR
CCC is now likely to hold a University-wide forum on the issue in late February or early March. Tristan Freeman ’07, chair of the Academic and Administrative Affairs
Queer Alliance, Alpha Phi Alpha and the Brotherhood — student organizations whose parties last semester sparked a broad review of the University’s social events and alcohol policies — have been placed on probation following disciplinary hearings by the Office of Student Life. QA, whose Sex Power God party resulted in over two dozen students requiring emergency medical attention for intoxication and landed the University in the national spotlight on Fox News’ “The O’Reilly Factor,” is on probation until December 2006, Margaret Klawunn, associate vice president for campus life and dean for student life, told The Herald. Klawunn said QA leaders managing Sex Power God did not adhere to some elements of their event-management plan, such as the number, location and responsibilities of student event managers, though she stressed that the organization was not held responsible for issues beyond its control, such as the large number of students who arrived intoxicated to the alcohol-free event. Before it can hold any social functions
see POLLING, page 9
see QA, page 4
BY SIMMI AUJLA SENIOR STAFF WRITER
The results of a Herald poll released Tuesday — which revealed that 70 percent of students disapprove of immediately adding pluses and minuses to the University’s grading system — seem to corroborate what administrators and students involved in debates over the proposal already suspected. Several members of the College Curriculum Council, including Dean of the College and CCC Chair Paul Armstrong, said they were not surprised by the high disapproval rating, which was the strongest expression of negative opinion on any question in the poll. The 63.6 percent of students who were against adding pluses and minuses for future classes reflected the second strongest reaction. But student opposition to pluses and minuses is not shared by the faculty — a 2003 Sheridan Center poll showed that 80 percent of the faculty was in favor of plus/ minus grading. In December, the CCC postponed a
Jacob Melrose / Herald
Steam continued to emanate from two separate locations on the Main Green, trapping a single bike, flooded in lights and guarded by DPS officers throughout the night. The University started to restore heat and hot water to all buildings without such amenities for most of yesterday, according to an e-mail from Facilities Management to all on-campus residents. Heat to 47 buildings may once again be disrupted at 9 a.m. this morning. The unexpected leak in the high temperature water loop that sprung early yesterday has affected faculty and students across campus. To conserve heat, Facilities Management urged researchers to close fume hoods and students to lower storm windows. recommendation on making pluses and minuses part of the University’s grading system. At its meeting Jan. 31, the CCC called on the Faculty Executive Committee to approve a faculty forum regarding the proposal. In response to a suggestion from the FEC at Tuesday’s faculty meeting, the
U. works to bolster its defense of open curriculum BY REBECCA JACOBSON SENIOR STAFF WRITER
After three years of evaluation, Harvard University’s core curriculum could undergo major restructuring if a faculty vote occurs this spring. But as Harvard and other peer institutions examine the importance of general education requirements, Dean of the College Paul Armstrong says Brown is taking steps to strengthen arguments in favor of its open curriculum. Key among these measures is a $100,000 grant the University received from the Teagle Foundation — a New York City-based organization that encourages “broad and intellectually stimulating curricula,” according to its online mission statement — to support a working group led by Brown and composed of eight schools with open curricula of various kinds. The working group has been meeting once a month since the beginning of the academic year to produce a “white paper” that articulates the values and goals of an open curriculum. Representatives from the schools, which include Wesleyan University and Amherst College, should have the “white paper” completed by June, Armstrong said. Armstrong said the project will also develop assessment measures to evaluate the concrete effects of an open curriculum. These will primarily examine the experiences of Brown alums. “Let’s look at what our graduates have actually learned,” he said. “Let’s look at the learning outcomes that are associated with the values that we have. We say lots of things about what a Brown
education does to prepare students for lives of usefulness and reputation. Let’s try to formalize that knowledge, assess it and see whether in fact the claims we make are true or not.” Over the past 15 to 20 years, the University has encountered challenges from “conservative educational pundits” that argue “in favor of a core curriculum for reasons that are contrary to values that I hold as an educator and values that inform our curriculum at Brown,” Armstrong said. In April 2004, the American Council of Trustees and Alumni issued letter grades to 50 universities and colleges, including all eight Ivy League and Seven Sisters colleges. ACTA, founded by Lynne Cheney, advocates a core curriculum — a series of general courses taken by all students — instead of distribution requirements or an open curriculum like Brown’s. In the 2004 report, ACTA identified seven subjects vital to a contemporary liberal arts education, such as literature, economics and mathematics, and surveyed schools to determine if broad courses in the seven fields were required or were merely offerings within a distribution. Brown received an F. No Ivy League school received higher than a C. ACTA President Anne Neal commended Brown for openly advertising what it does and does not offer, unlike other institutions that claim to have a core curriculum but in reality only mandate distribution requirements. Still, Neal maintains that the University’s curriculum does students a disservice.
Editorial: 401.351.3372 Business: 401.351.3260
see CORE, page 9
From Little Haiti to Brown and now — Congress?
Dufirstson Neree ’96 could be the country’s first HaitianAmerican congressman BY ASHLEY CHUNG CONTRIBUTING WRITER
Dufirstson Neree ’96 did not plan on a future in politics while he was at Brown. But today, he’s breaking new ground as the first Haitian immigrant ever to run for Congress. In the 10 years since he graduated, Neree has started two non-profit organizations, founded a credit union that serves his Haitian-American FEATURE community in Miami and earned two graduate degrees along the way. His commitment to solving economic inequality has often focused on Little Haiti, the Miami neighborhood in which he grew up. But after fostering economic equality through nonprofits and work in the private sector, Neree now seeks to effect change in his
Bill Cooke / Miami Herald
Dufirstson Neree ‘96 is the first HaitianAmerican candidate for Congress.
195 Angell Street, Providence, Rhode Island
hometown from the floor of the House of Representatives. His race against incumbent and member of the Congressional Black Caucus Rep. Kendrick Meek, D-Fla., is turning heads, but Neree said support for his candidacy has been forthcoming from both Little Haiti’s citizens and his former Brown classmates. While Brown may not have directly propelled him towards his congressional campaign, Neree credits his classmates and the “spirit” of Brown for inspiring him to pursue his dreams of changing the world for the better. From Haiti to… Little Haiti Neree was born in Cap-Haitian, Haiti and immigrated to Florida at age five. Though his memories of Haiti are scarce, he does recall peaceful images of a good life — sitting on his grandmother’s lap, walking along the beach and going to kindergarten wearing his bright yellow uniform shirt. But in Miami, daily life was more complicated. In the 1980s, the diverse community of the city was extremely segregated among Haitians, AfricanAmericans, Cuban-Americans and Caucasians. Neree witnessed his first public riot as an elementary school student. “It was an intense environment,” he said. To earn money for his private high school tuition, Neree began working at Ben Photo Express 54, located in the center of Little Haiti, Miami’s Haitian see NEREE, page 8 News tips: herald@browndailyherald.com