The Distributional Impacts of Trade

Page 24

■■

It provides a comprehensive set of complementary policies and economy-wide approaches to implementation that are necessary for trade to reduce poverty and inequality.

This report advances the policy maker’s ability to analyze trade policy retrospectively, and it provides new methods for short- and long-term analysis of the impact of prospective trade shocks on communities and countries. The Household Impacts of Tariff (HIT) approach incorporates detailed consumption patterns at the household level and estimates short-term impacts of tariff line changes on consumption in lowincome countries. The extension of the Global Income Distribution Dynamics (GIDD) approach provides greater granularity in the analysis of future trade policy changes, so that policy makers can assess the impact of reductions of tariffs, changes to nontariff measures, and improvements in trade facilitation at the subnational level. ­Reduced-form and structural approaches using detailed country-specific micro data allow for the study of impacts on local labor markets across time, regions, and demographic characteristics. Through a combination of methodologies, we can assess the impact of trade on a much larger set of outcomes affecting welfare, including income and wages, levels of formal and informal sector employment, consumption, poverty, and inequality at both national and subnational levels. Analysis conducted using these different approaches could help policy makers understand how to craft a reform agenda that distributes the gains from trade more widely. This report provides new evidence that trade brings overall gains to households and is critical for lowering poverty, but it also shows that labor market and consumption gains tend to concentrate in some regions and worker categories. The persistence of these concentrated impacts has until recently been underappreciated and varies considerably across countries, suggesting that individual country studies are necessary. Impacts also differ over time, depending on the speed of the adjustment process. The informal economy in some emerging economies serves as a buffer, expanding after a trade shock to help workers adjust to changes in the labor market. Benefits such as lower consumer prices do not fully pass through to consumers, though, largely because of barriers related to geography, the market power of intermediaries, and the structure of domestic markets. The report further deepens our knowledge about localized effects of trade through five empirical country studies. These describe (a) the impacts of apparel-led export growth on local labor market outcomes in Bangladesh, (b) labor mobility costs and their distributional consequences for welfare in Brazil, (c) the long-term effects of trade liberalization and their consequences on poverty in South Africa, (d) the impact of trade liberalization reforms on poverty and inequality in Mexican municipalities, and (e) the impact of trade policy reforms on employment at the subnational level in Sri Lanka.

2

Executive Summary


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

A.1 Methodological Approaches Applied in the Case Studies

5min
pages 128-131

References

16min
pages 119-127

Flourish

4min
pages 116-117

Their Impacts

2min
page 113

Implementing a Policy Agenda for Inclusive Trade

4min
pages 114-115

4.1 Overview of Complementary Policies

22min
pages 103-112

Complementary Policy Priorities for Inclusive Trade

2min
page 102

3.1 Assessment of Trade Policy Changes on Sri Lankan Welfare

2min
page 93

Conclusion

4min
pages 94-95

Subnational Level

2min
page 90

Brazil: How Trade Shocks Affect Wages and Job Opportunities across Regions and Industries

4min
pages 85-86

South Africa: How Apartheid’s Legacy Shapes the Impact of Trade Liberalization on Local Communities

2min
page 83

Bangladesh: How a Shock in Textiles and Apparel Spreads through Local Communities and across the Economy

2min
page 79

and Are More Unequal

4min
pages 77-78

Mexico: How Rising Exports Affect Local Poverty and Inequality

2min
page 76

Introduction

4min
pages 74-75

References

14min
pages 66-72

Notes

2min
page 65

Conclusion

2min
page 64

Imperfect Pass-Through of Tariff Prices to Consumers

2min
page 63

2.4 New Approaches to Measure Consumption Impacts

6min
pages 60-62

Impacts on Consumer Prices and Cost of Living

2min
page 59

Understanding Hefty Adjustment Costs

6min
pages 56-58

Tariffs Database

5min
pages 50-51

2.3 Informal Labor Markets and Trade

4min
pages 54-55

Local Labor Markets in Developing Countries

2min
page 49

2.1 Extensions of “The China Syndrome”

4min
pages 47-48

A Framework for Understanding the Distributional Impacts of Trade

4min
pages 43-44

Value Added and Road Map

7min
pages 34-36

Impacts on Labor Market Outcomes

4min
pages 45-46

2 Understanding Winners and Losers with the Household Impacts of

2min
page 24

ES.1 Case Studies Show Different Political and Economic Dynamics in Trade Reforms

3min
pages 27-28

1.4 Structure of This Report

1min
page 37

Why Distributional Issues Matter

2min
page 33
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
The Distributional Impacts of Trade by World Bank Publications - Issuu