F r i d a y, D e c e m b e r 2 2 , 2 0 1 7
Vo l u m e 3 8 , I s s u e 4
6 7 5 4 Va l l e y V i e w R d . E d i n a , M N , 5 5 4 3 9
w w w. e d i n a z e p h y r u s . c o m
EHS artist profiles page 5
Learn more about the hidden costs of college pages 6 & 7
Young Conservatives Club’s lawsuit against school rocks Edina community
Lily Jones, Tanner Jones, Ellery Mahlum, Greyson Mize, & Jenna Simon page editor, online copy editor, print copy editor, page editor, & online editor-in-chief Press conference: Young Conservatives Club and attorney Erick Kaardal gather outside Creek Valley Elementary to announce lawsuit
O
Junior Gold A hockey team shoots for success page 12
WEB PREVIEW Braemer Golf Course reopening delayed
Link Crew’s Cocoa and Cram
n Dec. 7, attorneys representing the Edina Young Conservatives Club announced they had filed a lawsuit against Edina Public Schools. The charges allege a violation of students’ rights relating to freedom of speech and association, along with violations of the U.S. Flag Code. At 4:00 PM on the same day, students and their legal representatives held a press conference outside of Creek Valley Elementary School in Edina to explain why they are suing the district. YCC President Nick Spades, Vice President Lizzie Ebner, and club member Jazmine Edmond spoke at the conference along with Attorney Erick Kaardal and Edina parent & alum David Buyse. “These students are proud of their conservative values. They have a passion for their beliefs, and yet they feel threatened to voice an opinion, and are bullied in the classroom and the hallways,” Buyse said. “I’m one of hundreds of parents who are tired of this, and the lawsuit filed today will provide incentive for the school to move forward toward positive change and a genuine tolerance.” In the lawsuit, the YCC asked to become “a fully approved club with the rights and privileges granted to all other fully approved clubs,” requested that the school “create fair and equal policies governing student groups who criticize [Edina School District’s] ‘mission, faith and beliefs,’” and that they be awarded “their costs of litigation, including reasonable attorneys’ fees.” Erick Kaardal, the attorney representing the EHS Young Conservatives Club in their lawsuit against Edina High School and the Edina Public School District, is wellknown in the Minnesota legal community.
On his website, Kaardal boasts about “participating in over one hundred public law cases representing parties opposed to the government, government agencies and government bureaucrats,” and in the past three years he has brought suits against the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources and at least three school districts (St. Louis County, Washington County, and Sibley East). To discover why Kaardal is so keen on opposing government institutions, one needs look no further than his book The Rebirth Constitution (self-published, 2013), in which Kaardal and his co-author, Thomas Dahlberg, propose ideological “war” and the writing of a “new, postmodern constitution.” They say this process will begin with force, and advocate that individuals sow discord in society, writing, “Neopopulism does not propose debate...but war.” More specifically, Kaardal proposes a “consummate war,” a war on all means of cultural production that includes “overt intellectual and moral disobedience of the establishment.” Under Kaardal and Dahlberg’s new constitution, the government would have no involvement in education. “No unit of government shall establish schools,” they write, “except for the purpose of training for government jobs.” They continue, “We will separate the state from all education and teach the people to ride roughshod over their government.” At the Dec. 7 press conference, Kaardal said “the school won’t let [the YCC] be a club because they did not respect disrespect for the flag…That’s a violation of the Equal Access Act, violation of free speech rights, and it is unlawful under the U.S Flag Code.” Despite Kaardal’s claims, there is no evidence that the YCC was formally terminated because of
their stance on school policy. The Equal Access Act states that all public secondary schools that receive federal funding are required by federal law to afford all student groups the same opportunities to form, convene on school grounds, and have access to all the same available resources. However, it also states that a school may choose to not allow any student-led noncurricular groups. To have a case supported by the Equal Access Act, Kaardal must first prove that EHS administrators are allowing other groups more privileges than the YCC under the same circumstances. The lawsuit also claims that the YCC’s rights were violated under U.S Flag Code. “The school has a very important pedagogical purpose, and that is under the Flag Code they must teach respect for the flag,” Kaardal said. “When the school starts sponsoring disrespecting the flag, that is accommodating protesters, and requiring other students to respect the protesters, that’s unlawful.” Despite Kaardal’s claims, the 1900 Supreme Court Case United States v. Eichman ultimately overturned the Flag Protection Act of 1989, invalidating the enforcement of the U.S Flag Code. The code remains in federal law and is used as a guideline, but cannot be used to criminalize first amendment rights. Since the lawsuit was filed, many Edina students and alumni have voiced their opinions on the YCC’s action. The perspectives that people have on the YCC’s lawsuit can be boiled down into three fundamental opinions: there are those who support the YCC and believe that the school did in fact violate their first amendment rights, those who think the district was right to shut down the club’s GroupMe, and those who simply wish the drama would end.
Student Senate attempts to bridge gap between students, administration Jenna Simon & Will Schwinghammer online editor-in-chief, head staff writer
Orchestra Pajama Concert
For more, visit EdinaZephyrus.com
O
n Nov. 2, 20 of Edina High School’s student leaders gathered for the first meeting of the high school’s new Student Senate. The Senate was introduced at the beginning of the year with a main purpose to bridge the gap in communication between the student body and EHS administration. However, as the school year nears the end of first semester, several students still feel uninformed on the big issues within EHS, and many are unaware of the Student Senate’s existence. The idea for a Student Senate was proposed
over a year ago, long before any students were aware of the concept. “The concept around the Student Senate started last year after the election when we had various opinions and thoughts on different aspects of the school, and we felt that we weren’t receiving the full voice and input of the student body,” Assistant Principal and Activities Director Troy Stein said. Stein currently works with the Student Senate during meetings as a representative from the administration, along with Principal Andy Beaton. The plan was for the Senate to be comprised of students from several different activities, athletic areas, and pre-existing leadership bodies. The administration hopes the Student Senate can become a go-to group
of students for them to bounce ideas off of relating to potential changes in policy or procedure. The administration made a point of choosing students for the Senate who could represent a wide variety of organizations at EHS. However, these organizations were not given the opportunity to elect their representatives. Many students were appointed by either the administration or their organization’s adviser. “I’m in Link Crew, and Mrs. Ronglien came up to me talking about it, and said that I should try to get on the Student Senate,” senior Student Senator Prasoon Sinha said. (continued on page 3)