Spectrum Newspaper February 2022

Page 1

the

SPECTRUM

“Your Voice in Print”

blakespectrum.org

Thursday | Feb 3 | 2022

Issue IV

The Blake School

Masking Inconsistencies Unsettle Student Body Firmer masking rules, punishments unless in cafeteria Ali Hecker | Staff Writer

“S

hould faculty, staff or administrators see anyone either not wearing a mask or wearing it inappropriately… You will be asked to immediately report to your grade dean or another administrator. It is very likely that you will be sent home, especially if it is not your first time being reminded of this behavior, and repeated mask issues could incur more significant disciplinary consequences, including suspension from school,” wrote Upper School Director, Joe Ruggiero, in an email sent out on Jan. 2 following the return to school from winter break. The consequences for improper mask wearing have recently been a large topic of discussion in the community, raising questions about the COVID-19 protocols at school during the surge of the Omicron variant. The COVID protocols in the lunchroom, in comparison to the rest of the school, are questioned by many students. Maia Schifman ‘22 says, “It’s nice to have lunch with everyone, but it definitely doesn’t feel safe with how crowded it is. It’s also kind of weird how different protocols are stricter everywhere else, but like

in the lunchroom, it just goes away.” Students also challenge the protocols surrounding eating in common areas. Habon Samatar ‘22 describes, “I’m at least four feet away from somebody drinking my water in the senior lounge but I’m one inch away from somebody eating my lunch.” Samatar, among many other students, finds these COVID protocols to be troubling and inconsistent. Many students wonder whether the lunchroom protocols from last year’s hybrid schedule will make a return. Ruggiero states, “Now that we have everyone in the building, to do plexiglass dividers, we wouldn’t have enough room for everybody to eat, is the problem... what we’ve been relying on instead is just people masking up as soon as possible when they’re not eating, maintaining as much distance as they can, and then also noting who they’re eating with.” In response to this dilemma, the gym has been opened up for ninth graders to eat in. Although the lunchroom is a place where COVID spread mitigation is not ideal, some look forward to lunch as the only time in the school day where students can take their masks off. Jonah Yousha ‘24 shares, “I like having my mask off since I have glasses and they fog up all the time… [The lunchroom] is probably the easiest place to get exposed,

but it’s also the only place we’re allowed to have our masks off.” In mid-January, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) announced that KN95 and N95 masks are the most effective against the Omicron variant, and that the cloth masks worn by the majority of students offer very little protection. Nevertheless, the mask policy stands which, according to the CDC, is ineffective unless wearing one of the aforementioned masks. As Omicron cases surge, only a small number of students wear KN95 and N95 masks, which questions whether changing the lunchroom protocols would really make an impact on limiting Omicron spread. Aside from the lunchroom, students voiced concerns about the consequences for incorrect mask wearing. Jay Bowles ‘24 says, “I feel like [the punishments are] pretty extreme… if teachers gave more of a warning before dealing out the consequences, the rules would be more fair.” Anne Graybeal, Associate Head of School, explains, “It can feel in the moment like it’s a battle for control or compliance. What it really is, is a lesson in just collective ethical responsibility for the community… and if people aren’t coming correct on that, we’ve got to start tightening the laces.” Graybeal explains that

Rowan Wallin

Above, students in French I study in class. Students wear masks, maintain distance, expressions hidden due to their masks. Below, a typical day in the lunchroom where students eat lunch, maskless, close together, and engage in conversation. In both of these photos, all students are abiding by current masking policies.

Rowan Wallin

although some students may find the punishments for incorrect mask-wearing unnecessarily harsh, the reinforcement of COVID protocols is necessary to keep students learning inperson. “What we’ve really focused on doing is just maximizing as many mitigation strategies as we can, ergo, the exhortations about mask-wearing... The upshot of all of it is that we really want to make as

much of this year as rich as possible, as typical as possible, as full as possible for Blake, and that’s staying in person.” Some students feel that excessive punishments are no longer necessary. Lola Palestrini ‘24 states, “When we’ve already reached herd immunity and a lot of our community already has natural antibodies, I think the harsher punishments are a little bit irrational, but

I understand getting reprimanded.” With the recent enforcements of masking, the masking policies in school are blatantly inconsistent. Community members only seek consistency. Lilly Anderson ‘23 explains, “I’m not saying I want the rules to be stricter or less strict... I just wish the mask rules were more consistent rather than erratic based on where you are in school.”

Elizabeth Rush Visits Symposium, Recounts Documenting Climate Change Journalist Rush bonds with victims of climate change Noor Naseer | Editor Emeritus

T Oscar Walsh Oscar Walsh Rush’s symposium on Jan. 18 enlightened students about her research regarding climate change and rising sea levels.

his year’s Otis Environmental Speaker, Elizabeth Rush, visited all three campuses during her four-day visit in midJanuary. Rush was originally supposed to come in 2020, but couldn’t because of the pandemic. Skylar Wang ‘22, a member of the Otis Committee

who chose Rush, recalls, “We thought that she would be accessible to both Lower School students and Upper School students because of her narrative style.” This narrative style is present in Rush’s book, Rising. Rush uses interview transcripts to tell the stories of individuals who have been affected firsthand by flooding and rising sea levels. She speaks on this experience saying, “I thought I was going to write about wealthy, sec-

After the past two seasons getting cut short due to COVID-19, the team has a very bright season ahead and a lot to look forward to.

Sam Hardy ‘24 says, “[Abortion is] really not a political issue but a human issue... and not whether you are a Democrat or Republican.”

Page 4

Page 6-7

ond home owners, and I was surprised that a lot of the communities that were feeling the crunch in the present tense were Black and brown communities or low income communities... I had an idea of who lived there [alongside the ocean] and it was different from what I imagined.” Rush reflects on the two years between her scheduled visit and her actual arrival saying, “Pre-COVID… I tried to really think about climate

change as both a threat and an opportunity multiplier—that there were ways to think about how it exposes this incredible shared vulnerability at the heart of our society with the hope that shared vulnerability would bring people together and produce large scale, structural change... [I’m] a little bit less willfully attached to the optimistic narrative around climate change.” Despite this, Rush acknowledges the heavy impact that climate change Jonah Yousha ‘24 says, “I would say based on the weather it’s usually about five minutes longer [in the winter] because… you want to drive slower because you want more control over the car.” Page 12

can have on young people. She has “a desire to be open and honest with you guys that climate change is really hard to live with and is overwhelming and does cause, certainly me, feelings of anxiety and overwhelm.” She continues to say, “My hope for you guys is not to turn off those feelings or turn off those emotions, but to have space for them and then from living inside that space, moving towards action and acknowledgment.”


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.