Exploring Social Sustainability in Architecture: A Research Study

Page 1


!"#$%&'()*+%,*-%.'/$*-0-1/'(/2'$'13*'-*/.+'4546*'(*/&.+'14.10&47*-#4.'8'./$$3*'(*-%.'/$* +%0-'()9

!"#$%&'%(&)#*+#,-./0("01(2(/3# ("#/4&#+(&25#*+#0'64(/&6/-'&#)(/4# 0"#&3&#*"#.*6(02#.-./0("01(2(/3

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

740/#(.#.-./0("01(2(/38#

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

Q-'@/-2'3/#"#'8'Q-'&("'5%"16'+5'S*3(%&"3&.*">4'"3+-+@%3'/-6'"-B%*+-@"-&/1'3+-3"*-#'/*"'$*%+*%&%T"6'+B"*' &("'#+3%/1'/#$"3&'8!/B%6#+-4':;;U>7'K(%1"'%&'#(+.16'*"3"%B"'"B"-'/&&"-&%+-7'P("*"5+*"4'&("'0"#&' $*"#"-&/&%+-'5+*'#.#&/%-/0%1%&2'3+.16'0"'%-'/'&*%$/*&%&"'31/##%5%3/&%+-'%-'/'&*%-)1"'89.*B%#'"&'/174':;<R>4'/#' %11.#&*/&"6'%-'?%).*"':7'VB"-'/-)1"#'*"$*"#"-&'"B"-'/&&"-&%+-7'W-'&(/&'/33+.-&4'&("'"##/2X# $*%@/*2' 5+3.#',%11'0"'+-'&("'+B"*1++A"6'$%11/*'+5'#.#&/%-/0%1%&27

?%).*"'<4'&2$%3/1'*"$*"#"-&/&%+-'+5'#.#&/%-/0%1%&2'/#'&(*""'%-&"*#"3&%-)'3%*31"#'89.*B%#'"&'/174':;<R>7 ?%).*"':4'1%&"*/1'$%11/*#'+5' #.#&/%-/0%1%&2'89.*B%#'"&'/174':;<R>FA"&3("6'02'&("'/.&(+*7

740/#(.#.*6(02#.-./0("01(2(/3#("#5&/0(28 S'#&*/&")2'5+*'0.%16%-)'&(*%B%-)4'1+-) 1/#&%-)'3+@@.-%&%"#'&(/&'$*+@+&"',"11 0"%-)'02'.-6"*#&/-6%-)' ,(/&'$"+$1"'/*"'1++A%-)'5+*'5*+@'&("'"-B%*+-@"-&'&("2'*"#%6"'/-6',+*A7'F+3%/1'#.#&/%-/0%1%&2' %-3+*$+*/&"#'$(2#%3/1'/-6'#+3%/1'6"#%)-4'%-31.6%-)'#+3%/1'/@"-%&%"#4'@"&(+6#'5+*'3%&%T"-'$/*&%3%$/&%+-4' /-6'#$/3"'5+*'$"+$1"'&+'6"B"1+$7'Q&'/1#+'%-31.6"#'%-5*/#&*.3&.*"'&+'#.$$+*&'#+3%/1'/-6'3.1&.*/1'/3&%B%&2' 8K++63*/5&''"&'/1>7

9.#/4&'&#0#6*""&6/(*"#1&/)&&"#.*6(02#.-./0("01(2(/3#0"5#.*6(02#4*-.(":8

S33+*6%-)'&+'YZ I/0%&/&4'@+*"'&(/-'/'&(%*6'+5'&("',+*16M#'$+$.1/&%+-',%11'-""6'#.%&/01"'#("1&"*'02' :;[;4',(%3('@"/-#'['@%11%+-'-",'(+.#%-)'.-%&#'"B"*2'@+-&('8YZ'I/0%&/&4':;::>7'Q&'%#'/-'%-3*"6%012' 3+1+##/1'$*+$+*&%+-'/-6',+.16'0"'/'*%)+*#'/-6'6%55%3.1&'3(/11"-)"#'&+'/3(%"B"7'Q-'/66%&%+-4'@/-2'+5'&("#"' -",'(+.#%-)'.-%&%"#',+.16'0"'%-'&("'5+*@'+5'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)'/#'(+.#%-)'%#'/1*"/62'5/3"6',%&('5%-%3/1' 1%@%&/&%+-#'/-6'1%@%&"6'/33"##'&+'1/-6'8Y-%&"6'Z/&%+-#'P"/@4':;:;>7' 740/#(.#.*6(02#4*-.(":8

F+3%/1'(+.#%-)4'/#'/'6"5%-%&%+-4'6%55"*#'/33+*6%-)'&+'&("'*")%+-7'?+*'"C/@$1"4'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)'%-'&("'Y-%&"6' \%-)6+@4'A-+,-'/#'$.01%3]3+.-3%1'(+.#%-)4'$*+B%6"#'1+, 3+#&'/-6'/55+*6/01"'*"-&/1'$*+$"*&%"#'#.3('/#' $*%B/&"'$*+B%6"*#'/-6'1+3/1'/.&(+*%&%"#'8Y\'D+B"*-@"-&4':;:[>7' I+,"B"*4'$.01%3]#+3%/1]3+.-3%1'(+.#%-)'%-'B/*%+.#'-/&%+-#'#"*B"#'&("'#/@"'$.*$+#"'/-6')+/14'&/*)"&%-)' &(+#"',%&('1+,'%-3+@"',(+'/*"'6""@"6'&+'(/B"'&("')*"/&"#&'-""6'5+*'/'#("1&"*'8Z/&%+-/1'I+.#%-)' ?"6"*/&%+-'P"/@4':;::>

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

Q-'&("'5%*#&'$*"3"6"-&#4'&("'3+@$/*/&%B"'#&*/&")2',%11'0"'"C$1/%-"6'&(+.)(& +.&'&("'"C/@$1"4'0*"/A%-)' 6+,-'&("'3+-3"$&'0"(%-6'&("'$#23(+1+)%3/1'@"&(+6+1+)27''

"#$%$&$'(!)!*!+,-'(.!/0'#01!21!343/53674!*!89$#9-$:!

!'64(/&6/< S1"_/-6*+'S*/B"-/4'V^VNVZPS^7

=-5:&/< `ab:7H'&(+.#/-67

!'&0< H;;;'@c

>&0'< :;;[

?*-"/'3< QJ.%J."4'O(%1"7

?%).*"'[4'V2"'0%*6'B%",'+5'd.%-&/'N+-*+2' 8WML*%"-'G'O/**/#3+4':;:;>7

$%&'%(&)<#

W-"'+5'&("'@+#&'3"1"0*/&"6'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)'%-'&("':<'3"-&.*2'%#'^+3/&"6'%-'&("'O(%1"/-'6"#"*&'%-'O(%1"' @.1&%$1"'3(/11"-)"#7'N+*"'&(/-'UU'

J@4',(%3('@"/-#'"/3('(+.#"'@.#&' "')*"/&'3+-#&*/%-&4'&("'0.6)"&',/#'/&'@+#&'`a4H;;'5+*'"/3('5/@%12'&+'

P("'("/6'/*3(%&"3&4'S1"_/-6*+'S*/B"-/4'%6"+1+)2'%#'&+'0"'#"1"3&%B"'%-'$*+_"3&#7'P("'6"3%6%-)'"1"@"-&'%-' *"#.1&'%-'&("'

*"/1%T/&%+-'&(/&'-+'/*3(%&"3&.*"'%#'31"/*12'3+-&*%0.&%-)'B/1."'&+'&("'3(/11"-)"'0"%-)'$*"#"-&"64'fP("'5/3&' A'5+*'(%@7f'8g%6/4':;:<>7 )*+,8K++63*/5&''

33+*6%-)'&+'89"&"*#4':;<=>4'3+.16'0"'#.@@/*%T"6'/#'(/B%-)'#"&&1"@"-&#'#.**+.-6"6'02'/'B/*%"&2'+5' /'$*"#"-3"'+5'-/&.*"'%-'&("'/*"/7' +3A#'.-6"*'S@"-%&%"#'S-6'F+3%/1' Q-5*/#&*.3&.*"'8K++63*/5&''"&'/174':;<:>4'/#'#""-'%-'?%).*"'b7'S33+*6%-)124'/'B%#./1'&++1'@.#&'0"'%-'&("'

)*/$(%3'*"$*"#"-&/&%+-'&+'#&.62'/-6'"C/@%-"'#.3('/'5/3&+*7'O+-#"J."-&124'S'#%&"'$1/-'&(/&'(%)(1%)(&#' &("'@+6"'+5'&*/-#$+*&/&%+-'/-6'&("'#.**+.-6%-)'/@"-%&%"#'(/#'0""-'3(+#"-7'F.3('"C"*3%#"',%11'("1$'&+' .-6"*#&/-6'&("'6%55"*"-&'.#"*'"C$"*%"-3"#',%&(%-'&("'/*"/',(%1"'6%*"3&12'1%-A"6'&+',"11 0"%-)7'

