JANUARY 2024
Manager’s Note With ALPA pilots leading the way, 2023 was the year of the defined benefit plan. The Market-Based Cash Balance Plan (MBCBP) negotiated by the Delta pilots became effective on October 1, 2023. In midDecember, it was estimated that the Delta MBCBP would have approximately $100M in assets by year end, after only three months of operation. United pilots ratified a new contract in September, which provides for the establishment of an MBCBP. Implementation steps on that MBCBP have already begun and negotiations on outstanding issues will soon begin, with the anticipated effective date of January 1, 2025. After the Alaska Master Executive Council (MEC) completed an education campaign for its members, discussions are underway at Alaska Airlines for an MBCBP. Additionally, the pilots at American and Southwest recently reached an agreement with their airlines to establish MBCBPs. With the Delta pilots’ plan now in operation and other new contracts establishing MBCBPs, pilots have been successful in resurrecting defined benefit plans when interest in such plans had been waning for decades on the national landscape. But with inflation, a volatile stock market, and high interest rates, employees are interested in defined benefit plans again and making job choices based on the availability of pensions. Last year many employers also began showing renewed interest in defined benefit plans. Recent articles in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Forbes, and Pensions & Investments, as well as white papers from leading actuarial firms, all champion the return of defined benefit plans. Financial institutions, like Fidelity, have also opined on MBCBPs. ALPA’s success may lead other employee groups and employers to explore an alternative to the traditional defined benefit, such as a MBCBP. While an MBCBP is a qualified defined benefit plan, it has many features of a defined contribution plan, such as individual accounts, portability, lump-sum distributions, and in-service distributions beginning at age 59½. The funding of an MBCBP is typically based on a flat dollar contribution or a percentage of wages and is designed to capture market upsides and protect against market downsides in a way that results in a fully funded plan less subject to the risk of a distress termination during an employer’s financial downturn. All these features made the MBCBP attractive to pilots and will continue to attract the interest of other employee groups and employers.
CONTENTS Manager’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
Canadian Update . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
R&I Spotlight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Membership Plans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
Legislative & Legal Updates . . . . . . . . . . . 3
R&I Fast Facts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Court Cases of Interest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Investing & Marketing Outlook . . . . . . . . 18
Spotlight on Investing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
R&I Contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
NOTE: Text in blue is a live link to referenced external PDF files. Click on the link to open the file.
Questions? Comments? Please click here or e-mail Celeste.Sweeney@alpa.org
R&I Spotlight
Retirement & Insurance Seminar Save the Dates: May 1–3
Group Variable Universal Life Insurance In their 2023 contract, Delta pilots secured a provision requiring the company to offer a group variable universal life (GVUL) insurance policy for pilots. This policy went into effect on January 1, 2024.
Mark your calendar now for the 2024 Retirement & Insurance Seminar at ALPA’s offices in McLean, Va., on May 2–3. A reception will be held the evening of May 1 to kick off the event. The seminar will again feature panel discussions with pilots, ALPA staff, and outside benefits and investment professionals discussing the innovative work pilot groups are doing at both U.S. and Canadian airlines to meet pilots’ retirement and healthcare needs. A wide range of benefits topics will be covered, such as benefits in corporate mergers, fiduciary duty around benefit cybersecurity, 401(k) trends, healthcare plan trends, disability plan trends, financial market updates, and executive compensation. We hope you will attend!
GVUL insurance is a unique life insurance option that provides value in terms of a traditional life insurance policy payout, or death benefit, but also provides a living benefit, in the form of an investable tax-sheltered savings vehicle that can be withdrawn under certain circumstances. The investment options and rate of return vary with the market. Participants can contribute additional funds to their GVUL plan and self-direct their investments. All earnings grow tax-deferred. Unlike a retirement account, funds can be removed from GVUL accounts at any point in time. However, there is value in leaving the account balance invested as an additional source of income in retirement or an increased life insurance benefit. In certain instances, the funds within the GVUL account are not taxable upon being paid out. If the participant dies, then the benefits pass tax-free to the beneficiaries. However, there is another route to receive the funds tax-free prior to death. Any amount paid in premiums and the amount individually contributed by the participant increases the cost basis and can be removed tax-free. For example, if the employer pays $8,000 in premiums, and the participant chooses to individually contribute an additional $20,000 to the policy, then the participant can remove $28,000 tax-free from the GVUL account. The premiums paid can offset the investment earnings allowing them to be removed tax-free. If the $20,000 is invested and grows to $28,000, the entire balance can be removed tax-free. Even though $8,000 was made through investing, capital gains tax would not be due if the participant removed the entire balance, since the cost basis (premiums paid and the additional post-tax contribution) was equivalent to $28,000. If the balance of the GVUL account is higher than the cost basis, then the portion that amounts to the cost basis will be tax-free, and the remainder will be taxable income if withdrawn. However, the entire balance can be left in the account and be an additional bump to the agreed-upon life insurance payout upon the death of the policy owner. Withdrawing the individually contributed funds and their investment earning never deteriorates the life insurance payout if the participant were to pass. Table 2-2. Cost Per $1,000 of Protection for 1 Month Upon retirement, portability is more frequently offered and affordable for GVUL policies, unlike most group term life insurance. Group term life is usually converted to an individual policy that typically has high premium rates. GVUL portability provides participants with the ability to continue this coverage into retirement. Additionally, the investment earnings and taxadvantaged dollars can be used in retirement to pay for the GVUL premiums.
Age
Cost
Under 25. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 0.05 25 through 29 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.06 30 through 34 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.08 35 through 39 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.09 40 through 44 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.10 45 through 49 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.15 50 through 54 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.23 55 through 59 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.43 60 through 64. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.66 65 through 69 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.27 70 and older . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.06
R&I Update • 2 • January 2024
Similarly, GVUL is more advantageous in terms of imputed income. The IRS requires that fringe benefits valued over a certain amount be included as imputed income to the participant or else the benefit must be capped at $50,000. The IRS determines the value of the fringe benefit based on the amount that is in excess of $50,000 in consideration of the participant’s age bracket (Publication 15-B 2024, Table 2-2). Group term life benefits above $50,000 have imputed income associated with them, and taxes are paid based on the imputed income. Delta’s GVUL plan is set up as a Section 162 bonus plan. This means all premiums and investment dollars are made on a post-tax basis. The actual cost of the premium is added to the participant’s pay instead of the imputed income and then taxes are determined. This is significant as imputed income with group term life plans increases based on age bracket. A participant in their sixties will have significantly higher imputed income added to their gross pay. The actual premiums for the GVUL plan are often cheaper than the imputed income associated with group term life insurance. Ultimately, the newly added GVUL plan at Delta provides an additional tax-sheltered saving option that is investible, portable life insurance coverage and removes the burden of imputed income.
Legislative & Legal Updates What Is the Significance of an IRS Favorable Determination Letter? Because new pilot retirement plans have been or are in the process of being negotiated at airlines, this article focuses on the IRS determination letter process. In November 2023, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) revised and released Publication 794 Favorable Determination Letter explaining the significance, scope, and limitations of a favorable determination letter for an employee retirement plan.
What Is an IRS Favorable Determination Letter? An IRS determination letter is issued in response to a plan sponsor’s request on whether the retirement plan meets the requirements under Internal Revenue Code (Code) Section 401(a). Generally, an employer or plan sponsor is not required to apply for a determination letter, but most plan sponsors do seek a determination letter for added assurance that the plan document is tax-qualified and meets the requirements of Code Section 401(a). An employee retirement plan with a favorable determination letter and operating in accordance with the IRS-approved plan document is entitled to the following favorable tax treatment:
y The employer may deduct contributions made to the plan up to the IRS limits. y Employer contributions and employee pretax contributions are not included in an employee’s
taxable income at the time of contribution. Plan participants defer income taxes on these amounts until distribution.
y Contributions grow tax-deferred until distributed from the plan. Scope and Limitations of an IRS Favorable Determination Letter A favorable determination letter is not all-encompassing and does come with limitations. Favorable determination letters do not consider the following:
y Whether a plan satisfies the Code’s nondiscrimination requirements (e.g., does not discriminate in favor of highly compensated employees) unless the applicant has elected to receive an opinion on whether the plan satisfies one of the safe harbor plan design models offered in the Code.
y Whether a plan satisfies the Code’s minimum participation and coverage requirements. R&I Update • 3 • January 2024
y Whether actuarial assumptions are reasonable for funding or deduction purposes. y Special requirements for affiliated service groups, leased employees, or partial terminations unless the favorable determination application specifically requests consideration.
y Favorable determination letters do not provide assurance regarding conformity with changes to Code
Section 401(a). The IRS issues a Required Amendments List/Cumulative List each year and establishes procedures and deadlines for certain plans to comply with changes to the law.
y When an employer maintains two or more retirement plans, favorable determination letters do not apply to the plans on an aggregate basis. A determination letter should be obtained for each plan.
