Vanguard Review Feb. 2022

Page 1

Book smart | 2

Automated alliance

The pros and cons of physical versus online textbooks

Chilled to the bone | 7

| 4-5

Managing the effects of winter weather on athletes

Robotics teams catapult to top tier in state

Vanguard College Preparatory School, 2517 Mt. Carmel Dr., Waco, Texas 76710

February 2022, Volume 49, Issue 4

The Vanguard Review A VCPS Publication

Beloved books: Banned?

Texas state senator issues questionnaire asking librarians to report on books that “make students feel discomfort” Isaac Saadi ‘22 editor-in-chief

T

he idea of book censorship has trickled its way from the 16th century Roman Catholic Church’s “Index of Forbidden Books” as an effort to prevent the “corruption of morals” to the Nazi Reich Ministry, which tried to eliminate all books that represented ideas opposed to the Nazism. Last fall in Texas, State Senator Matt Krause compiled a list of 850 books that he said could potentially “make students feel discomfort” as a preemptive measure to remove them from public school libraries. “A world where the government controls what books we can and cannot read would look dangerously like the book “1984,” senior Naomi West said. “Everyone would think the same thing regarding certain issues and if you have a different set of beliefs than everyone else, you will be chastised and looked down upon.” Krause’s book list includes topics on issues of race, sexuality and gender with titles such as “The Confessions of Nat Turner” by William Styron and “The Fight for LGBTQ+ Rights” by Devlin Smith. A January 2022 Vanguard Review poll indicat-

ed 58.5 percent of students either strongly disagree or somewhat disagree with banning the teaching of certain books in public schools - for content about slavery, race, religion and gender equality - while an overwhelming 80.4 percent believe the government should not be able to control what books students are able to read. “I don’t think the government should be allowed to ban teaching any books,” said senior Courtney Wiethorn. “It is important to learn about those topics in order to understand our world and respect other people. If the government bans books about our country’s past, we run the risk of repeating it, which would be catastrophic.” The fervor around the idea of book censorship is viewed by many students and teachers as wrong, as it attempts to erase a part of history and denies readers a chance to fully understand the issues that plague our society. AP English and European History teacher Jen Ferretter explained the importance of students engaging and learning history through literature. “Everyone knows that Antonio in “The Merchant of Venice” is horribly anti-Semitic and that Iago in “Othello” is racist,” Ferretter said. “But

Virtual reality

others. Great literature encourages us to be on guard against such behavior, she added. “I think Shakespeare has a very good understanding of anti-Semitism,” junior Avril Maldonado said. “People were still discriminating against Jews and hypocrisy was big.” Reading “Beloved’’ by Perched on her stool discussing Toni Morrison’s “Beloved,” English teacher Toni Morrison is deemed a Jen Ferretter expresses the significance of learning from the ghost of slavdefining characteristic of the ery’s past. Photo by Isaac Saadi / VR staff high school English curricubanning either play would be a travesty.” lum. The Virginia governor Knowing how anti-Semitic and racist the Re- race has brought discourse around the “Beloved” naissance was, allows students to better understand Bill (House Bill No. 516) which was introduced in how the Holocaust, slavery and imperialism came Virginia in 2016 to ban the book from the state’s to be,” Ferretter said. public school English curriculum. “Hitler didn’t invent anti-Semitism,” she said. Senior Bella Garzonie said “Beloved” has en“It had been encouraged for centuries. Hundreds to riched her high school experience. thousands of Jews were burned alive in Strasbourg “While Beloved is a tough book to read, I think in 1349 in response to the Black Death.” it has taught me about experiences that I would othShakespeare’s plays, Ferretter said, illustrate erwise have not known about,” she said. how people have always tried to boost their own Dana Williams, president of the Toni Morrison sense of self-worth by belittling and pulling down Society, explains the importance of reading “BeContinued on page 8

National stats show mental health impacts of pandemic on teens

More than 50 percent of VCPS students said that time spent in quarantine and virtual school over the last 18 months affected their mental health. Source: VR student poll, Jan. 2022