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

?%).*"'=4'?%).*"'a4'#&*""&'B%",'+5'd.%-&/'N+-*+2'8e/*T23A%4':;:<>7'Q&'%#'31"/*'&(/&'&("'$/B"@"-&'%#' .#"6' 02'3/*#'-+&'$"6"#&*%/-#4'@/-%5"#&%-) &("'31/%@'+5'-+&'0"%-)'#/5"'5+*'3231%#& /-6',/1A"*#7

740/#60"#1&#'&05#13#/4&#.(/&#B20"8

?%*#&12'%&'%#'31"/*'&(/&'QJ.%J."'%#'/'(%)(12'6"-#"'3%&2'5*+@'&("'/**/-)"@"-&'+5'*+/6#7'Q&'%-6%3/&"#'&(/&'&("' 3%&2'(/#'*/$%612'"C$/-6"6'/&'#+@"'$+%-&7'Q-'/66%&%+-4'&("'3%&2'%#'@+#&12'6"6%3/&"6'&+'3/*'5.-3&%+-#',(%1"' &("*"'%#'/'1+,'$+##%0%1%&2'5+*'#+3%/1 %-&"*/3&%+-4'3(%16*"-'$1/2%-)4'/-6'"C$1+*/&%+-'0"3/.#"'+5'&("' +B"*,("1@%-)'$*"#"-3"'+5'3/*#7'?.*&("*4'&("'3%&2'%#'0/*"12'0*"/&(/01"'/#'&("*"'%#'-+'0/1/-3"'0"&,""-' -/&.*"'8B")"&/&%+->'/-6'.*0/-'5/0*%37'

Q-'/66*"##%-)'&*/-#$+*&/&%+-'@"&(+6#4'3/*#4'0%A"#4'/-6'0.#"#'/*"'3+-B"-%"-&'5+*'/33"##%-)'&("' /0+B"@"-&%+-"6'/@"-%&%"#7'I+,"B"*4'&("*"'%#'/'(%)("*'*%#A'5+*'3231%#&#'5*+@'3/*#'/#'&("'#&*""&#'/*"'&%)(&' /-6'(/B"'#(/*$'&.*-#7

S11'-"3"##/*2'/@"-%&%"#'/*"'.-6"*'&("'*/-)"'+5':'A@7'I+,"B"*4'&("*"'%#'+-12'+-"'(+#$%&/1',%&(%-'&(%#' */-)"4'/-6'&("'-"C&'31+#"#&'+-"'%#',%&(%-'<;'A@'+5'6%#&/-3"4'/#'@+#&'/*"'@"6%3/1'31%-%3#7'S33+*6%-)124'%-' /'3/#"'+5'"@"*)"-324'&("'*"#%6"-&'@%)(&'-+&'0"'/01"'&+')"&'&("'-""6"6'("/1&(3/*"'+-'&%@"7

S'5*/)%1"'#"-#"'+5'$*%B/32'%-'/'#$/3"'3/-'3*"/&"'/-'.-$1"/#/-&'"C$"*%"-3"'5+*'&("'*"#%6%-)7'Q&'3/-'%-31.6"' -+&'(/B%-)'/'#@++&('&*/-#/3&%+-'0"&,""-'+.&#%6"'/-6'%-#%6"'8'\"%1'"&'/174':;:<>4'89"&"*#4':;<=>7'K(%3('%#' 6%*"3&12'3+**"1/&"6'&+'&("'J./1%&2'+5'3+@@+-'#$/3"]'3+@@.-/1'#$/3"7'P(/&'3/-'%-31.6"'-+%#"'$+11.&%+-' &(/&'%-&"*$*"&#'&("',+*@%-"##'+5'1%B%-)'*++@ /-6 0"6*++@ 02'(/B%-)'&("@'/6_/3"-&'+*'+-"',/11'/,/2' 5*+@'&("'#&*""&'8i/A+B1_"B%3'"&'/174':;;R>7'

P("'/.&(+*'*"5"**"6'&+'S10"*&#'^.-6'F26'%-'!"-@/*A'/#'/-'"C/@$1"',%&('/')++6'#+3%/1'3+-&"C&89"&"*#4' :;<=>7'?.*&("*4 %-':;:<'/'#&.62',/#'3+-6.3&"6'&+'"C/@%-"'3+@@+-/1%&2'/-6'%-6%B%6./1',"11 0"%-)4' $+%-&%-)'+.&'&(/&'j&("'$(2#%3/1'&*/-#%&%+-'0"&,""-'6+@"#&%3'/-6'3+@@+-'#$/3"# "#$"3%/112'&("' S10"*&#'^.-6'5"-3" /#'l&++'(/*6X'-+&'#.55%3%"-&12'"-3+.*/)%-)'3+-&/3&'0"&,""-'&(" &,+m'8'\"%1'"&'/174' :;:<>7

?%).*"'<;4'g/-6A.-#&"-X#' $*+$+#/1'l#+5&"-#X'&("'1%-"#' 0"&,""-'6+@"#&%3'/&*%.@' )/*6"-#'/-6'3+@@+-'#(/*"6'#$/3"#'02'*"$1/3%-)'&("'S10"*&#'^.-6'5"-3"',%&('/'B/*%"&2'+5'1/-6#3/$"' "1"@"-&#''8g/-6A.-#&"-'"&'/174':;<:>7

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n+#"-B/##"*4':;:<>7'S# %&' (/B"'0""-'6+-" /33+*6%-)'&+'&("'1"B"1'+5'%-&%@/32'0"&,""-'&("'.#"*'/-6'#$/3"7'

&+'5%&'Sb' $/)"7'^"/*-"6'02'8:;:<>7'P "**/3"6'/-6'6*/,-'02'

Q-'"C"3.&%-)'&("'&/*)"&'+5'<;;'(+.#"#'02'%-3*"@"-&/1'(+.#%-)4'$*%B/32'(/#'0""-'3+@$*+@%#"6'&+'+55"*' P(%#'3/-'0"'+0#"*B"6'02'*"3+)-%T%-)'&("'-.@0"*'+5',%-6+,# /-6' 0"6*++@#',%&('6%*"3&'B%",'&+'&("'3+@@+-'#$/3"'+-'&("')*+.-6'51++*',%&(+.&'/-2'#.))"#&"6'@"&(+6' &+'$*+B%6"'$*%B/327'N+*"+B"*4'*"#%6"-&#'@%)(&')"&'6%#&.*0"6',(%1"'#1""$%-)'02'&("'#.**+.-6%-)'3/*#M' 31.-A%-)'"-)%-"#7

/1'-""6#'5+*'1%B%-)'"-B%*+-@"-&#'89"&"*#4':;<=>7'P("'/.&(+*'+5' ?%).*"'<b4'0.%16%-)'01+3A#h'#$/3"'&+')*+,8K++63*/5&''"&'/174' P("'/0%1%&2'&+'3.#&+@%#"'/-6'3+-&*+1'+-"X#'#.**+.-6%-)#'/-6'(/B"'/'B+%3"'%-'(+,'%&'%#'/**/-)"6'&*%))"*"6' &("'/#$"3&'+5'+,-"*#(%$'/-6'%6"-&%5%3/&%+-7'N+*"+B"*4'#&.6%"#'(/B"'#(+,-'/'*"1/&%+-#(%$'0"&,""-'&("'

S66%&%+-/1124'%&'3/-'%-31.6"'#"1"3&"6'5.*-%&.*"4'3+1+*#4'@/&"*%/1#4'+$"-'/-6'31+#"',%-6+,#4'5.&.*"' "C&"-#%+-'/-6'@+6%5%3/&%+-'$+##%0%1%&%"#4'/-6'3+@@.-%&2')/*6"-#7'I+,"B"*4'&("#"'"1"@"-&#'+-12' ,(%3('%#'+,-%-)'/'#$/3"',%&(+.&'&("'-""6'&+'$/2'*"-&7'

Q-%&%/1124'0"5+*"'/-6'/5&"*'(/0%&./&%+-'51++*'$1/-#',"*"')+%-)'&+'0"'&("'@"&(+6'&+'/##"##'&("' /33+@$1%#(@"-& +5'+,-"*#(%$4',(%3('%#'%-51."-3"6'02'8:;<b>7'I+,"B"*4'#.3('6/&/'%#'%-/33"##%01"'/#' @/-2'*"#%6"-&#'$*"5"*'-+&'&+'*"B"/1'&("%*'1%B"-%-)'#$/3"4'/-6'%&'(/#'0""-'$*++5%-)'02',(/&'&("'_+.*-/1%#&' (/6'3+@"'/3*+##'8e/*T23A%4':;:<>7

