Hidden histories
State champs!
Artists in residence share their stories at Clemmons
Girls’ cross country wins Division I title
Page 2
Page 11
November 2, 2023
POSTAL CUSTOMER
PRSRT STD U.S. POSTAGE PAID PERMIT #217 CONCORD, NH ECRWSSEDDM
Weekly news coverage for Charlotte and Hinesburg
thecitizenvt.com
Forest fungi
PHOTO BY MAURA KELLEY
Maura Kelley shot this closeup autumn study of the forest floor in Hinesburg.
Appeal advances, Hinesburg will rebid wastewater project COREY MCDONALD STAFF WRITER
Hinesburg is proceeding with a rebid to build a new state-mandated wastewater treatment facility, as the town’s appeal of the state’s discharge permit advances. Engineers this summer went back to the drawing board to find alternatives in the facility’s engineering and to reduce overall costs in the design. Officials with Aldrich and Elliot presented the town with a new new design that has brought the estimated cost of construction of a new facility to $13 million, roughly $1.7 million less than the lowest bid the town received in April. “We’re doing our best here to try and minimize these increases to the extent possible,” Wayne
Elliot of Aldrich and Elliot said. Hinesburg since 2018 has faced a mandatory order to rebuild its wastewater treatment facility after a state discharge permit was issued that required the town to reduce the amount of phosphorus and ammonia in its wastewater discharged into the LaPlatte River. Voters in 2020 approved a borrowing capacity of $11.7 million for the new facility by a vote of 1,810 to 98. The town has already spent $2 million on site work at the Lagoon Road site. But in September, the fiveyear renewal of that permit added additional testing requirements and lower limits — conditions the town would have to test for and monitor on its own. Hinesburg is appealing that new discharge permit in Vermont
Environmental Court, arguing that the conditions imposed on the town are overly onerous, and that the new permit’s requirements were approved despite the state
not completing any field work to verify its findings. The town hopes a successful appeal could bring down the overall operating cost of the facility.
Any movement to decrease the overall cost of the project for the See WASTEWATER on page 13
Without state aid, school buildings suffer CVU fares better than most, infrastructure still failing LIBERTY DARR STAFF WRITER
It’s been more than 15 years since the state helped fund school construction projects, and even for schools like the Champlain Valley School District that aren’t facing massive, deferred maintenance costs, staff there is wasting no time in preparing for a troubling
next 10 years. In April 2022, the education committees in both the Vermont House and Senate commissioned the independent analysis, “Vermont School Facilities Inventory and Assessment,” that reviewed a broad range of facility-related factors in 54 school districts across the state. The study utilized a Facility
Condition Index to measure the aggregated depletion percentage of facilities for each district. The higher the percentage, the greater the need for infrastructure replacement or upgrades. The average for the districts participating in the study was 71.4 percent, which See INFRASTRUCTURE on page 12
Page 2 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen
Artists share histories in Clemmons residency Winosha Steele and William Ransom have been picked as artists-in-residence for “UnderWater, UnderGround: Black/Indigenous Creatives Historize Charlotte, Vermont’s Sea Change,” at Clemmons Family Farm in Charlotte. The two artists were selected through a competitive process open to artists in Vermont, New York and Quebec who self-identify as African American, African Diaspora or Afro-indigenous cultures. A jury made the selections based on artistic excellence, commitment to the spirit and purpose of the residency and availability and flexibility to fully engage in the project. The purpose of the “UnderWater, UnderGround” is to creatively lift up past, present and future voices and experiences of the peoples of the African diaspora who live or who have lived in the Lake Champlain Basin area. The artists will research, learn about and create new works about some of the untold history, cultures and geography of the area. Ransom, a Vermont resident, is primarily a sculptor whose work originates at the intersection of his material engagement and his investigations into personal history, collective history and agricultural experience. He was born and raised on a dairy farm in Vermont and his work and life continue to be informed by his early material experiences and engagement with the cycles and rhythms of the natural world.
COURTESY PHOTOS
Left, Winosha Steele, right, William Ransom
Ransom received a Master of Fine Art in Sculpture from Claremont Graduate University and a bachelor’s degree Bennington College. His most recent solo show, “HoldUp/UpHold,” was held at NE Sculpture in
Minneapolis. Steele, a Caribbean artist who lives in New York, incorporates her identity and passion fearlessly into her work. As a Black female artist, she creates pieces with flamboyance, aiming to establish a connec-
tion between viewer and artwork. She believes that the concept of nuances produced in her work create meaningful conversations and deeper understanding of the world provoked through introspection. Drawing inspiration from her Antiguan heritage, Steele’s art is boundary-pushing, yet personal. Her desire to expand her artistic horizon and emphasize racial correlation, however radical, stems from being a small islander. She earned a degree from SUNY Plattsburgh and has exhibit-
ed her work in numerous local and regional exhibitions in New York. During the residency, which will run through December 2024, each artist will receive $7,500, logistical support, art supplies, transportation assistance and occasional lodging and studio space on the Clemmons farm. An “UnderWater, UnderGround” multimedia art exhibit created by the two artists will be installed at the farm next fall. Learn more at clemmonsfamilyfarm.org.
EARLY DEADLINES
THANKSGIVING ISSUE DATE: Wednesday, Nov. 22
BANG and Combo Ads
DEADLINE: Thursday, Nov. 16, 5 p.m.
Display and Classified Ads DEADLINE: Friday, Nov. 17, Noon
Editorial Submissions
DEADLINE: Friday, Nov. 17, Noon
VERMONT COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER GROUP
The Citizen • November 2, 2023 • Page 3
Autumn leaves
PHOTO BY PHILIP GALIGA
Fall comes to an end, at least the leafy part, on Mt. Philo.
JetBlue to end Burlington-New York route AUDITI GUHA VTDIGGER
Come January, Vermonters will have fewer options when flying out of the Patrick Leahy Burlington International Airport. Jetblue, which operates two round-trip flights daily between Burlington and New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport, announced Wednesday, Oct. 25 that it is pulling out of the Vermont airport entirely, effective Jan. 4. Delta Airlines, meanwhile, is reducing flights between Burlington and New York airports, that airline confirmed to VTDigger Wednesday. Delta plans to scale back its three daily round-trip flights between Burlington and JFK to one, effective Dec. 7. It will also cut back four daily round-trip flights between Burlington and LaGuardia Airport in Queens to two as of Jan. 8, the company said. In a statement addressing the departure of JetBlue, Nic Longo, the Burlington airport’s direc-
tor of aviation, said that airline’s passengers made up 10 percent of the airport’s monthly customer base on average. “We are disappointed to learn the news JetBlue Airways will be discontinuing their one route to New York-JFK,” Longo said, adding that the company had flown out of Burlington for more than two decades. Longo noted in his statement that travelers will still have the option of flying Delta to JFK. He did not address that airline’s decision to reduce those flights. United Airlines also offer flights to New York from Burlington. In his statement Longo said the airport was “in active talks with a handful of new airline partners to establish new routes and destinations.” JetBlue, which is ending several other routes between JFK and other airports, cited “ongoing air traffic control staffing challenges” and an effort to reduce congestion in the New York airspace. The staffing shortage has led the
Federal Aviation Administration to allow several carriers to cut back on New York flights, the Associated Press reported. “Exiting a market is a difficult decision, however we expect the current air traffic controller shortage to last for some time and do not see a path to feasibly bringing back this flight,” JetBlue corporate communications said in a statement about its Burlington pullout. Affected customers will be refunded, the company said in its statement. Last year Frontier Airlines pulled out of the airport, which is physically located in South Burlington but is owned by the City of Burlington. The reductions come as the airport is undergoing a major expansion that is expected to include a hotel. Correction: An earlier version of this story incorrectly identified which airlines now offer direct flights from Burlington to New York City.
