SPORTS P. 12
ARTS P. 8
Elle Movie Review
VOL. CXXXI, NO. 17
Men’s hoops advances to Final Four
WEDNESDAY, MARCH 15, 2017
CC rejects censure, issues warning for Cap & Bells By FRANCESCA PARIS COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR Last night, College Council (CC) voted 23–2 in favor of issuing a formal warning to Cap & Bells, the College’s only studentrun theatre group, for 18 months. The warning will include an educational component, the nature of which CC has not yet clarified. Prior to the CC meeting in Paresky Auditorium, the Office of Student Life (OSL) had sanctioned Cap & Bells by forbidding alcohol at its registered or unregistered events until July 2018. The sanction also requires the organization to add a clause to its constitution encouraging alcohol and bystander training for its members. Before approving the formal warning, CC voted 20–5 to reject a recommendation from CC’s Student Organization Sanctions Committee (SOSC) for a censure. The censure would have prevented Cap & Bells from receiving funding during the subgroup allocation process and required the group to request supplemental funding, delaying budget submission by at least two weeks. SOSC brought the recommendation to CC after hearing charges brought against Cap & Bells by OSL regarding an incident on the evening of March 4. Two students at a party registered to Cap & Bells required hospitalization, according to the charges, one of whom was in a serious state of alcohol intoxication and required resuscitation. Madeline Seidman ’17, Cap & Bell’s artistic director, registered the party in question as a basic
event with no alcohol but was not in attendance due to medical reasons. According to the charges, 12 students attended the event, including one Cap & Bells board member, and hard alcohol was present. Attendees described the event as a cast party for a Cap & Bells performance. According to CC bylaws, a formal warning serves as a mechanism by which CC can express disapproval of a student organization’s actions and “forestall future violations.” Though the administration has final say in disciplinary action, it does not appear likely to take such action. “The Dean’s Office did not take disciplinary action against Cap & Bells and did not initiate any process that would result in suspension of the organization,” Rachel Bukanc, senior associate dean of the College, said in an email. Maria Fernanda Heredia ’20, chair of SOSC and vice president for student organizations, opened the meeting by stating that SOSC’s recommendation was based solely on the alcohol infraction. “The case will be looked [at] under the disciplinary implications of the events of March 4,” she said, “and not on the organization’s moral or community impact. SOSC does not base [its] decision on the number of infractions but on the severity of the events in question.” In the time allotted for open comment, several members of Cap & Bells argued that the censure was not a fair punishment for an umbrella organization with 100 to 200 members, including all students who have
Faculty elects to eliminate high pass By GIOVANNI DIRUSSO STAFF WRITER At the faculty meeting on March 8, the faculty voted overwhelmingly to eliminate the “high pass” grade for the Winter Study term, beginning with Winter Study 2018. This will change the possible grades for Winter Study to “pass,” “perfunctory pass,” and “fail.” The motion passed by a vote of 68-2. The decision was made in response to the Law School Admission Council (LSAC)’s recent correction of a policy to convert three-pass grading systems into grade points. This would make the “pass” grade worth 3.0 grade points, which would negatively affect the GPAs of many students applying to law schools. Although the rule had been on the LSAC’s books since 1970, it was only implemented this year, when it was discovered during an internal audit of the council, according to Barbara Casey, registrar of the College. A change back to a two-pass grading system will mean that future Winter Study grades are not included in students’ GPAs as calculated by LSAC. While the LSAC decision provided the impetus for the change, the faculty had a larger discussion about whether any benefit actually came from having that grading option, which guidelines suggested should be given to fewer than one in 10 students. “The Committee on Educational Affairs [CEA] had a general discussion on whether the High Pass was benefitting students in any way … the answer was no,” Casey said. Faculty also had concerns about the way in which the high pass interacted with the intent to have Winter Study be a time focused on exploration rather than grades and performance. “There was tremendous inconsistency as to how the high pass was assigned, from year to year and from class to class … Having the high pass in some ways made Winter Study feel like a regular semester class, and what we wanted to do was to encourage students
to try something they might not otherwise try, including something that might be challenging,” David Edwards, professor of anthropology and chair of the CEA, said. The CEA opted to propose cutting the high pass grade instead of the perfunctory pass grade because of the value the latter has for analyzing students’ academic standing. “The Committee on Academic Standing [CAS], when it deals with students having academic difficulty, was finding that there were cases where [it] got a better understanding of the situation students were in, when they were getting in trouble during Winter Study,” Edwards said. Indeed, during the faculty meeting, Professor of Statistics Richard De Veaux cited recent cases in which the perfunctory pass option has helped the CAS to assess a student’s academic standing at the College. The three-pass system was conceived of in the mid1990s, in an effort to make Winter Study more rigorous. This revision saw the addition of the high pass and perfunctory pass grades. “Winter Study as a whole was being reviewed … there was general concern that students weren’t taking it as seriously as some faculty hoped,” Casey said. The new Winter Study grading system will not apply retroactively, and student GPAs, for LSAC purposes, will still include grades that were earned under the three-pass system. Retroactively changing grades would contravene both LSAC policy in calculating GPAs and College policy on allowing instructors independence in assigning student grades. The College is continuing negotiations with LSAC, however, in hopes that it might reconsider its retroactive application of the conversion policy to students applying to law school from the College before the new policy takes effect in 2018. USPS 684-6801 | 1ST CLASS MAIL U.S. POSTAGE PAID WILLIAMSTOWN, MA PERMIT NO. 25
