The National Newspaper of St. Vincent and the Grenadines
;(52; :25.&(175( '1, ;(52; :25.&(175( '1, $OO LQ RQH 0XOWLIXQFWLRQ /DVHU 3ULQWHU $OO LQ RQH 0XOWLIXQFWLRQ /DVHU 3ULQWHU $1350.00 SALE Print, Copy, Fax nt, Scan, C Print Resolution: Resol 1200 x 1200 120 dpi Maximum Document aximum Do Size: 8.5" x 14" Monthly onthly Dut Duty Cycle: 80,000 Pages
FRIDAY,
APRIL 05, 2019
Stories by HAYDN HUGGINS JUSTICE BRIAN COTTLE has issued a reminder that the death penalty is still on the law books here, and can be applied in certain cases of murder. His comments came just before sentencing 33-year-old Patrick Lovelace is the only person currently on death row in this country.
The death penalty, when executed here, has been by hanging.
VOLUME 113, No.14
www.thevincentian.com
Andy Quashie of Layou to 35 years imprisonment for the murder of Layou resident Joseph Evans ‘Tuffy’ Lynch, 36. Lynch died after being shot multiple times in broad daylight, in full view of several persons, in that community, September 1, 2012. Quashie will however serve 28 years and six months, as the Judge deducted the time he spent on remand in connection with the matter. Justice Cottle pointed out that the death penalty is reserved for cases of exceptional depravity, and that the Andy Quashie case may have fallen within that category, given the circumstances and heinous nature of the crime. However, the Prosecution had at no point given any notice of
EC$1.50
Justice Brian Cottle gave a ‘gentle’ reminder to all Vincentians, that this country has not yet abolished the death penalty. intention to seek the death penalty in this case, and therefore the Judge did not consider that option. In 2001, the Eastern Caribbean Court of Appeal ruled that the mandatory nature of the death penalty was unconstitutional. That ruling was upheld by the Londonbased Privy Council. The ruling was handed down in two cases, Peter Hughes in St. Lucia and Newton Spence in St. Vincent and the Grenadines, and the Case Law became known as ‘Hughes and Spence’. Before this ruling, the death penalty was imposed indiscriminately upon any person convicted of murder, not giving them an opportunity to have the individual circumstances of their cases
considered by the Court which is to pronounce the sentence. A further development occurred June 22, 2009 when the Privy Council commuted convicted murderer Daniel ‘Compay’ Dick Trimmingham’s death sentence to life imprisonment.
28 YEARS PLUS FOR A “BRUTAL MURDER” ANDY QUASHIE is into the seventh day of a prison term of 28 years and six months for a murder which Justice Brian Cottle considers to be “brutal”. During a sentencing hearing at the Criminal Assizes Friday, March 29, Justice Cottle sentenced the 33-yearold Layou man to 35 years in prison for the daylight murder of Layou resident Joseph Evans ‘Tuffy’ Lynch, 36, who was gunned
down in that community in full view of several persons September 1, 2012. He was shot multiple time in an area known as Cashville, around midday. Cottle used 30 years as the starting point, and went up by five years, i.e. 35 years , taking the aggravating factors into account. “When I look at this case, I see no mitigating factors”, he contended.
The Judge, however, deducted the six years five months and 24 days Quashie spent on remand, leaving 28 years and six months for him to be incarcerated. Quashie also received a prison term of seven and a half years for possession of a firearm with intent to aid in the commission of an offence, but that will run concurrently to the other sentence. A 12-member jury
had found Quashie guilty on both counts February 12 this year, but sentencing was postponed. In mitigation, Quashie’s lawyer Grant Connell pointed out that there was an element of provocation, noting that Lynch had referred to Quashie as a “pussy”. Connell said that he was not justifying killing a man over the word ‘pussy’, but certain actions in this
society triggers reactions. He noted that two other men were charged in connection with the crime, but the case against them was discontinued and they became state witnesses. Continued on Page 3. Andy Quashie may well be into his 60s – a senior citizen before he completes his sentence.