Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable Development - A Case of Virar City, Maharashtra

Page 1


Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable Development - ACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

Urbanisation

● "Urbanizationistheprocessofsocial,economic,andpoliticalchange thattransformsapopulationfromprimarilyruraltoprimarilyurban."(UnitedNationsPopulationDivision,2018)

● "The proportion of a country's population living in urban areas comparedtoruralareas"(WorldBank,2021).

Urbanisation at Global level

● According to UN in 2021 56.2% of the world's population lives in urbanareas,i.e 4.4 billion people.

● TheUNprojectsthatthistrendwillcontinue,andby 2050, two-thirds of the world's population will live in urban areas.(UnitedNations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2021)."WorldUrbanizationProspects:The2021Revision".

India’s Rapidly Urbanising Top 3 Metropolitan Regions

MetropolitanRegion

NationalCapitalRegion (Delhi)

KolkataMetropolitanArea

INTRODUCTION

Source: Ministry of Housing and UrbanAffairs

Source: Ministry of Housing and UrbanAffairs

Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable DevelopmentACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

● Virar isaoneofthefourcitiespartofVasai-Virar Sub Region, situated at the north-west corner of theMumbaiMetropolitanRegion.

● The subregion is from Greater Mumbai and Mira-BhayanderbyVasaiCreek.However,dueto the development of the road and Suburban Rail network,itisstrategicallylinkedtoMumbai.

● Due to close proximity to Mumbai, Virar is experiencing rapid urban growth. With high prohibitive land prices in Mumbai, low and middle-incomehouseholdsareshiftingtoVirar.

● Thus,ithasbeenservingasagrowingdormitory town to Mumbai city with almost 60% population (CDP, VVMC) using Local Railways to commute regularlyforemploymentopportunities.

VIRAR CITYLocation & Linkages

Source: VVMC

Connectivity Road: Mumbai-Ahmedabad Highway (NH-48); Western Express Highway (NH-8) Railway: Virar station on Western Suburban Railway Airport: Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj InternationalAirport (60 kms)

StudyArea: Virar City, Maharashtra. HaswitnessedRapid urbanisationinpast decadesandexpecting massiveinfluxofmigrants incomingincomingyears.

Literature Review

● Urbanization: History, Theory, Causes, Consequences, Definition of Indian cities, Major Problems or Urban Areas in India ,Sustainable Urbanisation,

● Development Goals: Goal 11. Sustainable Cities and Communities, SDG Urban Index: NITI Aayog

Aim: Sustainable Planning and Development of Virar City.

PROPOSALSAND RECOMMENDATIONS

PRIORITISINGTHE CONCERNEDAREAS

1 To examine the urbanisation trends in a spatio-temporal context and responsible factors

11.3: Inclusive and SustainableUrbanisation 11.3.1 - Relating Land Consumption and PopulationGrowth

METHODOLOGY

Urban Population Growth and Spatial Growth

● Events leading to urbanization.(Timeline)

● Population growth rate (%)

● Ward wise population (no.)

● Ward wise density of population (no. of persons/sq.km)

● Direction of Growth

● Factors affecting growth and growth direction

● Total change in built up area (%)

● Land consumption rate to population growth rate (%)

● Percentage Change in occupational structure. (no. and %)

● Employment trend in Main, Marginal and Non Working Population. (no. and %)

● Land Consumption Rate (%)

● Percentage increase in no. of PropertiesResidential and Commercial (no. and %)

● Built - up area per capita for the year 2021 (m2/person)

IDENTIFICATIONOF ISSUES

DATAANALYSIS

2 To examine the status of infrastructure with respect to the growing population.

Land Use

11.1:SafeandAffordable Housing Encroachment

11.2: Affordable and Sustainable TransportationSystems

Transportation

● Percentage of Proposed Land Use Categories (sq km & %)

● Percentage Change in Landuse -Land Cover 2008 - 2019 (sq km & %)

● Percentage Built up in restricted areas

● Marking of the major encroachment zones

● Destination and No. of train trips from Virar (no.)

● No. of Daily commuters.(no.)

● Detail of Virar Railway Station with entries approach roads and parking.

● Classifications of Roads (types and lengths in km)

● Comparison of road lengths of each category.

11.6.: Reduce the environmental Impact of cities-AirQuality

11.7: Provide Access to SafeandInclusiveGreen andPublicSpaces Open Public Spaces

11.6.1 Reduce the environmental Impact of cities-SWM Solid Waste Management

6.1: Safe and Affordable DrinkingWater Water Supply

3.8: Achieve Universal HealthCoverage Health Care

4.1. Free Primary and SecondaryEducation Education

3 To review the existing governance, acts and policies to monitor the growth of the city.

● Percentage change in Existing Land Use in comparison of the proposed Land Use map 2027 (sq km & %)

● Percentage increase in encroachment in restricted areas

● Density of Roads (km/sq km)

● Marking of Conflict points, eg Parking, Bottlenecks Traffic Areas, Hawkers, Encroachment of footpath and Streets.

● No. of Busses, trips, bus stops

● Proportion of population that has convenient access to public transport

● Percentage increase in No. of Vehicles registered. (%)

● Annual mean levels of fine particulate matter (e.g. PM2.5 and PM10) in the city.

● Air quality mapping at various monitoring centers in Virar.

● Share of occupied land by Open Public Space, existing and proposed (%)

● Share of population with access to open space in public spaces (%)

● Share of built-up area of the city that is open space in public use (%)

● Proportion of municipal solid waste collected and managed in controlled facilities out of total municipal waste generated

● MSW collected

● MSW managed in controlled facilities

● Service Level Benchmarks

● Proportion of population using safely managed drinking water services.

