Sports
Opinions
Shayok Chakraborty PO â19 urges leftists at the Claremont Colleges to get out of the bubble.
Catch up with the Athenas in their trip la-cross the country.
Page 8
Page 10
THE
STUDENT
LIFE
The Student Newspaper of the Claremont Colleges Since 1889
CLAREMONT, CA
FRIDAY, MARCH 24, 2017
VOL. CXXIX NO. 7
Feminist Musician Vibes with the Motleyâs Message
Mudd Addresses Workload: Leaked Report Advocates Reform Kellen Browning
Lia Francis-Bongue⢠The Student Life
Malynda Hale performs at the Motley Coffeehouse Tunes nâ Deals at Scripps College on Mar. 21, 2017. See page 5
PZ Students Receive Death Threats For Controversial Mural Elinor Aspegren Three Pitzer College students received harrassment and death threats following national news attention on a mural they painted reading âWhite Girl, Take Off Your Hoops,â on the collegeâs free art space. According to Jacquelyn Aguilera PZ â19, one of the artists, the piece came from desires for selfhealing through art and to start a conversation at Pitzer around cultural appropriation. Aguilera said the reaction on campus to the mural has been relatively positive. âThereâs been support from people who had seen this phenomenon [of cultural appropriation] going on. There were a lot of women of color or femmes of color who reached out to us to thank us for our art,â she said. âBut thereâs also been a lot of people who are uncomfortable and unwilling to have dialogue around the presence of people of color on campus as a result.â Shortly after the murals was created, a student wrote an email to Student-Talk, Pitzerâs student listserv, asking for an explanation about why wearing hoops was problematic. After responding to the email, both Aguilera and AlegrĂa Martinez PZ â18, another student involved in the mural, were emailed requests for comment from a reporter at the Claremont Independent, a conservative-leaning publication at the Claremont Colleges. The Independent ran an article titled âPitzer College RA: White People Canât Wear Hoop Earrings,â which was then republished on several conservative news websites across the country, including The Daily Caller, The National Review, and The Blaze, including the names of the Pitzer students. After the article was picked up by other news outlets, Aguilera and Martinez, and later GalloGonzalez, started to receive death threats over Facebook from outside the Claremont Colleges. Aguilera said that the messages
she has received have ranged from homophobic and anti-black comments to calls for ethnic cleansing. She said that she has felt more unsafe on campus since the article was published. Martinez wrote in an email to TSL that she believes that people took their message so personally because they felt attacked when free speech was used to make people uncomfortableâbecause they felt ârestricted and controlled, something theyâd probably never felt before.â Gallo-Gonzalez said that the outcry over the mural showed her that issues women of color and non-binary people of color face are not talked about clearly. âPeople saw this message and didnât understand why it was an issue to wear hoop earrings. People paid attention to that mural but not the mural that said âProtect Black Trans Livesâ which is also there, but people ignored that,â she said. âIt just kind of shows that Pitzer students are not learning about race issues and gender issues in an intersectional way.â Eric Owen, The Daily Callerâs education editor, defended his decision to run the article. âI donât feel that I did anything in any way ethically questionable,â he said. Owen said the mural painters forfeited their right to privacy when they identified themselves on Student-Talk. âWhen you do things like this, you make yourself public in relation to the thing which you did. To me, thatâs a no-brainer.â Matthew Reade PO â18, coeditor-in-chief of the Claremont Independent, defended his publicationâs decision to publish the article, as well. âThe article that we wrote was objective and it presented the speech and it started a conversation, and thatâs what weâre trying to do,â he said. âOur main goal is to speak to students about what is happening on their campus.â However, he denounced those
Follow TSL on the web.
See Mural page 2
TSL recently obtained a leaked report conducted at the request of Harvey Mudd Collegeâs Teaching and Learning Committee in Oct. 2015. In the report, students and faculty participated in private focus groups evaluating the impact of HMCâs workload and honor code. The findings of the researchers, Charlie Blaich and Kathy Wise from the Center for Inquiry of Liberal Arts, were emailed to committee members in Feb. 2016, and the report, which was not intended for public release, can be found at tsl.news. The researchers, who help liberal arts colleges self-assess, found that HMC students were talented and hardworking, but many suffered from feelings of inferiority and insecurity due to an onslaught of work that superseded extracurricular activities, non-STEM academic interests, and even essential activities like eating, sleeping, laundry, and showering. In their report, Blaich and Wise provided their suggestions to the TLC after speaking with 24 students and 31 faculty members, all anonymous.
