Cons cie ntious Obje ction in Eritre a 1 De ce m be r: Pris one rs for Pe ace Day Back ground to th e country
Eritre a, l ocate d in th e h orn of Africa, w on its de -facto inde pe nde nce on 24 M ay 19 9 1 afte r 30 ye ars ofa bitte r, bl oody and cos tl y arm e d s truggl e agains trul e by its ne igh bour, Eth iopia. Eritre a form al l y de cl are d inde pe nde nce on 24 M ay 19 9 3 afte r an ove rw h e l m ing ye s vote in a re fe re ndum ove rs e e n by th e Unite d Nations . Th e tw o m ajor e th nic groups are th e Tigrigna (50% ) and Tigre (40% ). Th e Afar cons titute 4% and th e re m aining 6% incl ude K unam a, Nara, Bie l e n, Ras h aida, H idarb and Sah o. Th e tw o dom inating re l igions are Ch ris tianity, incl uding Coptics , Cath ol ics and oth e r Prote s tant de m oninations , and Is l am . Th e officiall anguage s are Tigrigna, Engl is h and Arabic, butdive rs e e th nic l anguage s pe rs is tas w e l l . Th e Ital ians col onis e d and nam e d Eritre a in 189 0. Afte r th e Ital ian de fe atin W orl d W ar II, its African col onie s ofEritre a, Som al ia and Libya w e re pl ace d unde r th e prote ctorate ofBritain for 10 ye ars . Th e future ofth e s e th re e nations w as a h otis s ue in th e Unite d Nations from 19 45 to 19 50, e nding in an il l -advis e d confe de ration of Eritre a and Eth iopia for a proje cte d 10 ye ars from 19 52 to 19 62. In 19 61, Eth iopia viol ate d th e te rm s of th e confe de ration and de cl are d Eritre a to be its 14th province . In th e s am e ye ar, th e Eritre an Libe ration Front(ELF) be gan arm e d re s is tance unde r th e l e ade rs h ip of H am id Idris Aw ate . In 19 70 a faction ofth e ELF, k now n as th e Pe opl e s Force s of Eritre a (PFE), brok e aw ay. Itw as a re vol utionary m ove m e ntl e d by th e younge r ge ne ration. Afte r its firs t congre s s in 19 77, th e PFE re organis e d as th e Eritre an Pe opl es Libe ration Front(EPLF) and e cl ips e d th e ELF. Th e EPLF s ucce e de d in ach ie ving inde pe nde nce from Eth iopia afte r a l ong w ar. Th e EPLF im m e diate l y e s tabl is h e d a trans itionalgove rnm e nt unde r Is s ayas Afe w e rk i, l e ade r of th e s ucce s s fulfigh tfor inde pe nde nce . EPLF m e m be rs took al ladm inis trative pos ts and oth e r k e y pos itions . In 19 9 4 th e th ird congre s s ofth e EPLF re nam e d its e l fth e Pe opl e s Frontfor De m ocracy and Jus tice (PFDJ). Unl ik e its nam e , th e re gim e w as unde m ocratic and unjus t. M ore ove r, itw as uncons titutional . Its ow n Eritre an Cons titutional
Com m is s ion, s e tup in 19 9 4, h ad produce d th e cons titution of19 9 7 afte r ratification by th e Eritre an pe opl e . Th e re gim e ignore d th is and, afte r Se pte m be r 2001, im pris one d 11 prom ine ntm e m be rs ofth e oppos ition party w h ich h ad de m ande d de m ocratic ch ange and e nforce m e ntofth e ratifie d cons titution. Today, th e PFDJ is th e s ol e l aw m ak e r in a h ars h dictators h ip. Eritre ans are de nie d th e ir bas ic civiland h um an righ ts , any prote s ts al w ays e nding in arbitrary arre s t, de te ntion and torture . For al l Eritre ans w h os e vis ion ofth e ir ne w nation incl ude d pe ace , s tabil ity and pros pe rity, th e s cal e ofw ars , corruption and abus e ofpow e r th at fol l ow e d inde pe nde nce w as unbe l ie vabl e . El e ve n ye ars afte r inde pe nde nce and 13 afte r fre e dom , Eritre a is a country w h e re pove rty and oppre s s ion are th e rul e. In th e l as tth re e ye ars , th e m il itary training cam p Saw a w as e s tabl is h e d as h e adq uarte rs for unive rs alnationals e rvice . Al lh igh s ch ools tude nts , fe m al e and m al e, are force d to finis h th e ir 12th ye ar ofs tudy in a s ch oolw ith in Saw a. None ofth e m h ave re turne d for furth e r e duation atunive rs ity once th e y com pl e te d nationals e rvice . Th e Unive rs ity ofAs m ara, Eritre a’s