Page 4 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen
OPINION
Take care of yourselves and your loved ones It’s not easy to find a therapist or counselor in Vermont right Rep. Chea Waters Evans now. Like many other industries, the unemployment rate is First, the past couple weeks low and the workforce shorthave been hideous. age is high. Luckily, there are War in Israel and Gaza, many reputable online therapy concern for our Jewish friends, options that allow you to talk break-ins and car thefts in our to a counselor either by phone normally peaceful town, the or video chat. Finding help for looming government kids is tougher. School shutdown while the guidance counselors U.S. House figures out can offer some support, how to manage itself, and maybe help bridge and another deadly the gap until a better shooting, this time solution is found. close to home in a way One thing we’re that makes us all pause working on in the and wonder not if it’s Legislature is a bill going to happen here, to approve interstate but when. Rep. Chea Waters Evans compacts for social It’s a lot. I encourworkers. This would age everyone to check definitely alleviate in on yourselves, your some of the burden on current kids and your loved ones, and mental health workers in the state make sure they’re doing OK. If and would provide a workforce you or anyone you know is in boost for the profession. Earlier crisis, you can text the letters this year, the Legislature passed, “VT” to the number 741741 and and the governor signed, an you’ll immediately be in touch interstate counseling compact to with a crisis counselor. The help achieve this goal. National Suicide and Crisis LifeNerd time: A compact is a line can be reached by calling statutory agreement between 211 or by texting 988. states that recognizes licenses for
From the House
The Citizen Serving the community of Charlotte & Hinesburg A publication of Vermont Community Newspaper Group LLC thecitizenvt.com Advertising Wendy Ewing wendy@shelburnenews.com (802) 985-3091 x12
Billing inquiries Leslie Lafountain leslie@stowereporter.com (802) 253-2101
Advertising Director Judy Kearns judy@otherpapersbvt.com (802) 864-6670 x21
Advertising submission deadline: Friday at 5 p.m. advertising@thecitizenvt.com classifieds@thecitizenvt.com
News Editor Tommy Gardner
Editorial submission deadline: Friday at 5 p.m. news@thecitizenvt.com
Staff Writers Aaron Calvin Corey McDonald Liberty Darr Production Manager Stephanie Manning stephanie@shelburnenews.com
Calendar submission deadline: Friday at 12 p.m. news@thecitizenvt.com Contact: 1340 Williston Road South Burlington, VT 05403 (802) 985-3091
Editor/Publisher Gregory Popa gpopa@stowereporter.com
The Citizen is published weekly and mailed free to residents and businesses in Charlotte and Hinesburg and rack distributed at select high traffic locations. The Vermont Community Newspaper Group LLC assumes no responsibility for typographical errors in advertisements and reserves the right to refuse advertising and editorial copy.
a profession that would let them work across state lines. In this case, counselors, and hopefully in the future it will also include social workers. These compacts and the licenses are managed by the state’s Office of Professional Regulation. They’re very strictly regulated—it’s not like you can wander into Vermont with a piece of paper that says, “I swear I was a counselor in Iowa” and get a license. There’s a process. The benefits of licensing compacts are numerous. Not only do they allow people to more easily practice in Vermont if they move or want to move here, but they allow easier telehealth visits, access for counselors who practice online from out of state, and allow military spouses and partners to quickly pick up their careers if they are transferred. I’m hopeful that all these smaller steps we take — the child care bill, the HOME act, interstate compacts for mental health professionals, and others — make life better for all of us in Vermont. I urge you to take care of yourselves and your neighbors, and as always, please be in touch with me any time. I heard from one constituent this past week
who was quite frustrated with a government issue, and I did have to tell him that unfortunately, I’ve learned that government can be effective and helpful and change-making, but I haven’t seen it move quickly yet. I’ll do my best on that front, but I don’t want to make any political promises I can’t keep. My number is 917-887-8231 and my email is cevans@leg.state. vt.us if you need anything at all.
Housekeeping items The Green Mountain Care Board is looking for public input on the health care system in Vermont. I know we all have a lot to say and a lot of thoughts about this. If you’d like to attend the local Zoom meeting, there’s a community meeting on Friday, Nov. 3, 4-6 p.m. To register, go bit.ly/47eyJ34to; there is also a call-in option: 888-475-4499; meeting ID: 99773972190; passcode: 750587. You can also share your thoughts with the board ahead of time through this form: /bit.ly/47e3ftw. I’ve been a Meals on Wheels volunteer for years through Age Well, which is a terrific and essential organization. They’re looking for volunteers, not only
for Meals on Wheels but for other stuff, too. Here’s what they need: “Age Well is seeking 100 new volunteers to provide regular social interaction and assistance to seniors in their homes. Help older Vermonters by volunteering in your community for any of the following: providing friendly visits, going grocery shopping, running errands, assisting with medical appointments, organizing, bill paying, providing respite to caregivers, delivering Meals on Wheels, doing minor home repairs, and more. “Time commitment is based on your availability — it can vary from one day a week to two days a month (Monday through Friday between 8 a.m.-4 p.m. Volunteers tell us that they feel an incredible sense of satisfaction and reward seeing the impact they have on those they support. Contact our Volunteer Department at 802-662-5249 or volunteer@agewellvt.org for more information and to sign up to volunteer.” Chea Waters Evans, a Democrat, represents Charlotte and Hinesburg in the Chittenden-5 House district.
The Citizen • November 2, 2023 • Page 5
In Middle East, it’s time to pick understanding over righteousness choosing one group of innocent people over the other. I have traveled through Israel and the West Bank and met young Sen. Kesha Ram Hinsdale children with big dreams, elders who As we watch the violence and terror have devoted their whole lives to the unfolding in Israel and Gaza, Americans cause of peace, people who have put should strive for nonviolence in our themselves in harm’s way to forge relawords and actions, instead of trying to be tionships across divides. right. I did not meet a single person who Withholding sympathy for those killed wanted war and conflict with their neighand injured in Israel or Gaza will harden bors, or even justified it. In fact, many of positions at the extremes and result in the victim remembrances have highlightmore bloodshed in this unprecedented ed humanitarians and bridge-builders. moment. We must advocate for a ceaseYes, they were taken unjustly, but would fire and the ability to get safety and aid they now want us killing innocent people to those in need. Of course, I in their name? want hostages returned safely At the very least, we must as well, but withholding insulin create respectful space for each and anesthesia from Palestinian other, even if we disagree. I hospitals is not going to bring teach at Vermont Law & Gradthem back any sooner. uate School and this past week I know, for many, this will I opened conversation with my simply be dismissed as trying students about the unfolding to support all sides and stay conflict. They shared personal politically safe. It would be and vicarious pain and trauma. safer to say nothing at all. But No one tried to have immediate Sen. Kesha Ram being silent in the face of so answers or dismiss the feelings much suffering is far more pain- Hinsdale of another. ful for me than speaking out. I Later, one of them emailed know what it’s like to inherit the to say I was the only professor legacy of brutal conflict. who spoke about the conflict at all, and I am Jewish on my mother’s side, and the silence was hard for them to bear. If her grandparents were lucky to leave we cannot process our feelings without Kiev at the start of the deadly pogroms. committing or receiving more harm, then They knew the incurable pain of being the silence will breed resentment. We will scapegoated and exiled as a communiretreat to our own corners of social media ty, and even threatened with systematic to feel justified in our growing rage. erasure, as we should reflect on now. Pain and death should not be a I am Hindu on my father’s side, and competition. These are open wounds, and he and his family fled the part of India pouring salt on them will not help. We that became Pakistan with just the clothes should have enough kindness to offer to on their backs. The Partition of India everyone experiencing grief, loss, and was the largest, bloodiest movement of sorrow — or we will foment more hatred. people across a border in history, resultCalling for a ceasefire while recognizing ing in the death of 10 million people and peoples’ right to exist does not mean we the displacement and devastation of 30 are on the side of Israelis or Palestinians, million more. it means we’re on the side of peace over My father never returned to Lahore to misdirected righteousness. see that the legacy of his great grandfaWhen my daughter asks me where I ther, credited with building the modern stood, I want to be able to say I buried city, was maintained by the people of the bitterness with my father and sought a Pakistan a century later. He died embitpath to lasting peace. tered and angry, especially toward Muslims. At some point, we have to set Kesha Ram Hinsdale, a Democrat aside our parents’ bitterness and fight for from Shelburne, serves the towns of South the reality we want for our children. Burlington, Shelburne, Charlotte, HinesThose stoking the conflict are seeking burg, Milton, Burlington, St. George, political ammunition to try and wipe the Westford, Underhill, Jericho, Richmond, other side out. We cannot give them more Winooski, Williston, Essex and Bolton in ammunition, figuratively and literally, by the Legislature.
Correction
In our story about a Hinesburg community solar project (Oct. 19, 2023) we misspelled the name of Aaron Lavallee. He also performs design and permitting work for Aegis, not inside sales.
From the Senate
Invest in community WHY GO
LOCAL?
Buying locally is a commitment to investing in your community. If you don’t do it, who will?
Vermont Community Newspaper Group: Stowe Reporter • The Other Paper • Shelburne News • News & Citizen • The Citizen
A TA L K O N C H R I S T I A N S C I E N C E
HOW SPIRITUAL PERCEPTION BRINGS HEALING We are not stuck! Understanding more clearly our relationship with God, infinite good, ends fear and leads the way forward.
