CVI.4 - December 2011

Page 1

Volume CVI, Issue 4

December 9, 2011

Walnut Hills High School

www.walnuthillseagles.com

Teachers and students divided on cheating

http://my.hsj.org/chatterbox

A recent Chatterbox survey shows disagreements about what constitutes cheating and how often it happens

JOE SCHMIDLAPP/CHATTERBOX

According to a voluntary Chatterbox survey, 25% of students cheat on tests, and over 50% cheat on homework in some way. Jonah Roth, ‘13 Design Editor Science teacher Dr. Rajni Harsh had a cheating problem in her classroom. She and former students alike agree that many people used to cheat on her homework assignments. With students choosing to copy instead of learn, grading for accuracy seemed much less effective. According to an anonymous Chatterbox survey of 163 students conducted last month, less than 65 percent of students consider

INSIDE

CPS levy rejected

NEWS AND FEATURES Exams: The Pressure is On Walnut: Then and Now

2

VIEWPOINTS Are leggings pants? Viewpoint:Formal Writing

3

SPORTS “Big Dogs” and Eagles have huge expectations Hockey brings the pain

4

FINE ARTS Annie Get Your Gun does it better Holiday Movies

5

STYLE AND CULTURE 6 I’ll Be Home for the Holidays! ARCADE Horoscope of the Month The Flood Cometh

7

JUST NUTS Marching Band season ends The Nutty Notebook

8

Volume CVI.4

this kind of copying cheating. Academic dishonesty, a persistent problem of all schools, has been receiving increased attention as technology enables students to do more, such as plagiarizing essays on the Internet and using cell phones to answer test questions. Some say that Walnut Hills High School, is a highly competitive college-preparatory school and therefore creates a drive to cheat. “Walnut’s a high pressure place,” says social studies teacher Kevin McCormick. “I think more and more students are encouraged

to be involved with more extracurriculars and as many APs as possible... there’s definitely more pressure on students, especially at Walnut Hills.” English teacher Virginia Hautz has also found that “the students who feel the greatest pressure to achieve… are the ‘best’ cheaters.” “Everyone does it,” says one SENIOR. “It’s the only way to make something that’s already unfair as fair as it can be.” Others take it even farther: “[Walnut] is so hard you have to be a master at cheating to pass some of the classes.” Peer pressure was also among students’ top reasons for cheating: “The nickname, ‘snitch,’ dissuades me from turning in someone I see cheating.” Carley Stichtenoth, ‘17, thinks the problem is the friends, not the ethics. “If your friends want you to cheat then I don’t think they’re really your friends.” “Busy work”, or unnecessary assignments, is a popular reason for cheating on homework. Some are frustrated with all the “busy work such as the vocabulary and grammar handouts I constantly have to turn in,” as one junior says. Some, like Jesse Wilson, ‘16, abstain from cheating. “I figure that I’m [at Walnut] for a good education so I’m going to…work my hardest.” Others just feel that cheating isn’t worth the effort: “Walnut is crazy on their cheating

Josh Medrano, ‘13 News & Features Print Editor On November 8, voters placed a negative verdict on Cincinnati Public Schools’ improvement levy-Issue 32--with 47 percent in favor and 53 percent against. In August, the school board approved a levy aimed to improve the district’s technology program which has been in existence for over 20 years. This levy would succeed the one placed in 2008. The need for money was also emphasized by superintendent Mary Ronan who projected a loss of over $30 million from state funds next year. This money granted from the levy would be used for the renovation and expansion of several schools. While the levy dramatically affected the district, Principal Jeffrey Brokamp says that it has less impact on Walnut Hills. “The levy not passing will have a very dramatic impact on the rest of the district,” says Brokamp. “It

