OPENING REMARKS AT THE THE 4th UCLG ASPAC CONGRESS 2012 “Resilient Cities: Rethink, Rebuild, Revitalize”
By: FAUZI BOWO Governor of Jakarta
JAKARTA CAPITAL CITY GOVERNMENT TUESDAY, 2 OCTOBER 2012 Pages: 5
1 Good morning, Yang Terhormat Menteri Dalam Negeri, Bapak Gamawan Fauzi, Dear participants of UCLG-ASPAC Congress; Dear Ladies and Gentlemen, Mayors and Governors of the Asia Pacific region, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to Jakarta for this 4th United Cities and Local Governments Asia Pacific congress. The theme of the 4th UCLG Congress is â&#x20AC;&#x153;Resilient Cities: Rethink, Rebuild, Revitalizeâ&#x20AC;? summarizes the challenges cities have in the Asia Pacific region in order that prosperity is achieved, a central ingredient for peace in this region. In order that our cities become resilient, we must be able to survive future challenges and in some cases these challenges will be extreme. Therefore, our cities must continually rethink about how to survive, and how to rebuild decaying parts of our cities which can easily become dead areas within the city weighing down on development. Finally a crucial part in ensuring
2 our cities are resilient is to have the capacity and tenacity within our cities to be able to revitalize in a sustainable manner and innovation plays an important role in this. There is no other region in the world like this region. As we are all aware, the UCLG in the Asia Pacific region is the biggest of the eight sections in the UCLG, with linkages to more than 7000 local government and representing 3.7 billion people. That is half of the worldâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s population. This region is home to great diversity, whether it be economic, religious or cultural. One indicator is reflected by the fact the variation in per capita disposable income in the region. In 2011 this ranged from US$34.739 in Japan, to US$ 8500 in China and US$ 3700 in India. Another point of diversity is the fact that some parts of the region are highly industrialized while others remain very much rural. One factor which has been a pressure point in the region is the pace of urbanization, which is unparalleled by any other area in the world. Eleven of the worlds Mega city with a population of more than 10 million are located in this region. In the
3 last two decades the Asia-Pacific urban proportion has risen by 29%, this rate of urbanization is more than any other region in the world. This urbanization has resulted in growth, but as the UN Economic and Social Commission noted, this has also driven up poverty within cities. The Asian Development Bank notes that two third of the worldâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s poor live in this region. One other crucial factor about this region according to the United Nations is the fact that this region is home to 45% of the worldâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s youth which amounts to approximately 700 million young people. If managed properly these youths can be an important engine in future economic growth in the region. The challenge this region faces includes managing climate change, the increasing urbanization, and reducing poverty just to mention a few. For these reasons and many others, the Asia Pacific region has no choice except to become home to resilient cities. Certainly urban planning and building design plays an important role in facilitating the development of a greater capacity for future resilience but there is more than this.
4 Two of the crucial and basic ingredients in building resilient cities are already present in this region that is economic growth and a large young population. These two factors are interrelated and special attention must be given to youths with a focus on education and employment creation. The challenge is how to harness these advantages in order that cities are able to sustain economic growth and distribute this growth so that prosperity is experienced by all. However, there are two crucial pillars to building strong cities. Preparing and developing infrastructure to be able to cope with the speed of growth our cities are experiencing. Equally important is also preparing the people that live in these cities to be resilient and able to embrace the changes needed to complement the urban planning. As the classical Greek Philosopher Plato said â&#x20AC;&#x153;This city is what it is because our citizens are what they areâ&#x20AC;?. City administrations and governments make policies and manage cities but in the end its the people who really make and shape the cities they live in.
5 Strong cities can only be established and be sustained if there is good governance in the way they are managed. The foundation of a strong city is a robust and participative community, with a good flow of communications between its mayor and its people in its day to day running and future development of the city. Strong cities are democratic cities this includes democratic elections. On this note allow me before finishing this speech to bid farewell to all you as beginning on the 7th October Jakarta will have a new governor as determined by a democratic election which took place on the 20th September. It has been indeed a great honor and also a great pleasure for me to be the 4th President of the United Cities and Local Governments Asia Pacific. I take with me valuable experiences which I could not gave gained anywhere else. I thank you all for the exchanges and also the friendships. Ladies and Gentlemen, it is my conviction that this region is the region of the future. I wish you all luck in the journey of creating strong resilient cities in order that prosperity is achieved. Thank you
CLOSING REMARKS AT UCLG ASPAC CONGRESS 2012
By: Fauzi Bowo Governor of Jakarta
JAKARTA CAPITAL CITY GOVERNMENT THURSDAY, 4 OCTOBER 2012 YHM : 4 Hlm
1 Good evening, - Cr. Chen Haosu, Founding President CoPresident for International Relations and Networking - Mr. Peter Woods, Co President of UCLG ASPAC; - Mr. Rudolf Hauter, Secretary General of UCLG ASPAC: - Distinguished Participants of UCLG ASPAC Congress. It is my great pleasure to be here among all of you who has just completed meeting and discussion much intensively during three days. The actual issues relating to the theme â&#x20AC;&#x153;rethink, rebuild and revitalizeâ&#x20AC;? has been fully encouraging us based on our responsibility toward a better and prosperous city. The ideas and thoughts of the participants have been emerged and shared, I firmly believe it could enrich insights and develop capability of the participants on overcoming urban development problems based on its own characteristic.
2 On behalf of the Jakarta Capital City Government and President of UCLG ASPAC, I truly extend my sincere thanks and appreciation to the distinguished participants have provided fruitful results and also commitments made among participants for a sustain and future of our organization. I would also congratulate to the Executive Bureau Meeting took smoothly and democratically and I am sure that all inputs and critics from the floor accommodated by the Executive Bureau Meeting and very convincingly will follow up in the next meeting of the UCLGASPAC in making the efforts of providing innovative solution and alternatives for a better and esteemed city. Concluded the results achieved from the Meeting, I would congratulate Dr. Jatin V. Modi as the elected President of UCLG ASPAC 20122013 and Mr. Syed Muhammad Asghar Shah Gillani as the elected President of UCLG ASPAC 2013-2014. Additionally, I would congratulate Gwangju City, Korea to host the
3 next Executive Bureau Meeting in May 2013 and Taipei City as host of the 5th UCLG ASPAC Congress in 2014. Distinguished participants, Tonight is our time to share a happiness and joyful among us and I hope through our farewell dinner will strengthen the ties of our friendship and expand our international networking. Again I personally would like to thanks the distinguished participants for consuming energy and sharing thoughts and your active participation is really appreciated. And I do believe that the results of congress as our further reference and feedback to a betterment. Before closing my remarks, Iâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;d like to recommend you to spare your time for sightseeing around Jakarta. I hope during your stay in Jakarta will bring impressive and memorable things that you might one day come to Jakarta again for holiday.