● No. and type of Healthcare public and private facilities

● No. of Private and Public Schools

● Coverage of Public Schools

11.3.2:urbanplanningand management that operates regularly and democratically Governance ● Hierarchy of Governance

● Departments, Roles & Responsibilities Structure and No. of Staff

● Service Level Benchmarks

● Mapping the source of water and supply to the city.

● No. of health physicians per lakh population.

● Coverage of essential health services

● No. of Degree Colleges and their accessibility.

● Schemes

● Category wise Complaints

● Survey - Likert Scale

4 Identify the issues and provide solutions and recommendations for the same.

Data Collection Primary:FieldVisits,Surveys,InterviewwithGovernmentOfficialsand residents,SurveyForms.

Secondary:CensusThaneDistrictHandbooks,VVcityDevelopmentPlan2007-2027,City SanitationPlan,2020,AirPollutionControlPlan,2020,EaseofLivingIndexSurvey2020T, MunicipalPerformanceIndex,Report,DepartmentwiseReports.

BC Emergence of Early Cities

Urban Population Fluctuations

UrbanlifebeganintheMiddleandNear East(present-dayIran),followedbythe MayacultureinMexicoandriverbasinsin ChinaandIndia.

1200-1300 AD

Urbanpopulationstartedfluctuating betweenone andsevenpercentof thetotalpopulation.

3500

Early Largest Cities in the World

Chang'an (Xi'an) and Hangzhou were the largest citiesintheworldwithoveronemillionpeople,while London did not reach that population until the 1700s.

CLASSIFICATION OF URBAN

AREAS IN INDIA

● Allmunicipalcorporations,municipal boards, cantonments and notified areas.

● All localities though not in themselves local bodies but forming partofacityortownagglomeration.

● Other places satisfying all three followingconditions

oPopulationexceeds5,000

o At least 75 %of the working population engages in non-agricultural pursuits

o The density of population exceeds 400personspersquarekm.

(Source: Census of India)

MAJOR CHALLENGES FACED BY URBANAREAS

● LackofEfficientTransport

● SlumsandSquatterSettlements

● DegradationofEnvironmentalQuality

● SewerageProblems

● UrbanHeatIsland

● UrbanFlooding

● IneffectiveFunctioningofULBs

Rapid Urbanization in Developed Countries

RapidurbanizationinEurope,Americas andAustralia.Numberoflargecities 1increasedto946;NewYorklargest (2.3M).

1950

HISTORYOF URBANISATION

1CE -1850 AD

Urbanization in the 19th Century

Urbanpopulation<3%in1800duetofoodand transportationlimitations.In1850,only3cities had >1M inhabitants (London, Beijing, Paris).About 110 cities had >100,000 inhabitants.

The concept of sustainable urbanizationemergesasanew trendinwhichsustainable,social and environmental dynamics are prioritized by abandoning the classical economic-based developmentapproach.

The Sustainable Development Goals orGlobalGoalsarea collectionofseventeeninterlinked objectivesdesignedtoserveasa "sharedblueprintforpeaceand prosperityforpeopleandtheplanet, nowandintothefuture".

SDG Urban Index: NITIAayog ➔ NITIAayogunderthe Indo-GermanCooperation releasedtheinauguralSustainable DevelopmentGoals(SDGs)Urban IndexandDashboard2021–22.

➔ Itranks56urbanareason77SDG indicatorsacross46targetsofthe SDGframework.

2000

Theory of Self-Generated Urbanisation

Present Day Rapid Global Urbanization

Marked a more catastrophic rapid urbanisation growthallovertheworld,ashalfofthepeoplein theworldwerenowlivinginurbanareasby2008

"Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present, without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs."

Categorizing Targets of SDG 11

11.3: InclusiveandSustainable Urbanisation 11.2: Affordable and Sustainable Transportation Systems

11.6Reducethe environmental Impactofcities

11.5: Reduce the Adverse Effects of NaturalDisasters.

11.C: Support least developed countries, including through financial and technical assistance, in building sustainable and resilient buildings utilizing localmaterials

11. A: Support positive economic, social and environmental links between urban, peri-urban and rural areas by strengthening national and regional development planning

11.1: Safe and Affordable Housing

11.4: Protect the world’s CulturalandNaturalHeritage

11.7: Provide Access to Safe and Inclusive Green and Public Spaces

<= direct relevanceto

<= direct relevanceto

7 SDGs (1, 3, 8, 9,10,11,13)

4SDGs(12,13, 14,15)

11.B: Sustainable and ResilientCities

SDG 5: Gender equality and empowerallwomenandgirls

SDG 16: Peaceful and inclusive societies & justice forall

SDG17:GlobalPartnership

Make Cities and Human Settlement Inclusive, Safe, Resilient and Sustainable.

Source:

Workshop on Implementation of SDG 11 in cities Takase, 2018

1. A Sustainable Model of Urbanization for Indian Cities, A Case Study of New Delhi

Developing model for sustainable urbanization for Indian cities, focusing on urban housing, using New Delhiasabenchmark.

➔ Urbansprawl

➔ Housingshortage

LITERATURE REVIEW

2. An Analysis of Spatio-Temporal Urbanization

Patterns in Northwest China

Explore the spatio-temporal patterns and drivers of urbanization in northwest China and identify the need for sustainable planning strategies.

➔ Squattersettlements

➔ Environmentalimpact

➔ Transportationissues

➔ Waterscarcityandpollution

➔ Wastemanagement

➔ Integratedplanning

➔ Green Urbanism (triple-zero framework)

➔ Land-UseChange

➔ UrbanizationIntensity

➔ Urbanization along the Urban–RuralGradient

➔ DriversofUrbanization

➔ Spatio-temporal analysis of Delhi's urban sprawl growth from1977topresent.

➔ Comparison of Delhi's City Development Plan provisions with published papers to assess the current status of environmental impact and provisions.