The IRS provides additional guidance on the scope and limitations of favorable determinations letters. Please refer to Publication 794 for more information.
John Hancock Life Insurance Company Advises Plan Sponsors to Calculate and Use Income Replacement Ratios to Determine Employee Retirement Readiness On November 8, 2023, John Hancock Life Insurance Company (John Hancock) released “How to Track Retirement Readiness with Income Replacement Ratios” as part of its State of the Participant 2023 retirement readiness series. The article encourages plan sponsors to “key in on the retirement readiness” of their employees, offers advice to employers on how to use income replacement ratios as a tool to measure retirement readiness, and provides specific plan design and participant experience improvements to increase retirement readiness. John Hancock considers a participant with an income replacement ratio of 70 percent as retirement ready. An income replacement ratio is a projection of how much of an employee’s salary will be replaced upon retirement. John Hancock includes the following factors when calculating its income replacement ratio:
y Participant’s current age y Retirement age of 67 y Account balance y Combined employer and employee contributions y Pension projection, if supplied by the employer y Social Security projection Due to the mandatory retirement age of 65, pilots will need more retirement savings than a participant retiring at age 67. The article suggests that income replacement ratios can help an employer determine whether a particular individual, a group of employees, or the entire employee population is on the right track toward retirement readiness or if the employer should consider a variety of plan improvements. For example, an income replacement ratio below 70 percent throughout the entire employee population may indicate the need for an increased employer matching contribution or the introduction of the auto-escalation feature. The article also suggests improvements such as providing guidance on deferral rates and expanding education campaigns overall to help participants achieve their goals. John Hancock compared the income replacement ratio and retirement readiness of its defined contribution plan participants on June 30, 2022, to the status of its participants on June 30, 2023, based on age and income and found declining retirement readiness among every age group and most income levels. For an in depth analysis of their findings and to learn more about income replacement ratios, read the full article.
R&I Update • 4 • January 2024
2024 U.S. Limits IRS Retirement Plan Limits
2023
2024
401(a)(17)—Qualified Plan Compensation Limit
$330,000
$345,000
415(b)—Defined Benefit Plan Limit
$265,000
$275,000
415(c)—Defined Contribution Plan Limit*
$66,000
$69,000
401(k)—Employee Pretax Deferral and Employee Roth 401(k) Contribution Limit
$22,500
$23,000
401(k) Catch-up (Age 50 and older)
$7,500
$7,500
Highly Compensated Employee Definition
$150,000
$155,000
*Catch-up contributions do not count against the 415(c) limit.
Traditional and Roth IRA eligibility and contributions limits do not apply to a rollover to a traditional or Roth IRA or to a conversion of a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA.
Group Health Plan Limits for 2024 The following are the HSA contribution limits and HSA qualifying high-deductible health plan (HDHP) cost-sharing limits for 2023 and 2024. In general, contributions to HSAs are permitted only if an individual is covered by an HDHP and no other health plan that is not an HDHP. Group Health Plan Limits
2023
2024
$3,850
$4,150
Family HDHP Coverage
$7,750
$8,300
Catch-up Contribution (age 55+)
$1,000
$1,000
Individual Coverage
$1,500
$1,600
Family Coverage
$3,000
$3,200
Individual Coverage
$7,500
$8,050
Family Coverage
$15,000
$16,100
HSA Contribution Limit Individual HDHP Coverage
HSA Minimum Deductible
HDHP Maximum Out-of-Pocket (In-network, including deductible and all other cost-sharing except premiums)
Note that the HDHP maximum out-of-pocket is different from and lower than the out-of-pocket limit that applies to all group health plans not grandfathered under the Affordable Care Act (ACA OOP limit). The inflation-adjusted ACA OOP limit applies to all in-network out-of-pocket expenses including deductibles, coinsurance, copayments, and any other cost-sharing for covered services, except premiums. The maximum out-of-pocket limit for an individual covered under an HDHP cannot exceed the ACA OOP limit, even if the HDHP does not otherwise have an embedded individual out-of-pocket limit. The inflation-adjusted ACA OOP limits for 2023 and 2024 are shown below. Maximum ACA Out-of-Pocket Limit (In-network, including deductible and all other cost-sharing except premiums)
2023
2024
Individual Coverage
$9,100
$9,450
Family Coverage
$18,200
$18,900
Flexible Spending Account Limits
2023
2024
Health Care FSA Contribution Limit
$3,050
$3,200
Health Care FSA Rollover Limit
$610
$640
Dependent Care FSA Contribution Limit
$5,000
$5,000*
*The $5,000 limit applies to participants who are single or married and filing jointly. Participants who are married and filing their taxes separately are limited to an annual contribution of $2,500.
R&I Update • 5 • January 2024
2024 Canadian Limits Retirement Limits
2023
2024
Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) Limit
$30,780
$31,560
Deferred Profit-Sharing Plan (DPSP) Limit
$15,780
$16,245
Money Purchase Registered Pension Plan (RPP) Limit
$31,560
$32,490
Defined Benefit (DB) Plan Limit
$3,506.67
$3,610
Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) Limit
$6,500
$6,500
CPP
QPP
Basic Exemption Amount
QPP
$3,500
$3,500
$66,600
$68,500
(no contributions required)
Maximum Pensionable Earnings (CPP1)
CPP
Employer/Employee Contribution Rate (CPP1)
5.95%
6.40%
5.95%
6.40%
NEW January 1, 2024
CPP
QPP
CPP
QPP
Additional Maximum Pensionable Earnings (CPP2)
n/a
$73,200
Employer/Employee Contribution Rate (CPP2)
n/a
n/a
4%
4%
Maximum Employer/Employee Contribution
$3,754.45
$4,038.40
$4,055.50
$4,348.00
The CPP provides retirement, disability, and survivor benefits and pensions to contributors and their families. The CPP applies in every province and territory in Canada with the exception of Quebec, where the QPP provides similar pensions and benefits. Every Canadian employee over age 18 must contribute to the CPP or QPP to qualify for retirement pension. The 2024 limits for U.S. and Canadian plans can be found on the R&I Resources site. They are also posted in the ALPA app, in the ALPA International Comms section.