onl y unive rs ity, h as onl y th ird and fourth ye ar s tude nts w h o h ad e nte re d be fore th e draftcam e into e ffe ct. Th e gove rnm e nth as m il itaris e d th e country com pl e te l y. Force d re cruitm e ntofyoung pe opl e , unde rage ch il dre n and adul ts unde r 50 is a dail y e ve nt. Re cruits are tre ate d brutal l y and th e re is e vide nce of s e xualabus e ofw om e n. Nobody h as a righ tto q ue s tion th e m il iary auth oritie s . Nobody h as a righ tto cons cie ntious obje ction. O ve r th e pas tth re e and a h al f ye ars , Eritre ans h ave be e n de nie d th e ir cons titutionalrigh toffre e e xpre s s ion. Th e re are no inde pe nde ntne w s pape rs , TVch anne l s or radio s tations . Th e onl y active m e dia are gove rnm e ntow ne d. O nl y th e Inte rne tgive s th os e w h o h ave acce s s to ita s ource of inform ation notcol oure d by gove rnm e ntpropaganda. Fore ign pol icy h as is ol ate d th e country from h um an righ ts organis ations , aid age ncie s and th e inte rnationalcom m unity atl arge . Th e dictator h as us e d th e conce pt ofNationalUnity to intim idate and dis cre ditoppone nts ofth e re gim e .
W ar is a Crim e agains tH um anity: Th e Story ofTh e W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational Ne w book by De vi Pras ad "W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational , born out of th e h orrors and s tupidity of W orl d W ar I, h as k e pt th e banne rs of cons cie ntious obje ction and abol ition of w ar fl ying th rough th e m os t atrocious ce ntury of Europe an h is tory. W ar re s is te rs , organis e d or not, w il lbring aboutth e e nd ofw ar." Joh an Gal tung, dr h c m ul t, ProfofPe ace Studie s De vi Pras ad s tudie d at Sh antinik e tan, Tagore 's Unive rs ity, w ork e d as a te ach e r and artis t in Se vagram , Gandh i's as h ram , from th e 19 40s until19 62. From 19 62-19 72 h e w as Ge ne ralSe cre tary ofth e W RI. Publ is h e d by: W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational ISBN 0-9 03517-20-5. 560 page s , 67 ph otos . Publ ication date : 21 O ctobe r 2005 £28.00 pl us pos tage . O rde r now on our w e bs h op ath ttp://w ri-irg.org/e n
Re l igious m inoritie s are be ing pe rs e cute d by m e ans ofpris on and torture . According to th e Com pas s Dire ctne w s age ncy, 187 Eritre an Ch ris tians h ave be e n arre s te d s o far th is ye ar, incl uding groups at praye r, w h ol e w e dding partie s , and h om e Bibl e s tudy groups , inte l l e ctual s and profe s s ional s . O fte n ch il dre n and th e e l de rl y are am ong th os e arre s te d. According to Th e Ch ris tian Pos t of24 Fe bruary 2005 th e Eritre an gove rnm e nts ince M ay 2002 h as cl os e d dow n th e country’s Prote s tantch urch e s , de cl aring th e ir pl ace s ofw ors h ip il l e galand forbidding h om e gath e rings . O nl y four re l igions are official l y acce ptabl e : O rth odox Ch ris tianity, Cath ol icis m , Luth e ranis m and Is l am . Cons cie ntious obje ction is taboo. CO s are brande d by th e re gim e as cow ardl y and unpatriotic. Th e re is no re cours e to th e l aw nor s ubs titute civil ian s e rvice for CO s . Th e cons e q ue nce s ofcons cie ntious obje ction and de s e rtion are s e ve re torture , l ong-te rm im pris onm e nt and e ve n de ath . Afte r th e h orrors ofth e borde r w ar w ith Eth iopia from 19 9 8 to 2000, th e num be r ofCO s w ith in th e m il itary incre as e d. Today th e re are th ous ands w h o obje cte d to m il itary s e rvice and th e m il itary. Th e y are force d to go into e xil e. Cons ide rabl e num be rs ofth e m are in Europe , Libya, Eth iopia and Sudan s e e k ing pol iticalas yl um . In Ge rm any, Eritre an re fuge e s founde d th e Eritre an Antim il itaris m Initiative (EAI), w h ich s upports re fuge e s w h o h ad to fl e e from th e Eritre an m il itary and figh ts for pe ace and antim il itaris m in Eritre a.