➔ Unplannedurbansprawl

➔ Housingshortage

➔ Formation of Squatter Settlements

➔ EnvironmentalConcern

➔ Transportation pollution and congestion.

➔ Waterscarcityandpollution.

➔ Trashdisposal.

➔ Multilevel logistic regression analysis.

➔ Infrastructure development leadingtourbansprawls

➔ Buffer analysis to analyse land urbanization intensity index(LUII)

➔ Regression analysis to examine the relationship between various spatial variablesandurbanization.

➔ Distantsub-centers

➔ Disregard for geographic features.

➔ Implement interlinked/integrated planning to address urban challengescomprehensively.

➔ Emphasize principles of Green Urbanism, including triple-zero frameworks of zero fossil-fuel energy, zero waste, and zero gas emissions.

3. Urban growth and transport: understanding the spatial temporal relationship Investigates the relationship between urban growth and transport in Jeddah city using spatial temporal analysis techniquestoinformpolicies.

➔ Annual urban spatial expansionindex

➔ Landusechangeindex

➔ Populationdensityindex

➔ Transport infrastructure expansionindex

➔ Transport infrastructure expansionindex

➔ Roadareadensityindex(area, percapita,residential)

➔ Urban trips density index (per capita,residential)

➔ Statistical analysis of the quantified indicators - The Pearson correlation analysis is implemented using SPSS 18software.

➔ Spatial proximity analysis using buffer analysis function ofGIS

➔ Strong urban-transport relationship

➔ Transport drives urban growth

➔ Imbalance in supply-demand leadingtocongestion

➔ Highwaysdrivelanduse

➔ Needforfurtherresearch

➔ Focus on preserving productive farmland considering geographicalconstraints.

➔ Policies should regulate urban expansion, protect farmlands, culturalsites.

➔ Land change simulations to exploreplanningpolicyoptions.

➔ Suggests further research using Spatial statistical analysis and Dynamic modeling to gain a better understanding of the reciprocal relationship between urbangrowthandtransport.

4. Research on satellite urban transportation and land spatial planning in big data environment

The aim of this study is to explore the use of big data in analyzing and improving the spatial and transportation planning of satellite towns, with a focus on a people-orientedapproach.

➔ Influencing factors of human settlementsinsatellitetowns.

➔ Space distance of satellite towntraffic.

➔ Time distance of satellite town traffic

➔ Categoricalanalysis

➔ Spatial Distance analysis(Evacuation theory of big cities in developing countries and Spatial structureplanningprinciples)

➔ Literature review and theoreticalanalysis

➔ Dataqualityandaccuracy

➔ Privacyandsecurity

➔ Biasanddiscrimination

➔ Technicalexpertise

➔ Publictrustandparticipation

➔ Utilizing Big data technology to improveurbantrafficplanningand decision-makingprocesses.

5. Transit Oriented Development and Its Impact on Level of Service of Roads & METRO: A Case Study of Mumbai Metro Line-I

Evaluatesthe impact of Transit Oriented Development in Mumbai by predicting mode choice behavior and evaluating indirectimpactssuchasfinancial feasibility,fuelconsumption,and traveltime.

LITERATURE REVIEW

➔ LandUseSurvey

➔ Traffic Volume Count Survey

➔ ModeChoiceModel

➔ Prediction of mode choicebehavior

➔ FuelConsumption

➔ Saving in Travel Time andValueofTime

➔ ImpactAnalysis

➔ FinancialFeasibility

ForapplyingTOD:

➔ Impact on existing infrastructure

➔ Unplanned Vertical development (FSI control)

➔ Inadequacyofmetroservices

➔ Wrongly predicting Mode shareshift

➔ Poorexistinginfrastructure.

➔ EvaluateTODimpactbeforehand.

➔ Limit vertical development based oninfrastructure.

➔ Check adequacy of metro services.

➔ Predictmodechoicebehavior.

➔ Improveexistinginfrastructure.

6. Urbanization in India –

Spatiotemporal analysis using remote sensing data

Analyze the spatial growth and future modeling of urban development in the 12 largest Indian urban agglomerations using multitemporal remote sensingandlandscapemetrics.

➔ Multitemporal remote sensing

➔ Time-series of Landsat data

➔ Absolute parameters (e.g. areal growth or built-updensity)

➔ Landscape metrics (e.g. SHAPEindex)

➔ Gradientanalysis

➔ Spatiotemporal urban footprints of the large Indian urban agglomerations.

➔ Spider charts characterising spatiotemporal urban development.

➔ Spatiotemporal relationship analysis using the parameter built-up density.

➔ Location based structure analysis using the SHAPE parameter.

➔ No fixed urban growth patternobserved.

➔ Spatiotemporal growth can be quantified by parameters measuring dimension, pattern, and form, including absolute urban area, built-up density, landscape shape index, largest patch index, number of patches, patch density, total edge, and edgedensity.

7. Establishing Urbanization Trends in Mumbai Metropolitan Region by analysing Geospatial data sets

EvaluateMumbai'surbangrowth with Landsat images for sustainabledevelopment.

➔ UrbanGrowthTrends ➔ Image Classification: "VIS Model"

➔ Object based Image Analysis (OBIA):"OBIA"

➔ Significant increase in built-up area in Mumbai MetropolitanRegion(MMR)

➔ Reduction in barren and vegetationareas

➔ Negligiblechangesinmarshy and water areas due to tidal variations

➔ Increaseinunclassifiedarea

➔ Policies that promote concentration of low-density development.

➔ conserving ecologically sensitive areas

➔ Effective urban management and planningstrategies

8. Exploration of urban sustainability of India through the lens of sustainable development goals

Analyze the urban sustainability of Indian cities through the lens of sustainable development goals.