November 11 @ 11:00am Saturday
Alex Fischer, CS Christian Science practitioner
L O C AT I O N
South Burlington Public Library, Auditorium 180 Market Street South Burlington VT C O N TA C T
Ninth Church of Christ, Scientist, San Francisco, CA 802 864 4709 www.ChristianScienceBurlington.org
Hall of Justice Member of the ChristianDepartment Science Religious Services Board of Lectureship 850 Bryant Street San Francisco, CA 94103
SPONSORED BY
First Church of Christ, Scientist Burlington VT
(415) 664–2456 westportalreadingroom@gmail.com
NOV. 9
Page 6 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen
State police makes arrest in fatal shooting of teen Vermont State Police have arrested a suspect in connection to the death of a 14-year-old Shelburne youth. The victim has been identified as Madden Gouveia. Police arrested Hussein Mohamed, 14, of Bristol, on a charge of second-degree murder. The Addison County State’s Attorney’s office will charge Mohamed as an adult. He was expected to be arraigned Tuesday in criminal court in Middlebury after press deadline. According to police, a handgun in Mohamed’s possession discharged while he was sitting in the backseat of a car
parked outside of a North Street home near the intersection with Plank Road in Bristol. A bullet struck Gouveia, who was in the front seat. First responders say the gunshot critically injured Gouvenia, and he was pronounced dead at the University of Vermont Medical Center in Burlington. The investigation involves members of the Vermont State Police Major Crime Unit, Bureau of Criminal Investigations, Field Force Division, Crime Scene Search Team and Victim Services Unit. The Bristol Police Department is assisting. Detectives believe there is no link between this shooting and other recent homicides.
Vermont State Police Blotter: Oct. 25
Colorful
Cozy and
Fall
Oct. 25 at 4:45 p.m., police arrested Christopher Carpentier, 35 of Charlotte, for driving under the influence, second offense, driving with a suspended license and violating conditions of release after state troopers stopped him on Route 7 near Ferry Road in Charlotte. State police were assisted by the
Shelburne Police Department. Oct. 25 at 4:45 p.m., police arrested Ashley Thurgate, 35, of Charlotte, for giving false information to a police officer during a traffic stop. Vermont State police alleged that Thurgate gave false information to deflect a DUI investigation on Route 7 in Charlotte.
Hinesburg Police Blotter: Oct. 24-30 Total incidents: 43 Traffic Stops: 7 Oct. 24 at 3:30 p.m., found property was turned in at the police station. Oct. 25 at 9:24 a.m., officers conducted a welfare check on North Road. Oct. 25 at 10 a.m., police assisted a neighboring agency with a records check. Oct. 25 at 3 p.m., officers served a subpoena on behalf of another agency. Oct. 25 at 4:30 p.m., a lost dog was turned in to police and later returned to its owner. Oct. 26 at 3:15 p.m., an officer assisted with a traffic hazard on CVU Road. Oct. 26 at 8:10 p.m., an alarm activated on Commerce Street. Oct. 27 at 7:40 a.m., officers investigated a burglary on Gilman Road. Oct. 27 at 10:52 a.m., officers responded to CVU for an unruly parent causing a disturbance.
Oct. 28 at 11:22 a.m., an officer assisted first responders with a medical emergency at Kelley’s Field. Oct. 29 at 6 a.m., officers investigated the report of a stolen car on Route 116. Oct. 29 at 7:30 a.m., police investigated a larceny from a motor vehicle on Lilac Lane. Oct. 30 at 8 a.m., an officer served a relief from abuse order to someone on Village Heights Road. Oct. 30 at 10 a.m., a trespass order on Village Heights Road. Oct. 30 at 10:20 a.m., an officer assisted first responders with a medical emergency on Richmond Road. Oct. 30 at 3:35 p.m., officers responded to a two-car motor vehicle crash on Shelburne Falls Road. Oct. 30 at 7:34 p.m., an officer investigated a noise complaint on Sherman Hollow Road.
Pastured Pork
Wholes/Halves • Roasts • Steaks Sausage • Ribs • Bacon • And More
Certified Organic Beef
HEIRLOOM PORK SHOP Get the news of Charlotte and Hinesburg online at TheCitizenVT.com
LeBlanc Family Farm 1547 Hardwick Street East Hardwick Monday-Saturday, 8am-6pm
leblancfamilyfarm@emypeople.net
802-595-3607
The Citizen • November 2, 2023 • Page 7
Forest activists seek reconsideration in Camel’s Hump logging case ALICIA WOLFRAM COMMUNITY NEWS SERVICE
Forest preservation activists are waiting to see whether their lawsuit to stop logging on about 3,760 acres on public lands around Camel’s Hump still has life. Activist group Standing Trees and Duxbury residents Jamison Ervin and Alan Pierce asked Vermont Superior Court Judge Timothy Tomasi on Sept. 26 to reconsider his dismissal of their 2022 lawsuit against the state. The lawsuit claims that officials violated public process laws regarding plans to start logging in the Camel’s Hump Management Unit, a stretch of about 26,000 acres in north-central Vermont that includes the popular mountain and state park. The lawsuit named the commissioners of the Department of Forests, Parks and Recreation and the Department of Fish and Wildlife. State officials announced in late 2021 that 34 commercial timber harvests were planned for the next 15 years, totaling about 3,764 acres. Tomasi granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the case on the grounds that the plaintiffs lacked standing to bring the suit because, among other reasons, no specific approval has yet been made for logging on each of the specified parcels. The plaintiffs, represented by attorney James Dumont, filed a motion to reconsider and argued the cases the judge relied on in the dismissal did not apply. The injury in those cases was too remote and speculative to establish standing, according to the plaintiffs’ motion. In this case, however, according to the 2022 complaint, the property owned by Ervin and Pierce “adjoins, is downhill and downstream of and enjoys views of Camel’s Hump State Park.” The complaint further alleges that the residents would therefore likely suffer injury to their property from the logging through flooding, for instance, and from loss of enjoyment of the land, which also constitutes injury under the law. In the complaint, the plaintiffs say the state has been making decisions about land management for years without codifying procedures as formal rules, which would subject those policies to public comment and an extensive justification process involving an environmental impact assessment. Rules have the force of law, and they stay in effect unless they’re repealed or modified by another rule, limited or thrown away by a court or repealed or changed by a state law. According to state law, the Department of Forests, Parks and Recreation commissioner must adopt rules for timber harvesting
DEPARTMENT OF FORESTS, PARKS AND RECREATION
Camel’s Hump mountain view.
on state forests or park lands. An agency must begin the rulemaking process when petitioned by at least 25 people, and the plaintiffs say they followed that process when they asked state officials to establish formal rules about the planned logging, which they say has only been governed by the agency’s internal practices. However, according to the plaintiffs, state officials “chose not to initiate the promulgation process and its concomitant environmental review, thereby depriving Dr. Ervin and Dr. Pierce of the ability to participate in the environmental review/public comment process that could result in rules that protect them against harm.” In a November 2022 letter to Dumont, Michael Snyder, former commissioner of the forests and parks department, said officials agreed “it is appropriate to develop
rules regarding the land management planning process,” but denied the Dumont’s request because officials want to develop a “comprehensive land managing planning process rule” rather than only convert specific procedures into rules. Snyder agreed to initiate the process of making that rule, according to the letter, but said it wouldn’t change previously adopted plans. The current commissioner, Danielle Fitzko, told Community News Service that the department is currently in the early stages of rulemaking. “Early winter is our goal to actually go through the public involvement process,” she said. The public involvement process, Porter said, is what the lawsuit is all about. “We’re continuing with our litigation to ensure that (process) happens in a timely manner and to
ensure that we have rules in place that will guide the actual logging that is proposed on the ground in Camel’s Hump State Park,” Porter said. Fitzko also said that the public did weigh in on the identification of the 34 parcels of proposed logging land. This process, she said, is part of the 2021 plan for the Camel’s Hump area, the Long Range Management Plan. “Once the Long Range Management Plan is signed, that gives us the authority to move forward and implement those logging, forest management projects,” Fitzko said. A spokesperson from the Department of Fish and Wildlife declined to comment, citing the litigation’s pending status. “It’s just a completely opaque process,” Porter said, “and that’s why we are challenging the state’s management because the public has
been kept in the dark on how these special places are being managed.” He added that the state manages public lands on the public’s behalf, and “right now, the degree to which these are decisions hidden from public view is just not appropriate for public land management.” Fitzko defended her department’s actions. “It is the direction of the state to manage our state lands, and one of those authorities includes forest management and timber harvesting, and so we’re acting within the guidelines of state law.” Porter said it could be weeks if not months before another decision. In the meantime, he said, logging could begin soon. The Community News Service is a program in which University of Vermont students work with professional editors to provide content for local news outlets at no cost.