Court Cases of Interest DOL Confirms That Citigroup’s Payment of Asset Manager Fees as Part of Diversity Initiative Does Not Involve Fiduciary Conduct On September 29, 2023, the Department of Labor issued Advisory Opinion 2023-01A addressing the fiduciary implications of a Citigroup diversity initiative. Citigroup launched its Action for Racial Equity Asset Manager Program (the “Program”) in 2020 to advance racial equity practices in the financial services industry. Under one component of the Program, Citigroup committed to paying some or all of the investment management fees for asset managers deemed “diverse asset managers” who were retained by Citigroup-sponsored employee benefit plans. The diverse asset manager designation is conferred based on the manager’s percentage of minority and/or female ownership. A Citigroup-appointed Investment Committee acts as the named fiduciary for the Citigroup-sponsored plans covered by the Program and is responsible for selecting and monitoring the asset managers for those plans. The Investment Committee takes eligibility for the Program into account as one of many factors to consider in selecting asset managers but maintains sole discretion as to which asset managers to select. Citigroup does not attempt to influence the Investment Committee in its decision-making process, nor does it consider the use of the Program in determining who to appoint to the Investment Committee. Citigroup does not ask the Investment Committee to explain its Program-related decisions regarding asset manager selection and does not set numerical goals for the Investment Committee to meet. Citigroup’s
R&I Update • 6 • January 2024
sole involvement is to determine to what extent the selected asset managers qualify for the fee payment under the Program. Citigroup asked the DOL for an opinion with respect to three items: 1. Are Citigroup’s activities under the Program settlor functions not subject to the fiduciary requirements of ERISA? 2. Is Citigroup’s commitment to pay fees under the Program among the financial factors the Investment Committee, as a prudent fiduciary, can consider in selecting an asset manager? 3. Would disclosing the Program to plan participants improperly influence their exercise of independent control over defined contribution plan accounts under any plans covered by the Program? The DOL first determined that Citigroup’s activities with respect to the Program are settlor and not fiduciary in nature. Those activities are limited to establishing the Program and paying fees for eligible asset managers. The DOL has long recognized that decisions regarding the extent to which fees are paid by plan sponsors are settlor decisions that are not subject to ERISA’s fiduciary standards. The DOL did emphasize that Citigroup is still a fiduciary with respect to management of the plan because it selects and monitors the members of the Investment Committee. The DOL next found that the Investment Committee could properly consider Citigroup’s payment of fees under the Program as a factor in its selection of asset managers. In the DOL’s view, the payment of fees is a relevant financial factor for the Investment Committee to consider and in and of itself would not be seen as impairing the Investment Committee’s best judgment as fiduciary. The DOL cautioned that it would be inconsistent with the Investment Committee’s fiduciary duties if its selection of an asset manager were motivated by a desire to advance Citigroup’s corporate public policy goals. In adding this cautionary note, the DOL emphasized that it was not addressing whether it would be inconsistent with ERISA’s fiduciary standards for plan fiduciaries to ever consider diversity, equity, and inclusion factors as material to the merits of choosing a particular asset manager. Lastly, the DOL stated that disclosures regarding the Program’s existence and the payment of fees for eligible asset managers would not improperly influence participants’ exercise of independent control over defined contribution plan accounts. Because the participants retain independent control and there is no improper influence, the plan fiduciaries are protected from liability in connection with the participant’s decisions with respect to those accounts. This Advisory Opinion provides a roadmap for plan sponsors and fiduciaries that may be interested in exploring creative ways to advance diversity in the financial services sector. We are not aware of any airlines that are considering similar initiatives, but it is anticipated that other companies may follow Citigroup’s lead.
Second Circuit Reiterates ERISA’s Duty of Loyalty and Prudence Standards and Requires Plaintiffs to Do More than Allege a Violation of the Statutory Elements in a Prohibited Transaction Claim In Cunningham v. Cornell University, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit (Second Circuit) held that for a prohibited transaction claim, “It is not enough to allege that a fiduciary caused the plan to compensate a service provider for its services; rather, the complaint must plausibly allege that the services were unnecessary or involved unreasonable compensation, thus supporting an inference of disloyalty.” R&I Update • 7 • January 2024
Applicable Law The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) defines a fiduciary and describes how fiduciaries must discharge their duties. Relevant to this case, fiduciaries must discharge their duties with respect to a plan solely in the interest of participants and beneficiaries (1) for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to participants and beneficiaries and defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan and (2) with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use in the conduct of an enterprise of a like character and with like aims. These duties are often referred to as the duty of loyalty and the duty of prudence, respectively. In addition to the duties of loyalty and prudence, ERISA bars certain transactions between a plan and a “party-in-interest” that involve uses of plan assets that are potentially harmful to the plan. The definition of a party-in-interest includes plan fiduciaries, any person providing services to a plan, employers, owners, certain relatives of any of the aforementioned, and unions. These barred transactions are known as prohibited transactions. Except as exempted by ERISA, a fiduciary is barred from engaging in transactions if the fiduciary knows or should know that the transaction constitutes a direct or indirect: 1. Sale or exchange, or leasing, of any property between the plan and a party-in-interest; 2. Lending of money or other extension of credit between the plan and a party-in-interest; 3. Furnishing of goods, services, or facilities between the plan and a party-in-interest; 4. Transfer to, or use by or for the benefit of a party-in-interest, of any assets of the plan; or 5. Acquisition, on behalf of the plan, of any employer security or employer real property in violation of Section 1107(a) of ERISA. ERISA provides several exemptions from prohibited transactions, including in relevant part, “[c]ontracting or making reasonable arrangements with a party-in-interest for office space, or legal, accounting, or other services necessary for the establishment or operation of the plan, if no more than reasonable compensation is paid therefor.”
Background The plaintiffs represent a class of former Cornell University employees who participated in two of the University’s defined contribution retirement plans: the Retirement Plan and the TDA Plan (Plans) from 2010 to 2016. As of 2016, the Retirement Plan had over 19,000 participants and nearly $2 billion in net assets, and the TDA Plan had over 11,000 participants and $1.34 billion in net assets. Cornell University, as administrator of the plans, delegated its administrative responsibilities to the Retirement Plan Oversight Committee (RPOC), which was responsible for selecting a menu of investment options for participants to choose from as well as other fiduciary duties. The RPOC hired CapFinancial Partners, LLC Financial Advisors (CAPTRUST) as the plans’ investment advisor and administrative consultant. The Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America-College Retirement Equities Fund (TIAA-CREF) and Fidelity Investments Inc. (Fidelity) served as the plans’ recordkeepers. The plaintiffs filed suit in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (District Court) against Cornell University, the RPOC, and CAPTRUST alleging the following ERISA fiduciary duty violations: 1. Offering certain investments, including high-cost retail class shares of mutual funds, despite their high fees and poor performance; 2. Failure to monitor and control recordkeeping fees paid to TIAA-CREF and Fidelity; 3. Failure to review the fees and performances associated with the plans’ investment options;
R&I Update • 8 • January 2024
4. Entering into certain prohibited transactions; and 5. Failure to monitor the appointed fiduciaries. The District Court either dismissed or granted summary judgment in favor of Cornell and other defendants on all allegations other than the defendants’ failure to adopt a lower-cost share of mutual funds. Cunningham appealed to the Second Circuit while the parties settled the one remaining claim.
Duty of Loyalty The Second Circuit affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of the plaintiff’s claim of failure to control recordkeeping fees. The plaintiffs alleged, based on the testimony of two expert witnesses, that a reasonable recordkeeping fee for the plans would have been a flat fee of $35 per participant from 2010 to 2014. Neither expert witness offered a methodology in support of their conclusions. The expert witnesses referenced other university plans with lower fees but offered no explanation as to how the comparators were selected. The plaintiffs purport that the retirement plan paid between $115 and $183 per participant and the TDA plan paid between $145 and $200 per participant per year from 2010 to 2014. The plaintiffs failed to allege any facts relative to the quality of recordkeeping services provided. The Second Circuit held “whether fees are excessive or not is relative to services rendered and it is not unreasonable to pay more for superior services.”
Duty of Prudence The Second Circuit affirmed the District Court’s ruling of summary judgment in favor of the defendants because the plaintiffs failed to establish that any breach of fiduciary duty resulted in loss. ERISA provides that fiduciaries are personally liable for losses to the plan resulting from a breach. Losses are measured by the difference between the plan’s actual performance and how the plan would have performed if the funds had been operated like other funds being properly operated during the same period. With respect to excessive fees, the plaintiff must prove that the excessive fees were charged as a result of the fiduciary’s imprudent actions and show a prudent alternative. To escape liability, the defendant must then prove that some or all of the loss would have occurred had the fiduciary not breached its duty. The Second Circuit held that the plaintiffs failed to provide evidence of a suitable benchmark against which loss can be measured. Further, the Second Circuit held that no reasonable trier of fact could determine that the defendants’ process of reviewing the plans’ investment options or determining whether to remove underperforming options was flawed such that the defendants’ violated their duty of prudence. To establish a breach of the duty of prudence, a plaintiff must show that the fiduciary’s conduct fell below the prudent man standard of care discussed above. Subsequently, plan fiduciaries must conduct their own independent evaluation to determine whether investments may be prudently included in the plan’s menu of options, and they must remove any imprudent investment options from the plan within a reasonable amount of time. Failure to do so would be imprudent. The Second Circuit held that the duty of prudence turns on the circumstances prevailing at the time of the fiduciary acts, and courts must determine whether a fiduciary employed the appropriate methods to investigate the merits of a particular investment based on the information available to the fiduciary at the time of the investment decision. The Second Circuit found that the defendants had processes to review the plans’ investment options at all points during the class period and the process was followed, that once the IRS updated its regulations on 403(b) plans, the defendants’ hired CAPTRUST and launched a multiyear process focused on the redesigning and streamlining the investment menu. Once a new investment policy statement was approved, the defendants’ considered the required qualitative and quantitative criteria described therein, CAPTRUST’s advice, popularity of investment options among participants, and available options among peer institutions.