➔ SDG scores

➔ interrelationships betweenvariousSDGs.

➔ Hierarchicalclustering

➔ Pearsoncorrelation

➔ Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA).

➔ Inequality among cities in achieving SDGs varies by region.

➔ Open and inclusive process for formulating and implementing SDG objectives at the local level.

ASMITASUTAR

1. Milestones leading to Urbanization

1800s

Fishing Village

Virar was a small fishing village with a population of a few hundredpeople.

1860s

First Train

The first rail operation started between Virar and Back bay in 1867 (nearChurchgateof today)

1950s

Industries

Some industrial development,mainly intheformofbrick kilns and small-scale manufacturing.

1970s

The extension of the Mumbai suburban railway networktoVirar. 1990s 2007

2009

CDP Virar

Thecitydevelopment plan of 2007 - 2027 was introduced to guide the city's growth in a sustainable and plannedmanner.

SpatialGrowth

3. LandConsumptionRate(%)

4. Percentageincrease inno.of Properties-Residentialand Commercial(no.and%)

Relationbetween UrbanPopulationand SpatialGrowth

1. Landconsumptionratetopopulation growthrate(%)

2. Built-upareapercapitafortheyear 2021 (m2/person)

1. PercentageofProposedLandUse Categories(sqkm&%)

LandUse

2. PercentageChangeinLandUse LandCover(sqkm&%)

3. PercentagechangeinExisting Land Use incomparisonoftheproposed LandUsemap2027(sqkm&%)

Housing

Proximity to MumbaiandLower PricesMadeVirara HousingHotspot

2011

Roadway

Inauguration of Virar-Dahanu Road corridor improved cityconnectivity

Population

The population of Virar crossed the 1 million mark, markingasignificant milestone in the city'sdevelopment.

2. Population Growth Rate

Source: Virar CDP, Census 2011

2014

Highway

The MumbaiAhmedabadhighway was completed, which further improved connectivity to the city.

Railway

2017

MMRDA Act

Inclusion in MMR boosted Virar-Vasai's development and investment prospects.

Indian Class 1 - towns with more than 1, 00,000 population; Maharashtra: C Class Town

Population growth rate (PGR = (LN(Pop_t+n / Pop_t))/y

Pop_t=378,877(populationin2011)

Pop_t+n=10,71,598(projectedpopulationin2021) y=10

PGR=(LN(1,071,598/378,877))/10

Substantialincreaseinpopulation,potentially impactinginfrastructure,resources,andcommunity development.

LN(1,071,598/378,877)

PGR=1.1003/10

PGR = 11.00%

Source:SDG Indicator 11.3.1

Substantialincreaseinpopulation,potentially impactinginfrastructure,resources,andcommunity development.

URBAN POPULATION GROWTH

4. Change in occupational structure

5. Change in Employment Trend

A transition from a more agriculture and manufacturing -based economy towards a service-based economy.

Virar has witnessed an increase in marginal workers, implying the rise of informal and low-paying work opportunities

➔ Virar has experienced a notable rise in the number of non-working individuals, with such individuals comprising 57% of the total working population in the city.

➔ This growth in the non-working population is likely due to factors such as migration, limited employment opportunities, and commuting difficulties for women.

➔ Thenumberofmainworkersinthecityhasincreasedsignificantlysince1991andhascontinuedto grow steadily in subsequent years. This indicates that Virar has been successful in attracting employmentopportunities.

3. Ward wise Density of Population
Source: VVMC, Census 2011
Source: VVMC, Census 2011

POPULATION PROJECTION

Source: PropertyTax Department, VVMC

● Ward C has witnessed the most significant growth in Virar, Residential properties increased from 22,014 to 91,537, indicating a growth rate of about 316%, Commercial properties grew from 1,208 to 8,499, representing a growth rate of around604%.

● Virar is experiencing both spatial and vertical growth this growth indicates a growingpopulationandeconomicdevelopmentinthearea

● The notable vertical growth indicates a shift towards higher-density construction, reflectingthedevelopmentofmulti-storybuildingsinthearea.

Source:District Census HandbookThane ,Census of India

➔ Accounting for Dual Nature: Averaging the projections from the Arithmetic Increase Method and Geometric Increase Method considers Virar's dual nature as an old town and a newly expanding area, providing a comprehensive outlook onpopulationgrowth. ➔ Balancing Conservatism and Optimism

SPATIALGROWTH

1.Direction of Growth and Factors affecting Growth Direction towards Nallasopara

1990 2000 2010 2020

Rapid Urbanisation of Virar

➔ AttentiontoUrbanPlanning

➔ Improvedtransportationinfrastructure

➔ Realestatedevelopment

➔ Demographicfactors

➔ Governmentpolicies

➔ Availabilityofland

➔ Lowerpropertyprices

➔ Improvedconnectivity

Growth Towards Nallasopara

➔ Availability of large tracts of undeveloped land along the Mumbai-Ahmedabad highway

➔ Attractive destination for real estate developers

➔ Relatively lower property prices than in otherpartsofMumbai

➔ Spillover effect from rapid development of VirarCity.

Substantial increase in population, potentially impacting infrastructure,resources,andcommunitydevelopment.

➔ Built-up area has increased by 154.68%, indicating significanturbanization.

➔ Land consumption rate is 15.45%, indicating a high rate of landconsumption.

➔ High land consumption could lead to habitat loss, environmentaldegradation,andresourcedepletion.

land consumption is growing faster than the population in the area.

Source: Google Earth
Source: Bhuvan Cartosat Imagery
Source: Bhuvan Cartosat Imagery

LAND USE & ENCROACHEMENT

1. Change in Built Up wrt Land Use

Source: Virar CDP2027 Land Use Percentages

Source: Virar CDP2027

● GreenZone:higharea,naturalhabitats,parks,andprotectedareas.