ESTABLISHED INDEPENDENT SENIOR COMMUNITY
Call today to plan for your future home at The Pines.
Spacious 1- and 2-Bedroom Apartments Hair Salon • Massage Studio • Art Gallery Expanded Outdoor Patio and Grilling Area • Exercise Room Community Rooms • Mature Landscaping • Resident Garden Vibrant Social Atmosphere with Weekly Events and Activities LOCATED IN THE HEART OF SOUTH BURLINGTON
7 Aspen Drive, South Burlington, VT • 802. 865.1109
www. SummitPMG. com
Make Our Home, Your Home.
Uniquely Affordable Residential Care Homes
Active, Independent Lifestyle in a Homelike Environment Prepared Meals • Daily Activities • Private Rooms/Suites • Medicaid Accepted 24/7 Nursing Oversight and Medication Management St. Joseph’s Residential Care Home BURLINGTON • 864-0264 Michaud Memorial Manor DERBY LINE • 873-3152 St. Joseph Kervick Residence RUTLAND • 755-5133
VERMONTCATHOLICHOMES.ORG
Page 8 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen
COMMUNITY Community Notes Huntington senior meal features turkey, trimmings The Community Church of Huntington is hosting a turkey dinner with all the fixings on Tuesday, Nov. 14, at noon. Apple or pumpkin pie will be served for dessert. A donation of $5 is suggested.
United Church of Hinesburg offers holiday bazaar The United Church of Hinesburg will hold its annual holiday bazaar on Saturday, Nov. 18, from 9 a.m.-1 p.m. in the parish house, 10580 Route 116. Come shop for reasonably priced items in Grandmother’s Attic, a jewelry corner and the arts and crafts center. A baked goods table will have an array of homemade treats, including pies, homemade breads, cookies, our traditional brown bobbies and more. Lunch will be available between 11 a.m.-1 p.m. and will feature homemade soups, sandwiches and a free dessert. Debit and credit cards be accepted. There will be wreaths for sale in the parking lot again this year (cash or check only). More at ucofh.org or email or call Yvonne Whitaker at unitedchurch@gmavt.net or 802-4823352.
CVU Theater presents Disney’s ‘Newsies’ The CVU Theater at Champlain Valley Union High School in Hinesburg will present four showings of the musical “Newsies” this November. Based on the real-life newsboy strike of 1899, this Disney musical tells the story of Jack Kelly, a rebellious newsboy who dreams of a life as an artist away from the big city. After publishing giant Joseph Pulitzer raises newspaper prices at the newsboys’ expense, Kelly and his fellow newsies take action.
With a funny, poignant book by Harvey Feirstein and music by Alan Menken and Jack Feldman — including the show-stopping “Seize the Day,” “Newsies” is a classic with the power to inspire. The show opens Friday, Nov. 10 at 7 p.m. with a Saturday matinee at 2 p.m. Saturday, Nov. 11 also features an evening show (7 p.m.) and a final Sunday matinee on Nov. 12 at 1 p.m. Tickets are $10 and can be purchased online at bit.ly/3Sk7Q9l.
Enjoy Age Well meals at Charlotte Senior Center The Age Well meal pickup for Thursday, Nov. 2, is from 10-11 a.m., Charlotte Senior Center, 212 Ferry Road, and features sweet-nsour vegetable pork, vegetable rice pilaf with lentils, Brussel sprouts, wheat bread, Halloween date cookie and milk. You must have pre-registered by the prior Monday at 802-4256345 or meals@charlotteseniorcentervt.org The meal on Thursday, Nov. 9, features roast pork with sauce, red mashed potatoes, butternut squash, wheat roll, apple crisp with topping and milk. The meal on Thursday, Nov. 16, features roast turkey, gravy, mashed potatoes, stuffing, carrots, cranberry sauce, wheat roll, pumpkin pie with cream and milk. The suggested donation is $5. Check the website for last-minute cancellations at charlotteseniorcentervt.org.
Turkey luncheon set at St. Catherine of Siena St. Catherine of Siena and Age Well are teaming up to offer a Thanksgiving turkey luncheon on Thursday, Nov. 16, in the St Catherine of Siena Parish Hall, 72 Church St., in Shelburne. Check-in time is 11:30 a.m. and the meal will be served at noon. There is a $5 suggested donation.
COURTESY PHOTO
The cast of “Newsies” in rehearsal at the CVU High School Theater.
There’ll also be entertainment, 50/50 raffle and door prizes. The menu is roast turkey, gravy, mashed potatoes, stuffing, carrots, cranberry sauce, wheat roll, pumpkin pie with cream and milk. Register by Nov. 10 with Kerry Batres, nutrition coordinator at 802-662-5283 or kbatres@agewellvt.org. Tickets are also available at the Age Well Office, 875 Roosevelt Highway, Suite 210, Colchester.
Shelburne Age Well hosts grab and go turkey dinner Age Well and St. Catherine’s of Siena Parish in Shelburne are teaming up to provide a meal to go for anyone age 60 and older on Tuesday, Nov. 14. The meal will be available for pick up in the parking lot at 72 Church St. from 11 a.m. until noon and are available for anyone 60 or older. Suggested donation is $5. The menu is roast turkey, gravy, mashed potatoes, stuffing, carrots, cranberry sauce, wheat roll, pump-
kin pie with cream and milk. To order a meal contact Kathleen at agewellstcath@gmail.com or 802-503-1107. Deadline to order is Wednesday, Nov. 8. If this is a first-time order, provide your name, address, phone number and date of birth. Learn more at agewellvt.org.
Federated Garden Clubs meet in Rutland The Rutland Country Club was the destination for the fall 2023 Federated Garden Clubs of Vermont meeting. The Central District club hosted the meeting. The Federated Garden Clubs of Vermont consists of 16 clubs throughout Vermont with over 700 members. Esther Swett, the Central District director, coordinated the guest speaker, local floral designer Michele Dauphinais, who spoke on “Fall Floral Inspirations.” Doris Van Mullen, Federated Garden Clubs president, said the
club projects promote and aid in the protection and conservation of our natural resources. Those projects include raising funds for a Blue Star Memorial Marker; promoting Penny for Pines, a national project dedicated to sustaining national and urban forests to forested areas damaged by insects, fires, or natural catastrophes; welcoming a new garden club, The Weathersfield Garden Club; and carrying out a flood recovery project with the Granite Center Garden Club in Barre for gardens and containers replacement of plants and flowers washed away from the recent flood.
Bella Voce chorus presents ‘A Ceremony of Carols’ Kick off the holiday season with Bella Voce women’s chorus and its rendition of Benjamin Britten’s Christmas classic, “A Ceremony of Carols,” with guest harpist Rebecca Kauffman as the concert’s centerSee COMMUNITY NOTES on page 9
The Citizen • November 2, 2023 • Page 9
Art feed Hinesburg
COURTESY PHOTO
At Responsible Growth Hinesburg’s annual meeting, co-presidents Catherine Goldsmith and Natacha Liuzzi hand a check to Laura Hoopes and Melissa Levy from the Hinesburg Community Resource Center. The funds are from the group’s Tiny Art Auction in July. This is the second year the net proceeds have gone to the Hinesburg Food Shelf.
COMMUNITY NOTES continued from page 8
piece, Saturday, Dec. 2, 7:30 p.m. at the College Street Congregational Church, 256 College St., Burlington. A second concert will be held Sunday Dec. 3, 4-6 p.m. Tickets are $20. Both concerts will feature festive and lively arrangements of carols and songs of the season with woodwinds, piano and percussion. For information, contact Sarah Pettineo at sarah@bellavocevt.org or call 215-4787336.
Sail Beyond Cancer holds benefit party Sail Beyond Cancer Vermont’s second annual Shake Your Buoy Benefit Party will be held on Thursday, Nov. 9, 6-10 p.m., at Hula Lakeside overlooking Lake Champlain in Burlington. The evening will feature heavy hors d’oeuvres, a live auction with many items, including lakefront vacation stays, silent auction and a DJ spinning you-can’t-sit-still dance tunes. The evening will also include a cash bar. Sail Beyond Cancer Vermont’s mission is to honor those who are challenged by cancer through harnessing the healing powers of wind, water and sail. It provides private sailing excursions for people suffering from the effects of cancer and their loved ones, creating opportunities to rebuild courage and make lasting memories. These excursions allow them to “leave their cancer ashore.” Learn more at sailbeyondcancer.org. Get your ticket at bit.ly/3FzcyIT. Email Suzanne Snyder Johnson, executive director, at suzanne@sailbeyondcancer.org for more information.