S#'/'*"#.1&4'%&'%#'0"#&'&+'(%)(1%)(&'+,-"*#(%$'5/3&+*#'/33+*6%-)'&+'&("')%B"-'$*+_"3&'/#'&("2'6%55"*7'P(%#' 3+.16'3+-#%#&'+5'0.&'%#'-+&'1%@%&"6'&+'&*""#'%-'5*+-&'+5'&("'(+.#"4'$/*A#4'$1/2)*+.-6#4'/-6'#(/*"6' 5/3%1%&%"#7'?+*'"C/@$1"4'@/-2'3+@@.-%&%"#'(/B"'0""-'0*+A"-'/-6'6%#%-&")*/&"6'0"3/.#"'+5'&("'%-/0%1%&2' &+'@+6%52'&("'#$/3"'%-'/1%)-@"-&',%&('5/@%12')*+,&(89"&"*#4':;<=>7'Y1&%@/&"124'&("'-.@0"*'+5' +,-"*#(%$'/#$"3&#'#(+.16'6"&"*@%-"'(+,'#&*+-)'/-6')++6'&("'3+@@.-%&2'%#'+-'/'#+3%/1'1"B"17

9*+B%6%-)'&("'/0%1%&2'5+*'5.&.*"'"C$/-#%+-'/-6'@+6%5%3/&%+-',/#'-+&'+-12'&+'%-3*"/#"'&("'B/1."'+5'&("' #"&&1"@"-&'5+*'&("'*"#%6"-&#7'L.&'/1#+'&+'"#&/01%#('/'*"/1%#&%3'/-6'#+@"(+,'%6"/1%#&%3'"C/@$1"'%-'&(%#' *")/*6'&(/&'3/-'%-51."-3"'&("'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)'%-6.#&*2'%-'O(%1"7'N+*"+B"*4'O(%1"',%11'#$"-6'+B"*'&"-' &(+.#/-6'@%11%+-'6+11/*#'%-'&("'-"C&'&,+'6"3/6"#'&+'+B"*3+@"'&("'(+.#%-)'6"5%3%"-32'8?*/3/1+##%4' :;;R>7'?.*&("*4'/'3+@@.-/1'#$/3"'(/#'0""-'$/*&'+5'&("'#3("@"4'@/-%5"#&%-)'&("'%@$+*&/-3"'+5'(/B%-)' /'#/5"'#$/3"'5+*'3(%16*"- /-6'/-'+.&6++*'#$+&'5+*'/6.1&#'&+'#+3%/1%T"'/-6'#"&'3+@@.-%&2'"B"-&#7' Y-5+*&.-/&"124'%&'6%6'-+&')+'5/*'/,/2',%&('&(%#'$1/-4'/#'&("'(+@"+,-"*#'&*/-#5+*@"6'&("'@/_+*%&2'+5' &("'/*"/'%-&+'/'$/*A%-)'1+&7

?%).*"'<H4'#(+,#'(+,'&("'3+@@.-/1'#$/3"'%#'.#"6'02'3(%16*"-'/-6'/#'/'5*+-&'2/*67'?%).*"'<=4'?%).*"'<a4' /-6'?%).*"'<R'*"B"/1'(+,'&("'#$/3"'(/#'&.*-"6'%-&+'/'$/*A%-)'1+&7

B%",'+5'&("'5/o/6"'.$+-'3+@$1"&%+1"B/&%+-'B%",'+5'&("'5/o/6"'/5&"*'(/0%&/&%+-'+5'['2"/*# 8WML*%"-'G'O/**/#3+4':;:;>

I+,"B"*4'&("*"'%#'-+'3+-3"*-'&(/&'/"#&("&%3#'/*"'#.0_"3&%B"'/-6'#+@"&%@"#'*"5"**"6'&+'/#'&("'/0%1%&2'&+' _.6)"7

fF&21"#'@/2'3(/-)"4'6"&/%1#'@/2'3+@"'/-6')+4'0.&'&("'0*+/6'6"@/-6#'+5'/"#&("&%3'_.6)"@"-&' /*"'$"*@/-"-&f'02'n+)"*'F3*.&+-'8!%3A%-#+-4':;::>7'

W-" ,(+ #&.6%"# 0.%16%-) .-6"*#&/-6# &(/& / 6"3"-&4 $*/3&%3/1 6"#%)- %# &(" @+#& %@$+*&/-& "1"@"-&7

L.&4 &+ / 1/2@/-4 %& %# ,(/& &("2 #""4 %7"74 /"#&("&%3#4 &(/& @/&&"*#7 Q- +&("* ,+*6#4 &(" +B"*/11 /"#&("&%3 %# J.%&" #%)-%5%3/-& 5+* &(" .#"* 8Z%@0/1A/*4 :;:<>7

N/##4 F$/3"4 9*+$+*&%+-4 F2@@"&*24 L/1/-3"4

O+-&*/#& /-6 9/&&"*- /*" 3+@$+-"-&# +5 &(" /"#&("&%3 &"*@# +5 0.%16%-)# VB/1./&%+- /11 /0+B" ,+.16 0" 5+*@%6/01" 5+* &(%# $/$"* +5 *"#"/*3(7 ?+* "C/@$1"4 "B/1./&%-) &(" 0/1/-3" 6%#&*%0.&%+/-6 #2@@"&*2 +5 ,%-6+,# ,%11 *"J.%*"6 / #+$(%#&%3/&"6 /-/12#%# 5%*#&4 %-B+1B%-) 6/21%)(&4 51++* $1/-#4 "1"B/&%+- %- *"1/&%+- &+ &(" 5.-3&%+- +5

#$/3"7

?%).*"'::4'#(+,#'?*+-&'"1"B/&%+-'+5'd.%-&/'N+-*+2'/5&"*'(/0%&/&%+-'8?*/3/1+##%4':;;R> 7

S# / 3+-#"J."-3"4 $/&&"*-4 #"1"3&"6 @/&"*%/1%&2 /-6 3+1+.* &("@" +5 &(" 5/o/6" +-12 ,%11 0" "C/@%-"67

N+*"+B"*4 &(" 5/3/6" (%)(12 3+-B"2# &(" 1"B"1 +5 /&&"-&%+-4 6"&/%1#4 /-6 "55+*& &(/& (/B" 0""- $1/3"6

%-&+ &(" #3("@"7 S33+*6%-)124 $*"#"-&%-) &(" )"-"*/1 /"#&("&%3 &("@" /-6 J./1%&27 Z"B"*&("1"##4 &(%# @"&(+6+1+)2 ,+.16 /3(%"B" @+*" B%#./1 3+@$/*%#+- /-6 "1"B/&%+- +-3" /1%)-"6 ,%&( /-+&("* $*"3"6"-&7

740/#60"#1&#*1.&'%&5#+'*J#/4&#+0K05& 8

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

3+@$1"@"-&"6'&("'+B"*/11'/$$"/*/-3"7'?1/&&"-%-)'&("'0+16'@%-%@/1%#&'+.&1%-"#'/-6'#++&(%-)'&("' /&@+#$("*"7

"#$%$&$'(!;!*!<0=&>?-(@!>(#$$(!*!89$#9-$:!

!'64(/&6/<#N%A(/%1'n%3("#7

=-5:&/<#p<a7H'@%11%+-7

!'&0<#<<H;;'@c7

>&0'<#:;<U7

?*-"/'3<#Z+*,%3('O%&24'Y\7 ?%).*" :[4'S-'/"*%/1'$(+&+)*/$(2'+5'D+16#@%&('F&*""& 8\"#A"2#4':;:<>7

$%&'%(&)<

W-"'+5'&("'@+#&',%6"12'*"3+)-%T"6'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)'$*+_"3&#'%-'V-)1/-6'%#'D+16#@%&('F&*""&7'!"#%)-"6'02' N%A(/%1'n%3("#'#&.6%+'/-6'6%*"3&"6'02'/*3(%&"3&#'!/B%6'N%A(/%1'/-6'S--/1%"'n%3("#7'Q&'%#'31/%@"6'&(/&'&("'

$*+_"3&'(/#'0""-')*""&"6',%&('%6"-&%3/1'3(/11"-)"#4'#.3('/#'/'#&*%3&'0.6)"&'/-6'1%@%&"6'1/-68O*++A'4' :;<U>7'I+,"B"*4'D+16#@%&('(/#'*"3"%B"6'&*"@"-6+.#'1.C.*2'5.-6%-)'%-'3+@$/*%#+-'&+'d.%-&/'N+-*+27' O+-#&*.3&%-)'@+*"'&(/-'<;;'(+.#%-)'.-%&#'3+-#%#&%-)'+5'0+&('(+.#"#'/-6'/$/*&@"-&#7'P("'&"**/3"6' (+.#%-)'+*%"-&/&%+-4'/**/-)"6'%-'5+.*'1%-"#4'(/#'@/6"'&(%#'$+##%01"8\"#A"2#4':;:<>7'

