Issue 11, Volume 122
Thursday, January 24, 2013
Administration issues statement on domestic partner benefits Justin Joo Staff Writer Chancellors Jimmy Cheek and Larry Arrington have issued a new, official response regarding the provision of benefits to the homosexual and heterosexual domestic partners of UT, and the answer is still no. In a nutshell, Cheek and Arrington’s reasoning is that UT is a publicly funded state institution and therefore must comply with state law. Cheek and Arrington state this because UT’s various insurance plans are provided through the state group insurance plan, which is given through the State Insurance Committee. The provided insurance plan includes health, dental, vision, pharmacy, long-term care and life insurances, as well as access to the Employee Assistance Program. Their letter then says that, “Extending these benefits to a broader class of persons is not a viable option for the University because of Tennessee Code Annotated § 8-27-201(c) expressly provides that ‘the group insurance plan (approved by the State Insurance Committee) shall be the only such approved plan for state employees.’” In consideration of that code, the letter continues that UT “does not have authority to extend coverage provided by the state group insurance plan or to establish a separate insurance plan for University employees.” In regard to “the other benefits” — which may refer to bereavement leave, discounts to football tickets, and other benefits provided to spouses of UT faculty which Faculty Senate suggested in its original resolution — Cheek and Arrington’s letter alluded to Tennessee Code Annotated § 36-3-113, which states that marriage is a “relationship of one (1) man and one (1) woman.” Furthermore, they state that “Any policy or law or judicial interpretation, purporting to define marriage as anything other than the … legal contract between one (1) man and one (1) woman, is contrary to the public policy of
... Tennessee. “These statutory and constitutional provisions are the basis of our conclusion that the operative clauses of the Faculty Senate resolution are inconsistent with the public policy of Tennessee,” the statement continues. The letter also states that UT System President Joe DiPietro had been notified of the issue and that he, too, believed that “… UT is not in a position to pursue domestic partners at this time.” The response from those involved with Faculty Senate and the LGBT community has not been positive about this letter. Keith Kirkland, general manager at the Clarence Brown Theatre and chair for the Commission for LGBT People, was not pleased, nor did he agree with the chancellors’ reasoning. “Honestly I wasn’t surprised by the response,” Kirkland said. “My first reaction was ‘why did it take you so long to formulate this response when this is what I was expecting to see 75 days ago.’” Kirkland wrote, on behalf of the Commission for LGBT People, an open letter responding to Cheek and Arrington’s first letter. With this new one released Wednesday, Kirkland plans to write a second response of his own. Kirkland doesn’t believe that the provisions of the state statutes are enough to stop the university from at least trying to get some benefits. He argued that UT could go before the State Insurance Committee to ask for them to extend the benefits out to domestic partners. “That still gives the state board the ability to deny that, of course, but at least then the university would be listening to its employees and acting on their behalf and in their stead,” Kirkland said. Kirkland is not the only one upset about the letter. Donna Braquet, associate professor and coordinator at the LGBT OUTreach Center, was very disappointed. “Really, to tell you the truth, my heart just really sank when I was reading the letter,” Braquet said. “This is my employer, the orga-
Tia Patron • The Daily Beacon
Jimmy Cheek listens during an interview last summer. Cheek has recently released a response saying that UT will still not be able to give benefits to homosexual domestic partnerships. nization I work hard for everyday. And it felt like I was being told ‘you don’t matter, you’re not worth the risk and would you please go somewhere else.’” Braquet is also one of the researchers that worked on the original Faculty Senate resolution that Cheek and Arrington were responding to. She is also a leading figure with the Benefit Equality Campaign, which has coordinator meetings and events trying to push the discussion on getting benefits for domestic partners.
Now with a new response from the administration, Braquet is not sure what their next move will be, but the campaign will be meeting again at 6 p.m. on Jan. 31 in the OUTreach Center. Braquet said anyone can attend the meeting. The Chancellor’s Office did not have an immediate response regarding the letter or the subject of domestic partner benefits in general at the time of print. They plan to talk with The Daily Beacon in the near future.
