business@tribunemedia.net
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 20, 2023
$5.59
$5.59
$5.25
$5.29
Gov’ts $544m undershoot on Dorian and COVID-19 By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
t "VEJUPS (FOFSBM THE two greatest crises Bahamian #PSSPXJOH CFBU inhistorymodern resulted in the Government’s 2019-2020 UBSHFU CZ revenues falling $544.1m t #VU SFQPSU OFWFS UBCMFE JO )PVTF t $POTUJUVUJPO NBOEBUFT UIBU OP AVOEVF EFMBZ
short of their target, its leading fiscal watchdog has affirmed. The Auditor General’s Office, in its report on the Government’s accounts for the Dorian and COVIDhit year, also disclosed that the then-Minnis administration’s $1.23bn borrowing exceeded Budget estimates by $474.6m or 62 percent as it urgently sought to plug this income hole and prop
Commission asset turnover as part of FTX’s settlement By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net FTX Bahamas’ liquidators have agreed to use “commercially reasonable efforts” to ensure some $426m worth of digital assets held by the Securities Commission are transferred to their US counterparts. This is among multiple measures in the “global settlement agreement” that Brian Simms KC, the Lennox Paton senior partner, and PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) accounting duo Kevin Cambridge and Peter Greaves, have struck with John Ray, head of the 134 FTX entities in Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in Delaware, to end an acrimonious year-long legal battle that delayed investor recoveries. Other terms in the deal, filed by Mr Ray and his team yesterday with the federal Delaware Bankruptcy Court, require the FTX US chief “to assist”
the Bahamian trio in recovering $143.2m in cash that was seized by the US Justice Department from accounts belonging to the local subsidiary that they have oversight responsibility for. That sum, which was in FTX Digital Markets’ name, would provide both a significant source of recovery for creditors as well as finance the liquidation’s expenses. Mr Simms and his PwC colleagues, in their third report to the Supreme Court last month, revealed that the $86.2m in cash balances inherited by the Bahamian liquidators on November 14, 2022, have since reduced by 45.5 percent to $47m at endOctober 2023. Most of the reduction is attributed to the combined $34.5m paid to the liquidators ($22.2m) and their advisers ($12.3m), as approved by the Supreme Court to cover their costs. However, Mr Ray and his
SEE PAGE B5
Abaco residents renew water billing complaints By FAY SIMMONS Tribune Business Reporter jsimmons@tribunemedia.net AN ABACO resident says she has been hit with a $1,300 Water & Sewerage Corporation bill despite being absent from her property for over three years after it was devastated by Hurricane Dorian. Ms Williams, a Spring City resident, said that she moved to New Providence while her home was rebuilt in the aftermath of the September 2019 Category Five
storm and only returned on November 2022. She said: “They charged me for three years of water that no one was even here at this property, and even when we came back the water company was load shedding so they were only turning the pumps on for a short time. “We were in Nassau. We weren’t even here and we came down one day and were sitting in the yard, because it wasn’t a house to even use the water, and
SEE PAGE B7
up an economy that had literally imploded overnight due to pandemic-related lockdowns and travel closures. The report, which has been placed on the Ministry of Finance’s new investor relations website, has never been tabled or laid in the House of Assembly as is the norm. But Terrance Bastian, the auditor general, as is customary, wrote in a note dated November 23, 2022, that he was submitting the report to House speaker, Patricia Deveaux, as required by Article 136 (4) of the Bahamian constitution. It is unclear why the Auditor General’s
2019-2020 report has yet to be tabled in the House more than a year after it was seemingly submitted by Mr Bastian, which raises questions over whether the Speaker has fulfilled her constitutional mandate to ensure such documents are “laid.... without undue delay”. The same article 136 (4) in the Bahamian constitution stipulates: “The Auditor General shall submit his reports under paragraph (3) of this article without undue delay to the Speaker (or, if the office of Speaker is vacant or the Speaker is for any reason unable to perform the functions of his/her office, to the
Deputy Speaker) who shall cause them to be laid before the House of Assembly without undue delay.” Ms Deveaux, when contacted by Tribune Business, said she was unaware of the Auditor General’s 20192020 fiscal year report and would have to “check into” the matter. One source, speaking on condition of anonymity, said there were only two possible explanations for why the report has not been laid in the House - either the Auditor General did not send it, or the Speaker failed to table it. Whether the Auditor General’s Office itself
TERRANCE BASTIAN
SEE PAGE B3
PATRICIA DEVEAUX
‘Landmark breakthrough’: FTX Bahamas strikes new Ray deal By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net FTX’s Bahamian liquidators yesterday hailed the settlement reached with their US counterpart as “a landmark breakthrough” that will avoid “years of protracted litigation” which would cost creditors dearly. Brian Simms KC, the Lennox Paton senior partner, and PricewaterhouseCoopers (PWC) accountant duo, Kevin Cambridge and Peter Greaves, said their agreement with John Ray, head of the 134 FTX entities in Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in Delaware, will create one unified
t "HSFFNFOU UP BWPJE AZFBST PG DPTUMZ MJUJHBUJPO t -PDBM USJP UBLF DIBSHF PG N QSPQFSUZ TBMF t #BIBNBT %FMBXBSF UP DSFBUF POF DMBJNT QPPM claims process designed to speed up the return of assets belonging to tens of thousands of creditors. The two sides, unveiling their long-awaited “global settlement agreement” via joint media releases
issued simultaneously at 9am, said the deal is based on combining assets from both estates into a single pool with creditors able to select where they will submit their claim - The Bahamas or Delaware. Double dipping, or submitting claims in both jurisdictions, will not be permitted. The agreement, which has to be approved by both the Supreme Court and Delaware Bankruptcy Court, will see the local trio “take the operational lead” in seeking to recover assets for creditors and investors via the sale of $256m worth of highend Bahamian real estate acquired by FTX in developments such as Albany,
BRIAN SIMMS KC GoldWynn and One Cable Beach. And Mr Simms and his PwC colleagues will also be “pursuing specific litigation and avoidance actions” under their agreement with Mr Ray in a bid to further maximise recoveries for creditors. Included among these targets are likely to be the 1,500 “Bahamian” investors who collectively got $100m out at the time FTX collapsed, which violated both Supreme Court and Chapter 11 asset freezes.
SEE PAGE B4
Business Licence audit can’t be ‘too draconian’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A BAHAMIAN accountant yesterday warned against the enhanced Business Licence verification process becoming “too draconian” and urged that some flexibility be provided on a “case by case” basis. Kendrick Christie, president of the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners Bahamas Chapter, told Tribune Business there should be sufficient “leeway” where $5m-plus companies who have engaged an auditor to produce full financial statements can obtain an extension beyond endJune 2024 if if can be justified. Noting that the Government is “sticking to its guns”, and refusing to agree to the year’s delay requested by the Bahamas Institute of Chartered Accountants
KENDRICK CHRISTIE (BICA) and Bahamas Chamber of Commerce and Employers Confederation (BCCEC), he argued that while “not backing away” from the set reporting deadlines it needs to examine every company’s case on an individual basis. Companies with annual turnover exceeding $5m presently have to file their audited financials by endApril, and can possibly obtain a further extension to end-June once they apply to the Department
SEE PAGE B3