S66%&%+-/1124'@+*"'&(/-'/'J./*&"*'+5'&("'#%&"'%#'/11+3/&"6'&+'/'3+@@.-%&2'#$/3"'&+'"-3+.*/)"'#+3%/1' %-&"*/3&%+-#7'S'0/3A#&*""&'&(/&'51+,#'&(*+.)('&("'3"-&*"'+5'&("'3+@$1"C'#"*B"#'/#'0+&('/'#(/*"6' 3+@@.-/1')/*6"-'/-6'/'#/5"'$1/2'/*"/'5+*'3(%16*"-8K/1#(4':;<U>7

@0'(&5#DAB&'(&"6&<#

g/*%"6'VC$"*%"-3"h'

Q-'3+@$/*%#+-'&+'QJ.%J."4'&("'#&*""&'6"-#%&2' +5'Z+*,%3('%#'*"@/*A/012'@+*"'0*"/&(/01"7' N+*"+B"*4'/1@+#&'/11'/@"-%&%"#'/*"'@+*"' )"-"*+.#'%-'#$/3"4'$*+B%6%-)'/'(%)("*'J./1%&2' "-B%*+-@"-&7'Z"B"*&("1"##4'&("'1/2+.&' *"$*"#"-&#')++6'*"#$"3&'%-'&"*@#'+5' 0/1/-3%-)'-/&.*"'/-6'.*0/-'01+3A#7' P("'3%&2'/1#+'$*+B%6"#'#"B"*/1'&*/-#%&'3(+%3"#4' @/A%-)'%&'@+*"'/55+*6/01"'/-6'3+-B"-%"-&'&+' B%#%&'-"3"##/*2'/@"-%&%"#',("-'-""6"67' ?.*&("*@+*"4'$*+B%6%-)'/'B/*%"&2'+5'

$+##%0%1%&%"#'5+*'+.&6++*'#+3%/1'%-&"*/3&%+-#' /-6'"3+-+@%3'/3&%B%&%"#7'P(%#'.1&%@/&"12'

%@$*+B"#'&("'3+@@.-%&2M#'6"#%*/0%1%&2'/-6' $*+)*"##'%-'&("'1+-)'*.-8\%@4':;<H>7'

WB"*'/-6'/0+B"4'/11'&("#"'/6B/-&/)"#',%11' )./*/-&""'/'5.15%11%-)4'@+*"'"-)/)%-)'

"C$"*%"-3"'5+*'/11'&("'+33.$/-&#7'n"#.1&%-)'%-'/'@+*"'5*%"-612'/-6'5/B+.*/01"'#%&"7

?%).*"':b 4'N/#&"*'$1/-'+5'QJ.%J."'%-'<h:;;;;'#3/1"4'#(*%-A'&+'5%&'&("'$/)"7'N/$'(/# 0""-'$*+B%6"6'02' D++)1"'V/*&('9*+4'/-6'N/$ #7'

?%).*"':=4'$*"#"-&'&("'J./1%&2'+5'&("'$*%B/&"'0/3A2/*6'#$/3"'8K/1#(4':;<U>7

S'#(+*&'@"&/1'@/#('/-6',++6"-'5"-3"# /*" $1/3"6'0"&,""-'&("'*+/6'/-6'&("'(+.#"4'#@++&(%-)'.$'&("' &*/-#/3&%+-'5*+@'&("'+.&#%6"'&+'&("'%-#%6"7'

Y#./1124'0/3A2/*6#'$1/2'+.&'/#'&*/#('3/-#'#&+*/)"4'#"/&%-)'/-6'*"1/C/&%+-'T+-"'5+*'(+@"+,-"*#7' I+,"B"*4',%&('D+16#@%&(4'&("'0/3A'#&*""&'(/#'&.*-"6'%-&+'/'@.&./1'#$/3"'(+#&%-)'/'#/5"'$1/2'T+-"'5+*' 3(%16*"-'/-6'@.1&%$1"'#"/&%-)'-"C&'&+'B/*%+.#')*""-'#$/3"#4'&/*)"&%-)'/11'/)"')*+.$#'+5'#+3%"&27'N+*"' %@$+*&/-&124'3/*#'/*"'$"*@%&&"6'5*+@'&(%#'/*"/',(%3('%#'/'3(+%3"'&(/&'#(+.16'(/B"'0""-'@/6"'%-

P("'#&*/&")2'+5'D+16#@%&('%#'%-&*%).%-)',("-'%&'6%#3.##"#'+,-"*#(%$7'O+-&*/*2'&+'d.%-&/'N+-*+24'&("*"' %#'-+'+$&%+-'5+*'/'5.&.*"'"C&"-#%+-'/#'-",'1"B"1#'+*'#$/3"#7'S1&"*-/&%B"124'&("')*+,%-)'/-6'3(/-)%-)' -""6#'+5'5/@%1%"#'(/B"'0""-'3+-#%6"*"6'02'$*+B%6%-)'6%55"*"-&'51"C%01"'#%T"'.-%&%"#'&(/&'3/-'0"' $/*&%&%+-"6'+*'3+@0%-"6'/33+*6%-)'&+'&("'-""6'+5'&("'+33.$%"*7'

O/*'6+@%-/-3"'(/#'0""-'@%-%@%T"6'%-'&("'3+@@.-%&2'02'6"#%)-%-)'#&*""&#'&+'0"'@+*"'$"6"#&*%/5*%"-612'/-6'"-3+.*/)%-)'5+*'3231%#&#4'.1&%@/&"12'%-3*"/#%-)'&("'%-&"*/3&%+-#'0"&,""-'3+@@.-%&2' @"@0"*#7'Q&'(/#'0""-'/3(%"B"6'02'6%#&*%0.&%-)')*""-'#$/3"#4'(/B%-)'/'&*""'%-'5*+-&'+5'"/3('.-%&'/-6' ,++6"-'3/*'0+11/*6#'?%).*"7'I+,"B"*4'%-'&("'$*"B%+.#'"C/@$1"4'*"#%6"-&#'(/B"'&.*-"6'@/-2'$/*&#'+5' 3+@@.-/1'#$/3"'/-6 5*+-&'2/*6#'%-&+'/'$/*A%-)'1+&4'/'@%##"6'3(/-3"'5+*'/'0"&&"*'/-6'@+*"'6%B"*#"' 3+@@.-%&27

D*""-'#$/3"#'3+@$*%#"'/'$/*A4'3+@@.-%&2')/*6"-'/-6',%161%5"'51++*')/*6"-7'S11'&("#"'5+#&"*'/'#"-#"'+5' 0"1+-)%-)'&+'&("'/*"/4'%-3*"/#%-)'#/&%#5/3&%+-'/-6'J./1%&2'/-6'"-3+.*/)%-)'*"#%6"-&#'&+'*"12'+-'&("%*' 5""&'@+*"'&(/-'3/*#7

?%).*"':a 4'?%).*"':R4'/',/1A%-)'$"*#$"3&%B"'$%3&.*"'6%#$1/2%-)'&("'J./1%&2'+5'&("'3"-&*"'+5')+16#@%&(' 8O*++A'4':;<U>7

W-'&+$'+5'&(/&4'$*+B%6%-)'/'B/*%"&2'+5'3+@@.-%&2'5/3%1%&%"#7'?+*'"C/@$1"4'%-6++*'#$/3"'&+'(+#&'6%55"*"-&' /3&%B%&%"#'#.3('/#'@.#%3'31/##"#4'0%*&(6/2'$/*&%"#'/-6'"B"-',+*A'@""&%-)#7'?.*&("*@+*"4'&("*"'/*"'/1#+' 1/.-6*2'*++@#'&+'#"*B"'&("'3+@@.-%&24'&/A%-)'/6B/-&/)"'+5',(/&'%#'3+-#%6"*"6'j#&*"-)&('+5',"/A'&%"#m' 8n/_A.@/* G'i/3J."#4':;::>7'P/A%-)'*/-6+@'6/%12'%-&"*/3&%+-'/#'/-'+$$+*&.-%&2'3/-'3*"/&"'-",' 0"-"5%3%/1'#+3%/1'&%"#7'

Q-'3+-31.#%+-4'&("'Z+*,/2'3+.-3%14'%-B+1B%-)'/*3(%&"3&#'/-6'%-B+1B"6'$/*&%"#4'(/B"'$+#%&%+-"6'6%55"*"-&' #&*/&")%"#'&+'5.15%1'&("'-""6'&+'0"1+-)'&+ &("'#$/3"7

<7 !%55"*"-&'W$&%+-# :7 P*""#

[7 O+@@.-/1'#$/3"7' b7 9/*A7

H7 F(/*"6'?/3%1%&%"#7 =7 91/2)*+.-67

?%).*"':U 4'?%).*"'[; 4'$%3&.*"#'#(+,%-)'&("'6%55"*"-&'5"/&.*"#'+5'D+16#@%&('F&*""&'8O*++A'4':;<U>7

!&./4&/(6<

W-"'+5'&("'$*+_"3&M#'@+#& 5/#3%-/&%-)' 5"/&.*"#'%#'&("'5/3/6"7'V@$1+2%-)'@+*"'

