'r ecord
Christmas joy at Plan Hospital " St Vincent de Paul 'strenuously resisted' WA's only Catholic weekly newspaper
Price: $1
By Peter Rosengren The Catholic Church in Perth has locked horns with Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital and will vigorously resist the hospital's plans to phase out existing chaplains and replace them over time with what it calls 'ecumenical chaplains.' Perth's Auxiliary Bishop Robert Healy said this week the hospital's plans were unacceptable and would be "strenuously resisted: Bishop Healy's comments followed the hospital's announcement that it intended to move to a new model of ecumenical chaplains as existing priests and ministers retire or are appointed to other positions by their relevant Churches. The new policy would see existing chaplains, all of whom are priests or ministers of religion, replaced with new ecumenical chaplains appointed by the hospital, who would make "pastoral diagnoses" of patients' spiritual needs. The new official chaplains would effectively be non-denominational, meaning that Catholics, Anglican and Uniting Church patients could no longer expect visits from official chaplains of their own denomination working at the hospital. But they would still be able to ask for a Catholic priest to come from outside the hospital 24 hours a day to administer the sacraments and spiritual counselling. Hospital staff would have a list of outside denominational priests and ministers to call if a patient requested one. Bishop Healy said both he and Archbishop Hickey had put their criticism of the new policy strongly to the hospital's acting director of medical services, Dr Diane Davies. "Only a Catholic priest can provide for the needs of Catholic patients in the hospital," Bishop Healy told The Record.
Bishop Robert Healy
"If the hospital wishes to provide the best professional pastoral care for Catholic patients, then the hospital should be willing to provide a Catholic priest for the Catholic patients." the bishop said. "This has been done in the past. at greater expense to the Church than the hospital, and it should continue in the future," he added. According to the hospital. there are three chaplains - two Catholic priests and a Uniting Church minister - working at the 628-bed hospital. A fourth position, filled until recently by an Anglican priest, had been advertised and would become the first of the new positions. It would be filled by a hospital "ecumenical chaplaincy coordinator." Dr Davies told The Record the appointment would be made according to skills, training and experience related to chaplaincy work rather than on denominational criteria. She said the move would ensure the best professional pastoral care was provided by the hospital's taxpayer-funded chaplaincy regardless of denomination, and followed the lead of other hospitals around Australia. But other public hospitals in Perth contacted by The Record last week said they were unaware of plans to alter existing chap-
Perth: December 12, 1996
laincy arrangements at their own hospitals. Instead, the trend appeared to be towards maintaining the status quo or, in some circumstances, enhancing hospitals' responses to denominational religious needs. A spokeswoman at Princess Margaret Hospital said the hospital had recently installed a Muslim prayer room to meet the needs of the hospital's Islamic patients. The chief executive officer of Fremantle Hospital, Peter Howe, said there were no plans to alter the chaplaincy regime there. "We have the highest regard for our chaplaincy service and believe it is an integral part of providing comprehensive care to our patients," he said. "We would not envisage changing the existing arrangements and would hope that we will be able to further strengthen our bond Notre Dame University students, Leticia Jennings, left, and Erin Callahan, were with the chaplaincy service in the at the Society of St Vincent De Paul headquarters in East Perth this week happy to help prepare hampers donated by students, staff and friends of the future." university for distribution to needy families at Christmas. Fremantle-based Dr Davies said no patients at Sir stuffed with items such as tinned food, puddings, hampers twenty-five The Charles Gairdner Hospital would be disadvantaged through being hams and drinks - together with a mountain of gifts for both young and old denied access to a chaplain of are currently being distributed by the society. In 1995, St Vincent De Paul volunteers and staff gave the spirit of hope to their choice. Christmas joy even If a hospital chaplain of the 3500 West Australian families but are hoping to spread year. this further required denomination was not West Australians wishing to share some of their good fortune this Christmas available, she said, the chaplaincan make donations of food, toys, gifts or money at any of the St Vincent De a list call on cy coordinator would of available clergy from outside Paul shops or by phoning the donation line on 221 8888. the hospital, as was the case for denominations and religions not included on the current chaplaincy staff. The convention, to be held from The Perth Catholic archdioBut Bishop Healy questioned cese's Youth Ministry director, January 12-18 at St Brigid's Colthe practicality of the new lege in Lesmurdie, are effectively arrangement because of the size Bruce Downes, has contradict- live-in retreats attended by severof the hospital. "We fail to see how ed the common wisdom that al hundred young people. a coordinator can be aware of, young people return to the Mr Downes said that he had spoand provide for, the needs of all Church through significant to experienced parish priests ken patients," he said. their lives such as occasions in in Perth and other dioceses and He added that a Catholic chap- marriages and baptisms, saying found that their consistent lain would continue to work at this is no longer the case. response was that now people the hospital "for the time being" His comments came in an arti- who ceased lobe involved in their but the future of the position was cle in this week's Record (see teens were now coming back for uncertain. Page 4) explaining the annual the events such as marriage and In any event, "any attempt to youth conventions used by the baptism but, except for small introduce a full ecumenical Chap- Archdiocese's Youth and Young numbers, did not become active laincy will be strenuously resist- Adult Ministry to make contact again in other areas of Church or ed," he said. with and evangelise youth parish life as previously. Catholics. Full report - Page 4 Continued on Page 15
Youth 'not coming back'
WA Presentation Sister hopes for Thai AIDS hospice
Two Perth men to be ordained
- Page 19
- Pages
The Record will publish a 24 page Christmas edition next week with the best a vailable Catholic Christmas reading.