4 Please enjoy the refreshment on dinner and entertainment. Thank you and see u.
WELCOME DINNER AT THE THE 4th UCLG ASPAC CONGRESS 2012 “Resilient Cities: Rethink, Rebuild, Revitalize”
By: FAUZI BOWO Governor of Jakarta
JAKARTA CAPITAL CITY GOVERNMENT TUESDAY, 2 OCTOBER 2012 Pages: 4
1 Mayors, Governors, Ladies and Gentlemen, welcome tonight to Fatahillah Museum. Today two very important sessions have been conducted. One, concerning the readiness of cities to change in order to anticipate the future, focused on the willingness of people themselves to change. The other was on infrastructure, innovations, and the building of roads for the future. Tonight, however, I will not be speaking about Resilient Cities of the future. Instead, for just a few brief moments, allow me to talk about a Resilient City of the Past, that is, Batavia, which is now called Jakarta. We are tonight having dinner in the Old Town of Jakarta, the location where the city of Jakarta was first established. This building in which we are having dinner is where the former City Hall was situated. Before becoming the City Hall, this building was originally called the Stadhuis, and was the administrative headquarters of the Dutch East India Company and the Dutch trading company, and later the office of the Dutch Government. The building was constructed in 1710 by Governor General van Riebeeck. It is located in front of a
2 public square, which in the past was known as Stadhuisplein or the City Hall Square. Many of you would have walked across this square in order to get to the building where we are having dinner tonight. This building has been a witness to some of the most important parts of Indonesian history. As they say, if only these walls could talk and tell what they have seen, we would probably be hearing a fascinating part of Indonesiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s story. For example, the building, which is underneath the building where we are having dinner, was a famous prison. Any Indonesians, and for that matter Dutch people, who rebelled against Dutch colonial rule, were imprisoned here. One very famous historical figure was the Indonesian freedom fighter Prince Diponegoro, who was arrested in Central Java and imprisoned here in 1830, before being banished to Manado in North Sulawesi. Despite this role, the place was also an important source of life not only because the port of Sunda Kelapa, which was the center of trade for Batavia and the surrounding areas, was just a stoneâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s throw away but because in the center of the
3 square, just in front of this building, there was a fountain, which served as the water supply for the colonial capital, Batavia. This place was the center of life for Old Jakarta for hundreds of years. Today this building is a museum. It has been temporarily closed since July 2011 for conservation work to be carried out on the badly damaged complex but it is expected to reopen in 2014. Jakarta or Batavia, as the city was first referred to in historical records in the 4th century, was originally a Hindu settlement and a port. Ever since, the city has been variously claimed by the Indianized kingdom of Tarumanegara, the Hindu Kingdom of Sunda, the Muslim Sultanate of Banten, the Dutch East Indies government, the Empire of Japan, and finally Indonesia. Today Jakarta is 485 years old. The fact that this place is still functioning as a city is proof that Jakarta is a resilient city and that somehow, during its journey of hundreds of years, it has managed to â&#x20AC;&#x153;Rethink, rebuild and revitalizeâ&#x20AC;?.
4 I often ask myself what has enabled this city to survive for so long, while in the process managing to adapt to major cultural and political changes and to flourish? In my humble opinion itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s the people who have lived here. Not just the people of Batavia but the different people from different parts of Indonesia who have come here and made this place what it is today, creating here one of the richest centers of culture in the country. In fact, I could almost say that Jakarta has been â&#x20AC;&#x153;Little Indonesiaâ&#x20AC;? for hundreds of years. Thank you. Please enjoy your dinner tonight.
WELCOME ADDRESS AT DINNER FUNCTION IN HONOUR OF THE PARTICIPANTS OF UNITED CITIES AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT (UCLG) WORLD CONGRESS
By : Fauzi Bowo Governor of Jakarta
JAKARTA CAPITAL CITY GOVERNMENT TUESDAY, 2 OCTOBER 2012 ANITA BOJE/YHM/SHB/HRY/ : Pages: 6
1 Good evening, Distinguished Delegates from the Asia Pacific Region, Ladies and Gentlemen, I would like to welcome you very warmly to the City Hall of the Jakarta Capital City of Jakarta. The room we gathered here tonight is called “Balai Agung”. In the Indonesian tradition, the name indicates a place where within a community very important things taking place – celebrations, inaugurations and significant announcements. So, this is the heart of the Jakarta Capital City Government. And I am very happy to be your host and celebrate here with you tonight in “Balai Agung” the 4th UCLG ASPAC Congress. Ladies and Gentlemen, The first day of our congress is nearly over. Today we have shared our experiences and ideas how to improve the resilience of our cities and municipalities – in terms of good and adaptive local governance and in terms of a modern and
2 innovative infrastructure, which unpredictable into consideration.
We, as city leaders or as persons in charge for urban development and welfare – we already know how demanding our job already is when things are normal and everything is working relatively smoothly in our cities. But when things getting rough, when turbulences shaking up our usual routines, when natural or man-made disasters threaten the lives and the wellbeing of the people, then we have to ask ourselves if our city is really ready to cope with it. Ladies and Gentlemen, As the overall theme of this Congress indicates, it is all about “Re-Think, Re-Build and “Re-Vitalize” to get ready for tomorrow, especially considering the challenge of global warming. As you may know, Jakarta, as many other member cities of UCLG-ASPAC, face basic bread and butter problems: housing, transportation, flooding, waste disposal, the provision of energy and adequate drinking water.
3 These problems derive mostly from an increasing migration into our cities, where people are looking for jobs and prospects for a better life for themselves and their children. In case of Jakarta, the excessive land-use in the past is now a severe obstacle and constraint for making the city fit for the future. Given Jakartaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s geographical condition as a low-lying region, our city is very vulnerable to climate change. Based on Economy and Environment Program for Southeast Asia (EEPSEA) study, Jakarta is indicated as the most prone area towards climate change impact in South East Asia. In February 2007, Jakarta was hit by one of the worst flood ever experienced, covering 70% of metropolitan area. This disaster claimed human lives and caused enormous financial damages. The increasing of global temperature has caused climate change and variability, such as the changes of rainfall intensity as well as extreme whether. And the Sea level rise makes Jakarta prone to the activity of extreme weather such as floods and has a substantial impact on the city.