3+1+.*#'&(/-'d.%-&/4 5*/@%-)'/-'"/*&(2' &+-"'3+1+.*'$/1"&&" 8K/1#(4':;<U>7'P("'

3+1+.*#'/-6'/&&"-&%+-'&+'6"&/%1'(/B"' @/6"'&("'$*+_"3&'B%0*/-&'/-6'+$&%@%#&%37' !%#&%-3&124'&("'5%*#&'%@$*"##%+-'&(/&'@%)(&' 0"'5+*@"6'%#'(+,'.-%J."'&("'$*+_"3&'%#4' /-6'%&'$*+0/012',+.16'0"'$"*3"%B"6'/#' $*%B/&"'$*+$"*&24'-+&'$.01%3' (+.#%-)8O*++A'4':;<U>7'

?%).*"'[< 4'#(+,#'?*+-&'"1"B/&%+-'+5'D+16#@%&('F&*""& 8O*++A'4':;<U>7

P("'3/*"5.1'#"1"3&%+-'+5'@/&"*%/1%&2'("1$"6')"-"*/&"'/'(%)( 31/##'/33+@@+6/&%+-'/)/%-#&'&("' $*+3*"/&%+-'%6"/'+5'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)7'Y#%-)'&*/6%&%+-/1'V-)1%#( #&21"'0*%3A#',%&('"/*&(2'&+-"#'&+'*"$*"#"-&' /'@+6"*-'/*3(%&"3&.*/1'&+.3(',(%1"'(/*@+-%T%-)',"11',%&('&("'#.**+.-6%-)'.*0/-'5/0*%37'

N+*"+B"*4'&("')1+##2'01/3A'&%1"#'3+B"*"6'&("'*++5#',%&('3(/*@%-)12'#&""$'$%&3("#'@/%-12'6"#%)-"6'&+' 6"3*"/#"'&("'("%)(&'+5'$*+$"*&%"#4'/11+,%-)'&("'+33.$%"*#'&+'0"'@+*"'/&&/3("6'&+'&("'-"%)(0+.*(++6' /-6'@+*"'(.@/-E#3/1"'5*%"-6127'K(%1"'3*"/@E3+1+.*"6'0*%3A'%#'&("'6+@%-/-&'$/&&"*-'/-6'@/&"*%/1'%-' &("'"-B"1+$"4'3*"/&%-)'/-6'@+6"11%-)'/-'/$$"/1%-)'3+-&*/#&'0"&,""-'&("'*++5'/-6'"C&"*%+*'5/0*%37' P("*"'%#'"C3"11"-&'/&&"-&%+-'&+'6"&/%17'?+*'"C/@$1"4')/*0/)"'0%-#'/*"'@/6"'%-B%#%01"'02'/'1/2"*'+5' $"*5+*/&"6'0*%3A'/13+B"#4'*"@+B%-)'/-2'3(/-3"'+5'6%#&*/3&%+-7'

O+@$*"("-#%B"124'&("'$*+$+#/1'%#'B%#./112'/$$"/1%-)4'$*"#"-&%-)'(+,'6"#%)-%-)',%&('3+@$1"&"'6"B+&%+-' /-6'/&&"-&%+-'%#'-+&'_.#&'#.0_"3&%B"'0"/.&%5.1'/*3(%&"3&.*"'$*%-&#4'/#'+-3"'%&'%#'0.%1&4'%&'3/-'%-51."-3"' 3+@@.-%&%"#7

?%).*"'[: 4'0/13+-2'B%",'+-'&("'3+@@.-/1'#$/3"'8D/"&"4':;<[>7 ?%).*"'[[ 4'S*%/1'B%",'+5'g%B/T'#+3%/1' (+.#%-)'8Q#@/%14':;:;> 7

!'64(/&6/<#L"*-/*6+'S-)"1%-%'/-6'!/B%6'O/#%-+qe%)T/)'S*J.%&"3&.*/7

=-5:&/<#p<;7:'@%11%+-7

!'&0<#<aRb;'@c7

?*-"/'3<#N%"*"#4'F$/%-7

$%&'%(&)<

g%B/TT'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)'$*+_"3&' 3+-#%#&#'+5'&(*""'@/%-'*"#%6"-&%/1' 0.%16%-)#'/33+@@+6/&%-)'a;' (+.#%-)'.-%&#'*/-)%-)'5*+@'+-"'&+' 5+.*'0"6*++@#8D/"&"4':;<[>7' ?.*&("*@+*"4'&("'#3("@"'(/#' 0*+.)(&'/&&"-&%+-'&+'"-"*)2 "55%3%"-&'("/&%-)'/-6'3++1%-)' #2#&"@#4'(/*B"#&%-)'5*+@'*/%-,/&"*' /-6'#+1/*'$/-"1#7'S#'/'*"#.1&4'&("' #3("@"'(/#'0""-'/,/*6"6'&("' f9/##%B(/.#f'3"*&%5%3/&%+- 8F1"##+*4' :;:;>7'N+*"+B"*4'&+'"#&/01%#('/' #.#&/%-/01"'"-B%*+-@"-&'/-6' 3+@5+*&/01"'1%B%-)7'P("'0.%16%-)'(/#' 0""-'6%*"3&"6'&+'@/C%@%T"'6/21%)(&' ,(%1" +55"*%-)'-/&.*/1'B"-&%1/&%+-' /-6'#(/6%-)'&+'/B+%6'.--"3"##/*2' )1/*"7 L/#"6'+-'&("'$*%-3%$1"#'+5' 0%+31%@/&"'/*3(%&"3&.*" 8S*J.%&"3&.*/4':;<H>7 ?%).*"'[b 4'N/#&"*'$1/-'+5'N%"*"# %-'<h:;;;;'#3/1"4'#(*%-A'&+'5%&'&("'$/)"7'N/$'(/# 0""-'$*+B%6"6'02' D++)1"'V/*&('9*+4'/-6'N/$ #7'

g%B/T',/#'6"#%)-"6'%-'*"#$+-#"'&+'&("')*+,%-)'1/3A'+5'#.#&/%-/01"'6,"11%-)# 8Q#@/%14':;:;>7'n")/*6%-)' *"-&%-)'&("'$*+$"*&%"#4'P("'@/C%@.@'*"-&'5+*'&("'/$/*&@"-&#'%#'6"&"*@%-"6'02'&("'&"-/-&M#'%-3+@" /-6'&("')+B"*-@"-&7'N/A%-)'%&'/#'51"C%01"'/#'$+##%01"'5+*'&("'*"#%6"-&#7'N+*"+B"*4'+-12'1+,'/-6' @+6"*/&" %-3+@"'5/@%1%"#'/*"'"1%)%01"'&+'1%B"7

@0'(&5#DAB&'(&"6&<

L/3A'%-'<U=;4'&("'#%&"',/#'&("'("/*&'+5'&("'3+/1'@%-%-)'%-6.#&*2'%-'F$/%-7'P+6/2'N%*"#'%#'/'(+@"'5+*'[R' &(+.#/-6'%-6%B%6./1# 8:;:;>4'@.#".@#'/-6'&("'Y-%B"*#%&2'+5'WB%"6+7'?.*&("*@+*"4'&("'#3("@"'%#' #%&./&"6'%-'/-'.-"B"-'&2$+)*/$(2'%-'/'B/11"2'0"&,""-'&("'@+.-&/%-#'/-6'-"C&'&+'&("'0/-A'+5'&("' O/.6/1'n%B"*7'

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

?%).*"'[b 4'0/13+-2'B%",'3+@$1"@"-&"6',++6"-'1/&&%3",+*A'8S*J.%&"3&.*/4':;<H>7'?%).*"'[H 4'?%).*"'[=4' 6%55"*"-&'B%",#'+5'&("'3+@@.-/1'#$/3"'8D/"&"4':;<[>7'

?.*&("*@+*"4'&("'/*3(%&"3&'$+#%&%+-"6'@/-2'(%)( %-&%@/32'*++@#'0"5+*"'&(" 0/13+-2',(%1"'(/B%-)'/' 3"*&/%-'6%#&/-3"'5*+@'&("'0/13+-2M#',%-6+,#7'L2'&(/&4'&("'.#"*',%11'(/B"'&("'$*%B%1")"'&*/-#5+*@/&%+-'+5' #$/3"#',(%1"'@/%-&/%-%-)'/'(%)('1"B"1'+5'$*%B/327