Students host discussion on racism, book bans Join Vermont students, advocates, nonprofit leaders, equity directors and others for a panel discussion of students and administrators on Wednesday, Nov. 8, at the Center for Community & Social Justice at Champlain College in Burlington.
National speaker professor Loretta J. Ross will join the conversation to talk about book bans and racial justice in America. In 2023, the Vermont Student Anti-Racism Network and the Rutland NAACP sent out a survey asking about student experiences with racism in schools. At the event, the network will release the results. Register at bit.ly/45SAFgi.
Violin virtuoso takes on Paganini’s ’24 Caprices’ Violinist Soovin Kim delves into the world of Niccolò Paganini in the talk, “The Paganini Phenomenon,” on Saturday, Nov. 18, at 9:30 a.m. at the University of Vermont Recital Hall, 392 S. Prospect St., Burlington. Then, on Sunday, Nov. 19, at 3 p.m., witness Kim’s virtuosity in action as he takes on the formidable and brilliant “24 Caprices” by Paganini. Paganini, the 19th-century Italian violin virtuoso, has long been shrouded in mystique. His technical prowess, including seemingly supernatural abilities on the violin, gave rise to the myth that he had made a Faustian pact with the devil in exchange for his unparalleled talent. Paganini’s performances, marked by his flamboyant stage presence and intricate compositions, further fueled the legend. His music, notably the “24 Caprices,” continues to challenge and inspire violinists, while his enigmatic persona endures as a symbol of both musical genius and the allure of the mysterious and the unattainable. For more, visit lccmf.org.
Shelburne Players offer ‘finely crafted diorama’ Join The Shelburne Players for its fall 2023 production, “Circle Mirror Transformation,” set in the fictional Shirley, Vt. The play offers finely crafted diorama, a petri dish in which we see, with hilarious detail and clarity, the antic sadness of a motley quintet. The show takes place at the Historic Shelburne Town Hall, 5372 Shelburne Road. For show dates and times, go to shelburneplayers.com.
Page 10 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen
Carbon markets and how they affect forests Into the Woods Ethan Tapper If you’re tuned into what’s happening with forests in our region, you may have heard that we can manage forests for carbon and be paid for it. But what are “carbon markets,” and what do they mean for the way we manage our forests? The idea of carbon markets is to create a marketplace where carbon emitters pay for practices that sequester and store carbon somewhere else, thus balancing their emissions of carbon or other greenhouse gasses.
The units of carbon that emitters purchase through carbon markets are called carbon offsets. There are two types of carbon markets: regulatory (compliance) markets and voluntary markets. In regulatory markets, such as in California and in Europe, greenhouse gas emitters are issued “allowances” – essentially permits to produce a certain amount of emissions – which can be sold or traded. If they produce greenhouse gas emissions beyond their allowances, emitters are allowed to purchase some carbon offsets to lower their net emissions and bring them into compliance. In regulatory markets,
greenhouse gas allowances are gradually reduced, thus lowering overall emissions over time. By contrast, voluntary carbon markets sell offsets to emitters that wish to voluntarily balance their carbon emissions. By purchasing voluntary carbon offsets, a carbon emitter like a person, a government agency or a corporation can claim to have reduced their net greenhouse gas emissions, or even to be “carbon neutral.” Forests naturally sequester and store carbon, and so both voluntary and regulatory carbon markets have looked to forests as places to generate carbon offsets. While
HONORING OUR
VETERANS
On Nov. 9, The Citizen will be honored to publish photos of the men and women who have unselfishly served our country. Page 14 • November 10, 2022 • Shelburne News
HONORING The Veterans Among Us
If you have a veteran who you would like us to honor, please mail or email your photo and the following information by
ROBERT F. WHITEMAN, SR. U.S. Air Force E6 1959-1979
LORENZO P. BUSHWAY, SR. April 28, 1960 Active Duty: Feb. 1953-Feb. 1955
ROBERT S. BORKOWSKI Sergeant (SFC) Medic VT Army National Guard 1982-2005
PVT. HENRI DE MARNE & PVT. CLAUDE DE MARNE Henri de Marne and his brother Claude, Patton’s 3rd army, WW2, 1944 following French resistance before liberation.
PETER PAUL ZUK U.S. Marine Corps 1st Lieutenant Served 1955-57 Japan and Korea
DAVID F. LELAND United States Navy Lieutenant WWII 1944-1955
ROLAND W. WILBUR United States Army T/4, 14th Armored Division WW II 1942-46
PERRY D. MELVIN U.S. Navy, HM 3 3rd Marine Regiment Vietnam War
BRUCE NUNZIATA 1st Infantry Vietnam 1967-68
THOMAS C. GIBSON Royal Air Force Squadron Leader 1947-1952, Malaya
MICHAEL W. LYNCH U.S. Navy, Lt.J.G. Civil Engineer Corp 1967-1975 VT Air Guard 1976-1979
PETER GADUE US Army and VTARNG 1970-2009
SHANNON B. BLAKE U.S. Army, Major 1986-2006 Afghanistan War Veteran
DAVID WINER Corporal, Marine Corps March 1944-July 1946 Peleliu Campaign
WILLIAM A. READ JR. U.S. Navy Commander Gunnery Instructor Patrol Squadron 101 Southwest Pacific
THURSDAY, NOV. 2 Please include: • Name of veteran • Branch of service • Rank • Years of service • Town of residence
EMAIL PHOTOS AND TEXT TO: news@thecitizenvt.com OR MAIL TO: The Citizen, P.O. Box 489, Stowe, VT 05672 If you have submitted a photo in a previous year, you do not need to resubmit.
producing carbon offsets for regulatory markets is more lucrative, it generally isn’t feasible for forests in our region – the forest carbon markets that you’re likely hearing about in Vermont are producing offsets for the voluntary carbon market. In essence, forest carbon markets pay for forest landowners to do, or not do, practices that lead to a higher-than-normal amount of carbon being stored in their forest. Practices may include planting trees (afforestation), reducing deforestation, and improved forest management practices like letting trees grow bigger and older before harvesting them. The higher amount of carbon stored in the forest after the landowners do (or don’t do) these practices, as compared to forests engaged in “business as usual,” is called additional carbon – that’s the amount of carbon that can be sold to someone else as a carbon offset. The trickiest part of these carbon markets is proving this additionality: that the carbon offset being sold to an emitter represents real, additional carbon stored in a forest that wouldn’t have existed without the carbon market. For instance, if “Bob” doesn’t manage his forest for the next twenty years, he can say that the greater amount of carbon in his forest (as compared to other forests in his area, managed under “business as usual” practices) is additional and can be sold as an offset. Unfortunately, forest carbon markets can’t judge Bob’s intent. If Bob wasn’t going to manage his forest for the next twenty years anyway, the carbon market hasn’t changed his behavior or led to any more carbon being stored in Bob’s forest. In this case, one could argue that Bob has actually made things a little worse: after twenty years the same amount of carbon dioxide will be in the atmosphere as would have been there anyway – the only difference that the carbon market made is allowing an emitter to claim to have lower net carbon emissions. Another concern to be aware of leakage: storing carbon in one place and emitting carbon somewhere else. If Bob starts heating his house with fuel oil instead of firewood from his land – or buying lumber from forests somewhere else instead of engaging in responsible forest management on his own land – his entry into a carbon program has actually caused more carbon to be emitted. Carbon markets may also be a force for good – promoting more carbon-friendly practices in the woods, providing an economic incentive to keep forests as forests and giving landowners money that can be reinvested in the responsible stewardship of their forest. But, like timber markets, they aren’t inherently good or bad – the benefits of forest carbon markets will depend on the nuances of how they are applied in our forests. For more information about forest carbon and carbon markets, check out these articles by Ali Kosiba in Northern Woodlands magazine. Ethan Tapper is the Chittenden County Forester for the Vermont Dept. of Forests, Parks and Recreation. See what he’s been up to, check out his YouTube channel, sign up for his eNews and read articles he’s written at https://linktr.ee/ChittendenCountyForester
The Citizen • November 2, 2023 • Page 11
SPORTS CVU runners capture cross country state title LAUREN READ CORRESPONDENT
The Champlain Valley girls’ cross-country team has been making headlines for years. From a 12-year run as the Division I state champs to national championship appearances, the Redhawks are used to breaking records and making a name for themselves. On Saturday at the state championship race in Thetford, CVU found some new ground to break. Champlain Valley ran a perfect race, with its first five runners finishing 1-2-3-4-5 to capture the program’s 20th state title. “I think there was like a point right about halfway in the race where I was coming through the halfway, I saw three people from our team in front of me and I knew one person was right behind me,” Audrey Neilson said. “It clicked into place in my head like, oh, we could actually get all five.” Alice Kredell crossed the finish line first, coming in 19 minutes, 49.3 seconds to capture first place and the individual title. Estella Laird followed just five seconds behind in second place. Neilson was third, Lydia Donahue came in
fourth and Charlotte Crum rounded out the top five for the Redhawks. All in all, the top five CVU runners all finished within 43 seconds of each other. “I was the fifth person, so my goal the whole race was to stick with the people ahead of me and work together,” Crum said. “I think about halfway through I realized that I could stick with these people, and we can complete that top five.” CVU’s Annalise Wood and Noe Jenni came in ninth and tenth, respectively. “This group puts in an incredible amount of hard work and in every workout, everything we do, and every race they do, everything they do is put a lot of hard work,” coach Dave Baird said. “I feel like that’s the secret ingredient that makes that happen.” Breaking new ground is part of the legacy of running in such an historic program, the CVU runners said. They are racing against all the runners from past teams. “I think some of the very fast girls from the past are also a big motivation for this team,” Kredell said. With 19 state championships in the last 21 years, there is certainly no shortage of CVU runners to look
PHOTO BY DAVE BAIRD
The CVU girls’ cross country team went 1-2-3-4-5 to take the Division I state title.