R&I Update • 9 • January 2024
Prohibited Transactions The Second Circuit affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of the prohibited transaction claims on the grounds that the plaintiff did not adequately allege that the challenged prohibited transaction involved self-dealing or disloyal conduct. The Second Circuit held that to plead a violation of ERISA’s prohibited transaction rules, a complaint “must plausibly allege that a fiduciary has caused the plan to engage in a transaction that constitutes the “furnishing of . . . services . . . between the plan and a party-in-interest” where that transaction was unnecessary or involved unreasonable compensation.” The Second Circuit explained that the existence of the prohibited transaction exemptions are referenced directly in the text of the prohibited transaction statute; therefore, the burden is on the plaintiff to plead and prove that the defendant is not within the exemption. If all payments by plans or plan fiduciaries to third parties in exchange for plan services were presumptively prohibited, then ERISA plans would no longer be able to outsource common fiduciary duties such as recordkeeping and investment advising, which would likely result in lower returns for participants and higher plan administration costs.
Existing Circuit Split on Prohibited Transaction Pleadings In affirming the District Court’s dismissal of the prohibited transaction claims, the Second Circuit recognized a split amount other circuit courts with respect to what facts a plaintiff must allege to please a plausible prohibited transaction claim. The Third, Seventh, and Tenth Circuits require plaintiffs to allege something more than the bare elements of ERISA; otherwise, fiduciaries would be prohibited from engaging third-party vendors to perform essential plan services for a plan. Following the Third, Seventh, and Tenth Circuits, the Second Circuit concluded that at the pleading stage, an ERISA-prohibited Key Takeaways transaction claim must do more than allege facts that the y To get past the pleading stage of a prohibited transaction claim, plaintiffs must meet the standard of the Circuit transaction meets the technical holding jurisdiction of the claim. It may not be enough to elements of a party-in-interest present facts alleging that the plan sponsor, investment transaction of the statute. manager, or recordkeeper engaged in a prohibited transaction Instead, plaintiffs must also plead with a party-in-interest. The plaintiff may also have to prove plausible facts showing that the that none of the exemptions are applicable. prohibited transaction statutory exemptions do not apply. y Considering that multiple Circuits are split on the pleading standard for prohibited transactions, the Supreme Court may On the other side, the Eighth find it appropriate to resolve the conflict. and Ninth Circuits only require a plaintiff to plead the elements y Fiduciaries do not have to select the third-party service of the prohibited transaction provider with the cheapest fees. It is not a breach of fiduciary rules and are not required to duty to choose to pay a higher price for superior services. allege that the compensation was y A fiduciary’s level of prudence is evaluated based on the unreasonable. These courts have facts and circumstances at the time of the decision-making held that the ERISA exemptions process. Courts do not evaluate prudence based on hindsight, from the prohibited transaction nor must a fiduciary prove that their decision was the only rules are affirmative defenses prudent choice. that are a defendant’s burden to prove.
R&I Update • 10 • January 2024
Spotlight on Investing In October, we published our annual 401(k) report, a comprehensive look at the features of ALPA pilot defined contribution plans, including how pilots save, invest, and interact with them. This report comprises 12 pilot groups, including FFT and SCA for the first time, as well as DAL, UAL, FDX, JBU, ALA, HAL, SPA, ENY, EDV, and ARW, all of which were included in past reports. As both the number of airlines and the number of pilots at each airline are expanding, this report now covers more than 65,000 pilot participants in these plans, up significantly from less than 54,000 in 2021. This is a substantial portion of ALPA’s 75,000 members. We have also been able to obtain and report on a wide range of new plan data and demographic information, building on similar improvements and expansion of the report in recent years. This report contains new data on managed accounts, IRS limit activity, and a deeper look at loan activity than has ever been aggregated across ALPA pilot plans. Nationwide, 2022 was a down year for DC plans. After several strong years of appreciation in financial markets, asset values across vast swaths of both equity and fixed income fell by doubledigit percentages in 2022. Despite strong growth in the number of participants and continued strong contributions resulting from high pilot participation rates, deferral rates, and employer contributions, plans covering ALPA pilots declined about 16 percent in 2022, from $40.0 billion to $33.6 billion. Although still below peaks reached at the end of 2021, plans regained many of those losses in 2023 as markets rebounded. While considering retirement and investing, it’s important to examine all aspects of financial planning. Below is a list of six areas to review when financial planning. The list has been adapted from Securian Financial Services by adding items that pertain to pilots. Additionally, while undergoing the process of financial planning, it may be helpful to review our Survivors’ Checklist, which can be a valuable resource for your family in the event of your death. Keep it updated at least every three years, or sooner if your family or financial situation changes substantially or if your pilot group negotiates a new contract with your airline.
R&I Update • 11 • January 2024
Canadian Update Corrective Contributions and Adjustments for Defined Contribution Pension Plans In June 2023, the enactment of Bill C-47 marked a significant milestone in the evolution of defined contribution pension plans (DCPPs) in Canada. This legislative development, part of the 2023 federal budget, introduced crucial amendments to the Income Tax Act and its regulations, with profound implications for correcting contribution errors with respect to DCPPs. These changes are effective retroactively to January 1, 2021.
Correcting Under-Contributions The amendments, inspired by long-anticipated changes initially introduced in the 2021 federal budget, revolutionize the correction of under-contributions. Previously, retroactive contributions to DCPPs were not permitted, which restricted corrections to the annual contribution limits. In response, Bill C-47 established the concept of a permitted corrective contribution (PCC). PCCs enable plan administrators to rectify common retrospective administrative issues, such as failure to enroll an individual as a plan member on time or to make required contributions according to the plan’s terms. This newfound flexibility allows the addressing of under-contributions within a 10-year window preceding the correction, offering a comprehensive solution to historical discrepancies. PCCs are intricately tied to specific criteria that focus on failures in enrolling individuals as plan members or ensuring the fulfillment of required contributions according to the plan's stipulations. This targeted approach ensures that corrective measures are directly aligned with instances of oversight or noncompliance, streamlining the correction process. While PCCs provide administrative ease, they are not without limitations. A PCC is limited to the lesser of two factors: 1. The difference between missed contributions and applicable interest and the amount of previous PCCs for that individual during the same period, or 2. 150 percent of the applicable money purchase dollar limit for the year minus the total prior PCCs for the individual. Just as DCPP contributions reduce an individual’s RRSP deduction limit, so too will a PCC. PCCs trigger an appropriate reduction in an individual’s RRSP deduction limit for the subsequent taxation year. In cases where this reduction leads to a negative balance of unused RRSP contribution room, individuals may find themselves restricted from making new deductible RRSP contributions until the excess contributions are withdrawn or the RRSP deduction limit returns to a positive balance. Previously, such accurate corrections were not permitted because there was no framework for managing the impact of corrections on prior years’ deduction limits. So, if an employer under-contributed to an employee’s DCPP, the typical solution would be a lump-sum payment in the current year based on extraordinarily complicated calculations regarding individual gains and losses. Eliminating this battle by standardizing the process will serve employees across the country well toward maintaining their contractual DCPP investment contributions and gains.