● General Residential and Plantation Zones: significant areas, indicating high demand for housing and agriculture.

● CommercialZone:lowestarea,implyinglimitedeconomicorcommercialactivities.

Source: Virar CDP2027, Bhuvan Cartosat Imagery

Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable Development -

ACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

● Plantation Zone: Intended for constructionofhomes for local residents only. However, there have been reports of violations in the restriction of built-up areainthiszone.

● Green Zone: Not designated for residential use. In recent years, slum mafias have increasingly encroached upon this area, particularly along State Highway 40.

● Special Residential Zone: This zone has not seen any affordable housing projects being developed.

● Industrial Zone: Despite being reserved for industrial development, this area has been subjected to encroachment.

● Coastal Regulation Zone: The native fishing community is not following FSI (floor space index) bye-lawsinthiszone.

ENCROACHMENT &AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECT

5. Occupancy in MHADAAffordable Housing

Low occupancy in MHADA buildings due to competition with similarly priced private builder properties. No choice of flats available in MHADA lottery, with allotment being the only option. Some MHADA housing scheme buildings face issues with inadequate water supply at times.

1. Percentage Built up in restricted areas 2. Marking of encroachment zones

3.

Indicator Value Comments

a) Percentage of people living in Slum/Informal Settlements households (SISH):(for VVMC) 2011

2.85% ➔ The Green Zone in Virar city has witnessed an increase in encroachment.

➔ As of 2011, there was only one non-notified slum in VVMC.

b) Percentage of land encroached for Slum/Informal Settlement 25.69% (Percentage Increase 202.08%)

Reasons for formation of slums In Virar:

● Rural to Urban Migration.

● Mumbai to Virar Migration.

● Lack of affordable housing for EWS and LIG.

➔ Recently, 5000 people were uprooted from their informal encroachment settlement near Virar Phata.

● The provision for special housing is made in the CDP 2027. But no housing societies have been developed.

● The mispredicted growth direction has led to the formation of slums near South East direction of the city.

● Slum Mafia encroachment of Land and sale of these slum units.

Source: VVMC Public Works Department, Google Maps
% of Land Encroached & 4. % Increase in Green Zone
Source: Google Street View

Virar city transportation system profile 2023

ConvenientAccess to Public Transport

Source: VVMT, Google Earth

Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable DevelopmentACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

● Around 50% of the the total built up does not have access to the public transportation & Highest no. of trains are for Churchgate.

Passengers

boarding=

Approx 5,59,200. 3:25amand 12:05am,one trainevery 5.54 minutes

Mumbai Suburban Railway

Source: Primary Survey Source: Google Earth
Train Trips Source:
Suburban Railway Network
Source: Mumbai Suburban Railway
Railway Network

TRANSPORTATIONAND MOBILITY- CONNECTIVITY

3D View of Virar City

Source: Bhuvan, Open Street Map, 2023

● Virar has low lying areas in mostparts.

● C ward has some high slopes in Green Zone.

Source: Bhuvan Cartotat andArcScene

Source: Open Street Maps, 2023

Source:SLBs for Urban Transport- MoUD, Source: Open Street Maps, 2023 NetworkAnalysis

Virar boasts a robust network connectivity, with Ward A exhibiting the highest density of roads and junctions, followed by Ward C, and Ward B having the lowest density.

Source: Open Street Maps, 2023 NetworkAnalysis

Virar Road Network

Sr. No

1.

2.

Indicators to calculate Citv-wide Level of Service (LoS) of Public Transport Facilities

Public TransportationAccessibility

5.

VVMT

TRANSPORTATIONAND MOBILITY- RAILWAY

Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable DevelopmentACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

Image 01: Raja Chatrapati Shivaji Marg
Image 02: Virar West Side under utilized Skywalk and traffic congestion
Image 03: Entry to Virar West Sky walk
Image 04: NarrowApproach roads
Image 05:Two Wheeler Parking on StationApproach Road
Image 06: Traffic congestion, hawlers, parking
IndicativePlanofStation
Source:M-Indicator, 2023
Source: Google Street View
Source:Google Maps
Detail of Virar Railway Station

TRANSPORTATIONAND MOBILITY- CONFLICT POINTS

Conflict Point 07, 08, 09

Only one Fuel station in Virar West leading to pressure of the facility and also that being on the approach road to station causes trafficjamsatpeak hours.

Congestion near Virar East Local Railway Station due to mismanaged rickshaw stand, lack of private parking, unreliable public transport, and encroachment by hawkers.

Pedestrians risking their lives by walking on flyovers without designatedwalkways.

Insufficient parking and unreliablepublictransport drive the surge in private vehicleownership.

Source:
People walking of flyover bridge

TheapproachroadtoVirarRailwaystation faces a bottleneck, with the road width abruptly reducing from 30 meters to 10 meters, resulting in congestion, traffic slowdowns, and difficulties in accommodating the high volume of vehicles.

Street Section: Survey Point 01 S 01

Street Section: Survey Point 02

● HighvolumeofvehiclesnearVirarRailwaystationposeschallengesin accommodatingtraffic.

● Issuesincludeinsufficientparking,encroachmentbyshopsandhawkers,andthe inefficiencyoftheskywalkinmanagingpedestrianflow.

Source: Primary Survey S 02

S02
Traffic Volume Count Survey (TVC)
Virar Station: Private Parking Facilities
Mode of Travel to Station

TRANSPORTATIONAND MOBILITY-AIR QUALITY

The number of registered 2-wheelers has increased by 143% due to the poor connectivity in the city, particularly for commuters traveling to Virar station.

