VOL. CXXXVI NO. 2
FRIDAY, September 20, 2024
CLAREMONT, CA
‘This is not a choice:’ Scripps administration demands Motley Coffeehouse remove Palestinian flag
KAYA SAVELSON • THE STUDENT LIFE Amidst pressures from administration, Scripps’ Motley Coffeehouse has refused to take down its Palestinian flag.
ANSLEY WASHBURN Scripps College’s Motley Coffeehouse has received backlash from administration for displaying a Palestinian flag on its wall. Despite repeated calls from administration to remove the flag, the Motley’s management team has refused to take it down in a show of solidarity with Palestine. On Wednesday, Sept. 18, the Motley’s management team received an email from the administration asking them to “promptly remove any unauthorized signage, decorations, flags, posters, or other materials.” “The College has not authorized Motley employees to display symbols or signage endorsing a political position or perspective that could be erroneously attributed to Scripps College,” the email read. Later that day, the email was
forwarded to the student listserv by Sha Bradley, Scripps’ vice president for student affairs and dean of students. The subject line read, “Commitment to Freedom of Expression and Inclusion-Motley Coffeehouse.” According to Bradley, the purpose of forwarding the message was to clarify the Motley’s responsibility to adhere to the college’s Advertising, Publicity, and Solicitation Policy and Principles of Community. “As we start a new academic year, we want to reinforce our commitment to freedom of expression and inclusion,” she wrote in a preface to the forwarded message. “I look forward to engaging in conversations about creating an environment that fosters belonging, inclusion, and values community.” Although administration only
informed the student body of the dispute on Wednesday, the Motley took to social media almost a week earlier to speak on the issue and to call students to action against the administration’s demands. On Thursday, Sept. 12, the Motley shared a joint Instagram post with Pomona Divest from Apartheid announcing that the Scripps administration had threatened to prevent them from opening “unless they take down their Palestinian flag.” The post called for students and community members to gather for a protest that afternoon to “demand that Scripps stop vilifying pro-palestinian speech.” It also included a screenshot of an email that the management team had received from Deborrah Herbert, Scripps’ interim special assistant to the vice president for
student affairs, earlier that week. The “leaked” email from Herbert disclosed that an unnamed Scripps faculty member had shown a photo of the Palestinian flag displayed in the Motley to Bradley and Scripps President Amy Marcus-Newhall. “I need you to understand, this is not a choice,” Herbert wrote. “The Motley is college owned and the flag must come down ASAP.” The email referenced the college’s posting policy and reminded the Motley’s management team that any public displays on college-owned property require approval. It also went into detail about what being “college-owned and student-run” means. “As a business open to all of the Scripps and 7C community [the Motley] needs to be a welcoming environment for all of the community, not just part of the community.” Herbert acknowledged the student employees’ rights to their personal political opinions but also stressed that the Motley is not an appropriate space to express them. “While student employees of the Motley have every right to hold their own personal political positions, being employed at the Motley does not turn the Motley
into your personal political platform,” she wrote. “It remains a College-owned business establishment irrespective of the political viewpoints held by the student employees in any given year.” The Motley post’s call to action, which was included alongside the screenshot of Herbert’s email, was heard by students, and at 4:15 p.m. that day, over 150 students gathered in the coffeehouse, many in keffiyehs and masks, in solidarity and in anticipation of an administrator’s arrival to take down the flag. “Banning the Palestinian flag on the grounds that it is unwelcoming is itself a discriminatory act,” one speaker said. The speaker also explained the addition of several flags now displayed within the Motley, which they said followed Herbert’s claim that the Palestinian flag was not part of a broader display recognizing international students at Scripps. “Well, now it is part of a broader display that recognizes international students at Scripps, queer students, black students, immigrant students and trans students,” the speaker said. “So what we want to find out is, will Scripps adminis-
See MOTLEY on page 2
KAYA SAVELSON • THE STUDENT LIFE Palestine flag displayed on the wall of the Motley.
Wildfires run rampant through Students demonstrate outside Starr’s house Southern California, causing amidst calls for divestment concern for 5C community KAHANI MALHOTRA & ELLIE LAKATOS California is no stranger to wildfires, with more than 7,500 wildfires tearing through the state in 2023, and 2024 being no different. Around the 5Cs, this year’s fire season has led to worsened air quality, discussions around canceling in-person
activities and speculations about a possible campus evacuation order. The Bridge Fire has been the most significant threat to the Claremont Colleges located just northwest of the campuses and is currently the largest active fire in Southern California. Since the fire started in Glendora on Monday, Sept. 9, it has burned over 54 thousand acres
in San Bernardino and Los Angeles Counties. On Tuesday, Sept. 10, the rapid spread of the Bridge fire prompted local officials to issue an evacuation warning for northern Claremont. At the same time, students received warning notifications concerning the possibility of being evacuated.
See WILDFIRES on page 3
TALIA BERNSTEIN • THE STUDENT LIFE On Sept. 15, Pomona Divest from Apartheid held a demonstration outside of President Starr’s house, leading students in a series of chants and screams centered around divestment.
ANNABELLE INK On Sunday, Sept. 15, approximately 60 students gathered in front of Pomona College President Gina Gabrielle Starr’s house on N. College Avenue for a demonstration led by Pomona Divest from Apartheid (PDfA). The demonstration, which began at 11:50 p.m., went on for about 20 minutes and included a series of screams and chants calling on the college to divest from what students have previously described as “companies aiding the ongoing apartheid system within the State of Israel.” According to the college, Sunday’s protest violated demonstration policies and student conduct investigations are underway. Hours before the demonstration,
PDfA posted on Instagram asking students to meet at Pomona’s Marston Quad at 11:30 p.m. that night. The post included a video of Starr speaking to protestors in Alexander Hall during the Apr. 5 arrests last semester, with the words “GENOCIDE GINA” and “we remember our enemies” displayed over it. “WE ARE STILL HERE,” the caption reads. “360,000 PLUS. NO PEACE FOR THE PERPETRATORS OF GENOCIDE.” Students, many donning allblack outfits, keffiyehs and face masks, began making their way over to Marston Quad at about 11:30 p.m. At 11:46 p.m., they began the short walk to Starr’s
See STARR on page 2
SARAH ZIFF • THE STUDENT LIFE The Bridge Fire burns behind 5C campuses, causing concern for members of the community.
ARTS & CULTURE At the Athenaeum on Sept. 16, Helena Bottemiller Evich CM ’09 delivered a lecture titled “The Politics of Food and Climate Change.” Evich stated that agriculture is crucial to the climate conversation but is underrepresented in U.S. climate policy, attributing this to strong opposition from farmers and the meat industry.
The student newspaper of the Claremont Colleges since 1889
OPINIONS
SPORTS
What is the difference between safety and surveillance? With tensions surrounding policing and the increased presence of Campus Safety officers at the Claremont Colleges, Ben Lauren PZ ’25 explores the state of what “safety” means on our campuses today.
On Monday, Sept. 9, the ClaremontMudd-Scripps (CMS) men’s soccer team proved they can hang with the best, taking down the St. Olaf College Lions, the reigning NCAA national Division III champions, in a 3-2 win.
INDEX: News 1 | Arts & Culture 5 | Opinions 8 | Sports 9