JUNE HAN/PHOTO EDITOR
College Council members listen to comments at their Tuesday hearing in Paresky auditorium regarding the sanctioning of Cap & Bells. participated in a performance. Others argued that a censure would stifle Cap & Bells’ financial ability to put on plays, violate the spirit of medical amnesty rules and disproportionately harm a space for students of identities traditionally marginalized on campus. Devyn Hebert ’17, general manager of Cap & Bells, said that a censure would significantly impact funding, as play rehearsals
cannot begin before the organizations has purchased the rights. As a result, delaying funding by two weeks would cut significantly into Cap & Bells’ fall season. Robert Hefferon ’18, technical director of Cap & Bells, pointed out that the College’s “Code of Conduct” extends medical amnesty to student organizations as well as individuals. Medical amnesty grants protection from disciplinary
action to an individual or group that seeks medical attention for themselves or another person. “Disobeying the existing medical amnesty policy destroys students’ faith in the system,” Hefferon said, “and decreases the chance that students in other organizations will alert CSS of unsafe incidents involving alcohol in the future.” CC co-President Web Farabow ’18 informed the audience that
CC is not bound by medical amnesty. Various council members, however, argued that CC should follow the spirit of the policy, so as not to discourage groups from registering parties and calling for help in the future. Cap & Bells supporters, as well as members of CC, also argued that the issue was fundamentally an issue of diversity and equality.
SEE CC, PAGE 5
College announces commencement speakers, honorary degrees By NICHOLAS GOLDROSEN NEWS EDITOR Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie will be the speaker for the College’s commencement on June 4. A Nigerian-American writer, Adichie is best known for her works Americanah, We Should All Be Feminists and Dear Ijeawele, or a Feminist Manifesto in Fifteen Suggestions. Billy Collins, a former U.S. poet laureate and distinguished professor at the City University of New York, will speak the day prior at the Baccalaureate service. Adichie and Collins will both receive honorary degrees from the College, as will Will Dudley ’89, Gina McCarthy and Gavin Schmidt. Adichie is a MacArthur Fellowship, or “Genius Grant,” recipient, and she has also garnered acclaim for her widely viewed TED talks, “The Danger of a Single Story” and “We Should All Be Feminists,” upon which one of her books is based. In 2013, Adichie received a U.S. National Book Critics Circle Award for Americanah, which was a New York Times Top Ten Best Book of the Year. She received her B.A. from Eastern Connecti-
WHAT’S INSIDE
cut State, her M.F.A. from Johns Hopkins and her M.A. from Yale. A member of the American Academy Arts and Letters, Collins has published works, including Aimless Love, The Trouble with Poetry and Questions About Angels. Collins holds a B.A. from Holy Cross and a M.A. and Ph.D. from the University of California at Riverside. Dudley, the current president of Washington and Lee University, served as the College’s provost from 2011 to 2016 and taught in the philosophy department from 1998 to 2011. He is also the vice chair of the board of trustees of the Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts. Dudley’s works include Understanding German Idealism and Hegel, Nietzsche and Philosophy: Thinking Freedom. He received his B.A. in mathematics and philosophy from the College and earned his Ph.D. in philosophy at Northwestern. McCarthy served as the administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency from 2013 to 2017 and, prior to that, as the assistant administrator for the Office of Air and Radiation from 2009
PHOTO COURTESY OF WILLIAMS COLLEGE
Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie will speak at commencement in June. to 2013. She has also served as the commissioner of the Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection and deputy secretary of the Massachusetts Office of Commonwealth Development. She holds a B.A. from University of Massachusetts at Boston and a M.S. from Tufts. Schmidt is the director of NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies, where he oversees and conducts climate, oceanographic and atmospheric research. He
is well-known for his work in communicating scientific findings to the larger community, with works including Climate Change: Picturing the Science, and was the recipient of the inaugural American Geophysical Union Climate Communication Prize. He received a B.A from Oxford and a Ph.D. from University College London. The College will award these honorary degrees at its 228th Commencement on June 4.
BILLY COLLINS, GINA MCCARTHY, GAVIN SCHMIDT AND WILL DUDLEY ’89 (CLOCKWISE) WILL RECIEVE HONORARY DEGREES
3 OPINIONS
Reflecting on queer culture on campus
5 NEWS
Student survey on the most and least rigorous majors
7 FEATURES
An Eph’s guide to off-campus housing
8 ARTS
Review of End Game: Afghanistan Photo Exhibition
11 SPORTS
Alison Swain ’01 and a tennis legacy built to last
PHOTOS COURTESY OF SUZANNAH GILMAN, WILLIAMS COLLEGE