10 levels :Air Monitoring Centers in Virar

➔ HighpollutionlevelsnearVirarandNalasopararailway stationsareindicatedonthemapduetoheavytraffic congestion.

FocusonaddressingproblemsinRailway StationVicinity.

Source: RTO 48

Proposed Organised Open Spaces

Existing Organised Open Spaces

No. of Trees and their

Source: Proposed Land Us Map 2027 , Google Earth, 2023

Open Public Spaces in comparison to other cities

Source: Proposed Land Us Map 2027 , Google Earth, 2023

Source: Bolinj and Virat Nagar Lake , Google Photos
Source: Tree Census VVMC, 2019
Source: PWD ‘23, VVMC

Augmentation to Vasai-Virar Water Supply Scheme (Source Surya)

Stage III

Rate the quality of water supply in your house (1 being the dirtiest and 5 being the cleanest)

AccordingtoMMRDA,thedailywaterdemandintheVasai-Virarregion, whichincludesNalasopara,is360mld.Thecivicbodyisonlyableto supply230mld.Thedemandisexpectedtotouch396mldby2026. The current shortfall of 130 mld has led to a crisis in the region.

Thestategovernment’sSuryaRegionalWaterSupplySchemeissetto startfromMay,providinganadditional185mldwatertothesuburbs.

How satisfied are you with the availability of water supply in your house? (1 being dissatisfied and 5 being satisfied)

➔ Low coverage of water supply

➔ Per capita water supply below standard

➔ No metering of water connections

➔ High non-revenue water

➔ Low continuity of water supply

➔ Inefficient redressal of customer complaints

➔ Low cost recovery in water supply services

➔ Inefficient collection of charges

Source:(PWD, VVMC, 2019)

➔ Disparity in citizen views between WardAand Wards B & C regarding the quality and quantity of supplied water

➔ Water tests indicate that supplied water in Virar meets recommended levels on various parameters.

Source: VVMC Water Supply Report, 2015.

WardA
Ward B & C
WardA
Ward B & C

PHC

Virar, there are several issues with the healthcarefacilities,including:

Inadequate number of public healthcare facilities.

Emergenceofexpensiveprivatefacilities.

Compromisedbuildingsafetystandards

Chandansar
Source: Primary Survey

Ward wise Enrollment of Students

CategoryofEducation No.ofStudentsenrolled

WardA 21627

WardB 26109

WardC 12650

Education Infrastructure in Virar

Total 60386

Source: VVMC website 2023,Google Earth Imagery

VVMC Budget Amount for Educational Sector

2013, 3.5% ofthetotalbudget-2224.35lakhs

2023,0.41% ofthetotalbudget-965.67lakhs

Source: VVMC Budget Report 2012-13;2022-23

➔ PublicschoolsinVirarareprimarilyrunbytheZillaParishad, andthelanguageofinstructionismostlyMarathi.

➔ TheseschoolsreceivefundingfromtheZIllaParishad(district council)ofVasai.

➔ Zilla Parishad schools in Virar have a diverse language of instruction that includes Marathi, Urdu, Hindi, and Gujarati.

➔ This fosters inclusivity and a sense of community among migrant communities, promoting a secure learning environment.

Language of Instruction

Source: VVMC , list of educational facilities

HierarchyofEducationFacilitiesandRequirement

Category StudentStrength&Perunit populationserved Required Existing

➔ Asperthesurvey,TheresidentsofVirar are satisfied with the available educationalinfrastructure.

➔ .Nopresenceofeducationaldepartment inVVMC.

➔ Availability of only one degree college leads to dependency on local train for highereducation.

➔ The majority of the educational facilities in Virar city do not align with the proposed Virar land-use map for 2007-2027.

Source: URDPFI, Educational Infra,Educational Department VVMC.

Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable DevelopmentACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

Zilla Parishad Urdu School, Virar (E)
Source:Google Street View
Viva Degree College, Virar (W)

SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT

Source:

Virar solid waste management has the necessary equipment for effective waste management. Efforts have been made to raise awareness about waste management. However, the issue of source segregation remains a challenge.

Impacts

on

Desludging Vehicles
Trommel Machine for Processing Legacy Waste

1 . MaharashtraRegional PlanningandTown PlanningAct1966

2 . UrbanDevelopment ControlandPromotion Regulation(UDCPR)

3 . ApprovedDevelopment Plan

Town Planning Department: Scope of Work

➔ Department oversees development plan implementation and compliance with regulations

➔ Provides technical support and advice to the Municipal Corporation on town planning matters

➔ Prepares funding proposals and acquires land

➔ Manages all aspects of implementation, including proposing modifications

Healthcare Department: Scope of Work

T

provide necessary medical services to the citizens of the Municipal Corporation, to implement the National Health Programme, to take measures to prevent epidemics, to create public awareness abouthealth.

➔ Enforces development control regulations, reviewing permits and ensuring compliance

➔ Provides guidance on unauthorized construction.

GOVERNANCE

Source: ITDepartment, VVMC

➔ Virardemonstratesamoderate performance across various indicators.

➔ The economic ability score is relativelylowcomparedtoboth themedianandhighestscores. This suggests that while there areareaswhereVirarperforms well, there is a need to focus on improving economic opportunities and enhancing the overall livability of the city to match the standards set by thetop-performingULBs.

➔ Themost complaintsarefor thedepartmentof Encroachmentwith 56%.

➔ Thegrievances redressalrateis 99.6%.

Source: ITDepartment, VVMC

E-Governance Services Availability

PublicGrievancesRedressal Yes

RegistrationsofBirthsandDeaths Yes

PaymentofOnlinePropertyTax, UtilityBillsandManagementof Utilities. Yes

BuildingPlanApproval Yes

UseofGIS No

Source: ITDepartment, VVMC

➔ Outofwhich20% closedcomplaints aredissatisfied.