Addressing Over-Contributions Where under-contributions are corrected with PCCs, the new legislation provides over-contributions with their own corrective process: the pension adjustment correction (PAC). Traditionally when contributions made to a DCPP surpass the prescribed limits set by the plan, severe consequences could be triggered, potentially leading to the revocation of the plan’s registration. The PAC R&I Update • 12 • January 2024
process ensures that individuals restore their RRSP room for each year in which excess contributions are refunded or corrected, subject to certain limits. In particular, a PAC can only be calculated and reported on excess contributions that were made in the 10 years immediately preceding the calendar year in which the plan refunds excess contributions. The streamlined PAC process enhances the efficiency of plan administration, aligning with the broader goal of simplifying regulatory compliance. For pilots enrolled in defined contribution pension plans, these legislative changes bring several benefits. The ability to make retroactive contributions provides a means to rectify errors or missed contributions over the past decade. This flexibility not only ensures compliance with plan terms but also safeguards your RRSP deduction limits. The streamlined correction processes for both under-contributions and over-contributions contribute to a more straightforward and efficient management of registered pension plans, ultimately enhancing the financial well-being of all plan members.
Navigating the Skies of Financial Security: A Guide to Canada’s First Home Savings Account In the ever-evolving financial planning landscape, it is crucial to stay informed about opportunities that help shape the future. One such opportunity that has recently taken flight in Canada is the First Home Savings Account (FHSA), a governmentsponsored program designed to help Canadians achieve their dreams of homeownership while reaping tax benefits along the way. Launched in April 2023, the FHSA is a strategic initiative by the Canadian government to address the challenges of housing affordability, recognizing the importance of stable housing for individuals and families.
How Does the FHSA Work? The FHSA operates as a tax-advantaged savings account specifically earmarked for the purchase of a first home. Here are the basics: 1. Eligibility Criteria: Participants must be Canadian residents, at least 18 years of age, and a first-time homebuyer. This opportunity can be helpful for both seasoned captains, or brand new first officers, as residents are eligible until they reach age 71. 2. Contribution Limits: There is an annual contribution limit of $8,000, up to an ultimate contribution maximum of $40,000, and any unused contribution room carries forward to the next year. Unlike TFSAs where contribution room accrues every year even before the TFSA has been opened, FHSA contribution room only begins to accrue once the account is created, or the first deposit is made. Each year thereafter, a participant may contribute an additional $8,000, up to the $40,000 maximum. 3. Tax Advantages: One of the key advantages of the FHSA is the tax treatment it receives. Similar to a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP), contributions to the FHSA are tax-deductible, meaning taxable income is reduced by the amount contributed. However, unlike RRSPs, investment gains and withdrawals from the FHSA are tax-free, as long as they are used to purchase a qualifying home. 4. Investment Options: FHSA funds can be invested in a variety of financial instruments, such as mutual funds, GICs, and other low to moderate-risk investments. This allows savings to grow over time, potentially increasing the purchasing power when the participant is ready to buy a home. 5. Withdrawal Conditions: Funds from the FHSA can be withdrawn without any tax implications as long as they are used to purchase a qualifying home. Otherwise, any amount withdrawn from the FHSA must be included as taxable income for the year the withdrawal is received.
R&I Update • 13 • January 2024
Strategies for Airline Pilots The unique financial circumstances and income patterns of an airline pilot may require a tailored approach to maximize the benefits of the FHSA. Here are some strategies to consider: 1. Income Averaging: Given the variable nature of pilot income, consider utilizing the FHSA during years with higher earnings. This can help optimize tax deductions and take advantage of the FHSA’s tax benefits during peak earning years. 2. Spousal Contributions: Married people can explore the option of having both partners contribute to separate FHSAs. This can effectively double the annual contribution limit, allowing for faster accumulation of funds for a first home. 3. Investment Diversification: FHSA investments can be diversified with a mix of stocks and bonds to potentially enhance returns over the long term. However, it is important to ensure that the risk aligns with overall personal financial goals. 4. Long-Term Planning: The FHSA is not a short-term solution. It requires careful long-term planning to maximize its benefits. Individuals should evaluate their homeownership goals and create a timeline that aligns with their career trajectory and personal aspirations. While the FHSA is an effective standalone tool, its utility is significantly enhanced when used in tandem with complementary savings vehicles. For example, the FHSA seamlessly complements another powerful tool in Canada’s homeownership toolkit—the Home Buyers’ Plan (HBP). Understanding the symbiotic relationship between the FHSA and the HBP is an important step in judicious financial planning for homeownership.
The Home Buyers' Plan Introduced in 1992, the HBP allows first-time homebuyers to withdraw up to $35,000 from their RRSPs to finance the purchase or construction of a qualifying home. The withdrawn amount is not subject to income tax, provided it is repaid to the RRSP within a 15-year timeframe.
Harmony Between the FHSA and the HBP The FHSA and HBP operate in concert, creating a harmonious financial toolbelt for aspiring homeowners. Pilots can diversify their funding sources by utilizing both programs. The FHSA allows tax-deductible contributions and tax-free withdrawals for home purchases, while the HBP leverages RRSPs to provide additional financial flexibility. In terms of withdrawal limits, while the FHSA allows full withdrawal of all the property tax-free, the HBP permits tax-free withdrawals of up to $35,000. By strategically leveraging both programs, a buyer can potentially access more than $75,000 for their first home, offering a substantial financial cushion. The combination of FHSA and HBP funds significantly boosts down payment capabilities. An increased down payment not only strengthens negotiating positions but may also help secure more favorable mortgage terms, ultimately reducing the overall cost of homeownership. Strategic collaboration between FHSA and HBP offers a comprehensive approach to financing the path to homeownership.
Strategic Integration to Make the Most of Your FHSA and HBP To optimize the utility of both the FHSA and HBP, thoughtful strategic integration is key. It is wise to prioritize the FHSA for its flexibility, particularly due to the absence of a mandatory repayment schedule. This makes it an ideal choice for short-to-medium-term financial goals, such as funding for a down payment. For longer-term planning, consider tactically using the HBP. Reserve it for scenarios where a more extended repayment period aligns with your overall financial strategy. This approach can be particularly advantageous for those who anticipate a more stable income in the future. R&I Update • 14 • January 2024
A crucial aspect of this integration is coordinating contributions. By carefully aligning contributions to both the FHSA and RRSP, individuals can optimize their tax deductions. Consulting with a financial advisor is recommended to ensure a balanced approach to contributions, tailored to your specific financial goals. As pilots chart their course toward homeownership, the combination of the FHSA and HBP presents a powerful symphony of financial empowerment. By strategically integrating these two programs, pilots can navigate the complexities of entering the real estate market with a robust financial strategy, bringing them closer to the dream of a secure and stable home.
Membership Plans Premium Holiday for ALPA National Disability Plan Participants A premium holiday for the month of December 2023 was awarded for all members enrolled in an ALPA national disability plan, which resulted in over $380,000 in saved premiums for 12,743 active members enrolled in the Base, Extended, and Lump Sum plans.
New Dental Provider January 1, 2024 ALPA changed from Anthem Dental to MetLife Dental beginning January 1, 2024. Eligible active and retired members can enroll via the Member Insurance enrollment portal. MetLife Dental is the largest administrator of dental benefit plans among all single commercial carriers (LIMRA 4Q21 U.S. Workplace Benefits Dental and Vision Final In Force Report, based on in force market share) providing dental plan administration for more than 20 million people (MetLife data as of January 2022).
y Largest Network. Through MetLife Dental, members will have access to more than 400,000 general practitioners and 118,000 specialists with over 535,800 access points nationwide. Typical network savings of 30 to 45 percent on covered services when using a participating dentist. (Based on internal analysis by MetLife. Savings from enrolling in a dental benefits plan will depend on various factors, including the cost of the plan, how often participants visit the dentist and the cost of services rendered.)
y Regular cleanings. The ALPA plans make preventive care affordable with two free cleanings per calendar year.
y Access Online Services. The MyBenefits website is a quick
and easy way for members to get information about MetLife benefits. Members can log in at metlife.com/mybenefits to access plan information, find a participating dentist, or view their benefits, copay, coinsurance amount, and claims online. Plus, members have access to MetLife’s extensive Oral Health Library to research important dental topics. Additionally, MetLife’s mobile app allows members to quickly access and manage benefit information—anytime, anywhere.