âOur recommendations are simple,â the researchers wrote in the report. âFirst, be more generous in addition to being tough, and second, create time for students to develop the qualities that the institution values, including the values behind the Honor Code.â On March 7, Muddâs Faculty Executive Committee emailed an action document addressing the reportâs findings to Mudd students and faculty. Though faculty were emailed the full report, only a summary appeared in the action document available to the student body. The action plan notes that the reportâs concerns âare important issues that call for a concerted and sustained effort from students, faculty, and staff at all levels of seniority.â The document outlines âprior and ongoing activitiesâ by HMC to address student workload, including a review of HMCâs common core curriculum, a faculty job satisfaction survey, a âfaculty and student time expenditureâ study, the Peer Academic Liaisons program, and the work of the health and wellness staff. Students seeking immediate
See WORKLOAD page 2
Pitzer Surges to Victory in PowerDown Competition Anna Hall For the first time since 2014, Pitzer College won the 5C PowerDown 2017, an annual competition to minimize energy usage between the residence halls of the five undergraduate Claremont Colleges. As a reward, Pitzerâs longest-standing environmental club, EcoCenter, will receive a $500 cash prize. The prize is available for EcoCenter members and the Pitzer student body as a whole to spend in an environmentallyrelated way. From Monday, Feb. 13, to Monday, March 6, each collegeâs ranking fluctuated in correlation to the amount of kilowatts per hour (kWh) used or saved by each residence hall, with Pitzer ultimately taking the victory at a 7.7 percent energy reduction. Claremont McKenna College came in close behind at a 6.4 percent reduction, Harvey Mudd College with a 5.2 percent reduction, Pomona College with a 1.5 percent reduction, and Scripps College falling in last place with a .2 percent increase in kWh usage. According to the eventâs Facebook page, PowerDown 2017
saved 33,170 kilowatt-hours of energy, which is âequivalent to powering 3 homesâ electricity for a year.â To keep students engaged and willing to participate, events were held on all five campuses to promote PowerDown2017. Students were urged to take the Power Down Pledge which, according to EcoCenter member and PowerDown representative Laurel Melton PZ â20, was âa pledge basically saying you would try to do a bunch of different things to reduce your power usage during the competition. EcoCenter member Haley Burger PZ â20 said that, among other events, âthere was a silent disco, CMC did a hang-your-clothes-inthe quad-to-dry event, and Scripps did an outdoor field night where they had an astronomy teacher come.â Energy increases and reductions during PowerDown 2017 were evaluated in comparison to a twoweek data collection baseline period prior to the start of the three-week competition period, according to Pitzer Sustainability Manager Warren Biggins. âThe 5C PowerDown competition grew out of a national energy and water reduction competition
Courtesy of Warren Biggins
that was sponsored by a group called Campus Conservation Nationals (CCN),â Biggins said. According to its website, CCN is âthe largest short-term electricity reduction competition in the world.â Since its inception in 2013, the 5C PowerDown competition has been affiliated with CCN, but because CCN has been in limbo for the past two years, last year Pitzer
spearheaded its own 5C version of the national competition. For this yearâs data collection process, Pomona and HMC contracted with a software company called Lucid, while Scripps, Pitzer, and CMC collected their own data reading the numbers on the electricity meters of each residence hall.
See POWERDOWN page 2
Pitzer and Claremont McKenna Welcome New Executive Board Members Julie Tran The Associated Students of Claremont McKenna College and Pitzer College Student Senate welcomed executive board officers elected for the 2017-2018 term on Feb. 28 and March 10, respectively. Hajar Hammado PZ â18 will become the first woman of color to serve as Pitzer Senate President; this election cycle marked the first where both candidates were women of color. âIâm glad that I will have the opportunity to collaborate with the Pitzer community on initiatives to improve our
http://tsl.news
institution,â Hammado wrote in an email to TSL. âI hope that my track record will serve as an inspiration for others who are interested in partaking in shared governance.â Hammado hopes to address funding at Pitzer in collaboration with 5C governments. âI plan to play an active role in the upcoming 5C and Pitzer Budget Hearings in order to ensure that student activities fees are fairly allocated to all of the great clubs and organizations that we have here on campus,â Hammado wrote. Hammado also expressed admiration for the executive boardâs
Like us on facebook: facebook.com/thestudentlife
passion and dedication to improve the student experience at Pitzer. âI look forward to collaborating with my executive board on making Student Senate truly representative and redefining our priorities so they align with the student body,â Hammado wrote. Incoming treasurer Lindsay Mooradian PZ â19 was also enthusiastic about working with the executive board. âIâm looking to speed up the reimbursement process, make student activities fees more accessible to the student body, and increase transparency between the student body and Senate re-
@TSLnews
garding the budget and budget committee,â Mooradian wrote in an email to TSL. In an email to TSL, secretaryelect Kamyab Mashian PZ â19 laid out his goal to improve the dynamic between Student Senate and Pitzerâs clubs and student organizations. He hopes the senate can spend more time discussing issues that affect the student body and less time getting âbogged down in procedural debates.â In their first meeting since the election, Mashian and Hammado have discussed their shared goals, including a plan to live stream fu-
See VOTE page 3
NEWS................................1 LIFE & STYLE.....................4 OPINIONS........................7 SPORTS.............................9