➔ Thestatusof e-governancein Virarreflectsa positivetrendwith successful implementations.

➔ However,theuseof GISremainsan areathatrequires furtherattentionand development.

Source: Ease of Living Index ULB 1 million Category Virar

SDG Target Indicator 11.3.2

Indicator11.3.2:Proportionofcitieswithadirectparticipationstructureofcivilsocietyinurbanplanningand managementthatoperatesregularlyanddemocratically Questions Agree (3) StronglyAgree (4)

Are there structures for civil society participation in urban planning, including design and agreements that are direct, regular and democratic?

Are there structures for civil society participation in urban budget decision making that are direct, regular and democratic?

Are there structures for civil society evaluation and feedback on the performance of urban management, which are direct, regular and democratic?

Do the structures promote the participation of women, young men and women, and/or other marginalized groups?

Rating=14/16

● URDPFIguidelines: Comprehensiveframeworkfor inclusiveandsustainableurban planninginIndia

● Citizenparticipation:Encourages involvementofcitizens, associations,andorganizationsin decision-making.

● Recommends reservations for women in elected positions Many states have implemented a 33% reservation for women in seats/wards within ULBs.

● Suggests reservations for marginalized groups

● Delimitation of Wards: Emphasizes fair representation through ward demarcation

● State-Level Legislation:Allows states to enact laws for ULB governance and elections.

Source: Google form Survey

PROPOSALS: IMPLEMENTATION OF TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT

TOD integrates land use and transport planning and aims to develop planned sustainable urban growth centers, having walkable and livable communes with high density mixed land-use. Citizens have access to open green and public spaces and at the same time transit facilities are efficiently utilized.

Source: NationalTransit Oriented Development (TOD) Policy

Reasons for Implementing TOD in Virar

Aspect Issues TOD component as Solutions

Spatial Growth Rapid population growth and high land consumption rate Optimised DensitiesCompact Settlement

Insufficient land allocation for commercial activities. Mixed Land use

Lack of Employment opportunities.

Transport and Mobility Congested Railways Station NMT network

Parking Issues Managed Parking

Encroachment of Streets by Hawkers Informal Sector Integration

BENEFITS OF COMPACT SETTLEMENT

ECONOMICAL

- Increased Business Opportunities LocalEconomic Growth

- Reduced Transportation cost&Commuting time.

SOCIAL

- ImprovedAccess toServicesand Facilities

- IncreasedSense ofBelongingand Community Cohesion

LAND SUITABILITYANALYSIS FOR COMPACT DEVELOPMENT

ENVIRONMENT

- EfficientUseof Resourcesand Infrastructure

- Conservationof LandandNatural Resources

Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable DevelopmentACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

01. POPULATION DENSITY
LAND USE
RAILWAYSTATIONS
ROAD NETWORK

Improved Awareness,Strengthen Enforcementand MonitoringandStrict Penalties

Lowoccupancy rateinaffordable housingscheme buildings

PROPOSALS: TRANSPORTATIONAND MOBILITY

Virar Railway Station

Issues

Non-compliance withbuilding bye-lawsin plantationzones withrespectto FSI.

Other Spatial Growth Issues

IncreaseAwareness& MarketingEfforts, ImproveWaterSupply Infrastructure, StreamlineAllotment Process.

AddressEncroachment andLandMafiaIssues bysurveillance, regular inspections,andlegal actionagainst encroachers. Potential

● Solutions for Underutilised Skywalk

➔ Installation of lifts and escalators

Encroachmentin Restricted Development Areas

● High dependency on local railway for commute to

● Mumbai

● Congested core city area near the railway station

● Lack of parking areas and emergence of private two-wheeler parking areas

● Underutilization of skywalks

● Inefficient public transportation with poorly designed bus routes

● Footpath encroachment by hawkers

● Good existing connectivity in the form of rail and road to MMR and Gujrat.

● Potential to improvise the Public Bus Network.

● Good potential for water front development for use as water transport. water sports.

PROPOSALSAT VIRAR RAILWAY STATION

Solutions and Recommendations

● Non-Motorised Zone Street

● No parking zone near Railway Station

● Scattered Multi-Level Private 2 and 4 Wheeler Slots.

● Integration of ICT for Booking Parking Slots

● Gradual Increase in Parking Prices- to encourage people to opt for Public Transportation

● Regular Monitoring and Evaluation.

● Engage Public and Private Stakeholders:(PPP)

● Integrated Transportation Planning:

➔ Enhanced safety and security measures

➔ Promoting community engagement

➔ Utilizing skywalk space for cultural events

➔ Regular maintenance

➔ Signage and information boards highlighting Virar's history

➔ Public art and beautification

accessibility

● Hawker Management and Regulation:

Enforce regulations to prevent encroachment by hawkers near the railway station area and designating specific areas for street vendors

Impacts of Urbanization on City's Sustainable DevelopmentACase of Virar City, Maharashtra

3. Open Public Spaces

➔ Inadequate allocation of land for public openspaces.

➔ Presence of illegal settlements on public openspaces.

ISSUES , POTENTIALS & RECOMMENDATIONS

➔ Availability of land for proposing organized openpublicspaces.

➔ Good accessibility to the proposedpublicspaces.

➔ Budget allocation for the conservation and beautification of lakes in Virar.

● IncreaseAllocation of Land for Public Open Spaces

● Utilize the available land to propose organized open public spaces that cater to various recreational activities and communityneeds.

● Involve urban designers and landscape architects to create well-designed and functional spaces that enhance the overallqualityoflifeinthearea.

● Address Illegal Settlements on Open Public Spaces:

● Take strict measures to prevent illegal settlements on open public spaces, including regular monitoring and enforcementofrelevantlawsandregulations.

