IS HE OR ISN’T HE? FIND OUT IN MONDAY’S ISSUE. VOLUME 45, ISSUE 38
THURSDAY, MARCH 8, 2012
WWW.UCSDGUARDIAN.ORG
VOLUME 45, ISSUE 38
THURSDAY, MARCH 8, 2012
WWW.UCSDGUARDIAN.ORG
SPECIAL ELECTION
NO SANCTIONS FOR ALLCAMPUS EMAIL
THIS WEEK
Judicial Board dismisses grievances over alleged misinformation, improper campaigning in D-I election. By angela chen • Editor in Chief
T
he all-campus pro-referendum email sent by former A.S. President Utsav Gupta does not violate election guidelines, the Judicial Board ruled 4-0-2 on March 7. Although the Elections Committee unanimously agreed that misinformation presented in the email broke election bylaws — and thus forwarded the grievance for an official hearing before J-Board — the board dismissed the grievance on the grounds that there was no intent to mislead. A.S. Advocate General Courtney Hill, who chairs the Elections Committee, represented con campaign leader Kevin Quirolo in the hearing. Speaking on behalf of Quirolo (who filed the grievance), she stated that claims in Gupta’s Feb. 29 email were false. Gupta wrote that the move to D-I would lead to higher U.S. News & World Report rankings, which Hill said was not necessarily true, as News & World does not use sports funding as criteria for ranking. In addition, the email said that students on financial aid would not be affected by the $495 annual student fee increase, since 29 percent of the increase returns to scholarship. Hill said that a portion of financial aid consists of loans, which students will need to pay back. Hill clarified that the grievance did not address the method Gupta used to send the email; Gupta has stated that he did not use any official resources or access a campuswide listserv improperly, as was earlier alleged. Associate Vice President of Academic Affairs Mac Zilber represented Gupta, who is currently in Walnut Creek, Calif. Zilber first addressed procedural problems with the hearing that violated sections of the Election Code — for example, Gupta had not been notified of the grievance in a timely manner. In regard to the charges, Zilber stated that Section 7.2.3 of the Elections Code allowed for sanctions against providing misleading information only if the information was “intentionally and provably false.” He cited Gupta’s arguments in defense of his email, specifically that although News & World does not use sports funding as a criteria, there is a definite correlation between D-I athletics and the rankings. In addition, Gupta had interpreted “on financial aid” loosely, as the term could be used to indicate students who have a full ride to UCSD and may not be required to pay back additional loans. Gupta obviously believed in the validity of his arguments and his arguments were not intentionally false, Zilber argued. The Judicial Board ruled in favor of Gupta by dismissing
R obert A sami /G uardian
San Jose-based “skunge” band Monstrauss performed at Eleanor Roosevelt College’s annual Rock ‘n Roosevelt concert on Friday, March 2.
UC SYSTEM
Police Block Release of Davis Pepper Spray Report By Zev Hurwitz Associate News Editor A California judge temporarily blocked the planned March 6 release of a report about last year’s UC Davis pepper spray incident. The Federated University Police Officers Association OPINION The report filed a restrainshould be ing order March 5 released ASAP. against the report, PAGE 4 claiming that it named and incriminated several police officers who were involved in the incident. California Superior Court Judge Evelio Grillo ruled that the findings must be postponed in conjunction with California Penal Code sections 832.7 and 827.8, which bar release A lyssa S tocker -K eefe /G uardian
See GRiEVANCE, page 2
sSPOKEN
“
See REPORT, page 2
FORECAST
...Percussion is an extremely broad area that can allow a person to delve into many different areas, and the only thing that limits what you do is yourself.”
Thursday
STEPHEN SOLOOK
saturday
Musician
H 73 L 51
H 70 L 54
friday
H 77 L 53
sunday
H 59 L 53
NIGHT WATCH
thursday
saturday
friday
sunday
GAS PER GALLON
SURF REPORT thursday Height: 1-2 ft. Wind: 8-9 mph Water Temp: 60 F
friday Height: 1 ft. Wind: 10-14 mph Water Temp: 60 F
saturday Height: 1 ft. Wind: 2-11 mph Water Temp: 60 F
sunday Height: 1-2 ft. Wind: 3-10 mph Water Temp: 60 F
LOw
$4.17
Valero, San Diego - South 2029 La Media Rd HIGH
$4.89
76, Coronado 900 Orange Ave & 9th St.
INSIDE As Per Usual...........................2 New Business.........................3 Spin Cycle..............................4 Letter to the Editor.................5 Peanut Butter and Telly..........6 Sudoku...................................9 Sports...................................12