$)"&'.4(B<#

P("'$*+_"3&'%-31.6"#'#(/*"6'5/3%1%&%"#'#.3('/#'/'3+@@.-%&2')/*6"-4'/'$1/2)*+.-64'/-6'/'@.1&%5.-3&%+-/1' *++@'5+*'*"#%6"-&#7'P("#"'#$/3"#'/*"'6"#%)-"6'&+'$*+@+&"'#+3%/1'%-&"*/3&%+-'/-6'3+@@.-%&2'0.%16%-)' /@+-)'&("'*"#%6"-&#7'Q-&"-6%-)'&+'"-3+.*/)"'3+@@.-%&2'6"B"1+$@"-&'/-6'#+3%/1'"-)/)"@"-&'/@+-)' &("'1+3/1#7'

S66%&%+-/1124'6.*%-)'&("'6"#%)-'$*+3"##4'&("'1+3/1#',"*"'/11+,"6'&+'#(/*"'&("%*'+$%-%+-#'/-6'#.))"#&%+-#' +-'&("'$*+_"3&7'V-#.*%-)'&("'$*+$+#/1',%11'0"'3+@$/&%01"',%&('&("'$*"5"*"-3"#'/-6'1%5"#&21"'+5'&("' 1+3/1#7

Z"B"*&("1"##4'%-'3/#"'+5'5.&.*"'.$)*/6"#4'&("'#&/A"(+16"*#'"-#.*"6'(/B%-)'6%55"*"-&'/$/*&@"-&'3(+%3"#' &(/&'3/-'@/-/)"'.$'&+'H'5/@%12'@"@0"*#7

<7 !%55"*"-&'W$&%+-#7' :7 P*""#7

[7 O+@@.-/1'#$/3"7'

b7 9/*A7

H7 F(/*"6'?/3%1%&%"#7

F"B"*/1'/*3(%&"3&.*/1'6"3%#%+-#'(/B"'0""-'&/A"-' &+'/3(%"B"'&("'5%-/1'%-B"-&%B"'J./1%&27'?%*#&4',%&(' *")/*6'&+'&("'.*0/-'@+6"*-'5/0*%34'N%*"#M'$/#&' %- %*+-'/-6'#&""1'%-6.#&*2'%#'#2@0+1%T"6'02'&("' 5/o/6"'+5'&("'.*0/-'5/0*%3'#%6"4',(%3('%#'@/6"'.$' +5'3+**.)/&"6'#&""1'#(""&'$/-"1#'%-'/'6/*A')*"2' &+-"7'W-'&("'+&("*'(/-64'&("'3+.*&2/*6'%#'6*"##"6' .$'02'/'6+.01"'#A%-'5/3/6"7

Q&'%#'@/6"'.$'5*+@'1/*)"',%-6+,#',%&('/-'/33"##' &+'/'3+-&*+11"6',++6"-'1/&&%3",+*A'1/2"*'&(/&'%#' /6_.#&/01"'02'&("'.#"*'6"#%*"4'3+-&*+11%-)'0+&(' #+1/*'"C$+#.*"'/-6'$*%B/32'1"B"17'P("',++6"-' $/&&"*-4'%@$1"@"-&#'&("'#3"-"*2'+5'&("'5%"16#'%-' &("'(%)("*'$/*&'+5'&("'#.**+.-6%-)'@+.-&/%-#7'' P(%#'*"%-5+*3"#'&("',/*@'/-6'#/5"'#"-#"'+5'/-' "-31+#"6'3+@@+-'#$/3"7

?%).*"'[= 4'?*+-&'/-6'0/3A' "1"B/&%+-'+5'g%B/TT4'N%"*"#'8D/"&"4':;<[>7

WB"*/114'&("'/*3(%&"3&'(/#'@/-/)"6'&+'/3(%"B"'/')++6'/"#&("&%3'B/1."'02'3+-&*/#&%-)'&("'+.&"*'#A%-',%&(' &("'%--"*'$/*&'*"#$"3&%-)'&("'B/1."'+5'&("'3+.*&2/*6 /-6'&("'%@$+*&/-3"'&+'@/%-&/%-'/'3+@$1"@"-&/*2' 5/o/6"'&+'&("'.*0/-'5/0*%37'S3(%"B%-)'&("'%6"/1'0/1/-3"'%-'@/&"*%/1# 0"&,""-'/-'+$"-'#$/3"'/-6'&("' *+/6,/27

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

P(*+.)(+.&'&(%#'"C/@%-/&%+-4'#+3%/1'#.#&/%-/0%1%&2'%-'#+3%/1'(+.#%-)'$*+_"3&#'(/#'0""-'"C/@%-"6'02'5+.*' 5/3&+*#'#"1"3&"6'3/*"5.112'5*+@'&("'"%)(&'0/#%3'$#23(+1+)%3/1'-""6#'5+*'1%B%-)'"-B%*+-@"-&#7'P("' 5+11+,%-)'/*"'&("'5/3&+*#h'g/*%"6'VC$"*%"-3"'*"5"**"6'02'/'@/#&"*'$1/-'#&.624'$*%B/32'*"5"*""6',%&('/' #"3&%+-'3.&4'+,-"*#(%$'/-6'%6"-&%5%3/&%+-'*"5"**"6'02'(%)(1%)(&%-)'6"#%)-'"1"@"-&#'&(/&'0"1+-)'&+'&(%#' /#$"3&4'/-6'5%-/1124'/"#&("&%3',(%3(',/#'"C$1+*"6'02'/-/12#%#'+5'&("'5/o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

=(12(*:'0B43

,-./0!120!3.-456!0!72!89:!;<-=>8-5-0!?2!@$"$#A!!"#$%&"'#%()*+%,"*'-"./""('0()010)2%#0.3'%()'+4552(%#0.36' 74+0%#'842*0(9'0(':#-"&.*#2()'73)0!;%3#4&'<'=&%(+0*2!36B5/-:C-!?8D/6=!E!F=89G.4!H=6BI2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMMNNN2589:O69/.9-2G6>M:6.MOB//M#"2#"*"M"#&$(%+)2$"$"2#*&+'*)!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!'0!$"$%A2!

:-42.'*4+0%#'842*0(9 @$"$$A!>%.04(%#'?42*0(9'=")"&%.04(2!Q85.698/!R6B4.9C!F-:-=85.692!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMMNNN2L6B4.9C26=C2BSM8J6B5 L6B4.9C 8446G.85.694M8J6B5 46G.8/ L6B4.9CM!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!%0!$"$%A2!

:$$4&)%-#"'%()'*4+0%#'842*0(9@'?42*0(9'=0(%(+" @$"$"A!A>BCB2!U9.5-:!Q85.694!VG696>.G!W6>>.44.69!O6=! VB=6I-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMB9-G-26=CML6B4.9CM8OO6=:8J/-L6B4.9C!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!%0!$"$%A2! ;/84.80!;2!".'%#D @$"$#A!;80*',%,"&',&"*"(.*'.8"'5".84)4#493'2*")'.4'9"("&%."'.8"'$0&*.'(%.04(/0)"')%.%-%*"'4$' ,&4E050.3'5"%*2&"*'%()'.8"'&"*2#.*'4-.%0(")'/0.8'%'$0&*.'*".'4$'."('5"%*2&"*D'.8"'+45,2.%.04(%#'5".84)*' %&"',&"*"(.")'%*'%'9"("&%#0F%-#"'54)"#')2"'.4'.8"'$%+.'.8%.'0.'0*'(4/',4**0-#"'.4'%,,#3'*050#%&'5".84)*'.4'%' 52#.0.2)"'4$'4.8"&'*"&10+"*'4&'%5"(0.0"*@'0('%'1%&0".3'4$'%#."&(%.01"'*,"+0$0+%.04(*D0!G"%*2&0(9',&4E050.3'.4' *"&10+"*'%()'%5"(0.0"*6':('"E,"&05"(.%#'*".'4$'0()0+%.4&*'$4&'("098-42&844)*'%()'#4+%#0.0"*2!H6<-=9>-95! 6O!W898:80!7585.45.G4!W898:8!X-J4.5-2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN#'"24585G892CG2G8M9#MIBJM#* ""# YM#* ""# Y$"$"""# -9C2L5>!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#+0!$"$%A2!

;=ZB.5-G5B=80![2!@$"#'A!H01%FF0!:&"%2!;=-8!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN28=-8T8=GL2.5M-9M<.<8\\M! @;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#(0!$"$%A2!

]8L8:B=4.9CL0!Q2!@$"$%A!IJ',&4K"+.*'.8%.'*84/+%*"'.8"'$2.2&"'4$'%$$4&)%-#"'842*0(9' %&+80.0F"&'K42&(%#0! :&+80.0F"&'M42&(%#2!;=GL.5.\-=!^6B=98/!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMM8=GL.5.\-=2G6>MJ/6CM.94I.=85.69MG6//-G5.694M9-NT8OO6=:8J/-TL6B4.9CM!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#0!$"$%A2!