policy.” However, cheating comes so naturally to some that they justify their honesty: “I don’t sit next to smart people.” “If I were to cheat and one day I wasn’t able to because of seating arrangements, I would be screwed.” Some students characterized their teachers as “totally oblivious” to the cheating in their classrooms: “I don’t think they realize how many kids cheat. They have [pictures] on their phones and... vocab books on their laps. Tests get put on Facebook and half the worksheets they give are available on the Internet,” one SENIOR said. Other teachers just don’t seem to care, as this freshman reports, “The teacher announces to the class that he or she is leaving the class for 15 minutes, and says that they left copies of the exam on the table.” Teachers’ perspectives are very different from students’: 65 percent of the 26 teachers surveyed believe that they catch cheating students. “It’s pretty obvious,” says Latin teacher Christine Lynn. “[For example], they do poorly on the test and then their homework is exactly the same as somebody else’s.” Some teachers take direct action to catch cheating as it happens in the classroom. “When they’re taking a test you can’t just be sitting there at your desk,” says social studies teacher Keith Semrad. “I’m... looking for every single

thing [students] do that doesn’t seem right. I’ll purposefully... talk to a student and use that opportunity to see the deviance taking place.” When asked what they think drives students to cheat, several teachers cited laziness as the leading factor. “Students don’t want to put in the work, but want to see a good end result,” says one teacher. Others cited unrealistic expectations from parents, as well as the pressure Walnut creates. Teachers looking to end cheating have found a variety of solutions. Mathematics teacher Michael Wathen does little to discipline cheaters. Frustrated with the flaws of the educational system, he fights cheating in his classroom by taking away the reasons and social pressure to cheat using cell phone polls. “Students can respond anonymously whether they cheated on the last test. Students can see the results... in real time,” he says. He also devalues cheating by requiring deeper answers on his tests: “If it’s… multiple choice, you can’t say ‘the answer’s B’. You have to explain everything about it. Why is it B?” Countering technology with technology, some teachers choose to use programs like Blackboard and ExamView to easily detect cheating in papers and tests, respectively. Cont’d on page 2

Quiz team prepares for season will have an impact here, probably not as dramatic, but it’s still an impact.” Walnut’s wide array of resources provides its funding. The Alumni Foundation and the Parent Board have been main players in providing the best education Walnut students could get. For instance, the Alumni Foundation donated over $9 million for the building of the Arts and Science Center in 1998 after a CPS levy was rejected; similarly, when CPS’ state funds were reduced last year, the Parent Board organized the Walnut24 Walkathon to save school clubs and extracurricular activities. Nevertheless, the district’s levy stresses the need to modernize the district’s technology. The goal would also benefit Walnut Hills. Cont’d on pg. 2

Josh Medrano, ‘13 News & Features Print Editor After placing first in both varsity and junior varsity categories in its first competition, the Academic Quiz Team prepares for another season of success. Until a decade ago, Walnut Hills’ Quiz Team was not what one might call today a “sports team.” However, when social studies teacher Scott Grunder started coaching in the fall of 1999 the team practiced regularly, went to local tournaments and eventually won its first state tournament. This year, the team, with three SENIORS, 16 juniors and four sophomores, is led by juniors and long-time members Will Schueller and Ashwin Kumar. With them, Grunder expects to win the Ohio Athletic Conference state competition, in which Walnut has been a runner-up in 2006 and 2009. “I’d be surprised if they didn’t get to go,” says Grunder. “I used

Editor-in-Chief: Mia Manavalan

JOE SCHMIDLAPP/CHATTERBOX

Scott Grunder, Quiz Team advisor. to tell them... [to] stop losing at the state level in order to keep me as a coach.” For most, the key to triumph is commitment, teamwork and confidence that counts. “Confidence is a big one,” says new team member Harrison Hildenbrandt, ‘13. “They give you a study packet to learn, but a lot of stuff you just [have to] know.” As a result of their first competition and first victory of the season, the quiz team is headed for the Partnership for Academic Competition in St. Louis and National Academic Quiz Tournaments in Atlanta. Both will be held in May 2012.

Walnut Hills High School


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.