4 We are undertaking a series of adaption methods to prevent and control flooding and seawater infusion leading to subsidence. One of the major developments of flood control system in Jakarta is the development of East Flood Canal that has already flown to the sea at the end of 2009. The east flood canal has reduced the flood risk in Jakarta as much as 30%. The development of East Flood Canal is not only aimed to control the flood in Jakarta, but also to act as an economic prime mover at the northern and eastern part of Jakarta. It is supposed to be an integrated infrastructure development between Green Infrastructure and Water Front Development and will function as flood control, water conservation and not least as a green open space corridor. Ladies and Gentlemen, Sometimes it is necessary to make bold steps to shape a cities future, e.g. by big infrastructure projects like the East Flood Canal and the Green Infrastructure around it. This is an urgently needed adaptation measure to prevent disastrous
5 flooding in the East and North of Jakarta. We aim to make virtue out of necessity and seize the opportunity to create a green belt around this canal for the benefit of both economy and ecology in Jakarta. However to achieve real sustainability and resilience, we have to promote more than ever local control and to utilize local resources. By this, it is also possible to change peopleâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s mindsets. People should realize that initiatives for resilience donâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t just aim at a better life in an unknown future but are going to improve the quality of life of the people now. To work on the city of tomorrow pays off today. Ladies and Gentlemen, I am very glad that UCLG ASPAC has competent partner organisations that have enormous expertise in the field of urban sustainable development and resilience. Various organisations also supported us a great deal to organize this Congress. I would like to thank the UN International Strategy for Disaster Reduction UNISDR, the Cities Development Initiative for Asia CDIA, the
6 WORLDBANK Jakarta, ICLEI, and the Cultural Development Network, Australia, for their outstanding support and commitment to this Congress. Tomorrow, these partners will facilitate Breakout Sessions and discuss in depth ideas and strategies with you, Ladies and Gentlemen, how we can make our cities ready. I wish all of us fruitful and interesting discussions. Ladies and Gentlemen, But this is the schedule for tomorrow. Now is time for celebrating, enjoying good food and pleasant company and having a good time here in â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Balai Agungâ&#x20AC;?. Enjoy this first evening of the 4th UCLG ASPAC Congress in Jakarta and enjoy your whole stay. It is a great pleasure to have you as our guest. Thank you!
Abstract for the Keynote Speech (by Dong-Shin Moon, Mayor of Gunsan, Republic of Korea) th
The main theme of "Resilient Cities: Rethink, Rebuilt, Revitalize" for the 4 Congress in Jakarta, Indonesia is very significant. Local governments of today are no longer able to exist independently from the international community, as we have entered into an era of an ever-growing need for inter-municipal cooperation with the advent of global climate problems and trade issues affecting local governments. The environment in which we live today has changed significantly, and it is continuously evolving at a tremendous speed, affected by multiple complex variables which no local government has experienced before. Problems arising from urbanization, multi-culturalism, sprawl, and other forms of natural environment pollution will become the subjects which will be resolved through the lens of "Resilience." Counter-Punch: Solution to Change is to Change It is important to absorb shocks with flexibility, but at the same time we should go one step further and utilize situations as opportunities for greater advancements. This is analogous to the effects of a "counter-punch" in boxing. Rather than limiting oneself to the defensive posture, we should introduce new policies or make necessary amendments to the existing system and framework in response to the changes to guarantee unprecedented rippling effects. Therefore, in order to maximize these effects, you must be aggressive but also bold, requiring you to think outside the box. External changes and stresses can be successfully managed by employing a necessary corresponding force. A proactive response, in other words, requires determination and endeavors to renovate the existing structure against the surrounding developments which can then become the stimulus to acquire the needed resilience against the evolving global community. Unity, Key for Development; Diversity, Key for Resilience Since resilience is a fundamental element required for future urban development, and unity cannot be completely discredited by municipal governments, it is critical that we find a workable balance between these seemingly contradicting principles. In order to successfully address and overcome the inherent problems embedded in diversity, I propose the introduction and operation of regular and effective communication channel. The establishment of a responsible organizational body will be able to provide long-term, workable solutions to current existing problems. Rather than simply registering civil complaints and providing temporary solutions, the introduction of a comprehensive system reflecting different opinions in extracting a socially agreed upon consensus is required to overcome the inherent characteristics of diversity in the absence of unity. Urban Design: Case Study - Gunsan Modern Historical Landscape Project Gunsan, as the center of the Saemangeum Project, the largest land reclamation project in Korea is renowned as a future city. However, at the same time, Gunsan is a city of history of 1,000 years and modern culture. The Modern Historical Landscape Project, in short, is to add new life to the modern architectural buildings by st adding the color of the 21 century. The fundamental design principles governing this project are "Completeness of Community" and "Spirit of Revitalizationâ&#x20AC;? (utilizing local resources). The project aims at installing various facilities to minimize the distance human movement and maximizing the utility of existing resources in our efforts to create new added values, engaging in aggressive and active transformation of the urban infrastructure, thus expecting to revitalize the slow inner urban communities. In conclusion, I would like to introduce "Self-Innovation" as the key word in securing the necessary resilience needed to successfully adapt to the changing global community. The definition of the word "resilience" itself has a resilient character which can be applied to many different situations. Therefore, we must also respect the definitional characteristics of the word and exercise a spirit of activeness and flexibility in our endeavors.
