Critique on some important lecures like 154,152 etc copy

Page 1

INCONSISTENT SYSTEM OF THOUGHT OF ALI MIRZA [CRITIQUE ON LECTURES 154,152,158.156 ETC.] Engineer "Ali: Mirza: of Jhelum in lecture 152 accepts that the belief of H:ad:ir VA Naz:ir is Kufr. It may please be noted that he did not declare this belief as Shirk but as Kufr. So according to his own standard one who believes in this belief commits a Theoritical Kufr. So in this case it is clear that in the system of thought of Engineer "Ali: Mirza: a Mushrik can be a Muslim. But even he does not say a Kafir can be a Muslim. As according to him a person may be Mushrik and Muslim simultaniously , his statment is very important in regard to his views. For cross reference it may be pointed out that the very same Engineer "Ali: Mirza: of city of Jhelum claimed that 'Ima:m 'ibn Taimiah commited Kufr. The cleaver Engineer did not claimed Shirk otherwise according to his own system of thought he must not be able to claim that 'Ima:m 'ibn Taimiah RH: committed Kufr. Since accoding to Enginner "Ali: Mirza:, Shirk is not Kufr unless and otherwise a Person denies Qur'a:n as Divine Revelation, and Holy Prophet as his Final Prophet. But in can be seen that in the case of H:ad:ir Va Na:z:ir Engineer "Ali Mirza: claimed that this belief is Kufr. 1]So one who believes that any Ghairullah is H:a:d:ir Va Na:z:ir then the Person is certainly a Kafir even according to the standard of Engineer "Ali: Mirza of Jhelum. Now one may see that there is no follower of 'Ah:mad Rad:a: Son Of Naqi: "Ali: who does not believe that Holy Prophet is H:ad:ir Va Na:z:ir. So is Engineer "Ali: Mirza: going to accept whether these followers of the mensioned above personality are Kafir. Also whether this person himself is Kafir accrding to Engineer "Ali: Mirza. If the answer of this Engineer is Posative Affirmative then Engineer himself commits Kufr. His Kufr is that he believes that a certain belief is Kufr yet its believers are Muslim. If this is the case then why did he not say that 'Ima:m 'Ibn Taimiah RH: committed a Kufr yet this Kufr could not make him a Kafir, and he was a perpetual Muslim whether he repended from this belief or did not. If his response is negative then he cannot claim that "Ali Mirza:'s own followers are Muslim. Why ? The answer is very clear. If some one believe in atleast one article of Kufr he ceases to be a Muslim. And any one who considers such a person who does consider such a Muslim who does belief in atleast on article of Kufr is Not a Muslim. This is a Perfect Checkmate for Engineer "Ali: Mirza:. He cannot escape this delimma which exist in his system of thought. Engineer "Ali: Mirza: has his limits.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Critique on some important lecures like 154,152 etc copy by AHLUSSUNNAHVSALIMIRZA - Issuu