up to, but it also puts the pressure on to perform. “What took the pressure off was that every week they saw they were putting in the work and they were then making adjustments and getting faster and faster each week,” Baird said. Now, Champlain Valley sets its sights on the New England Cross Country championship on Saturday, Nov. 11, in Maine — one of its season-opening goals.
“We definitely are going to try and close the gap and do what we always do,” Kredell said. “I think if we do that then we have a pretty good chance at a good score.”
Boys’ cross country The Champlain Valley boys’ cross-country team came in third
overall at state championship race. Dan Knight was the first Redhawk to finish, coming in fourth, while Owen Deale was just behind in fifth. Kody Guiterman was 16th, Charles Garavelli came in 21st and Treson McEnaney was 22nd for CVU.
CVU athletes eye titles in playoffs LAUREN READ CORRESPONDENT
Field hockey (3) Champlain Valley 2, (6) Essex 1: Champlain Valley opened a lead in the first half and held off Essex in a 2-1 win Friday in the field hockey quarterfinals. Claire Marcoe and Marlie Cartwright scored for the Redhawks, while Bibi Frechette and Cordelia Thomas each had assists. Sophie Comeau in goal helped the defending champs advance to the semifinals. CVU took on No. 2 Rice Wednesday at Middlebury College in the semifinals. The Green Knights handed the Redhawks two of its three losses this season.
Boys’ volleyball (4) Champlain Valley 3, (5) Mount Mansfield 0: The team beat Mount Mansfield in straight
sets on Friday in the quarterfinals. The Redhawks advanced to the DI semifinals where they faced No. 1 Burlington on Tuesday after presstime. CVU fell in both regular season matchups to the Seahorses, losing both 3-0.
Boys’ soccer (1) Champlain Valley 3, (9) St. Johnsbury 0: Top-seeded Champlain Valley opened a first half lead and then extended that lead in the second half to beat St. Johnsbury in the Division I boys’ soccer quarterfinals on Saturday, Oct. 28. Chandler Turner had a goal and two assists for the Redhawks, while Charlie Jennings and Luke Sampson each scored. Ziggy Babbott in goal had seven saves. Champlain Valley faced No. 4 Colchester in the DI semifinals on Wednesday after press time. The Redhawks narrowly beat Colchester 1-0 in their only meeting of the regular season but will
need to get another win to advance to the state championship. A CVU win means it will face the winner of a matchup between No. 6 Burlington and No. 2 South Burlington.
Girls’ volleyball (2) Champlain Valley 3, (10) Lyndon 0: The girls began their playoff push with a win over No. 10 Lyndon in the DI quarterfinals Saturday. The Redhawks won the first set 25-9, then followed up with a 25-8 win in the second set. They clinched the win, 25-14, in the third set. CVU will now take on No. 3 Enosburg in the semifinals on Thursday, Nov. 2, at 5 p.m. The two teams met early in the regular season, with the Redhawks winning 3-2. If Champlain Valley beats Enosburg, it will play the winner See PLAYOFFS on page 13
Say you saw it in The Citizen!
Page 12 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen
INFRASTRUCTURE continued from page 1
reflected a considerable amount of concern for the overall condition of school infrastructure across the state. Although Champlain Valley School District’s overall depletion percentage of 48 percent fared better than other districts, staff is still dealing with a slew of issues related to failing infrastructure due to aging buildings. Gary Marckres, the district’s chief operations officer, said that although the buildings have been
relatively well maintained, many of them are reaching the end of their useful life. “That’s where the needs specifically come from, just the age of our buildings,” he said. “Even though they’re in pretty good shape, and they’ve had good solid investment, it’s just getting to the time period over the next 10 years where many systems will be will not be able to continue in the in the state that they’re in.” For decades, Vermont provid-
ed state money to cities and towns to build or renovate schools, but the state shut down its school construction aid fund in 2007. The program used to fund up to 30 percent of a school infrastructure project. “You have to remember that it was right before the 2008 recession,” said Chittenden County Sen. Ginny Lyons, who was involved in these infrastructure conversations in the Legislature in 2007. “A discussion was had
TOWN OF CHARLOTTE, VERMONT SPECIAL TOWN MEETING OFFICIAL WARNING NOVEMBER 7, 2023 The legal voters of the Town of Charlotte, Vermont, are hereby notified and warned to meet at Charlotte Town Hall, 159 Ferry Road in the Town of Charlotte on Tuesday, November 7, 2023, between the hours of seven o’clock (7:00) in the forenoon (a.m.), at which time the polls will open, and seven o’clock (7:00) in the afternoon (p.m.), at which time the polls will close, to vote by Australian ballot upon the following Articles of business: ARTICLE I Shall the voters authorize the acquisition of solar energy equipment and its installation on the roof of the Town garage in an amount not to exceed Two Hundred Eighty-two Thousand Five Hundred Ten and 00/100 Dollars ($282,510.00) to be financed with debt instruments other than bonds over a period not to exceed ten (10) years (the “Solar Project”)? ARTICLE II Shall the Town amend the Town of Charlotte Land Use Regulations at Sections 2.4 (Commercial/ Light Industrial District definitions of Permitted and Conditional Uses), 2.5 (Rural District definition of Conditional Uses), 3.12 A) 3) and 6) (Performance Standards), 4.3 (Adaptive Reuse of an Existing Structure), 4.17 (Temporary Structures), 4.20 (Cannabis Establishment) and 10.2 (Definitions) for the purposes of defining “cannabis establishment,” specifying where such operations may be located, and specifying relevant performance standards for the operation of a “cannabis establishment”? (A copy of the Land Use Regulations showing all proposed additions and deletions is available for review at the Town offices and on the Town’s website at www.charlottevt.org.) The legal voters of the Town of Charlotte are further notified that voter qualification, registration, and absentee voting relative to said special meeting shall be as provided in Chapters 43, 51 and 55 of Title 17, Vermont Statutes Annotated. The legal voters of the Town of Charlotte are further notified that an informational hearing will be held on Monday, October 30, 2023, at the Town Offices in the Town of Charlotte and electronically on the Zoom platform beginning at six-thirty (6:30) in the evening (p.m.), for the purpose of explaining the proposed project and the financing thereof. The details concerning access to and participation using the Zoom platform will be specified in the warning for the public informational hearing. Adopted and approved at a meeting of the Selectboard of the Town of Charlotte duly called, noticed, and held September 25, 2023. TOWN OF CHARLOTTE SELECTBOARD /s/_________________________ James Faulkner, Chair /s/_________________________ Kelly Devine /s/_________________________ Lewis Mudge
/s/_________________________ Frank Tenney, Vice Chair /s/_________________________ Louise McCarren
Received for record and recorded in the records of the Town of Charlotte on September 27, 2023. /s/_________________________ Mary Mead, Town Clerk