R&I Update • 15 • January 2024
Long-Term Care Resources for ALPA Members and Staff The number of Americans finding themselves needing long-term care (LTC) services continues to grow. The American healthcare system offers a wide range of care services for those who develop a long-term illness or disability. These services often begin with care at home, followed by care in a range of facilities including assisted living facilities and nursing homes. People of all ages may need long-term services at some point in life due to illness or injury. Because the need for LTC can last for years, expenses may present a difficult financial situation that impacts both quality of life and financial security. ALPA offers a marketplace where members can browse and select from LTC options with the help of a consultant. Learn more.
Member Insurance Enrollment New Enrollments 2023: VEBA Plans with Start Dates January 1 to December 1, 2023 Note: The difference between “full annual premium” and “annual member contribution” are applicable discounts for new hires.
Policies
Full Annual Premium
Annual Member Contribution
Life
1,763
$381,531
$335,616
Long-Term Disability
1,610
$337,085
$164,180
Accident
1,533
$211,448
$64,972
Critical Illness
1,925
$209,941
$73,870
Dental
44
$53,502
$53,502
Grand Total
6,875
$1,193,506
$692,140
Plan/Membership Class
All VEBA Plan Enrollments as of November 28, 2023 Note: The difference between “full annual premium” and “annual member contribution” are applicable discounts for new hires.
Plan Name
Policies
Full Annual Premium
Annual Member Contribution
Life
15,601
$5,829,288
$5,706,904
ALPA National Disability
12,315
$4,527,841
$4,021,519
Critical Illness
7,091
$1,247,866
$1,015,212
Accident
5,824
$1,033,274
$793,818
Dental
1,193
$1,529,008
$1,529,008
Grand Total
42,024
$14,167,276
$13,066,461
R&I Fast Facts Long-Term Care in the United States The National Bureau of Economics Research released a paper analyzing the increasing need for long-term care plans in the impending future. By 2050 it is estimated that one-fifth of the population will be above age 65 in most states. Long-term care is becoming more of a necessity when considering 30% of those age 65, and 60% of those age 85 report at least one activity of daily living is limited. Currently, four hours of in-home care a day can amount to over $30,000 annually, while private nursing homes have a far greater cost, estimated to be $108,000 annually. R&I Update • 16 • January 2024
2024 Benefit Trends Mercer released its assessment of top benefit trends in 2023 that will carry into 2024. The average cost of employer-sponsored healthcare rose 5.2% in 2023. Prescription coverage experienced an increase of 8.4% and is projected to keep rising in the new year as Glucagon-like Peptied-1 drugs used with diabetes and weight management become a more popular form of treatment. With healthcare costs rising, employers remain concerned about affordability. Other coverage concerns include mental health care and women’s reproductive health. In Segal’s 2024 trends report, a portion of the increase in pharmacy benefits was related to utilization changes. Patients are using higher-cost specialty drugs in lieu of low-cost therapies. However, inflation is the primary cause of the increased cost for hospital, physician, and prescription costs. Additionally, the report projects a 4% increase for dental plans in the upcoming year.
Kaiser’s 2023 Employer Benefits Survey The report found the average annual cost in 2023 for family healthcare coverage was $23,968—a $2,626 increase from last year. In addition to rising premiums, costs built into plans are also increasing; deductibles are up 78% from 10 years ago. When considering how to fight rising healthcare costs, the survey reveals that plan sponsors are either considering increasing the cost share (17% of employers) or increasing the worker’s premium contribution (23% of employers). Increasing the cost share includes altering plan design features, like raising deductibles, coinsurance, copays, and out-of-pocket maximums. Of the employers who responded, a majority of participants were enrolled in either a PPO plan (47%) or an HDHP (29%). Adding an HSA-qualified plan was another more popular option for planning for managing the increasing healthcare costs.
2023 Health Savings Account (HSA) Survey Results Plan Sponsor Council of America released its 2023 HSA Survey results, which analyze 2022 HSA data. The results revealed that 80% of HSA-eligible participants contribute to their HSA. In addition to the participant contributions, 75% of employers contribute as well. Another way employers are aiding in HSA participation is paying the monthly fee associated with having a health savings account. This typically amounts to a monthly fee of less than $5 per participant, and 60% of employers pay for this fee. At least a third of the surveyed employers are educating employees and emphasizing how an HSA can be used in retirement; however, 70% of HSA funds remain uninvested and liquid. Another interesting trend is the increase in the use of automatic enrollment. When a participant enrolls in an HSA-eligible high-deductible health plan, 46.5% of employers automatically enroll their participants in the HSA component. R&I Update • 17 • January 2024
SCHWAB CENTER FOR FINANCIAL RESEARCH
Investing & Markets Outlook January 2024
In this publication, the Schwab Center for Financial Research provides its point of view on timely issues of importance to investors as they make decisions about their portfolios. The perspectives in this report are current as of January 1, 2024. This report covers six key areas: Macro Outlook
U.S. Equities U.S. Fixed Income International Equities International Fixed Income Washington
Charles Schwab
Classification: Schwab Internal
R&I Update • 18 • January 2024
2
MACRO OUTLOOK Sluggish global economic growth is likely in 2024 •
Global economic activity appears to be stabilizing. The Global Manufacturing Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) has shown some stabilization in recent months, and services PMI may be following. Manufacturing contributes more to changes in economic growth than services does, and it tends to lead changes in services activity. Employment could weaken, as it tends to lag changes in demand.
•
Central banks are likely to cut benchmark interest rates. Declining inflation tends to increase inflation-adjusted (or “real”) interest rates. A rise in real rates combined with an ongoing contraction of central bank balance sheets—in which the bank sells securities or does not replace maturing ones, a form of “quantitative tightening”— could slow economic growth and prompt central banks to cut rates.
•
Gradual decline and recovery is possible. If the manufacturing stabilization is a sign that the global economy is undergoing a “soft landing” (that is, an economic slowdown that avoids recession), we would expect the subsequent recovery to be U-shaped (gradual decline and recovery), not V-shaped (drastic decline and sharp recovery). Tight labor markets and lack of excess debt globally could help prevent a severe recession.
•
Both inflation and the job market might inspire the Fed to cut rates in 2024. Fed policymakers have signaled intent to cut the federal funds rate in 2024, with many citing declining inflation. We think job-market softness also will be a catalyst for rate cuts. The pace of hiring has continued to slow and a significant portion of payroll gains over the past few months have been in sectors that typically don’t shed jobs even during a recession.
Manufacturing activity may have stabilized July’s reading may have been the low point for this cycle
Source: Charles Schwab, FactSet, as of 1/4/2024. The S&P Global Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) surveys output and employment intentions of manufacturers and service providers. A level above 50 indicates economic expansion, while a number below 50 indicates a contracting economy. Lines are truncated for visual purposes. The Manufacturing PMI index low was 39, Services was 23 and Composite was 26. The Services PMI peak was 58 and Composite was 59.
Charles Schwab
Classification: Schwab Internal
3
U.S. EQUITIES Stocks continued to rally into the end of 2023 •
Stocks maintained their upward momentum in December. A continuation of the rally that started in late October led to a strong finish for the S&P 500, with the index up 24% in 2023. The Russell 2000 saw a smaller gain of 15%, but that’s an impressive feat given the index was in negative territory (year-to-date) in October. The fall in bond yields at the end of the year was a significant driver of the strength in stocks.
•
Stocks have gone a long time without a new high. As of the end of 2023, the S&P 500 hadn’t managed to surpass its prior all-time high in January 2022. That means the index has now gone at least 500 days without making a new high—a longer-than-usual streak based on its history. The length of time alone doesn’t suggest a good or bad situation for the market, but perhaps reinforces that the climb since the October 2022 low hasn’t been easy.
•
Market breadth has improved. A key, positive aspect of the market’s rally since late October has been an improvement in breadth, or the number of stocks advancing relative to those that are declining. Segments like small-capitalization stocks and more economically sensitive “cyclical” equity sectors—which struggled throughout 2023—have outperformed. If those trends hold, it should bode well for the market as the new year unfolds. We don’t expect this to occur without bouts of volatility, however.
•
We suggest focusing on companies with high-quality attributes, such as strong profit margins, upward revisions to earnings estimates, and high interest coverage ratios. These companies may be better positioned to weather potential ups and downs.
