Boston Or Berlin: How To Fund The System?
Given a putative choice of a health system funded largely by tax, or alternatively, largely by private individuals, most tend to opt for central, Government funding. This is the case for most people, although those who currently pay for VHI or BUPA cover are slightly more in favour of private funding than are others.
HEALTH FUNDING : BOSTON OR BERLIN? Adults aged 15+
Individuals healthcare funding should be by…
(100%)
Governments through tax
71
Private individuals Both Don't Know
Privately insured (48%)
Medical Cards (31%)
Hospital visit past year (16%)
Hospital visits in wider family past year (29%)
77
75
77
16
14
14
62
29
21 3 5
5
2 3
6
5
5 4
4
Q. In your opinion, do you think the healthcare expenses of individuals SHOULD be paid for mainly by a) Governments through taxation, or b) Private individuals, whether through private insurance, or out of their own pockets?
The „Boston or Berlin‟ fixation is not a uniquely Irish phenomenon. Right across the world there is a general conviction that Government funding should take pre-eminence, albeit with the sole exception of Switzerland, where a slight majority favour individual funding.
In America and Indonesia the balance of preference is even (50:50) in each country, but in many other countries where healthcare might be regarded as progressive, the balance in favour of the exchequer is quite strong (for example in Sweden 77% favour central funding, in The Netherlands 66%, in Canada 79% and so on.)
22