about finding savings and reduc- Marckres said. “There’s a lot of ing property taxes. So historically, building that is already approved there were good intentions about to happen, particularly in Hineshelping people with their proper- burg and some in Williston as ty taxes, but the bad outcome is well, that will put some capacity that it put significant pressure on pressures on our school,” he said, school boards to find additional noting that the change in multimoney when schools were fail- tiered systems of supports and ing.” interventions that require one-onVermont is now the only state one spaces take up most of the in New England without a school space that was traditionally used construction aid program, along for full classrooms. with the second oldest building Marckres said that the district stock of school buildings in the is currently planning a revision of country, said Jill Briggs Campbell, the school’s capital improvement the Vermont Agency of Educa- plan after Town Meeting Day that tion’s operations director. will expand the current committee “That doesn’t necessarily mean to include community members that those buildings are going to be to help inform a new long-range in poor condition if they’ve been capital plan. well maintained, it’s all about ongoThrough Act 72, adopted in ing maintenance and operations,” 2021, the state restarted a convershe said. “It’s more that we have a sation about setting standards for huge backlog of school facilities deferred mainte— which the “What we’re looking state does not nance, and school districts have currently have at is a proposal to not been able to — for things budget approprilike training restart in this next ately for ongoing and certificamaintenance and tion standards legislative session operations.” for facilities But the managers and and the question, district’s biggest doing a thorough issues currentcomprehensive of course, will ly don’t have facilities assessmuch to do with ment for every be balancing the deferred mainpublic-school tenance, said building in the needs that we’re Marckres. state. “The deferred “That work is identifying with the maintenance being completed answer is not how now,” Briggs funding resources I would characCampbell said. available.” terize Champlain “We’re getting Valley Union,” he the final reports said. “We haven’t — Jill Briggs Campbell in. That also deferred a lot of allows us to do maintenance until recently.” modeling on what the need is with The largest issue facing the dollar amounts attached to it. So, district now is a mix of infla- we’re going to have a better sense tion-related costs in the construc- of the actual condition of our tion industry that have caused school facilities.” the district to postpone several All this is meant to inform the planned projects. work of the State School ConstrucIn 2022, voters approved a tion Aid Task Force, which was $7.5 million bond vote to fund created in the appropriations bill various infrastructure upgrades in of the last legislative session, school buildings, including $4.7 Act 78. It creates a 17-member million in upgrades just at Char- group co-chaired by the Agency lotte Central School, which was of Education and the Vermont built in 1969. treasurer’s office, which will presThe majority of the work ent a proposal to the Legislature focused on a sizable electrical in January on a reinstated state system upgrade as well as a new school construction aid program. building-wide fire suppression “What we’re looking at is a system. But now, costs are more proposal to restart in this next than double what had already been legislative session and the quesbudgeted, leaving the district with tion, of course, will be balancing a nearly $3 million shortfall. the needs that we’re identifying In addition to the list of capital with the funding resources availinvestment projects, the district, able,” Briggs Campbell. “We’re like many throughout the state, at this pivot point. At the agency is facing the pressures of rising level and on my team, it is our capacity issues. understanding that if the mission “We are a school district that is equitable access to high-qualidemographic studies say will ty education, that includes faciligrow over the next 10 years,” ties.”
The Citizen • November 2, 2023 • Page 13
WASTEWATER
Public Notice of Training Burn
continued from page 1 town would be an improvement, Hinesburg town manager Todd Odit said. “Obviously we’d like it to get as low as possible, so this is an improvement,” he said, adding that what matters to the town is how much it will eventually have to pay back in bonds. The redesign, which Aldrich and Elliot did at no additional cost to the town, brings the overall borrowing cost to about $1.4 million less than what it will have to pay back in loans. The town in the spring received three multi-million-dollar bids to build the facility, all well over
PLAYOFFS
continued from page 11 of No. 5 BFA-St. Albans and No. 1 Essex in the state championship on Sunday, Nov. 5.
Girls’ soccer (9) Essex 1, (1) Champlain Valley 0: The Champlain Valley girls’ soccer team was upset Friday in the DI quarterfinals, falling to Essex 1-0. The Hornets scored the lone goal of the game on a free kick in the second half to upset the previously unbeaten Champlain Valley. The Redhawks finished the season with a 14-1 record.
Football (3) Champlain Valley 45, (6) Essex 0: The defending champs kicked off the high school football postseason in convincing fashion on Saturday. The Redhawks defeated Essex 45-0 in the quarterfinals to advance to the semis. Ollie Cheer threw for one touchdown and rushed for another for the Redhawks. Brian Rutherford had 15-yard TD catch and Michael Dunbar nabbed a 4-yard TD catch. Asher Vaughn ran for two touchdowns and Nolan Walpole added a 3-yard touchdown. The Redhawks will now travel to No. 2 Burr and Burton for their semifinal matchup on Saturday at 1 p.m. CVU will look to get some payback against the only team to beat them this season. The Bulldogs had a 38-28 victory to open the regular season schedule. If CVU wins the semifinal game, it will face the winner of No. 5 Middlebury and No. 1 Hartford in the final.
the borrowing capacity approved this back out to bid in December by voters. All before the end three bids were of the year, but “We’d really like to try rejected by the worst case, we’re selectboard at its really shooting to get this back out to June meeting. for early in Janubid in December before ary,” Elliot said. The facility, as proposed in the Construction the end of the year, but bids, would have could theoretiworst case, we’re really cally start in the cost the town well over $20 spring — if no shooting for early in million. more surprise January.” The town costs arise. would like to take “I’m envi— Wayne Elliot sioning the cereadvantage of the full construction monial first flush season next year. of the toilet or something,” select“We’d really like to try to get board member Paul Lamberson.
SHELBURNE Stormwater Coordinator $26 - $32 hourly DOQ Full-time position with specific training available and excellent local government benefits. The Town of Shelburne team has grown to require a dedicated stormwater professional. The Town has a new stormwater utility, ordinance, and regulations. Help our community achieve environmental excellence, working with a wide range of partners. This coordinator will support other departments and contractors with mapping, grants, construction management, and agency reporting. The ideal candidate has related education and experience in stormwater work, with a mix of technical and people skills. We have opportunities to grow, and to shape this position to the skills and interests of the right candidate. The work is both indoors and outdoors in the beautiful environment of Shelburne. Visit www.shelburnevt.org/jobs to see the full job description and application. To apply, email scannizzaro@shelburnevt.org. Review of applications begins immediately. The Town of Shelburne is an Equal Opportunity Employer.
thecitizenvt.com
Get the News of Charlotte and Hinesburg 24/7
The Hinesburg Fire Department will be conducting a training burn of a residential structure located at 14407 Route 116, Hinesburg VT on Sunday, November 12th starting at 7:00am. Conducting a controlled burn of a structure provides the best possible training for our members, and is a valuable opportunity made possible by the State of Vermont. HFD, along with the property owners, have complied with the States requirements in preparation of the burn, and have submitted all necessary paperwork to the US EPA, Vermont Department of Health Asbestos Program and the Vermont Air Quality and Climate Division. Our training burn plan is compliant with NFPA 1403, Standard on Live Fire Training Evolutions. Shelburne Dispatch Center will be notified in advance of the training burn, as there will be smoke in the area for the duration of the training. The public can expect fire apparatus from multiple agencies to be parked in the area of Route 116/Hollow Rd. We anticipate the training burn to be completed by 1:00pm. Any questions can be directed to Chief Nicholas Baker at nbaker@ hinesburg.org
Community Bankers – Chittenden County BUILDERS | MAKERS | DOERS® There is no better time to join our Team!
Community Bankers – Chittenden County
Northfield Savings Bank, founded in 1867, is BUILDERS | MAKERS | DOERS®
the largest LOCAL BANK in Vermont. We are There is no better time to join our Team! committed to providing a welcoming work environment for all.Bank, founded in 1867, is Northfield Savings
the largest LOCAL BANK in Vermont. We are Consider joining our team as ato Community in Chittenden committed providing Banker a welcoming work County! environment for all. Consider joining team as aService, Community in Chittenden Relevant Skills: our Customer Cash Banker Handling (we’ll train County! you!)