]/899-=0!^2!@$"$#A!=01"'*.",*'.4/%&)*'%'50(05%#0*.'%"*.8".0+'%.'845"0!M2#0"'N#%(("&2!^B/.-!]/899-=!X-J4.5-!2! ;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMM_B/.-J/899-=2G6>M>.9.>8/.45T

8-45L-5.GM`KaK5-Y5b;c$">.9.>8/.45c$"8-45L-5.Gc$".4c$":-O.9-:0d.45=8G5.694c$"8=-c$"_B45c$"5L85c V$c*"c;(!@;GG-44-:K!;I=./!$"0!$"$%A2!

WL855-=_--0!e2!@$"$#A!O".80(P0(9'.8"'%&+80."+.2&"'4$'*4+0%#'842*0(90!O;='Q'O".80(P0(9';8"'=2.2&"2!3-5L.9S.9C! ?L-!FB5B=-!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN2=- 5L.9S.9C5L-OB5B=-2G6>M$"$#M"+M%"M8'%)) =-5L.9S.9C 5L- 8=GL.5-G5B=- 6O 46G.8/ L6B4.9CM!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!*0!$"$%A2! W=66S!0!12!@$"#+A!G0P8%0#'O0+8"*'+&"%."*'"("&93 "$$0+0"(.'."&&%+")'*.&"".*'%*'*4+0%#'842*0(9'0('>4&/0+80! R"F""(2!d-\--9!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN2:-\--92G6>M$"#+M"*M"#MC6/:4>.5L 45=--5 46G.8/ L6B4.9C >.SL8./ =.GL-4 96=N.GLM!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$0!$"$%A2! d8<.:4690!P2!@$""+A!f76G.8/!7B458.98J./.5DK!;!I65-95.8/!O6=!I6/.5.G4g0h!S4+%#'B(10&4(5"(.0!#&@)A0!II2!(") (#+2! ;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMM:6.26=CM#"2#"*"M#%'&+*%"+"%"*+$+#2! d.GS.94690!d2!@$"$$A!C&"%.0(9'%&+80."+.2&%#'1%#2"'.8&4298'%"*.8".0+*0!:&+8R%0#32!;=GL!d8./D!2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMMNNN28=GL:8./D2G6>M+*$#%)MNL85T.4T8-45L-5.G4!@;GG-44-:K!^89B8=D!$)0!$"$%A2!

F=8G8/644.0!e2!@$""*A!T20(.%'G4(&43'U'"#"5"(.%#0!:&+8R%0#32!;=GLd8./D!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMMNNN28=GL:8./D2G6>M#"))'MZB.958 >69=6D -/->-958/!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#0!$"$%A2!

H8-5-0!^2!@$"#%A!H01%FF@'50"&"*'*4+0%#'842*0(9'U'V09F%9':&W20."+.2&%0!:&+8R%0#32!;=GLd8./D!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-! 85K!L55I4KMMNNN28=GL:8./D2G6>M%+%$))M<.<8\\ >.-=-4 46G.8/ L6B4.9C \.C\8C 8=ZB.5-G5B=8!@;GG-44-:K! P8=GL!#)0!$"$%A2!

H.//-55 7N890!^2,2!89:!78=C-8950!^2!@$"#'A!!"##-"0(9'%*'%'X&4+"**'4$':++&2%#6'N"34()'72-K"+.010.3'%()'N"34()' .8"'G45"(.0!O"*"%&+8'Y%."2!3-4-8=GL!H85-!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMMNNN2=-4-8=GLC85-29-5MIBJ/.G85.69M$(#)("#'$jX-//J-.9Cj84j8jk=6G-44j6Oj;GG=B8/j]-D69:j7BJ _-G5.<.5Dj89:j]-D69:j5L-jP6>-95!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!+0!$"$%A2!

Y4#)*50.8'*.&"". @$"$%A!OZN:2!3e];!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN28=GL.5-G5B=-2G6>M8N8=:4 89: G6>I-5.5.694T/89:.9CTI8C-M8N8=:4M=.J8T=-C.698/T8N8=:4M=.J8T-845T8N8=:TN.99-=4M$"#+MC6/:4>.5LT45=--5! @;GG-44-:K!;I=./!&0!$"$%A2!

Y4#)*50.8'*.&"".@'>4&/0+8' /0.8'0)"%#+45-0'/0()4/*'%()'$&4(.')44&* @$"$$A!Z)"%#+45-0'A[2!e:-8/G6>J.!U,! X-J4.5-!2 ;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMM.:-8/G6>J.2G6>M.94I.=85.69MC6/:4>.5LT45=--5T96=N.GLM!@;GG-44-:K!;I=./!#0! $"$%A2!

Z>B-%*" U #0*.'4$',#%+"'(%5"6'X4,2#%.04('4$'.8"'C4(.0(242*'G2(0+0,%#'O"90*."&'-3',4,2#%.04('2(0. U *"%&+8' &"*2#.* @$"$"A!Z(*.0.2.4'>%+04(%#')"'B*.%)\*.0+%D']7,%(0*8'7.%.0*.0+%#'Z(*.0.2."^2!e945.5B56!Q8G.698/!:-! V458:l45.G8!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMMNNN2.9-2-4M96>-9$M.9:-Y2:6g8GG.69bJB4ZB-:8d-4:-R6>-E/89CB8C-b#E96>J=-k6J/8G.69b>.=-4!@;GG-44-:K!;I=./!$0!$"$%A2!

e4>8./0!H2!@$"$"A!74+0%#'?42*0(9'C%*"'7.2)3'Q'H01%FF@'50"&"*'*4+0%#'842*0(9' Z77AA0!Z**222!e44BB!e9G!X-J4.5-!2! ;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMM.44BB2G6>MCL8:--= .4>8./M:6G4MG84-j45B:DjCL8:--=j.4>8./j#"'+(#"2II5Y!@;GG-44-:K! P8=GL!#*0!$"$%A2!

^8S6</_-<.G0!]20!k8B96<.G0!,2!89:!]-/6_-<.G0!H2!@$""*A!O4%) .&%$$0+'(40*"'%()'$%+.4&*'0($#2"(+0(9'(40*"' %((43%(+"'0('%('2&-%(',4,2#%.04(0!7+0"(+"'R0&"+.'2!e945.5B5-!O6=!RDC.-9-!89:!P-:.G8/!VG6/6CD0!7GL66/!6O! P-:.G.9-0!U9.<-=4.5D!6O!]-/C=8:-0!7-=J.82!;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMMNNN24G.-9G-:.=-G52G6>M4G.-9G-M8=5.G/-MI..M7"#("&#$""*""$#)#!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#&0!$"$%A2! ,-4S-D40!k2!@$"$#A!Y4#)*50.8'*.&"".6';8"'$2.2&"'4$'*2*.%0(%-#"@'%$$4&)%-#"'842*0(9_' %&+80.0F"&'K42&(%#0! :&+80.0F"&'2!;=GL.5.\-=!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMM8=GL.5.\-=2G6>MJ/6CM.94I.=85.69M456=.-4MC6/:4>.5L 45=--5 45.=/.9C I=.\-M!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!(0!$"$%A2! ,.>0!72!@$"#'A!!83',2-#0+'*,%+"*'%&"'%'-%*0+'("")'$4&'+0.0"*0!!4&#)'B+4(450+'=4&252!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMMNNN2N-O6=B>26=CM8C-9:8M$"#'M"&MNLD IBJ/.G 4I8G-4 8=- 8 J84.G 9--: O6= G.5.-4M!@;GG-44-:K! P8=GL!$%0!$"$%A2!

184B-=5>-=0!d2!@$"$$A!`J'4$'.8"'!4&#)a*'G4*.'Z5,&"**01"'74+0%#'?42*0(9'X&4K"+.*0!N"*.'G7!'X&49&%5*2!]-45! P7X!k=6C=8>4!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN2J-45>4NI=6C=8>42G6>M.>I=-44.<- 46G.8/ L6B4.9C I=6_-G54M!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!'0 $"$%A2!

PGW8=59-D0!72!89:!364-9<844-=0!m2!@$"$#A!X&01%+3'."&&0.4&0"*'0('*.2)"(.'2(01"&*0.3'842*0(9'DDD' *%9"'K42&(%#*0! 7%9"'M42&(%#'2!78C-!^6B=98/!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMM_6B=98/4248C-IBJ2G6>M:6.MOB//M#"2##))M$#'*$&&"$$#"*++'%!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$&0!$"$%A2!