ELECTED COUNCIL AND EXECUTIVE BUREAU FOR 2012 - 2014
EAST & NORTHEAST ASIA 1 Governor Association of Korea (GAOK) (Executive Bureau) 2 City of Hamamatsu (Executive Bureau) 3 Beijing City (Executive Bureau) 4 Taipei City (Executive Bureau) 5 Gunsan City (Executive Bureau) 6 Guangzhou City 7 Haikou City 8 Shanghai City 9 Dalian City 10 Harbin City 11 New Taipei City 12 Taichung City 13 Jeju Special Self Governing Province 14 Seoul Metropolitan Government 15 Gumi City 16 Changwon City 17 Gangwon Province 18 Gyeonggi Province 19 Korean City Federation 20 Shenzhen City 21 Xi'an City 22 Chengdu City 23 Fuzhuo City 24 Kunming City
Co-President: Song, Young-Gil (Incheon Metropolitan City)
Co-President: Chen Haosu, Founding President (CPAFFC) Designated representative to the Council and Executive Bureau: Council of Local Authorities for International Relations (CLAIR)
PACIFIC 1 Local Government New Zealand (Executive Bureau) 2 Ministry of Internal & Social Affairs of Kiribati (Executive Bureau) 3 Ministry of Provincial Government & Institutional Strengthening
Co-President: Cr. Felicity-ann Lewis (Australian Local Government Association)
SOUTHEAST ASIA 1 Association of Indonesian Municipalities (APEKSI) (Executive Bureau) 2 Association of Cities of Vietnam (Executive Bureau) 3 Municipal League of Thailand (Executive Bureau) 4 Wakatobi Regency (Executive Bureau) 5 Association of Indonesian Municipal Councils (ADEKSI) 6 League of Cities of the Philippines (LCP) 7 National League of Commune/Sangkat of Cambodia 8 City fo Makati 9 City of Probolinggo 10 City of Cimahi
Immediate Past President : Dr. Fauzi Bowo Co President (Host): Gov. Joko Widodo (Jakarta Capital City Government)
SOUTH & SOUTHWEST ASIA 1 Municipal Association of Nepal (MuAN) (Executive Bureau) 2 Federation of Sri Lanka LG Association (Executive Bureau) 3 Local Council Association of the Punjab Pakistan (Executive Bureau) 4 Municipal Association of Bangladesh (MAB) (Executive Bureau) 5 National Association of Village Dev. Committees in Nepal (NAVIN)
6 Local Council Association of Khyber Paktunkhwa 7 Bangladesh Union of Parishad Forum 8 City of Kathmandu
Presidents: Dr. Jatin V. Modi; Syed Muhammad Asghar Shah Gillani Co-President: Krishna Prasad Jaishi (ADDCN)
Achieve a Safe & Happy Life by building a Resilient City Mr. Chen Mingquan Vice Secrectary General of Wuhan Political Consultative Committee, Hubei Province, P.R.China 2012.10.02, Jakarta Dear friends, ladies & gentlemen, Good Afternoon. I come from Wuhan, China. Later I will give a few words of my city. First of all, I’d like to express our sincere appreciation to Jakarta municipality for hosting the grand event of UCLG ASPEC 4TH Congress. It is a great honor and a great pleasure for me as well to have the opportunity today to give a speech here in Jakarta on the topic of resilient cities. We’ve got to know the definition of resilience highlights the capacity or the ability of a city to absorb shocks and stresses, survive and retain vitality in front of disturbance. It is the fact that cities grow more and more civilized, but seems weaker than before in recovery from both natural disaster and man-made shocks and stress. Facing all kinds of risks increasingly in this time, how to enhance the resilience of a city and how to build such a city has been a common challenge of top concern around the world. With a population over 10 million people, Wuhan is a megalopolis in central China. It is the capital city of Hubei Province, abundant in water resources with hundreds of lakes and a big river. Yangtze River, the world’s third longest river and its largest tributary Han River meet in Wuhan. Wuhan is situated at the confluence of the Yangtze River and the Han River and the two big rivers cut the city into three parts of Hankou, Hanyang and Wuchang, namely Three Towns of Wuhan which are standing like the three feet of a tripod by the two rivers. It has been renowned as a cultural city with a long-standing history dating back to 3500 years ago. Next, I’d like to give a brief introduction of the methods adopted by our city on
resilience-building and our thinking for the future. Since the beginning of this century, Wuhan Municipality put resilient construction of the city with public safety as a key on top agenda. We paid efforts and got good results. Basic methods of building a resilient city A
Organizations in charge of public safety administration grow increasingly
strong The city government set up an emergency committee exclusively in charge of unexpected public events, and over 10 such committees of special sectors of construction, transportation, public safety, water affairs, higene, agriculture, earthquake, environmental protection, safe production monitoring, grain, food safety and medicine safety etc. Emergency committees are also established in district level, in charge of ordinary incidents. In general, an organization system of emergency management takes shape with 3 levels of municipality, special sector authorities, and district government, and It works under the principal of unified leadership, comprehensive coordination, hierarchical responsibility, and priority of localized management. B
Exposure rating and early warning system under construction step by step
The city government pays great attention to the construction of basic emergency data base, and communication information system of emergency commanding. In the year of 2008, the municipality launched Trial Regulation of Methods on Precaution of Emergency Events and Information Release & Dissemination, established unified platform of information release for early natural disaster, and has released meteorological disaster information in time to citizens. Especially, five fundamental data base of rules and regulations, precaution plan, experts, teams and materials supply for early warning have been established. And since the beginning of 2009, exposure rating system of social stability was established for heavy accidents. C
Formulation of emergency preplan more standardized, and exercise regularized
Emergency preplan system was established with integrated structure, all functions, rapid reaction and high efficiency, which is most important for early warning. Fifteen
specialized preplan has been worked out involving production accidents, road traffic accidents, public health accidents, food safety and medicine safety etc., with over 500 sub-preplan. Therefore overall preplan system has taken shape. On the other hand, regularized exercise raised the capability of people and different departments, and made those preplans increasingly perfect. D
Collection and release of information of public safety administration sound and
effective Networks and teams of public safety information are enhanced, as well as information collection, disposal and analysis, early warning, report and dissemination, cooperation with news media. By real-time press briefing, rumors clarified and stopped, panic eliminated. E
Construction of refuge for public safety has achieved a good result
Refuge construction is the most important method to guarantee life safety of citizens at crisis. It is the top concern of the municipality. By far, there are 386 refuges for emergency use in the whole city, 37 of which are municipal level, 349 are district level. 7 municipal level over ground cover an area of 600,000 sq. meters, which can accommodate 436.000 people at the same time, more than 30 underground mainly for air attack. Meditation on resilient construction of the city of Wuhan for the next step In the process of rapid urbanization, enlargement of the size of city, problems and shortages also emerge in terms of resilience. For the future improvement, we would like to pay more efforts as below: A
Enhance the education and training in terms of public safety
Awareness of public safety crisis is of great help in reducing occurrence of possible crisis, as well as reducing the loss and disorder generated by crisis or emergency. Later in the future, education of such subject will be taken into schools. Promotion, skill training and exercise will be strengthened among citizens to improve their ability for anti-crisis. B
Enhance the planning and assessment of urban public safety
Construction of early warning and monitoring system is priority in prevention and
elimination of risk and crisis. Analysis and study of risk is necessary for a city, by which we should make reasonable special planning and timing of human activities. The support of science of high technology should be largely used in the research and study in this sector, such as remote sensing, topography, geographical exploration, meteorological study, etc. Then the forecast of all information of possible crisis and emergency can offer conductive reference for both the citizens and the government. C
Reinforce the construction of emergency administration system
Prevention is more important than treatment. Preplan plays a role of planning and guiding in anti-crisis, turning people from unprepared to fully prepared. So the preplan system should be more feasible and easily operated, and promoted to community level, to rural area, to all kinds of organizations and units of a city. With regards to improving the precaution, we can try to establish anti-crisis fund, insurance of responsibility and super-serious disaster, and promote charity development, to form strong financial support backup. In terms of material preparation, reserve of all kinds of material, communication equipments, life utensils should be adequate. Meanwhile, special teams should be trained effectively and constantly to raise the ability of cooperation. D Intensify the information sharing system, improving sound communication among government, news media and citizens We have embraced a time of information. The government should guide the medias to interfere in emergency events under the principal of â&#x20AC;&#x153;just, fair and openâ&#x20AC;?. Social power should be motivated in crisis treatment. Meanwhile, monitoring of news release should be paid high attention. Especially we should be prudent in the release of information regarding public safety. In addition, the government should enhance exchange and cooperation with citizens, especially NGOs, give them a full play in anti-crisis. In general, on the occasion of crisis, the government should make people more confident, and the people should give more faith to the government, news media should play a good bridge between the two. If so, a sound communication will be generated among the three parties to achieve a good treatment of crisis and a rapid recovery from crisis.
