USED CAR NEWS
NADA Study Shows Recall Laws Cost Consumers The National Automobile Dealers Association said a report that it commissioned from J.D. Power shows that many consumers could see the value of their vehicle trade-ins decline by an average of $1,210 – and by as much as $5,713 – if auto dealers were prohibited from selling any used vehicles with open recalls. The J.D. Power study, titled “An Economic Assessment of Trade-In Value Reduction Caused by Preventing Auto Dealers from Selling Passenger Vehicles with any Open Recall,” concluded that the enactment of legislation -- including the “Used Car Safety Recall Repair Act,” proposed by Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) – requiring auto dealers to fix all outstanding safety recalls before selling or leasing any used passenger motor vehicle could have an adverse impact on the value of those trade-ins. Each year, approximately 10 million vehicles are traded-in to franchised dealers, and in virtually all of these
03_UCN.indd 1
transactions, the trade-in manager at the dealership uses a combination of electronic analytic tools and physical inspections to decide how much of a “tradein allowance” to offer the consumer. This trade-in allowance is an important part of the overall transaction because, typically, the consumer uses it to fund the down payment needed to finance the purchase or lease. But if the dealer is restricted from reselling a recalled vehicle, either at retail or at wholesale, until that recall was remedied, J.D. Power identified a number of costs that would be incurred during the grounding period that could negatively impact the trade-in allowance offered. While there are additional factors to consider regarding reselling a recalled vehicle, J.D. Power’s analysis was related only to the additional expenses of: the cost of financing the vehicle purchased from the consumer, the cost of storing the ve-
TEXT CRIME: GM is recalling Chevrolet Silverado HD, Chevrolet Express, GMC Sierra HD vehicles and GMC Savana compressed natural gas vehicles because the CNG fuel-only label is smaller than the required size. Dealer groups say these types of recalls must be treated differently than safety recalls.
hicle, the cost of insuring the vehicle, and depreciation costs. Furthermore, while $1,210 represents the weighted average for both in-brand trade-ins (for illustration a Honda traded to a Honda dealer) and out-of-brand trade-ins (a Honda traded to a Ford dealer), the costs are higher for out-of-brand
trade-ins because out-ofbrand dealers incur additional costs when holding the vehicle during the repair delay and when transporting the vehicle to an in-brand dealer for repair, the report states. According to government and industry data collected for the study, repair delays will result from the chal-
lenges faced in engineering, producing, and distributing the replacement parts needed to address recalls. Also significant is the fact that dealers will not know in advance how long a recall delay will last, and thus must estimate the delay, which could further exacerbate the trade-in value reductions that consumers will face.
11/30/15 1:16 PM