Q.>J8/S8=0!P2!@$"$#A!Z*'%&+80."+.2&"'4(#3'%-42.'%"*.8".0+*_' O;=6'O".80(P0(9'.8"'$2.2&"0!O;='Q'O".80(P0(9';8"' =2.2&"2!3?F!n!3-5L.9S.9C!?L-!FB5B=-!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN2=-T 5L.9S.9C5L-OB5B=-2G6>M$"$#M"'M#&M8&#*$ .4 8=GL.5-G5B=- 69/D 8J6B5 8-45L-5.G4M!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#+0! $"$%A2!

op]=.-90!d2!89:!W8==84G6!0!72!@$"$"A!C4(."*.")'0(+&"5"(.%#0*56'B#"5"(.%#b*'T20(.%'G4(&43'7"..#"5"(.'=0$.""(' c"%&*'4(0!7+0"(+"'R0&"+.'2!7G.-9G-!d.=-G5!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMMNNN24G.-9G-:.=-G52G6>M4G.-9G-M8=5.G/-MI..M7$"+'$(%'$"%"")$*`KaK5-Y5bqB.958c$"P69=6Dc$".4 c$"89c$"8N8=:04BJ4.:.-4c$"56c$"=-:-<-/6Ic$"5L-c$"4-55/->-952!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$0!$"$%A2!

k-5-=40!?2!@$"#(A!74+0%#'72*.%0(%-0#0.3'0('+4(."E.6'O")0*+41"&0(9'Z(9&0)'Y"8#b*'N4 G0#Kd0!O"*"%&+8Y%." W8>J=.:C-!U9.<-=4.5D!k=-442!;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMMNNN2=-4-8=GLC85-29-5MIBJ/.G85.69M%##$)#'+&j76G.8/j7B458.98J./.5Dj.9jW695-Y5j=-:.4G6<-=.9Cje9 C=.:jH-L/p4j]6TP./_6!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$0!$"$%A2! kB=<.40!]20!P860!r2!89:!36J.94690!d2!@$"#*A!;8&""',0##%&*'4$'*2*.%0(%-0#0.36'Z('7"%&+8'4$'C4(+",.2%#'e&090(*' 72*.%0(%-0#0.3'7+0"(+"0!7,&0(9"&S0(P2!7I=.9C-=!^8I892!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMM/.9S24I=.9C-=2G6>M8=5.G/-M#"2#"")M4##($'T"#*T"($)T'!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#"0!$"$%A2! T20(.%'G4(&43'?42*0(9@'0W20W2"' :#"K%()&4':&%1"(% "#"5"(.%# @$"$#A!:&W20."+.2&%'H01%2!;=ZB.5-G5B=8!s.<8! X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMM8=ZB.5-G5B=8<.<82G6>MN6=S4M<.<.-9:84 ZB.958 >69=6D #!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL! %0!$"$%A2!

38_SB>8=!0!,2!89:!^8GZB-40!H272!@$"$$A!;8"'&"%#'*.&"(9.8'4$'/"%P'.0"*0!7.%($4&)'>"/*2!7589O6=:!Q-N4!X-J4.5-!2! ;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMM9-N424589O6=:2-:BM$"$$M"+M#'M=-8/ 45=-9C5L N-8S 5.-4M`KaK5-Y5b?L-c$"cV$c*"c+W45=-9C5Lc$"6Oc$"N-8Sc$"5.-4cV$c*"c+dc$"5L-6=Dc$">8.958. 94c$"5L85c$".9O=-ZB-95c$W089:c$"N8C-4c$"5L89c$"45=69Cc$"5.-42!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$#0!$"$%A2!

3.GL-40!P2!@$"$%A!Y4#)*50.8'*.&"".0!G0P8%0#'O0+8"*2!P.SL8./!3.GL-4!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMMNNN2>.SL8./=.GL-42G6>MI=6_-G5MC6/:4>.5L 45=--5M!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#"0!$"$%A2!

78/5\>890!R20!W66I-=>890!^212!89:!V<8940!H2X2!@$"#(A!?42*0(9'T2%#0.3 %()'+80#)&"(a*'*4+04"54.04(%#'8"%#.80! 8..,*6UUK42&(%#*D*%9",2-D+45U)40U%-*UIJDIIffUJJI`gIhJIiIgf`Jj`2!7;HV!^6B=98/4!2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55IKMM48C-2G9I-=-8:.9C2G6>MI8=8C=8ILM8=5.G/-Mg:6.b#"2##))M""#%+#("#$#+)%"&%!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!##0! $"$%A2!

7/-446=0!W2!@$"$"A!74+0%#'842*0(9'-3'V09F%9':&W20."+.2&%@'G0"&"*@':*.2&0%*@'7,%0(0!:&+80."+.2&%#'O"10"/2!?L-! ;=GL.5-G5B=8/!3-<.-N!X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN28=GL.5-G5B=8/ =-<.-N2G6>M56:8DM46G.8/ L6B4.9C JD \.C\8C 8=ZB.5-G5B=8 >.-=-4 845B=.84 4I8.9!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#&0!$"$%A2! 75B:.6!0!;2;2d2!@$"#&A!R/"##0(9'.3,4#490"*0!Z**222!;;d!75B:.6!2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMM.44BB2G6>M88:j/B9:M:6G4M844.C9>-95j$M+%!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$"0!$"$%A2! US!H6<-=>-95!0!U2!@$"$%A!74+0%#'?42*0(9'O"92#%.4&0!YeHDA[2!U9.5-:!,.9C:6>!H6<-=9>-952!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMMNNN2C6<2BSMC6<-=9>-95M6=C89.485.694M=-CB/856= 6O 46G.8/ L6B4.9CM8J6B5`KaK5-Y5b76G.8/c$"L6B4.9Cc$".9G/B:-4c$"/6Nc$dG645089:c$"O6=c$dI=6O.5c$"6=C89. 485.694A2!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#'0!$"$%A2!

U/=.GL0!3272!@$"$#A!B$$"+.*'4$'?"%#.8+%&"'B(10&4(5"(.%#'R"*09('4('G")0+%#'e2.+45"*0!Y449#"2!3-4-8=GLH85-!2! ;<8./8J/-!85K!

L55I4KMMNNN2=-4-8=GLC85-29-5MIBJ/.G85.69M$)%%'&%&&jVOO-G54j6OjR-8/5LG8=-jV9<.=69>-958/jd-4.C9j69j P-:.G8/joB5G6>-4!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$$0!$"$%A2!

UQ!R8J.585!0!U2Q2R2!@$"$$A!?42*0(90!A(8%-0.%.'$4&'%'-".."&'2&-%('$2.2&"2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55I4KMMB9L8J.58526=CM56I.GML6B4.9C!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!#%0!$"$%A2!

s.:80!k2!@$"$#A!:#"K%()&4':&%1"(%6'X80#4*4,83'%()'0)"4#493' O;=6'O".80(P0(9'.8"'$2.2&"0!O;='Q'O".80(P0(9' ;8"'=2.2&"2!3-5L.9S.9C!?L-!FB5B=-!k/85O6=>!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN2=5L.9S.9C5L-OB5B=-2G6>M$"$#M"'M$#M8&$(( 8/-_89:=6 8=8<-98 IL./646ILD 89: .:-6/6CDM!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL! $#0!$"$%A2!

s.C8=0!?2!@$""+A!G0#0.%&3'*2-2&-%(0*56'?4/'.4',#%('$4&',2&"'/%&0!72-.4,0%2!;<8./8J/-!85K! L55IKMM4BJ56I.82J/6C4I652G6>M$""+M"$M>./.58=D 4BJB=J89.4> L6N 56 I/89 O6=2L5>/!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$(0! $"$%A2!

X8/4L0!Q2k2!@$"#+A!Y%##"&3'4$'O0-%'&"1"%#*'iJIg'7.0&#0(9'X&0F"'*84&.#0*.' I0!:&+8R%0#32!;=GLd8./D!X-J4.5-!2! ;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN28=GL:8./D2G6>M+$#&)"M=.J8 =-<-8/4 $"#+ 45.=/.9C I=.\4L6=5/.45M':%#&:%'$*&::#$)+%"""'"(T=.J8T=-<-8/4T$"#+T45.=/.9CTI=.\-T4L6=5/.45TIL656!@;GG-44-:K!;I=./!'0! $"$%A2!

X66:G=8O5!0!720!R8GS-55!0!?2!89:!;=-9:8=!0!12W2!@96!:85-A!RB7ZY>'=eO'7eCZ:S'7A7;:Z>:NZSZ;c':' $&%5"/4&P'$4&'+&"%.0(9'.8&010(9'("/'+4552(0.0"*2!V:.5-:!JD!72k2!R8//2!169:69!K!76G.8/!1.O-!2! [8=\DGS.0!12!@$"$#A!O"10*0.6'T20(.%'G4(&43'-3'B#"5"(.%#0!:&+80."+.2&%#'O"10"/2!?L-!;=GL.5-G5B=8/!3-<.-N! X-J4.5-!2!;<8./8J/-!85K!L55I4KMMNNN28=GL.5-G5B=8/ =-<.-N2G6>MJB./:.9C4ML6B4.9CM=-<.4.5 ZB.958 >69=6D JDT-/->-958/!@;GG-44-:K!P8=GL!$$0!$"$%A2!

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Exploring Social Sustainability in Architecture: A Research Study by Fayadh Almutaweh - Issuu