Last but not least, Iâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;d like to take this opportunity to invite you to visit our city and exchange with us in this sector and others as well, to know each other, to understand each other, to learn from each other, and to find chances of cooperation. Thatâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s all for my speech today. Thank you for your patience.
A Presentation at the Fourth Congress of the United Cities and Local Governments â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Asia Pacific Jakarta 2 October 2012
Partnership for Governance Reform
1. Introduction 2. Why local governments and communities? 3. Current challenges faced by cities in the Asia-Pacific region â&#x20AC;&#x201C; and the need to rethink about the way we plan and manage cities 4. The need for cities to be resilient 5. The need for most/many local governments to be reformed 6. A few case studies 7. Conclusions and recommendations www.
This presentation uses the broader definition of ”, which refers to the capacity or ability of a “ system to absorb shocks and stresses [conference TOR] A is one that has developed capacity to help absorb future shocks and stresses to its social, economic and technical systems and infrastructures so as to still be able to maintain essentially the same functions, structures, systems and identity [www.resilientcity.org as quoted in the conference TOR]
refers to changes or improvement for better conditions or corrections of “wrong” practices. is fundamental changes at the local level that can be internally initiated or/and externally induced/supported www.
! Local governments and communities are the ones who will first deal directly any possible disaster Local governments and communities are the ones who most likely posses " and " that are often fitting to the local situations regarding hazards As most initiatives require local actions, they are also most-likely more successful when they are supported by " and $ www.
! But local governments and communities cannot work alone They need support from the national government and actors as well as from the relevant international communities However many initiatives are not sustainable and too project-oriented... To create more sustainable resilience initiatives, we need the right approach(es) as well as multistakeholder supports www.
Hyogo Framework for Action 2005 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2015 and its national/local adaptation National regulations and institutionalization (In the case of Indonesia: Law 24/2007 and establishment of BNPB) and local implementation Supports (expertise, funds, networks, etc) from donors such as UNDP, UNISDR, bilateral donors, relevant international NGOs â&#x20AC;&#x201C; most of them are in collaboration with national/local governments and organizations University networks Some local-based intiatives www.
& - )
But the â&#x20AC;&#x153;homeworksâ&#x20AC;? are still huge Many other local areas and communities are not yet covered or adopting the preparedness measures The ones that already have strategies or action plans on paper have not put them into practice
( + /(
/ ! .
Asia-Pacific “region” is one of the most “region” in the world: in terms of culture, geography, socio-economic development and many other aspects of life One thing in common: the region is 3 – with more and more people living in urban areas (of which, many are densely populated) Cities have been the drivers of the
Many countries are 3 their governance, transfering more government functions and responsibilities to local governments Some countries are experiencing 3 , where civil society has more says in the public processes www.
With all of the above transformations going on in the regions, local governments and communities are facing some other challenges The region is also part of the “Ring of Fire” and $ 3 : earthquakes, tsunamis, various volcanic explosions, typhoons and others.
But is also $
to semi-natural and 2 or human-made hazards: floods, deseaseoutbreak, urban fire, forest fire, violent civil conflicts, etc. The human-made hazards can be expanded to cover “things” that are gradual (not-sudden), in front of us on dailiy basis, but potentially creating disasters lifestyles, deforestations, reckless use of ground water, etc. www.
2 aspects: some cities are built in naturally but hazard-prone areas such as in lowlying river delta or mountainous steep slopes 2 $ : some people are either unaware or fatalistic toward potential disasters. $ has generally been diminishing in bigger cities 8 2 $ : local governments (and 2 $$ and unable communities) are generally to maximize local economic potentials wisely 2 9 $ is often short-term, populist yet www.
: politics oriented 67
Because the challenges are multi-dimensional, the reforms needed tend to also be multi-layered At the $ : instilling community awareness and pressuring for political will â&#x20AC;&#x201C; persuading local leadership that it is important to â&#x20AC;&#x153;be preparedâ&#x20AC;?... At the : developing supportive policies, strategies and regulations, matched by adequate budgets At the $ : conducting preparedness training and drills; cross-learning with others Without this multi-layered approach, the initiative will not be sustainable www.
/ ( "!
One way of national government engages cities to pursue resiliency
External contexts, actors and factors
Internal contexts, actors and factors www.
/ ( "!
One way of national government engages LGs for sustainable urban resiliency National government provide technical and financial assistance to LGs with limited capacities
“Graduated” LGs “Graduated” LGs “Graduated” LGs
National government provides incentives & disincentives for capable LGs Period-3
Similar principle of increasing local participation should also be applied to any other externally-induced initiatives www.