● Ensure Effective Budget Utilization for Lake Conservation and Beautification.

Engage local communities and environmental experts in the process to ensure the conservation efforts align with the uniquecharacteristicsofthelakesandtheirsurroundings.

4. Solid Waste Management

➔ Poor implementation of the project and inadequate efforts towards source segregation.

➔ Inefficient collection of solid waste management (SWM) charges.

➔ Limited extent of scientifically disposing municipal solidwaste.

➔ Inefficiency in recovering municipal solidwaste.

➔ Availability of funds and equipment for managing municipalsolidwasteand sanitation.

➔ A higher percentage of the literate population to understand the importance of municipal wastemanagement.

➔ Integration of ICT (Information and Communication Technology)toeffectively manage waste and addressgrievances.

● Improve Project Implementation and Source Segregation Efforts:

- Enhanceprojectmonitoringandoversighttoensureeffectiveimplementationofsolidwastemanagementinitiatives.

- Conduct awareness campaigns to educate the public about the importance of source segregation and encourage activeparticipation.

● Streamline Collection of Solid Waste Management Charges

- Implementefficientandtransparentsystemsforthecollectionofsolidwastemanagementcharges,ensuringproper accountabilityandrevenuegeneration.

- Utilizetechnology,suchasonlinepaymentplatforms,tosimplifythepaymentprocessandincreasecompliance.

● Enhance Scientific Disposal of Municipal Solid Waste:

- Invest in the development and expansion of waste treatment facilities, including composting, recycling, and waste-to-energyplants.

● Improve Municipal Solid Waste Recovery Efficiency

- Establish effective waste recovery mechanisms, such as segregation at source, recycling programs, and waste pickinginitiatives.

- UtilizeICTforEfficientWasteManagement:

- IntegrateInformationandCommunicationTechnology(ICT)solutionstonotjuststreamlinecomplaintmanagement butalso wastemanagementprocesses,includingwastecollectionschedulinganddataanalysis.

5. Water Supply ➔ Inadequate coverage of water supply connections.

➔ Unabletocatertothe water demand of the city.

➔ Absence of water metering for connections.

➔ Insufficient continuity ofwatersupply.

➔ Limited cost recovery in water supply services.

➔ The Surya Regional Water Supply Scheme initiated by the state government is poised to have a beneficial impact on the water supply situationinVirar.

● Enhance Water Supply Capacity

- Implement infrastructure upgrades, such as the construction of additional water treatment plants or reservoirs, to meetthegrowingwaterdemand.

● Improve Coverage of Water Supply Connections:

- Extendwatersupplynetworksandensureaccesstocleanwaterforallresidents.

● Implement Water Metering for Connections:

- Implement water metering for all connections to accurately measure water usage, improve billing accuracy, and promoteresponsiblewaterconsumptionandconservation.

● Ensure Continuous Water Supply

● Strengthen Cost Recovery Mechanisms:

- Developandimplementefficientbillingandrevenuecollectionsystemstoimprovethefinancialsustainabilityofwater supplyservices.

Healthcare ➔ Inadequate number of public healthcare facilities

➔ Emergence of expensive private facilities

➔ Hospitals operating inside residential buildingsdisregarding bye-laws and Compromised building safety standards

➔ Lack of specialized healthcarefacilities

7. Education ➔ Inadequatepublic schoolsin economicallyweak areas

➔ Limitedavailability ofgeneraldegree collegeswithonly oneinVirar.

➔ Education departmentisnot presentinVVMC.

8. Governance ➔ Largeareawards turndifficultto manage.

➔ Lackofeducation department.

➔ AbsenceofGIS technology implementation.

ISSUES , POTENTIALS & RECOMMENDATIONS

➔ Has land available for specialized health care facilities and medical institute.

● Increase the Number of Public Healthcare Facilities:

- Allocate resources and prioritize the establishment of additional public healthcare facilities to meet the growing healthcareneedsofthepopulation.

● Enforce Building Safety Standards

- Strictly enforce building bye-laws and safety regulations to prevent the operation of hospitals inside residential buildings.

Conduct regular inspections to ensure compliance with safety standards and take appropriate legal action against violations.

● Develop Specialized Healthcare Facilities:

- Utilize available land to develop specialized healthcare facilities and medical institutes to cater to the specific healthcareneedsofthepopulation.

➔ Virarhasayoung populationthusdueto highpopulationnew education program implementationwouldbe success.

➔ Offersgoodscopefor largespace-extensive educationsocial& culturalinstitutions.

➔ Gettingfundsfrom multipleagencieslike, MMRDA,SatelliteTown Scheme,ZillaParishad

➔ PotentialofIntegratingIT withVVMTbusserviceto improvisethereliability.

● EstablishMorePublicSchoolsinEconomicallyWeakAreas

● Expand General Degree CollegeAvailability:

- Collaboratewitheducationalinstitutionsandgovernmentbodiestosetupcollegesthatofferdiversecoursesand provideopportunitiesforhighereducation.

● Skill Development

- Incorporatevocationaltrainingandskilldevelopmentprogramstoenhanceemployabilityandcreateopportunitiesfor economicgrowth.

● EstablishanEducationDepartment

- Thedepartmentshouldberesponsibleforcoordinatingwithschools,colleges,andeducationalinstitutionstoimprove thequalityofeducationandaddresseducationalchallenges.

● Redefine Ward Boundaries for Effective Governance:

- Reevaluate and potentially redefine the boundaries of large area wards to ensure effective governance and administration.

● Integrate IT with VVMT Bus Service for Enhanced Reliability:

- Exploretheintegrationofinformationtechnology(IT)solutionswiththeVVMT(Virar-VasaiMunicipalTransport)bus servicetoimproveitsreliabilityandefficiency.

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.