the
Boomerang a University College Student Association Magazine |September 2012
Remember, Remember, the Third of September Changing Dining Hall: reflections on the new system Robert van Schaik and Christian Bobocea
W
eek two of the academic year brought a major change in the core of UCU students’ daily routine: Dining Hall. Along with the change of the caterer came new food, new prices, new rules and brand new DH cards. Only the old staff remained almost unchanged and the new situation inevitably affected social life on campus. Sodexo – a French foodservice corporation with multinational clients including schools of all shapes and sizes, hospitals and military bases – has become the word on everyone’s lips.
The change in DH sparked controversy among students and protests ranging from facebook pages and multi-digit e-mails sent to the UCSA, the Dining Hall Advisory Group and College Hall staff, to a public petition, posters and fliers around campus. Interestingly, our case is not unique. Sodexo has a history of instigating students’ discontent as reported in student newspapers: “Students lose appetite for Sodexo dining” (Los Angeles Loyolan), “Students plan Sodexo Boycott” (The Depauw); “Kick-Out-Sodexo Coalition Joined By New Student Groups For Latest Sit-In” (The Daily of The University of Washington). But who bears the blame in our situation? Is it Sodexo, or maybe College Hall’s approach, or Utrecht University’s policy? Or better, is there a problem with the new system at all?
Costs
The prices of food in DH sparked angry discussions for the last two weeks. After the first day, prices were immediately adjusted downward, with a budget dinner option for 3.95 euro. For some, this seems to be reasonable; for others, it doesn’t make a big difference. “The quality of the food has definitely improved, but for students it is still expensive,” second semester student Shahzaib Momin said. It isn’t clear who sets the prices. “College Hall has no influence on prices because we buy directly from Sodexo,” Campus Life Forum Chair Valeria Boers Trillers said. But Dining Hall Manager Kees Jan van Spronsen says this is not the case: “It’s the UU that sets the prices. That’s why the prices could be lowered so easily within a day.” The decision to lower the prices after the first day was taken in conjunction between Sodexo and the UU, while “it could well be that other Sodexo locations maintain higher prices.” According to van Spronsen, strictly speaking, prices haven’t increased at all. “We still buy products for the same price as we used to under Eurest,” he said. Previously, however, the system worked with an all-inclusive policy, with College Hall paying for the staff costs and the operating funds. This is no longer the case under the new system, thus prices have risen. “There is a very close consultation between College Hall and Sodexo, who have been given
formal and informal feedback since starting, including issues over prices,” Student Life Officer Mark Baldwin said in an e-mail interview. Boers Trilles stressed that changes are possible, “but returning to the old system is not.” The paying-per-item system has been students’ most frequent preferred option in the Dining Hall improvement survey that went out last year, she added. There is a call among students to make Dining Hall optional. Students who wish to have meals in Dining Hall will continue to pay the 1,500 euros fee to College Hall, while those who do not wish to do so for various reasons will not pay and will find alternative dining options. The current policy only allows Dining Hall exemptions to students with specific health issues. “There might be students who find it morally repulsive to eat here because they do not agree with the history or policy of the com-
pany who offers the catering service, as an example,” second year Simon van Oort said. He thinks students should not be forced to pay the Dining Hall fee. “Have Dining Hall there, because we need it, leave it open for Saturday dinner as well, but make the 750 euro [per semester] optional.”
ASC’s Invisbility Cloak » PAGE 03 The Bubble
Social aspects
Along with the food and DH operation, consequently, campus social life is changed for good: less people are now eating in Dining Hall. Will relaxed, one-hour long dinners in a noisy, bubbling Dining Hall only be part the past? Simon van Oort thinks that “the purpose of Dining Hall was to be a place to meet your
» PAGE 06
“No words, please, Mr. Cook” » PAGE 04 The Bubble
Permit Problems » PAGE 06 Cover Story
Exchange Feature: Singapore » PAGE 08 Special Feature
How Dining Hall Made Me a Carnivore
» PAGE 09
Special Feature
City Gems: Utrecht » PAGE 10 Colosseum
Discovering the Dutch.. the Silver Screen
» PAGE 11 Colosseum