Local governments and local communities play crucial role in making cities resilient Yet, there are a number of challenges in engaging LGs to adopt and implement the necessary measures The challenges are of various levels There are particular ways in approaching LGs, which potentially help ensure more sustained implementation of the principles www.
e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org e-mail: email@example.com blog: http://wicaksarosa.blogspot.com
Future Challenges • Increase of population and migration to urban areas • Depletion of stock of non-renewable natural resources • Degradation of upper catchment areas resulting in flood and freshwater shortage
Policy to meet the challenges • Efficiency of the use of non renewable resources • Intensification of the use of renewable resources • Optimization of the use of land in accordance with its carrying capacity • Sustainable growth with equity to the people Sustainable development with green growth as a tool
Strategy to meet the challenges • Green growth (GG) is not a goal but merely a tool to sustainable development • Sustainable development is the ultimate objective of implementing GG • Implementation of GG should be directed towards the achievement of sustainable economic growth with equity – Green Economy • Strategic Environment Assessment (SEA) as a main tool for spatial planning (Act. No. 32 Year 2009, Article 15)
ELEMENT OF GREEN ECONOMY • Low Carbon • Resource efficiency • Socially Inclusive (UNEP, 2011)
GREEN ECONOMY IN PRACTICES - PRIVATE Initiated by private sector •
SUSTAINABLE MINING PT Medco E&P Indonesia (Oil and gas) The Intensive Planting Program, PT Medco E&P Indonesia Kampar Block replants twice as many trees as the cleared land. Up to 2011, the company has planted 137 trees that absorb carbon dioxide. PT Medco E&P Indonesia Kampar Block also recycles organic waste and turns them into compost. Local people are involved in this program, which can recycle an average of 200 kilograms of waste per month, half of which is turned into compost. RE – LC - SI
Source:Overview Indonesia’s Sustainable Development
GREEN ECONOMY IN PRACTICES - PRIVATE Initiated by private sector â&#x20AC;˘
SUSTAINABLE INDUSTRY PT. HOLCIM Indonesia (Cement) For ex-mining site conservation, PT Holcim Indonesia-Cilacap Factory conducted reclamation activity in Nusakambangan site area by planting 8,670 native trees in the 22.8 hectare area (or 20.2% of the total operational site) in 2010. The company also planted hard-wood trees in 29.1 hectare of site in Jeruklegi, or approximately 28.1% of the total operational site. The reclamation activities reached almost 100%. LC Source:Overview Indonesiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Sustainable Development
GREEN ECONOMY IN PRACTICES - GOVERNMENT Initiated by Government â&#x20AC;˘
SUSTAINABLE CITIES Green Building and Low Carbon Development Implementation of Green Building practices is a component to support low carbon development through policies and programs on increasing energy and water efficiency using environment-friendly construction materials, and using lowcarbon technology. The government also encourages all stakeholders to participate in tackling climate change issue in the building construction sector through the Ministry of Environment Regulation No. 8/2010 on Criteria and Certification of Environment-Friendly Buildings. LC
Source:Overview Indonesiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Sustainable Development
GREEN ECONOMY IN PRACTICE - GOVERNMENT Initiated by Government •
SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE Sustainable Food Reserve Garden Ministry of Agriculture has also developed programs to empower rural family to build its own capacity in food security. One of them is development of Food Reserve Garden (FRG). FRG is implemented by involving communities and relevant parties at central and regional levels The pilot of FRG was established in February 2011 at Jelok, Kayen Village, Pacitan, East Java RE - SI Source:Overview Indonesia’s Sustainable Development
GREEN ECONOMY IN PRACTICE - GOVERNMENT Infrastructure •
SUSTAINABLE CITIES Green City Development Green City Development, Green city program started with raising Green City initiatives and commitments from 60 cities and districts through the formulation of Green City Action Plan (RAKH) in 2011. The 60 cities and districts will have to implement the action plan in 2012 Program will focus on three out of eight green city attributes: 1. City planning and design which accommodate the green agenda 2. Creation and development of green open space and urban green open space network 3. Raising community’s sensitivity, awareness and active roles in developing green city’s attributes (green planning and design, green open space, green community, green building, green energy, green water, green transportation, and green waste) Source:Overview Indonesia’s Sustainable Development
GREEN ECONOMY IN PRACTICE - GOVERNMENT â&#x20AC;˘
RENEWABLE ENERGY AND ENERGY EFFICIENCY Self Reliant Energy Village (DME) The Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) has launched a program that handles self-reliant energy village program (DME). The DME program is a program of energy supply by utilizing the potential energy found in that village from both biofuel and non-biofuel with technology that can be operated by the local people, such as Biofuel technologies, Micro-hydro, Wind Energy Technology, Solar Technology, Biogas Technology, Biomass technology, and others. The DME program is intended as an entry point for the first rural economic activities launched by the President of Indonesia in Grobogan Village, Central Java in 2007and is followed by other villages throughout Indonesia. At the end of 2009 it is expected to achieve 850 DME and at the end of 2014 it is expected to form 3000 DME
Source:Overview Indonesiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Sustainable Development
GREEN ECONOMY IN PRACTICE - LOCAL â&#x20AC;˘
RENEWABLE ENERGY AND ENERGY EFFICIENCY Cinta Mekar Hydro Power One of the most recognized micro hydro power project in indonesia is that is developed by yayasan ibeka in cinta mekar village (Cinta Mekar Micro Hydro Power Plant/MHPP). It catapults ibeka's reputation in developing public private and community based micro hydro power plant. The cinta mekar project is a 120- kW micro hydro power plant (MHPP) designed to generate supply of grid connected electricity. The project is located in Cinta Mekar village, Subang, West Java, about 150 km from the capital city of Jakarta. Cinta Mekar, which consists of four subvillages, is home to 646 families. Prior to the start of the project, 102 households were without electricity
Source:Overview Indonesiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Sustainable Development
Individual initiatives by local communities, private companies, and government efforts indicates practices that may eventually lead to sustainable development. However, aggregation of individual efforts at national level may not fully lead Indonesia to green economy, unless some policy actions are taken Analysis from various studies indicates Indonesia is still in very low ranking in terms of carbon in the world, still not efficient in using its resources, while the inequality of distribution of income remains
Jakarta has introduced the bus rapid transit, the emission inspection and the introduction of gas as fuel for public transport. Even if all vehicles in Jakarta switch to cleaner fuel, the problem of heavy traffic, inefficiency of energy use will not be solved A good mass rapid transport (MRT system) needs to be put in place in order to promote a more intensive use of public transport and better efficiency and cleaner use of energy resources The Government needs to develop more new energy and renewable energy resources that are cleaner than conventional fossil energy
Economic instruments need to be put in place in order to apply the polluters pay principle A fiscal reform needs to be introduced where higher tax be imposed to activities with more intensive use of resources and more carbon emission and tax incentive be imposed to activities with more efficient use of resources and less carbon release Moratorium of conversion of forest and protected areas that has been taken by the Government should be maintain until further evaluation
GREEN GROWTH IMPLEMENTATION
â&#x20AC;˘ The concept of sustainable development, let alone green growth, might not be well understood in our country. However, Local wisdom becomes the basis for further developing best partices of sustainable development principles, in more focus way, in a more systemic way, that may eventually lead the country to culture herself as a sustainability society. The Government will play a role of facilitating and encouraging good sustainable development practices at all level that will result in the increase of resilience of our economy in coping with potential crises in the next decade, be in food, in energy, in water, and in climate change. Greening the economy will be developed into the development of sectors at middle and low level that will increase the resilience of our economy, by gradually replacing the domination of extractive economy and industry.