Cons e q ue nce s ofw ar
Th e adve rs e im pactofth e l ong w ar for inde pe nde nce and l ate r confl icts on Eritre an s ocie ty and e conom y h ave be e n incal cul abl e. Th e y h ave e xace rbate d th e cycl e ofdraugh t, w h ich h as affl icte d th e e ntire re gion and caus e d m il l ions of pe opl e to be com e de pe nde nton e xte rnalas s is tance for th e ir s urvival . Th e re s ul ts ofth e s e dis pute s are h orre ndous : l os s ofl ife , im pove ris h m e nt, dis pl ace m e ntof pe opl e,l and m ine h az ards , l ooting, confis cation ofprope rty, e xil e, traum a. Atth e m om e nt, m ore th an one th ird ofth e Eritre an popul ation is l iving in e xil e . Th e w ar h as re s ul te d in th e dis inte gration offam il ie s and th e l os s ofcul ture and norm s of s ocie ity both ath om e and in e xil e.
Inte rnationaland national NGO s
are ignore d. Al linte rnational journal is ts h ave be e n official l y banne d.
Cons cie ntious O bje ction as one w ay to pe ace
Th e pe opl e ofEritre a are in pol itical , s ocialand e conom ic cris is . Th e re is an urge ntne e d to e s tabl is h a h e al th y de m ocratic atm os ph e re w ith a cons titutional l y el e cte d l e ade rs h ip and a m ul tiparty pol iticals ys te m . Th e re is an urge nt ne e d to re l e as e al lpol iticalpris one rs and CO s . H e nce th e AEI is advocating th e re fus alofm il itary s e rvice in th e above conte xt. W e be l ie ve th atre fus ing m il itary s e rvice , m il itaris m and w ar is vital for th e s e re as ons : 1. Th e ide as and te ach ings of cons cie ntious obje ction are bas e d on pe ace , h um anity and m oral ity. W e be l ie ve th e y are th e ans w e r to w ith s tanding th e propaganda ofnationalunity and nationals ove re ignty, w h ich are m is l e ading and provacative . 2. Th e m ore pe opl e s ay No to w ar in Eritre a and th e m ore pe opl e s ay No to w ar in our ne igh bouring countrie s , th e re gion and th e w orl d, th e m ore gove rnm e nts m ay be gin to th ink about pe ace fuls ol utions , s tartto de ve l op re s pe ctfor h um an l ife and pl an to buil d a jus tand s e cure s ocie ty for com ing ge ne rations . 3. Cons cie ntious obje ction is th e ch e ck and bal ance agains tw ar and m il itaris m . A CO is atth e oth e r e xtre m e ofa w arl ord. W e be l ie ve CO s can confrontand dive rtm il itary obje ctive s .
Ste ps for l as ting pe ace
Th e AEI be l ie ve s th atth e fol l ow ing s te ps can h e l p to ach ie ve al as ting pe ace on th e bas is of h um an, civiland pol iticalrigh ts . 1. Introduce and cul tivate re s pe ct for th e righ tofcons cie ntious obje ction and offe r CO s al te rnative civil ian s e rvice . 2. Es tabl is h a cul ture ofpl ural is m , civil ity, re s pe ctand tol e rance . 3. De ve l op th e pol iticall e ade rs h ip on principl e s ofde m ocracy. 4. Adoptnonviol e ntw ays of s truggl e. 5. Sol ution ofconfl icts pe ace ful l y th rough dial ogue , m e diation and ne gotiation. 6. Re s pe ctfor inte rnationall aw .