Landri Wheeler ‘24 reporter

W

hile COVID-19 has devastated families across the country, killing 861,000 to date, it is also killing something else: the spirit of many teens who have experienced fear, anxiety and isolation during what should be the most fun and carefree time of their lives. Though Vanguard was able to remain in-person the entire 2020-21 school year, many students across the country found themselves continuing to stay home and attend virtual school. During 2020, the proportion of mental health– related emergency department (ED) visits among adolescents aged 12–17 years increased 31 percent compared with that during 2019, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC). In May 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, ED visits for suspected suicide attempts began to increase among adolescents aged 12–17 years, especially girls. During February 21–March 20, 2021, suspected suicide attempt ED visits were 50.6 percent higher among girls aged 12–17 years than during the same period in 2019; among boys aged 12–17 years, suspected suicide attempt ED visits increased 3.7 percent, the CDC data showed. There were more than 47,000 mental health visits to emergency departments at 38 children’s hospitals around the country in the first three quarters of 2021 – nearly 40 percent higher than the same period in 2020, according to data from the Children’s Hospital Association.

Clinical psychologist Cassie Kendrick, Psy.D. of Waco Psychological Associates, said isolation most definitely affects the minds of teenagers. “It is well known that stress and isolation impact mental health,” Kendrick said. “The nature of adolescence creates particular vulnerability to mental health issues simply because of the myriad of physiological, social, and psychological changes happening during this important developmental time,” Kendrick said. “When teenagers face increasing stress and isolation, we naturally see an uptick in symptoms of depression, anxiety and other related issues, such as increased suicide risk.” Sixty-four percent of VCPS students have been quarantined or had to participate in the Viking FLEX program due to COVID or contact tracing, according to a Jan. 2022 VR poll. And just over 50 percent said that being in quarantine and virtual school ‘somewhat’ affected their mental health. Sophomore Juliet Indergard said that quarantine, in a way, affected her mental health. “It affected my mental health because of the inability to have social contact with my friends and it took a small toll on me,” Indergard said. Freshman Caroline Rice said that while in virtual school, it was a more lonely environment being without friends and family. “My experience with virtual [school] wasn’t necessarily bad, but I felt kind of lonely, locked up in my house,” Rice said.

Some of the long term effects from the pandemic can include depression and anxiety, Kendrick said. “Even before the pandemic, concern was growing regarding the seeming increase of social isolation within our culture due to the extraordinary impact that such isolation can have on not only mental, but physical health,” Kendrick said. “The effects of the pandemic have only heightened these concerns. Kendrick cited a 2020 review called “The Impact of Social Isolation and Loneliness on the Mental Health of Children and Adolescents in the Context of COVID-19,” published in the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, which examined factors such as isolation, loneliness and symptoms commonly associated with mental health issues in persons ranging in age from four to 21. The study found an association between loneliness and susceptibility to mental health symptoms, such as anxiety and depression and that the impact of loneliness upon mental health can persist for years. “That being said, a period of loneliness doesn’t doom anyone to a life fraught with depression and

anxiety,” she said. “What we do know, however, is that it is important for all of us, especially young people, to establish, reestablish and maintain normal social connections to the degree that is possible not just during or post the pandemic, but also for years to come.” Without a routine and a normal school environment, it can be hard to stay focused while at home

There were more than 47,000 mental health visit to emergency departments at 38 children’s hospitals in the first three quarters of 2021 — early 40 percent higher than the same period in 2020. — Children’s Hospital Association where you would usually relax after being at school all day. Almost 65 percent of students said that it is harder to focus and concentrate when they are out on the flex program or quarantined according to the Jan. ‘22 VR student poll. Rice said it was harder to find her motivation while at home. “It was a lot harder to actually find motivation to do my school work,” Rice said. “What was an hour’s worth of homework took me forever because I couldn’t focus at home.”

Continued on page 8


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Vanguard Review Feb. 2022 by Gretchen Eichenberg - Issuu