The National League of Communes/Sangkats Communes/ Sangkats
Geographical Areas Areas: 181,035 km2 Population:14.7 million (Census 2008) Capital: Phnom Penh (1.2 millions) Provinces: 23 Sub-National Structure Provinces/Capital (24) Disticts/Muinicipalities/Khans (194) Communes/Sangkats (1,633) (directly elected by citizens)
Energy Access Access to modern cooking fuels urban % HH, 2008 rural % HH, 2008
7.9 37.3 1.5
Electricity Access, national % HH, 2010 urban % HH, 2008 rural % HH, 2008
29.7 87 13
No. of people w/o access to electricity (2009) (mil.) 11.3 Population served by offoff-grid sources ((minigrids minigrids,, HH systems) 4% Electricity access target 70% of HH in 2030 (100% of villages)
Renewable Energy - Biomass - Biogas - Biofuel - Solar - Win - Hydro - Mini/Micro/ Mini/Micro/pico pico hydro power - Other Renewable Energy sources
Transportation Infrastructure - Skippers - National Highways - Railways - Highways - Rural roads - Seaports and harbors - Airports Role of Public Transportation - Buses companies increase considerably but without any short distance bus - Railwayâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s just renovated (Aug 2012) - Taxi meter, Tuk tuk, tuk, moto dup, cyclo cyclo,, remoque moto - No subway
Energy Consumption to be reduced - Bio digesters - Small hydro power and biofuel - Hybrid diesel - Biomass wastes/biochar wastes/biochar production - Biomass gasifier - Used fuel generator - Geothermal/wind
Efficiency of Energy
- Loans of DPs focused on the natural resources and energy - National Miodigester Program - Rural Energy Strategy Program (National Gov.) - Rural electrification based on renewable energy (solar lanterns, Jatropha)) Jatropha
Challenges Regarding Energy, Renewable Energies and Rural Energy in Cambodia - Institutional Structure - Policy and Regulatory Framework - Programme Concerns - Access Issues - Financing Concerns - Gender Concerns - Monitoring and Evoluation Framework
Other resources to be increased - Green technology - Forest replantation - Biomass - Biogas - Biofuel - Solar - Win - Hydro - Other Renewable Energy
Efficient circular economy helps protect environment - Since the 1990th, Cambodiaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s economic growth around 10% - Plus, revenues from minerals and newly found oil and gas reserves - Although its economic growth, funding support for environmental protection and management is still poor - Land grabbing, illegal logging, illegal fishing and mineral extraction are major concerns - However, local communities with funding support from dev. partners have established fishery and forestry communities.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION!
UCLG ASPAC Members: Towards Low Carbon Cities
By Kalanidhi Devkota, Executive Director Municipal Association of Nepal (MuAN) UCLG ASPAC Congress, Borobudur Hotel, Jakarta, 3 Oct. 2012
Per Capita Emissions (In Tonnes) London
Washington, DC Kolkata Ranchi
19.7 1.83 1.97
Carbon Emission in Kathmandu
Per capita emission in Kathmandu city is 0.42 Ton
76% of the total emission coming from Transportation 76%
7% of the total emission coming from Waste
Points to be Noted The GHG emission in Washington DC can be responsible for the droughts in Uganda, floods in the Philippines and Indonesia and melting glacier in Nepal Climate-induced disasters such as floods, landslides and droughts have killed more than 4,000 people in Nepal alone over the last 10 years. The economic losses caused by disasters add up to about USD 5.34 billion in Nepal World Bank's annual investments of US$ 140â&#x20AC;&#x201C;175 billion are projected for the next 20 years and another US$ 30â&#x20AC;&#x201C;100 billion per annum for climate change adaptation.
) * +
Regional LG Associations i.e., UCLG ASPAC, CITYNET, ICLEI etc need to play strategic roles by involving ASEAN, SAARC etc. National LGAs i.e., MuAN, NLC/S, ADKASI etc have to support their members to develop their capacity, help develop GHG inventory & implementation National LGAs should advocate and lobby for low carbon policy and engage private sector to invest in renewable energy, sustainable transport such as electric vehicle and cycle friendly roads. National LGAs should ensure LG are incorporating responses to climate change in their planning, investment decisions, and emergencypreparedness plans.
Initiatives in Nepal Nepal prepared its National Adaptation Program of Action (NAPA) for adapting to extreme climate events through consultative process. The document was shared with Parties to the UNFCCC in November 2010.
National Framework for Local Adaptation Plan for Action (LAPA) has also been developed for implementing adaptation actions, and integrating climate change into local development planning.
MuAN and ICLEA SA are coordinating â&#x20AC;&#x153;Toward Zero Waste in SAâ&#x20AC;? supported by EU for 3 years Implementing cities are: Coimbatore & Simla (India) Matale (Srilanka) Phunstonling (Bhutan) Hetuada & Tansen (Nepal) North Dhaka City (Bangladesh) AGRE (Austria) and VVSG (Belgium) Technical Supporter
!"#" !"$" % !"!$ & !"$"' ($) *
Source: World Urbanization Prospects, the 2009 Revision
* + , *
/ -0 1 2"
#'2""5 - . !$"'""" $'"""'"""
CDIA Focus Areas
F S F A
0 7 8
7 0 '
' ' •
8 ; 0 9
Private Sector Financing Schemes for Strategic Urban Infrastructure Investments William Young UCLG ASPAC Congress October 2012
Table of Contents • Introduction • Seeking financing from the private sector • Private sector trends relating to debt and equity type financing • Projects and return profiles • Criteria and Risks
Introduction New Risk to Europe's Growth: Banks Cut Lending to Cities Source: Wall Street Journal, 7 June 2012
Across Southeast Asia, public works are being expanded by governments needing to counter a slowdown in global demand and sustain an acceleration in growth that has made the region one of the few bright spots in a volatile world economy. Source: Reuters, 2 September 2012
The Asian Development Bank (ADB) estimates that Southeast Asia’s 10 countries need at least $60 billion a year to fund ambitious infrastructure work. Infrastructure projects are not without danger. Source: Reuters, 2 September 2012
Execution problems and cost overruns are common. Land acquisition can be thorny — laws sometimes don’t help — and financing can be complicated. Source: Bloomberg, 8 September 2012
Introduction In affluent Singapore, the roads are good and public housing is the envy of most other countries, but a jump in the population in the recent years has caused problems. Source: Reutersl, 15 September 2012
"Providing effective infrastructure for trade will be critical to help ASEAN economies move progressively into more complex and highervalue manufacturing and production, including meeting rising demand from a growing middle class in the region," the ADBâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Goswami said.