Yoh anne s K idane is a re fuge e from Eritre a and l ive s in Ge rm any, Th e re is l ittl e activity by national w h e re h e is active w ith th e and inte rnationalnon-gove rnm e ntal Eritre an Antim il itaris m Initiative organis ations (NGO s ). W h atdoe s e xis tis unde r th e s upe rvis ion ofth e Source s : re gim e . Th e re are no inte rnational Eritre an De m ocratic Partie s NGO s th atadvocate h um an righ ts (EDP) m anife s to, As m arion and or w itne s s th e force d m il itary Aw ate h om e page s on th e re cruitm e ntw ith its brutal ity of Inte rne t. re cruits and its pe rs e cution ofCO s . Nor doe s th e gove rnm e nttol e rate Eritre an Antim il itaris m Initiative , inde pe nde ntnationalNGO s , c/o Yoh anne s K idane , h um an righ ts groups , inte rnational Bah ns tras s e 51, D-61449 obs e rve rs or fore ign re porte rs . Ste inbach , e m ail Inve s tigations de m ande d by yoh anne s k 2000@ yah oo.com Am ne s ty Inte rnationaland oth e rs
Editorial
M any ofus m igh tre m e m be r th e h ope s conne cte d w ith Eritre an inde pe nde nce back in th e e arl y 19 9 0s . I m ys e l fre m e m be r re ading abouts e l f-re l iantde ve l opm e nt, th e form ation ofcoope rative s , and in ge ne ralabout Eritre a tak ing a path w h ich w oul d notre l y on inte rnational ins titutions s uch as th e W orl d Bank , w h ich drove m any oth e r countrie s into h uge e xte rnal de bts . H ow e ve r, 14 ye ars l ate r th e s ituation l ook s e ntire l y diffe re ntl y, and th is is s ue ofTh e Brok e n Rifl e can onl y give a gl im ps e ofw h atis actual l y h appe ning in th e country. W h e n W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational firs tre ce ive d inform ation from th e Eritre an Antim il itaris m Initiative , w e w e re s h ock e d. Force d re cruitm e ntand im pris onm e nt/e xe cution ofyoung pe opl e – m e n and w om e n – w h o avoid m il itary s e rvice s e e m s to be a dail y fe ature for Eritre a's youth , w ith e xil e th e onl y "al te rnative ". W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational 's contacts in Africa are s til lpoor. Four ye ars ago, in 2001, w e h igh l igh te d th e s ituation in Angol a on 15 M ay (Inte rnationalCons cie ntious O bje ctors ' Day). Pris one rs for Pe ace Day 2005 w ith a focus on Eritre a is th e re fore a good opportunity to re ach outto African antim il itaris tgroups , w h e re th e y e xis t. Th e articl e s in th is is s ue – - th e inte rvie w s w ith obje ctors – s h ow ve ry cl e arl y h ow urge ntl y Eritre an w ar re s is te rs ne e d our s upport. M ore inform ation on th e s ituation in Eritre a is avail abl e in a docum e ntation publ is h e d on W RI's w e bs ite ath ttp://w riirg.org/ne w s /2005/e ritre ae n.h tm . Fe e lfre e to dow nl oad and dis tribute . Andre as Spe ck
Th e Brok e n Rifl e Th e Brok e n Rifl e is th e ne w s l e tte r ofW ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational , and is publ is h e d in Engl is h , Spanis h , Fre nch and Ge rm an.Th is is is s ue 68, Nove m be r 2005. Th is is s ue ofTh e Brok e n Rifl e w as produce d by Andre as Spe ck . Spe cialth ank s go to Nuk e Re s is te r, Forum 18, Am ne s ty Inte rnational , and al l oth e rs w h o provide d th e inform ation us e d in th is is s ue , and to M itz i Bal e s for h e l p w ith e diting. Ifyou w ante xtra copie s ofth is is s ue ofTh e Brok e n Rifl e , pl e as e contactth e W RI office , or dow nl oad itfrom our w e bs ite . W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational , 5 Cal e donian Road, London N1 9 DX, Britain te l+ 44-20-7278 4040 fax+ 44-20-7278 0444 info@ w ri-irg.org h ttp://w ri-irg.org/pubs /br68-e n.h tm