JUNE 2021.VOL. 21, NO. 06. PORTLAND, MAINE.
PORTLAND’S COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER. FREE!
Charter Commission faces far-reaching issues
Analysis: Political enthusiasm may be too great for charter commissioners to take a narrow view of their role By Tony Zeli
No matter who is elected to the Portland Charter Commission, whatever agendas they bring and whatever process they choose to follow, the public will be involved and ready to fight for the issues they care about. On June 8th, Portland voters select nine additional members to a twelve-member charter commission. Five members represent the city’s five political districts and four are at-large members. The city council already appointed the remaining three seats to former school board member Peter Eglinton, ACLU of Maine Policy Counsel Michael Kebede, and former City Councilor Dory Waxman. Many describe the city charter as being like the US Constitution, but for our city. It is not the worst metaphor. Like the Constitution, the City of Portland Charter grants powers to the city government, lays out rules for electing city officials, and begins with a pithy preamble. Unlike the Constitution, the city charter has no version of the Bill of Rights. The city charter is more focused on the perfunctory rules that enable the city to conduct business. For instance, the charter governs everything from city council and mayoral pay rates to how the city borrows money.
WHY NOW? Ultimately, the charter commission was formed because of a local petition for public campaign financing. Fair Election Portland turned in a qualifying ballot petition for a local Clean Elections system, but the Portland City Council decided to send the issue to a charter commission rather than to -WEN file photo by T. Zeli voters – since it would require a change to the charter. Portland voters approved of the charter commission in a vote in July 2020.
Banner by Artists' Rapid Response Team (ARRT!). -Photo by Karen Silverman (2021)
CLIMATE JUSTICE FEATURE
David vs. Goliath
South Portland's Ongoing Struggle Against Big Oil
Of course, as was the case a little over a decade ago when the city last formed a By Espahbad Dodd charter commission, once the commission was opened there were plenty of other Speaking with people around issues that people were ready to discuss. town, I’m struck by how little folks know about the David versus Goliath battle that is ongoing just across THE ISSUES the Fore River in South Portland. It Public Campaign Financing started in 2013 and continues until today and is a case of the underdog Arguably the first issue on the agenwinning against incredible odds… at da should be public campaign financing. least for now. Like Maine’s Clean Elections system, local candidates would qualify for funding from This is fundamentally a story about the city to run their campaigns. The last small “d” democracy and activism. It’s a charter commission discussed public fi- story about a community and those who nancing, but enough commissioners were live there. And it’s a story about fighting concerned about costs to sink the idea. the humongous power and influence of a gigantic industry with little more than Role of the Mayor spirit and a "slingshot."
Another difference: the US Constitution is not regularly amended in a wholesale way by an elected commission. The charter commission can drastically change the dynamics of government, potentially creating an entire new branch of governThe push led by progressives to crement like an executive mayor. However, ate a position of a popularly elected mayor the charter commission can only make kickstarted the last charter commission. recommendations. Portland voters get to And the balance of power between the approve or reject any amendments they put forth. Cont'd on Pg. 3
In this case, by putting the well-being of children and the elderly together with every resource they could muster, the underdogs miraculously came out on top. It’s a short history, an alive, ever-evolving sto-
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Espahbad Dodd lives on State Street in the West End. He is a member of the Portland Climate Action Team and the primary editor of that team’s monthly Bright Ideas column (see Pg. 18). Readers may reach him at espahbad@gmail. com. He welcomes feedback. ry, of the City of South Portland which has long been treated by the petroleum industry as an industrial “sacrifice zone.” Initially, people living in South Portland and their supporters sought to prevent the reversal of the Portland-Montreal Pipeline to bring tar sands oil from Canada. More recently, it has become a battle for clean air. How did it start? Who was behind it? Where does it currently stand? And where could it be headed?
Cont'd on Pg. 4
Page 8
Interview with entrepreneur Eric Kalala, owner of Chez Castel
Page 9
Antitrust enforcement is having a moment
Page 7
Surviving Cancer: What’s Next? From the Cancer care team at Northern Light Mercy
Pages 12-13
Layne's Wine Gig presents unusual Sake pairings and Sake Mini-glossary
Page 14
West End traveler Nancy Dorrans takes us to Namibia and Botswana
Page 15
Puzzles and Best Worst Trivia presents Maine Lakes