Seeking financing from Private Sector • Reduction in bank financing • Vast increase in public projects • Reduction in public money (tax revenue) • Increasing population and aging population • Need to understand drivers for private investors
Private Sector Trends to Debt and Equity • Increase conservatism in the private sector (risk appetite) • Private investors are on a wait and see approach due to the global economy • More stringent assessment criteria • • • • •
Wanting more control Higher weighting on risk premium Looking for preservation of equity Better alignment of interest Transparency
Project and Return Profiles • 5 year term for development type projects (time bound) • Higher expected returns • Guarantee equity/Project guarantee by government (Europe) • Investor involvement in decision making • Working together with private sector investors in developing projects, Australia is a good example
Criteria and Risks • • • • • • • •
Executional risks and cost overruns Country risks & transparency Sound legal framework Green and sustainable projects Well defined exit strategies Government support/continuity Development support/reliable partners Reporting in English and to international standards
Urban Infrastructure Financing UCLG ASPAC â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Congress Jakarta, October 3, 2012
Copyrights: University of Washington
Accessing Infrastructure Financing
What kind of infrastructure financing is available for cities in Indonesia? What should cities do to access the financing?
Source of Financing
Cities own funds National Government Other Local Government Financial Institutions Corporations
C I T I E S
NatGov. Subsidiary Loan/ Grant Agreement
Foreign Governments International Donor Agency Financial Institutions
Local Corp. PPP
Source of Infrastructure Financing for Cities
Ministriesâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; Budget & Mechanism
Subsidiary Loan /Grant Agreement
Other Local Governt
Governmt Investm. Fund
Corporations (non FI)
Budget Mechanism (APBD)
Budget Mechanism(APBD) Cities/Local Government
Planning Agency 3 mth after Mediumterm Dev Plan, revised annually
RPPLN (Plan for Offshore Financing)
YES 6 mth after Mediumterm Dev Plan NO
Ministries or SOE
Evaluation on administration, technical and financial DRPLN-JM (List of Potential Activities)
Subsidiary Loan Agreement Procedure
Inform plan for DRPLN 4
Proposal Summary of Prop 5
Ministries or SOE Detail Proposal
When forwarding the loan, the Government (Ministry of Finance) enters a subsidiary loan agreement with cities.
DRPPLN (List of Priority)
Ministries or SOE List of Activities (Projects)
Meet readiness criteria
Ministry of Finance
Type of Financing â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Grant Source: National Government/Ministries Offshore funds G R A N T
Characteristics: 1. Grant is mostly used for preparation or assistance funds. 2. Cities involvement is quite limited in proposing grant. 3. Ministries can forward funds to cities as either grant or loan (PER.004/M.PPN/2011). Each Ministry has its own mechanism of distributing funds to cities e.g. RPIJM (Public Works).
Finding out financing mechanism in Sectoral Ministries
Type of Financing â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Loan Source:
L O A N
National Government (PIP, PT SMI, PT IFF) Offshore funds â&#x20AC;&#x201C; through SLA Financial Institutions Other LGs Retail (Bonds)
Characteristics: 1. Each financing has a different mechanism but all is subject to PP 30/2011 2. Some lenders are more stringent than others 3. Loan requires strong fiscal capacity, good financial management as well as some degree of transparency More suitable for income generating projects 7
Type of Financing â&#x20AC;&#x201C; PPP Source: National Government (PIP, PT SMI, PT IFF) Private Sector (Corporations, State-Owned Enterprise, Local Government Owned Companies and Cooperatives): PP56/2011 allows foreign legal entities P P P
Characteristics: 1. The part offered to private sector should be interesting enough for them to participate 2. PPP requires advance knowledge on project structure 3. Initiatives can come from Ministries/Cities or Private Sector A PPP project can be a combination of different financing types 8
Challenges in Accessing Financing
Most cities depend on budget transfer from Government which currently still dominates the city financial income structure (around 70-80% of the total income) and is just enough for routine expenditures.
Considering the limited amount of funds, cities need to prioritize their infrastructure projects.
Packaging is about how to design financial scheme of a project to be not only attractive but also fits the risk profile of each source of funds. This is all about creativity, skills and experience.
Successful infrastructure financing needs not only good planning but more importantly execution starting with establishing a team, timeline, target.
Breakout Sessions/ Parallel Sessions III â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Revitalize
Application of Culture in City Planning Process Case-studies of cultural planning and impacts
1. Consider a recent cultural event or activity in your local government area 2. Discuss and reflect on any cultural impacts, changes or issues that were uncovered 3. Think though the next similar event and in planning would you enhance the cultural impact or seek to reduce the cultural impact 4. How would you do it differently?
1st Discussion Worksheet
2nd Discussion Worksheet
Critical Issues: Matrix Overview • • • •
Step 1: Brainstorming exercise – What are the critical issues? (And what are the objectives in relation to those critical issues?) Step 2: Brainstorming exercise – What are the criteria for assessing issues? (e.g. cost, urgency, ability to affect) Step 3: Consider driving forces and pressures Step 4: Analyse Issues – A. Compare and rate criteria – B. Compare and rate issues – against all criteria – C. Assess impacts (positive and negative) between issues Step 5: Interpret results – What is the overall assessment of positive vs negative impacts? – What is the final shortlist of material issues?
Critical Issues Matrix • • • •
Iterative Continual ‘Virtuous’ Cycle Compatible with macro-strategic review processes
Grazie Thank you Merci Obrigado 謝謝 Danke