The National Newspaper of St. Vincent and the Grenadines PRINTER SCANNER COPIER FAX Color scan, Fax forward to email, Network scan, PC/Walkup Fax, Copy/Print speed of up to 35ppm, USB 2.0
FRIDAY,
DECEMBER 5, 2014
VOLUME 108, No. 49
www.thevincentian.com
EC$1.50
ÂTHE DPP SHOULD RESIGN,Ê SAYS QC
bad.” Dougan thinks that the DPP’s office has done a great disservice and injustice to his client, Sheon Veira, who was acquitted of six criminal charges, including a murder by HAYDN HUGGINS charge, last week Thursday, November 28, at the Criminal QUEEN’S COUNSEL CARLYLE Assizes, after Justice Kathy DOUGAN has called for the Ann Latchoo upheld a no case resignation of Director of Public submission by Dougan. Prosecutions (DPP) Colin He was assisted at the trial Williams, and for Assistant DPP by lawyer Grant Connell and Colin John to be appointed DPP. law student Evelyn StewartDougan, a former Attorney John. General here, issued the call Veira, 42, also known as while speaking to THE ‘Scobie’, originally of Lowmans VINCENTIAN on Tuesday. He Windward, had been charged expressed the view that John with the June 22, 2010 seems to have a more balanced murder of 37-year-old approach to criminal justice. Venezuelan businessman, According to him, while Juan Carlos Cuauro Chirinos, Williams is at times good in and unlawfully and his functions as DPP, maliciously wounding with sometimes he is “drastically Carlyle Dougan QC has described the DPP as sometimes being ‘drastically bad’.
Stabbing death in Cane Hall MURDER INVESTIGATIONS into the death of 23year-old Sylvanus ‘Joey’ Porter, a labourer of Campden Park, continued yesterday, Thursday. According to Police, Porter died after he sustained multiple stab wounds about his body, following an altercation with his girlfriend, around 8 pm Wednesday, in the Upper Cane Hall area. Post mortem results are expected today, after which police will determine whether and on whom charges would be laid. Police sources have also confirmed that the number of murders for the year now stands at 35. Sylvanus Porter reportedly died after being stabbed numerous times.
intent Chirinos’ brother, 34year-old Douglas Efren Cuauro Chirinos, also of Venezuela. He was also charged on two counts of unlawful use of a firearm and two counts of possession of a firearm with intent to commit an offence. All the charges stemmed from the same incident. Veira was charged jointly with Otricia ‘One Eye’ Smart, 29, originally of Greiggs, who was acquitted on November 24, after Justice Latchoo upheld Smart’s lawyer Patina Knights’ application in objection to the admission in evidence of three caution statements Smart had given to the police, as well as any utterances she made at the crime scene. Smart was initially listed as
a key witness in the matter, but at a Preliminary Inquiry which had commenced at the Serious Offences Court on December 24, 2010. The prosecution withdrew the charges against Veira on January 4, 2011, after Smart refused to testify against him. She was then arrested and charged with the crimes, and Veira was subsequently recharged in connection with the matter. Both Veira and Smart remained in custody for close to four years in connection with the charges. The matter had been traversed several times at the Criminal Assizes. Dougan told THE VINCENTIAN that he would be writing to Government seeking compensation for false imprisonment of his client, the violation of his client’s constitutional rights and the rights enshrined in the International Convention for Human Rights. He lamented that his client had lost about four years of his life.
Colin Williams was appointed DPP amidst protest from some members of the legal fraternity.
attached to Douglas Chirinos’ deposition evidence,” the veteran lawyer explained. “The prosecution must never forget that its role as the proverbial minister of justice is a public duty. They must never seek a conviction, but always endeavour to introduce credible evidence in the interest of justice,” he continued. “The role of the prosecutor, as it has long been established, excludes any notion of winning or losing. An accused has an absolute right to a fair trial,” he underscored. In the no case submission, Dougan stressed that the prosecution relied heavily on the deposition of Douglas Chirinos, as he did not turn up to testify at the trial, and he argued that the prosecution failed to diligently search for him. The QC also pointed out No evidence that Chirinos had given a written statement to the police Dougan is of the view that on July 25, 2010, in which he the DPP was aware that the said a dark slim man shot prosecution’s prospect of him, and another man, stout success in this case was and clear in complexion, minimal and the risk of fought with his brother just injustice to Veira was before his brother was shot substantial, but proceeded to and killed. trial. But according to the “There was no forensic deposition which was read in evidence against him (Veira), and the identification evidence evidence, Chirinos did not mention anything about a was very poor and dark, slim man at the uncorroborated. Preliminary Inquiry. “We concluded, as part of the no case submission, that Continued on Page 3. little value whatever could be