The S&P 500 has not surpassed its all-time high The index has gone at least 500 days without making a new high, a longer-than-usual streak based on its history
Source: Schwab Center for Financial Research, Bloomberg data, as of 12/29/2023. For illustrative purposes only. Indexes are unmanaged, do not incur management fees, costs and expenses (or “transaction fees or other related expenses”) and cannot be invested in directly. See Important Disclosures page for definitions of the index used in this chart. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Charles Schwab
Classification: Schwab Internal
R&I Update • 19 • January 2024
4
U.S. FIXED INCOME The Federal Reserve signaled it will pivot to easing in 2024 •
The Federal Reserve has signaled a likely shift to easing in 2024. The 2023 year-end bond market rally was spurred in part by the Fed's median projection showing three rate cuts of 25 basis points (or 0.25%) each in 2024, but the market is pricing in five to six cuts. Our base-case outlook calls for a total of 75 basis points in cuts, likely starting mid-year, given inflation’s decline toward the Fed’s 2% target.
•
Ten-year Treasury yields historically have peaked before the final rate hike of the cycle, but it was different this time. Assuming the last rate hike was in July 2023, the rise in 10-year yields postpeak was the exception to the pattern. However, yields returned to the July level after the Fed’s December dot plot—which shows policymakers’ estimates for interest rates in the future—signaled no further hikes in this cycle.
•
Ten-year Treasury yields are near fair value. Based on the longterm median spread between the Fed's projected long-run federal funds rate target of 2.5%, the 10-year Treasury yield appears fairly valued near 4%. While the range of the spread can be wide, the current level is near the lower end, suggesting it may be hard for yields to fall much farther near term.
•
Consider high-quality bonds. Highly rated bond yields are attractive, as yields remain near their highest levels in years, albeit down from recent peaks. We suggest investors consider riskier investments only in moderation. Positive returns for bond investments seem likely in 2024, but it could be difficult for riskier investments to outperform Treasuries given the low yield advantage.
Ten-year Treasury yield is now down from peak rate After bucking its historical trend, by the end of 2023 the 10year yield was below its July 2023 level
Source: Schwab Center for Financial Research with data from Bloomberg. US Generic Govt 10 Yr (USGG10YR Index) and Federal Funds Target Rate – Upper Bound (FDTR Index). Change in 10-year Treasury yield using monthly data, with the peak federal funds rate at month zero using the following months: Feb. 1995, May 2000, June 2006, Dec. 2018 and July 2023. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Charles Schwab
Classification: Schwab Internal
5
INTERNATIONAL EQUITIES The “average” international stock has outperformed the average U.S. stock •
International stocks have been outpacing U.S. stocks, if one compares broad-based indices on an equal-weight basis (an equal-weight index assigns the same importance to all stocks in the index, versus a market-capitalization index in which the largest-cap stocks have a bigger influence). On a market-cap basis, the MSCI EAFE Index is less concentrated than the S&P 500. The biggest seven names comprise 27% of the S&P 500 index vs. just 12% for the MSCI EAFE Index. If the rally in stocks continues to broaden out across companies and sectors, international stocks could benefit on a relative basis.
•
Markets are cheering rate-cut prospects but could be erratic. Risks include volatility in economic data and earnings, geopolitical unrest, and a possible shift to nationalist policies ahead of elections in countries totaling half the world’s population.
•
A rate hike by the Bank of Japan could impact investors globally. Domestic Japanese investors are the largest non-U.S. holders of U.S. Treasuries and foreign stocks in the world. If yields on Japanese government bonds rise, domestic Japanese investors could bring back money from the rest of the world, which could hurt prices of stocks, bonds, and currencies globally.
•
Investors may need to get used to slower growth for longer in China, due in part to a weak property market and the past buildup of debt. While the property market is a drag on growth, we don’t believe international spillover is likely—China’s slowdown is likely to be felt mainly in China.
The average international stock has outperformed The equal-weight MSCI EAFE index has performed well vs the equal-weight S&P 500 index
For illustrative purposes only. Indexes are unmanaged, do not incur management fees, costs and expenses (or “transaction fees or other related expenses”) and cannot be invested in directly. See Important Disclosures page for definitions of the indexes used in this chart. Source: Charles Schwab, Bloomberg, as of 1/2/2024. Chart data begins (normalized) 10/31/2022. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Charles Schwab
Classification: Schwab Internal
R&I Update • 20 • January 2024
6
INTERNATIONAL FIXED INCOME Global central bank interest rate-hike cycle is likely coming to an end •
Rate cuts are likely on the horizon. Most large developed-market central banks, like the European Central Bank, the Bank of England, and the Bank of Canada, have held steady at their last few meetings, and the next move for each central bank is expected to be a cut. The Bank of Japan continues to be the outlier, whose next move could be a hike.
•
Global bond markets generally posted gains in 2024. Yields tended to decline as policy shifted from aggressive tightening over the last few years to potential easing in 2024. The Bloomberg Global Aggregate ex-USD Index posted a total return of 5.7% last year, as income return, price return, and currency return were all positive.
•
The decline in the dollar helped boost global bond returns as bonds denominated in rising local currencies benefited. The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index fell 2.7% last year, following a 6% increase in 2022.
•
Emerging-market bond spreads declined at the end of 2023 and are near their lowest levels since late 2021. A soft landing for the U..S economy would generally be good news for emerging-market economies. So would a continued decline in the dollar, which could boost emerging-market bonds denominated in local currencies.
The U.S. dollar weakened in 2023 After rising 6% in 2022, the Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index declined 2.7% in 2023
Source: Bloomberg, using daily data as of 12/31/2023. Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index (BBDXY). The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index tracks the performance of the U.S. dollar versus a basket of leading global currencies including the euro, Japanese yen, Canadian dollar, British pound and Mexican peso. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Charles Schwab
7
Charles Schwab
8
Classification: Schwab Internal
WASHINGTON Congress starts 2024 with tricky government funding deadlines •
Congress faces twin government shutdown deadlines. The House and Senate return to Washington the week of January 8 to immediately face a government shutdown risk. About 20% of government operations is funded through January 19, while the rest of the government has funding only until February 2. But the two chambers have not even agreed on the overall federal spending numbers, let alone all the agency-by-agency and program-byprogram funding details. While the risk of a government shutdown is high, previous shutdowns have not had a big impact on the markets.
•
The emergency aid package for Ukraine and Israel also remains in limbo. The president’s $106 billion proposal includes aid for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan, along with humanitarian aid and border security funds. A bipartisan group of senators has been negotiating for weeks on border security policy changes, which they hope will win enough support to unlock the much-needed aid for Ukraine. But those negotiations have not yielded an agreement yet and optimism about getting a deal for the emergency aid has waned.
•
Welcome to an election year unlike any other. A presidential rematch seems likely. But questions about the President Joe Biden’s age and stamina and former President Donald Trump’s numerous legal challenges make this election season particularly unpredictable. The Republican primary season gets underway with the January 15 Iowa caucuses and the January 23 New Hampshire primary. There also will be tight battles for control of the House and Senate. There is a real possibility Republicans will flip the Senate while Democrats flip the House, which would mean two more years of divided government.
