Observer SARASOTA
NEWS MAYor’s SEAT
A newly elected commissioner could lead the city. 3A.
?
DIVERSIONS: POSH PAPERBOY
NEIGHBORHOOD 9A
Big Kid Playground
INSIDE | PAGE 1B
Locals join the construction crew at People at Play.
Style guru Eric Cross proves print isn’t dead at upcoming fashion show.
You. Your neighbors. Your neighborhood.
SLICE OF THE CITY PEOPLE, PICS & PLACES
Thursday, MARCH 24, 2011
THE JACKSON LABORATORY
Follow the money
A group of Collier County government appointees asked The Jackson Laboratory tough questions. In the end, Collier decided it was too risky.
By Jean Gruss Gulf Coast Business Review Rachel S. O’Hara
+ Pastry Art workers show shamrock style Jovee Henehan, Thomas Connel and Jesse Hillman, Pastry Art employees, celebrated St. Patrick's Day by dressing up in their best Irish flair Thursday, March 17. The employees wore their outfits and enjoyed having “the luck of the Irish” with them all day long.
Loren Mayo
Darby Adams and Yakira Padilla made this “robug.”
+ Bug robots roar to life at Brookside Whether she’s spearheading a pumpkin-carving project or teaching her students about hydroponic farming, Brookside Middle School teacher Susan Roberts is always up to something. This time, thanks to a grant from Sun Hydrolics and assistance from electrician Willie Woody, her classes built buzzing soda can “robugs.”
See SLICE / PAGE 16A
INDEX Black Tie.................................9B Classifieds..............................20A Cops Corner..........................17A Crossword.............................19A Opinion....................................6A Real Estate...........................18A Weather................................19A Vol. 7, No. 20 Two sections www.YourObserver.com
Joe Swaja has some advice for decision makers in Sarasota who are now considering millions of dollars in charitable gifts and taxpayer subsidies for The Jackson Laboratory. “I would go and get a group of individuals who are involved in this industry, understand this business and have nothing to do with Tampa or Sarasota to give unbiased advice,” says Swaja. Swaja, who retired to Marco Island after serving as vice president of worldwide customer service for production systems at Xerox Corp., was one of eight financially skilled volunteers who examined The Jackson Laboratory project in Collier County last summer. He was part of a little-known group called the Productivity Committee, volunteers appointed by the county commission to review county operations and suggest improvements. Swaja is blunt about Bar Harbor, Maine-based Jackson Laboratory’s efforts last year to establish a Florida research facility in eastern Collier County, 40 miles east of Naples. “If that was a business plan coming across my desk, I wouldn’t have approved it,” he says. “It’s kind of hard to swallow in today’s world.” In its quest to boost the local economy, Collier County economic-development officials recruited Jackson Laboratory with the promise of $260 million of taxpayer money, half of which would have come from the state and the other half from the county. In addition, the nonprofit genetics research institute planned to raise another $120 million from pri-
Nancy DeNike
Joe Swaja (pronounced “sway”), a retired Xerox Corp. executive who lives on Marco Island, says he wouldn’t have approved The Jackson Laboratory’s business plan. Swaja is a volunteer member of the Collier County Government Productivity Committee, which reviewed the institute’s plan for a research lab in eastern Collier.
ON REVIEW.NET Visit the website of The Observer’s sister paper, Gulf Coast Business Review, to read the entire Collier County Productivity Committee's “Economic Vitality of Jax-Florida” analysis. vate donors and millions more from government grants. Jackson Laboratory would directly employ 244 people, with the promise of thousands more from related operations that would move nearby. The Jackson Laboratory
project in Collier began to unravel when the Productivity Committee questioned Jackson’s business plan and growth assumptions in a report to the county commission in July. “The return wasn’t there for the risk involved,” concludes
Stephen Harrison, chairman of the committee and a corporate accountant. The Collier County effort eventually failed, because Naples resident Gov. Rick Scott and successful Naples entrepreneurs such as Reinhold Schmieding, founder of global Naples-based medical device manufacturer Arthrex, didn’t support the venture as it was
SEE LAB / PAGE 8A
The return wasn’t there for the risk involved. — Stephen Harrison, chairman of the Collier County Government Productivity Committee