Even better… if you have prior banking experience, we Relevant Skills: you Customer Service, Cash Handling (we’ll train you!) encourage to apply! Even better… if you have prior banking experience, we youortoolder apply!and have a high school diploma, Ifencourage you are 18 general education (GED) degree, or equivalent, consider If you are 18 or older and have a high school diploma, joining the NSB Team! general education (GED) degree, or equivalent, consider joining the NSB Team! Opportunity for Growth NSB has training opportunities to engage employees and Opportunity for Growth assist with professional development within our company. NSB has training opportunities to engage employees and The average years of service for an NSB employee is 9! If assist with professional development within our company. you’re looking for a career in an environment that promotes The average years of service for an NSB employee is 9! If growth, join our team! you’re looking for a career in an environment that promotes joinOff our Whatgrowth, NSB Can erteam! You What NSB Can Offer You Competitive compensation based on experience. WellCompetitive compensation on experience. Wellrounded benefi ts package. based Profit-Sharing opportunity. rounded benefits Excellent 401(k) package. matchingProfit-Sharing retirement opportunity. program. Excellent 401(k) matching retirement program. Commitment to professional development. Opportunities Commitment development. Opportunities to volunteer to andprofessional support our communities. Work-Life to volunteer and support our communities. Work-Life balance! balance! Please send an NSB Application & your resume in confidence to: Careers@nsbvt.com Equal Opportunity Employer / Member FDIC
continued from page 2
Page 14 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen
The week-long bait drop is a cooperative effort between Vermont and the U.S. Department of Agriculture Wildlife Services to stop the spread of the potentially fatal disease. Rabies is a deadly viral disease of the brain that infects mammals. It is most often seen in raccoons, skunks, foxes, and bats, but unvaccinated pets and livestock can also To rabies. advertise theisservice directory get The in virus spread through the email: Advertising@thecitizenvt.com bite of an infected animal or contact with its
service
directory or call 985-3091 Brush Hogging
Empowering people to achieve their best health and wellbeing
The week-long bait drop is a cooperative effort between Vermont and the U.S. Collectibles Department of Agriculture Wildlife Services Y P Ethe spread of the potentially fatal to stop disease. Buying Sports and Rabies is a deadly viral disease of the Collectible R that infects brain mammals. It isCards most often C E I L seen in raccoons, skunks, foxes, and bats, Hyper Relic Cards but unvaccinated petsSports and livestock can also Bob & Jessica Trautwine get rabies. The virus is spread through the Cell/Txt: • Office: 802-497-1681 bite of an802-233-1451 infected animal or contact with its
R
Will rototill your garden or brush hog your fields.
saliva. If left untreated, rabies is almost always fatal in humans and animals. However, treatment with the rabies vaccine is nearly 100 percent effective when given soon after Acupuncture a person is bitten by a rabid animal. So far this year, 23 animals in Vermont have tested positive for rabies, and 14 of thoseAcupuncture have been raccoons. According to wildlife officials, rabid & Massage animals often show a change in their normal behavior, but you cannot tell whether Champlainwellness.com an animal has rabies simply by looking at 802-989-9031 RABIES BAIT it. People should not touch or pick up wild Felipe Toro, LAc continued from page 2 527 Ferry Road Charlotte, animals or strays – even VT baby animals.
H
RABIES BAIT
SHELBURNE DAY Antiques continued from page 4
ANTIQUES WANTED
fac
bu he th Go de lan Ro
Shelburne Historical Society will have a Decluttering? Downsizing? display and president Dorothea Penar will We can help you discover, learn about and sell: lead a cemetery tour at 1 p.m. Food venWATCHES • JEWELRY • COINS • SILVER • ARTWORK dors round out the event with everything from coffee and lemonade to burgers and creemees. Kids will enjoy meeting animals saliva.Brian IfBittner left rabies is almost al•untreated, 802-489-5210 • info@bittnerantiques.com Showroom at 2997 Shelburne Rd • Shelburne from Shelburne Farms, craft projects, and ways fatal humans andtoanimals. However, Open in Wed-Fri, with walk-ins sell every Thursday. www.bittnerantiques.com treatment with the rabies vaccine is nearly 100 percent effective when given soon after SH a person is bittenConstruction by a rabid animal. con So far this year, 23 animals in Vermont Basement have tested positive for •rabies, and 14 of Waterproofing Sh those have been raccoons.• Crawl Space Repair dis • Sump Pump Systems According to wildlife officials, rabid lea • Foundation Repair animals often show a change in their nor• Egress Windows do mal behavior, but you cannot tell whether fro an animal has rabies simply by looking at for rates: call 985-3 cre it. People should not touch or pick up wild or email advertising fro animals or strays – even baby animals.
SERVICE DIRECTORY Call Frenchy 324-5796 or 324-0558 985-5379
Hyperreliccards@gmail.com • hyperrelic.com
1111-855-DRY-TIME • www.northernbasements.com
Health Insurance
Build / Remodel Construction
Health Knife Sharpening
PLEASANT VALLEY, INC.
Roofing Siding & T rim W ork Siding Carpentry R epairs Renovations Painting & Staining Painting Decks & Porches Decks O utdoor Structures 802-343-4820 802-343-4820 www.pleasantvalleyvt.com www.pleasantvalleyvt.com
TONY BRICE PAINTING, LLC Free Estimates Interior & Exterior
64 Steeplebush Road Shelburne
SERVICE DIRECTO 802-862-1600 • info@turnbaughinsurance.com 188 Allen Brook Lane • Suite 1 • Williston, VT 05495
For more information contact Bill Lowell Intro Offer for New Clients (802) 363-2447 • TheSharperBlade109@gmail.com
Build / Remodel Health Landscape / Lawncare
Health Insurance Metal
Full Line Steel Service Center
4/29/2019 Roofing Spring Cleanup & Mulch Huge inventory of steel, Since 1988 Siding Lawn aluminum and stainless 3.5 Maintenance x 2 AD for Shelburne News & The Citizen in many shapes and sizes Renovations Landscape Design from sheets to tubing Tim Gould Serving both all your metal needs 24 Consecutive Weeks $18.00/week for papers $432.00 to angle iron PT, DPT Painting Stonework &MS,Planting for over two generations Cutting, Punching, Drilling Decks 4281802-864-0326 Shelburne Rd 985-2453 Mini Excavation South Burlington Shelburne and Office: Bending Services 23 San Remo Drive 166 Athletic Drive 800-540-4692 PO Box 476, Shelburne Cell: 363-0590 We’ll even recycle your 802-343-4820 tel 865.0010 tel 985.4440 802-343-4820 35 Intervale Rd, Burlington ferrous and non-ferrous metal titus@titusinsurance.net Fax: 985-8620 www.DeePT.com www.pleasantvalleyvt.com www.pleasantvalleyvt.com www.qcsteel.com Delivery available Funeral / Cremation Sheds
DEE.PT.bCARD.2.4x1.5FINAL.indd 12
1/9/14 9:12 AM
Town & Country Sheds, LLC CORBIN & PALMER FUNERAL HOMERd & CREMATION SERVICES 2175 N Wolcott
802.777.8771
Wolcott, VT 05680FUNERAL CHAPEL SHELBURNE (802) 888-7012 Family owned and operated since 1921
TO ALL OF OUR CLIENTS, THANK YOU!
services available FORPre-planning RENT LL US CA 60 FOOT LIFTRoad, 209 Falls Shelburne, VT TODAY! JLG600S (802) 985-3370
Scheduling 2023-2024 Interior Painting
MassageWorksVT Kitchen Knives Sharpened 802-985-8984 Deep Tissue, Hot Stones Fast Turnaround • Convenient Charlotte Drop Box cell 338-7001 & Swedish Massage at The Old Brick Store
PLEASANT VALLEY, INC.
FUNERAL HOME & CREMATION SERVICES
Painting
THE SHARPER BLADE Certified Massage Therapist Home • Auto • Motorcycle • Watercraft Business • Contractor
CORBIN & PALMER Family owned and operated since 1921 Pre-planning services available 209 Falls Road, Shelburne, VT (802) 985-3370
Nancy Marconi
Covering Your Life’s Journey
Funeral / Cremation Landscape / Lawncare
SHELBURNE FUNERAL CHAPEL
The Holidays Are Coming
P
F L L M S D
8&
w
Health Siding/Remodeling
BEAGLE BUILDERS, LLC Remodeling & Additions
ALL TYPES OF SIDING
Since 1988
Vinyl/Wood/Composite
Tim Gould Windows & Doors • Decks & Porches PT, MS, DPT
South Burlington 23 San Remo Drive tel 865.0010
Monkton, VT
Kitchens & Bathrooms Sunrooms & Garages Shelburne 166 Athletic Drive tel 985.4440
beaglebuilders@gmavt.net
802-453-4340 CALL US! 802-355-0807 www.DeePT.com
42 P ti
The Citizen • November 2, 2023 • Page 15
Horoscope November 2, 2023
ANSWERS FROM THIS ISSUE
Weekly Puzzles
Page 16 • November 2, 2023 • The Citizen