Classification: Schwab Internal
R&I Update • 21 • January 2024
Important Disclosures The information and content provided herein is general in nature and is for informational purposes only. It is not intended, and should not be construed, as a specific recommendation, individualized tax, legal, or investment advice. Tax laws are subject to change, either prospectively or retroactively. Where specific advice is necessary or appropriate, individuals should contact their own professional tax and investment advisors or other professionals (CPA, Financial Planner, Investment Manager) to help answer questions about specific situations or needs prior to taking any action based upon this information. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. The information provided here is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered an individualized recommendation or personalized investment advice. The investment strategies mentioned here may not be suitable for everyone. Each investor needs to review an investment strategy for his or her own particular situation before making any investment decision. All expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice in reaction to shifting market conditions. Data contained herein from third-party providers is obtained from what are considered reliable sources. However, its accuracy, completeness, or reliability cannot be guaranteed. Examples provided are for illustrative purposes only and not intended to be reflective of results you can expect to achieve. The policy analysis provided by the Charles Schwab & Co., Inc., does not constitute and should not be interpreted as an endorsement of any political party. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Fixed income securities are subject to increased loss of principal during periods of rising interest rates. Fixed income investments are subject to various other risks including changes in credit quality, market valuations, liquidity, prepayments, early redemption, corporate events, tax ramifications, and other factors. Lower rated securities are subject to greater credit risk, default risk, and liquidity risk. Tax-exempt bonds are not necessarily a suitable investment for all persons. Information related to a security's tax-exempt status (federal and in-state) is obtained from third-parties and Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. does not guarantee its accuracy. Tax-exempt income may be subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT). Capital appreciation from bond funds and discounted bonds may be subject to state or local taxes. Capital gains are not exempt from federal income tax. International investments involve additional risks, which include differences in financial accounting standards, currency fluctuations, political instability, foreign taxes and regulations, and the potential for illiquid markets. Investing in emerging markets may accentuate these risks. Currencies are speculative, very volatile and are not suitable for all investors. Forecasts contained herein are for illustrative purposes only, may be based upon proprietary research and are developed through analysis of historical public data. Schwab does not recommend the use of technical analysis as a sole means of investment research. Performance may be affected by risks associated with non-diversification, including investments in specific countries or sectors. Additional risks may also include, but are not limited to, investments in foreign securities, especially emerging markets, real estate investment trusts (REITs), fixed income, small capitalization securities and commodities. Each individual investor should consider these risks carefully before investing in a particular security or strategy. Diversification and asset allocation strategies do not ensure a profit and cannot protect against losses in a declining market. Source: Bloomberg Index Services Limited. BLOOMBERG® is a trademark and service mark of Bloomberg Finance L.P. and its affiliates (collectively “Bloomberg”). Bloomberg or Bloomberg’s licensors own all proprietary rights in the Bloomberg Indices. Neither Bloomberg nor Bloomberg’s licensors approves or endorses this material, or guarantees the accuracy or completeness of any information herein, or makes any warranty, express or implied, as to the results to be obtained therefrom and, to the maximum extent allowed by law, neither shall have any liability or responsibility for injury or damages arising in connection therewith. Supporting documentation for any claims or statistical information is available upon request. Schwab Center for Financial Research is a division of Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.
Schwab Retirement Plan Services, Inc. and Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. are separate but affiliated companies and subsidiaries of The Charles Schwab Corporation. Brokerage products and services are offered by Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. (“Schwab”, Member SIPC, www.sipc.org). Schwab Retirement Plan Services, Inc. is not a fiduciary to retirement plans or participants and only provides recordkeeping and related services.
Charles Schwab
9
Classification: Schwab Internal
Schwab Wealth Advisory™ ("SWA") is a non‐discretionary investment advisory program sponsored by Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. ("Schwab"). Schwab Wealth Advisory, Inc. ("SWAI") is a Registered Investment Adviser and provides portfolio management for the SWA program. Schwab and SWAI are affiliates and are subsidiaries of The Charles Schwab Corporation. Indexes are unmanaged, do not incur management fees, costs and expenses, and cannot be invested in directly. For more information on indexes please see schwab.com/indexdefinitions. Small-cap stocks are subject to greater volatility than those in other asset categories. Some of the statements in this document may be forward looking and contain certain risks and uncertainties.
The Russell 2000® Index measures the performance of the 2,000 smallest companies in the Russell 3000® Index. It is a market-capitalization-weighted index. The S&P 500® Index measures the performance of 500 leading publicly traded U.S. companies from a broad range of industries. It is a float-adjusted market-capitalization weighted index. The MSCI EAFE Equal Weight Total Return Index represents an alternative weighting scheme to its market-cap-weighted parent index, the MSCI EAFE Index. The index includes the same constituents as its parent (large and mid-cap securities from developed market countries around the world excluding the U.S. and Canada). However, at each quarterly rebalance date, all index constituents are weighted equally, effectively removing the influence of each constituent’s current price (high or low). Between rebalances, index constituent weightings will fluctuate due to price performance. Total return includes interest, capital gains, dividends, and realized distributions. The S&P 500® Equal Weight Total Return Index is the equal-weight version of the widely-used S&P 500. The index includes the same constituents as the capitalization weighted S&P 500, but each company in the S&P 500 EWI is allocated a fixed weight - or 0.2% of the index total at each quarterly rebalance. Total return includes interest, capital gains, dividends, and realized distributions. Total return includes interest, capital gains, dividends, and realized distributions.
The Bloomberg Global Aggregate ex-USD Index measures the performance of global investment grade debt from 24 local currency markets. It is a multi-currency benchmark that includes treasury, government-related, corporate and securitized fixed-rate bonds from both developed and emerging markets issuers, excluding US Dollar-Denominated bonds. It is a market-value weighted index. The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index tracks the performance of a basket of leading global currencies versus the U.S. dollar. The indices represent both developed- and emerging-market currencies that have the highest liquidity in the currency markets and the biggest trade flows with the United States.
©2024 Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. (“Schwab”). Member SIPC. All rights reserved 0124-4R9M Charles Schwab
Classification: Schwab Internal
R&I Update • 22 • January 2024
10
R&I Contacts REPRESENTATION DEPARTMENT—R&I TEAM MEC-BASED STAFF TELEPHONE
ASPEN
Phil Borgman, Benefits Specialist (ALA MEC)
206-241-3138
1946
Phil.Borgman@alpa.org
Dianne Myers, Associate Benefits & Contract Specialist (ALA MEC)
206-241-3138
1949
Dianne.Myers@alpa.org
Sontia Green, Sr. Benefits Specialist (DAL MEC)
404-763-5193
5193
Sontia.Green@alpa.org
Louis Parks, Associate Benefits Specialist (DAL MEC)
404-763-4932
4932
Louis.Parks@alpa.org
Ann Giannini, Benefits Specialist (FDX MEC)
901-842-2207
2207
Ann.Giannini@alpa.org
Brandy Hough, Sr. Benefits Specialist (FDX MEC)
901-842-2208
2208
Brandy.Hough@alpa.org
Stacey Stewart, Associate Benefits Specialist (FDX MEC)
901-257-2024
2020
Stacey.Stewart@alpa.org
Christal Oliver, Benefits Specialist (JBU MEC)
703-689-4261
4261
Christal.Oliver@alpa.org
Lisa Kwilas, Benefits Specialist (UAL MEC)
847-292-1723
1723
Lisa.Kwilas@alpa.org
NAME/JOB TITLE
NATIONAL STAFF Danika Borda, Benefits Specialist (Canada)
613-265-7970
Kevin Burton, Benefits Attorney
703-689-4117
4117
Kevin.Burton@alpa.org
Dave March, Benefits Specialist (Canada)
416-679-8333
8333
Dave March@alpa.org
Jack Parrack, Sr. Enrolled Actuary
703-689-4379
4379
Jack.Parrack@alpa.org
Catherine Powers, Assistant Director, Representation
703-689-4126
4126
Catherine.Powers@alpa.org
Celeste Sweeney, Benefits Specialist (U.S.)
703-689-4224
4224
Celeste.Sweeney@alpa.org
Michael Swierczek, Investment Portfolio Advisor
703-689-4137
4137
Michael.Swierczek@alpa.org
Anngi Tipton, Administrative Specialist
703-689-4114
4114
Anngi.Tipton@alpa.org
Dan White, Supervising Benefits Attorney
703-689-4118
4118
Dan.White@alpa.org
TELEPHONE
ASPEN
Navea Harris, Supervisor
703-689-4156
4156
Navea.Harris@alpa.org
Mike Barreto, Sr. Insurance Analyst
703-689-4330
4330
Mike.Barreto@alpa.org
Patricia Morse, Insurance Clerk
703-689-4152
4152
Patricia.Morse@alpa.org
Danika.Borda@alpa.org
MEMBER INSURANCE STAFF NAME/JOB TITLE
NATIONAL R&I COMMITTEE NAME
Capt. Jon Erickson (DAL), Chairman
Jon.Erickson@alpa.org
Capt. Fred Greene (UAL)
Fred.Greene@alpa.org
Capt. Travis Wheat (SPA)
Travis.Wheat@alpa.org
F/O Ben Monshor (FDX)
Ben.Monshor@alpa.org
R&I Update • 23 • January 2024