Lecture focuses on legal discrimination Graham Gibson Staff Writer Highly acclaimed author, legal scholar and civil rights advocate Michelle Alexander gave a lecture in the Alumni Memorial Building’s Cox Auditorium on Tuesday. However, those who weren’t able to make it shouldn’t worry. The event concerning America’s social division, which filled up the auditorium, will be broadcasted nationally on C-Span in a few weeks. Alexander discussed the issues addressed in her bestselling new book, entitled “The New Jim Crow: Mass
Janie Prathamamvong • The Daily Beacon
Michelle Alexander speaks about new Jim Crow laws on Tuesday.
Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness,” including the war on drugs, racial prejudice through the judicial system, and decimation of AfricanAmerican communities during an age of supposed colorblindness and equality. The lecture primarily consisted of what Alexander considers as the relegation of many African-Americans to secondclass citizen status via mass incarceration, and describes caste-like social, judicial and economic structures that systematically discriminate against African-Americans, even during an age of supposed racial equality. She argued that, in the name of the war on drugs, AfricanAmericans have been targeted by police and incarcerated at astronomical rates, despite there being similar rates of drug use between AfricanAmericans and other races. She claimed this creates a cycle of crime and incarceration, damages AfricanAmerican communities and, by labeling them as felons, not only strips many AfricanAmericans of the certain rights, such as voting and serving on a jury, but also makes post-prison life more difficult in the form of legal discrimination against convicts in important areas of life, such as housing and employment. See LECTURE on Page 2
Tara Sripunvoraskul • The Daily Beacon
Chris Hedges autographs various books after a lecture on Tuesday.
Journalist discusses Middle Eastern conflicts Claire Dodson Copy Editor Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist and foreign correspondent Chris Hedges discussed his at times controversial views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict on Tuesday in the UC Auditorium. The talk, which was sponsored by UT’s Issues Committee, covered America’s role in this conflict as well as the atrocities that have been occurring in the Middle East because of it. “We have not brought freedom, democracy or other virtues of western civilization to the Muslim world,” Hedges
said. “We have filled its graveyards, leveled its villages, displaced its people and solidified systems of state terror. “And no one believes, except for perhaps us, that we have any intention of leaving,” he added. He emphasized the power America has in the international sphere, and that in supporting Israel, America creates problems and causes suffering in the Muslim world. He said that in some ways, the Israeli/ American alliance gives cause for extremists in the Middle East. “We and our Israeli allies are the biggest problem
Check out the Daily Beacon Weekender
INSIDE THE DAILY BEACON: Page Page Page Page Page
2 3 4 5 6
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . News .Arts & Culture . . . . Opinions . . . . . Sports . . . . . Sports
Page 3
in the Middle East. It is we who legitimize the Mahmoud Ahmadinejads, suicide bombers and radical jihadists,” Hedges said. “The longer we occupy Muslim land, the more these monsters, reflections of our own distorted image, will proliferate. As Nietzsche wrote, ‘If you gaze into the abyss, the abyss gazes into you.’” Hedges thinks the solution lies in taking troops out of the Middle East and focusing on more diplomatic problem solving. “The biggest favor we can do for the Muslim world is to withdraw troops and begin
to speak to the Muslim world in the civilized language of diplomacy, respect, and mutual interest,” Hedges said. Nationalism, according to Hedges, is a “disease” that cripples people’s instincts for compassion and justice. “This ideology does not require cultural, historical or linguistic literacy,” Hedges said. “It reduces the world to black and white, good and evil.” For Hedges, it is our responsibility to act and take on the suffering of other humans in order to improve life for everyone. See HEDGES on Page 2
The Daily Beacon is printed using soy based ink on newsprint containing recycled content, utilizing renewable sources and produced in a sustainable, environmental responsble manner.
utdailybeacon.com