What is the most effective form of a plenary in Early Years teaching? Holly Swain, EYFS Leader and English Coordinator, Monks Risborough Primary School
Jean Piaget’s work on child development separated cognitive development into age related bands: Age
Stage
Birth - 18 months
Sensorimotor
18 months – 6 years
Pre-operational
6 years – 12 years
Concrete Operational
12 years and older
Formal Operational
Introduction Plenaries at the end of a lesson, or throughout, give the learner a chance to reflect upon their learning so far. Ofsted deem them to be an essential part of the learning process and research has shown that if new information is revisited within an hour, retention is stronger (Making Good Use of the Plenary, DfES, 2002). Plenaries also give the teacher an opportunity to assess the children, correct any misconceptions and be informed as to next step planning. Although the importance of a plenary is widely known, it is still the part of the learning session that is often dropped, perhaps due to time constraints, or skipped due to lack of inspiration as to how best to implement the device. Early Years teaching sessions often miss the plenary opportunity due to the short attention spans of their cohort. If we subscribe to the idea that a child’s attention span in minutes is its age +/- one minute, then we could be teaching within a very small window ranging from three to six minutes maximum. With this in mind, what is the best form of a plenary for Early Years teaching? Research ‘Children learn best when they are actually doing the work themselves and creating their own understanding of what’s going on, instead of being given explanations by adults’ (Carol Garhart Mooney, Theories of Childhood, St.Paul, MN: Redleaf, 2000). This idea compliments Jean Piaget’s theory that ‘Construction is superior to instruction’ (Joanne Hendrick, The Whole Child, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Merrill, 1992), so should an Early Years plenary be more ‘hands on’ than to simply take the form of an explanation?
Behaviours -Learn through senses -Learn through reflexes -Manipulate materials -Form ideas based upon their perceptions -Can only focus on one variable at a time -Overgeneralise based on limited experience -Form ideas based on reasoning -Limit thinking to objects and familiar events -Think conceptually -Think hypothetically
Early Years children working within the pre-operational stage will find it difficult to maintain focus on anything abstract or unrelated to their own experiences. Children of this age are in the ‘Egocentric stage’. Specifically it has been postulated that, Children are egocentric (think of everything only as it relates to them), can only focus on one characteristic of a thing or person at a time, gather information from what they experience rather than from what they are told, and over generalise from their experiences. (Theories of Childhood, p.69, 2000.) Considering all these factors, can a plenary be devised that allows the child to relate the learning to themselves and also build upon their experiences? I have trialled two different forms of a plenary in a school Reception class with children aged four to five years old, across a range of subjects. Alongside this, I also collected data for a more traditional form of plenary involving interactive whiteboard pictures, key words and teacher led talk (Plenary A).